T cell contact with Ia antigens on nonhemopoietic cells in vivo can lead to immunity rather than tolerance

PD-L1's Role in Preventing Alloreactive T Cell Responses Following Hematopoietic and Organ Transplant

Over the past decade, Programmed Death-Ligand 1 (PD-L1) has emerged as a prominent target for cancer immunotherapies. However, its potential as an immunosuppressive therapy has been limited. In this review, we present the immunological basis of graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), followed by a summary of biologically relevant molecular interactions of both PD-L1 and Programmed Cell Death Protein 1 (PD-1). Finally, we present a translational perspective on how PD-L1 can interrupt alloreactive-driven processes to increase immune tolerance. Unlike most current therapies that block PD-L1 and/or its interaction with PD-1, this review focuses on how upregulation or reversed sequestration of this ligand may reduce autoimmunity, ameliorate GVHD, and enhance graft survival following organ transplant.

The immunopathology of thymic GVHD

The clinical success of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) depends on the appropriate reconstitution of the host's immune system. While recovery of T-cell immunity may occur in transplant recipients via both thymus-dependent and thymus-independent pathways, the regeneration of a population of phenotypically naive T cells with a broad receptor repertoire relies entirely on the de novo generation of T-cells in the thymus. Preclinical models and clinical studies of allogeneic HSCT have identified the thymus as a target of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), thus limiting T-cell regeneration. The present review focuses on recent insight into how GVHD affects thymic structure and function and how this knowledge may aid in the design of new strategies to improve T-cell reconstitution following allogeneic HSCT.

DC homeostasis in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is an important experimental tool and therapeutic modality. Its efficacy and toxicity are both linked to a GvH reaction that is initiated by donor T cells recognizing recipient APC, of which DC are the most potent. In most tissues recipient DC are replaced after transplantation because they turnover rapidly from BM-derived precursors. However, in a number of sites, notably the skin, recipient DC may persist and even self-renew for many months after transplantation. Understanding the homeostasis of different APC populations and how they are related to the induction of alloreactivity may help to improve the therapeutic benefit of transplantation.

The role of antigen-presenting cells in triggering graft-versus-host disease and graft-versus-leukemia

After allogeneic blood or bone marrow transplantation, donor T cells interact with a distorted antigen-presenting cell (APC) environment in which some, but not all, host APCs are replaced by APCs from the donor. Significantly, host APCs are required for the priming of acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Donor APCs play a lesser role in the induction of acute GVHD despite their predicted capacity to cross-present host antigens. In contrast, donor APCs may play a role in perpetuating the tissue injury observed in chronic GVHD. Host APCs are also required for maximal graft-versus-leukemia responses. Recent studies have suggested potential strategies by which the continued presence of host APCs can be exploited to prime strong donor immunity to tumors without the induction of GVHD.

Donor T-cell alloreactivity against host thymic epithelium limits T-cell development after bone marrow transplantation

Acute graft-versus-host disease (aGVHD) impairs thymus-dependent T-cell regeneration in recipients of allogeneic bone marrow transplants through yet to be defined mechanisms. Here, we demonstrate in mice that MHC-mismatched donor T cells home into the thymus of unconditioned recipients. There, activated donor T cells secrete IFN-gamma, which in turn stimulates the programmed cell death of thymic epithelial cells (TECs). Because TECs themselves are competent and sufficient to prime naive allospecific T cells and to elicit their effector function, the elimination of host-type professional antigen-presenting cells (APCs) does not prevent donor T-cell activation and TEC apoptosis, thus precluding normal thymopoiesis in transplant recipients. Hence, strategies that protect TECs may be necessary to improve immune reconstitution following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation.

The replacement of graft endothelium by recipient-type cells conditions allograft rejection mediated by indirect pathway CD4(+) T cells

BACKGROUND

Whereas the participation of alloreactive T cells sensitized by indirect allorecognition in graft rejection is well documented, the nature of recipient antigen presenting cells recognized by indirect pathway CD4(+) T cells within the graft has yet to be identified. The purpose of this study was to determine the role played by graft endothelium replacement in the immune recognition of cardiac allografts rejected by indirect pathway CD4(+) T cells.

METHODS

Transgenic RAG2(-/-) mice expressing I-A(b)-restricted male antigen H-Y-specific TcR were studied for their capacity to reject H-2(k) male cardiac allografts. Chronic vascular rejection in this model was due to the indirect recognition of H-Y antigen shed from H-2(k) male allograft and presented by the recipient's own I-A(b) APC to transgenic T cells.

RESULTS

Immunohistochemical analysis of rejected grafts revealed the presence of numerous microvascular endothelial cells (EC) that expressed recipient's I-A MHC class II molecules. This observation suggested that graft endothelium replacement by I-A(b)-positive cells of recipient origin could stimulate the rejection of male H-2(k) graft by I-A(b)--restricted H-Y--specific T cells. To investigate further this possibility, hearts from H-2(b)--into--H-2(k) irradiation bone marrow (BM) chimera were transplanted in transgenic recipients. A direct correlation was observed between the presence of I-A(b)-positive EC within myocardial microvessels and the induction of acute rejection of chimeric H-2(k) male cardiac allografts transplanted in transgenic recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that graft endothelium replacement by recipient-type cells is required for the rejection of cardiac allograft mediated by indirect pathway alloreactive CD4(+) T cells.

