High Titer Inhibitors in Severe Haemophilia A

In vivo neutralization of a C2 domain–specific human anti–Factor VIII inhibitor by an anti-idiotypic antibody

Factor VIII (FVIII) administration elicits specific inhibitory antibodies (Abs) in about 25% of patients with hemophilia A. The majority of such Abs reacts with FVIII C2 domain. mAbBO2C11 is a high-affinity human monoclonal antibody (mAb) directed toward the C2 domain, which is representative of a major class of human FVIII inhibitors. Anti-idiotypic Abs were raised to mAbBO2C11 to establish their neutralizing potential toward inhibitors. One mouse anti-idiotypic mAb, mAb14C12, specifically prevented mAbBO2C11 binding to FVIII C2 domain and fully neutralized mAbBO2C11 functional inhibitory properties. Modeling of the 3-D conformation of mAb14C12 VH and alignment with the 3-D structure of the C2 domain showed putative 31 surface-exposed amino acid residues either identical or homologous to the C2 domain. These included one C2 phospholipid-binding site, Leu2251-Leu2252, but not Met2199-Phe2200. Forty putative contact residues with mAbBO2C11 were identified. mAb14C12 dose-dependently neutralized mAbBO2C11 inhibitory activity in mice with hemophilia A reconstituted with human recombinant FVIII (rFVIII), allowing full expression of FVIII activity. It also neutralized in an immunoprecipitation assay approximately 50% of polyclonal anti-C2 Abs obtained from 3 of 6 unrelated patients. mAb14C12 is the first example of an anti-idiotypic Ab that fully restores FVIII activity in vivo in the presence of an anti-C2 inhibitor. The present results establish the in vitro and in vivo proof of concept for idiotype-mediated neutralization of a major class of FVIII inhibitors.

The epidemiology of inhibitors in haemophilia A: a systematic review

This paper emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between the prevalence, incidence and cumulative incidence of inhibitors in haemophilia A. Incidence and cumulative incidence data will include patients with transient inhibitors or whose inhibitors have been eliminated by treatment. As these will not be included in prevalence data, prevalence studies will tend to give rise to lower figures than incidence studies. As a result, the most accurate estimates of the true risk of inhibitor development comes from prospective studies of newly diagnosed haemophiliacs who are tested regularly for the presence of inhibitors. This paper reports a systematic review of the best available evidence relating to the epidemiology of inhibitors in haemophilia A. Cohort studies, registry data reporting incidence or prevalence of inhibitors in patients with haemophilia A, and prospective studies of factor VIII (FVIII) in the treatment of previously untreated patients which reported the development of inhibitors as an outcome, were included in the review. The overall prevalence of inhibitors in unselected haemophiliac populations was found to be 5-7%. The cumulative risk of inhibitor development varied (0-39%). Incidence and prevalence were substantially higher in patients with severe haemophilia. Studies of patients using a single plasma-derived FVIII (pdFVIII) preparation reported lower inhibitor incidence than those using multiple pdFVIII preparations or single recombinant FVIII preparations. Incidence data should be used to estimate the likely demand for treatments aimed at eliminating inhibitors, whereas the best estimates of the overall burden to the National Health Service (NHS) of treating bleeding episodes in patients with continuing inhibitors will come from prevalence studies.

Low molecular weight peptides restore the procoagulant activity of factor VIII in the presence of the potent inhibitor antibody ESH8

