Partial duplications of the ATRX gene cause the ATR-X syndrome

Integrated omics analyses clarifies ATRX copy number variant of uncertain significance

Partial duplications of genes can be challenging to detect and interpret and, therefore, likely represent an underreported cause of human disease. X-linked dominant variants in ATRX are associated with Alpha-thalassemia/impaired intellectual development syndrome, X-linked (ATR-X syndrome), a clinically heterogeneous disease generally presenting with intellectual disability, hypotonia, characteristic facies, genital anomalies, and alpha-thalassemia. We describe an affected male with a de novo hemizygous intragenic duplication of ~43.6 kb in ATRX, detected by research genome sequencing following non-diagnostic clinical testing. RNA sequencing and DNA methylation episignature analyses were central in variant interpretation, and this duplication was subsequently interpreted as disease-causing. This represents the smallest reported tandem duplication within ATRX associated with disease. This case demonstrates the diagnostic utility of integrating multiple omics technologies, which can ultimately lead to a definitive diagnosis for rare disease patients.

A. Epigenetic regulation of craniofacial development and disease

BACKGROUND

The formation of the craniofacial complex relies on proper neural crest development. The gene regulatory networks (GRNs) and signaling pathways orchestrating this process have been extensively studied. These GRNs and signaling cascades are tightly regulated as alterations to any stage of neural crest development can lead to common congenital birth defects, including multiple syndromes affecting facial morphology as well as nonsyndromic facial defects, such as cleft lip with or without cleft palate. Epigenetic factors add a hierarchy to the regulation of transcriptional networks and influence the spatiotemporal activation or repression of specific gene regulatory cascades; however less is known about their exact mechanisms in controlling precise gene regulation.

AIMS

In this review, we discuss the role of epigenetic factors during neural crest development, specifically during craniofacial development and how compromised activities of these regulators contribute to congenital defects that affect the craniofacial complex.

A new mouse model of ATR-X syndrome carrying a common patient mutation exhibits neurological and morphological defects

ATRX is a chromatin remodelling ATPase that is involved in transcriptional regulation, DNA damage repair and heterochromatin maintenance. It has been widely studied for its role in ALT-positive cancers, but its role in neurological function remains elusive. Hypomorphic mutations in the X-linked ATRX gene cause a rare form of intellectual disability combined with alpha-thalassemia called ATR-X syndrome in hemizygous males. Clinical features also include facial dysmorphism, microcephaly, short stature, musculoskeletal defects and genital abnormalities. As complete deletion of ATRX in mice results in early embryonic lethality, the field has largely relied on conditional knockout models to assess the role of ATRX in multiple tissues. Given that null alleles are not found in patients, a more patient-relevant model was needed. Here, we have produced and characterized the first patient mutation knock-in model of ATR-X syndrome, carrying the most common causative mutation, R246C. This is one of a cluster of missense mutations located in the chromatin-binding domain and disrupts its function. The knock-in mice recapitulate several aspects of the patient disorder, including craniofacial defects, microcephaly, reduced body size and impaired neurological function. They provide a powerful model for understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying ATR-X syndrome and testing potential therapeutic strategies.

Electroencephalographic findings in ATRX syndrome: A new case series and review of literature

Alpha-thalassemia X-linked intellectual disability syndrome (ATRX) is a rare genetic condition caused by mutations in the ATRX gene characterized by distinctive dysmorphic features, alpha thalassemia, mild-to-profound intellectual disability, and epilepsy, reported in nearly 30% of the patients. To date, different types of seizures are reported in patients with ATRX syndrome including either clonic, tonic, myoclonic seizures or myoclonic absences. However, an accurate analysis of electroencephalographic features is lacking in literature. We report on the epileptic and electroencephalographic phenotype of seven unpublished patients with ATRX syndrome, highlighting the presence of a peculiar EEG pattern characterized by diffuse background slowing with superimposed low voltage fast activity. Likewise, we also review the available literature on this topic.

