Lack of correlation of human fibroblast radiosensitivity in vitro with early skin reactions in patients undergoing radiotherapy

Radiogenomics and radiotherapy response modeling

Advances in patient-specific information and biotechnology have contributed to a new era of computational medicine. Radiogenomics has emerged as a new field that investigates the role of genetics in treatment response to radiation therapy. Radiation oncology is currently attempting to embrace these recent advances and add to its rich history by maintaining its prominent role as a quantitative leader in oncologic response modeling. Here, we provide an overview of radiogenomics starting with genotyping, data aggregation, and application of different modeling approaches based on modifying traditional radiobiological methods or application of advanced machine learning techniques. We highlight the current status and potential for this new field to reshape the landscape of outcome modeling in radiotherapy and drive future advances in computational oncology.

In vitro prediction of breast cancer therapy toxicity

BACKGROUND

Understanding the basis of clinical radiosensitivity is a key goal of radiation research. In this study, we used the limiting dilution assay (LDA) to analyze in vitro radiosensitivity of cell lines from individuals with breast and other cancers, who had been treated with ionizing radiation, and who either had a non-radiosensitive (RS) radiation response or who were clinically RS.

METHODS

Lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) were created from 29 cancer patients including 19 RS patients, 10 controls who had not developed severe normal tissue reactions, and 1 ataxia telangiectasia RS control cell line. The clinically RS patients had grade 3 or grade 4 reactions; one had a grade 2 reaction. All cells were exposed to graded doses of gamma-radiation in vitro and cell survival assessed via LDA. Cell survival was expressed on non-linear regression analysis-fitted survival curves and also as the surviving fraction at 2 Gray (Gy) (SF₂).

RESULTS

Our LDA analysis yielded two notable positive results. Firstly, it could distinguish control cells from cells from pooled breast cancer cases with severe reactions of all types (acute reactors, consequential late reactors and late reactors). Secondly, two radiosensitivity outliers were detected on the fitted curves, corresponding clinically to grade 3 and 4 late radiation reactions in breast and head and neck cancer cases respectively. The assay showed considerable cell survival heterogeneity.

CONCLUSIONS

The LDA as used here may provide unique clinical utility in detecting potential RS breast cancer patients prior to radiotherapy (RT), a form of personalized medicine. The assay may be especially useful in situations where its results can be temporally available prior to therapy initiation (e.g., those patients not undergoing RT until some months after surgery, typically those having adjuvant chemotherapy prior to RT). Two LCLs from RS outliers could potentially yield insight into the cellular and/or genetic basis of radiosensitivity, for example by undertaking genomic analyses on these cell lines.

Quantification of patient-reported outcome measures of radiation-induced skin reactions for use in clinical trial design

PURPOSE

Skin toxicity is a common effect from radiotherapy, although difficult to predict on an individual basis, and there is little evidence-based management. This study aimed to quantify inter-patient variation in patient-reported outcome measures for radiation-induced skin reactions (RISR) to enable the determination of the number of patients required for adequate power in a comparative trial of RISR management strategies.

METHODS

The study included 154 patients scheduled to receive breast cancer radiotherapy. Patients filled in a weekly questionnaire during and up to 4 weeks following the end of radiotherapy scoring five aspects of their experience of RISR: skin redness, and bother from redness like itching, burning sensation and tenderness/pain.

RESULTS

Assessment of patients' reported experience of their RISR was shown to be feasible, with 91 % of patients returning at least two questionnaires. The mean score increase between weeks 1 and 4 was 25 points (p value <0.0001, 95 % CI 21-29), and the estimated standard deviation at 4 weeks was 18 (95 % CI 16-21).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients' assessment of their reaction was not predicted on the basis of treatment and patient-related characteristics. Based on the observed variance in scores at 4 weeks, we could calculate the sample size required for a comparative study of two RISR management policies would be 200 patients to have statistical power to detect a clinically significant difference in patient-rated scores of their skin reactions. A trial employing this tool would help provide an evidence base to guide policy in advising patients how to manage their RISR.

Radiation-induced CD8 T-lymphocyte Apoptosis as a Predictor of Breast Fibrosis After Radiotherapy: Results of the Prospective Multicenter French Trial

BACKGROUND

Monocentric cohorts suggested that radiation-induced CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis (RILA) can predict late toxicity after curative intent radiotherapy (RT). We assessed the role of RILA as a predictor of breast fibrosis (bf +) after adjuvant breast RT in a prospective multicenter trial.

METHODS

A total of 502 breast-cancer patients (pts) treated by conservative surgery and adjuvant RT were recruited at ten centers. RILA was assessed before RT by flow cytometry. Impact of RILA on bf + (primary endpoint) or relapse was assessed using a competing risk method. Receiver-operator characteristic (ROC) curve analyses were also performed in intention to treat. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT00893035 and final analyses are presented here.

FINDINGS

Four hundred and fifty-six pts (90.8%) were included in the final analysis. One hundred and eight pts (23.7%) received whole breast and node irradiation. A boost dose of 10-16 Gy was delivered in 449 pts (98.5%). Adjuvant hormonotherapy was administered to 349 pts (76.5%). With a median follow-up of 38.6 months, grade ≥ 2 bf + was observed in 64 pts (14%). A decreased incidence of grade ≥ 2 bf + was observed for increasing values of RILA (p = 0.012). No grade 3 bf + was observed for patients with RILA ≥ 12%. The area under the ROC curve was 0.62. For cut-off values of RILA ≥ 20% and < 12%, sensitivity and specificity were 80% and 34%, 56% and 67%, respectively. Negative predictive value for grade ≥ 2 bf + was equal to 91% for RILA ≥ 20% and positive predictive value was equal to 22% for RILA < 12% where the overall prevalence of grade ≥ 2 bf + was estimated at 14%. A significant decrease in the risk of grade ≥ 2 bf + was found if patients had no adjuvant hormonotherapy (sHR = 0.31, p = 0.007) and presented a RILA ≥ 12% (sHR = 0.45, p = 0.002).

INTERPRETATION

RILA significantly predicts the risk of breast fibrosis. This study validates the use of RILA as a rapid screening test before RT delivery and will change definitely our daily clinical practice in radiation oncology.

FUNDING

The French National Cancer Institute (INCa) through the "Program Hospitalier de Recherche Clinique (PHRC)".

Cerebral radiation necrosis: a review of the pathobiology, diagnosis and management considerations

Radiation therapy forms one of the building blocks of the multi-disciplinary management of patients with brain tumors. Improved survival following radiation therapy may come with a cost, including the potential complication of radiation necrosis. Radiation necrosis impacts the quality of life in cancer survivors, and it is essential to detect and effectively treat this entity as early as possible. Significant progress in neuro-radiology and molecular pathology facilitate more straightforward diagnosis and characterization of cerebral radiation necrosis. Several therapeutic interventions, both medical and surgical, may halt the progression of radiation necrosis and diminish or abrogate its clinical manifestations, but there are still no definitive guidelines to follow explicitly that guide treatment of radiation necrosis. We discuss the pathobiology, clinical features, diagnosis, available treatment modalities, and outcomes in the management of patients with intracranial radiation necrosis that follows radiation used to treat brain tumors.

In vivo versus in vitro individual radiosensitivity analysed in healthy donors and in prostate cancer patients with and without severe side effects after radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

A high cellular radiosensitivity may be connected with a risk for development of severe side effects after radiotherapy and indicate cancer susceptibility. Hence, a fast and robust in vitro test is desirable to identify radiosensitive individuals.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study included 25 prostate cancer patients with severe side effects (S) and 25 patients without severe side effects (0) after radiotherapy as well as 23 male healthy age-matched donors. Blood samples were exposed to 0.5 Gy or 1 Gy of γ-rays. The initial level of double-strand breaks (dsb) and repair kinetics measured by phosphorylation of histone H2A (γ-H2AX-assay), apoptosis (Annexin V-assay) and the induction of chromatid aberrations after irradiation in the G2-phase of the cell cycle (G2-assay) were analysed.

RESULTS

A significant higher chromatid aberration yield was found in lymphocytes from prostate cancer patients when compared to healthy donors. We found no significant differences between patients S and patients 0.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no obvious correlation between clinical and cellular radiosensitivity in lymphocytes of prostate cancer patients when all chosen in vitro assays are considered. Although 25% of the patients showed both severe side effects and increased radiation-induced chromosomal sensitivity, predictive value of G2-assay is doubtful.

