The folding and unfolding behavior of ribonuclease H on the ribosome

How proteins manage to fold and how chaperones manage to assist the folding

This review presents the current understanding of (i) spontaneous self-organization of spatial structures of protein molecules, and (ii) possible ways of chaperones' assistance to this process. Specifically, we overview the most important features of spontaneous folding of proteins (mostly, of the single-domain water-soluble globular proteins): the choice of the unique protein structure among zillions of alternatives, the nucleation of the folding process, and phase transitions within protein molecules. We consider the main experimental facts on protein folding, both in vivo and in vitro, of both kinetic and thermodynamic nature. We discuss the famous Levinthal's paradox of protein folding and its solution, theoretical models of protein folding and unfolding, and the dependence of the rates of these processes on the protein chain length. Special attention is paid to relatively small, single-domain, and water-soluble globular proteins whose structure and folding are much better studied and understood than those of large proteins, especially membrane or fibrous proteins. Lastly, we describe the chaperone-assisted protein folding with an emphasis on the chaperones' ability to prevent proteins from their irreversible aggregation. Since the possible assistance mechanisms connected with chaperones are still debatable, experimental data useful in selecting the most likely mechanisms of chaperone-assisted protein folding are presented.

Beyond Misfolding: A New Paradigm for the Relationship Between Protein Folding and Aggregation

Aggregation is intricately linked to protein folding, necessitating a precise understanding of their relationship. Traditionally, aggregation has been viewed primarily as a sequential consequence of protein folding and misfolding. However, this conventional paradigm is inherently incomplete and can be deeply misleading. Remarkably, it fails to adequately explain how intrinsic and extrinsic factors, such as charges and cellular macromolecules, prevent intermolecular aggregation independently of intramolecular protein folding and structure. The pervasive inconsistencies between protein folding and aggregation call for a new framework. In all combined reactions of molecules, both intramolecular and intermolecular rate (or equilibrium) constants are mutually independent; accordingly, intrinsic and extrinsic factors independently affect both rate constants. This universal principle, when applied to protein folding and aggregation, indicates that they should be treated as two independent yet interconnected processes. Based on this principle, a new framework provides groundbreaking insights into misfolding, Anfinsen's thermodynamic hypothesis, molecular chaperones, intrinsic chaperone-like activities of cellular macromolecules, intermolecular repulsive force-driven aggregation inhibition, proteome solubility maintenance, and proteinopathies. Consequently, this paradigm shift not only refines our current understanding but also offers a more comprehensive view of how aggregation is coupled to protein folding in the complex cellular milieu.

Resolving chaperone-assisted protein folding on the ribosome at the peptide level

Protein folding in vivo begins during synthesis on the ribosome and is modulated by molecular chaperones that engage the nascent polypeptide. How these features of protein biogenesis influence the maturation pathway of nascent proteins is incompletely understood. Here, we use hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to define, at peptide resolution, the cotranslational chaperone-assisted folding pathway of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase. The nascent polypeptide folds along an unanticipated pathway through structured intermediates not populated during refolding from denaturant. Association with the ribosome allows these intermediates to form, as otherwise destabilizing carboxy-terminal sequences remain confined in the ribosome exit tunnel. Trigger factor binds partially folded states without disrupting their structure, and the nascent chain is poised to complete folding immediately upon emergence of the C terminus from the exit tunnel. By mapping interactions between the nascent chain and ribosomal proteins, we trace the path of the emerging polypeptide during synthesis. Our work reveals new mechanisms by which cellular factors shape the conformational search for the native state.

The ribosome lowers the entropic penalty of protein folding

Most proteins fold during biosynthesis on the ribosome1, and co-translational folding energetics, pathways and outcomes of many proteins have been found to differ considerably from those in refolding studies2-10. The origin of this folding modulation by the ribosome has remained unknown. Here we have determined atomistic structures of the unfolded state of a model protein on and off the ribosome, which reveal that the ribosome structurally expands the unfolded nascent chain and increases its solvation, resulting in its entropic destabilization relative to the peptide chain in isolation. Quantitative 19F NMR experiments confirm that this destabilization reduces the entropic penalty of folding by up to 30 kcal mol-1 and promotes formation of partially folded intermediates on the ribosome, an observation that extends to other protein domains and is obligate for some proteins to acquire their active conformation. The thermodynamic effects also contribute to the ribosome protecting the nascent chain from mutation-induced unfolding, which suggests a crucial role of the ribosome in supporting protein evolution. By correlating nascent chain structure and dynamics to their folding energetics and post-translational outcomes, our findings establish the physical basis of the distinct thermodynamics of co-translational protein folding.

