Evaluation of site-specific homologous recombination activity of BRCA1 by direct quantitation of gene editing efficiency

HR eye & MMR eye: one-day assessment of DNA repair-defective tumors eligible for targeted therapy

Homologous recombination (HR) and mismatch repair (MMR) act as guardians of the human genome, and defects in HR or MMR are causative in at least a quarter of all malignant tumors. Although these DNA repair-deficient tumors are eligible for effective targeted therapies, fully reliable diagnostic strategies based on functional assay have yet to be established, potentially limiting safe and proper application of the molecular targeted drugs. Here we show that transient transfection of artificial DNA substrates enables ultrarapid detection of HR and MMR. This finding led us to develop a diagnostic strategy that can determine the cellular HR/MMR status within one day without the need for control cells or tissues. Notably, the accuracy of this method allowed the discovery of a pathogenic RAD51D mutation, which was missed by existing companion diagnostic tests. Our methods, termed HR eye and MMR eye, are applicable to frozen tumor tissues and roughly predict the response to therapy. Overall, the findings presented here could pave the way for accurately assessing malignant tumors with functional defects in HR or MMR, a step forward in accelerating precision medicine.

Assay for Site-Specific Homologous Recombination Activity in Adherent Cells, Suspension Cells, and Tumor Tissues

Homologous recombination (HR) is a major pathway to repair DNA double-strand breaks. Hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndrome (HBOC) is caused by germline pathogenic variants of HR-related genes, such as BRCA1 and BRCA2 (BRCA1/2). Cancer cells with HR deficiency are sensitive to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors. Therefore, accurate evaluation of HR activity is helpful to diagnose HBOC and predict the effects of PARP inhibitors. The direct-repeat GFP (DR-GFP) assay has been utilized to evaluate cellular HR activity. However, evaluation by the DR-GFP assay tends to be qualitative and requires the establishment of stable cell lines. Therefore, we developed an assay to quantitatively measure HR activity called Assay for Site-Specific HR Activity (ASHRA), which can be performed by transiently transfecting two plasmids. In ASHRA, we use Cas9 endonuclease to create DNA double-strand breaks at specific sites in the genome, enabling the targeting of any endogenous loci. Quantification of HR products by real-time PCR using genomic DNA allows HR activity evaluated at the DNA level. Thus, ASHRA is an easy and quantitative method to evaluate HR activity at any genomic locus in various samples. Here, we present the protocols for adherent cells, suspension cells, and tumor tissues. Key features • This assay quantitatively evaluates homologous recombination (HR) activity. • This assay can measure HR activity in adherent cells, suspension cells, and tumor tissues. • This real-time PCR-based assay does not require a flow cytometer or next-generation sequencer.

Armadillo domain of ARID1A directly interacts with DNA-PKcs to couple chromatin remodeling with nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway

The SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling complex that comprises multiple subunits orchestrates diverse cellular processes, including gene expression, DNA repair, and DNA replication, by sliding and releasing nucleosomes. AT-interacting domain-rich protein 1A (ARID1A) and ARID1B (ARID1A/B), a pivotal subunit, have significant relevance in cancer management because they are frequently mutated in a broad range of cancer types. To delineate the protein network involving ARID1A/B, we investigated the interactions of this with other proteins under physiological conditions. The ARID domain of ARID1A/B interacts with proteins involved in transcription and DNA/RNA metabolism. Several proteins are responsible for genome integrity maintenance, including DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs), bound to the armadillo (ARM) domain of ARID1A/B. Introducing a knock-in mutation at the binding amino acid of DNA-PKcs in HCT116 cells reduced the autophosphorylation of DNA-PKcs and the recruitment of LIG4 in response to ionizing radiation. Our findings suggest that within the SWI/SNF complex, ARID1A couples DNA double-strand break repair processes with chromatin remodeling via the ARM domains to directly engage with DNA-PKcs to maintain genome stability.

