Synthetic promoter elements obtained by nucleotide sequence variation and selection for activity

A computational pipeline for identifying kinetic motifs to aid in the design and improvement of synthetic gene circuits

BACKGROUND

An increasing number of genetic components are available in several depositories of such components to facilitate synthetic biology research, but picking out those that will allow a designed circuit to achieve the specified function still requires multiple cycles of testing. Here, we addressed this problem by developing a computational pipeline to mathematically simulate a gene circuit for a comprehensive range and combination of the kinetic parameters of the biological components that constitute the gene circuit.

RESULTS

We showed that, using a well-studied transcriptional repression cascade as an example, the sets of kinetic parameters that could produce the specified system dynamics of the gene circuit formed clusters of recurrent combinations, referred to as kinetic motifs, which appear to be associated with both the specific topology and specified dynamics of the circuit. Furthermore, the use of the resulting "handbook" of performance-ranked kinetic motifs in finding suitable circuit components was illustrated in two application scenarios.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that the computational pipeline developed here can provide a rational-based guide to aid in the design and improvement of synthetic gene circuits.

Development and functional analysis of novel genetic promoters using DNA shuffling, hybridization and a combination thereof

BACKGROUND

Development of novel synthetic promoters with enhanced regulatory activity is of great value for a diverse range of plant biotechnology applications.

METHODOLOGY

Using the Figwort mosaic virus full-length transcript promoter (F) and the sub-genomic transcript promoter (FS) sequences, we generated two single shuffled promoter libraries (LssF and LssFS), two multiple shuffled promoter libraries (LmsFS-F and LmsF-FS), two hybrid promoters (FuasFScp and FSuasFcp) and two hybrid-shuffled promoter libraries (LhsFuasFScp and LhsFSuasFcp). Transient expression activities of approximately 50 shuffled promoter clones from each of these libraries were assayed in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi) protoplasts. It was observed that most of the shuffled promoters showed reduced activity compared to the two parent promoters (F and FS) and the CaMV35S promoter. In silico studies (computer simulated analyses) revealed that the reduced promoter activities of the shuffled promoters could be due to their higher helical stability. On the contrary, the hybrid promoters FuasFScp and FSuasFcp showed enhanced activities compared to F, FS and CaMV 35S in both transient and transgenic Nicotiana tabacum and Arabidopsis plants. Northern-blot and qRT-PCR data revealed a positive correlation between transcription and enzymatic activity in transgenic tobacco plants expressing hybrid promoters. Histochemical/X-gluc staining of whole transgenic seedlings/tissue-sections and fluorescence images of ImaGene Green™ treated roots and stems expressing the GUS reporter gene under the control of the FuasFScp and FSuasFcp promoters also support the above findings. Furthermore, protein extracts made from protoplasts expressing the human defensin (HNP-1) gene driven by hybrid promoters showed enhanced antibacterial activity compared to the CaMV35S promoter.

SIGNIFICANCE/CONCLUSION

Both shuffled and hybrid promoters developed in the present study can be used as molecular tools to study the regulation of ectopic gene expression in plants.

Systematic dissection and optimization of inducible enhancers in human cells using a massively parallel reporter assay

Learning to read and write the transcriptional regulatory code is of central importance to progress in genetic analysis and engineering. Here we describe a massively parallel reporter assay (MPRA) that facilitates the systematic dissection of transcriptional regulatory elements. In MPRA, microarray-synthesized DNA regulatory elements and unique sequence tags are cloned into plasmids to generate a library of reporter constructs. These constructs are transfected into cells and tag expression is assayed by high-throughput sequencing. We apply MPRA to compare >27,000 variants of two inducible enhancers in human cells: a synthetic cAMP-regulated enhancer and the virus-inducible interferon-β enhancer. We first show that the resulting data define accurate maps of functional transcription factor binding sites in both enhancers at single-nucleotide resolution. We then use the data to train quantitative sequence-activity models (QSAMs) of the two enhancers. We show that QSAMs from two cellular states can be combined to design enhancer variants that optimize potentially conflicting objectives, such as maximizing induced activity while minimizing basal activity.