Identification of SNPs associated with susceptibility for development of adverse reactions to radiotherapy

Although cancer treatment with radiation can produce high cure rates, adverse effects often result from radiotherapy. These toxicities are manifested as damage to normal tissues and organs in the radiation field. In recognition of the substantial variation in the intrinsic response of individuals to radiation, an effort began approximately 10 years ago to discover the genetic markers, primarily SNPs, which are associated with susceptibility for the development of these adverse responses to radiation therapy. The goal of this research is to identify the SNPs that could serve as the basis of an assay to predict which cancer patients are most likely to develop complications resulting from radiotherapy. This would permit personalization and optimization of the treatment plan for each cancer patient.

No correlation between radiosensitivity or double-strand break repair capacity of normal fibroblasts and acute normal tissue reaction after radiotherapy of breast cancer patients

The aim was to study the relationship between cellular radiosensitivity or double-strand break (dsb) repair capacity of skin fibroblasts and the extent of acute reaction after radiotherapy for breast cancer. The study was performed with 25 breast cancer patients submitted to the radiotherapy unit of the Egyptian National Cancer Institute after conserving surgery. Dermal fibroblasts, established from skin biopsies, were used to determine the cellular radiosensitivity via colony assay and the capacity of dsb repair by constant-field gel electrophoresis. Acute reactions were scored using the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) classification. The spectrum of acute reactions varied from grade 1 to 4, whereby most patients developed a grade 1 reaction after total doses ranging between 46 and 70 Gy. Skin fibroblasts showed a pronounced variation in both cellular radiosensitivity expressed as the mean inactivation dose (Dbar) (coefficient of variation, CV=25%) as well as in the number of residual dsb (CV=33%) with no significant correlation between these two endpoints (r2=0.20, p=0.14). Both parameters did not correlate with the extent of acute reaction of the respective patient. The data obtained indicate that the sensitivity of fibroblasts measured either by colony assay or by dsb repair capacity is not a major parameter determining the extent of acute reaction after radiotherapy of breast cancer patients.

Individual radiosensitivity measured with lymphocytes may predict the risk of acute reaction after radiotherapy

PURPOSE

We tested whether the chromosomal radiosensitivity of in vitro irradiated lymphocytes could be used to predict the risk of acute reactions after radiotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Two prospective studies were performed: study A with 51 patients included different tumor sites and study B included 87 breast cancer patients. Acute reaction was assessed using the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group score. In both studies, patients were treated with curative radiotherapy, and the mean tumor dose applied was 55 Gy (40-65) +/- boost with 11 Gy (6-31) in study A and 50.4 Gy +/- boost with 10 Gy in study B. Individual radiosensitivity was determined with lymphocytes irradiated in vitro with X-ray doses of either 3 or 6 Gy and scoring the number of chromosomal deletions.

RESULTS

Acute reactions displayed a typical spectrum with 57% in study A and 53% in study B showing an acute reaction of Grade 2-3. Individual radiosensitivity in both studies was characterized by a substantial variation and the fraction of patients with Grade 2-3 reaction was found to increase with increasing individual radiosensitivity measured at 6 Gy (study A, p = 0.238; study B, p = 0.023). For study B, this fraction increased with breast volume, and the impact of individual radiosensitivity on acute reaction was especially pronounced (p = 0.00025) for lower breast volume. No such clear association with acute reaction was observed when individual radiosensitivity was assessed at 3 Gy.

CONCLUSION

Individual radiosensitivity determined at 6 Gy seems to be a good predictor for risk of acute effects after curative radiotherapy.

Genetic predictors of adverse radiotherapy effects: the Gene-PARE project

PURPOSE

The development of adverse effects resulting from the radiotherapy of cancer limits the use of this treatment modality. The validation of a test capable of predicting which patients would be most likely to develop adverse responses to radiation treatment, based on the possession of specific genetic variants, would therefore be of value. The purpose of the Genetic Predictors of Adverse Radiotherapy Effects (Gene-PARE) project is to help achieve this goal.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A continuously expanding biorepository has been created consisting of frozen lymphocytes and DNA isolated from patients treated with radiotherapy. In conjunction with this biorepository, a database is maintained with detailed clinical information pertaining to diagnosis, treatment, and outcome. The DNA samples are screened using denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) and the Surveyor nuclease assay for variants in ATM, TGFB1, XRCC1, XRCC3, SOD2, and hHR21. It is anticipated that additional genes that control the biologic response to radiation will be screened in future work.

RESULTS

Evidence has been obtained that possession of variants in genes, the products of which play a role in radiation response, is predictive for the development of adverse effects after radiotherapy.

CONCLUSIONS

It is anticipated that the Gene-PARE project will yield information that will allow radiation oncologists to use genetic data to optimize treatment on an individual basis.

Expression and prognostic implications of apoptosis-related proteins in locally unresectable non-small cell lung cancers

BACKGROUND

Apoptosis related proteins in early staged NSCLC seem to have prognostic value. We studied the value of a combination of eight of those proteins in advanced NSCLC.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Bronchoscopically procured tumor biopsies of NSCLC patients were stained immunohistochemically and rated for expression of eight different cellular proteins. Patients were treated with 60 Gy radiotherapy with or without carboplatin as radiosensitizer.

RESULTS

Apoptotic proteins in tumors that showed positive staining were the highest for Bax (99%), Fas (92%), FasL (87%), Rb (87%), p21(WAF1) (73%), and p53 (70%), and the lowest for c-myc (58%) and Bcl-2 (58%). In the Cox regression analysis Bcl-2 positivity (RR = 0.61, 95% CI, 0.37-0.98, p = 0.04) was predictive for overall survival. Only Bcl-2 staining percentage (RR(10) (RR associated with an increase in stained cells of 10%) = 0.93, 95% CI, 0.89-0.99), p53 (RR(10) = 0.94, 95% CI, 0.89-0.99) and FasL (RR(10) = 0.92, 95% CI, 0.86-0.99) were predictive for a longer progression-free survival. No specific constellation of apoptotic proteins was associated with tumor response.

CONCLUSION

Bcl-2 expression in tumor tissue of patients with unresectable NSCLC predicts a better overall survival, while Bcl-2, p53, and FasL expressions predict for a longer progression-free survival.

CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis can predict radiation-induced late toxicity: a prospective study in 399 patients

PURPOSE

Predicting late effects in patients treated with radiation therapy by assessing in vitro radiation-induced CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis can be useful in individualizing treatment.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

In a prospective study, 399 curatively irradiated patients were tested using a rapid assay where fresh blood samples were in vitro irradiated with 8 Gy X-rays. Lymphocytes were collected and prepared for flow cytometric analysis. Apoptosis was assessed by associated condensation of DNA. The incidences of late toxicities were compared for CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptoses using receiver-operating characteristic curves and cumulative incidence.

RESULTS

No association was found between early toxicity and T-lymphocyte apoptosis. Grade 2 and 3 late toxicities were observed in 31% and 7% of patients, respectively. More radiation-induced T-lymphocyte apoptosis was significantly associated with less grade 2 and 3 late toxicity (Gray's test, P < 0.0001). CD8 (area under the curve = 0.83) was more sensitive and specific than CD4. No grade 3 late toxicity was observed for patients with CD4 and CD8 values greater than 15% and 24%, respectively. The 2-year cumulative incidence for grade 2 or 3 late toxicity was 70%, 32%, and 12% for patients with absolute change in CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis of < or =16, 16 to 24, and >24, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiation-induced T-lymphocyte apoptosis can significantly predict differences in late toxicity between individuals. It could be used as a rapid screen for hypersensitive patients to radiotherapy. In future dose escalation studies, patients could be selected using the apoptosis assay.

Comparison ofin vitroandin vivo / ratios for prostate cancer

Parallel in vitro and in vivo studies provide insight into the relationship between clinical response and intrinsic cellular radiosensitivity and may aid in the development of predictive assays. Compilations of radiosensitivity parameters from in vitro experiments can also be used to examine the potential effectiveness of alternative or new treatment plan designs until enough clinical data become available to directly estimate the requisite radiosensitivity parameters. In this work, survival data for six prostate cancer cell lines (ten datasets total) have been extracted from the literature and re-analysed using the linear-quadratic (LQ) survival model. The paired bootstrap technique for regression is used to compute 95% confidence intervals for the estimated radiosensitivity parameters. LQ radiosensitivity parameters derived from the in vitro data are then compared to radiosensitivity parameters derived from clinical data for prostate cancer. Estimates of alpha range from 0.09 to 0.35 Gy(-1) (all cell lines), and the alpha/beta ratio ranges from 1.09 to 6.29 Gy (all cell lines). Point estimates of the repair half-time (PPC-1, TSU-Pr1, PC-3 and DU-145 cell lines) range from 5.7 to 8.9 h (95% confidence interval from 0.26 h to 10.7 h). Differences in the radiosensitivity parameters determined from the data reported by different laboratories are as large as or larger than the differences in radiosensitivity parameters observed among the various prostate cell lines. The reported studies demonstrate that even seemingly small corrections for dose rate effects, such as those expected in high dose rate (HDR) experiments, can sometimes have a significant impact on estimates of alpha and alpha/beta. By neglecting dose rate effects in the analysis of HDR experiments, estimates of the alpha/beta, ratio may be too high by factors as large as 1.3 to 6.2. The half-time for repair derived from the in vitro experiments appears significantly larger (slower repair rate) than estimates derived from the clinical data. However, the prostate radiosensitivity parameters alpha and alpha/beta may be approximately the same in vitro and in vivo. Most of the in vitro data are consistent with an alpha/beta ratio for prostate cancer less than 3 or 4 Gy.

