Salivary cortisol as an indicator of stress in sheep (Ovis ovis)

Do cows with stereotypic tongue-rolling behaviour cope better with their environment?

Introduction

Stereotypic behaviours, especially oral stereotypic behaviours, are frequently expressed in farm animals. Tongue-rolling is the most common oral stereotypic behaviour in dairy cows (Bos taurus). If animals frequently display stereotypic behaviours, this is an indication of poor welfare. It has been suggested that animals express stereotypic behaviours as a way of coping with stress. As a result, animals with stereotypic behaviours may have lower levels of stress hormones than animals without stereotypic behaviours.

Methods

In this study, 916 Holstein cows in the first lactation were subjected to scan sampling behavioural observations 200 times for 10 days. All cows were assigned to either a stereotypic behaviours group (SB) or a control group (CON). The SB group was further subdivided into a tongue-rolling group (TR) and an other-stereotypic behaviours group (OS). The TR group was also split into an only tongue-rolling group (OTR) and a mixed tongue-rolling and other stereotypic behaviours group (TROS). Some cows in the TR group belonged to an extreme tongue-rolling group (ETR). Hair and saliva samples were collected from 601 cows to test cortisol concentrations and dairy herd improvement (DHI) data were collected from a total of 762 cows.

Results

There were no differences in hair or saliva cortisol concentrations between the groups (p>0.05), and the frequencies of tongue-rolling were not associated with cortisol concentrations (p>0.05). For DHI in cows, the milk protein percentage (p = 0.028), milk true protein percentage (p = 0.021) and milk crude protein percentage (p = 0.023) of cows in the ETR group were significantly lower than those in the CON group. For cows in ETR group, as the frequencies of tongue-rolling increased, the milk protein percentage (p = 0.034, r = 0.365), milk true protein percentage (p = 0.022, r = 0.393) and milk crude protein percentage (p = 0.035, r = 0.363) increased.

Discussion

We investigated the relationship between stereotypic behaviours and stress by using a non-invasive sampling method to minimise harm to the cows. We suggest that tongue-rolling may not be a way for cows to cope with stress, at least in terms of cortisol concentrations.

Conditions for assessing cortisol in sheep: the total form in blood v. the free form in saliva

Cortisol is often used as a stress indicator in animal behaviour research. Cortisol is commonly measured in plasma and can also be measured in saliva. Saliva contains only the free form of cortisol, which is biologically active, and saliva sampling is not invasive and may therefore be less stressful. Our study aims to guide the choice between the measurements of cortisol in plasma v. saliva depending on experimental conditions. We analysed the effect of the level of cortisol in plasma on the concentration of cortisol in saliva compared to plasma and the effect of saliva sampling v. jugular venepuncture on the cortisol response. In Experiment 1, blood and saliva were collected simultaneously under conditions in which the expected cortisol release in blood varied: in an undisturbed situation or after the isolation of lambs from their pens or the administration of exogenous ACTH (six animals per treatment). In Experiment 2, we subjected lambs to saliva sampling, venepuncture or neither of these for 8 days to evaluate how stressful the sampling method was and whether the animals habituated to it by comparing the responses between the first and last days (four animals per treatment). All animals were equipped with jugular catheters to allow regular blood sampling without disturbance. Samples were collected 15 min before any treatment was applied, then at various time points up to 135 min in Experiment 1 and 45 min in Experiment 2. In Experiment 1, we observed a strong correlation between salivary and plasma cortisol concentrations (r = 0.81, P < 0.001). The ratio between salivary and plasma cortisol concentrations was 0.106 on average. This ratio was higher and more variable when the cortisol concentration in plasma was below 55 nmol/l. In Experiment 2, venepuncture induced a larger cortisol response than saliva sampling or no intervention on day 1 (P < 0.02); this difference was not observed on day 8, suggesting that sheep habituated to venepuncture. We recommend the measurement of cortisol in saliva to avoid stressing animals. However, when the expected concentration in plasma is below 55 nmol/l, the cortisol in saliva will reflect only the free fraction of the cortisol, which may be a limitation if the focus of the experiment is on total cortisol. In addition, if cortisol is measured in plasma and blood is collected by venepuncture, we recommend that sheep be habituated to venepuncture, at least to the handling required for a venepuncture.