Translation Rates and Protein Folding

The mRNA coding sequence defines not only the amino acid sequence of the protein, but also the speed at which the ribosomes move along the mRNA while making the protein. The non-uniform local kinetics - denoted as translational rhythm - is similar among mRNAs coding for related protein folds. Deviations from this conserved rhythm can result in protein misfolding. In this review we summarize the experimental evidence demonstrating how local translation rates affect cotranslational protein folding, with the focus on the synonymous codons and patches of charged residues in the nascent peptide as best-studied examples. Alterations in nascent protein conformations due to disturbed translational rhythm can persist off the ribosome, as demonstrated by the effects of synonymous codon variants of several disease-related proteins. Charged amino acid patches in nascent chains also modulate translation and cotranslational protein folding, and can abrogate translation when placed at the N-terminus of the nascent peptide. During cotranslational folding, incomplete nascent chains navigate through a unique conformational landscape in which earlier intermediate states become inaccessible as the nascent peptide grows. Precisely tuned local translation rates, as well as interactions with the ribosome, guide the folding pathway towards the native structure, whereas deviations from the natural translation rhythm may favor pathways leading to trapped misfolded states. Deciphering the 'folding code' of the mRNA will contribute to understanding the diseases caused by protein misfolding and to rational protein design.

Navigating the complexities of multi-domain protein folding

Proteome complexity has expanded tremendously over evolutionary time, enabling biological diversification. Much of this complexity is achieved by combining a limited set of structural units into long polypeptides. This widely used evolutionary strategy poses challenges for folding of the resulting multi-domain proteins. As a consequence, their folding differs from that of small single-domain proteins, which generally fold quickly and reversibly. Co-translational processes and chaperone interactions are important aspects of multi-domain protein folding. In this review, we discuss some of the recent experimental progress toward understanding these processes.

AutoRNC: An automated modeling program for building atomic models of ribosome-nascent chain complexes

The interpretation of experimental studies of co-translational protein folding often benefits from the use of computational methods that seek to model or simulate the nascent chain and its interactions with the ribosome. Building realistic 3D models of ribosome-nascent chain (RNC) constructs often requires expert knowledge, so to circumvent this issue, we describe here AutoRNC, an automated modeling program capable of constructing large numbers of plausible atomic models of RNCs within minutes. AutoRNC takes input from the user specifying any regions of the nascent chain that contain secondary or tertiary structure and attempts to build conformations compatible with those specifications-and with the constraints imposed by the ribosome-by sampling and progressively piecing together dipeptide conformations extracted from the Research Collaboratory for Structural Bioinformatics Protein Data Bank (RCSB). Despite using only modest computational resources, we show here that AutoRNC can build plausible conformations for a wide range of RNC constructs for which experimental data have already been reported.

The SecM arrest peptide traps a pre-peptide bond formation state of the ribosome

Nascent polypeptide chains can induce translational stalling to regulate gene expression. This is exemplified by the E. coli secretion monitor (SecM) arrest peptide that induces translational stalling to regulate expression of the downstream encoded SecA, an ATPase that co-operates with the SecYEG translocon to facilitate insertion of proteins into or through the cytoplasmic membrane. Here we present the structure of a ribosome stalled during translation of the full-length E. coli SecM arrest peptide at 2.0 Å resolution. The structure reveals that SecM arrests translation by stabilizing the Pro-tRNA in the A-site, but in a manner that prevents peptide bond formation with the SecM-peptidyl-tRNA in the P-site. By employing molecular dynamic simulations, we also provide insight into how a pulling force on the SecM nascent chain can relieve the SecM-mediated translation arrest. Collectively, the mechanisms determined here for SecM arrest and relief are also likely to be applicable for a variety of other arrest peptides that regulate components of the protein localization machinery identified across a wide range of bacteria lineages.

How the ribosome shapes cotranslational protein folding

During protein synthesis, the growing nascent peptide chain moves inside the polypeptide exit tunnel of the ribosome from the peptidyl transferase center towards the exit port where it emerges into the cytoplasm. The ribosome defines the unique energy landscape of the pioneering round of protein folding. The spatial confinement and the interactions of the nascent peptide with the tunnel walls facilitate formation of secondary structures, such as α-helices. The vectorial nature of protein folding inside the tunnel favors local intra- and inter-molecular interactions, thereby inducing cotranslational folding intermediates that do not form upon protein refolding in solution. Tertiary structures start to fold in the lower part of the tunnel, where interactions with the ribosome destabilize native protein folds. The present review summarizes the recent progress in understanding the driving forces of nascent protein folding inside the tunnel and at the surface of the ribosome.

