Analysis of substrate specificity of the RuvC holliday junction resolvase with synthetic Holliday junctions

Novel insights into ATP-Stimulated Cleavage of branched DNA and RNA Substrates through Structure-Guided Studies of the Holliday Junction Resolvase RuvX

Much of our understanding of the homologous recombination (HR) machinery hinges on studies using Escherichia coli as a model organism. Interestingly enough, studies on the HR machinery in different bacterial species casts doubt on the universality of the E. coli paradigm. The human pathogen Mycobacterium tuberculosis encodes two Holliday junction (HJ)-resolvase paralogues, namely RuvC and RuvX; however, insights into their structural features and functional relevance is still limited. Here, we report on structure-guided functional studies of the M. tuberculosis RuvX HJ resolvase (MtRuvX). The crystalline MtRuvX is a dimer in the asymmetric unit, and each monomer has a RNAse H fold vis-à-vis RuvC-like nucleases. Interestingly, MtRuvX also contains some unique features, including the residues essential for ATP binding/coordination of Mg²⁺ ions. Indeed, MtRuvX exhibited an intrinsic, robust ATPase activity, which was further accentuated by DNA cofactors. Structure-guided substitutions of single residues at the ATP binding/Mg²⁺coordination sites while markedly attenuating the ATPase activity completely abrogated HJ cleavage, indicating an unanticipated relationship between ATP hydrolysis and DNA cleavage. However, the affinity of ATPase-deficient mutants for the HJ was not impaired. Contrary to RuvC, MtRuvX exhibits relaxed substrate specificity, cleaving a variety of branched DNA/RNA substrates. Notably, ATP hydrolysis plays a regulatory role, rendering MtRuvX from a canonical HJ resolvase to a DNA/RNA non-sequence specific endonuclease, indicating a link between HJ resolvase and nucleic acid metabolism. These findings provide novel insights into the structure and dual-functional activities of MtRuvX, and suggest that it may play an important role in DNA/RNA metabolism.

Single bacterial resolvases first exploit, then constrain intrinsic dynamics of the Holliday junction to direct recombination

Homologous recombination forms and resolves an entangled DNA Holliday Junction (HJ) crucial for achieving genetic reshuffling and genome repair. To maintain genomic integrity, specialized resolvase enzymes cleave the entangled DNA into two discrete DNA molecules. However, it is unclear how two similar stacking isomers are distinguished, and how a cognate sequence is found and recognized to achieve accurate recombination. We here use single-molecule fluorescence observation and cluster analysis to examine how prototypic bacterial resolvase RuvC singles out two of the four HJ strands and achieves sequence-specific cleavage. We find that RuvC first exploits, then constrains the dynamics of intrinsic HJ isomer exchange at a sampled branch position to direct cleavage toward the catalytically competent HJ conformation and sequence, thus controlling recombination output at minimal energetic cost. Our model of rapid DNA scanning followed by ‘snap-locking’ of a cognate sequence is strikingly consistent with the conformational proofreading of other DNA-modifying enzymes.

Structural insights into the promiscuous DNA binding and broad substrate selectivity of fowlpox virus resolvase

Fowlpox virus resolvase (Fpr) is an endonuclease that cleaves a broad range of branched DNA structures, including the Holliday junction (HJ), with little sequence-specificity. To better understand the mechanisms underlying its relaxed substrate specificity, we determined the crystal structures of Fpr and that in a novel complex with HJ at 3.1-Å resolution. In the Fpr-HJ complex, two Fpr dimers use several distinct regions to interact with different DNA structural motifs, showing versatility in DNA-binding. Biochemical and solution NMR data support the existence of non-canonical modes of HJ interaction in solution. The binding of Fpr to various DNA motifs are mediated by its flat DNA-binding surface, which is centered on a short loop spanning K61 to I72 and flanked by longer α-helices at the outer edges, and basic side grooves near the dimer interface. Replacing the Fpr loop K61~I72 with a longer loop from Thermus thermophilus RuvC (E71~A87) endows Fpr with an enhanced selectivity toward HJ cleavage but with a target sequence preference distinct from that of RuvC, highlighting a unique role of this loop region in Fpr-HJ interaction. Our work helps explain the broad substrate selectivity of Fpr and suggests a possible mode of its association with poxvirus hairpin telomeres.

Recognition and processing of branched DNA substrates by Slx1-Slx4 nuclease

Structure-selective endonucleases cleave branched DNA substrates. Slx1 is unique among structure-selective nucleases because it can cleave all branched DNA structures at multiple sites near the branch point. The mechanism behind this broad range of activity is unknown. The present study structurally and biochemically investigated fungal Slx1 to define a new protein interface that binds the non-cleaved arm of branched DNAs. The DNA arm bound at this new site was positioned at a sharp angle relative to the arm that was modeled to interact with the active site, implying that Slx1 uses DNA bending to localize the branch point as a flexible discontinuity in DNA. DNA binding at the new interface promoted a disorder-order transition in a region of the protein that was located in the vicinity of the active site, potentially participating in its formation. This appears to be a safety mechanism that ensures that DNA cleavage occurs only when the new interface is occupied by the non-cleaved DNA arm. Models of Slx1 that interacted with various branched DNA substrates were prepared. These models explain the way in which Slx1 cuts DNA toward the 3' end away from the branch point and elucidate the unique ability of Slx1 to cleave various DNA structures.

Single-Molecule Imaging Reveals Conformational Manipulation of Holliday Junction DNA by the Junction Processing Protein RuvA

Interactions between DNA and motor proteins regulate nearly all biological functions of DNA such as gene expression, DNA replication and repair, and transcription. During the late stages of homologous recombination (HR), the Escherichia coli recombination machinery, RuvABC, resolves the four-way DNA motifs called Holliday junctions (HJs) that are formed during exchange of nucleotide sequences between two homologous duplex DNA. Although the formation of the RuvA-HJ complex is known to be the first critical step in the RuvABC pathway, the mechanism for the binding interaction between RuvA and HJ has remained elusive. Here, using single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) and ensemble analyses, we show that RuvA stably binds to the HJ, halting its conformational dynamics. Our FRET experiments in different ionic environments created by Mg²⁺ and Na⁺ ions suggest that RuvA binds to the HJ via electrostatic interaction. Further, while recent studies have indicated that the HR process can be modulated for therapeutic applications by selective targeting of the HJ by chemotherapeutic drugs, we investigated the effect of drug-modified HJ on binding. Using cisplatin as a proof-of-concept drug, we show that RuvA binds to the cisplatin-modified HJ as efficiently as to the unmodified HJ, demonstrating that RuvA accommodates for the cisplatin-introduced charges and/or topological changes on the HJ.

