Evasion of cGAS and TRIM5 defines pandemic HIV

HIV-1 with gag processing defects activates cGAS sensing

BACKGROUND

Detection of viruses by host pattern recognition receptors induces the expression of type I interferon (IFN) and IFN-stimulated genes (ISGs), which suppress viral replication. Numerous studies have described HIV-1 as a poor activator of innate immunity in vitro. The exact role that the viral capsid plays in this immune evasion is not fully understood.

RESULTS

To better understand the role of the HIV-1 capsid in sensing we tested the effect of making HIV-1 by co-expressing a truncated Gag that encodes the first 107 amino acids of capsid fused with luciferase or GFP, alongside wild type Gag-pol. We found that unlike wild type HIV-1, viral particles produced with a mixture of wild type and truncated Gag fused to luciferase or GFP induced a potent IFN response in THP-1 cells and macrophages. Innate immune activation by Gag-fusion HIV-1 was dependent on reverse transcription and DNA sensor cGAS, suggesting activation of an IFN response by viral DNA. Further investigation revealed incorporation of the Gag-luciferase/GFP fusion proteins into viral particles that correlated with subtle defects in wild type Gag cleavage and a diminished capacity to saturate restriction factor TRIM5α, likely due to aberrant particle formation. We propose that expression of the Gag fusion protein disturbs the correct cleavage and maturation of wild type Gag, yielding viral particles that are unable to effectively shield viral DNA from detection by innate sensors including cGAS.

CONCLUSIONS

These data highlight the crucial role of capsid in innate evasion and support growing literature that disruption of Gag cleavage and capsid formation induces a viral DNA- and cGAS-dependent innate immune response. Together these data demonstrate a protective role for capsid and suggest that antiviral activity of capsid-targeting antivirals may benefit from enhanced innate and adaptive immunity in vivo.

Cell-free assays reveal the HIV-1 capsid protects reverse transcripts from cGAS

Retroviruses can be detected by the innate immune sensor cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS), which recognizes reverse-transcribed DNA and activates an antiviral response. However, the extent to which HIV-1 shields its genome from cGAS recognition remains unclear. To study this process in mechanistic detail, we reconstituted reverse transcription, genome release, and innate immune sensing of HIV-1 in a cell-free system. We found that wild-type HIV-1 capsids protect their genomes from cGAS even after completion of reverse transcription. Viral DNA could be "deprotected" by thermal stress, capsid mutations, or reduced concentrations of inositol hexakisphosphate (IP6) that destabilize the capsid. Strikingly, capsid inhibitors also disrupted viral cores and dramatically potentiated cGAS activity, both in vitro and in cellular infections. Our results provide biochemical evidence that the HIV-1 capsid lattice conceals the genome from cGAS and that chemical or physical disruption of the viral core can expose HIV-1 DNA and activate innate immune signaling.

HIV-1 capsid stability and reverse transcription are finely balanced to minimize sensing of reverse transcription products via the cGAS-STING pathway

A critical determinant for early post-entry events, the HIV-1 capsid (CA) protein forms the conical core when it rearranges around the dimeric RNA genome and associated viral proteins. Although mutations in CA have been reported to alter innate immune sensing of HIV-1, a direct link between core stability and sensing of HIV-1 nucleic acids has not been established. Herein, we assessed how manipulating the stability of the CA lattice through chemical and genetic approaches affects innate immune recognition of HIV-1. We found that destabilization of the CA lattice resulted in potent sensing of reverse transcription products when destabilization per se does not completely block reverse transcription. Surprisingly, due to the combined effects of enhanced reverse transcription and defects in nuclear entry, two separate CA mutants that form hyperstable cores induced innate immune sensing more potently than destabilizing CA mutations. At low concentrations that allowed the accumulation of reverse transcription products, CA-targeting compounds GS-CA1 and lenacapavir measurably impacted CA lattice stability in cells and modestly enhanced innate immune sensing of HIV. Interestingly, innate immune activation observed with viruses containing unstable cores was abolished by low doses of lenacapavir. Innate immune activation observed with both hyperstable and unstable CA mutants was dependent on the cGAS-STING DNA-sensing pathway and reverse transcription. Overall, our findings demonstrate that CA lattice stability and reverse transcription are finely balanced to support reverse transcription and minimize cGAS-STING-mediated sensing of the resulting viral DNA.