Optical Genome Mapping in Routine Human Genetic Diagnostics-Its Advantages and Limitations

In recent years, optical genome mapping (OGM) has developed into a highly promising method of detecting large-scale structural variants in human genomes. It is capable of detecting structural variants considered difficult to detect by other current methods. Hence, it promises to be feasible as a first-line diagnostic tool, permitting insight into a new realm of previously unknown variants. However, due to its novelty, little experience with OGM is available to infer best practices for its application or to clarify which features cannot be detected. In this study, we used the Saphyr system (Bionano Genomics, San Diego, CA, USA), to explore its capabilities in human genetic diagnostics. To this end, we tested 14 DNA samples to confirm a total of 14 different structural or numerical chromosomal variants originally detected by other means, namely, deletions, duplications, inversions, trisomies, and a translocation. Overall, 12 variants could be confirmed; one deletion and one inversion could not. The prerequisites for detection of similar variants were explored by reviewing the OGM data of 54 samples analyzed in our laboratory. Limitations, some owing to the novelty of the method and some inherent to it, were described. Finally, we tested the successful application of OGM in routine diagnostics and described some of the challenges that merit consideration when utilizing OGM as a diagnostic tool.

ATR-X syndrome: genetics, clinical spectrum, and management

ATR-X, an acronym for alpha thalassemia and mental retardation X-linked, syndrome is a congenital condition predominantly affecting males, characterized by mild to severe intellectual disability, facial, skeletal, urogenital, and hematopoietic anomalies. Less common are heart defects, eye anomalies, renal abnormalities, and gastrointestinal dysfunction. ATR-X syndrome is caused by germline variants in the ATRX gene. Until recently, the diagnosis of the ATR-X syndrome had been guided by the classical clinical manifestations and confirmed by molecular techniques. However, our new systematic analysis shows that the only clinical sign shared by all affected individuals is intellectual disability, with the other manifestations varying even within the same family. More than 190 different germline ATRX mutations in some 200 patients have been analyzed. With improved and more frequent analysis by molecular technologies, more subtle deletions and insertions have been detected recently. Moreover, emerging technologies reveal non-classic phenotypes of ATR-X syndrome as well as the description of a new clinical feature, the development of osteosarcoma which suggests an increased cancer risk in ATR-X syndrome. This review will focus on the different types of inherited ATRX mutations and their relation to clinical features in the ATR-X syndrome. We will provide an update of the frequency of clinical manifestations, the affected organs, and the genotype-phenotype correlations. Finally, we propose a shift in the diagnosis of ATR-X patients, from a clinical diagnosis to a molecular-based approach. This may assist clinicians in patient management, risk assessment and genetic counseling.

Alternative lengthening of telomeres in childhood neuroblastoma from genome to proteome

Telomere maintenance by telomerase activation or alternative lengthening of telomeres (ALT) is a major determinant of poor outcome in neuroblastoma. Here, we screen for ALT in primary and relapsed neuroblastomas (n = 760) and characterize its features using multi-omics profiling. ALT-positive tumors are molecularly distinct from other neuroblastoma subtypes and enriched in a population-based clinical sequencing study cohort for relapsed cases. They display reduced ATRX/DAXX complex abundance, due to either ATRX mutations (55%) or low protein expression. The heterochromatic histone mark H3K9me3 recognized by ATRX is enriched at the telomeres of ALT-positive tumors. Notably, we find a high frequency of telomeric repeat loci with a neuroblastoma ALT-specific hotspot on chr1q42.2 and loss of the adjacent chromosomal segment forming a neo-telomere. ALT-positive neuroblastomas proliferate slowly, which is reflected by a protracted clinical course of disease. Nevertheless, children with an ALT-positive neuroblastoma have dismal outcome.

Molecular genetic characterization of a prenatally detected 1.484-Mb Xq13.3-q21.1 duplication encompassing ATRX and a literature review of syndromic intellectual disability and congenital abnormalities in males with a duplication at Xq13.3-q21.1

OBJECTIVE

We present prenatal diagnosis of dup(X)(q13.3q21.1) in a male fetus and molecular genetic analysis in three generations and a literature review of syndromic intellectual disability and congenital abnormalities in males with a duplication at Xq13.3-q21.1.