Molecular mechanisms of individual radiosensitivity studied in normal diploid human fibroblasts

The molecular mechanisms of individual radiosensitivity were studied in normal diploid human fibroblasts. For fibroblasts irradiated with X-rays in G1-phase the individual radiosensitivity was shown to be correlated with the extent of double-strand break (dsb) repair. The number of residual dsbs (including both non- and mis-rejoined dsbs) varied between 2 and 5% of the initial number induced and was low for resistant and high for sensitive strains. In the G1-phase dsbs are considered to be mostly repaired via the non-homologous end-joining pathway (NHEJ). However, so far none of the parameters tested for this pathway was found to be correlated with the number of residual dsbs. The parameters tested were mRNA expression, protein level and localisation and activity of the DNA-PK, which is the central complex of NHEJ. The dsb-repair capacity is also not regulated by the differentiation status, which varies substantially among fibroblast strains, whereas there is some indication that dsb repair might depend on the chromatin structure, with more efficient repair in cells with condensed DNA. Residual dsbs are converted into lethal chromosome aberrations finally leading to the loss of clonogenic activity, when cells pass through mitosis. Beside this so-called mitotic death, X-irradiated human fibroblasts are also inactivated via the TP53-dependent permanent G1-arrest, while apoptosis appears to be not important. On average, mitotic death and G1-arrest are equally effective, but there is a broad variation from one strain to the other, with a negative correlation between these two pathways. Fibroblast strains exhibiting only a moderate G1-arrest showed a high number of lethal aberrations and vice versa. This result points to a common regulator of both G1-arrest and dsb repair, which is presently under investigation.

Prediction of normal tissue response and individualization of doses in radiotherapy

In this work we estimate the therapeutic gain that could be obtained using a radiotherapy programme in which doses were based on a radiosensitivity test that was able to predict the final response of normal tissues to radiation for each particular patient. To date, no good radiosensitivity assay has been demonstrated and by way of example we use an assay based on initial DNA damage. The individualized programme we propose is based on an increase in the dose delivered to patients showing a resistant behaviour to radiation and on the adoption of alternative programmes or a careful monitoring of those patients in whom an excessive reaction is expected. To quantify the results produced by the individualization programme, both analytical and Monte Carlo simulation methods are used. The increase in tumour control probability obtained by means of this individualization strongly depends on the dose-response curve for the particular tumour. In certain cases, this enhancement can be marked, and 40% of the patients considered in this work could attain more than 10% increase in tumour control probability. The quantitative estimations in this study indicate the need to seek a predictive assay of radiosensitivity, for both normal and tumour tissue response, in order to develop individualized treatment protocols.

Lymphocyte radiosensitivity correlated with pelvic radiotherapy morbidity

PURPOSE

To test the hypothesis that, before treatment, prostate cancer patients who demonstrate a high yield of ex vivo radiation-induced micronucleus (MN) in G(0) lymphocytes represent a patient population with a greater-than-average risk of developing radiotherapy (RT)-related morbidity.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We prospectively conducted the cytokinesis-block MN assay of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) in 38 prostate cancer patients. Before the initiation of RT, PBLs from each patient were irradiated (1-4 Gy). The mean patient age +/- SEM was 68.7 +/- 1.0 years. The clinical stage was T1 in 17, T2 in 15, and T3 in 6. The preoperative prostate-specific antigen level was < or =4 ng/mL in 5, 4-10 ng/mL in 18, and >10 ng/mL in 15. All patients underwent standardized pelvic external beam radiotherapy (range 41.4-50.4 Gy) and boost (range 16-26 Gy). The mean follow-up +/- SEM was 32.8 +/- 4.6 months. At the end of follow-up, a radiation oncologist scored the GI or GU morbidity according to the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group criteria without knowledge of the MN data.

RESULTS

We found that between the average reactors (n = 25; i.e., patients who had Grade 1 or less RT-related morbidity) and over reactors (n = 13; i.e., patients who developed Grade 2 or greater RT-related morbidity), the differences in the ex vivo radiation dose-response relationship of MN yield in PBLs were highly significant, especially at doses of > or =2 Gy. Also, the development of RT-related morbidity correlated with the radiation dose-response relationship of MN yield in PBLs before treatment, but did not correlate with any of the patients' clinical variables.

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that the pre-RT ex vivo radiation dose-response relationship of MN yield in PBLs may be a significant predictive factor for the development of GI or GU morbidity in prostate cancer patients after pelvic RT.

Does skin fibroblast radiosensitivity predict squamous cancer cell radiosensitivity of the same individual?

Individualization of radiation doses is presumed to result in better radiotherapy outcome. Success rate in measuring radiosensitivity is probably the most limiting factor for present radiosensitivity assays to be introduced into clinical routine. To find a simpler predictive parameter, we compared the radiosensitivity of dermal fibroblasts and head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) cell lines established from the same individuals. The radiosensitivity was tested using the clonogenic 96-well plate assay. The surviving fraction at 2.0 Gy (SF2) was determined, as well as the mean inactivation dose (AUC) of cancer cells. SF2 of SCC cell lines and skin fibroblasts were 0.25-0.44 and 0.11-0.43, respectively. AUC of SCC cells was 1.4-2.1 Gy. Dermal fibroblasts were more radiosensitive than SCC cells in 14 of 15 cases. In 1 patient (UT-SCC-8), cancer cells were found to be more radiosensitive than corresponding dermal fibroblasts. There was a clear tendency to a correlation between radiosensitivities of these 2 cell types, but statistical significance was reached only when the data of UT-SCC-8 was excluded. In our material, the intrinsic radiosensitivity of head and neck SCC cells could in most cases be predicted from the intrinsic radiosensitivity of dermal fibroblasts established from the same individual.

Indicators of late normal tissue response after radiotherapy for head and neck cancer: fibroblasts, lymphocytes, genetics, DNA repair, and chromosome aberrations

PURPOSE

To investigate the relationship between late tissue response after radiotherapy, cellular sensitivity and DNA repair capacity measured in dermal fibroblasts and chromosomal aberrations measured in lymphocytes. The study was in particular designed to compare cellular parameters of patients with maximum differences in late tissue reactions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was performed with 16 pair-wise matched head and neck cancer patients 2-7 years after curative therapy exhibiting maximum differences (grade 1 vs. grade 3) in late normal tissue reactions. Clinical endpoints were fibrosis, telangiectasia, mucositis and xerostomia using the radiation therapy oncology group score. Patients with grade 3 reactions were tested for mutations in ataxia telangiectasia (AT), Nijmegen Breakage Syndrome (NBS), MRE11, RAD50 and DNA ligase IV genes by means of polymerase chain reaction-single-strand conformation polymorphism and sequencing analysis. Skin fibroblasts obtained from biopsies were used to determine the cellular sensitivity by colony formation and the induction and repair of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) using constant-field gel electrophoresis. Lymphocytes were taken to measure chromosomal damage either in metaphase using conventional chromosome analysis or in G(0) using premature chromosome condensation (PCC)-technique.

RESULTS

Patients with extreme late reactions (grade 3) showed no evidence for an AT, NBS, MRE11 or RAD50 mutation. Studies with fibroblasts revealed that extreme late reactions were associated neither with a pronounced cellular radiosensitivity nor with a difference in dsb repair capacity. In contrast, there was a significant difference in chromosomal damage measured in lymphocytes. After in vitro irradiation with 6Gy, lymphocytes taken from overreacting patients showed on average a significantly higher number of lethal aberrations than lymphocytes isolated from patients with mild reactions (7.2+/-0.8 vs. 5.0+/-0.3). Similar differences were found for PCC fragments.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that lymphocytes are more promising than fibroblasts to predict patient's normal tissue response after radiotherapy.