Nicaraven enhances the cytotoxicity of X-ray irradiation in cancer cells with homologous recombination deficiency

Poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) is involved in the repair of DNA single-strand breaks. PARP inhibitors are cytotoxic to cancer cells with homologous recombination (HR) deficiency through a synthetic lethality mechanism. Nicaraven is a hydroxyl radical scavenger that has been investigated for the treatment of organ ischemia such as brain infarction. Nicaraven also shows PARP inhibitory and anti-cancer activity in vitro and in vivo. In this study, we investigated the potential synthetic lethality of nicaraven in cells with HR deficiency and whether the PARP inhibitory and radical scavenger activities of nicaraven contributes to its anti-cancer effects, especially in combination with exposure to ionizing radiation. The results showed that nicaraven was cytotoxic against cancer cells after knockdown of the HR factors BRCA1 or RAD51, indicating that nicaraven exerted synthetic lethal effects on cells with HR deficiency. X-ray irradiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) increased at 2 h and were largely repaired after 24 h in control cells, whereas nicaraven significantly increased the amounts of residual DSBs 24 h after X-ray irradiation, especially in HR-deficient cells. Nicaraven treatment enhanced the cytotoxicity of X-ray irradiation in HR-deficient cells, but not that in HR-proficient cells. These data suggest that the combination of nicaraven with X-ray irradiation selectively increases the cytotoxic effects of X-ray irradiation on HR-deficient cancer cells. Thus, nicaraven might be a valuable agent for cancer therapy, particularly in combination with radiotherapy.

PLK1 overexpression suppresses homologous recombination and confers cellular sensitivity to PARP inhibition

The overexpression of Polo-like kinase 1 (PLK1) is associated with poor clinical outcomes in various malignancies, making it an attractive target for anticancer therapies. Although recent studies suggest PLK1's involvement in homologous recombination (HR), the impact of its overexpression on HR remains unclear. In this study, we investigated the effect of PLK1 overexpression on HR using bioinformatics and experimental approaches. Analyzing The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) and Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia (CCLE) datasets with the Homologous Recombination Deficiency (HRD) score, we found a positive correlation between PLK1 expression and HRD score, indicating that increased PLK1 expression suppresses HR. To validate these findings, we performed cell line-based experiments, demonstrating that PLK1 overexpression attenuates RAD51 focus formation and HR, as measured by ASHRA in T47D cells. Since HR-deficient cells are hypersensitive to PARP inhibitors, we further confirmed that PLK1 overexpression increases sensitivity to PARP inhibitors, both in CCLE dataset analysis and experiments using T47D cells. Additionally, we found that the effects of PLK1 overexpression on HR suppression and increased PARP inhibitor sensitivity were mitigated by either a PLK1 kinase inhibitor or the kinase-dead mutant [T210A]. This suggests that PLK1's impact on HR and PARP inhibitor sensitivity is mediated through its kinase activity. Moreover, analysis of clinical ovarian cancer samples revealed that higher PLK1 expression correlates with increased sensitivity to PARP inhibitors. Our results suggest that PLK1 overexpression suppresses homologous recombination, leading to enhanced sensitivity to PARP inhibition, presenting a potential therapeutic strategy for targeting cancers with overexpression of PLK1.

Inherited C-terminal TREX1 variants disrupt homology-directed repair to cause senescence and DNA damage phenotypes in Drosophila, mice, and humans

Age-related microangiopathy, also known as small vessel disease (SVD), causes damage to the brain, retina, liver, and kidney. Based on the DNA damage theory of aging, we reasoned that genomic instability may underlie an SVD caused by dominant C-terminal variants in TREX1, the most abundant 3'-5' DNA exonuclease in mammals. C-terminal TREX1 variants cause an adult-onset SVD known as retinal vasculopathy with cerebral leukoencephalopathy (RVCL or RVCL-S). In RVCL, an aberrant, C-terminally truncated TREX1 mislocalizes to the nucleus due to deletion of its ER-anchoring domain. Since RVCL pathology mimics that of radiation injury, we reasoned that nuclear TREX1 would cause DNA damage. Here, we show that RVCL-associated TREX1 variants trigger DNA damage in humans, mice, and Drosophila, and that cells expressing RVCL mutant TREX1 are more vulnerable to DNA damage induced by chemotherapy and cytokines that up-regulate TREX1, leading to depletion of TREX1-high cells in RVCL mice. RVCL-associated TREX1 mutants inhibit homology-directed repair (HDR), causing DNA deletions and vulnerablility to PARP inhibitors. In women with RVCL, we observe early-onset breast cancer, similar to patients with BRCA1/2 variants. Our results provide a mechanistic basis linking aberrant TREX1 activity to the DNA damage theory of aging, premature senescence, and microvascular disease.