AP profiling resolves co-translational folding pathway and chaperone interactions in vivo

Natural proteins have evolved to fold robustly along specific pathways. Folding begins during synthesis, guided by interactions of the nascent protein with the ribosome and molecular chaperones. However, the timing and progression of co-translational folding remain largely elusive, in part because the process is difficult to measure in the natural environment of the cytosol. We developed a high-throughput method to quantify co-translational folding in live cells that we term Arrest Peptide profiling (AP profiling). We employed AP profiling to delineate co-translational folding for a set of GTPase domains with very similar structures, defining how topology shapes folding pathways. Genetic ablation of major nascent chain-binding chaperones resulted in localized folding changes that suggest how functional redundancies among chaperones are achieved by distinct interactions with the nascent protein. Collectively, our studies provide a window into cellular folding pathways of complex proteins and pave the way for systematic studies on nascent protein folding at unprecedented resolution and throughput.

AutoRNC: an automated modeling program for building atomic models of ribosome-nascent chain complexes

The interpretation of experimental studies of co-translational protein folding often benefits from the use of computational methods that seek to model the nascent chain and its interactions with the ribosome. Ribosome-nascent chain (RNC) constructs studied experimentally can vary significantly in size and the extent to which they contain secondary and tertiary structure, and building realistic 3D models of them therefore often requires expert knowledge. To circumvent this issue, we describe here AutoRNC, an automated modeling program capable of constructing large numbers of plausible atomic models of RNCs within minutes. AutoRNC takes input from the user specifying any regions of the nascent chain that contain secondary or tertiary structure and attempts to build conformations compatible with those specifications - and with the constraints imposed by the ribosome - by sampling and progressively piecing together dipeptide conformations extracted from the RCSB. We first show that conformations of completely unfolded proteins built by AutoRNC in the absence of the ribosome have radii of gyration that match well with the corresponding experimental data. We then show that AutoRNC can build plausible conformations for a wide range of RNC constructs for which experimental data have already been reported. Since AutoRNC requires only modest computational resources, we anticipate that it will prove to be a useful hypothesis generator for experimental studies, for example, in providing indications of whether designed constructs are likely to be capable of folding, as well as providing useful starting points for downstream atomic or coarse-grained simulations of the conformational dynamics of RNCs.

Thermodynamics of co-translational folding and ribosome-nascent chain interactions

Proteins can begin the conformational search for their native structure in parallel with biosynthesis on the ribosome, in a process termed co-translational folding. In contrast to the reversible folding of isolated domains, as a nascent chain emerges from the ribosome exit tunnel during translation the free energy landscape it explores also evolves as a function of chain length. While this presents a substantially more complex measurement problem, this review will outline the progress that has been made recently in understanding, quantitatively, the process by which a nascent chain attains its full native stability, as well as the mechanisms through which interactions with the nearby ribosome surface can perturb or modulate this process.

Cell-Free Synthesis Strategies to Probe Co-translational Folding of Proteins Within Lipid Membranes

In order to comprehend the molecular basis of transmembrane protein biogenesis, methods are required that are capable of investigating the co-translational folding of these hydrophobic proteins. Equally, in artificial cell studies, controllable methods are desirable for in situ synthesis of membrane proteins that then direct reactions in the synthetic cell membrane. Here we describe a method that exploits cell-free expression systems and tunable membrane mimetics to facilitate co-translational studies. Alteration of the lipid bilayer composition improves the efficiency of the folding system. The approach also enables membrane transport proteins to be made and inserted into artificial cell platforms such as droplet interface bilayers. Importantly, this gives a new facet to the droplet networks by enabling specific transport of molecules across the synthetic bilayer against a concentration gradient. This method also includes a protocol to pause and restart translation of membrane proteins at specified positions during their co-translational folding. This stop-start strategy provides an avenue to investigate whether the proteins fold in sequence order, or if the correct fold of N-terminal regions is reliant on the synthesis of downstream residues.