IMPORTANCE

In HIV-1 particles, the dimeric RNA genome and associated viral proteins and enzymes are encased in a proteinaceous lattice composed of the viral capsid protein. Herein, we assessed how altering the stability of this capsid lattice through orthogonal genetic and chemical approaches impacts the induction of innate immune responses. Specifically, we found that decreasing capsid lattice stability results in more potent sensing of viral reverse transcription products, but not the genomic RNA, in a cGAS-STING-dependent manner. The recently developed capsid inhibitors lenacapavir and GS-CA1 enhanced the innate immune sensing of HIV-1. Unexpectedly, due to increased levels of reverse transcription and cytosolic accumulation of the resulting viral cDNA, capsid mutants with hyperstable cores also resulted in the potent induction of type I interferon-mediated innate immunity. Our findings suggest that HIV-1 capsid lattice stability and reverse transcription are finely balanced to minimize exposure of reverse transcription products in the cytosol of host cells.

HIV-2 mediated effects on target and bystander cells induce plasma proteome remodeling

Despite low or undetectable plasma viral load, people living with HIV-2 (PLWH2) typically progress toward AIDS. The driving forces behind HIV-2 disease progression and the role of viremia are still not known, but low-level replication in tissues is believed to play a role. To investigate the impact of viremic and aviremic HIV-2 infection on target and bystander cell pathology, we used data-independent acquisition mass spectrometry to determine plasma signatures of tissue and cell type engagement. Proteins derived from target and bystander cells in multiple tissues, such as the gastrointestinal tract and brain, were detected at elevated levels in plasma of PLWH2, compared with HIV negative controls. Moreover, viremic HIV-2 infection appeared to induce enhanced release of proteins from a broader range of tissues compared to aviremic HIV-2 infection. This study expands the knowledge on the link between plasma proteome remodeling and the pathological cell engagement in tissues during HIV-2 infection.

Capsid-dependent lentiviral restrictions

Host antiviral proteins inhibit primate lentiviruses and other retroviruses by targeting many features of the viral life cycle. The lentiviral capsid protein and the assembled viral core are known to be inhibited through multiple, directly acting antiviral proteins. Several phenotypes, including those known as Lv1 through Lv5, have been described as cell type-specific blocks to infection against some but not all primate lentiviruses. Here we review important features of known capsid-targeting blocks to infection together with several blocks to infection for which the genes responsible for the inhibition still remain to be identified. We outline the features of these blocks as well as how current methodologies are now well suited to find these antiviral genes and solve these long-standing mysteries in the HIV and retrovirology fields.

The ISG15-Protease USP18 Is a Pleiotropic Enhancer of HIV-1 Replication

The innate immune response to viruses is formed in part by interferon (IFN)-induced restriction factors, including ISG15, p21, and SAMHD1. IFN production can be blocked by the ISG15-specific protease USP18. HIV-1 has evolved to circumvent host immune surveillance. This mechanism might involve USP18. In our recent studies, we demonstrate that HIV-1 infection induces USP18, which dramatically enhances HIV-1 replication by abrogating the antiviral function of p21. USP18 downregulates p21 by accumulating misfolded dominant negative p53, which inactivates wild-type p53 transactivation, leading to the upregulation of key enzymes involved in de novo dNTP biosynthesis pathways and inactivated SAMHD1. Despite the USP18-mediated increase in HIV-1 DNA in infected cells, it is intriguing to note that the cGAS-STING-mediated sensing of the viral DNA is abrogated. Indeed, the expression of USP18 or knockout of ISG15 inhibits the sensing of HIV-1. We demonstrate that STING is ISGylated at residues K224, K236, K289, K347, K338, and K370. The inhibition of STING K289-linked ISGylation suppresses its oligomerization and IFN induction. We propose that human USP18 is a novel factor that potentially contributes in multiple ways to HIV-1 replication.

