A study to evaluate primary dressings for the application of cultured keratinocytes

Artificial Skin Therapies; Strategy for Product Development

Significance: Tissue-engineered artificial skin for clinical reconstruction can be regarded as an established practice. Bi-layered skin equivalents are available as established allogenic or autologous therapy, and various acellular skin replacements can support tissue repair. Moreover, there is considerable commonality between the skin and other soft tissue reconstruction products. This article presents an attempt to create a comprehensive global landscape review of advanced replacement materials and associated strategies for skin and soft tissue reconstruction. Recent Advances: There has been rapid growth in the number of commercial and pre-commercial products over the past decade. In this survey, 263 base products for advanced skin therapy have been identified, across 8 therapeutic categories, giving over 350 products in total. The largest market is in the United States, followed by the E.U. zone. However, despite these advances, and the investment of resources in each product development, there are key issues concerning the clinical efficacy, cost-benefit of products, and clinical impact. Each therapeutic strategy has relative merits and limitations. Critical Issues: A critical consideration in developing and evaluating products is the therapeutic modality, associated regulatory processes, and the potential for clinical adoption geographically, determined by regulatory territory, intellectual property, and commercial distribution factors. The survey identifies an opportunity for developments that improve basic efficacy or cost-benefit. Future Directions: The economic pressures on health care systems, compounded by the demands of our increasingly ageing population, and the imperative to distribute effective health care, create an urgent global need for effective and affordable products.

Analysis of transferred keratinocyte-like cells derived from mouse embryonic stem cells on experimental surgical skin wounds of mouse

Autologous/allogenic skin grafts constituted from differentiated adult or embryonic stem cells can be used in treatment of skin disorders. In our study we aimed to differentiate keratinocytes from mouse embryonic stem cells and the transfer of viable keratinocyte-like cells to a model of surgical skin wound of mouse. Embryoid bodies, derived from mouse embryonic stem cells, were cultured on basement membrane matrix with added BMP-4 for 10 days. The identification of differentiated keratinocyte-like cells was done by detection of cytokeratin-8 and cytokeratin-14 localization using an indirect immunoperoxidase technique and transmission electron microscopy evaluation. Distribution of BrdU, cytokeratin-8 and cytokeratin-14 were evaluated using an indirect immunoperoxidase technique from the experimental (dressing including BrdU labelled cells applied after the surgical wound was created on mouse), control (only the surgical wound was created on mouse) and sham (only the dressing applied after the surgical wound was created on mouse) in groups after 3, 5 and 7 days. Immunohistochemically and ultrastructurally, cells derived from mouse embryonic stem cells were similar to differentiated keratinocyte-like cells. Differentiated keratinocyte-like cells were demonstrated by positive BrdU, cytokeratin-8 and cytokeratin-14 staining after transfer to the wound area. In the experimental group wound healing was better after transferring differentiated keratinocytes when compared to the sham and control groups. In vivo continuity and usability of derived cells are very important issues. In wound repair mechanisms, keratinocyte-like cells could provide positive effects during the wound healing and could be used in clinical treatments of wound repair process.

Embryonic porcine skin precursors can successfully develop into integrated skin without teratoma formation posttransplantation in nude mouse model

How to improve the wound healing quality of severe burn patients is still a challenge due to lack of skin appendages and rete ridges, no matter how much progress has been made in the fields of either stem cell or tissue engineering. We thus systematically studied the growth potential and differentiation capacity of porcine embryonic skin precursors. Implantation of embryonic skin precursors (PESPs) of different gestational ages in nude mice can generate the integrity skin, including epidermis, dermis and skin appendages, such as sweat gland, hair follicle, sebaceous gland, etc.. PESPs of embryonic day 42 possess the maximal growth potential, while, the safe window time of PESPs transplantation for prevention of teratoma risk is E56 or later. In conclusion, PESPs can form the 3 dimensional structures of skin with all necessary skin appendages. Our data strongly indicate that porcine embryonic skin precursors harvested from E56 of minipig may provide new hope for high-quality healing of extensive burns and traumas.