Chromosomal aberrations induced by chemotherapy and radiotherapy in lymphocytes from patients with breast carcinoma

PURPOSE

Stable chromosomal aberrations (SCAs) have been found in circulating lymphocytes from patients treated for breast carcinoma. Therefore, we tried to define their incidence in such patients, to determine an in vitro dose-effect relationship, and to correlate these data with clinical parameters.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This prospective study included 25 patients who, after surgery, underwent either radiotherapy (RT) alone (n = 15) or RT combined with chemotherapy (n = 10). SCAs were scored using the fluorescent in situ hybridization technique before RT and 4 and 12 months after RT. Dose-effect curves were established by in vitro irradiation of blood samples with 2 and 4 Gy, before and after treatment.

RESULTS

In all patients, the rate of SCAs increased significantly after external irradiation. No significant decrease in SCAs was observed during the first year after RT. RT and chemotherapy had no effect on the lymphocyte in vitro dose-effect relationship. No relationship was found in the distribution of patients between the yield of SCAs scored after external irradiation and after in vitro irradiation. SCAs after RT or in vitro irradiation did not correlate with family history of breast carcinoma or acute toxicity of treatment. More significantly, the yield of SCA after external irradiation was strongly related to the irradiation of the internal mammary chain and the supraclavicular lymph node area, suggesting that the volume of irradiated blood vessels was an essential parameter in determining the rate of SCAs.

CONCLUSION

A high and stable yield of SCAs persisted at least 1 year after external irradiation. The nature of the volume irradiated containing large blood vessels was the major determinant of the observed biologic dose.

Studies on radiosensitivity from an epidemiological point of view - overview of methods and results

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The establishment of a predictive in vitro assay for radiosensitivity has been a goal in radiotherapy research. To date, no single assay has proven to be effective for this purpose. A review of the epidemiologic methods used in the studies has been undertaken to evaluate limitations associated with specific design options and to develop recommendations for future research.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We focused on studies attempting to establish the usefulness of an assay in breast cancer patients undergoing radiotherapy using skin reactions as indicators for radiosensitivity. The 25 published studies included were evaluated with respect to criteria for good epidemiological studies: (a) study design, (b) study population, (c) assessment of radiation reaction, and (d) treatment of confounding factors.

RESULTS

Limitations in study design were often found among the studies reviewed. Possible sources of bias are, among others, misclassification due to non-standardized assessment of side effects, selection bias due to drawing convenience patient groups instead of representative patient groups, and confounding due to analysis not adjusted for important factors influencing the severity of side effects.

CONCLUSIONS

Further studies should make use of good epidemiological practice so that valid conclusions can be drawn with respect to the usefulness of an in vitro assay to distinguish between patients with different degrees of radiosensitivity in clinical practice.

Series model volume effects in a population of non-identical patients: how low is low?

Working with several mechanisms of critical local tissue damage, formulae are analytically derived that describe normal tissue complication probabilities (ntcps) for series-type radiotherapy complications arising in heterogeneous patient populations. Using the formulae, values are calculated for deltaD50(10)-the increase in dose leading to a 50% series-type complication rate (D50) when irradiated organ volume is reduced tenfold. From the structure of the ntcp formulae derived, it follows that dose-levels leading to clinically relevant serious complication rates (less than 5%) will change less with irradiated volume than will D50. Calculated values of deltaD50(10) for the heterogeneous series model are low-generally less than 6 Gy; such values are much lower than those calculated for the non-heterogeneous series model (27-37 Gy). These results suggest that if the dose-limiting toxicity of a radiotherapy treatment is a series-type complication with a local damage mechanism similar to any of those studied in this work, then even very substantial improvements in technique-leading to large reductions in highly dosed normal tissue volumes-would be unlikely to allow a useful degree of escalation of the dose delivered to the tumour, unless highly dosed normal tissue volumes can be reduced below the length-scale of a functional subunit.

Impact of dose-distribution uncertainties on rectal ntcp modeling. II: Uncertainty implications

A trial of nonescalated conformal versus conventional radiotherapy treatment of prostate cancer has been carried out at the Royal Marsden NHS Trust (RMH) and Institute of Cancer Research (ICR), demonstrating a significant reduction in the rate of rectal bleeding reported for patients treated using the conformal technique. The rate of bleeding has been shown to fall significantly as the extent of rectal wall receiving a planned dose-level in excess of 57 Gy is reduced. Dose-distributions delivered to the rectal wall over the course of radiotherapy treatment inevitably differ from planned distributions. In a previous paper estimates were obtained of the uncertainties in some planned rectal dose-distribution parameters generated by patient setup error, rectal wall movement and the variable degree of rectal wall distension. Here these uncertainties are combined to obtain estimates of the total planning uncertainties in rectal dose-distribution parameters thought likely, on the basis of mechanistic biological modeling, to correlate strongly with the complication rate. Working from these totaled uncertainty values, together with values of patient-to-patient and technique-to-technique differences in planned dose-distribution parameters, it can be inferred that the rectal dose-distribution uncertainties: (i) Have only a marginal impact on fits of a normal tissue complication probability (ntcp) model to RMH/ICR dose-distribution and grade 1, 2, 3 bleeding data (slightly flattening observed volume-response curves); (ii) only slightly reduce the power of a 2 x 100 patient trial of conformal versus conventional prostate radiotherapy to detect a significantly lower rate of grade 1,2,3 rectal bleeding amongst conformally treated patients; (iii) do not diminish the information content of individual planned patient dose-distribution data to the point where the fitting of technique-averaged data would provide as sensitive a test of the existence of a volume effect as the fitting of individual patient data.

[Radiation-induced superficial fibrosis and TGF-alpha 1]

Radiation-induced fibrosis is a late sequela of both therapeutic and accidental irradiations, which has been described in various tissues, including the lung, liver, kidney and skin. This review presents different aspects of superficial radiation-induced fibrosis, such as clinical observations, histological changes, cellular and molecular regulations, and medical management. Recent evidence on the critical role played by TGF-beta 1 in the initiation, development and persistence of fibrosis are discussed, as well as the possibility that this cytokine may constitute a specific target for antifibrotic agents.

Relationship between in vitro chromosomal radiosensitivity of peripheral blood lymphocytes and the expression of normal tissue damage following radiotherapy for breast cancer

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

There is a need for rapid and reliable tests for the prediction of normal tissue responses to radiotherapy, as this could lead to individualization of patient radiotherapy schedules and thus improvements in the therapeutic ratio. Because the use of cultured fibroblasts is too slow to be practicable in a clinical setting, we evaluated the predictive role of assays of lymphocyte chromosomal radiosensitivity in patients having radiotherapy for breast cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Radiosensitivity was assessed using a micronucleus (MN) assay at high dose rate (HDR) and low dose rate (LDR) on lymphocytes irradiated in the G(0) phase of the cell cycle (Scott D, Barber JB, Levine EL, Burril W, Roberts SA. Radiation-induced micronucleus induction in lymphocytes identifies a frequency of radiosensitive cases among breast cancer patients: a test for predispostion? Br. J. Cancer 1998;77;614-620) and an assay of G(2) phase chromatid radiosensitivity ('G(2) assay') (Scott D, Spreadborough A, Levine E, Roberts SA. Genetic predisposition in breast cancer. Lancet 1994; 344: 1444). In a study of acute reactions, blood samples were taken from breast cancer patients before the start of radiotherapy, and the skin reaction documented. 116 patients were tested with the HDR MN assay, 73 with the LDR MN assay and 123 with the G(2) assay. In a study of late reactions, samples were taken from a series of breast cancer patients 8-14 years after radiotherapy and the patients assessed for the severity of late effects according to the'LENT SOMA' scales. 47 were tested with the HDR assay, 26 with the LDR assay and 19 with the G(2) assay. For each clinical endpoint, patients were classified as being normal reactors or 'highly radiosensitive patients' (HR patients (Burnet NG. Johansen J, Turesson I, Nyman J. Describing patients' normal tissue reactions: Concerning the possiblity of individualising radiotherapy dose presciptions based on potential predictive assays of normal tissue radiosensitivity. Int. J. Cancer 1998;79:606-613)).

RESULTS

The HR patients could be identified in some of the assays. For example, for acute skin reactions, 9/123 patients were judged as HR; they had significantly higher G(2) scores than normal reactors (P=0.004). For the late reactions, the mean HDR MN scores were higher for the 4/47 patients who had severe telangiectasia (P=0.042) and the 8/47 patients had severe fibrosis (P=0.055). However, there were no trends towards increased chromosomal radiosensitivity with the micronucleus scores at HDR or LDR, or with G(2) chromosomal radiosensitivity.

