NMR studies on the flexibility of the poliovirus C3 linear epitope inserted into different sites of the maltose-binding protein

Application of the random coil index to studying protein flexibility

Protein flexibility lies at the heart of many protein-ligand binding events and enzymatic activities. However, the experimental measurement of protein motions is often difficult, tedious and error-prone. As a result, there is a considerable interest in developing simpler and faster ways of quantifying protein flexibility. Recently, we described a method, called Random Coil Index (RCI), which appears to be able to quantitatively estimate model-free order parameters and flexibility in protein structural ensembles using only backbone chemical shifts. Because of its potential utility, we have undertaken a more detailed investigation of the RCI method in an attempt to ascertain its underlying principles, its general utility, its sensitivity to chemical shift errors, its sensitivity to data completeness, its applicability to other proteins, and its general strengths and weaknesses. Overall, we find that the RCI method is very robust and that it represents a useful addition to traditional methods of studying protein flexibility. We have implemented many of the findings and refinements reported here into a web server that allows facile, automated predictions of model-free order parameters, MD RMSF and NMR RMSD values directly from backbone 1H, 13C and 15N chemical shift assignments. The server is available at http://wishart.biology.ualberta.ca/rci.

The RCI server: rapid and accurate calculation of protein flexibility using chemical shifts

Protein motions play important roles in numerous biological processes such as enzyme catalysis, muscle contractions, antigen–antibody interactions, gene regulation and virus assembly. Knowledge of protein flexibility is also important in rational drug design, protein docking and protein engineering. However, the experimental measurement of protein motions is often difficult, requiring sophisticated experiments, complex data analysis and detailed information about the protein's tertiary structure. As a result, there is a considerable interest in developing simpler, more effective ways of quantifying protein flexibility. Recently, we described a method, called the random coil index (RCI), which is able to quantitatively estimate backbone root mean square fluctuations (RMSFs) of structural ensembles and order parameters using only chemical shifts. The RCI method is very fast (<5 s) and exceedingly robust. It also offers an excellent alternative to traditional methods of measuring protein flexibility. We have recently extended the RCI concept and implemented it as a web server. This server allows facile, accurate and fully automated predictions of MD RMSF values, NMR RMSF values and model-free order parameters (S²) directly from chemical shift assignments. It also performs automatic chemical shift re-referencing to ensure consistency and reproducibility. On average, the correlation between RCI predictions and experimentally obtained motional amplitudes is within the range from 0.77 to 0.82. The server is available at http://wishart.biology.ualberta.ca/rci.

Antigenicity and immunogenicity of the HIV-1 gp41 epitope ELDKWA inserted into permissive sites of the MalE protein

The highly conserved amino acid sequence ELDKWA of HIV-1 gp41 has been inserted into Escherichia coli MalE protein which had been shown to be an adequate carrier to present foreign epitopes to the immune system. We first investigated whether eight different permissive sites of MalE are able to tolerate an insertion of 7-50 residues encoding this epitope. Secondly, antigenicity of the epitope inserted in MalE protein was estimated from monoclonal antibody 2F5 binding analysis using the BIAcore(R) technology and its immunogenicity in mice was measured as the ability of hybrid proteins to elicit antibodies against a synthetic peptide containing this epitope. This study revealed a good correlation between the antigenicity of the inserted epitope and its immunogenicity. Increasing the length of the inserted epitope, as well as inserting multicopies of this epitope increased both its antigenicity and immunogenicity. However, none of the MalE hybrid proteins tested induced anti-HIV-1 neutralizing antibodies. This study strongly suggests that the capacity of the 2F5 epitope to induce neutralizing antibodies depends on the molecular context in which it is presented.

Biosensor characterization of antigenic site A of foot-and-mouth disease virus presented in different vector systems

The region 141-160 of the VP1 protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus known as site A is an immunodominant region that has been extensively studied for the purpose of developing a synthetic vaccine. In the present study, site A of foot-and-mouth disease virus was inserted in three different loops of the maltose-binding protein and its antigenicity was compared with site A presented as a conjugated synthetic peptide or inserted in beta-galactosidase. The affinity of antibodies elicited against the site A synthetic peptide was also compared with that of antibodies raised against the site A inserted within the two carrier proteins. Using biosensor technology it was possible to estimate the concentration of site A antibodies present in the various antisera and to show that site A fused to maltose-binding protein was a slightly better mimic of the epitope present in the virus particle than the synthetic peptide or the beta-galactosidase recombinant construct.

