Phenotypic characteristics and tendency to apoptosis of peripheral blood mononuclear cells from HIV+ long term non progressors

Cytometry, immunology, and HIV infection: three decades of strong interactions

Flow cytometry (FCM) has been extensively used to investigate immunological changes that occur from infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). This review describes some of the most relevant cellular and molecular changes in the immune system that can be detected by FCM during HIV infection. Finally, it will be discussed how this technology has facilitated the understanding not only of the biology of the virus but also of the mechanisms that the immune system activates to fight HIV and is allowing to monitor the efficacy of antiretroviral therapy.

Different immunological phenotypes associated with preserved CD4+ T cell counts in HIV-infected controllers and viremic long term non-progressors

BACKGROUND

HIV-infected controllers control viral replication and maintain normal CD4+ T cell counts. Long Term Non-Progressors (LTNP) also maintain normal CD4+ T cell counts, but have on-going viral replication. We hypothesized that different immunological mechanisms are responsible for preserved CD4+ T cell counts in controllers and LTNP.

METHODS

25 HIV-infected controllers and 14 LTNP were included in this cross-sectional study. For comparison, 25 progressors and 34 healthy controls were included. Production and destruction of T cells were addressed by determination of T cell receptor excision circles (TREC), recent thymic emigrants, naïve cells, immune activation, senescence and apoptosis. Furthermore, telomere length was determined, and the amount of lymphoid tissue in tonsil biopsies was quantified.

RESULTS

Controllers presented with partly preserved thymic output, preserved expression of the IL-7 receptor and IL-7 receptor density, and lower levels of destruction of cells than progressors resembling HIV-negative healthy controls. In contrast, LTNP appeared much like progressors, and different from controllers in immune activation, senescence, and apoptosis. Interestingly, CD8+ RTE, TREC and telomere length were partly preserved. Finally, both controllers and LTNP displayed decreased amounts of lymphoid tissue compared to healthy controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Controllers presented with an immunological profile different from LTNP. While controllers resembled healthy controls, LTNP were similar to progressors, suggesting different immunological mechanisms to be responsible for preserved CD4+ T cell counts in LTNP and controllers. However, both controllers and LTNP presented with reduced amounts of lymphoid tissue despite preserved CD4+ T cell counts, indicating HIV to cause damage even in non-progressors.

Novel genetic association of TNF-α-238 and PDCD1-7209 polymorphisms with long-term non-progressive HIV-1 infection

OBJECTIVES

About 2-5% of HIV-1-infected subjects, defined as long-term non-progressors (LTNPs), remain immunologically stable for a long time without treatment. The factors governing this condition are known only in part, and include genetic factors. Thus, we studied 20 polymorphisms of 15 genes encoding proinflammatory and immunoregulatory cytokines, chemokines and their receptors, genes involved in apoptosis, and the gene HCP5.

METHODS

We analyzed 47 Caucasian LTNPs infected for >9 years, compared with 131 HIV-1-infected Caucasian patients defined as 'usual progressors'. The genotypes were determined by methods based upon PCR, and the statistical analysis was performed by univariate logistic regression.

RESULTS

The well-known CCR5Δ32 del32 allele, the cell death-related TNF-α-238 A and PDCD1-7209 T alleles, and HCP5 rs2395029 G, a non-coding protein associated with the HLA-B*5701, were found positively associated with the LTNP condition. No association was observed for other single nucleotide polymorphisms (SDF-1-801, IL-10-592, MCP-1-2518, CX3CR1 V249I, CCR2V64I, RANTES-403, IL-2-330, IL-1β-511, IL-4-590, FASL IVS3nt-169, FAS-670, FAS-1377, FASL IVS2nt-124, PDCD1-7146, MMP-7-181, and MMP7-153).

CONCLUSIONS

The novel genetic associations between allelic variants of genes TNF-α-238 and PDCD1-7209 with the LTNP condition underline the importance of host genetic factors in the progression of HIV-1 infection and in immunological preservation.