Evaluation of new biomarkers of stress in saliva of sheep

Some routine handling procedures can produce stress in farm animals, and an adequate control of these stressors is important to avoid the negative effects on animal health and production. The measurement of biomarkers in saliva can be a suitable tool for the evaluation and control of stress. In this report, lipase, butyrylcholinesterase (BChE), total esterase (TEA) and adenosine deaminase (ADA) activities in the saliva of sheep were evaluated as biomarkers of stress. For this purpose, they were measured after inducing stress by facing a dog (experiment 1) and shearing (experiment 2), and comparing them to other stress salivary biomarkers such as α-amylase (sAA) and cortisol, as well as heart rate (HR). Each analyte was measured at the basal time, and during and just after the end of the stressful stimulus, and at various times for the first hour after the period of stress induction. Values were compared with those obtained from a control group. Lipase was the only analyte that showed significant changes between the stress and the control group in both experiments. Although TEA and ADA increased after stress, no significant differences were seen compared with the control group. Lipase was correlated highly with sAA and HR, in experiment 1; and correlated moderately with cortisol and HR in experiment 2. Lipase showed the greatest percentage increase after the stressful stimuli and less overlap with the control group in the two experiments. From the results of this study it can be concluded that lipase, TEA, BChE and ADA are enzymes present in the saliva of sheep and that they can be measured by using simple and fast colorimetric methods. Further studies should be undertaken with regard to the possible application of lipase as a biomarker of stress in sheep.

Development of a Pain Scoring System for Use in Sheep Surgically Implanted with Ventricular Assist Devices

Purpose/Aim: In prey species, such as sheep, clinical signs of postoperative pain can manifest in subtle ways or may be concealed entirely. Previous publications describing pain assessment in ruminants focus on lameness and flock behavior, often in a farm environment. These indicators of pain may be difficult to assess in sheep housed in biomedical research settings. We have developed a novel pain scoring system for sheep undergoing thoracotomy for implantation of ventricular assist devices that are permanently housed in modified stanchions. Materials and Methods: The pain scoring system includes ruminant-specific behavioral signs of pain in addition to objective measurements that can be readily evaluated in a biomedical research setting. A numerical score is generated by the evaluator for each category. A decision tree is utilized to help guide further action following the generation of a cumulative score by the evaluator. A total score of 0-2 requires no intervention, 3-9 requires the consideration of additional analgesic administration, and a pain score ≥ 10 warrants the consideration of additional multimodal analgesia. Results: A novel pain scoring system and decision tree specifically designed for sheep undergoing thoracotomy in a biomedical research environment was developed and successfully utilized. Out of 102 postoperative pain scores measured, 86 scores were <2. There were 17/102 postoperative pain scores ≥3, which typically resulted in the administration of supplemental rescue analgesia in the immediate postoperative period. Conclusions: A novel pain scoring system was developed and utilized in a biomedical research environment for evaluating postoperative pain in sheep undergoing thoracotomy for implantation of a ventricular assist device. Further studies are necessary to validate the reliability of this novel pain scoring system.

Technical note: comparison of salivary and serum cortisol concentrations after adrenocorticotropic hormone challenge in ewes

An ACTH challenge was conducted to determine if salivary cortisol concentration reflects serum cortisol concentration in ewes. Twelve yearling ewes (64.0 +/- 1.2 kg) were administered ACTH (100 IU, intravenously) or saline. Serum and salivary samples were collected at 30-min intervals for 2 h before ACTH administration, at 15-min intervals for 2 h after treatment, and at 30-min intervals for an additional 3 h, and cortisol concentration was determined by RIA. Although ewes responded to ACTH and saline, cortisol concentration was greater (P < 0.001) in ACTH-treated ewes from 15 to 120 min and tended to be greater (P = 0.054) at 150 min after challenge in serum. In saliva, cortisol concentration was greater (P < 0.001) in ACTH-treated ewes from 30 to 120 min and tended to be greater (P = 0.092) at 15 min after challenge. No difference was observed between ACTH-treated ewes and controls for time to peak serum cortisol concentration (P = 0.126) and time to peak salivary cortisol concentration (P = 0.109), or between saliva and serum for time to peak cortisol concentration (P = 0.220) and return to baseline cortisol concentration (P = 0.341). The serum (P = 0.009) and salivary (P = 0.050) cortisol areas under the curve between 0 and 150 min were greater for ACTH-treated ewes than controls, and serum (P = 0.002) and salivary (P < 0.001) cortisol return to baseline concentration was longer for ACTH-treated ewes. The correlation coefficient between serum and salivary cortisol concentrations was 0.88 (P < 0.001). These data indicate that salivary cortisol concentration is closely related to serum cortisol concentration and that the former may represent a suitable noninvasive alternative to blood collection for measurement of cortisol in sheep.