The role of glutathione-mediated triacylglycerol synthesis in the response to ultra-high cadmium stress in Auxenochlorella protothecoides

Under ultra-high cadmium (Cd) stress, large amounts of glutathione are produced in Auxenochlorella protothecoides UTEX 2341, and the lipid content increases significantly. Glutathione is the best reductant that can effectively remove Cd, but the relationship between lipid accumulation and the cellular response to Cd stress has not been ascertained. Integrating analyses of the transcriptomes and lipidomes, the mechanism of lipid accumulation to Cd tolerance were studied from the perspectives of metabolism, transcriptional regulation and protein glutathionylation. Under Cd stress, basic metabolic pathways, such as purine metabolism, translation and pre-mRNA splicing process, were inhibited, while the lipid accumulation pathway was significantly activated. Further analysis revealed that the transcription factors (TFs) and genes related to lipid accumulation were also activated. Analysis of the TF interaction sites showed that ABI5, MYB_rel and NF-YB could further regulate the expression of diacylglycerol acyltransferase through glutathionylation/deglutathionylation, which led to increase of the triacylglycerol (TAG) content. Lipidomes analysis showed that TAG could help maintain lipid homeostasis by adjusting its saturation/unsaturation levels. This study for the first time indicated that glutathione could activate TAG synthesis in microalga A. protothecoides, leading to TAG accumulation and glutathione accumulation under Cd stress. Therefore, the accumulation of TAG and glutathione can confer resistance to high Cd stress. This study provided insights into a new operation mode of TAG accumulation under heavy metal stress.

The driving force for co-translational protein folding is weaker in the ribosome vestibule due to greater water ordering

Interactions between the ribosome and nascent chain can destabilize folded domains in the ribosome exit tunnel's vestibule, the last 3 nm of the exit tunnel where tertiary folding can occur. Here, we test if a contribution to this destabilization is a weakening of hydrophobic association, the driving force for protein folding. Using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, we calculate the potential-of-mean force between two methane molecules along the center line of the ribosome exit tunnel and in bulk solution. Associated methanes, we find, are half as stable in the ribosome's vestibule as compared to bulk solution, demonstrating that the hydrophobic effect is weakened by the presence of the ribosome. This decreased stability arises from a decrease in the amount of water entropy gained upon the association of the methanes. And this decreased entropy gain originates from water molecules being more ordered in the vestibule as compared to bulk solution. Therefore, the hydrophobic effect is weaker in the vestibule because waters released from the first solvation shell of methanes upon association do not gain as much entropy in the vestibule as they do upon release in bulk solution. These findings mean that nascent proteins pass through a ribosome vestibule environment that can destabilize folded structures, which has the potential to influence co-translational protein folding pathways, energetics, and kinetics.

Fundamentals to function: Quantitative and scalable approaches for measuring protein stability

Folding a linear chain of amino acids into a three-dimensional protein is a complex physical process that ultimately confers an impressive range of diverse functions. Although recent advances have driven significant progress in predicting three-dimensional protein structures from sequence, proteins are not static molecules. Rather, they exist as complex conformational ensembles defined by energy landscapes spanning the space of sequence and conditions. Quantitatively mapping the physical parameters that dictate these landscapes and protein stability is therefore critical to develop models that are capable of predicting how mutations alter function of proteins in disease and informing the design of proteins with desired functions. Here, we review the approaches that are used to quantify protein stability at a variety of scales, from returning multiple thermodynamic and kinetic measurements for a single protein sequence to yielding indirect insights into folding across a vast sequence space. The physical parameters derived from these approaches will provide a foundation for models that extend beyond the structural prediction to capture the complexity of conformational ensembles and, ultimately, their function.

Reconstruction of mechanical unfolding and refolding pathways of proteins with atomic force spectroscopy and computer simulations

Most proteins in proteomes are large, typically consist of more than one domain and are structurally complex. This often makes studying their mechanical unfolding pathways challenging. Proteins composed of tandem repeat domains are a subgroup of multi-domain proteins that, when stretched, display a saw-tooth pattern in their mechanical unfolding force extension profiles due to their repetitive structure. However, the assignment of force peaks to specific repeats undergoing mechanical unraveling is complicated because all repeats are similar and they interact with their neighbors and form a contiguous tertiary structure. Here, we describe in detail a combination of experimental and computational single-molecule force spectroscopy methods that proved useful for examining the mechanical unfolding and refolding pathways of ankyrin repeat proteins. Specifically, we explain and delineate the use of atomic force microscope-based single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) to record the mechanical unfolding behavior of ankyrin repeat proteins and capture their unusually strong refolding propensity that is responsible for generating impressive refolding force peaks. We also describe Coarse Grain Steered Molecular Dynamic (CG-SMD) simulations which complement the experimental observations and provide insights in understanding the unfolding and refolding of these proteins. In addition, we advocate the use of novel coiled-coils-based mechanical polypeptide probes which we developed to demonstrate the vectorial character of folding and refolding of these repeat proteins. The combination of AFM-based SMFS on native and CC-equipped proteins with CG-SMD simulations is powerful not only for ankyrin repeat polypeptides, but also for other repeat proteins and more generally to various multidomain, non-repetitive proteins with complex topologies.