Thirty Years with HIV Infection-Nonprogression Is Still Puzzling: Lessons to Be Learned from Controllers and Long-Term Nonprogressors

In the early days of the HIV epidemic, it was observed that a minority of the infected patients did not progress to AIDS or death and maintained stable CD4+ cell counts. As the technique for measuring viral load became available it was evident that some of these nonprogressors in addition to preserved CD4+ cell counts had very low or even undetectable viral replication. They were therefore termed controllers, while those with viral replication were termed long-term nonprogressors (LTNPs). Genetics and virology play a role in nonprogression, but does not provide a full explanation. Therefore, host differences in the immunological response have been proposed. Moreover, the immunological response can be divided into an immune homeostasis resistant to HIV and an immune response leading to viral control. Thus, non-progression in LTNP and controllers may be due to different immunological mechanisms. Understanding the lack of disease progression and the different interactions between HIV and the immune system could ideally teach us how to develop a functional cure for HIV infection. Here we review immunological features of controllers and LTNP, highlighting differences and clinical implications.

HIV Protease Cleavage of Procaspase 8 is Necessary for Death of HIV-Infected Cells

Numerous host and viral factors are capable of causing death of HIV infected cells, uninfected bystander cells, or both. We assessed the relevance of HIV protease in infected cell killing by mutating its obligate substrate for death, procaspase 8. VSV pseudotyped HIV infection of cells expressing WT caspase 8 resulted in apoptotic cell death and generation of the HIV protease specific cleavage product of procaspase 8, casp8p41. Conversely, both cell death and casp8p41 production were inhibited in cells expressing procaspase 8 engineered to be resistant to HIV protease cleavage. Lymph nodes from HIV-infected patients with ongoing viral replication also selectively expressed casp8p41, which colocalized with both infected and apoptotic cells. HIV protease cleavage of procaspase 8 appears to be a necessary event for infected cell killing, which is responsible for infected cell death within lymphoid tissues from HIV-infected patients.

Increased plasma levels of extracellular mitochondrial DNA during HIV infection: a new role for mitochondrial damage-associated molecular patterns during inflammation

HIV infection is characterized by a chronic inflammatory state. Recently, it has been shown that mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) released from damaged or dead cells can bind Toll like receptor-9 (TLR9), an intracellular receptor that responds to bacterial or viral DNA molecules. The activation of TLR9 present within monocytes or neutrophils results in a potent inflammatory reaction, with the production of proinflammatory cytokines. We measured plasma levels of mtDNA in different groups of HIV(+) patients, i.e., those experiencing an acute HIV infection (AHI), long term non progressors (LTNP), late presenters (LP) taking antiretroviral therapy for the first time, and healthy controls. We found that in AHI and LP mtDNA plasma levels were significantly higher than in healthy individuals or in LTNP. Plasma mtDNA levels were not correlated to peripheral blood CD4(+) T cell count, nor to markers of immune activation, but had a significant correlation with plasma viral load, revealing a possible role for mtDNA in inflammation, or as a biomarker of virus-induced damage.

Characterization of host genetic expression patterns in HIV-infected individuals with divergent disease progression

The course of HIV-1 infection shows a variety of clinical phenotypes with an important involvement of host factors. We compare host gene expression patterns in CD3+ T cells from two of these phenotypes: long-term non-progressor patients (LTNP) and matched control patients with standard HIV disease progression. Array analysis revealed over-expression of 322 genes in progressors and 136 in LTNP. Up-regulated genes in progressors were mainly implicated in the regulation of DNA replication, cell cycle and DNA damage stimulus and mostly localized into cellular organelles. In contrast, most up-regulated genes in LTNP were located at the plasmatic membrane and involved in cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction, negative control of apoptosis or regulation of actin cytoskeleton. Regarding gene interactions, a higher number of viral genes interacting with cellular factors were seen in progressors. Our study offers new comparative insights related to disease status and can distinguish differentiated patterns of gene expression among clinical phenotypes.

Proteomic analysis of PBMCs: characterization of potential HIV-associated proteins

Background

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) pandemic has continued unabated for nearly 30 years. To better understand the influence of virus on host cells, we performed the differential proteome research of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from HIV-positive patients and healthy controls.