Holliday junction resolvases mediate chloroplast nucleoid segregation

Holliday junctions, four-stranded DNA structures formed during homologous recombination, are disentangled by resolvases that have been found in prokaryotes and eukaryotes but not in plant organelles. Here, we identify monokaryotic chloroplast 1 (MOC1) as a Holliday junction resolvase in chloroplasts by analyzing a green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mutant defective in chloroplast nucleoid (DNA-protein complex) segregation. MOC1 is structurally similar to a bacterial Holliday junction resolvase, resistance to ultraviolet (Ruv) C, and genetically conserved among green plants. Reduced or no expression of MOC1 in Arabidopsis thaliana leads to growth defects and aberrant chloroplast nucleoid segregation. In vitro biochemical analysis and high-speed atomic force microscopic analysis revealed that A. thaliana MOC 1 (AtMOC1) binds and cleaves the core of Holliday junctions symmetrically. MOC1 may mediate chloroplast nucleoid segregation in green plants by resolving Holliday junctions.

Srs2 and Mus81-Mms4 Prevent Accumulation of Toxic Inter-Homolog Recombination Intermediates

Homologous recombination is an evolutionally conserved mechanism that promotes genome stability through the faithful repair of double-strand breaks and single-strand gaps in DNA, and the recovery of stalled or collapsed replication forks. Saccharomyces cerevisiae ATP-dependent DNA helicase Srs2 (a member of the highly conserved UvrD family of helicases) has multiple roles in regulating homologous recombination. A mutation (srs2^K41A) resulting in a helicase-dead mutant of Srs2 was found to be lethal in diploid, but not in haploid, cells. In diploid cells, Srs2^K41A caused the accumulation of inter-homolog joint molecule intermediates, increased the levels of spontaneous Rad52 foci, and induced gross chromosomal rearrangements. Srs2^K41A lethality and accumulation of joint molecules were suppressed by inactivating Rad51 or deleting the Rad51-interaction domain of Srs2, whereas phosphorylation and sumoylation of Srs2 and its interaction with sumoylated proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) were not required for lethality. The structure-specific complex of crossover junction endonucleases Mus81 and Mms4 was also required for viability of diploid, but not haploid, SRS2 deletion mutants (srs2Δ), and diploid srs2Δ mus81Δ mutants accumulated joint molecule intermediates. Our data suggest that Srs2 and Mus81–Mms4 have critical roles in preventing the formation of (or in resolving) toxic inter-homolog joint molecules, which could otherwise interfere with chromosome segregation and lead to genetic instability.

Homologous recombination (HR) is a DNA-repair mechanism that is generally considered error free because it uses an intact sister chromatid as a template. However, in diploid cells, HR can also occur between homologous chromosomes, which can lead to genomic instability through loss of heterozygosity. This alteration is often detected in genetic disorders and cancer, suggesting that tight control of this process is required to ensure genome stability. Yeast Srs2, conserved from bacteria to humans, plays multiple roles in the regulation of HR. We show here that a helicase-dead mutant of Srs2, srs2^K41A, is lethal in diploid cells but not in haploid cells. Expression of Srs2^K41A in diploid cells causes inter-homolog joint molecule intermediates to accumulate, and leads to gross chromosomal rearrangements. Moreover, srs2Δ mus81Δ double mutants have a severe diploid-specific growth defect with accumulation of inter-homolog joint molecules. These data demonstrate that Srs2 and Mus81-Mms4 participate in essential pathways preventing accumulation of inter-homolog recombination intermediates, thereby reducing the risk of genome instability.

Structure and Metal Binding Properties of a Poxvirus Resolvase

Poxviruses replicate their linear genomes by forming concatemers that must be resolved into monomeric units to produce new virions. A viral resolvase cleaves DNA four-way junctions extruded at the concatemer junctions to produce monomeric genomes. This cleavage reaction is required for viral replication, so the resolvase is an attractive target for small molecule inhibitors. To provide a platform for understanding resolvase mechanism and designing inhibitors, we have determined the crystal structure of the canarypox virus (CPV) resolvase. CPV resolvase is dimer of RNase H superfamily domains related to Escherichia coli RuvC, with an active site lined by highly conserved acidic residues that bind metal ions. There are several intriguing structural differences between resolvase and RuvC, and a model of the CPV resolvase·Holliday junction complex provides insights into the consequences of these differences, including a plausible explanation for the weak sequence specificity exhibited by the poxvirus enzymes. The model also explains why the poxvirus resolvases are more promiscuous than RuvC, cleaving a variety of branched, bulged, and flap-containing substrates. Based on the unique active site structure observed for CPV resolvase, we have carried out a series of experiments to test divalent ion usage and preferences. We find that the two resolvase metal binding sites have different preferences for Mg(2+) versus Mn(2+) Optimal resolvase activity is maintained with 5 μm Mn(2+) and 100 μm Mg(2+), concentrations that are well below those required for either metal alone. Together, our findings provide biochemical insights and structural models that will facilitate studying poxvirus replication and the search for efficient poxvirus inhibitors.

Holliday junction resolvases

Four-way DNA intermediates, called Holliday junctions (HJs), can form during meiotic and mitotic recombination, and their removal is crucial for chromosome segregation. A group of ubiquitous and highly specialized structure-selective endonucleases catalyze the cleavage of HJs into two disconnected DNA duplexes in a reaction called HJ resolution. These enzymes, called HJ resolvases, have been identified in bacteria and their bacteriophages, archaea, and eukaryotes. In this review, we discuss fundamental aspects of the HJ structure and their interaction with junction-resolving enzymes. This is followed by a brief discussion of the eubacterial RuvABC enzymes, which provide the paradigm for HJ resolvases in other organisms. Finally, we review the biochemical and structural properties of some well-characterized resolvases from archaea, bacteriophage, and eukaryotes.