CONCLUSIONS

While these results support the concept of using lymphocytes to detect elevated sensitivity to radiotherapy (as an alternative to fibroblasts), these assays are unlikely to be of assistance for the prediction of normal tissue effects in the clinic in their present form.

Relationship between DNA double-strand breaks, cell killing, and fibrosis studied in confluent skin fibroblasts derived from breast cancer patients

PURPOSE

To investigate the relationship between DNA double-strand breaks (dsbs), cell killing, and fibrosis using skin fibroblasts derived from breast cancer patients who received postmastectomy radiotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Experiments were performed with 12 lines of normal skin fibroblasts derived from recurrence-free breast cancer patients. Cells were irradiated in confluence and cell survival was determined either after immediate or delayed (14 h) plating using a colony-forming assay. Dsbs were measured by constant-field gel electrophoresis. The "excess risk of fibrosis" was previously scored by Johansen et al. (IJRB 1994;66:407-412).

RESULTS

The 12 cell lines showed a typical spectrum of radiosensitivity. The mean value of surviving fraction after 3.5 Gy (SF3.5) was 0.063 for immediate and 0.174 for delayed plating with a coefficient of variation (CV) of 44 and 39%, respectively. There was also a broad variation in the extent of recovery from potentially lethal damage (RPLD), which was not correlated with the immediate sensitivity. The number of initial dsbs as well as the half-times of dsb repair showed little variation, whereas there were considerable differences in the number of residual dsbs (CV = 29%). The number of residual dsbs after 100 Gy was correlated significantly only with SF3.5 after delayed (r2 = O.59; p = 0.006) but not after immediate plating (r2 = 0.21, p = 0.16). There was also no significant relationship between residual dsbs and the "excess risk of fibrosis" determined for the respective patients.

CONCLUSION

It is shown that the number of residual dsbs measured in confluent human fibroblast lines can be used to predict the cellular radiosensitivity after delayed but not after immediate plating and also not to predict the excess risk of fibrosis of the respective breast cancer patients.

Correlation between normal tissue complications and in vitro radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts derived from radiotherapy patients treated for variety of tumors

PURPOSE

To assess the relationship between fibroblast intrinsic radiosensitivity in vitro and late reactions of normal tissues in patients treated by definitive radiotherapy for variety of tumors.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Ten patients were selected for this study. They were treated by radical radiotherapy for variety of tumors, including non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, prostate, glottic larynx, anal canal, cervix, bladder, thyroid gland, and tonsil pillar. Five patients did not develop any significant late reactions (normally sensitive group, NS). The other five developed late complications in different normal tissues and organs that proved to be fatal in one patient (clinically hyper-sensitive group, HS). Fibroblast cultures were established from punch skin biopsy and radiosensitivity in vitro was measured. The survival fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) was calculated and compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

SF2 ranged between 0.10 and 0.38 with a mean of 0.24. The mean SF2 for each of the NS and the HS groups were 0.31 and 0.17, respectively. The non-parametric rank test of Mann-Whitney shows that the difference between the two groups is statistically significant (p = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

This study indicates that the in vitro radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts is correlated with late complications in different organs and normal tissues following radiotherapy for variety of tumors. It also lends support to the existence of a common genetic component determining the radiosensitivity of cells targeted by the late effects of ionizing radiation.

Acute and late toxicity, tumour control and intrinsic radiosensitivity of primary fibroblasts in vitro of patients with advanced head and neck cancer after concomitant boost radiochemotherapy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The existence of hereditary factors influencing the cellular response to ionising radiation has led to the hypothesis that the inter-patient variability of clinical radiation reactions may, at least in part, be attributable to an individual, or intrinsic, radiosensitivity. Considerable effort has been spent in the development of test systems that would determine individual radiosensitivity before or early during radiotherapy to possibly predict treatment outcome, but the results are still conflicting. The present explorative study was therefore aimed at the detection of associations between acute and late radiation effects, tumour control and in vitro radiosensitivity of primary normal tissue fibroblasts.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Sixty-eight patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (93% UICC stage IV) were treated with a simultaneous concomitant boost radiochemotherapy with Carboplatin as part of a prospective non-randomised multicenter study at the University of Heidelberg. Primary fibroblasts were obtained from skin biopsies prior to treatment from 25 unselected patients of this study and the SF2 was determined using the colony forming assay and high dose-rate irradiation. The median follow-up was 21 months (range 2.5-81 months).

RESULTS

The locoregional control rate at three years was 32%. No significant association between acute (mucosa reaction grade 1 or 2 vs. grade 3 and 4), late radiation effects (subcutaneous fibrosis, osteonecrosis, larynx oedema), locoregional tumour control and SF2 of primary fibroblasts was found using Cox proportional hazards regression analysis, log-rank test and Mann-Whitney U-test. Although a steep dose-response relationship was observed for the radiation-induced severe larynx oedema, Cox proportional hazards regression analysis could not fully explain the occurrence of severe radiation-induced larynx oedema with the dose to the larynx (P = 0.09). In the subgroup of twenty-five patients, where the SF2 was determined, bivariate analysis revealed about the same non-significant influence of the dose to the larynx on the larynx oedema (P = 0.1) and no influence of the SF2 (P = 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

In our study of patients with advanced cancer of the head and neck, neither the normal fibroblast SF2 nor the severity of acute radiation effects were able to predict late radiation effects or locoregional tumour control.

Analysis by alkaline comet assay of cancer patients with severe reactions to radiotherapy: defective rejoining of radioinduced DNA strand breaks in lymphocytes of breast cancer patients

Therapeutic exposure to ionising radiation reveals inter-individual variations in normal tissue responses. To examine whether a defect in DNA repair capacity might be involved in such hypersensitive phenotypes, we analysed, using the alkaline comet assay, the response as a function of time to in vitro irradiation at 5 Gy of lymphocytes from 17 breast cancer and 9 Hodgkin's disease patients who developed severe reactions to radiotherapy in comparison with 22 patients with "average" reactions and 24 healthy donors. A difference between breast cancer over-reactors and both patients with normal reactions and healthy donors was observed 30 and 60 min after exposure. A subgroup of breast cancer over-reactors (7/17) reproducibly demonstrated increased levels of residual damage. When the kinetic analyses were prolonged to 120 min, results were in favour of delayed kinetics of rejoining in these patients. Among Hodgkin's disease over-reactors, only one patient showed defective repair. Interestingly, all patients with the most severe complications (grade 4 RTOG/EORTC), i.e., 5 breast cancer and 1 Hodgkin's disease, showed impaired rejoining. Our results suggest that impairment in DNA strand break processing may be associated, in specific subgroups of breast cancer patients, with an individual risk of major toxicity of radiation therapy. Thus, the alkaline comet assay appears to be useful for documenting the DNA repair phenotype in cancer patients.

[In vitro radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts can identify a group of patients with complications in various health tissues after radiotherapy]

PURPOSE

A retrospective study of the in vitro radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts derived from two groups of patients treated by definitive radiotherapy for a variety of tumors who either displayed or did not display severe complications.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seven radiotherapy patients were selected: three were treated for head and neck, prostate and non-Hodgkin lymphoma tumors, and did not develop any significant complications (control group); four patients were treated for bladder, thyroid, head and neck and anal canal tumors and developed serious acute and especially late reactions (hypersensitive group). Primary cell cultures of skin fibroblasts were established and their radiosensitivity studied by the clonogenic assay after exposing to single radiation doses ranging between 1 and 8 Gy.

RESULTS

The survival fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) ranged from 0.27 to 0.38, with a mean of 0.33 for the control group, and from 0.10 to 0.20 with a mean of 0.17 for the hypersensitive group. The Mann-Whitney non-parametric test showed that the difference between the two means was statistically significant (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

The data are in favor of a correlation between the radiosensitivity of patients' fibroblasts and the reactions of different normal tissues to radiotherapy. This association supports the use of the clonogenic survival, or a surrogate test, as a predictive assay. The multiplicity of normal tissues and organs implicated in this association suggests the existence of genetic factors that determine, at least in part, the radiosensitivity of target cells involved in the expression of normal tissues complications following radiotherapy.

Cellular responses to radiation and risk of breast cancer

Mutations in the ataxia telangiectasia gene (ATM) result in an abnormal p53-mediated cellular response to DNA damage produced by ionising radiation. This deficiency is believed to contribute to the radiosensitivity and high cancer risk seen in ataxia telangiectasia (AT) patients and AT heterozygotes. Epidemiological studies have demonstrated that relatives of AT patients are particularly predisposed to breast cancer. This observation, together with the finding that a relatively high proportion of breast cancer patients display an abnormal severe reaction of normal tissues following radiotherapy, has led to the suggestion that AT heterozygosity plays a role in radiosensitivity and breast cancer development. The cloning of the ATM gene has allowed this possibility to be examined at the molecular level. The studies reported to date remain inconclusive, with the number of AT heterozygotes being found in radiosensitive breast cancer patients being less than would be expected based on the family studies. The potential role of several other recently identified genes which are involved in the cellular DNA damage response to ionising radiation and which could also play a role in radiosensitivity and breast cancer development are reviewed.