Results

26 protein spots with more than 1.5-fold difference were detected in two dimensional electrophoresis (2DE) gels. 12 unique up-regulated and one down-regulated proteins were identified in HIV-positive patients compared with healthy donors. The mRNA expression of 10 genes was analyzed by real time RT-PCR. It shows that the mRNA expression of talin-1, vinculin and coronin-1C were up-regulated in HIV positive patients and consistent with protein expression. Western blotting analysis confirmed the induction of fragments of vinculin, talin-1 and filamin-A in pooled and most part of individual HIV-positive clinical samples. Bioinformatic analysis showed that a wide host protein network was disrupted in HIV-positive patients.

Conclusions

Together, this work provided useful information to facilitate further investigation of the underlying mechanism of HIV and host cell protein interactions, and discovered novel potential biomarkers such as fragment of vinculin, filamin-A and talin-1 for anti-HIV research.

CD57+ T lymphocytes and functional immune deficiency

CD57(+) expression in T lymphocytes has been recognized for decades as a marker of in vitro replicative senescence. In recent years, accumulating evidences have pointed on the utility of this marker to measure functional immune deficiency in patients with autoimmune disease, infectious diseases, and cancers. We review here the relevant literature and implications in clinical settings.

Different sensitivity to apoptosis in cells of monocytic or lymphocytic origin chronically infected with human immunodeficiency virus type-1

Apoptotic death of CD4+ T lymphocytes is a major cause of the immunodeficiency caused by human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), but it is still unclear how this process precisely occurs. To characterize a potentially useful cellular model, we have analyzed the tendency of chronically HIV-infected CD4+ human cell lines of different origin to undergo apoptosis. We studied ACH-2 and U1 lines, derived from the CD4+ T-cell A301 and the promonocytic U937 cell lines, respectively, and induced apoptosis via several stimuli that trigger different pathways. Their capacity to regulate plasma membrane CD95 expression and to produce soluble CD95 was also analyzed. Using staurosporine, TNF-alpha plus cycloheximide, and gamma-radiations, we observed that ACH-2 were more sensitive to programmed cell death than A301, while U1 were less sensitive than U937. Both infected cell types had a lower sensitivity to CD95-induced apoptosis; the analysis of changes in mitochondrial membrane potential corroborated these observations. Plasma membrane CD95 was similarly regulated in all cell types, which, however, presented a different capacity to produce soluble CD95 molecules. Our in vitro results may offer a new perspective for developing further studies on the pathogenesis of HIV infection. A chronically infected cell line of lymphocytic origin is more susceptible to apoptosis than its parental cell type, while infected monocytic cells are less sensitive than their uninfected counterpart. Thus, it is possible to hypothesize that one of the reasons by which circulating monocytes survive and represent a viral reservoir is the capacity of HIV to decrease the sensitivity to apoptosis of this cell type. However, further studies on ex-vivo collected fresh cells, as well as on other cell lines, are urgently needed to confirm such hypothesis.

Vpr R77Q is associated with long-term nonprogressive HIV infection and impaired induction of apoptosis

The absence of immune defects that occurs in the syndrome of long-term nonprogressive (LTNP) HIV infection offers insights into the pathophysiology of HIV-induced immune disease. The (H[F/S]RIG)(2) domain of viral protein R (Vpr) induces apoptosis and may contribute to HIV-induced T cell depletion. We demonstrate a higher frequency of R77Q Vpr mutations in patients with LTNP than in patients with progressive disease. In addition, T cell infections using vesicular stomatitis virus G (VSV-G) pseudotyped HIV-1 Vpr R77Q result in less (P = 0.01) T cell death than infections using wild-type Vpr, despite similar levels of viral replication. Wild-type Vpr-associated events, including procaspase-8 and -3 cleavage, loss of mitochondrial transmembrane potential (deltapsi(m)), and DNA fragmentation factor activation are attenuated by R77Q Vpr. These data highlight the pathophysiologic role of Vpr in HIV-induced immune disease and suggest a novel mechanism of LTNP.

Markers of cell death-activation in lymphocytes of vertically HIV-infected children naive to highly active antiretroviral therapy: the role of age

BACKGROUND

Apoptosis plays a major role in depleting CD4(+) lymphocytes during infection with HIV-1. Few data exist on its role during HIV infection of children. Sensitivity of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) to apoptotic stimuli and the importance of the patient's age remain unclear.