AtGEN1 and AtSEND1, two paralogs in Arabidopsis, possess holliday junction resolvase activity

Holliday junctions (HJs) are physical links between homologous DNA molecules that arise as central intermediary structures during homologous recombination and repair in meiotic and somatic cells. It is necessary for these structures to be resolved to ensure correct chromosome segregation and other functions. In eukaryotes, including plants, homologs of a gene called XPG-like endonuclease1 (GEN1) have been identified that process HJs in a manner analogous to the HJ resolvases of phages, archaea, and bacteria. Here, we report that Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), a eukaryotic organism, has two functional GEN1 homologs instead of one. Like all known eukaryotic resolvases, AtGEN1 and Arabidopsis single-strand DNA endonuclease1 both belong to class IV of the Rad2/XPG family of nucleases. Their resolvase activity shares the characteristics of the Escherichia coli radiation and UV sensitive C paradigm for resolvases, which involves resolving HJs by symmetrically oriented incisions in two opposing strands. This leads to ligatable products without the need for further processing. The observation that the sequence context influences the cleavage by the enzymes can be interpreted as a hint for the existence of sequence specificity. The two Arabidopsis paralogs differ in their preferred sequences. The precise cleavage positions observed for the resolution of mobile nicked HJs suggest that these cleavage positions are determined by both the substrate structure and the sequence context at the junction point.

Crystal structure of RuvC resolvase in complex with Holliday junction substrate

The key intermediate in genetic recombination is the Holliday junction (HJ), a four-way DNA structure. At the end of recombination, HJs are cleaved by specific nucleases called resolvases. In Gram-negative bacteria, this cleavage is performed by RuvC, a dimeric endonuclease that belongs to the retroviral integrase superfamily. Here, we report the first crystal structure of RuvC in complex with a synthetic HJ solved at 3.75 Å resolution. The junction in the complex is in an unfolded 2-fold symmetrical conformation, in which the four arms point toward the vertices of a tetrahedron. The two scissile phosphates are located one nucleotide from the strand exchange point, and RuvC approaches them from the minor groove side. The key protein-DNA contacts observed in the structure were verified using a thiol-based site-specific cross-linking approach. Compared with known complex structures of the phage resolvases endonuclease I and endonuclease VII, the RuvC structure exhibits striking differences in the mode of substrate binding and location of the cleavage site.

Structural asymmetry in the Thermus thermophilus RuvC dimer suggests a basis for sequential strand cleavages during Holliday junction resolution

Holliday junction (HJ) resolvases are structure-specific endonucleases that cleave four-way DNA junctions (HJs) generated during DNA recombination and repair. Bacterial RuvC, a prototypical HJ resolvase, functions as homodimer and nicks DNA strands precisely across the junction point. To gain insights into the mechanisms underlying symmetrical strand cleavages by RuvC, we performed crystallographic and biochemical analyses of RuvC from Thermus thermophilus (T.th. RuvC). The crystal structure of T.th. RuvC shows an overall protein fold similar to that of Escherichia coli RuvC, but T.th. RuvC has a more tightly associated dimer interface possibly reflecting its thermostability. The binding mode of a HJ-DNA substrate can be inferred from the shape/charge complementarity between the T.th. RuvC dimer and HJ-DNA, as well as positions of sulfate ions bound on the protein surface. Unexpectedly, the structure of T.th. RuvC homodimer refined at 1.28 Å resolution shows distinct asymmetry near the dimer interface, in the region harboring catalytically important aromatic residues. The observation suggests that the T.th. RuvC homodimer interconverts between two asymmetric conformations, with alternating subunits switched on for DNA strand cleavage. This model provides a structural basis for the 'nick-counter-nick' mechanism in HJ resolution, a mode of HJ processing shared by prokaryotic and eukaryotic HJ resolvases.

ATP-dependent RecG helicase is required for the transcriptional regulator OxyR function in Pseudomonas species

The oxyR gene appears to reside in an operon with the recG helicase gene in many bacteria, including pathogenic Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Pseudomonas putida. Analysis of P. putida transcriptomes shows that many OxyR-controlled genes are regulated by the ATP-dependent RecG helicase and that RecG alone modulates the expression of many genes. We found that purified RecG binds to the promoters of many OxyR-controlled genes and that expression of these genes was not induced under conditions of oxidative stress in recG mutants of P. aeruginosa, P. putida, and Escherichia coli. In vitro data revealed that promoters containing palindromic sequences are essential for RecG binding and that single-strand binding proteins and ATP are also needed for RecG to promote transcription, whereas a magnesium ion has the opposite effect. The OxyR tetramer preferentially binds to promoters after RecG has generated linear DNA in the presence of ATP; otherwise, the OxyR dimer has higher affinity. This study provides new insights into the mechanism of bacterial transcription by demonstrating that RecG might be required for the induction of the OxyR regulon by unwinding palindromic DNA for transcription. This work describes a novel bacterial transcriptional function by RecG helicase with OxyR and may provide new targets for controlling Pseudomonas species pathogen.

Retroviral integrase superfamily: the structural perspective

The retroviral integrase superfamily (RISF) comprises numerous important nucleic acid-processing enzymes, including transposases, integrases and various nucleases. These enzymes are involved in a wide range of processes such as transposition, replication and repair of DNA, homologous recombination, and RNA-mediated gene silencing. Two out of the four enzymes that are encoded by the human immunodeficiency virus--RNase H1 and integrase--are members of this superfamily. RISF enzymes act on various substrates, and yet show remarkable mechanistic and structural similarities. All share a common fold of the catalytic core and the active site, which is composed primarily of carboxylate residues. Here, I present RISF proteins from a structural perspective, describing the individual members and the common and divergent elements of their structures, as well as the mechanistic insights gained from the structures of RNase H1 enzyme complexes with RNA/DNA hybrids.