Co-translational folding of nascent polypeptides: Multi-layered mechanisms for the efficient biogenesis of functional proteins

The coupling of protein synthesis and folding is a crucial yet poorly understood aspect of cellular protein folding. Over the past few years, it has become possible to experimentally follow and define protein folding on the ribosome, revealing principles that shape co-translational folding and distinguish it from refolding in solution. Here, we highlight some of these recent findings from biochemical and biophysical studies and their potential significance for cellular protein biogenesis. In particular, we focus on nascent chain interactions with the ribosome, interactions within the nascent protein, modulation of translation elongation rates, and the role of mechanical force that accompanies nascent protein folding. The ability to obtain mechanistic insight in molecular detail has set the stage for exploring the intricate process of nascent protein folding. We believe that the aspects discussed here will be generally important for understanding how protein synthesis and folding are coupled and regulated.

Cotranslational Translocation and Folding of a Periplasmic Protein Domain in Escherichia coli

In Gram-negative bacteria, periplasmic domains in inner membrane proteins are cotranslationally translocated across the inner membrane through the SecYEG translocon. To what degree such domains also start to fold cotranslationally is generally difficult to determine using currently available methods. Here, we apply Force Profile Analysis (FPA) - a method where a translational arrest peptide is used to detect folding-induced forces acting on the nascent polypeptide - to follow the cotranslational translocation and folding of the large periplasmic domain of the E. coli inner membrane protease LepB in vivo. Membrane insertion of LepB's two N-terminal transmembrane helices is initiated when their respective N-terminal ends reach 45-50 residues away from the peptidyl transferase center (PTC) in the ribosome. The main folding transition in the periplasmic domain involves all but the ~15 most C-terminal residues of the protein and happens when the C-terminal end of the folded part is ~70 residues away from the PTC; a smaller putative folding intermediate is also detected. This implies that wildtype LepB folds post-translationally in vivo, and shows that FPA can be used to study both co- and post-translational protein folding in the periplasm.

A protein folding intermediate pulls its weight

Proteins must acquire and maintain a specific fold to execute their biochemical function(s). In solution, unfolded proteins typically find this native structure through a biased sampling of preferred intermediate conformations. However, the initial search for these structures begins during protein synthesis, and it is unclear how much interactions between the ribosome and nascent polypeptide skew folding pathways. In this issue, Jensen and colleagues use a ribosomal force-profiling assay to show that RNase H forms a similar folding intermediate on and off the ribosome. In conjunction with measurements of the rate of RNase H unfolding on and off the ribosome, their results show that ribosomal interactions have little impact on the folding pathway of RNase H. These findings suggest that the ribosome itself does not necessarily rewire protein folding reactions.

Interactions between nascent proteins and the ribosome surface inhibit co-translational folding

Most proteins begin to fold during biosynthesis on the ribosome. It has been suggested that interactions between the emerging polypeptide and the ribosome surface might allow the ribosome itself to modulate co-translational folding. Here we combine protein engineering and NMR spectroscopy to characterize a series of interactions between the ribosome surface and unfolded nascent chains of the immunoglobulin-like FLN5 filamin domain. The strongest interactions are found for a C-terminal segment that is essential for folding, and we demonstrate quantitative agreement between the strength of this interaction and the energetics of the co-translational folding process itself. Mutations in this region that reduce the extent of binding result in a shift in the co-translational folding equilibrium towards the native state. Our results therefore demonstrate that a competition between folding and binding provides a simple, dynamic mechanism for the modulation of co-translational folding by the ribosome.

Cotranslational folding of alkaline phosphatase in the periplasm of Escherichia coli

Cotranslational protein folding studies using Force Profile Analysis, a method where the SecM translational arrest peptide is used to detect folding-induced forces acting on the nascent polypeptide, have so far been limited mainly to small domains of cytosolic proteins that fold in close proximity to the translating ribosome. In this study, we investigate the cotranslational folding of the periplasmic, disulfide bond-containing Escherichia coli protein alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) in a wild-type strain background and a strain background devoid of the periplasmic thiol: disulfide interchange protein DsbA. We find that folding-induced forces can be transmitted via the nascent chain from the periplasm to the polypeptide transferase center in the ribosome, a distance of ~160 Å, and that PhoA appears to fold cotranslationally via at least two disulfide-stabilized folding intermediates. Thus, Force Profile Analysis can be used to study cotranslational folding of proteins in an extra-cytosolic compartment, like the periplasm.