OBJECTIVES

We sought to analyze the following: (1) markers of cell death-activation (CD95, CD45 isoforms, and CD28) in PBLs from vertically HIV-infected children of different ages before highly active antiretroviral therapy; (2) changes in other PBL populations; (3) PBL sensitivity to cell death and mitochondrial damages; and (4) role of age during progression of infection.

METHODS

Cell culture techniques and flow cytometry were used to analyze surface antigens, PBL susceptibility to apoptosis, or PBL susceptibility to change of mitochondrial membrane potential.

RESULTS

Donor age had a strong negative correlation with numbers of CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. Virgin T lymphocyte (CD45RA(+), CD95(-)) levels and those of CD95(+) cells showed no correlation with the children's clinical status but did show a correlation with patient age. CD28(-) T lymphocytes were markedly augmented in HIV-infected children but were unrelated to stage of infection or age. A relevant decrease in B lymphocytes and an increase in natural killer cells were also found. Finally, PBLs from HIV-positive children had a marked tendency to undergo apoptosis and mitochondrial damage.

CONCLUSION

Changes in PBL phenotype, increased expression of CD95, and high sensitivity to apoptosis suggest that a precocious aging of the immune system occurs in HIV-infected children.

Mechanisms of HIV-associated lymphocyte apoptosis

Infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is associated with a progressive decrease in CD4 T-cell number and a consequent impairment in host immune defenses. Analysis of T cells from patients infected with HIV, or of T cells infected in vitro with HIV, demonstrates a significant fraction of both infected and uninfected cells dying by apoptosis. The many mechanisms that contribute to HIV-associated lymphocyte apoptosis include chronic immunologic activation; gp120/160 ligation of the CD4 receptor; enhanced production of cytotoxic ligands or viral proteins by monocytes, macrophages, B cells, and CD8 T cells from HIV-infected patients that kill uninfected CD4 T cells; and direct infection of target cells by HIV, resulting in apoptosis. Although HIV infection results in T-cell apoptosis, under some circumstances HIV infection of resting T cells or macrophages does not result in apoptosis; this may be a critical step in the development of viral reservoirs. Recent therapies for HIV effectively reduce lymphoid and peripheral T-cell apoptosis, reduce viral replication, and enhance cellular immune competence; however, they do not alter viral reservoirs. Further understanding the regulation of apoptosis in HIV disease is required to develop novel immune-based therapies aimed at modifying HIV-induced apoptosis to the benefit of patients infected with HIV.

Mechanisms of HIV-associated lymphocyte apoptosis

Infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is associated with a progressive decrease in CD4 T-cell number and a consequent impairment in host immune defenses. Analysis of T cells from patients infected with HIV, or of T cells infected in vitro with HIV, demonstrates a significant fraction of both infected and uninfected cells dying by apoptosis. The many mechanisms that contribute to HIV-associated lymphocyte apoptosis include chronic immunologic activation; gp120/160 ligation of the CD4 receptor; enhanced production of cytotoxic ligands or viral proteins by monocytes, macrophages, B cells, and CD8 T cells from HIV-infected patients that kill uninfected CD4 T cells; and direct infection of target cells by HIV, resulting in apoptosis. Although HIV infection results in T-cell apoptosis, under some circumstances HIV infection of resting T cells or macrophages does not result in apoptosis; this may be a critical step in the development of viral reservoirs. Recent therapies for HIV effectively reduce lymphoid and peripheral T-cell apoptosis, reduce viral replication, and enhance cellular immune competence; however, they do not alter viral reservoirs. Further understanding the regulation of apoptosis in HIV disease is required to develop novel immune-based therapies aimed at modifying HIV-induced apoptosis to the benefit of patients infected with HIV.

Deregulation of the CD95/CD95L system in lymphocytes from patients with primary acute HIV infection

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the role of CD95/CD95 ligand (CD95L) expression and functionality in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) during primary, acute HIV syndrome (AHS) and in the subsequent period.

PATIENTS

Twelve patients were studied during the acute phase of the viral infection and most were followed for some months.