Evaluating homologous recombination activity in tissues to predict the risk of hereditary breast and ovarian cancer and olaparib sensitivity

Homologous recombination (HR) repairs DNA damage including DNA double-stranded breaks and alterations in HR-related genes results in HR deficiency. Germline alteration of HR-related genes, such as BRCA1 and BRCA2, causes hereditary breast and ovarian cancer (HBOC). Cancer cells with HR deficiency are sensitive to poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors and DNA-damaging agents. Thus, accurately evaluating HR activity is useful for diagnosing HBOC and predicting the therapeutic effects of anti-cancer agents. Previously, we developed an assay for site-specific HR activity (ASHRA) that can quantitatively evaluate HR activity and detect moderate HR deficiency. HR activity in cells measured by ASHRA correlates with sensitivity to the PARP inhibitor, olaparib. In this study, we applied ASHRA to lymphoblastoid cells and xenograft tumor tissues, which simulate peripheral blood lymphocytes and tumor tissues, respectively, as clinically available samples. We showed that ASHRA could be used to detect HR deficiency in lymphoblastoid cells derived from a BRCA1 pathogenic variant carrier. Furthermore, ASHRA could quantitatively measure the HR activity in xenograft tumor tissues with HR activity that was gradually suppressed by inducible BRCA1 knockdown. The HR activity of xenograft tumor tissues quantitatively correlated with the effect of olaparib. Our data suggest that ASHRA could be a useful assay for diagnosing HBOC and predicting the efficacy of PARP inhibitors.

Bevacizumab increases the sensitivity of olaparib to homologous recombination-proficient ovarian cancer by suppressing CRY1 via PI3K/AKT pathway

PARP inhibitors have changed the management of advanced high-grade epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC), especially homologous recombinant (HR)-deficient advanced high-grade EOC. However, the effect of PARP inhibitors on HR-proficient (HRP) EOC is limited. Thus, new therapeutic strategy for HRP EOC is desired. In recent clinical study, the combination of PARP inhibitors with anti-angiogenic agents improved therapeutic efficacy, even in HRP cases. These data suggested that anti-angiogenic agents might potentiate the response to PARP inhibitors in EOC cells. Here, we demonstrated that anti-angiogenic agents, bevacizumab and cediranib, increased the sensitivity of olaparib in HRP EOC cells by suppressing HR activity. Most of the γ-H2AX foci were co-localized with RAD51 foci in control cells. However, most of the RAD51 were decreased in the bevacizumab-treated cells. RNA sequencing showed that bevacizumab decreased the expression of CRY1 under DNA damage stress. CRY1 is one of the transcriptional coregulators associated with circadian rhythm and has recently been reported to regulate the expression of genes required for HR in cancer cells. We found that the anti-angiogenic agents suppressed the increase of CRY1 expression by inhibiting VEGF/VEGFR/PI3K pathway. The suppression of CRY1 expression resulted in decrease of HR activity. In addition, CRY1 inhibition also sensitized EOC cells to olaparib. These data suggested that anti-angiogenic agents and CRY1 inhibitors will be the promising candidate in the combination therapy with PARP inhibitors in HR-proficient EOC.

CDK2 regulates collapsed replication fork repair in CCNE1-amplified ovarian cancer cells via homologous recombination

CCNE1 amplification is a common alteration in high-grade serous ovarian cancer and occurs in 15-20% of these tumors. These amplifications are mutually exclusive with homologous recombination deficiency, and, as they have intact homologous recombination, are intrinsically resistant to poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors or chemotherapy agents. Understanding the molecular mechanisms that lead to this mutual exclusivity may reveal therapeutic vulnerabilities that could be leveraged in the clinic in this still underserved patient population. Here, we demonstrate that CCNE1-amplified high-grade serous ovarian cancer cells rely on homologous recombination to repair collapsed replication forks. Cyclin-dependent kinase 2, the canonical partner of cyclin E1, uniquely regulates homologous recombination in this genetic context, and as such cyclin-dependent kinase 2 inhibition synergizes with DNA damaging agents in vitro and in vivo. We demonstrate that combining a selective cyclin-dependent kinase 2 inhibitor with a DNA damaging agent could be a powerful tool in the clinic for high-grade serous ovarian cancer.

Paclitaxel sensitizes homologous recombination-proficient ovarian cancer cells to PARP inhibitor via the CDK1/BRCA1 pathway

OBJECTIVE

An effective treatment strategy for epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC) with homologous recombination (HR)-proficient (HRP) phenotype has not been established, although poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors (PARPi) impact the disease course with HR-deficient (HRD) phenotype. Here, we aimed to clarify the cellular effects of paclitaxel (PTX) on the DNA damage response and the therapeutic application of PTX with PARPi in HRP ovarian cancer.

METHODS

Two models with different PTX dosing schedules were established in HRP ovarian cancer OVISE cells. Growth inhibition and HR activity were analyzed in these models with or without PARPi. BRCA1 phosphorylation status was examined in OVISE cells by inhibiting CDK1, which was reduced by PTX treatment. CDK1 expression was evaluated in EOC patients treated with PTX-based neoadjuvant chemotherapy.