Computational design of synthetic regulatory networks from a genetic library to characterize the designability of dynamical behaviors

The engineering of synthetic gene networks has mostly relied on the assembly of few characterized regulatory elements using rational design principles. It is of outmost importance to analyze the scalability and limits of such a design workflow. To analyze the design capabilities of libraries of regulatory elements, we have developed the first automated design approach that combines such elements to search the genotype space associated to a given phenotypic behavior. Herein, we calculated the designability of dynamical functions obtained from circuits assembled with a given genetic library. By designing circuits working as amplitude filters, pulse counters and oscillators, we could infer new mechanisms for such behaviors. We also highlighted the hierarchical design and the optimization of the interface between devices. We dissected the functional diversity of a constrained library and we found that even such libraries can provide a rich variety of behaviors. We also found that intrinsic noise slightly reduces the designability of digital circuits, but it increases the designability of oscillators. Finally, we analyzed the robust design as a strategy to counteract the evolvability and noise in gene expression of the engineered circuits within a cellular background, obtaining mechanisms for robustness through non-linear negative feedback loops.

Enhancement of reporter gene detection sensitivity by insertion of specific mini-peptide-coding sequences

Two important aspects of gene therapy are to increase the level of gene expression and track the gene delivery site and expression, and a sensitive reporter gene may be one of the options for preclinical studies and possibly for human clinical trials. We report the novel concept of increasing the activity of the gene products. With the insertion of the mini-peptide-coding sequence CWDDWLC into the plasmid DNA of a SEAP reporter gene, we observed vast increases in the enzyme activity in vitro in all murine and human cell lines used. In addition, in vivo injection of this CWDDWLC-SEAP-encoding gene resulted in the same increases in reporter gene activity, but these increases did not correspond to alterations in the level of the gene products in the serum. Minor sequence changes in this mini-peptide negate the activity increase of the reporter gene. We report the novel concept of increasing the activity of gene products as another method to improve the reporting sensitivity of reporter genes. This improved reporter gene could complement any improved vector for maximizing the reporter sensitivity. Moreover, this strategy has the potential to be used to discover peptides that improve the activity of therapeutic genes.

Transcriptional targeting to brain cells: Engineering cell type-specific promoter containing cassettes for enhanced transgene expression

Transcriptional targeting using a mammalian cellular promoter to restrict transgene expression to target cells is often desirable for gene therapy. This strategy is, however, hindered by relatively weak activity of some cellular promoters, which may lead to low levels of gene expression, thus declining therapeutic efficacy. Here we outline the advances accomplished in the area of transcriptional targeting to brain cells, with a particular focus on engineering gene cassettes to augment cell type-specific expression. Among the effective approaches that improve gene expression while retaining promoter specificity are promoter engineering to change authentic sequences of a cellular promoter and the combined use of a native cellular promoter and other cis-acting elements. Success in achieving high level and sustained transgene expression only in the cell types of interest would be of importance in allowing gene therapy to have its impact on patient treatment.

In vitro search for alternative promoters to the human immediate early cytomegalovirus (IE-cMV) to express the G gene of viral haemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) in fish epithelial cells

Present DNA vaccines against fish rhabdoviruses require intramuscular injection (fish-to-fish vaccination) of their G-protein gene under the control of the human immediate early cytomegalovirus (IE-CMV) promoter, while immersion delivery (mass DNA vaccination), for instance, by using fish epithelial-specific promoters, would be more practical for aquaculture. To find fish epithelial-specific promoters alternative to the IE-CMV, a comparative study of the effectiveness of different fish promoters constitutively expressing the G gene of the viral haemorrhagic septicemia virus (VHSV) in the epithelial papulosum cyprini (EPC) cell line was performed. The study included MCV1.4 (an alternative IE-CMV promoter version), AE6 (a version of the carp beta-actin promoter), long terminal repeats (LTR) of zebrafish or walleye retroviruses, trout Mx1, carp myosin-heavy-chain and flatfish pleurocidin promoters and salmonid sleeping beauty (SB)/medaka Tol2 transposon repeats. The G-protein expression in transfected EPC cells was studied by estimating the number of cells expressing the G-protein in their membrane and the average expression level per cell. In addition, in an attempt to reduce their sizes, some regions of the MCV1.4 and AE6 promoters were deleted and expression levels compared to those observed for full-length promoters. Since both zebrafish LTR and carp AE6 promoters were the most effective regulatory sequences for expressing the VHSV G-protein in EPC cells, these sequences might be candidates for new DNA vaccine vectors for fish epithelial tissues avoiding the IE-CMV promoter. Furthermore, known transcription factor binding sites (TFBS) common to most of the fish G-expressing promoters, might enable the future design of fully synthetic or hybrid promoters with improved efficacy of VHSV G-protein expression in epithelial fish cells.