METHODS

Cell culture and cytotoxicity assays based upon 51Cr release and flow cytometry were used to evaluate cell killing via CD95 molecule, flow cytometry to assess surface antigens, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the determination of soluble CD95 and CD95L plasma levels, quantitative competitive (QC) reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) with an original RNA competitor for the analysis of CD95L mRNA expression and QC RT-PCR for determining plasma viral load.

RESULTS

The analysis of PBL during this phase revealed that almost all cells, including CD8 T cells with a virgin phenotype, B lymphocytes and natural killer cells displayed CD95 molecules on the plasma membrane. Activation of CD95 on the surface of isolated lymphocytes by anti-CD95 monoclonal antibodies or binding to CD95L induced rapid apoptosis. However, CD95L mRNA was not expressed in PBL from these patients and was poorly inducible. Soluble CD95 was found in the plasma of all patients, but only in a few at high levels, even some months after seroconversion. In contrast, soluble CD95L was detected in only one patient, this occurring after the symptomatic period. For 10 of the 12 patients, expression of CD95 on the cell membrane or in the plasma did not correlate with the plasma viral load, which varied widely from patient to patient. Further, plasma levels of soluble CD95 were not altered by decreased lymphocyte activation or by efficient antiretroviral therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients experiencing an acute, primary HIV infection, a prolonged deregulation of the CD95/CD95L system may exist, which is probably not entirely related to virus production but may contribute to the pathogenesis of the disease. The hypothesis can be put forward that a complex balance exists between proapoptotic events (increase in CD95 expression), probably triggered by the host as a method to limit viral production, and antiapoptotic events (decrease in CD95L expression) probably triggered by the virus as a way to increase its production and survival.

HIV type 1-induced inhibition of CD45 tyrosine phosphatase activity correlates with disease progression and apoptosis, but not with anti-CD3-induced T cell proliferation

The tyrosine phosphatase CD45 is a key positive element in multiple lymphocyte signaling pathways. To understand the contribution of CD45 to HIV-1-induced T cell hyporesponsiveness and apoptosis we evaluated the CD45-associated tyrosine phosphatase activity of lymphocytes from patients with different stages of HIV-1 disease and compared it with CD45 expression, spontaneous and Fas-induced apoptosis, anti-CD3-induced T cell proliferation, distribution of CCR5 delta32/wt, and cytokine production. The proliferative response to anti-CD3 as well as the CD45-associated phosphatase activity were significantly reduced in progressors. In long-term nonprogressors (LTNPs) the proliferative response to anti-CD3 was also diminished, although to a lesser extent, while the tyrosine phosphatase activity was not significantly impaired. One-third of LTNPs were found positive for the 32-bp deletion of the CCR5 gene. This mutation had no effects on anti-CD3 proliferative response or CD45 phosphatase activity. A significant reduction in IL-2 and IFN-gamma was observed in both LTNPs and in normal progressors, whereas IL-4 production was significantly decreased only in progressors. Last, we observed a significant correlation between CD45 phosphatase activity and apoptosis. We therefore conclude that the impairment of CD45 tyrosine phosphatase activity correlates with disease progression and the level of T cell apoptosis, but not with anti-CD3-induced T cell proliferation. Moreover, we suggest that evaluation of CD45 tyrosine phosphatase activity may represent an additional tool with which to assess disease progression.

Differential down-regulation of CD95 or CD95L in chronically HIV-infected cells of monocytic or lymphocytic origin: cellular studies and molecular analysis by quantitative competitive RT-PCR