Following repeated administration of factor VIII (FVIII), a significant number of hemophilia A patients develop antibodies (Abs), inhibiting the procoagulant activity of infused FVIII. We have designed an approach based on the blocking of the deleterious activity of these Abs by peptide decoys mimicking the anti-FVIII Ab epitopes. Here, the well characterized inhibitory monoclonal Ab ESH8 served as a model. Several phage peptide libraries were screened for specific binding to ESH8. Seven constrained dodecapeptide sequences were obtained. Six sequences carried the consensus motif, hydrophobic-(Y/F)GKTXL. This motif showed a certain similarity with the (2231)QVDFQKTMKV(2240) sequence of the C(2) domain. In the seventh sequence, YCNPSIGDKNCR, the residues GDKN are similar to the sequence (2267)DGHQ(2270). Upon inspection of the C(2) domain crystallographic structure, the two stretches QVDFQKTMKV and DGHQ appeared close together in space and might constitute a discontinuous epitope. Corresponding synthetic peptides were able to inhibit the binding of ESH8 to FVIII in a specific and dose-dependent manner. Moreover, the ability of the selected peptides to neutralize the inhibitory activity of ESH8 was demonstrated in functional tests as well as in vivo in a murine model of hemophilia A. This study demonstrates the potential of this approach to neutralize the activity of potent inhibitory Abs.

Incidence of factor VIII inhibitors in severe haemophilia: the importance of patient age

The potential effect of age at the start of replacement therapy on the development of factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors was assessed in 62 severe (FVIII < 2 IU/dl) haemophilia A patients who started FVIII therapy at one of two haemophilia centres. Inhibitors were tested on an annual basis. Persistent or high-titre inhibitors were detected in 15 patients (24%). Kaplan-Meier cumulative incidence at 3 years from first FVIII exposure was 41% (95% CI 22-67%) in patients starting therapy before the age of 6 months, 29% (95% CI 13-57%) in patients starting therapy between 6 and 12 months of age, and 12% (95% CI 4-34%) in those starting therapy beyond 1 year of age (P = 0.03). By multivariate analysis, the influence of age was shown to be independent of other variables, including calendar year at the onset of therapy and baseline FVIII plasma levels. In conclusion, patient age at initial treatment appears to influence inhibitor formation. If confirmed, this finding would have a major impact on the management of haemophilia.

The French haemophilia cohort: rationale and organization of a long-term national pharmacosurveillance system

Medicinal products of biological origin still carry a specific iatrogenic risk, mainly because of their starting material, mode of preparation and variability. Careful postmarketing surveillance systems are therefore necessary. To assess the long-term safety of haemophilia treatment with plasma-derived and recombinant clotting factor products, a cohort study was set up in France in 1994. Participants were patients with haemophilia A and B, with or without previous clotting factor therapy. Clinical events, treatments, biological data and adverse events were recorded on standard forms. Blood samples were separated into serum, plasma and peripheral blood mononuclear cells, frozen, and banked in a central laboratory. The same data and samples were collected at yearly follow-up visits. As of December 1999, 1234 haemophiliacs were enrolled in 39 haemophilia centres. At enrollment, 50.2% of patients were under 15 years of age, and the cumulative number of days of exposure to the product was below 50 in 35.1% of cases. The median duration of follow-up was 26.9 months, with a total of 2729 patient-years (135,947 days of exposure and 211 million units of factor VIII or IX). To date, only 17 patients were lost to follow-up. The initial results show good compliance with this health-watch policy among patients and clinicians specializing in haemophilia. The regular follow-up data and centralized sample bank will serve to investigate rapidly any suspected outbreaks as soon as reliable biological tests become available in the future.

Treatment of coagulation inhibitors with extracorporeal immunoadsorption (Ig-Therasorb)