RecA-mediated excision repair: a novel mechanism for repairing DNA lesions at sites of arrested DNA synthesis

In Escherichia coli, bulky DNA lesions are repaired primarily by nucleotide excision repair (NER). Unrepaired lesions encountered by DNA polymerase at the replication fork create a blockage which may be relieved through RecF-dependent recombination. We have designed an assay to monitor the different mechanisms through which a DNA polymerase blocked by a single AAF lesion may be rescued by homologous double-stranded DNA sequences. Monomodified single-stranded plasmids exhibit low survival in non-SOS induced E. coli cells; we show here that the presence of a homologous sequence enhances the survival of the damaged plasmid more than 10-fold in a RecA-dependent way. Remarkably, in an NER proficient strain, 80% of the surviving colonies result from the UvrA-dependent repair of the AAF lesion in a mechanism absolutely requiring RecA and RecF activity, while the remaining 20% of the surviving colonies result from homologous recombination mechanisms. These results uncover a novel mechanism - RecA-mediated excision repair - in which RecA-dependent pairing of the mono-modified single-stranded template with a complementary sequence allows its repair by the UvrABC excinuclease.

The RuvABC resolvasome

The RuvABC resolvasome of Escherichia coli catalyses the resolution of Holliday junctions that arise during genetic recombination and DNA repair. This process involves two key steps: branch migration, catalysed by the RuvB protein that is targeted to the Holliday junction by the structure specific RuvA protein, and resolution, which is catalysed by the RuvC endonuclease. We have quantified the interaction of the RuvA protein with synthetic Holliday junctions and have shown that the binding of the protein is highly structure-specific, and leads to the formation of a complex containing two tetramers of RuvA per Holliday junction. Our data are consistent with two tetramers of RuvA binding to the DNA recombination intermediate in a co-operative manner. Once formed this complex prevents the binding of RuvC to the Holliday junction. However, the formation of a RuvAC complex can be observed following sequential addition of the RuvC and RuvA proteins. Moreover, by examining the DNA recognition properties of a mutant RuvA protein (E55R, D56K) we show that the charge on the central pin is critical for directing the structure-specific binding by RuvA.

p53 blocks RuvAB promoted branch migration and modulates resolution of Holliday junctions by RuvC

The Holliday junction is the central intermediate in homologous recombination. Branch migration of this four-stranded DNA structure is a key step in genetic recombination that affects the extent of genetic information exchanged between two parental DNA molecules. Here, we have constructed synthetic Holliday junctions to test the effects of p53 on both spontaneous and RuvAB promoted branch migration as well as the effect on resolution of the junction by RuvC. We demonstrate that p53 blocks branch migration, and that cleavage of the Holliday junction by RuvC is modulated by p53. These findings suggest that p53 can block branch migration promoted by proteins such as RuvAB and modulate the cleavage by Holliday junction resolution proteins such as RuvC. These results suggest that p53 could have similar effects on eukaryotic homologues of RuvABC and thus have a direct role in recombinational DNA repair.

Evidence that phenylalanine 69 in Escherichia coli RuvC resolvase forms a stacking interaction during binding and destabilization of a Holliday junction DNA substrate

Escherichia coli RuvC resolvase is a specific endonuclease that recognizes and cleaves Holliday junctions formed during homologous recombination and recombinational repair. This study examines the phenotype of RuvC mutants with amino acid substitutions at phenylalanine 69 (F69L, F69Y, F69W, and F69A), a catalytically important residue that faces the catalytic center of the enzyme. F69Y, but not the other three mutants, almost fully complements the UV sensitivity of a DeltaruvC strain and substantially resolves synthetic Holliday junctions in vitro. In the presence of 100 mm NaCl, RuvC F69A and F69L are defective in junction binding, but F69Y and F69W retain near wild-type binding activity during a gel shift binding assay. KMnO(4) was used to probe synthetic Holliday junction DNA in a complex with wild-type and mutant RuvC; F69A and F69L did not induce disruption of base pairing at the crossover to the same extent as wild-type RuvC. Thus, the aromatic ring of Phe-69 is involved in DNA binding, probably via a stacking interaction with a nucleotide base, and this interaction may induce a structural change in junction DNA that is required to form a catalytically competent complex.

The X philes: structure-specific endonucleases that resolve Holliday junctions

Genetic recombination is a critical cellular process that promotes evolutionary diversity, facilitates DNA repair and underpins genome duplication. It entails the reciprocal exchange of single strands between homologous DNA duplexes to form a four-way branched intermediate commonly referred to as the Holliday junction. DNA molecules interlinked in this way have to be separated in order to allow normal chromosome transmission at cell division. This resolution reaction is mediated by structure-specific endonucleases that catalyse dual-strand incision across the point of strand cross-over. Holliday junctions can also arise at stalled replication forks by reversing the direction of fork progression and annealing of nascent strands. Resolution of junctions in this instance generates a DNA break and thus serves to initiate rather than terminate recombination. Junction resolvases are generally small, homodimeric endonucleases with a high specificity for branched DNA. They use a metal-binding pocket to co-ordinate an activated water molecule for phosphodiester bond hydrolysis. In addition, most junction endonucleases modulate the structure of the junction upon binding, and some display a preference for cleavage at specific nucleotide target sequences. Holliday junction resolvases with distinct properties have been characterized from bacteriophages (T4 endo VII, T7 endo I, RusA and Rap), Bacteria (RuvC), Archaea (Hjc and Hje), yeast (CCE1) and poxviruses (A22R). Recent studies have brought about a reappraisal of the origins of junction-specific endonucleases with the discovery that RuvC, CCE1 and A22R share a common catalytic core.