RESULTS

PTX suppressed CDK1 expression resulting in impaired BRCA1 phosphorylation in OVISE cells. The reduced CDK1 activity by PTX could decrease HR activity in response to DNA damage and therefore increase the sensitivity to PARPi. Immunohistochemistry showed that CDK1 expression was attenuated in samples collected after PTX-based chemotherapy compared to those collected before chemotherapy. The decrease in CDK1 expression was greater with dose-dense PTX schedule than with the conventional PTX schedule.

CONCULSIONS

PTX could act synergistically with PARPi in HRP ovarian cancer cells, suggesting that the combination of PTX with PARPi may be a novel treatment strategy extending the utility of PARPi to EOC. Our findings provide cules for future translational clinical trials evaluating the efficacy of PTX in combination with PARPi in HRP ovarian cancer.

Impact of Nuclear De Novo NAD+ Synthesis via Histone Dynamics on DNA Repair during Cellular Senescence To Prevent Tumorigenesis

NAD⁺ synthesis is a fundamental process in living cells. The effects of local metabolite production on chromatin influence the epigenetic status of chromatin in DNA metabolism. We have previously shown that K5 acetylation of H2AX by TIP60 is required for the ADP ribosylation activity of PARP-1, for histone H2AX exchange at DNA damage sites. However, the detailed molecular mechanism has remained unclear. Here, we identified de novo NAD synthetase 1 (NAD syn1) as a novel binding partner to H2AX. The enzymatic activity of NAD syn1 is crucial for the ADP ribosylation activity of PARP-1 for the H2AX dynamics at sites of DNA damage. Inhibition of the NAD synthetase activity in the cell nucleus decreased the overall cellular NAD⁺ concentration, leading to cellular senescence. Accordingly, the acetylation-dependent H2AX dynamics and homologous recombination repair were suppressed, leading to increased tumorigenesis. Our findings have revealed the importance of de novo NAD⁺ production in the cell nucleus for protection against the decreased DNA repair capacity caused by cellular senescence and thus against tumorigenesis.

BRCA1/ATF1-Mediated Transactivation is Involved in Resistance to PARP Inhibitors and Cisplatin

Homologous recombination (HR)-deficient cells are sensitive to PARP inhibitors through a synthetic lethal effect. We previously developed an HR activity assay named Assay of Site-Specific HR Activity (ASHRA). Here, we evaluated the HR activity of 30 missense variants of BRCA1 by ASHRA and found that several BRCA1 variants showed intermediate HR activity, which was not clearly discerned by our previous analyses using a conventional method. HR activity measured by ASHRA was significantly correlated with sensitivity to olaparib. However, cells expressing the severely HR-deficient BRCA1-C61G variant were resistant to olaparib, and resistance was dependent on high expression of activating transcription factor 1 (ATF1), which binds to BRCA1 and activates the transcription of target genes to regulate cell proliferation. The BRCA1-C61G variant bound to ATF1 and stimulated ATF1-mediated transactivation similar to wild-type BRCA1. High expression of ATF1 conferred resistance to olaparib and cisplatin activating BRCA1/ATF1-mediated transcription without affecting HR activity in BRCA2-knockdown or RAD51-knockdown cells, but not in BRCA1-knockdown cells. These results suggest that ASHRA is a useful method to evaluate HR activity in cells and to predict the sensitivity to PARP inhibitors. The expression level of ATF1 might be an important biomarker of the effect of PARP inhibitors and platinum agents on HR-deficient tumors with the BRCA1-C61G variant or alteration of non-BRCA1 HR factors such as BRCA2 and RAD51.

Significance

ASHRA could evaluate HR activity in cells and predict the sensitivity to PARP inhibitors. High expression level of ATF1 may predict the resistance of BRCAness tumors with alterations of non-BRCA1 HR factors to PARP inhibitors and platinum agents.

New RAD51 Inhibitors to Target Homologous Recombination in Human Cells

Targeting DNA repair proteins with small-molecule inhibitors became a proven anti-cancer strategy. Previously, we identified an inhibitor of a major protein of homologous recombination (HR) RAD51, named B02. B02 inhibited HR in human cells and sensitized them to chemotherapeutic drugs in vitro and in vivo. Here, using a medicinal chemistry approach, we aimed to improve the potency of B02. We identified the B02 analog, B02-isomer, which inhibits HR in human cells with significantly higher efficiency. We also show that B02-iso sensitizes triple-negative breast cancer MDA-MB-231 cells to the PARP inhibitor (PARPi) olaparib.