Up-regulation of activating transcription factor-5 suppresses SAP expression to activate T cells in hemophagocytic syndrome associated with Epstein-Barr virus infection and immune disorders

Hemophagocytic syndrome (HPS) is a fatal, pro-inflammatory cytokine disorder that is associated with viral infections and immune disorders. Previously, we demonstrated that Epstein-Barr virus latent membrane protein-1 (LMP-1) could down-regulate the SAP gene, enhancing Th1 cytokine secretion in T cells and leading to HPS. The exact mechanism of SAP gene regulation by LMP-1 remains to be clarified. In this study, using cDNA microarray analysis, we identified ATF5 as the candidate transcriptional repressor for SAP expression in LMP-1-expressing T cells. LMP-1 up-regulated ATF5 via TRAF2,5/NF-kappaB signals to suppress SAP gene expression. Reporter assays and electrophoretic mobility shift assays revealed that ATF5 bound differentially to two sites of the SAP promoter. In resting T cells, ATF5 bound predominantly to the high-affinity site in the -81 to -74 region while additionally binding to the low-affinity site at -305 to -296 in LMP-1-expressing T cells. Such binding subsequently disrupted the transcription of the SAP gene. At the same time, Th1 cytokine secretion was enhanced. This phenomenon was also observed in conditions such as ATF5 overexpression, phytohemagglutinin stimulation of primary T cells, and ligand engagement of T-cell lines. Therefore, the down-regulation of the SAP gene by ATF5 may represent a common mechanism for the pathogenesis of HPS that is associated with either Epstein-Barr virus infection or immune disorders with dysregulated T-cell activation.

Construction and functional characteristics of tuber-specific and cold-inducible chimeric promoters in potato

The improvement of processing quality of potato products (fries and chips) demands less accumulation of reducing sugars (glucose and fructose) in cold-stored potato (Solanum tuberosum) tubers. Control of gene expression to achieve this requires promoters with specificity to tubers as well as inducible activity under low temperatures. Here we use overlapping extension PCR to construct two chimeric promoters, pCL and pLC, to control gene expression in a tuber-specific and cold-inducible pattern. This combined different combinations of the LTRE (low-temperature responsive element) from Arabidopsis thaliana cor15a promoter and the TSSR (tuber-specific and sucrose-responsive sequence) from potato class I patatin promoter. The cold-inducible and tuber-specific activities of the chimeric promoters were investigated by quantitative analysis of GUS activity in transgenic potato cultivar E3 plants. The results showed that the cis-elements, LTRE and TSSR, played responsive roles individually or in combination. pCL with the TSSR closer to the TATA-box showed substantially higher promoter activity than pLC with the LTRE closer to the TATA-box at either normal (20 degrees C) or low temperature (2 degrees C), suggesting that the promoter activity was closely associated with the position of the two elements. The chimeric promoter pCL with tuber-specific and cold-inducible features may provide valuable tool for controlling the expression of gene constructs designed to lower the formation of reducing sugars in tubers stored at low temperature and to improve the processing quality of potato products.

A positive feedback vector for identification of nucleotide sequences that enhance translation

In earlier studies, we identified short (6- to 22-nt) sequences that functioned as internal ribosome entry sites (IRESes) and enhanced translation. The size of these IRES elements suggested that they might be prevalent within the messenger population and that individual elements might affect the translation of different groups of mRNAs. To begin to assess the number of different IRES elements in mammalian cells, we have developed a powerful method that uses a positive feedback mechanism to amplify the activities of individual IRES elements. This method uses a vector that encodes a dicistronic mRNA with a reporter gene (Renilla luciferase or the EGFP) as the first cistron and the yeast Gal4/viral protein 16 (VP16) transcription factor as the second cistron. Transcription of this mRNA is driven by a minimal promoter containing four copies of the Gal4 upstream activation sequence. In this method, the presence of an IRES in the intercistronic region facilitates the translation of Gal4/VP16, which binds to the upstream activation sequences and triggers a positive feedback loop that escalates the production of dicistronic mRNA and Gal4/VP16. A corresponding increase in the translation of the first cistron (luciferase or EGFP) is monitored either by measuring luciferase activity or by using FACS. The latter enables IRES-positive cells to be isolated. We present tests of the feedback mechanism by using an IRES module from Gtx homeodomain mRNA and an IRES from hepatitis C virus and demonstrate the utility of this vector system for the screening, identification, and analysis of IRES elements.