Coagulation inhibitors may occur as alloantibodies in patients with congenital factor deficiencies or as autoantibodies in patients with a previously normal coagulation. We treated 10 patients with factor VIII inhibitors (three haemophiliacs and seven patients with acquired factor VIII inhibitors) and one patient with a factor V inhibitor using extracorporeal immunoadsorption to immobilized antibodies against human immunoglobulins (Ig-Therasorb). The initial inhibitor titre was between 18 BU/ml and 540 BU/ml. Nine patients had signs of bleeding. Eighty-nine immunoadsorption sessions were performed in the 11 patients (8.1 +/- 5.1 per patient), each processing 6980 +/- 880 ml of plasma in 3.8 +/- 0.5 h. The mean reduction of the inhibitor titre was 71.9 +/- 19.4% per session. Serum IgG, IgA and IgM levels decreased by 68.7 +/- 10.1%, 55.7 +/- 12.7% and 48.6 +/- 11.1% respectively. In two haemophiliac patients, an initial titre reduction prior to an immune tolerance protocol was performed. Another haemophiliac patient was treated because of acute cerebral bleeding. In six out of eight patients with acquired inhibitors, a durable elimination was achieved within a median of 18 d. Treatment was safe and well-tolerated and seems to be a promising method in the treatment of patients with coagulation inhibitors, especially when a fast inhibitor titre reduction is necessary.

Major surgery for a gastric cancer in a haemophilic with high inhibitor titre successfully performed by the use of recombinant FVIIa

A total gastrectomy with omentectomy and resection of the distal oesophagus in a 69-year-old haemophilia A patient with high inhibitor of 128 Bethesda units is described. Surgery was successfully performed after infusion of 112 microg kg-1 bw of recombinant FVIIa. Ninety-two microg kg-1 were given thereafter at time intervals of 2 h until 12 h, then every 3 h until 24 h, and every 4 h until 48 h after surgery. Doses were gradually reduced in the following days and finally discontinued on day 28 after surgery. The complete treatment schedule required the administration of a total of 708 mg of recombinant FVIIa. Using this approach, we observed normal haemostasis, and there were no signs of excessive postoperative bleeding or wound haematoma. No clinical side-effects or evidence of systemic activation of coagulation occurred during the treatment. As judged from the clinical course of this major surgery, recombinant FVIIa appears to be highly efficacious and safe and should be used as first line treatment in high titre inhibitor patients with cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII, undergoing surgery.

Histocompatibility antigens and alleles in Japanese haemophilia A patients with or without factor VIII antibodies

We carried out human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A, B, Cw, DR and DQ serological typing and HLA-DQA1, DQB1, DRB1 and DPB1 genetic typing for 46 Japanese haemophilia A patients, including 20 who had developed an antibody to factor VIII. It appears that anti FVIII inhibitor formation is associated with the major histocompatibility complex in Japanese haemophilia A patients. Absence of HLA-A24 is a principal risk factor for inhibitor formation in Japanese haemophilia A patients. As supplemental risk factors, HLA-DR4.1, DQ4 and DQA1*0301=2 are positively associated with patients exhibiting inhibitor compared with normal subjects. This and previous studies show that the association between HLA antigens and the formation of inhibitor depends on race. Data of HLA typing may be useful for the recognition of groups at high risk for the possible formation of inhibitor among Japanese haemophilia A patients.

How do some haemophiliacs develop inhibitors?

The purpose of this presentation is to concentrate on three issues: Is there an explanation for the large difference in reported incidence rates of inhibitor formation in haemophiliacs? Why do not all severe patients develop inhibitors? And how on the contrary do some patients with mild haemophilia develop inhibitors?

Zero incidence of inhibitor development in previously treated haemophilia A, HIV-negative patients upon exposure to a plasma-derived high-purity and double viral inactivated factor VIII concentrate

Thirty-six haemophilia A, HIV-negative, previously treated patients were changed therapy to a highpurity and double-inactivated (solvent/detergent and dry-heating) previously unused factor VIII concentrate. The mean age of these patients was 27 years at the time of the change. Twenty-three patients were severe haemophiliacs (FVIII:C < 0.02 IU mL-1), seven moderate (FVIII:C between 0.02 and 0.05 IU mL-1) and six mild (FVIII:C > 0.05 IU mL-1). The mean follow-up with this single product was 16 months, with 82 accumulated exposure days and the mean consumption was 117,300 IU of FVIII corresponding to a mean of six batches per patient. No patient developed FVIII inhibitors (upper limit of the CI95: 7.98%), resulting in an incidence rate of 0/48 patient-years (upper limit of the CI95: 77/1000 patient-years). The change in therapy to this new factor VIII concentrate was not associated with the appearance of inhibitors.

Cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII of factor VIII inhibitors in patients with haemophilia in Australia and New Zealand

BACKGROUND

Inhibitory antibodies which neutralise factor VIII develop in 10-20% of individuals with inherited haemophilia A and rarely as autoantibodies in normal individuals to cause acquired haemophilia. The antibodies are directed against human factor VIII but cross-react to varying degrees with porcine factor VIII. Porcine factor VIII can be used for treatment in individuals with low cross-reactivity.

AIMS

To determine the cross-reactivity of factor VIII inhibitors between human factor VIII and porcine factor VIII, in a population of patients with inherited and acquired haemophilia A. Also, to determine whether patients with inherited haemophilia and inhibitors have a higher incidence of factor VIII gene inversion in intron 22.

METHODS

Samples and data sheets from 43 patients with inherited and ten with acquired haemophilia were submitted from hospitals in Australia and New Zealand. Inhibitor levels to human and porcine factor VIII were measured by the Bethesda method in 39 with inherited and nine with acquired haemophilia A.

RESULTS

Of 39 patients with inherited haemophilia A, cross-reactivity was 0% in 17 patients, 1-19% in six, 20-39% in 11 and 40-80% in five. In six of nine patients with acquired haemophilia cross-reactivity was < or = 7%. In inherited severe haemophilia A, the frequency of the intron 22 inversion was not greater in 37 study patients than in 28 patients without an inhibitor.

CONCLUSIONS

Many patients in Australia and New Zealand with inhibitors to human factor VIII presently show a low or absent level of cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII. These may respond to treatment with this concentrate at least in the short term. There remains a group of patients with high cross-reactivity who will respond only to recombinant factor VIIa or prothrombin complex concentrates.

Loss of Tolerance to Exogenous and Endogenous Factor VIII in a Mild Hemophilia A Patient With an Arg593 to Cys Mutation

A 42-year-old patient with mild hemophilia A developed spontaneous muscle hematomas 1 month after intense therapy with factor VIII concentrates. Factor VIII clotting activity was less than 1% and his factor VIII inhibitor was 10 Bethesda units (BU)/mL. The titer peaked at 128 BU despite daily infusions of factor VIII; 1 year later, the titer was 13 BU with no spontaneous bleeding for 4 months. The plasma inhibitor was 95% neutralized by factor VIII A2 domain but less than 15% neutralized by light-chain or C2 domain. His inhibitor did not cross-react with porcine factor VIII and was at least 10-fold less reactive to a series of hybrid factor VIII proteins in which human residues 484-508 are replaced by the homologous porcine sequence (Healey et al, J Biol Chem 270:14505, 1995). The inhibitor patient's DNA encoding his A2 domain and flanking sequences showed a C-T transition predicting Arg593 to Cys. Thirteen patients from 5 unrelated families with Cys593 have not developed inhibitors. Factor VIII clotting activity from one of them was inhibited similarly to diluted normal plasma by inhibitor patient plasma. In an homologous structure, ceruloplasmin (Zaitseva et al, J Biol Inorgan Chem 1:15,1996), the residue equivalent to Arg593, is in a loop distinct from residues 484-508. On solution phase immunoprecipitation with labeled factor VIII fragments, A2, light chain, and C2 domains bound. In contrast to typical immune responses to factor VIII in patients with severe hemophilia A, this patient's inhibitor was almost entirely reactive with common epitopes within the A2 domain whereas by more sensitive immunoprecipitation testing antibodies to light chain epitopes were also present. Accordingly, immune responsiveness to exogenous factor VIII (antigen burden) appears to be more critical than his endogenous, hemophilic factor VIII to his developing high-titer anti–factor VIII antibodies and loss of tolerance to both native and hemophilic factor VIII proteins.