A comparison of tissue-engineered hyaluronic acid dermal matrices in a human wound model

The derivatives of hyaluronic acid (hyaluronan) have been extensively studied in the field of tissue engineering. Several forms of the material are available (benzyl esters of hyaluronic acid, HYAFF), with differing degradation profiles. This study compared 2 such products used for dermal regeneration (HYAFF p80 and HYAFF p100, the partial and total benzyl ester of hyaluronan, respectively), in a human model. In a prospective, randomized, controlled trial, 20 tattoos were tangentially excised and 1 of 2 hyaluronic acid-derived dermal matrices were applied to the wound bed. The partial ester was changed after 1 week and the total ester was kept for 2 weeks. After 2 weeks, cultured epidermal autograft was applied using the Laserskin method. Wounds were subsequently assessed by several modalities and by such features as rate of epithelialization, wound contraction, and histologic and immunohistologic appearances. Subtle differences were seen between the 2 groups, indicating that the total ester, which showed better clinical performance, could be used, especially in burns. This has the advantage of a single application for a 2-week period, rather than the comparison material, a partial ester, which requires weekly changing and degrades faster. Further, the method of epidermal grafting with a dermal substitute shows excellent results and adds to the armory for the treatment of both chronic and acute wounds.

The basement membrane component of biologic scaffolds derived from extracellular matrix

The extracellular matrix (ECM) has been successfully used as a scaffold for constructive remodeling of multiple tissues in both preclinical studies and in human clinical applications. The basement membrane is a specialized form of the ECM that supports and facilitates the growth of epithelial cell populations. The morphology and the molecular composition of the ECM, including the basement membrane, vary depending upon the organ from which the ECM is harvested and the methods by which it is processed for use as a medical device. Processing steps, such as decellularization, lyophilization, disinfection, and terminal sterilization, may affect the morphology and composition of an ECM scaffold, including, but not limited to, the integrity of a basement membrane complex. The present study evaluated the presence and integrity of a basement membrane complex in processed ECM derived from three different tissues: the urinary bladder, small intestine, and liver. Immunohistochemical determination of the presence and localization of three basement membrane molecules, collagen IV, laminin, and collagen VII, was conducted for each ECM scaffold. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to further explore the surface ultrastructure of selected ECM scaffolds. The effect of a surface basement membrane presence upon the pattern of in vitro growth of two separate cell types, NIH 3T3 fibroblasts and human microvascular endothelial cells (HMEC), was also evaluated for each ECM scaffold. Results showed that the only intact basement membrane complex was found on the luminal surface of the ECM derived from the urinary bladder and that the basement membrane was an effective barrier to penetration of the scaffold by the seeded cells. We conclude that the urinary bladder ECM but not the small intestine- or liver-derived ECM contains a surface with composition and morphology consistent with that of an intact basement membrane complex, that the basement membrane complex can survive processing, and that the basement membrane structure can modulate in vitro cell growth patterns.

The role of hyaluronic acid in wound healing: assessment of clinical evidence

Hyaluronic acid (hyaluronan), a naturally occurring polymer within the skin, has been extensively studied since its discovery in 1934. It has been used in a wide range of medical fields as diverse as orthopedics and cosmetic surgery, but it is in tissue engineering that it has been primarily advanced for treatment. The breakdown products of this large macromolecule have a range of properties that lend it specifically to this setting and also to the field of wound healing. It is non-antigenic and may be manufactured in a number of forms, ranging from gels to sheets of solid material through to lightly woven meshes. Epidermal engraftment is superior to most of the available biotechnologies and, as such, the material shows great promise in both animal and clinical studies of tissue engineering. Ongoing work centers around the ability of the molecule to enhance angiogenesis and the conversion of chronic wounds into acute wounds.