Characterization and radiosensitivity of fibroblasts derived from squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck, and the surrounding oral mucosa

Recently, extensive stromal fibroblast contamination has been reported in the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay for cellular in vitro radiosensitivity in tumour biopsies. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the hypothesis that an immunocytochemical analysis added to the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay provides a measure of both fibroblast and tumour cell radiosensitivity. Therefore, fibroblasts derived from squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck, and from the surrounding oral mucosa were compared for immunocytochemistry, DNA ploidy, plating efficiency and surviving fraction of cells after a radiation dose of 2 Gy. The results of our study suggest that the stromal fibroblasts derived from tumour biopsies are representative of normal fibroblasts with respect to the characteristics examined using mucosal fibroblasts as normal controls.

Comparison of high dose rate, low dose rate, and high dose rate fractionated radiation for optimizing differences in radiosensitivities in vitro

Radiotherapy is administered with the assumption that all patients respond similarly to radiation although radiosensitivity does vary from patient to patient, resulting in different degrees of early and late effects. Because the dose given to a patient is limited by the response of normal tissue in the treatment field, it would be beneficial to determine the sensitivity of this normal tissue prior to therapy. Previous studies to predict radiosensitivity have used surviving fractions after a single dose given in vitro, however, differences in cell survival at this low level of kill are not easy to resolve. In this study, we set out to evaluate the use of alternative dose regimens which may better resolve differences in radiosensitivity. We have examined several radiation protocols for predictive value, including survival after high doses (6 Gy) at both high (112 cGy/min) and low (.882 cGy/min) dose rates and after fractionated doses of 2 Gy (6 fractions). A sensitive human fibroblast line (S11358) cultured from a patient showing severe effects after therapy is compared with a cell line (OMB1) cultured from an apparently normal subject. Differences between these cell lines have been compared with those between two human melanoma cell lines (SKMEL3 and HT144) which have shown resistant and sensitive response to radiation in vitro respectively. In both fibroblast and melanoma cell lines, the difference in the survival of normal and sensitive cells increased with increasing dose regardless of whether irradiation was delivered as low dose rate, high dose rate, or as fractionated doses. We propose that radiation doses which more closely mimic clinical treatment are more suitable than surviving fraction after 2 Gy (SF2) for in vitro evaluation of relative radiosensitivities of cell populations.

Chromosomal in-vitro radiosensitivity of lymphocytes in radiotherapy patients and AT-homozygotes

BACKGROUND

We investigated the in-vitro radiosensitivity of peripheral blood lymphocytes with a special FISH/CISS-technique.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From October 1993 through April 1996, a total number of 52 cancer patients was enrolled in the study. The tumor sites in these patients were: breast (n = 41), lung (n = 4), head and neck (n = 3) as well as prostate, bladder, rectal cancer and Hodgkin's disease (each n = 1). Twenty-six of them were examined prior to planned radiotherapy (prospective group) and 26 after radiotherapy (retrospective group). Three additional individuals (without cancer or radiotherapy) with proven ataxia telangiectasia (Louis-Bar syndrome, AT-homozygotes) were also investigated and their blood samples served as positive control for radiosensitivity. The clinical radiation response of normal tissue in radiotherapy patients was scored according to the WHO grading system for acute and according to the RTOG grading system for late effects. For to estimate the intrinsic radiosensitivity, blood samples were taken and irradiated in vitro with 0 (control) or 0.7 or 2 Gy with a 6 MV-linear accelerator, standard 48-hour lymphocyte cultures were prepared, chromosomes #1, #2 and #4 were simultaneously labeled with a FISH/CISS-technique and 200 to 1,000 metaphase spreads were scored for chromosomal aberrations. The radiation sensitivity of lymphocytes was expressed as the number of radiation-induced chromosomal breaks per mitosis after 0.7 Gy or 2 Gy corrected for the 0-Gy control value.

RESULTS

The frequency of chromosomal breaks/mitosis in the unirradiated control lymphocytes was 0.020 +/- 0.015 in prospective patients who had not yet received radiotherapy. It was significantly higher in retrospective patients (0.264 +/- 0.164 breaks/mitosis) as a result of the previous radiation exposure. The 3 AT-homozygotes showed also an increased number of spontaneous chromosomal breaks (0.084 +/- 0.016 breaks/mitosis), probably resulting from the chromosomal instability in this disease. This figure, however, was significantly lower than in retrospective patients. The number of radiation-induced breaks after in-vitro irradiation was comparable in lymphocytes of patients who showed no normal tissue reaction (n = 11) as compared to those with mild to moderate radiation reaction (n = 32, acute reactions Grade 1 to 2, late reactions Grade 0 to 2). In 9 patients with unexpected severe plus late Grade 3 to 4 reactions, however, a significantly higher number of radiation-induced chromosomal breaks was measured; the highest number was observed in a patient with a radiation myelitis. The 3 AT-homozygotes showed, as expected, an extreme radiosensitivity of their lymphocytes. The number of breaks/mitosis after 0.7 Gy in vitro irradiation of lymphocytes was 0.103 +/- 0.059 in patients with no normal tissue radiation reaction (n = 11), 0.122 +/- 0.146 in the group with mild to moderate radiation reactions Grade 1 to 2 (n = 32), 0.359 + 0.226 in patients with unexpected Grade 3 to 4 normal tissue reactions (n = 9) and 0.550 +/- 0.243 in the 3 AT-homozygotes (p < 0.01, t-test). The difference in lymphocyte radiosensitivity between these 4 groups was also detected after in-vitro irradiation with 2 Gy (0.484 +/- 0.132 vs. 0.535 +/- 0.228 vs. 0.926 +/- 0.349 vs. 1.423 +/- 0.072).

CONCLUSIONS

We found a significantly higher number of chromosomal breaks in lymphocytes of patients with severe or extreme radiation reaction of normal tissues as compared to patients with no or only mild to moderate radiation reactions. The radiosensitivity of lymphocytes in these radiosensitive patients was in the range between normal radiosensitivity and the radiosensitivity of AT-homozygotes. Detection of patients with severely enhanced intrinsic radiosensitivity might be possible with this method.

DNA damage and prediction of radiation response in lymphocytes and epidermal skin human cells

The success of radiotherapy in eradicating tumours depends on the total radiation dose, but what limits this dose is the tolerance of the normal tissues within the treatment volume. Studies involving fibroblast survival have demonstrated the theoretical feasibility of a predictive assay of radiation sensitivity, but such an assay is still far from clinical application. Using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), we have quantified the initial "apparent" number of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) induced by the radiation as an alternative measure of sensitivity in 2 different normal cell types from the same patients, epidermal skin cells and lymphocytes. We found significant inter-individual variation in the measured dsb (1-5 dsb/Gy/DNA unit). We also found a linear correlation between molecular damage in lymphocytes and skin samples from the same patient (slope = 0.83; r = 0.694; p = 0.0001). These results suggest that the initial number of dsb could be used as an indicator of the in vivo response to radiation.

No predictive value of the micronucleus assay for patients with severe acute reaction of normal tissue after radiotherapy

In approximately 5% of cancer patients undergoing radiotherapy, this treatment has to be interrupted because of an acute reaction of normal tissues. To test the possibility of predicting this type of reaction, the micronucleus assay was used to determine radiosensitivities of peripheral blood lymphocytes of 15 patients with severe acute reaction of normal tissue, 15 patients without this reaction and 15 healthy donors. Whole-blood cultures were irradiated with X-rays (4 Gy, 1.08 Gy/min) and treated with cytochalasin B. The micronuclei scores observed in irradiated cells were corrected for the scores in unirradiated cells. Intra-individual and interindividual variations in micronuclei scores were analysed in samples from healthy donors, and highly significant interindividual differences were found (P < 0.001). Scores of cells not irradiated in vitro were higher for cancer patients before radiotherapy than for healthy donors (P < 0.001), and those for cancer patients after radiotherapy were higher than for patients before radiotherapy (P < 0.001). Average micronuclei scores induced by in vitro irradiation were significantly higher in samples from cancer patients compared with those from healthy donors (P < 0.01). Moreover, all subgroups of cancer patients included individuals with very high levels of micronuclei after in vitro irradiation. There was, however, no relationship between the micronuclei scores and the occurrence of severe acute reactions in normal tissues.