Cleavage of symmetric immobile DNA junctions by Escherichia coli RuvC

The Holliday junction is a key DNA intermediate in the process of genetic recombination. It consists of two double-helical domains composed of homologous strands that flank a branch point; two of the strands are roughly helical, and two form the crossover between the helices. RuvC is a Holliday junction resolvase that cleaves the helical strands at a symmetric sequence, leading to the production of two recombinant molecules. We have determined the position of the cleavage site relative to the crossover point by the use of symmetric immobile junctions; these are DNA molecules containing two crossover points, one held immobile by sequence asymmetry and the second a symmetric sequence, but held immobile by torsional coupling to the first junction. We have built five symmetric immobile junctions, in which the tetranucleotide recognition site is moved stepwise relative to the branch point. We have used kinetic analysis of catalysis, gel retardation, and hydroxyl radical hypersensitivity to analyze this system. We conclude that the internucleotide linkage one position 3' to the crossover point is the favored site of cleavage.

Control of crossing over

The Holliday junction is a central intermediate in homologous recombination. It consists of a four-way structure that can be resolved by cleavage to give either the crossover or noncrossover products observed. We show here that the formation of these products is controlled by the E. coli resolvasome (RuvABC) in such way that double-strand break repair (DSBR) leads to crossing over and single-strand gap repair (SSGR) does not lead to crossing over. We argue that the positioning of the RuvABC complex and its consequent direction of junction-cleavage is not random. In fact, the action of the RuvABC complex avoids crossing over in the most commonly predicted situations where Holliday junctions are encountered in DNA replication and repair. Our observations suggest that the positioning of the resolvasome may provide a general biochemical mechanism by which cells can control crossing over in recombination.

Two basic residues, Lys-107 and Lys-118, of RuvC resolvase are involved in critical contacts with the Holliday junction for its resolution

BACKGROUND

Crystallographic and mutational studies of Escherichia coli RuvC Holliday junction resolvase have revealed that a catalytic site of each subunit is composed of four acidic residues at the bottom of the putative DNA-binding cleft, whose surface contains eight basic residues.

RESULTS

To elucidate the functional roles of the basic residues on the cleft surface, we constructed a series of mutant ruvC genes and characterized their properties in vivo and in vitro. Among them, two RuvC mutants with a single alteration, K107A and K118A, were defective in UV-repair and showed a dominant negative effect. The purified K107A and K118A proteins showed reduced binding activity to the junction DNA in the presence of Mg2+ under high salt conditions. Mn2+ increased both the junction binding and cleaving activities of the mutant proteins. In the absence of a divalent cation, the wild-type, K107A and K118A proteins did not bind to junction DNA under high salt conditions, but the D7N mutant, with an alteration of the catalytic centre, was able to bind to the junction efficiently.

CONCLUSION

The results presented here, in conjunction with previous crystallographic studies, suggest that the catalytic complex which is formed through interactions of acidic residues, Mg2+ and a cleavable phosphodiester bond, is stabilized by Lys-107 and Lys-118 via electrostatic interactions with the DNA backbone, a process which is critically important for the cleavage reaction to take place. One or two basic residues near the catalytic centre have also been found in other RNase H superfamily proteins, indicating that this is the conserved reaction mechanism in this superfamily.

Cleavage of holliday junctions by the Escherichia coli RuvABC complex

The Escherichia coli RuvABC proteins process recombination intermediates during genetic recombination and recombinational repair. Although early biochemical studies indicated distinct RuvAB-mediated branch migration and RuvC-mediated Holliday junction resolution reactions, more recent studies have shown that the three proteins act together as a "resolvasome" complex. In this work we have used recombination intermediates made by RecA to determine whether the RuvAB proteins affect the sequence specificity of the RuvC resolvase. We find that RuvAB proteins do not alter significantly the site specificity of RuvC-dependent cleavage, although under certain conditions, they do affect the efficiency of cleavage at particular sites. The presence of RecA also influences cleavage at some sites. We also show that the RuvAB proteins act upon transient strand exchange intermediates made using substrates that have the opposite polarity of those preferred by RecA. Together, our results allow us to develop further a model for the recombinational repair of DNA lesions that lead to the formation of post-replication gaps during DNA replication. The novel features of this model are as follows: (i) the RuvABC resolvasome recognizes joints made by RecA; (ii) resolution by RuvABC occurs at specific sites containing the RuvC consensus cleavage sequence 5'-(A/T)TT downward arrow(G/C)-3'; and (iii) Holliday junction resolution often occurs close to the initiating gap without significant heteroduplex DNA formation.

Recombinational repair of DNA damage in Escherichia coli and bacteriophage lambda

Although homologous recombination and DNA repair phenomena in bacteria were initially extensively studied without regard to any relationship between the two, it is now appreciated that DNA repair and homologous recombination are related through DNA replication. In Escherichia coli, two-strand DNA damage, generated mostly during replication on a template DNA containing one-strand damage, is repaired by recombination with a homologous intact duplex, usually the sister chromosome. The two major types of two-strand DNA lesions are channeled into two distinct pathways of recombinational repair: daughter-strand gaps are closed by the RecF pathway, while disintegrated replication forks are reestablished by the RecBCD pathway. The phage lambda recombination system is simpler in that its major reaction is to link two double-stranded DNA ends by using overlapping homologous sequences. The remarkable progress in understanding the mechanisms of recombinational repair in E. coli over the last decade is due to the in vitro characterization of the activities of individual recombination proteins. Putting our knowledge about recombinational repair in the broader context of DNA replication will guide future experimentation.

Sequence and functional-group specificity for cleavage of DNA junctions by RuvC of Escherichia coli

RuvC is the DNA junction-resolving enzyme of Escherichia coli. While the enzyme binds to DNA junctions independently of base sequence, it exhibits considerable sequence selectivity for the phosphodiester cleavage reaction. We have analyzed the sequence specificity using a panel of DNA junctions, measuring the rate of cleavage of each under single-turnover conditions. We have found that the optimal sequence for cleavage can be described by (A approximately T)TT downward arrow(C>G approximately A), where downward arrow denotes the position of backbone scission. Cleavage is fastest when the cleaved phosphodiester linkage is located at the point of strand exchange. However, cleavage is possible one nucleotide 3' of this position when directed by the sequence, with a rate that is 1 order of magnitude slower than the optimal. The maximum sequence discrimination occurs at the central TT in the tetranucleotide site, where any alteration of sequence results in a rate reduction of at least 100-fold and cleavage is undetectable for some changes. However, certain sequences in the outer nucleotides are strongly inhibitory to cleavage. Introduction of base analogues around the cleavage site reveals a number of important functional groups and suggests that major-groove contacts in the center of the tetranucleotide are important for the cleavage process. Since RuvC binds to all the variant junctions with very similar affinity, any contacts affecting the rate of cleavage must be primarily important in the transition state. Introduction of the optimal cleavage sequence into a three-way DNA junction led to relatively efficient cleavage by RuvC, at a rate only 3-fold slower than the optimal four-way junction. This is consistent with a protein-induced alteration in the conformation of the DNA.

