Tubular antigen-derivatized cells induce a disease-protective, antigen-specific, and idiotype-specific suppressor T cell network restricted by I-J and Igh-V in mice with experimental interstitial nephritis

Manipulation of idiotype networks in autoimmunity

The spontaneous occurrence of anti-idiotypes associated with the amelioration of disease activity in some autoimmune disorders encourages the view that one may be able to develop a therapeutic strategy based upon manipulation of idiotype networks. Attempts to abrogate autoimmunity by using heterologous anti-idiotype reagents have been rather disappointing and there may well be an expansion of idiotype-negative antibody clones. We argue that idiotypic reagents based on T cells or antibodies derived from the species being treated are more likely to lead to success because they interact more profoundly with the individual's own networks than do heterologous antibodies.

Therapeutic immune regulation in experimental interstitial nephritis with suppressor T cells and their soluble factors

The therapeutic application of immune regulation and suppressor T cells to the control and modulation of autoimmune disease is an area of growing experimental interest. Our group has been studying experimental interstitial nephritis, both to better understand the disease process itself and to test immunoregulatory strategies for their inhibitory and protective effects. This report gives a brief overview of this work.

Oral feeding of renal tubular antigen abrogates interstitial nephritis and renal failure in Brown Norway rats

We have examined whether oral feeding of antigen can regulate the expression of autoimmune interstitial nephritis induced by antigen-in-adjuvant (RTA/CFA) immunization of Brown Norway rats. Male rats were divided into six experimental groups: Group I, RTA/CFA immunization alone; Groups II, III, and IV were pretreated with 1 mg (Group II), 5 mg (Group III), and 25 mg (Group IV) of oral tubular antigen every other day for ten days, followed by RTA/CFA immunization; Group V was pretreated with a control antigen, followed by RTA/CFA immunization; and Group VI was immunized with CFA alone. Renal histology, inulin clearance, DTH responses to RTA, and IgG antibody responses to RTA were monitored as endpoints of the study. Our results demonstrated that Group III and IV animals had significantly less severe renal injury, as assessed by inulin clearance and extent of renal cortical involvement by mononuclear cells. Group II and IV animals had suppressed DTH responses, and only Group IV animals had significantly depressed antigen-specific IgG serum titers. Group III animals had neither suppressed DTH responses or IgG titers. We conclude that oral administration of tubular antigen can modulate the intensity of interstitial nephritis produced by immunization, but that the regulatory mechanism is not dependent (at all doses of fed antigen) on suppressed DTH reactivity to RTA or suppressed antigen-specific IgG.

Inhibition of murine nephritogenic effector T cells by a clone-specific suppressor factor

We have used a murine model of organ-specific autoimmunity to characterize therapeutic modalities capable of down-regulating the cellular limb of the autoimmune response. Murine interstitial nephritis is an autoimmune disease mediated by tubular antigen-specific CD8+ nephritogenic effector T cells which are delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactive and cytotoxic to renal epithelial cells. Previous studies have demonstrated that disease can be suppressed with experimentally induced populations of T cells (Ts1 and Ts2 cells) obtained after injection of tubular antigen-coupled splenocytes into syngeneic mice. As the target of Ts2 is the CD8+ effector T cell, we have evaluated its effects on nephritogenic effector T cell clones isolated from diseased animals. Our studies demonstrate that soluble proteins expressed by Ts2 cells (TsF2) specifically abrogate the DTH, cytotoxic, and nephritogenic potential of M52 cells, although T cell receptor and IL-2 receptor expression are unchanged in these unresponsive M52 clones. TsF2-induced inhibition is dependent on new mRNA and protein synthesis. In a cytotoxic clone, M52.26, exposure to TsF2 induces expression of TGF-beta 1 which is, in turn, required for inhibition of cytotoxicity and nephritogenicity. Our studies are consistent with TGF-beta 1 behaving, at least in some T cells, as a nonspecific final effector of clone-specific suppression.