The origin of subfunctions and modular gene regulation

Evolutionary explanations for the origin of modularity in genetic and developmental pathways generally assume that modularity confers a selective advantage. However, our results suggest that even in the absence of any direct selective advantage, genotypic modularity may increase through the formation of new subfunctions under near-neutral processes. Two subfunctions may be formed from a single ancestral subfunction by the process of fission. Subfunction fission occurs when multiple functions under unified genetic control become subdivided into more restricted functions under independent genetic control. Provided that population size is sufficiently small, random genetic drift and mutation can conspire to produce changes in the number of subfunctions in the genome of a species without necessarily altering the phenotype. Extensive genotypic modularity may then accrue in a near-neutral fashion in permissive population-genetic environments, potentially opening novel pathways to morphological evolution. Many aspects of gene complexity in multicellular eukaryotes may have arisen passively as population size reductions accompanied increases in organism size, with the adaptive exploitation of such complexity occurring secondarily.

Identification of synthetic endothelial cell-specific promoters by use of a high-throughput screen

Transcriptional targeting is a desirable property for many gene transfer applications. Because endothelial cells line most blood vessels, they are attractive candidates for the introduction of therapeutic gene products. As a proof-of-concept study, we attempted to identify a synthetic, endothelial cell-specific promoter by use of a high-throughput screen involving self-inactivating (SIN) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-based vectors. Select duplex oligodeoxynucleotides recognized by transcription factors and located 5' of endothelial cell-specific mRNA transcripts were randomly ligated and cloned upstream of a minimal ICAM-2 promoter driving enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) in a SIN HIV-1-based vector. Vesicular stomatitis virus G protein-pseudotyped particles were prepared from a library of >10(6) vector recombinants and used to transduce an endothelial cell line. The highest eGFP expressers were repeatedly sorted, and the synthetic promoters were recovered and retested by a luciferase reporter. Several promoters were active and specific to endothelial cells of varied species, with high selectivity indexes and inducibility under hypoxia-mimetic conditions. One in particular was then introduced back into a SIN HIV-1-based vector to confirm its endothelial cell activity and specificity. This study suggests that SIN vectors may be used in a high-throughput manner to identify tissue-specific promoters of high activity, with potential applications for both transcriptional targeting and gene transfer.

Progress in Methodology Improved Reporter Gene Assays Used to Identify Ligands Acting on Orphan Seven-Transmembrane Receptors

Seven-transmembrane G-protein-coupled receptors play a central role in physiology by facilitating cell communication through recognition of a wide range of ligands. Even more important, they represent important drug targets. Unfortunately, for many of these receptors the endogenous ligands, and hence their functions, remain to be identified. These receptors are referred to as "orphan" receptors. A pre-requisite for the identification of ligands activating orphan receptors is powerful assay systems. Until now, reporter gene assays have not been in common use in this process. Here, we summarize our development of improved reporter gene assays. We optimized reporter gene assays in respect of (i) the promoter region of the construct, (ii) the reporter enzyme used, (iii) and the assay procedure. Furthermore, an unique fluorescence-based clone selection step was introduced, allowing rapid selection of the most sensitive reporter cell clones when establishing stable reporter cell lines. Mathematical formulae are provided to enable a simple and reliable comparison between different cell lines, when tested with a compound of interest. The resulting reporter cell lines responded in a very sensitive way to the stimulation of various test receptors. The reporter system was termed HighTRACE (high-throughput reporter assay with clone election). Its high assay quality makes it suitable as a primary screening tool. Ligands for two recently unknown 7TM receptors were identified using the HighTRACE system i.e., two cell surface free fatty acid receptors, GPR40 (FFA1R) and GPR43 (FFA2R). The identification was accomplished using a reverse pharmacology approach.