A Holliday junction resolvase from Pyrococcus furiosus: functional similarity to Escherichia coli RuvC provides evidence for conserved mechanism of homologous recombination in Bacteria, Eukarya, and Archaea

The Holliday junction is an essential intermediate of homologous recombination. RecA of Bacteria, Rad51 of Eukarya, and RadA of Archaea are structural and functional homologs. These proteins play a pivotal role in the formation of Holliday junctions from two homologous DNA duplexes. RuvC is a specific endonuclease that resolves Holliday junctions in Bacteria. A Holliday junction-resolving activity has been found in both yeast and mammalian cells. To examine whether the paradigm of homologous recombination apply to Archaea, we assayed and found the activity to resolve a synthetic Holliday junction in crude extract of Pyrococcus furiosus cells. The gene, hjc (Holliday junction cleavage), encodes a protein composed of 123 amino acids, whose sequence is not similar to that of any proteins with known function. However, all four archaea, whose total genome sequences have been published, have the homologous genes. The purified Hjc protein cleaved the recombination intermediates formed by RecA in vitro. These results support the notion that the formation and resolution of Holliday junction is the common mechanism of homologous recombination in the three domains of life.

Assembly of the Escherichia coli RuvABC resolvasome directs the orientation of holliday junction resolution

Genetic recombination can lead to the formation of intermediates in which DNA molecules are linked by Holliday junctions. Movement of a junction along DNA, by a process known as branch migration, leads to heteroduplex formation, whereas resolution of a junction completes the recombination process. Holliday junctions can be resolved in either of two ways, yielding products in which there has, or has not, been an exchange of flanking markers. The ratio of these products is thought to be determined by the frequency with which the two isomeric forms (conformers) of the Holliday junction are cleaved. Recent studies with enzymes that process Holliday junctions in Escherichia coli, the RuvABC proteins, however, indicate that protein binding causes the junction to adopt an open square-planar configuration. Within such a structure, DNA isomerization can have little role in determining the orientation of resolution. To determine the role that junction-specific protein assembly has in determining resolution bias, a defined in vitro system was developed in which we were able to direct the assembly of the RuvABC resolvasome. We found that the bias toward resolution in one orientation or the other was determined simply by the way in which the Ruv proteins were positioned on the junction. Additionally, we provide evidence that supports current models on RuvABC action in which Holliday junction resolution occurs as the resolvasome promotes branch migration.

Substrate specificity of the SpCCE1 holliday junction resolvase of Schizosaccharomyces pombe

SpCCE1 from Schizosaccharomyces pombe is an endonuclease that resolves Holliday junctions in vitro. SpCCE1 also binds and cleaves a range of other DNAs (Y-junction; flap; and flayed, nicked, and partial duplexes) with varying efficiency. Cleavage sites are always 3' of thymine nucleotides positioned at or close to the branch point or strand interruption. SpCCE1's favored substrate is the X-junction. Up to two dimers of SpCCE1 can bind concurrently to the same X-junction at its crossover point. From mixing experiments of SpCCE1 and the Escherichia coli RuvA protein, we show that each dimer of SpCCE1 binds to a different face of the X-junction and that both are seemingly competent for strand cleavage. We propose that this provides a mechanism whereby SpCCE1 can scrutinize all four junction strands simultaneously for cleavable thymine nucleotides. SpCCE1 appears to resolve X-junctions by a nick and counter-nick mechanism. Therefore, to ensure a high probability of bilateral strand cleavage, SpCCE1 has a relatively long lifetime on X-junctions. This mechanism has the drawback of limiting dissociation from noncleavable junctions. We discuss why this might not be a problem in vivo.

Mutational analysis on structure-function relationship of a holliday junction specific endonuclease RuvC

BACKGROUND

Escherichia coli RuvC protein is a specific endonuclease that resolves Holliday junctions during homologous recombination. For junction resolution, RuvC undergoes distinct steps such as dimerization, junction-specific binding and endonucleolytic cleavage. The crystal structure of RuvC has been revealed.

RESULTS

To identify functionally important residues, we isolated a large number of mutant ruvC genes created by random mutagenesis and characterized their properties in vivo and in vitro. The mutations which were isolated most frequently were mapped to the four acidic residues constituting the catalytic centre. Amongst the several mutant proteins affected in the dimer interface, only one could not form a dimer. The others were able to form a dimer but were defective in cleavage. F69L and K118R mutant proteins could not cleave the junction, but they were able to form a dimer and bind the junction DNA.

CONCLUSIONS

Random mutagenesis highlighted many structurally and functionally important residues of RuvC, most of which are highly conserved among RuvC homologues. Dimer formation and also conservation of intact interface interactions between the subunits are important for junction binding and subsequent cleavage. Phe-69 and Lys-118 are critically important for the interactions which lead to junction cleavage.

Coordinated actions of RuvABC in Holliday junction processing

The RuvA, RuvB and RuvC proteins of Escherichia coli process Holliday junctions during genetic recombination and DNA repair. Biochemical studies have shown that RuvA and RuvB promote branch migration whereas RuvC resolves junctions by endonucleolytic cleavage. Here we show that RuvAB stimulate Holliday junction resolution by RuvC. Elevated RuvC activity was dependent upon RuvAB-mediated ATP-hydrolysis. These results show that the three Ruv proteins work in a coordinated manner to promote Holliday junction resolution, and account for the resolvase-defective phenotype exhibited by ruvA, ruvB or ruvC mutant strains.