CASE REPORT

A 35-year-old, primigravid woman underwent amniocentesis at 18 weeks of gestation because of advanced maternal age. The woman and her mother were phenotypically normal, and there was no intellectual disability in the maternal family. Cytogenetic analysis of cultured amniocytes revealed a karyotype of 46,XY. Simultaneous array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) analysis on uncultured amniotic fluid incidentally detected a 1.484-Mb microduplication of Xq13.3-q21.1 encompassing ATRX. Subsequent aCGH analysis on fetal blood, maternal blood and grandmother's blood revealed the same 1.484-Mb dup(X)(q13.3q21.1). Prenatal ultrasound findings were unremarkable with no growth restriction and no short stature. After genetic counseling of syndromic intellectual disability in males with ATRX duplication, the woman elected to terminate the pregnancy. The fetus postnatally manifested hypoplastic male external genitalia, clinodactyly, hypertelorism, midface hypoplasia, epicanthic folds and micrognathia.

CONCLUSION

Simultaneous aCGH analysis on uncultured amniotic fluid in addition to conventional cytogenetics at amniocentesis is practical and may help in detecting unknown familial inheritance of subtle X chromosome aberrations.

625 kb microduplication at Xp22.12 including RPS6KA3 in a child with mild intellectual disability

Here, we report on a patient with a 625 kb duplication in Xp22.12, detected by array comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). The duplicated region contains only one gene, RPS6KA3, that results in partial duplication. The same duplication was present in his mother and his maternal uncle. This partial duplication inhibits the RPS6KA3 expression, mimicking the effect of loss-of-function mutations associated with Coffin-Lowry syndrome (CLS). The phenotype of the patient here presented is not fully evocative of this syndrome because he does not present some of the facial, digital and skeletal abnormalities that are considered the main diagnostic features of CLS. This case is one of the few examples where RPS6KA3 mutations are associated with a non-specific X-linked mental retardation.

Neuroradiologic features in X-linked α-thalassemia/mental retardation syndrome

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

X-linked α-thalassemia/mental retardation syndrome (Mendelian Inheritance in Man, 301040) is one of the X-linked intellectual disability syndromes caused by mutations of the ATRX gene and characterized by male predominance, central hypotonic facies, severe cognitive dysfunction, hemoglobin H disease (α-thalassemia), genital and skeletal abnormalities, and autistic and peculiar behavior. More than 200 patients in the world, including >70 Japanese patients, have been diagnosed with ATR-X syndrome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We reviewed the brain MRI and/or CT findings of 27 Japanese patients with ATR-X with ATRX mutations retrospectively.

RESULTS

The findings were categorized into 5 types: 1) nonspecific brain atrophy (17/27); 2) white matter abnormalities, especially around the trigones (11/27); 3) widespread and scattered white matter abnormalities (1/27); 4) delayed myelination (4/27); and 5) severe and rapidly progressive cortical brain atrophy (1/27).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report on a comprehensive study of brain MRI/CT findings of ATR-X syndrome. Our findings suggest that the ATRX protein seems to be involved in normal myelination. The classification will require revisions in the near future, but it will be helpful in establishing the relationship between ATRX mutation and brain development and understanding the ATRX protein function in the brain.

The role of genetics in the establishment and maintenance of the epigenome

Epigenetic mechanisms play an important role in gene regulation during development. DNA methylation, which is probably the most important and best-studied epigenetic mechanism, can be abnormally regulated in common pathologies, but the origin of altered DNA methylation remains unknown. Recent research suggests that these epigenetic alterations could depend, at least in part, on genetic mutations or polymorphisms in DNA methyltransferases and certain genes encoding enzymes of the one-carbon metabolism pathway. Indeed, the de novo methyltransferase 3B (DNMT3B) has been recently found to be mutated in several types of cancer and in the immunodeficiency, centromeric region instability and facial anomalies syndrome (ICF), in which these mutations could be related to the loss of global DNA methylation. In addition, mutations in glycine-N-methyltransferase (GNMT) could be associated with a higher risk of hepatocellular carcinoma and liver disease due to an unbalanced S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)/S-adenosylhomocysteine (SAH) ratio, which leads to aberrant methylation reactions. Also, genetic variants of chromatin remodeling proteins and histone tail modifiers are involved in genetic disorders like α thalassemia X-linked mental retardation syndrome, CHARGE syndrome, Cockayne syndrome, Rett syndrome, systemic lupus erythematous, Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome, Coffin-Lowry syndrome, Sotos syndrome, and facioescapulohumeral syndrome, among others. Here, we review the potential genetic alterations with a possible role on epigenetic factors and discuss their contribution to human disease.