Stress induces CRF release in the paraventricular nucleus, and both CRF and GABA release in the amygdala

In the hypothalamus, corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF) initiates the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis response to stress, resulting in the release of glucocorticoids, including cortisol. Extrahypothalamic CRF, particularly in the limbic system, also appears to play a role in the stress response. To further define brain CRF response to stress, immunosensor-based microdialysis probes were used to measure the extracellular levels of CRF in the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (PVN) and in the amygdala of sheep during a predator (dog) exposure stress. In addition, gamma amino butyric acid (GABA) was measured in the amygdala and cortisol was measured in venous blood. Exposure to the predator stress increased CRF in the PVN and both CRF and GABA in the amygdala. These were followed in time by a rise in venous cortisol. Application of a CRF antagonist to the amygdala, immediately prior to stress, had a small effect on the subsequent observed stress responses. This treatment, however, significantly reduced the responses to a repeat stress administered 2 days later, compared to nontreated animals. Application of a GABA antagonist to the amygdala prior to stress had no effect on the subsequent observed stress response but increased the response to the stress repeated 2 days later. Perfusion with 4-aminopyridine, a neuronal depolarising agent, into the PVN induced a release of CRF accompanied shortly thereafter by a small increase in CRF in the amygdala, and 5-10 min later by an increase in venous cortisol. Perfusion into the amygdala increased the levels of both CRF and GABA but had no effect on either PVN CRF or venous cortisol. These data support roles for both the PVN and amygdala in stress responsiveness. It suggests further that actions at the amygdala can strongly influence subsequent responsiveness to a further stress, mediated in part by both CRF and GABA actions.

Quantitative analysis of human salivary glucose by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry

A reference analytic methodology was developed for the determination of human salivary glucose concentration. The technique involves the glucose derivatization with acetic anhydride and subsequent analysis of glucose penta-acetylated by gas chromatography combined with mass spectrometry. Glucose concentration in the biological fluid depends on the physiological status of the donor.

Glucocorticoid feedback increases the sensitivity of the limbic system to stress

In the hypothalamus, corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) has a well-described role initiating the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis response to stress. Cortisol, released from the adrenal gland, exerts negative feedback on this axis. The role of extrahypothalamic CRH in stress responses is less well known. The purpose of this study was to measure the response of CRH in the amygdala to acute and repeated stress and to examine if cortisol had any effect on this response. Immunosensor-based microdialysis probes were used to measure CRH and cortisol in the amygdala and cortisol systemically in sheep exposed to a predator stress (a dog). Upon presentation of a dog, CRH increased in the amygdala of the sheep and then fell off. Cortisol levels rose both systemically and in the amygdala, and as they peaked, a second CRH response was observed. Repeated stress changed this response, with the magnitude of the first CRH peak decreasing while the second peak increased. Repeated stress also produced an exaggeration in both of the CRH peaks to presentation of a subsequent novel stress (a forelimb electric shock). Animals that had an escape route from the repeated dog stress did not show this exaggeration when faced subsequently with the novel stress. Administration of mifepristone, a glucocorticoid receptor antagonist, prior to the delivery of the repeat stress prevented subsequent changes in the CRH response. The data suggest that the amygdala shows a CRH response to presentation of a stressor acutely and repeatedly and that repeated stress can alter subsequent amygdala responsiveness to the same or a different stressor. This alteration appears dependent on circulatory glucocorticoids.

Rapid noninvasive measurement of hormones in transdermal exudate and saliva

Experiments were conducted in both sheep and humans to evaluate techniques for rapid sampling and measurement of testosterone, insulin, 17-beta estradiol, cortisol and glucose collected in saliva or transdermal exudate. Ultrasound and an electric current facilitated the latter collection. All but insulin were successfully measured in saliva, under resting conditions, and the measured hormones correlated best with blood levels 20-40 min prior to the saliva collection. With imposition of, and recovery from, an exercise stress, this correlation was weakened irrespective of considering the time lag between blood measures during this period and subsequent changes in saliva values. Provided an initial transdermal flux was established, all the hormones and glucose were successfully measured in the transdermal exudate at levels correlating with blood measures at the time of collection, and this held across stressor application and recovery. The transdermal exudate sampling and measurement apparatus is relatively portable, enabling noninvasive collection and analyte measurement, rapidly, at the site where the experiment is being conducted with minimal interference to subjects. This potentially offers a tool of considerable value to endocrine studies.