Sequence-specificity of Holliday junction resolution: identification of RuvC mutants defective in metal binding and target site recognition

The RuvC protein of Escherichia coli resolves Holliday intermediates in recombination and DNA repair by a dual strand incision mechanism targeted to specific DNA sequences located symmetrically at the crossover. Two classes of amino acid substitutions are described that provide new insights into the sequence-specificity of the resolution reaction. The first includes D7N and G14S, which modify or eliminate metal binding and prevent catalysis. The second, defined by G114D, G114N, and A116T, interfere with the ability of RuvC to cleave at preferred sequences, but allow resolution at non-consensus target sites. All five mutant proteins bind junction DNA and impose an open conformation. D7N and G14S fail to induce hypersensitivity to hydroxyl radicals, a property of RuvC previously thought to reflect junction opening. A different mechanism is proposed whereby ferrous ions are co-ordinated in the complex to induce a high local concentration of radicals. The open structure imposed by wild-type RuvC in Mg2+ is similar to that observed previously using a junction with a different stacking preference. G114D and A116T impose slightly altered structures. This subtle change may be sufficient to explain the failure of these proteins to cleave the sequences normally preferred. Gly114 and Ala116 residues link two alpha-helices lining the wall of the catalytic cleft in each subunit of RuvC. We suggest that substitutions at these positions realign these helices and interfere with the ability to establish base-specific contacts at resolution hotspots.

Lactococcus lactis phage operon coding for an endonuclease homologous to RuvC

The function of the Lactococcus lactis bacteriophage bIL66 middle time-expressed operon (M-operon), involved in sensitivity to the abortive infection mechanism AbiD1, was examined. Expression of the M-operon is detrimental to Escherichia coli cells, induces the SOS response and is lethal to recA and recBC E. coli mutants, which are both deficient in recombinational repair of chromosomal double-stranded breaks (DSBs). The use of an inducible expression system allowed us to demonstrate that the M-operon-encoded proteins generate a limited number of randomly distributed chromosomal DSBs that are substrates for ExoV-mediated DNA degradation. DSBs were also shown to occur upstream of the replication initiation point of unidirectionally theta-replicating plasmids. The characteristics of the DSBs lead us to propose that the endonucleolytic activity of the M-operon is not specific to DNA sequence, but rather to branched DNA structures. Genetic and physical analysis performed with different derivatives of the M-operon indicated that two orfs (orf2 and orf3) are needed for nucleolytic activity. The orf3 product has amino acid homology with the E. coli RuvC Holliday junction resolvase. By site-specific mutagenesis, we have shown that one of the amino acid residues constituting the active centre of RuvC enzyme (Glu-66) and conserved in ORF3 (Glu-67) is essential for the nucleolytic activity of the M-operon gene product(s). We therefore propose that orf2 and orf3 of the M-operon code for a structure-specific endonuclease (M-nuclease), which might be essential for phage multiplication.

Functional interactions between the holliday junction resolvase and the branch migration motor of Escherichia coli

Homologous recombination generates genetic diversity and provides an important cellular pathway for the repair of double-stranded DNA breaks. Two key steps in this process are the branch migration of Holliday junctions followed by their resolution into mature recombination products. In E.coli, branch migration is catalysed by the RuvB protein, a hexameric DNA helicase that is loaded onto the junction by RuvA, whereas resolution is promoted by the RuvC endonuclease. Here we provide direct evidence for functional interactions between RuvB and RuvC that link these biochemically distinct processes. Using synthetic Holliday junctions, RuvB was found to stabilize the binding of RuvC to a junction and to stimulate its resolvase activity. Conversely, RuvC facilitated interactions between RuvB and the junction such that RuvBC complexes catalysed branch migration. The observed synergy between RuvB and RuvC provides new insight into the structure and function of a RuvABC complex that is capable of facilitating branch migration and resolution of Holliday junctions via a concerted enzymatic mechanism.

Processing of recombination intermediates by the RuvABC proteins

The RuvA, RuvB, and RuvC proteins in Escherichia coli play important roles in the late stages of homologous genetic recombination and the recombinational repair of damaged DNA. Two proteins, RuvA and RuvB, form a complex that promotes ATP-dependent branch migration of Holliday junctions, a process that is important for the formation of heteroduplex DNA. Individual roles for each protein have been defined, with RuvA acting as a specificity factor that targets RuvB, the branch migration motor to the junction. Structural studies indicate that two RuvA tetramers sandwich the junction and hold it in an unfolded square-planar configuration. Hexameric rings of RuvB face each other across the junction and promote a novel dual helicase action that "pumps" DNA through the RuvAB complex, using the free energy provided by ATP hydrolysis. The third protein, RuvC endonuclease, resolves the Holliday junction by introducing nicks into two DNA strands. Genetic and biochemical studies indicate that branch migration and resolution are coupled by direct interactions between the three proteins, possibly by the formation of a RuvABC complex.

Characterization of a Holliday junction-resolving enzyme from Schizosaccharomyces pombe

The rearrangement and repair of DNA by homologous recombination involves the creation of Holliday junctions, which are cleaved by a class of junction-specific endonucleases to generate recombinant duplex DNA products. Only two cellular junction-resolving enzymes have been identified to date: RuvC in eubacteria and CCE1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondria. We have identified a protein from Schizosaccharomyces pombe which has 28% sequence identity to CCE1. The YDC2 protein has been cloned and overexpressed in Escherichia coli, and the purified recombinant protein has been shown to be a Holliday junction-resolving enzyme. YDC2 has a high degree of specificity for the structure of the four-way junction, to which it binds as a dimer. The enzyme exhibits a sequence specificity for junction cleavage that differs from both CCE1 and RuvC, and it cleaves fixed junctions at the point of strand exchange. The conservation of the mechanism of Holliday junction cleavage between two organisms as diverse as S. cerevisiae and S. pombe suggests that there may be a common pathway for mitochondrial homologous recombination in fungi, plants, protists, and possibly higher eukaryotes.