Identification of promoter regions in the human genome by using a retroviral plasmid library-based functional reporter gene assay

Attempts to identify regulatory sequences in the human genome have involved experimental and computational methods such as cross-species sequence comparisons and the detection of transcription factor binding-site motifs in coexpressed genes. Although these strategies provide information on which genomic regions are likely to be involved in gene regulation, they do not give information on their functions. We have developed a functional selection for promoter regions in the human genome that uses a retroviral plasmid library-based system. This approach enriches for and detects promoter function of isolated DNA fragments in an in vitro cell culture assay. By using this method, we have discovered likely promoters of known and predicted genes, as well as many other putative promoter regions based on the presence of features such as CpG islands. Comparison of sequences of 858 plasmid clones selected by this assay with the human genome draft sequence indicates that a significantly higher percentage of sequences align to the 500-bp segment upstream of the transcription start sites of known genes than would be expected from random genomic sequences. We also observed enrichment for putative promoter regions of genes predicted in at least two annotation databases and for clones overlapping with CpG islands. Functional validation of randomly selected clones enriched by this method showed that a large fraction of these putative promoters can drive the expression of a reporter gene in transient transfection experiments. This method promises to be a useful genome-wide function-based approach that can complement existing methods to look for promoters.

Generation of a synthetic mammalian promoter library by modification of sequences spacing transcription factor binding sites

The development of a set of synthetic mammalian promoters with different specific activities is described. The library is based on a synthetic promoter, JeT, constructed as a 200 bp chimeric promoter built from fragments of the viral SV40 early promoter and the human beta-actin and ubiquitin C promoters. The JeT promoter was made by separating the included consensus boxes by the same distances in base pairs as found in the wild-type promoters, thus preserving transcription factor interaction. The resulting promoter was shown to drive reporter expression to high levels in enhanced green fluorescent protein and secreted alkaline phosphatase reporter assays. By replacing sequences separating the transcription factor binding sites with randomized sequences of the same length, sets of new promoters with different strengths, spanning a 10-fold range of transcriptional activity in cell culture, was obtained. The measured activity of each promoter in the library was highly specific and reproducible when tested in HiB5 and ARPE-19 cell culture.

The use of retroviruses as pharmaceutical tools for target discovery and validation in the field of functional genomics

Retrovirally mediated functional genomics enables identification of physiologically relevant cellular therapeutic targets. Unique properties of retroviruses make them ideal tools for the introduction of large and diverse libraries of potential genetic effectors to a variety of cell types. The identification and recovery of intracellular library elements responsible for altered disease responses establishes a direct basis for pharmaceutical development. Recent innovations in retroviral infection efficiency and expression control have broadened application of the methodology to include libraries of mutagenized cDNAs, peptides and ribozyme genetic effectors.

Identification of two short internal ribosome entry sites selected from libraries of random oligonucleotides

Sequences that control translation of mRNA may play critical roles in regulating protein levels. One such element is the internal ribosome entry site (IRES). We previously showed that a 9-nt segment in the 5' leader sequence of the mRNA encoding Gtx homeodomain protein could function as an IRES. To identify other short sequences with similar properties, we designed a selection procedure that uses a retroviral vector to express dicistronic mRNAs encoding enhanced green and cyan fluorescent proteins as the first and second cistrons, respectively. Expression of the second cistron was dependent upon the intercistronic sequences and was indicative of IRES activity. B104 cells were infected with two retroviral libraries that contained random sequences of 9 or 18 nt in the intercistronic region. Cells expressing both cistrons were sorted, and sequences recovered from selected cells were reassayed for IRES activity in a dual luciferase dicistronic mRNA. Two novel IRESes were identified by this procedure, and both contained segments with complementarity to 18S rRNA. When multiple copies of either segment were linked together, IRES activities were dramatically enhanced. Moreover, these synthetic IRESes were differentially active in various cell types. These properties are similar to those of the previously identified 9-nt IRES module from Gtx mRNA. These results provide further evidence that short nucleotide sequences can function as IRESes and support the idea that some cellular IRESes may be composed of shorter functional modules. The ability to identify IRES modules with specific expression properties may be useful in the design of vectors for biotechnology and gene therapy.