Evolution of enhanced innate immune suppression by SARS-CoV-2 Omicron subvariants

Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) human adaptation resulted in distinct lineages with enhanced transmissibility called variants of concern (VOCs). Omicron is the first VOC to evolve distinct globally dominant subvariants. Here we compared their replication in human cell lines and primary airway cultures and measured host responses to infection. We discovered that subvariants BA.4 and BA.5 have improved their suppression of innate immunity when compared with earlier subvariants BA.1 and BA.2. Similarly, more recent subvariants (BA.2.75 and XBB lineages) also triggered reduced innate immune activation. This correlated with increased expression of viral innate antagonists Orf6 and nucleocapsid, reminiscent of VOCs Alpha to Delta. Increased Orf6 levels suppressed host innate responses to infection by decreasing IRF3 and STAT1 signalling measured by transcription factor phosphorylation and nuclear translocation. Our data suggest that convergent evolution of enhanced innate immune antagonist expression is a common pathway of human adaptation and link Omicron subvariant dominance to improved innate immune evasion.

Molecular frustration: a hypothesis for regulation of viral infections

The recent revolution in imaging techniques and results from RNA footprinting in situ reveal how the bacteriophage MS2 genome regulates both particle assembly and genome release. We have proposed a model in which multiple packaging signal (PS) RNA-coat protein (CP) contacts orchestrate different stages of a viral life cycle. Programmed formation and release of specific PS contacts with CP regulates viral particle assembly and genome uncoating during cell entry. We hypothesize that molecular frustration, a concept introduced to understand protein folding, can be used to better rationalize how PSs function in both particle assembly and genome release. More broadly this concept may explain the directionality of viral life cycles, for example, the roles of host cofactors in HIV infection. We propose that this is a universal principle in virology that explains mechanisms of host-virus interaction and suggests diverse therapeutic interventions.

IFIH1 (MDA5) is required for innate immune detection of intron-containing RNA expressed from the HIV-1 provirus

Antiretroviral therapy (ART) suppresses HIV-1 viremia and prevents progression to AIDS. Nonetheless, chronic inflammation is a common problem for people living with HIV-1 on ART. One possible cause of inflammation is ongoing transcription from HIV-1 proviruses, whether or not the sequences are competent for replication. Previous work has shown that intron-containing RNA expressed from the HIV-1 provirus in primary human blood cells, including CD4+ T cells, macrophages, and dendritic cells, activates type 1 interferon. This activation required HIV-1 rev and was blocked by the XPO1 (CRM1)-inhibitor leptomycin. To identify the innate immune receptor required for detection of intron-containing RNA expressed from the HIV-1 provirus, a loss-of-function screen was performed with shRNA-expressing lentivectors targeting twenty-one candidate genes in human monocyte derived dendritic cells. Among the candidate genes tested, only knockdown of XPO1 (CRM1), IFIH1 (MDA5), or MAVS prevented activation of the IFN-stimulated gene ISG15. The importance of IFIH1 protein was demonstrated by rescue of the knockdown with non-targetable IFIH1 coding sequence. Inhibition of HIV-1-induced ISG15 by the IFIH1-specific Nipah virus V protein, and by IFIH1-transdominant inhibitory CARD-deletion or phosphomimetic point mutations, indicates that IFIH1 filament formation, dephosphorylation, and association with MAVS, are all required for innate immune activation in response to HIV-1 transduction. Since both IFIH1 and DDX58 (RIG-I) signal via MAVS, the specificity of HIV-1 RNA detection by IFIH1 was demonstrated by the fact that DDX58 knockdown had no effect on activation. RNA-Seq showed that IFIH1-knockdown in dendritic cells globally disrupted the induction of IFN-stimulated genes. Finally, specific enrichment of unspliced HIV-1 RNA by IFIH1 was revealed by formaldehyde crosslinking immunoprecipitation (f-CLIP). These results demonstrate that IFIH1 is required for innate immune activation by intron-containing RNA from the HIV-1 provirus, and potentially contributes to chronic inflammation in people living with HIV-1.