A new Holliday junction resolving enzyme from Schizosaccharomyces pombe that is homologous to CCE1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The resolution of Holliday junctions is a critical stage in recombination. We describe the identification and initial biochemical characterisation of a new Holliday junction resolvase from Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Resolvase activity was initially detected in partially purified cell-free extracts of S. pombe. Resolution of X-junction DNA occurred by the introduction of symmetrical cuts in strands of the same polarity. All cuts occurred 3' of thymine nucleotides with a possible preference for cleavage one nucleotide 3' from the point of strand crossover. During the course of these studies, a potential S. pombe homologue of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Cruciform Cutting Endonuclease I was identified in the database (SpCCE1). The gene was cloned by PCR, overexpressed in Escherichia coli and its product purified as a His-tagged fusion protein. Purified SpCCE1 binds to X-junctions in a structure-specific manner and resolves them to nicked linear duplex products that are repairable by DNA ligase. SpCCE1 cuts X-junctions in precisely the same way as the resolvase activity from partially purified extracts of S. pombe, indicating that they are probably the same. Finally, we show that SpCCE1 can function as a Holliday junction resolvase in vivo by its ability to complement a resolvase-deficient strain of E. coli.

Effect of DNA topology on Holliday junction resolution by Escherichia coli RuvC and bacteriophage T7 endonuclease I

Holliday junctions are key intermediates in homologous genetic recombination. Their resolution requires specialised nucleases that nick pairs of strands at the junction point, leading to the separation of mature recombinants. Resolution occurs in either of two orientations, according to which DNA strands are cut. We show that DNA topology can determine the efficiency and outcome of a recombination reaction. Using two Holliday junction resolvases, Escherichia coli RuvC protein and T7 endonuclease I, we observed that supercoiled figure-8 DNA molecules containing Holliday junctions were resolved with a specific orientation bias, and that this bias was reversed by the presence of a topological tether (catenation). In contrast, when all topological constraints were removed by restriction digestion, the recombination intermediates were resolved equally in the two orientations. These results show that topological constraints affecting Holliday junction structure influence the orientation of resolution by cellular resolvases.

Recognition and manipulation of branched DNA structure by junction-resolving enzymes

The junction-resolving enzymes are a class of nucleases that introduce paired cleavages into four-way DNA junctions. They are important in DNA recombination and repair, and are found throughout nature, from eubacteria and their bacteriophages through to higher eukaryotes and their viruses. These enzymes exhibit structure-selective binding to DNA junctions; although cleavage may be more or less sequence-dependent, binding affinity is purely related to the branched structure of the DNA. Binding and cleavage events can be separated for a number of the enzymes by mutagenesis, and mutant proteins that are defective in cleavage while retaining normal junction-selective binding have been isolated. Critical acidic residues have been identified in several resolving enzymes, suggesting a role in the coordination of metal ions that probably deliver the hydrolytic water molecule. The resolving enzymes all bind to junctions in dimeric form, and the subunits introduce independent cleavages within the lifetime of the enzyme-junction complex to ensure resolution of the four-way junction. In addition to recognising the structure of the junction, recent data from four different junction-resolving enzymes indicate that they also manipulate the global structure. In some cases this results in severe distortion of the folded structure of the junction. Understanding the recognition and manipulation of DNA structure by these enzymes is a fascinating challenge in molecular recognition.

Sequence specificity and biochemical characterization of the RusA Holliday junction resolvase of Escherichia coli

The RusA protein of Escherichia coli is an endonuclease that resolves Holliday intermediates in recombination and DNA repair. Analysis of its subunit structure revealed that the native protein is a dimer. Its resolution activity was investigated using synthetic X-junctions with homologous cores. Resolution occurs by dual strand incision predominantly 5' of CC dinucleotides located symmetrically. A junction lacking homology is not resolved. The efficiency of resolution is related inversely to the number of base pairs in the homologous core, which suggests that branch migration is rate-limiting. Inhibition of resolution at high ratios of protein to DNA suggests that binding of RusA may immobilize the junction point at non-cleavable sites. Resolution is stimulated by alkaline pH and by Mn2+. The protein is unstable in the absence of substrate DNA and loses approximately 80% of its activity within 1 min under standard reaction conditions. DNA binding stabilizes the activity. Junction resolution is inhibited in the presence of RuvA. This observation probably explains why RusA is unable to promote efficient recombination and DNA repair in ruvA+ strains unless it is expressed at a high level.

In vitro reconstitution of the late steps of genetic recombination in E. coli

Purified proteins have been used to reconstitute an in vitro system for the medial-to-late stages of recombination in E. coli. In this system, RecA protein formed recombination intermediates that were processed by the actions of the RuvA, RuvB, and RuvC proteins. RuvAB was found to promote branch migration, to dissociate the RecA filament, and to modulate the orientation of cleavage of Holliday junction resolution by RuvC. Monoclonal antibodies directed against RuvA, RuvB, or RuvC inhibited resolution in the reconstituted system. Specific protein-protein interactions between the branch migration motor (RuvB) and the resolvase (RuvC) were also observed. These results provide evidence for coordinated action during the late stages of recombination, possibly involving the assembly of a RuvABC branch migration/resolution complex.

The RuvC protein dimer resolves Holliday junctions by a dual incision mechanism that involves base-specific contacts

The Escherichia coli RuvC protein resolves DNA intermediates produced during genetic recombination. In vitro, RuvC binds specifically to Holliday junctions and resolves them by the introduction of nicks into two strands of like polarity. In contrast to junction recognition, which occurs without regard for DNA sequence, resolution occurs preferentially at sequences that exhibit the consensus 5'-(A/T)TT/(G/C)-3' (where / indicates the site of incision). Synthetic Holliday junctions containing modified cleavage sequences have been used to investigate the mechanism of cleavage. The results indicate that specific DNA sequences are required for the correct docking of DNA into the two active sites of the RuvC dimer. In addition, using chemically modified oligonucleotides to introduce a hydrolysis-resistant 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkage at the cleavage site, it was found that, as long as the sequence requirements are fulfilled, the two incisions could be uncoupled from each other. These results indicate that RuvC protein resolves Holliday junctions by a mechanism similar to that exhibited by certain restriction enzymes.