Conformational and functional properties of an undecapeptide epitope fused with the C-terminal end of the maltose binding protein

Monoclonal antibody mAb164 is directed against the TrpB2 subunit of the Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase. It recognizes the synthetic peptide P11, constituted of residues 273-283 of TrpB, with high affinity. We constructed a hybrid protein in which the C-terminal end of protein MalE was linked with the N-terminal end of P11. Hybrid MalE-P11 was produced in E. coli from a plasmidic gene and purified in one step as MalE. MalE-P11 and the isolated P11 had identical conformational and functional properties according to the following criteria. The NMR spectra of MalE and MalE-P11 in TOCSY experiments showed that the P11 moiety of MalE-P11 moved independently from its MalE moiety. The chemical shifts of the protons for the P11 moiety of MalE-P11 and for the isolated P11 were very close and did not show significant deviations from random coil values. The equilibrium constant of dissociation (KD) from mAb164, measured by a competition ELISA, was identical for MalE-P11 and the isolated P11, around 6 nM. The change of the C-terminal residue of MalE-P11 from Lys into Ala increased 37-fold this dissociation constant. This increase showed that the P11 moiety of MalE-P11 was not degraded. The high molecular mass of MalE-P11 allowed us to follow its kinetics of interaction with immobilized mAb164 by surface plasmon resonance, using the BIAcore apparatus. The rates of association with mAb164 were similar for MalE-P11 and TrpB2, but the dissociation was faster for MalE-P11 than for TrpB2, as previously observed for the isolated P11 by a fluorometric method. Thus, the fusion of peptides with the C-terminal end of MalE could constitute an alternative to chemical synthesis for the study of their recognition by receptors, in vivo or in vitro.

Structure of poliovirus type 2 Lansing complexed with antiviral agent SCH48973: comparison of the structural and biological properties of three poliovirus serotypes

BACKGROUND

Polioviruses are human pathogens and the causative agents of poliomyelitis. Polioviruses are icosahedral single-stranded RNA viruses, which belong to the picornavirus family, and occur as three distinct serotypes. All three serotypes of poliovirus can infect primates, but only type 2 can infect mice. The crystal structures of a type 1 and a type 3 poliovirus are already known. Structural studies of poliovirus type 2 Lansing (PV2L) were initiated to try to enhance our understanding of the differences in host range specificity, antigenicity and receptor binding among the three serotypes of poliovirus.

RESULTS

The crystal structure of the mouse neurovirulent PV2L complexed with a potent antiviral agent, SCH48973, was determined at 2.9 A resolution. Structural differences among the three poliovirus serotypes occur primarily in the loop regions of the viral coat proteins (VPs), most notably in the loops of VP1 that cluster near the fivefold axes of the capsid, where the BC loop of PV2L is disordered. Unlike other known structures of enteroviruses, the entire polypeptide chain of PV2L VP4 is visible in the electron density and RNA bases are observed stacking with conserved aromatic residues (Tyr4020 and Phe4046) of VP4. The broad-spectrum antiviral agent SCH48973 is observed binding in a pocket within the beta-barrel of VP1, in approximately the same location that natural 'pocket factors' bind to polioviruses. SCH48973 forms predominantly hydrophobic interactions with the pocket residues.

CONCLUSIONS

Some of the conformational changes required for infectivity and involved in the control of capsid stability and neurovirulence in mice may occur in the vicinity of the fivefold axis of the poliovirus, where there are significant structural differences among the three poliovirus serotypes in the surface exposed loops of VP1 (BC, DE, and HI). A surface depression is located at the fivefold axis of PV2L that is not present in the other two poliovirus serotypes. The observed interaction of RNA with VP4 supports the observation that loss of VP4 ultimately leads to the loss of viral RNA. A model is proposed that suggests dual involvement of the virion fivefold and pseudo-threefold axes in receptor-mediated initiation of infection by picornaviruses.

Modulating the immunological properties of a linear B-cell epitope by insertion into permissive sites of the MalE protein

In a previous study, a set of positions in the MalE protein from Escherichia coli were identified, which tolerated short insertions or deletions without compromising the maltose binding activity of the protein. It is now shown that these sites accommodate an insert of 13 amino acids and are, therefore, permissive. Eleven sites were used, including eight permissive sites, to display a linear neutralization B-cell epitope of poliovirus (C3 epitope) at different positions on the surface of MalE. The affinity of a monoclonal neutralizing anti-poliovirus antibody (anti-C3 mAb) for the hybrid proteins varied from undetectable, to more than 1000 times higher than for the synthetic peptide. Therefore, some MalEC3 proteins mimic interactions of the viral epitope with the monoclonal antibody more efficiently than the free peptide. The results are interpreted in terms of the mobility of the insert and its flanking regions. It was further shown that some of the purified hybrid proteins are able to induce high titer anti-C3-peptide antibodies in mice. A strong correlation exists between the capacity of a MalEC3 protein to induce anti-C3-peptide antibodies and the antigenicity of the inserted peptide, measured with a polyclonal serum raised against the synthetic peptide.