Derivation of novel genetically diverse human embryonic stem cell lines

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) have the potential to revolutionize many biomedical fields ranging from basic research to disease modeling, regenerative medicine, drug discovery, and toxicity testing. A multitude of hESC lines have been derived worldwide since the first 5 lines by Thomson et al. 13 years ago, but many of these are poorly characterized, unavailable, or do not represent desired traits, thus making them unsuitable for application purposes. In order to provide the scientific community with better options, we have derived 12 new hESC lines at New York University from discarded genetically normal and abnormal embryos using the latest techniques. We examined the genetic status of the NYUES lines in detail as well as their molecular and cellular features and DNA fingerprinting profile. Furthermore, we differentiated our hESCs into the tissues most affected by a specific condition or into clinically desired cell types. To our knowledge, a number of characteristics of our hESCs have not been previously reported, for example, mutation for alpha thalassemia X-linked mental retardation syndrome, linkage to conditions with a genetic component such as asthma or poor sperm morphology, and novel combinations of ethnic backgrounds. Importantly, all of our undifferentiated euploid female lines tested to date did not show X chromosome inactivation, believed to result in superior potency. We continue to derive new hESC lines and add them to the NIH registry and other registries. This should facilitate the use of our hESCs and lead to advancements for patient-benefitting applications.

X-chromosome duplications in males with mental retardation: pathogenic or benign variants?

Studies to identify copy number variants (CNVs) on the X-chromosome have revealed novel genes important in the causation of X-linked mental retardation (XLMR). Still, for many CNVs it is unclear whether they are associated with disease or are benign variants. We describe six different CNVs on the X-chromosome in five male patients with mental retardation that were identified by conventional karyotyping and single nucleotide polymorphism array analysis. One deletion and five duplications ranging in size from 325 kb to 12.5 Mb were observed. Five CNVs were maternally inherited and one occurred de novo. We discuss the involvement of potential candidate genes and focus on the complexity of X-chromosomal duplications in males inherited from healthy mothers with different X-inactivation patterns. Based on size and/or the presence of XLMR genes we were able to classify CNVs as pathogenic in two patients. However, it remains difficult to decide if the CNVs in the other three patients are pathogenic or benign.

The first case of X-linked Alpha-thalassemia/mental retardation (ATR-X) syndrome in Korea

Mutation of the ATRX gene leads to X-linked alpha-thalassemia/mental retardation (ATR-X) syndrome and several other X-linked mental retardation syndromes. We report the first case of ATR-X syndrome documented here in Korea. A 32-month-old boy came in with irritability and fever. He showed dysmorphic features, mental retardation and epilepsy, so ATR-X syndrome was considered. Hemoglobin H inclusions in red blood cells supported the diagnosis and genetic studies confirmed it. Mutation analysis for our patient showed a point mutation of thymine to cytosine on the 9th exon in the ATRX gene, indicating that Trp(C), the 220th amino acid, was replaced by Ser(R). Furthermore, we investigated the same mutation in family members, and his mother and two sisters were found to be carriers.

Array comparative genomic hybridization as a diagnostic tool for syndromic heart defects

OBJECTIVES

To investigate different aspects of the introduction of array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) in clinical practice.

STUDY DESIGN

A total 150 patients with a syndromic congenital heart defect (CHD) of unknown cause were analyzed with aCGH at 1-Mb resolution. Twenty-nine of these patients, with normal results on 1Mb aCGH, underwent re-analysis with 244-K oligo-microarray. With a logistic regression model, we assessed the predictive value of patient characteristics for causal imbalance detection. On the basis of our earlier experience and the literature, we constructed an algorithm to evaluate the causality of copy number variants.

RESULTS

With 1-Mb aCGH, we detected 43 structural variants not listed as clinically neutral polymorphisms, 26 of which were considered to be causal. A systematic comparison of the clinical features of these 26 patients to the remaining 124 patients revealed dysmorphism as the only feature with a significant predictive value for reaching a diagnosis with 1-Mb aCGH. With higher resolution analysis in 29 patients, 75 variants not listed as clinically neutral polymorphisms were detected, 2 of which were considered to be causal.

CONCLUSIONS

Molecular karyotyping yields an etiological diagnosis in at least 18% of patients with a syndromic CHD. Higher resolution evaluation results in an increasing number of variants of unknown significance.