The cyclophilin A-binding loop of the capsid regulates the human TRIM5α sensitivity of nonpandemic HIV-1

The rather few cases of humans infected by HIV-1 N, O, or P raise the question of their incomplete adaptation to humans. We hypothesized that early postentry restrictions may be relevant for the impaired spread of these HIVs. One of the best-characterized species-specific restriction factors is TRIM5α. HIV-1 M can escape human (hu) TRIM5α restriction by binding cyclophilin A (CYPA, also known as PPIA, peptidylprolyl isomerase A) to the so-called CYPA-binding loop of its capsid protein. How non-M HIV-1s interact with huTRIM5α is ill-defined. By testing full-length reporter viruses (Δ env) of HIV-1 N, O, P, and SIVgor (simian IV of gorillas), we found that in contrast to HIV-1 M, the nonpandemic HIVs and SIVgor showed restriction by huTRIM5α. Work to identify capsid residues that mediate susceptibility to huTRIM5α revealed that residue 88 in the capsid CYPA-binding loop was important for such differences. There, HIV-1 M uses alanine to resist, while non-M HIV-1s have either valine or methionine, which avail them for huTRIM5α. Capsid residue 88 determines the sensitivity to TRIM5α in an unknown way. Molecular simulations indicated that capsid residue 88 can affect trans-to-cis isomerization patterns on the capsids of the viruses we tested. These differential CYPA usages by pandemic and nonpandemic HIV-1 suggest that the enzymatic activity of CYPA on the viral core might be important for its protective function against huTRIM5α.

POLE3 is a repressor of unintegrated HIV-1 DNA required for efficient virus integration and escape from innate immune sensing

Unintegrated retroviral DNA is transcriptionally silenced by host chromatin silencing factors. Here, we used the proteomics of isolated chromatin segments method to reveal viral and host factors associated with unintegrated HIV-1DNA involved in its silencing. By gene silencing using siRNAs, 46 factors were identified as potential repressors of unintegrated HIV-1DNA. Knockdown and knockout experiments revealed POLE3 as a transcriptional repressor of unintegrated HIV-1DNA. POLE3 maintains unintegrated HIV-1DNA in a repressive chromatin state, preventing RNAPII recruitment to the viral promoter. POLE3 and the recently identified host factors mediating unintegrated HIV-1 DNA silencing, CAF1 and SMC5/SMC6/SLF2, show specificity toward different forms of unintegrated HIV-1DNA. Loss of POLE3 impaired HIV-1 replication, suggesting that repression of unintegrated HIV-1DNA is important for optimal viral replication. POLE3 depletion reduces the integration efficiency of HIV-1. POLE3, by maintaining a repressive chromatin structure of unintegrated HIV-1DNA, ensures HIV-1 escape from innate immune sensing in primary CD4+ T cells.

SARS-CoV-2 variants evolve convergent strategies to remodel the host response

SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern (VOCs) emerged during the COVID-19 pandemic. Here, we used unbiased systems approaches to study the host-selective forces driving VOC evolution. We discovered that VOCs evolved convergent strategies to remodel the host by modulating viral RNA and protein levels, altering viral and host protein phosphorylation, and rewiring virus-host protein-protein interactions. Integrative computational analyses revealed that although Alpha, Beta, Gamma, and Delta ultimately converged to suppress interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs), Omicron BA.1 did not. ISG suppression correlated with the expression of viral innate immune antagonist proteins, including Orf6, N, and Orf9b, which we mapped to specific mutations. Later Omicron subvariants BA.4 and BA.5 more potently suppressed innate immunity than early subvariant BA.1, which correlated with Orf6 levels, although muted in BA.4 by a mutation that disrupts the Orf6-nuclear pore interaction. Our findings suggest that SARS-CoV-2 convergent evolution overcame human adaptive and innate immune barriers, laying the groundwork to tackle future pandemics.