Inherited interstitial nephritis in kdkd mice

kdkd mice, a mutant subline of CBA/Ca mice, develop a progressive, T cell-mediated, autoimmune interstitial nephritis which leads to renal failure and death of all mice at 20-28 weeks of age. This disease is inherited in an autosomal recessive manner, with complete penetrance, and has been linked to grizzled and waltzer on mouse chromosome 10. Immunologic evaluation of this lesion has demonstrated that histologic disease is initiated by a population of CD8+, H-2Kk-restricted T cells, which recognize an antigen in collagenase-solubilized syngeneic renal tubules. These nephritogenic effector cells can also be demonstrated in non-disease prone CBA/Ca mice. Susceptibility to autoimmune nephritis correlates with distinct expression of regulatory, rather than effector, T cells. Interstitial nephritis in kdkd mice can be inhibited by protein-calorie restriction, infusions of CBA/Ca CD8+ T cells, or monoclonal antibodies of ICAM-1. This murine model most closely resembles medullary cystic disease in humans, which has not historically been considered an autoimmune disease. Mapping of the genes for both medullary cystic disease and the defect in kdkd mice should augment our understanding of mechanisms of organ-specific autoimmunity.

Characterization of suppressor T cell clones derived from a mouse tolerized with conjugates of ovalbumin and monomethoxypolyethylene glycol

The induction of antigen-specific tolerance in mice by conjugates of ovalbumin (OVA) and monomethoxypolyethylene glycol (mPEG) previously had been shown to be associated with the generation of antigen-specific suppressor T (Ts) cells. For the elucidation of the nature of these Ts cells, five nonhybridized OVA-specific Ts cell clones were generated from the spleen cells of a BDF1 mouse which had been immunosuppressed by the tolerogenic conjugate, OVA(mPEG)12. The cloned Ts cells were maintained in vitro by periodic stimulation with OVA and feeder cells and were able to suppress the in vitro antibody production in an OVA-specific and MHC class I (H-2Kd or H-2Dd)-restricted manner. All these Ts cell clones were shown to be Thy1.2+, CD4-, CD5-, CD8+, and to express CD3 and the alpha beta heterodimer of the T cell receptor. The cell-free extracts of these cells contained soluble suppressor factors which could mimic in vitro the suppressive activity of the intact cells. In contrast to cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), none of the cloned Ts cells were endowed with cytolytic activity as revealed in the perforin-mediated microhemolysis and in the 18-hr51Cr release assays. These results demonstrate that (i) OVA-specific Ts cell clones can be generated from mice pretreated with OVA(mPEG)12 by employing conventional T cell culture techniques, and (ii) these Ts cells are functionally different from conventional CD8+ CTL.

Tolerance to acetylcholine receptor induced by AChR-coupled syngeneic cells

Intravenous administration of acetylcholine receptor (AChR)-coupled syngeneic spleen cells induced AChR-specific tolerance in Lewis rats. Injection of 20 x 10(6) AChR-coupled spleen cells resulted in a significant reduction of the antibody response to AChR when the animals were subsequently immunized with AChR (up to 66% inhibition). Tolerance induced by AChR-coupled cells was antigen-specific: challenge with AChR plus an unrelated antigen, ovalbumin (OVA), resulted in significantly reduced serum antibody titers to AChR but normal or enhanced titers to OVA, compared to controls. Lymphocytes from these rats showed substantially reduced proliferative responses in vitro to AChR, and normal or enhanced responses to OVA. To investigate the role of Ia antigens in tolerance induction, AChR was coupled to Ia-positive or Ia-negative spleen cells. Injection of AChR-coupled Ia-positive cells induced antigen-specific tolerance to AChR; challenge with AChR plus OVA resulted in reduced serum antibody titers and lymphoproliferative responses to AChR, and normal or enhanced titers and cellular responses to OVA. Injection of AChR-coupled Ia-negative cells did not induce tolerance to AChR. These results demonstrate that AChR, which is known to be highly immunogenic, can be rendered tolerogenic without denaturation or linkage to toxic substances. The possible mechanisms of tolerance induced by AChR-coupled spleen cells are discussed.

Does the presence of self-reactive T cells indicate the breakdown of tolerance?

There are many experimental systems in which autoreactive T cells can easily be demonstrated but where the host does not normally develop autoimmune disease. How do these animals avoid autoimmunity? Does the presence of these self-reactive cells indicate the failure of self-tolerance? To answer these questions it is necessary to consider how some T cells might escape tolerance induction and why they are not activated in the host. There are several different explanations which can be broadly placed into one of two categories. First, although autoreactive cells may be easily stimulated under experimental conditions, the requirements for activation and likewise deletion may not be met under physiological conditions. The self-antigen may be poorly presented by APC or sequestered in a particular body compartment; alternatively, these T cells may have low affinity receptors needing high levels of antigen. The second category is characterized by the need for immunoregulation. A random selection of T cells may escape clonal inactivation in the thymus but may be kept under constant suppression, which provides a fail-safe mechanism for deletional tolerance. In this review we will discuss these mechanisms and their possible importance in the prevention of autoimmunity.