We analysed the expression of CD95/CD95L in two widely used models for studying the cellular effects of chronic infection with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), i.e. ACH-2 cells, derived from the lymphocytic cell line A301, and U1, derived from monocytic U937 cells. A301 and ACH-2 mounted the same amount of plasma membrane CD95, while U1 had a consistent decrease in CD95 expression. Using different antibodies, we failed to detect the plasma membrane form of its ligand, CD95L, but we could see the intracellular presence of that molecule in A301 cells and, to a lesser extent, in ACH-2 cells, but not in U937 or U1 cells. To confirm the cytofluorimetric data and quantify the expression of CD95L at the RNA level, we developed a quantitative competitive RT-PCR assay. The HUT78 cell line had about 50,000 copies mRNA/1000 cells, three times more after induction with a phorbol ester and ionomycin. ACH-2 expressed about 400- (basal) or 10- (induced) fold less CD95L mRNA than the parental cell line A301; U937 and U1 were below the limit of detection. In cells of lymphoid origin (ACH-2) chronic HIV infection inhibits the expression of CD95L, the phenomenon occurring at the transcriptional level. In cells of monocytic origin (U1) the infection decreases the plasma membrane expression of CD95. This suggests that HIV could trigger different anti-apoptotic strategies which likely depend upon the cell line which is infected. In monocytic cells which act as a viral reservoir, the expression of the molecule whose binding triggers apoptosis decreases, while in lymphoid cells, capable of exerting cytotoxicity, the expression of a molecule which induces apoptosis is reduced.

Apoptotic features of peripheral blood granulocytes and monocytes during primary, acute HIV infection

Apoptosis plays a major role during HIV infection, including the primary, acute HIV syndrome (AHS), during which such phenomenon is massive. We asked whether apoptosis involved not only peripheral blood lymphocytes, but also monocytes (PBM) and granulocytes (PBG). Thus, we studied cells from different patients during the acute phase of the viral syndrome. The CD95 molecule was expressed at high density on the PBM and PBG surface during AHS. Culturing PBG for a few hours resulted in a significant membrane expression of phosphatidylserine, consistent with apoptosis. However, cells maintained for hours plasma membrane integrity and showed no relevant changes in mitochondrial membrane potential. The overexpression of CD95 was not associated with high plasmatic levels of sCD95 and, together with apoptosis and its related markers decreased after a few weeks of highly active antiretroviral therapy. During AHS, a deregulation of the CD95 system occurs in monocytes and granulocytes, is related to a high propensity of PBG to undergo apoptosis, and may contribute to the pathogenesis of the disease. Antiretroviral treatment resulted not only in a decrease of virus production, but also in a reduced PBG tendency to undergo spontaneous apoptosis. Even if the mechanism(s) responsible for this phenomenon remains to be elucidated, our data suggest a possible (indirect?) action of antiretroviral therapies on PBG and PBM which could explain, at least partially, the rescue of natural immunity and the reduced use of granulocyte-colony stimulating factor during such treatments.

The role of oxidative imbalance in progression to AIDS: effect of the thiol supplier N-acetylcysteine

In this study we investigate the redox profile of HIV+ patients at different stages of disease with regard to immunological parameters, i.e., the number of circulating CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes. For this purpose, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) obtained from healthy donors, HIV+ patients in the asymptomatic phase, long-term nonProgressors (LTNPs), and AIDS patients have been considered. Cells have been exposed in vitro to the prooxidizing agent menadione, which is able to induce superoxide anion formation, and the susceptibility of the cells to the induced oxidative stress was estimated. Moreover, the possibility that the susceptibility of the cells to oxidative stress might be reduced by preexposing them to the antioxidizing agent N-acetylcysteine (NAC) has also been analyzed. The results obtained can be summarized as follows: (1) treatment with the prooxidant agent is capable of inducing massive morphological alterations in PBMCs. In particular, a significant correlation was found between the decrease in number of CD4+ lymphocytes in patients at different stages of disease and the susceptibility of their PBMCs to oxidative stress; (2) preincubation with NAC was able to preserve partially the ultrastructural characteristics of PBMCs isolated from HIV+ patients. In particular, a direct relationship was found between the efficacy of NAC protection and CD4 counts; (3) evaluation of the plasma index of peroxidation and the number of circulating CD4 lymphocytes indicates the existence of a positive correlation between "systemic" oxidative imbalance and stage of the disease; and (4) cells from LTNPs display either oxidative susceptibility or oxidative markers similar to those of healthy donor cells. Our study suggests that the redox profile of patients may be considered a predictive marker of AIDS progression and that the acute infection and the asymptomatic phase of the disease may represent a useful period in which the combined use of antiretroviral and antioxidant drugs may be beneficial.