HIV-Induced CPSF6 Condensates

Viruses are obligate parasites that rely on their host's cellular machinery for replication. To facilitate their replication cycle, many viruses have been shown to remodel the cellular architecture by inducing the formation of membraneless organelles (MLOs). Eukaryotic cells have evolved MLOs that are highly dynamic, self-organizing microenvironments that segregate biological processes and increase the efficiency of reactions by concentrating enzymes and substrates. In the context of viral infections, MLOs can be utilized by viruses to complete their replication cycle. This review focuses on the pathway used by the HIV-1 virus to remodel the nuclear landscape of its host, creating viral/host niches that enable efficient viral replication. Specifically, we discuss how the interaction between the HIV-1 capsid and the cellular factor CPSF6 triggers the formation of nuclear MLOs that support nuclear reverse transcription and viral integration in favored regions of the host chromatin. This review compiles current knowledge on the origin of nuclear HIV-MLOs and their role in early post-nuclear entry steps of the HIV-1 replication cycle.

A frequent SNP in TRIM5α strongly enhances the innate immune response against LINE-1 elements

The intracellular restriction factor TRIM5α inhibits endogenous LINE-1 retroelements. It induces innate immune signaling cascades upon sensing of cytoplasmic LINE-1 complexes, thereby underlining its importance for protecting the human genome from harmful retrotransposition events. Here, we show that a frequent SNP within the RING domain of TRIM5α, resulting in the variant H43Y, blocks LINE-1 retrotransposition with higher efficiency compared to TRIM5α WT. Upon sensing of LINE-1 complexes in the cytoplasm, TRIM5α H43Y activates both NF-κB and AP-1 signaling pathways more potently than TRIM5α WT, triggering a strong block of the LINE-1 promoter. Interestingly, the H43Y allele lost its antiviral function suggesting that its enhanced activity against endogenous LINE-1 elements is the driving force behind its maintenance within the population. Thus, our study suggests that the H43Y variant of the restriction factor and sensor TRIM5α persists within the human population since it preserves our genome from uncontrolled LINE-1 retrotransposition with higher efficiency.

Primary role of type I interferons for the induction of functionally optimal antigen-specific CD8+ T cells in HIV infection

BACKGROUND

CD8⁺ T cells equipped with a full arsenal of antiviral effector functions are critical for effective immune control of HIV-1. It has nonetheless remained unclear how best to elicit such potent cellular immune responses in the context of immunotherapy or vaccination. HIV-2 has been associated with milder disease manifestations and more commonly elicits functionally replete virus-specific CD8⁺ T cell responses compared with HIV-1. We aimed to learn from this immunological dichotomy and to develop informed strategies that could enhance the induction of robust CD8⁺ T cell responses against HIV-1.

METHODS

We developed an unbiased in vitro system to compare the de novo induction of antigen-specific CD8⁺ T cell responses after exposure to HIV-1 or HIV-2. The functional properties of primed CD8⁺ T cells were assessed using flow cytometry and molecular analyses of gene transcription.

FINDINGS

HIV-2 primed functionally optimal antigen-specific CD8⁺ T cells with enhanced survival properties more effectively than HIV-1. This superior induction process was dependent on type I interferons (IFNs) and could be mimicked via the adjuvant delivery of cyclic GMP-AMP (cGAMP), a known agonist of the stimulator of interferon genes (STING). CD8⁺ T cells elicited in the presence of cGAMP were polyfunctional and highly sensitive to antigen stimulation, even after priming from people living with HIV-1.

INTERPRETATION

HIV-2 primes CD8⁺ T cells with potent antiviral functionality by activating the cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS)/STING pathway, which results in the production of type I IFNs. This process may be amenable to therapeutic development via the use of cGAMP or other STING agonists to bolster CD8⁺ T cell-mediated immunity against HIV-1.