CRISPR-based knock-in mutagenesis of the pioneer transcription factor FOXA1: optimization of strategies for multi-allelic proteins in cancer cells

Precise genome engineering of living cells has been revolutionized by the introduction of the highly specific and easily programmable properties of the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) technology. This has greatly accelerated research into human health and has facilitated the discovery of novel therapeutics. CRISPR‐Cas9 is most widely employed for its ability to inactivate or knockout specific genes, but can be also used to introduce subtle site‐specific substitutions of DNA sequences that can lead to changes in the amino acid composition of proteins. Despite the proven success of CRISPR‐based knock‐in strategies of genes in typical diploid cells (i.e., cells containing two sets of chromosomes), precise editing of cancer cells, that typically have unstable genomes and multiple copies of chromosomes, is more challenging and not adequately addressed in the literature. Herein, we detail our methodology for replacing endogenous proteins with intended knock‐in mutants in polyploid cancer cells and discuss our experimental design, screening strategy, and facile allele frequency estimation methodology. As proof of principle, we performed genome editing of specific amino acids within the pioneer transcription factor FOXA1, a critical component of estrogen and androgen receptor signaling, in MCF‐7 breast cancer cells. We confirm mutant FOXA1 protein expression and intended amino acid substitutions via western blotting and mass spectrometry. In addition, we show that mutant allele frequency estimation is easily achieved by topoisomerase‐based cloning combined with allele‐specific PCR, which we later confirmed by next‐generation RNA‐sequencing. Typically, there are 4 ‐ 5 copies (alleles) of FOXA1 in breast cancer cells, making the editing of this protein inherently challenging. As a result, most studies that focus on FOXA1 mutants rely on ectopic overexpression of FOXA1 from a plasmid. Therefore, we provide an optimized methodology for replacing endogenous wild‐type FOXA1 with precise knock‐in mutants to enable the systematic analysis of its molecular mechanisms within the appropriate physiological context.

Exploiting DNA repair pathways for tumor sensitization, mitigation of resistance, and normal tissue protection in radiotherapy

More than half of cancer patients are treated with radiotherapy, which kills tumor cells by directly and indirectly inducing DNA damage, including cytotoxic DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Tumor cells respond to these threats by activating a complex signaling network termed the DNA damage response (DDR). The DDR arrests the cell cycle, upregulates DNA repair, and triggers apoptosis when damage is excessive. The DDR signaling and DNA repair pathways are fertile terrain for therapeutic intervention. This review highlights strategies to improve therapeutic gain by targeting DDR and DNA repair pathways to radiosensitize tumor cells, overcome intrinsic and acquired tumor radioresistance, and protect normal tissue. Many biological and environmental factors determine tumor and normal cell responses to ionizing radiation and genotoxic chemotherapeutics. These include cell type and cell cycle phase distribution; tissue/tumor microenvironment and oxygen levels; DNA damage load and quality; DNA repair capacity; and susceptibility to apoptosis or other active or passive cell death pathways. We provide an overview of radiobiological parameters associated with X-ray, proton, and carbon ion radiotherapy; DNA repair and DNA damage signaling pathways; and other factors that regulate tumor and normal cell responses to radiation. We then focus on recent studies exploiting DSB repair pathways to enhance radiotherapy therapeutic gain.

Special bioactive compounds and functional foods may exhibit neuroprotective effects in patients with dementia (Review)

Dementia is a failure of cognitive ability characterized by severe neurodegeneration in select neural systems, and Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common type of neurodegenerative disease. Although numerous studies have provided insights into the pathogenesis of AD, the underlying signaling and molecular pathways mediating the progressive decline of cognitive function remain poorly understood. Recent progress in molecular biology has provided an improved understanding of the importance of molecular pathogenesis of AD, and has proposed an association between DNA repair mechanisms and AD. In particular, the fundamental roles of phosphatase and tensin homologue deleted on chromosome 10 (PTEN) and breast cancer gene 1 (BRCA1) tumor suppressors have been shown to regulate the pathogenesis of neurodegeneration. Consequently, onset of neurodegenerative diseases may be deferred with the use of dietary neuroprotective agents which alter the signaling mediated by the aforementioned tumor suppressors. In a healthy neuron, homeostasis of key intracellular molecules is of great importance, and preventing neuronal apoptosis is one of the primary goals of treatments designed for dementia-associated diseases. In the present review, progress into the understanding of dietary regulation for preventing or limiting development of dementia is discussed with a focus on the modulatory roles of PTEN and BRCA1 signaling.