Patterns of weaning and adult response to stress

Early environmental effects including variation in maternal care, can modify hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis function. One of the more overt early effects, involving maternal care, is weaning restraint. In this study the effects of different patterns of weaning, in the rat (Rattus norvegicus), on both adult response to restraint stress and to dexamethasone administration were examined. Animals that as pups experienced a gradual lengthening time of separation from the mother, between 21 and 30 days of postnatal age (completely separated on 30 days), showed lower levels of systemic corticosterone and glutamate in the sensory cortex in response to restraint stress than seen in other groups. These animals also showed greater suppression of corticosterone by dexamethasone than did animals abruptly removed from the mother at 21 days of age. Animals left in the cage with the mother until either 30 or 40 days of age showed the greatest levels of corticosterone and glutamate in the sensory cortex in response to the stress and the least suppression by dexamethasone. These results suggest that changes in maternal contact at time of weaning can influence adult responsiveness to stress.

Maternal behaviour in sheep (Ovis aries) following administration of opioid agonists

AIMS

As kappa(kappa)-opioids have marked effects on pain threshold in sheep during oestrus, late pregnancy and after birth, a study was undertaken to determine if kappa -opioids also had other roles during these states.

METHODS

Opioid agonists (GR89696, DAMAGO) were administered into either the lateral hypothalamus (LH) or amygdala of non-pregnant sheep (n = 5) or pregnant sheep (n = 15) in late pregnancy (n = 5) within 12 h of birth (n = 5) or in the third week after birth (n = 5). Cortisol, behavioural and electrocardiographic responses to an auditory stimulus were assessed with and without drug administration, as was feed consumption and suckling events.

RESULTS

In non-pregnant sheep, DAMAGO injected into either the LH or amygdala had little effect on the response to the auditory stimulus but when injected into the LH did decrease food consumption. GR 89696 had no obvious effects. In late pregnancy, cortisol and heart rate responses to the auditory stimulus were significantly reduced compared to the non-pregnant animals irrespective of treatment. This was also the case in the third week after birth. Immediately post-partum cortisol responses were closer to that seen in the non-pregnant animal. In late pregnancy and both post-partum periods, GR 89696 in the LH significantly increased feed consumption while DAMAGO had no significant effects. GR 89696 injected into the amygdala reduced the behavioural response to the auditory stimulus in late pregnancy and both post-partum periods.

CONCLUSION

Changes in sensitivity to opioids occur in both the amygdala and LH with pregnancy and after birth. These may influence maternal behaviours and feed intake.

Real-time measurements of corticosteroids in conscious animals using an antibody-based electrode

An electrochemical immunosensor for real-time determination of corticosteroids, a group of steroidal hormones, is reported. The sensor measures competitive binding of endogenous corticosteroid and a corticosteroid-peroxidase conjugate with antibodies, immobilized on a platinum electrode, by monitoring of peroxidase activity. The electrode is encased within a dialysate membrane, which separates the electrode environment from the sampled fluid, allowing corticosteroid to equilibrate across the membrane. This permits measurements to be made in vivo. The small size of the probe (350 microns D) allows implantation into tissue or circulatory systems. The electrode was viable for 200 to 400 sequential measurements and at least 48 h in vivo. Detection sensitivity is 0.2 to 0.6 microgram/100 ml of cortisol or corticosterone. The results suggest the possibility of monitoring hormones in real-time within the blood or organ systems of conscious animals.

Real-time extracellular measurement of neurotransmitters in conscious sheep

Measurements of neurotransmitters in conscious animals have been restrictive in real-time. The use of specific enzymes within an amperometric probe, based upon a microdialysis membrane, may overcome some of these problems. I report the use of such a probe, with different perfusions of enzymes, to allow real-time measurement of glutamate, catecholamines and indoleamines, in conscious animals. At an adjacent site microdialysis sample collections were made concurrently and neurotransmitters measured in the dialysate. Both probes were positioned within the somatosensory cortex. Values obtained by amperometric probes were similar to those in dialysate samples for glutamate, catecholamines and indoleamines during basal and stimuli related collections. Amperometric measurements showed higher peak concentrations and better time resolution than dialysate sampling. This reflects sampling differences. Application of external stimuli increased extracellular concentrations of glutamate, catecholamines and indoleamines, in both forms of sampling. Dopamine measurements did not correlate well between the two forms of sampling. This may reflect the non-specificity of the enzyme (dopamine-beta-hydroxylase) used in the amperometric probe. This combination, of microdialysis and amperometry, offers a useful tool for real-time neurotransmitter studies in vivo.