Resistance to experimental autoimmune thyroiditis: L3T4+ cells as mediators of both thyroglobulin-activated and TSH-induced suppression

Mechanisms suppressive to induction of murine experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) can be activated by pretreatment with tolerogenic doses of mouse thyroglobulin (MTg) or prior TSH infusion to raise circulatory MTg levels. MTg-activated suppressor T cells (Ts), shown earlier to be Thy-1+ and probably I-J+, were further characterized by in vivo administration of paired rat monoclonal antibodies to distinct epitopes on the L3T4 or Lyt-2 molecule, either on the day of, or subsequent to, initiation of the tolerogenic regimes. The cells required at the time of MTg pretreatment were L3T4+, Lyt-2- and low anti-L3T4 doses had no effect on their activation. The cells that mediated the strong MTg-induced resistance following pretreatment were also L3T4+; their suppressor function could only be abrogated by depletion of L3T4+, but not Lyt-2+, cells. Injection of cyclophosphamide (20-100 mg/kg) either prior to EAT induction or after Ts activation did not affect the severity of disease. Similarly, the suppressor state evoked by TSH infusion could only be abrogated by anti-L3T4 treatment. These findings indicate that both MTg-activated and TSH-induced suppression are mediated by L3T4+ cells. We hypothesize that MTg-specific Ts are present in normal, EAT-susceptible mice in low numbers to contribute to the maintenance of self-tolerance and that they are stimulated by increased levels of circulatory MTg to expand/differentiate and mediate the marked resistance to EAT induction.

Murine interstitial nephritis. VIII. Characterization of Igh-V restriction determinants in the development of anti-idiotypic immunity using blocking antibodies

We have prepared antisera specific for Igh-V-linked determinants (alpha Igh-V) in order to study Igh-V restriction during the development of protective, T cell-mediated anti-idiotypic immunity in autoimmune interstitial nephritis. Suppressor T cells in this network use an antigen-binding (RE-Id+) factor (TsF1) secreted by first-order suppressor cells (Ts-1) to induce an anti-idiotypic (RE-alpha Id+) soluble factor (TsF1) released by effector-phase, Ts-2 suppressor cells. Each of these soluble suppressor factors requires homology in the Igh-V region to complete its regulatory functions. Our alpha Igh-V antisera, adsorbed against network idiotypes, can interfere with the Igh-V restriction used in the induction of Ts-2 suppression by TsF1. The antisera bind both TsF1 and TsF2 in an allele-specific manner and are cytotoxic to induced Ts-2 cells, but not their precursors. These Igh-V determinants appear to behave like activation molecules. They lie outside of the ligand-binding site, do not map with the serologic binding of idiotype, and thus act as distinct associative-recognition elements in the maturation of anti-idiotypic immunity.

Augmentation of transfer of experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) in mice by irradiation of recipients

Experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) can be adoptively transferred to normal syngeneic recipients using spleen cells from susceptible strains of mice primed in vivo with mouse thyroglobulin (MTg) and lipopolysaccharide (LPS) following in vitro activation of spleen cells by culture with MTg. Irradiation of recipient animals markedly augments the severity of thyroiditis induced in this system. Irradiation of recipients does not alter the time course of the development of thyroiditis, nor does it alter the requirement for both in vivo priming and in vitro activation of spleen cells for the development of EAT. Spleen cells from EAT-resistant strains of mice (e.g., Balb/c) do not induce EAT in irradiated recipients. Irradiated recipients develop significant levels of anti-MTg antibodies while unirradiated recipients have little detectable antibody response. The augmenting effect of irradiation can be substantially reversed by transferring naive spleen cells to recipients prior to the transfer of MTg/LPS-primed in vitro-activated spleen cells. In addition athymic CBA/Tufts nude mice develop more severe EAT than CBA/Tufts nude/+ littermates following transfer of activated CBA/J spleen cells. These data suggest that natural suppressor cells may regulate the development of EAT at the effector cell level.