[Genetic predisposition and radiation sensitivity of tumors]

BACKGROUND

Studies on normal tissue radiation sensitivity have demonstrated profound differences of individual sensitivities. A number of genetic syndromes associated with abnormal radiation sensitivity have been described. Significant differences have also been detected in persons without known genetic disorders. The question arises as to whether tumors originating from normal tissues with abnormal radiation sensitivity share this abnormal sensitivity and as to whether a general correlation between normal tissue sensitivity and tumor tissue sensitivity can be substantiated.

METHODS

Experimental and clinical data derived from own investigations and an extensive review of the literature was used to answer the question.

RESULTS

Experimental studies on normal and tumor tissues of SCID-and C3H-mice demonstrated that the 2.7-fold enhanced radiation sensitivity of SCID normal tissues is also found in SCID tumors. Clinical investigations on cervical carcinoma and breast cancer patients revealed higher local control rates in patients with more pronounced acute side effects. A weak trend towards the same relationship was found in head and neck cancer patients. Case reports on unusually severe acute radiation side effects or unexpected tumor remissions as well as few reports on radiotherapy in ataxia telangiectasia (AT) patients suggest a correlation between normal- and tumor-tissue radiation sensitivity. Studies on fibroblasts and tumor cells from the same patient support this hypothesis in soft tissue sarcoma patients, but do not so for head and neck cancer patients. Tumor cells exhibit a considerably higher variation of radiation sensitivities than normal tissue cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Experimental and clinical data are compatible with the hypothesis that normal tissue radiation sensitivity predicts for tumor tissue sensitivity. However, in view of the larger heterogeneity of tumor cell radiation sensitivity as compared to normal tissue radiation sensitivity, the development of a clinically useful predictive test for tumor sensitivity based on normal cell sensitivity appears to be unrealistic.

Response of human hair cortical cells to fractionated radiotherapy

Hair cortical cell counting (HCCC) represents a non-invasive, in-vivo measure of cell kill in the human integument. Sixty-six patients undergoing conventionally fractionated, external beam radiotherapy for early stage carcinoma of the prostate had groin hair samples counted. This technique is a sensitive and reproducible measure of radiation effect and may have applicability as an in-vivo prediction tool or in the field of biological dosimetry. A repopulative follicular response occurring at 3-4 weeks may explain flattening of the dose response curve.

Potential clinical impact of normal-tissue intrinsic radiosensitivity testing

A critical appraisal is given of the possible benefit from a reliable pre-treatment knowledge of individual normal-tissue sensitivity to radiotherapy. The considerations are in part, but not exclusively, based on the recent experience with in vitro colony-forming assays of the surviving fraction at 2 Gy, the SF2. Three strategies are reviewed: (1) to screen for rare cases with extreme radiosensitivity, so-called over-reactors, and treat these with reduced total dose, (2) to identify the sensitive tail of the distribution of 'normal' radiosensitivities, refer these patients to other treatment, and to escalate the dose to the remaining patients, or (3) to individualize dose prescriptions based on individual radiosensitivity, i.e. treating to isoeffect rather than to a specific dose-fractionation schedule. It is shown that these strategies will have a small, if any, impact on routine radiotherapy. Screening for over-reactors is hampered by the low prevalence of these among otherwise un-selected patients that leads to a low positive predictive value of in vitro radiosensitivity assays. It is argued, that this problem may persist even if the noise on current assays could be reduced to (the unrealistic value of) zero, simply because of the large biological variation in SF2. Removing the sensitive tail of the patient population, will only have a minor effect on the dose that could be delivered to the remaining patients, because of the sigmoid shape of empirical dose-response relationships. Finally, individualizing dose prescriptions based exclusively on information from a normal-tissue radiosensitivity assay, leads to a nearly symmetrical distribution of dose-changes that would produce a very small gain, or even a loss, of tumor control probability if implemented in the clinic. From a theoretical point of view, other strategies could be devised and some of these are considered in this review. Right now the most promising clinical use of in vitro radiosensitivity assays may be as a guide for the prescription of treatment schedules that are costly or involves a high risk of complications. Examples of this are certain strategies attempting to widen the therapeutic window, the use of very high doses or re-irradiation of a previously irradiated region, or the selection of patients for experimental strategies like the use of biological response modifiers to reduce normal-tissue toxicity. Finally, published data are summarized on the possible correlation between the radiosensitivities of tumor and normal tissues or between the sensitivities of various normal tissues.

In vitro radiosensitivity of primary human fibroblasts. Lack of correlation with acute radiation toxicity in patients with head and neck cancer

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

There is a considerable hope among clinicians and radiobiologists to detect genetically radiosensitive patients prior to radiotherapy. A predictive assay would enable adjustment of the total irradiation dose to the individual at a constant risk of normal tissue complications. In this prospective study, the clonogenic survival assay for primary human fibroblasts to determine radiosensitivity in vitro was evaluated and then correlated with clinically observed acute radiation reactions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-five independent survival experiments with primary fibroblasts derived from 63 biopsies from 55 cancer and non-cancer patients were performed.

RESULTS

A wide variation of cell survival between biopsies was detected. Statistical analysis revealed a highly significantly larger interindividual than intraindividual variation of SF2 values. However, a considerable scatter of SF2 values in repeated experiments was observed in individual cases. Age, gender, disease status (cancer patient, non-cancer patient) and origin of fibroblasts (skin, periodontal tissue) were demonstrated not to be statistically significant confounding factors on the intrinsic radiosensitivity in vitro. In a prospective study, no correlation of the SF2 and acute reactions in 25 patients with head and neck cancer treated with a primary accelerated radiochemotherapy was detected.

CONCLUSION

Our data show that the clonogenic assay is able to distinguish between intrinsic radiosensitivities of primary human fibroblasts if a statistical approach is used but does not predict acute radiation toxicity.

Rapid assay of intrinsic radiosensitivity based on apoptosis in human CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocytes

PURPOSE

An assay for radiosensitivity has numerous applications in the clinic. Avoidance of acute responses, prediction of normal tissue toxicity, and individualization of patient radiotherapy are included among these. We have developed a rapid assay (about 24 h) able to predict intrinsic radiosensitivity of CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocytes based on radiation-induced apoptosis.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fresh blood samples (1-2 ml in heparinized tubes) were irradiated with 0-, 2-, and 8-Gy X rays at a dose rate of approximately 3 Gy/min. Following irradiation, the cells were collected and prepared for flow-cytometric analysis and cell sorting. In conjunction with the CellQuest software available with the FACSVantage cell sorter (Becton-Dickinson), two T-lymphocyte types were analyzed on the basis of their cell-specific antigens (CD4 and CD8), and DNA was stained with DAPI. Following the separation of these cell types, radiation-induced cell death was assessed. Cytotoxicity was characterized by gradual degradation of internucleosomal DNA which results in a sub-G1 peak on the DNA histogram, and by the associated loss of surface antigens causing an intermediate positive peak in the antibody histogram. Using the assay, we investigated the interdonor variation in a cohort of 45 healthy adult blood donors and 5 children [one had immunodeficiency, centromeric instability, and facial anomalies syndrome (ICF), and one had ataxia telangiectasia (AT)]. Intradonor variation was assessed with 10 different experiments from a single donor.

RESULTS

CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocyte radiosensitivities were correlated (r = 0.63 and 0.65 for 2 and 8 Gy, respectively) in 45 adult donors. Both for CD4 and CD8 cells, 2 and 8 Gy irradiation responses showed a good correlation (r = 0.77 for both). Interdonor variation was significantly higher than intradonor variation (p < 0.0005) for all CD4 and CD8 data. We observed a decrease in the antigen fluorescence of dying cells, a phenomenon referred to as antigen-ebb. Antigen-ebb was clearly observed in both cell types, and correlated significantly with cytotoxicity. A trend was observed between radiosensitivity and donor age, but there was no correlation for gender. Blood from a 4-year-old girl presenting with ICF demonstrated compromised radiation-induced cytotoxicity in her CD4 T-lymphocytes, and an 11-year-old boy presenting with AT demonstrated compromised radiation-induced cytotoxicity in both his CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocytes.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that the assay provides a rapid means of determining radiosensitivity, can discriminate differences in radiation-induced cytotoxicity between individuals, and can be used as a rapid screen for genetically hypersensitive patients. Antigen-ebb offers interesting possibilities for molecular biological investigations, permitting characterization and isolation of abnormal but vital cells in the absence of clastogenic agents.