Esophageal reconstruction with ECM and muscle tissue in a dog model

An in vivo study was conducted to determine if an extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffold co-localized with autologous muscle tissue could achieve constructive remodeling of esophageal tissue without stricture. ECM derived from the porcine urinary bladder was processed, decellularized, configured into a tube shape, and terminally sterilized for use as a bioscaffold for esophageal reconstruction in a dog model. Twenty-two dogs were divided into four groups, three groups of five and one group of seven. Groups 1 and 2 were repaired with either ECM alone or muscle tissue alone, respectively. Groups 3 and 4 were repaired with ECM plus either a partial (30%) covering with muscle tissue or a complete (100%) covering with muscle tissue, respectively. Animals in groups 1 and 2 were sacrificed within approximately 3 weeks because of the formation of intractable esophageal stricture. Four of five dogs in group 3 and six of seven dogs in group 4 were survived for 26 days to 230 days and showed constructive remodeling of esophageal tissue with the formation of well organized esophageal tissue layers, minimal stricture, esophageal motility, and a normal clinical outcome. Mechanical testing of a subset of the remodeled esophageal tissue from animals in groups 3 and 4 showed progressive remodeling from a relatively stiff, non-compliant ECM tube structure toward a tissue with near normal biomechanical properties. We conclude that ECM bioscaffolds plus autologous muscle tissue, but not ECM scaffolds or muscle tissue alone, can facilitate the in situ reconstitution of structurally and functionally acceptable esophageal tissue.

The role of allogenic fibroblasts in an acute wound healing model

Skin is the first tissue-engineered organ to have been successfully developed in the laboratory, and it has been clinically available for use as epidermal sheets for some time. As refinements in this field of tissue engineering continue, several key issues give cause for concern. One issue is the need to form a more complete dermal analogue before grafting. To this end, fibroblasts may be used in vitro to deposit extracellular matrix components within a basic scaffold, laying down those molecules not endogenous to the material and thereby improving the quality of the skin replacement. Many studies have shown the benefits of in vitro seeding with fibroblasts, but there has been some debate regarding the longevity of such cells after allotransplantation into an immunocompetent host. In this study, the authors set out to determine the longevity of transplanted cells in an immunocompetent porcine model. A total of 24 wounds were made on four female animals, 12 of which were covered with acellular hyaluronic acid dermal matrices, and the remainder of which were covered with matrices seeded with allogenic (male) fibroblasts. After a week in vivo, the wounds were grafted with either split-thickness skin grafts or cultured epithelial autograft. Biopsy specimens were obtained from wounds at varying time intervals and assessed using genetic analysis to determine the survival of allotransplanted cells. No cells were detectable by polymerase chain reaction analysis (sensitivity, 1:100,000) after 7 days in vivo. Subsequent histologic examination demonstrated little difference in wound morphology. The authors conclude that allogenic fibroblasts do not survive transplantation in a porcine wound model.

Comparison of different wound dressings on cultured human fibroblasts and collagen lattices

OBJECTIVE

We compared the effects on cultured human fibroblasts of a new non-adhesive wound dressing, Urgotul, with five other wound dressings. Urgotul is a hydrocolloid dressing; the comparator dressings included impregnated gauze and modern wound dressings.

METHOD

Cultures in monolayer were used to study the morphology and growth of fibroblasts. The Bell model of cultured dermis equivalents was used to investigate myofibroblast differentiation. These cultures were labelled a-SM actin and F-actin.

RESULTS

Two of the tested dressings induced cytotoxic effects. They were found to inhibit cell growth (greater than 60%) and to disturb cell shape and cytoskeletal differentiation. Urgotul and the remaining three dressings showed no effect on proliferation. However, some of them modified fibroblast morphology and affected F-actin distribution.

CONCLUSION

Depending on their nature and components, wound dressings may respect or affect fibroblast behaviour in vitro (proliferation, morphology and a-SM actin and F-actin distribution). The significance of these in vitro observed findings require further investigations.