Suppressor system in murine interstitial nephritis. Analysis of tubular basement membrane (TBM)-specific suppressor T cells and their soluble factor in C57BL/6 mice using a syngeneic system

We induced typical interstitial nephritis with high titers of anti-tubular basement membrane (TBM) autoantibody in genetically resistant C57BL/6 mice by treating them with sodium aurothiomalate (gold) and immunizing them with syngeneic TBM antigen. When gold was not used, the T-cell fraction of nylon wool adherent splenic cells showed prominent suppressive activity against the proliferative response of nonadherent cells to TBM antigen. However, this suppressive activity was remarkably decreased by the gold treatment. TBM antigen sensitized thymocytes, a thymocyte extract, and a spleen cell extract were transferred to C57BL/6 mice which had been immunized with TBM antigen and treated with gold. This transfer clearly depressed the induction of autoimmune interstitial nephritis in an antigen-specific manner. These results indicate that TBM antigen-specific suppressor T cells and their soluble factor may play an important role in the negative regulation of interstitial nephritis in C57BL/6 mice.

Prostaglandin E1 inhibits effector T cell induction and tissue damage in experimental murine interstitial nephritis

Immunosuppressive effects of E-series prostaglandins have been demonstrated in many in vitro assays of immune responsiveness as well as in autoimmune diseases. To explore the mechanisms underlying prostaglandin E1 (PGE1)-associated immunosuppression in autoimmunity, we treated SJL mice immunized to produce immune-mediated interstitial nephritis with PGE1, PGF2 alpha, or vehicle alone. Mice receiving PGE1 treatment do not develop interstitial nephritis, nor do they display delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) to the immunizing renal tubular antigen preparation. The observed immunosuppression is critically dependent on PGE1 administration during the period of effector T cell induction. We therefore investigated the effect of PGE1 on the in vitro induction of DTH effector T cells reactive to renal tubular antigens (SRTA). PGE1 inhibits effector T cell induction in a dose-dependent, reversible manner, but has no inhibitory effect on fully differentiated DTH effector cells or SRTA-reactive cell lines. The PGE1 effect is indirect and mediated via nonspecific suppressor lymphokines. This suppression can be overcome by recombinant interleukin 1 (IL-1), which suggests a mechanism related to either diminished IL-1 secretion or target cell sensitivity to IL-1.

Contrasuppression in autoimmunity. Abnormal contrasuppression facilitates expression of nephritogenic effector T cells and interstitial nephritis in kdkd mice

We have used the murine model of spontaneous autoimmune interstitial nephritis in kdkd mice to examine the importance of abnormal immunoregulation in the expression of disease. T cells from naive congenic CBA/Ca mice suppress both histologic renal injury in the kdkd strain as well as the DTH reactivity to CBA/Ca renal tubular antigens mediated by lymphocytes from nephritic kdkd mice. These antigen-specific suppressor T cells are Lyt-2+, L3T4+, I-Jk+, genetically dominant and I-Jk restricted. Unfractionated spleen cells from young, prenephritic kdkd mice also demonstrate such suppressor function. Shortly preceding disease onset, however, net suppression is functionally bypassed by emergent contrasuppressor T cells. These regulatory cells are also Lyt-2+ and I-Jk+, and adhere both to the Vicia Villosa lectin and CBA/Ca TBM. By admixing these contrasuppressor cells with spleen cells from non-disease-prone CBA/Ca mice we were able to demonstrate the presence of DTH-reactive and nephritogenic effector cells in the latter population. Such nephritogenic effector cells could also be simply demonstrated after depletion of the suppressor cells with anti-I-Jk mAbs and complement. These findings support a role for contrasuppressor cells in the abrogation of tolerance to parenchymal self-antigens.

Experimental strategies for the study of cellular immunity in renal disease

This overview has examined some of the current experimental options available for the study of cellular immunity in the immunopathogenesis of renal disease. T cell immunity, where it has been examined, seems to have a particularly pivotal role in orchestrating and regulating functional patterns of renal injury. The use of the research methods presented here for the study of cell-mediated interactional events in kidney disease, however, has lagged behind similar efforts in other organ systems. We hope, therefore, this report will serve to stimulate and strengthen further interest in the cell biology of the nephritogenic immune response.