FUNDING

This work was funded by INSERM, the Institut Curie, and the University of Bordeaux (Senior IdEx Chair) and by grants from Sidaction (17-1-AAE-11097, 17-1-FJC-11199, VIH2016126002, 20-2-AEQ-12822-2, and 22-2-AEQ-13411), the Agence Nationale de la Recherche sur le SIDA (ECTZ36691, ECTZ25472, ECTZ71745, and ECTZ118797), and the Fondation pour la Recherche Médicale (EQ U202103012774). D.A.P. was supported by a Wellcome Trust Senior Investigator Award (100326/Z/12/Z).

Function and regulation of cGAS-STING signaling in infectious diseases

The efficacious detection of pathogens and prompt induction of innate immune signaling serve as a crucial component of immune defense against infectious pathogens. Over the past decade, DNA-sensing receptor cyclic GMP-AMP synthase (cGAS) and its downstream signaling adaptor stimulator of interferon genes (STING) have emerged as key mediators of type I interferon (IFN) and nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB) responses in health and infection diseases. Moreover, both cGAS-STING pathway and pathogens have developed delicate strategies to resist each other for their survival. The mechanistic and functional comprehension of the interplay between cGAS-STING pathway and pathogens is opening the way for the development and application of pharmacological agonists and antagonists in the treatment of infectious diseases. Here, we briefly review the current knowledge of DNA sensing through the cGAS-STING pathway, and emphatically highlight the potent undertaking of cGAS-STING signaling pathway in the host against infectious pathogenic organisms.

Cytosolic DNA sensor activation inhibits HIV infection of macrophages

Cytosolic recognition of microbial DNA in macrophages results in the activation of the interferon (IFN)-dependent antiviral innate immunity. Here, we examined whether activating DNA sensors in peripheral blood monocyte-derived macrophages (MDMs) can inhibit human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). We observed that the stimulation of MDMs with poly(dA:dT) or poly(dG:dC) (synthetic ligands for the DNA sensors) inhibited HIV infection and replication. MDMs treated with poly(dA:dT) or poly(dG:dC) expressed higher levels of both type I and type III IFNs than untreated cells. Activation of the DNA sensors in MDMs also induced the expression of the multiple intracellular anti-HIV factors, including IFN-stimulated genes (ISGs: ISG15, ISG56, Viperin, OAS2, GBP5, MxB, and Tetherin) and the HIV restriction microRNAs (miR-29c, miR-138, miR-146a, miR-155, miR-198, and miR-223). In addition, the DNA sensor activation of MDM upregulated the expression of the CC chemokines (RANTES, MIP-1α, MIP-1β), the ligands for HIV entry coreceptor CCR5. These observations indicate that the cytosolic DNA sensors have a protective role in the macrophage intracellular immunity against HIV and that targeting the DNA sensors has therapeutic potential for immune activation-based anti-HIV treatment.

On the Evolutionary Trajectory of SARS-CoV-2: Host Immunity as a Driver of Adaptation in RNA Viruses

Host immunity can exert a complex array of selective pressures on a pathogen, which can drive highly mutable RNA viruses towards viral escape. The plasticity of a virus depends on its rate of mutation, as well as the balance of fitness cost and benefit of mutations, including viral adaptations to the host's immune response. Since its emergence, SARS-CoV-2 has diversified into genetically distinct variants, which are characterised often by clusters of mutations that bolster its capacity to escape human innate and adaptive immunity. Such viral escape is well documented in the context of other pandemic RNA viruses such as the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and influenza virus. This review describes the selection pressures the host's antiviral immunity exerts on SARS-CoV-2 and other RNA viruses, resulting in divergence of viral strains into more adapted forms. As RNA viruses obscure themselves from host immunity, they uncover weak points in their own armoury that can inform more comprehensive, long-lasting, and potentially cross-protective vaccine coverage.