Clinical and molecular overview of inherited disorders resulting from epigenomic dysregulation

Epigenetics is the study of heritable changes in gene expression that occur without a change in the DNA sequence. Most constitutional defects in genes encoding components of the machinery that regulates the epigenome lead to embryonic death. Hypomorphic mutations may be compatible with life, but lead to severe developmental disorders. Their study is of great importance to our understanding of epigenetics and may clarify the interplay between different epigenetic mechanisms. This review will briefly introduce DNA methylation, post-translational histone modifications, and non-coding small RNA transcription, which are the best known epigenetic mechanisms. Then it will describe five human disorders (RETT, ATRX, ICF, Coffin-Lowry, and Rubinstein-Taybi) resulting from mutations in genes responsible for DNA methylation and in genes involved in chromatin remodeling. Finally, it will discuss how research in medical genetics can elucidate fundamental epigenetic processes.

Xq13.2q21.1 duplication encompassing the ATRX gene in a man with mental retardation, minor facial and genital anomalies, short stature and broad thorax

In a man with severe mental retardation, minor facial and genital anomalies, disproportionate short stature and a broad thorax, we identified a de novo Xq13.2q21.1 duplication by array CGH. This 7 Mb duplication encompasses 23 known genes, including the X-linked mental retardation (XLMR) genes ATRX and SLC16A2. The phenotype of this patient is similar to that described in more than 10 previously reported patients with overlapping Xq duplications. Detailed comparison of the clinical characteristics and the function of the genes located in the commonly duplicated regions of these patients led us to the hypothesis that an increased dosage of ATRX and perhaps of other genes is involved in the pathogenetic mechanism of this XLMR phenotype, including mental retardation, short stature, and genital abnormalities comprising cryptorchidism and/or a small penis.

Mutations in the chromatin-associated protein ATRX

ATRX belongs to the SNF2 family of proteins, many of which have been demonstrated to have chromatin remodeling activity. Constitution mutations in the X-encoded gene give rise to alpha thalassemia mental retardation (ATR-X) syndrome and a variety of related conditions that are often associated with profound developmental delay, facial dysmorphism, genital abnormalities, and alpha thalassemia. Acquired mutations in ATRX are observed in the preleukemic condition alpha thalassemia myelodysplastic syndrome (ATMDS). Mutations in ATRX have been shown to perturb gene expression and DNA methylation. This is a comprehensive report of 127 mutations including 32 reported here for the first time. Missense mutations are shown to cluster in the two main functional domains. The truncating mutations appear to be "rescued" to some degree and so it appears likely that most if not all constitutional ATRX mutations are hypomorphs.

A complex submicroscopic chromosomal imbalance in 19p13.11 with one microduplication and two microtriplications

Complex chromosomal rearrangements [CCRs] are considered very rare, but are being detected with an increasing frequency because of the enhanced resolution of novel molecular karyotyping techniques like array-CGH. This report describes a patient carrying a unique CCR involving one duplication and two triplications in a 3.2 Mb region on 19p13.11. The patient presented with microcephaly, velopharyngeal insufficiency, dysmorphism, mental retardation and a muscular ventricular septal defect. We show that CCRs are likely to be more frequent than hitherto appreciated. This has important consequences for genotype-phenotype correlations and warrants caution before labelling imbalances as "simple".

The first large duplication of the RSK2 gene identified in a Coffin-Lowry syndrome patient

Heterogeneous mutations in the X-linked gene RPS6KA3, encoding the protein kinase RSK2, are responsible for Coffin-Lowry Syndrome. Here we have further studied a male patient with a highly suggestive clinical diagnosis of CLS but in whom no mutation was found by exon sequencing. Western blot analysis revealed a protein much larger than the normal expected size. Sequencing of the RSK2 cDNA, showed the presence of an in-frame tandem duplication of exons 17-20. The mutated RSK2 protein was found to be inactive in an in-vitro kinase assay. This event, which was the result of a homologous unequal recombination between Alu sequences, is the first reported large duplication of the RPS6KA3 gene. Our finding provides further evidence that immunoblot analysis, or a molecular assay capable to detect large genomic mutational events, is essential for patients with a highly suggestive CLS clinical diagnosis but remaining without mutation after exon sequencing.