Theory and practice of predictive assays in radiation therapy

PURPOSE

An overview of the field of predictive assays is presented. It has been written with the many clinicians and scientists in mind who would like to become better acquainted with the general scope, principles and themes in the field.

RESULTS

Predictive assays have yielded much valuable information about the radiobiology of tumors e.g. the overall treatment time for rapidly proliferating tumors should be kept to a minimum. However, alteration of current treatment protocols based on results from predictive assays is still a matter of debate. What justification do we have to change established treatment protocols? A necessary and sufficient justification would be when the test value indicated an alternative treatment producing a better outcome, i.e. higher survival, improved local control, etc. Necessary but not always sufficient justification is correlation between the parameter measured and clinical outcome, if insufficient clinical benefit can be derived even when this is known. It is not sufficient that a test be demonstrated to be discriminatory. It must discriminate a sufficient number of patients, and its use must provide the patient with useful therapeutic alternatives. These parameters measured by predictive assays may well interact radiobiologically, and restricting observations to just one assay is probably insufficient for reliable indications. In the future, it is more likely that a panel of tests will be performed, and clinical decisions based on multi-parametric analysis of biopsy material.

CONCLUSION

In the following overview general predictive assay theory is presented followed by a brief introduction to some of the more established assays and finally some guidelines are suggested for the development of new assays.

Low dose-rate fibroblast radiosensitivity and the prediction of patient response to radiotherapy

The relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and normal-tissue response to radiotherapy in individual cancer patients has attracted increasing attention over the last few years. Recent work has suggested that a correlation exists between fibroblast sensitivity and normal-tissue reactions. We have examined the radiosensitivity of fibroblasts grown from skin biopsies of four normal individuals and three patients identified as having suffered unexpectedly severe reactions to clinical radiotherapy, called here 'over-reactor' (OR) patients. Clonogenic survival was measured after high (HDR) and low dose-rate (LDR) irradiation. By comparing the two, and LDR Recovery Factor was derived. Potentially-lethal damage repair was examined in 4 cell strains. After HDR the OR strains were indistinguishable from the normals. At LDR the range of sensitivity was expanded. The OR strains fell at the sensitive end of the range and were characterized by a lack of LDR recovery, which clearly distinguished them from the normal strains. Experimental errors were estimated by considering all the data sets together rather than viewing each experiment individually. Duplicate strains from several patients were tested, and the differences between them were found to be within the estimated experimental errors, suggesting that these differences were not biologically significant. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that normal-tissue response is linked to individual cellular radiosensitivity. Our data confirm the importance of using LDR irradiation in clinical investigations of cellular sensitivity.

Micronuclei in cytokinesis-blocked lymphocytes may predict patient response to radiotherapy

We have applied the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay to peripheral blood lymphocytes of patients undergoing radiotherapy in pelvic and pulmonary sites, in order to evaluate the individual cytogenetic response. Our cytogenetic data correlated with the equivalent whole-body dose are homogeneous and compare well with the data presented by other authors. We have used an exponential mathematical formula to calculate the attenuation of the cytogenetic effect with time. The k coefficient (cytogenetic recovery factor) in the formula expresses the degree of attenuation. In lymphocytes from patients after radiotherapy, the trend of the micronucleus frequency observed after 2 Gy of in vitro X-irradiation demonstrates that the cytogenetic effect obtained in vitro is added to that obtained in vivo. The k coefficient is inversely proportional to the micronucleus frequency observed after 2 Gy in vitro. The micronucleus assay and the cytogenetic recovery factor are proposed as suitable diagnostic tools for application in the field of radiotherapy.

Relationship between the in vitro radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts and the expression of subcutaneous fibrosis, telangiectasia, and skin erythema after radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE

To investigate if the occurrence of subcutaneous fibrosis after radiotherapy in an unselected group of breast cancer patients is related to cellular radiosensitivity of skin fibroblasts as measured in a clonogenic assay.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An in vitro colony-forming assay of normal fibroblast radiosensitivity was applied to primary skin biopsies from 31 breast cancer patients who received post-mastectomy radiotherapy with large doses per fraction (2.7-3.9 Gy) more than 10 years earlier. Three clinical normal-tissue endpoints were assessed. Two late endpoints, subcutaneous fibrosis and telangiectasia, were evaluated in three treatment fields by a single experienced clinician. In addition, skin erythema had been assessed at the end of treatment by members of the staff and junior staff. From previous analyses of normal tissue response, individual clinical radiosensitivity could be assessed as "excess risk' of each of the three reactions. This was defined as the difference between the actual observed response in the patient and the expected response estimated from individual treatment characteristics in a linear quadratic (LQ) mixture model and, for the two late endpoints, with correction for the follow-up time. This clinical radioresponsiveness was compared with the in vitro radiosensitivity of the skin fibroblasts. To this end, the fractions of colony-forming cells after graded single doses were fitted by an LQ survival curve using non-linear regression from which the surviving fraction at 3.5 Gy (SF3.5) was estimated. Assessment at 3.5 Gy was chosen to reflect the fraction size during clinical radiotherapy.

RESULTS

A statistically significant variability of in vitro radiosensitivity between patients could be detected for both SF2 (P = 0.0095) and SF3.5 (P = 0.0008). A significant correlation was observed between SF3.5 and excess risk of fibrosis (rs = -0.46, P = 0.009) while no association was found between fibroblast radiosensitivity and either the occurrence of severe skin telangiectasia or the acute endpoint skin erythema.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that variability in the occurrence of subcutaneous fibrosis, but not telangiectasia or erythema, after radiotherapy is partly accounted for by differences in cellular radiosensitivity of normal skin fibroblasts.

Comparison between normal tissue reactions and local tumor control in head and neck cancer patients treated by definitive radiotherapy

PURPOSE

This study was conducted to test for the relationship between tumor and normal tissue radiosensitivity, by comparing local tumor control to the severity of acute and late normal tissue reactions in head and neck cancer patients treated by definitive radiotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Two hundred eighty-six patients with head and neck cancer who were treated at the University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center between 1983 and 1993 were selected for the study. Of these, 124 (43%) were treated by a concomitant boost regimen and 162 (57%) by hyperfractionation. All patients had at least 1 year of follow-up. The tumor stage distribution according to the 1992 American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system was as follows: T1, 3%; T2, 53%; T3, 40%; T4, 4%. The average doses delivered were 71.2 Gy and 76.2 Gy for the concomitant boost and hyperfractionation regimens, respectively, with no significant variation between patients. Acute and late reactions were recorded using the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG)/European Organization for Research on Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) grading system (0 to 4). The median follow-up period was 38 months (range: 12-107 months). The time to local tumor recurrence was analyzed in relation to the severity of acute and late reactions expressed as the maximum recorded grades, and to the time intensity of acute mucositis, expressed as the area under the curve of mucositis grade vs. time. Univariate and multivariate analyses also included T stage, N stage, and site of origin as other prognostic variables, and were carried out using a proportional hazards model.

RESULTS

Fifty-four patients (19%) suffered local failure. T stage was found to significantly influence local control (p = 0.009). There was a nonsignificant trend for higher failure rates in patients with maximum Grade 1 or 2 vs. those with Grade 3 or 4 acute mucositis (28 and 18%, respectively; p = 0.17). No correlation was found between the severity of late reactions and local tumor control after radiotherapy. Analysis by time intensity of mucositis revealed a wide variation between individuals with a nonsignificant trend for higher local failure rates in patients with low mucositis time intensity scores.

CONCLUSIONS

These clinical results suggest a possible relationship between normal tissue and tumor radiosensitivity. However, additional studies with a larger numbers of patients, and using refined normal tissue endpoints that incorporate a time function are needed to fully elucidate this question.

How much could the radiotherapy dose be altered for individual patients based on a predictive assay of normal-tissue radiosensitivity?

Predictive assays are presently being developed to identify the patients at highest risk for developing severe late normal-tissue complications. If such patients could be identified prior to treatment, then the doses to those patients could be reduced to lower their complication rate. In addition, patients identified as being relatively radioresistant could receive higher doses without an increase in complications. The aim of the present study was to estimate the magnitude of the dose adjustments that could potentially be made if radiotherapy doses were tailored to the individual patient using a predictive assay of normal-tissue radiosensitivity. The dose adjustments were estimated by re-analyzing data from an earlier study [13] to determine the influence of dose and in vitro fibroblast radiosensitivity on the incidence of severe late normal-tissue complications. Although the dose estimates are preliminary and based on limited data, the results of this study support the concept that a significant therapeutic gain could be achieved for a subset of patients from the use of a predictive assay of normal-tissue radiosensitivity.