Vascular Endothelium Does Not Activate CD4+ Direct Allorecognition in Graft Rejection

Expression of MHC class II by donor-derived APCs has been shown to be important for allograft rejection. It remains controversial, however, whether nonhemopoietic cells, such as vascular endothelium, possess Ag-presenting capacity to activate alloreactive CD4(+) T lymphocytes. This issue is important in transplantation, because, unlike hemopoietic APCs, allogeneic vascular endothelium remains present for the life of the organ. In this study we report that cytokine-activated vascular endothelial cells are poor APCs for allogeneic CD4(+) T lymphocytes in vitro and in vivo despite surface expression of MHC class II. Our in vitro observations were extended to an in vivo model of allograft rejection. We have separated the allostimulatory capacity of endothelium from that of hemopoietic APCs by using bone marrow chimeras. Hearts that express MHC class II on hemopoietic APCs are acutely rejected in a mean of 7 days regardless of the expression of MHC class II on graft endothelium. Alternatively, hearts that lack MHC class II on hemopoietic APCs are acutely rejected at a significantly delayed tempo regardless of the expression of MHC class II on graft endothelium. Our data suggest that vascular endothelium does not play an important role in CD4(+) direct allorecognition and thus does not contribute to the vigor of acute rejection.

Graft-versus-leukemia in a retrovirally induced murine CML model: mechanisms of T-cell killing

The graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect, mediated by donor T cells, has revolutionized the treatment of leukemia. However, effective GVL remains difficult to separate from graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), and many neoplasms are GVL resistant. Murine studies aimed at solving these problems have been limited by the use of leukemia cell lines with limited homology to human leukemias and by the absence of loss-of-function leukemia variants. To address these concerns, we developed a GVL model against murine chronic-phase chronic myelogenous leukemia (mCP-CML) induced with retrovirus expressing the bcr-abl fusion cDNA, the defining genetic abnormality of chronic-phase CML (CP-CML). By generating mCP-CML in gene-deficient mice, we have studied GVL T-cell effector mechanisms. mCP-CML expression of Fas or tumor necrosis factor (TNF) receptors is not required for CD8-mediated GVL. Strikingly, maximal CD4-mediated GVL requires cognate interactions between CD4 cells and mCP-CML cells as major histocompatibility complex-negative (MHC II(-/-)) mCP-CML is relatively GVL resistant. Nevertheless, a minority of CD4 recipients cleared MHC II(-/-) mCP-CML; thus, CD4 cells can also kill indirectly. CD4 GVL did not require target Fas expression. These results suggest that CPCML's GVL sensitivity may in part be explained by the minimal requirements for T-cell killing, and GVL-resistance may be related to MHC II expression.

Preterminal host dendritic cells in irradiated mice prime CD8+ T cell-mediated acute graft-versus-host disease

To understand the relationship between host antigen-presenting cells (APCs) and donor T cells in initiating graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), we followed the fate of host dendritic cells (DCs) in irradiated C57BL/6 (B6) recipient mice and the interaction of these cells with minor histocompatibility antigen- (miHA-) mismatched CD8+ T cells from C3H.SW donors. Host CD11c+ DCs were rapidly activated and aggregated in the T cell areas of the spleen within 6 hours of lethal irradiation. By 5 days after irradiation, <1% of host DCs were detectable, but the activated donor CD8+ T cells had already undergone as many as seven divisions. Thus, proliferation of donor CD8+ T cells preceded the disappearance of host DCs. When C3H.SW donor CD8+ T cells were primed in vivo in irradiated B6 mice or ex vivo by host CD11c+ DCs for 24-36 hours, they were able to proliferate and differentiate into IFN-gamma-producing cells in beta(2)-microglobulin-deficient (beta(2)m(-/-)) B6 recipients and to mediate acute GVHD in beta(2)m(-/-) --> B6 chimeric mice. These results indicate that, although host DCs disappear rapidly after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, they prime donor T cells before their disappearance and play a critical role in triggering donor CD8+ T cell-mediated GVHD.

Non-hematopoietic allograft cells directly activate CD8+ T cells and trigger acute rejection: an alternative mechanism of allorecognition

Despite evidence that human non-hematopoietic cells, such as vascular endothelium, can activate allogeneic T lymphocytes in vitro, the prevailing view has been that hematopoietic antigen-presenting cells are required to trigger alloimmune responses in vivo. Here we report that mouse non-hematopoietic cells activate alloreactive CD8+ T lymphocytes in vitro and in vivo. We also show that vascularized cardiac allografts are acutely rejected via CD8+ direct allorecognition even if the alloantigen is not presented by hematopoietic professional antigen-presenting cells. Because activation of alloreactive CD8+ T cells by donor-type non-hematopoietic cells can continue for the life of the allograft, these findings present a new clinically relevant mechanism of allorecognition and should be taken into consideration when developing strategies to prevent allograft vasculopathy or to induce tolerance.

Single-cell analysis of costimulation by B cells, endothelial cells, and fibroblasts demonstrates heterogeneity in responses of CD4(+) memory T cells

Human endothelial cells (EC) express MHC class II molecules in vivo and are likely to be involved in presentation of antigens to CD4(+) T cells. We examined, at the single-cell level, EC presentation of superantigens to resting CD4(+) memory T cells. Within 2 h of adherence to class II+ EC early T cell activation is evidenced by translocation of nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT), surface expression of CD69, and synthesis of IFN-gamma and IL-2. Naive T cells are not activated. T cell activation is dependent on the prior induction of MHC class II molecules on EC and is blocked by antibodies to LFA-3 (CD58). Our data place EC along a spectrum of antigen-presenting ability. Activated B cells and macrophages trigger more cells to express cytokines than do EC and at lower antigen concentrations; EC are in turn, superior to fibroblasts or smooth muscle cells. Furthermore, the concept of activation thresholds for cytokine synthesis within T cells also extends to earlier activation events: NFAT translocation is relatively easy to trigger, as is CD69 expression; fewer cells can be triggered to express IFN-gamma and fewer still to express IL-2. EC may, therefore, contribute to a graded immune response by inducing qualitatively and quantitatively different responses than professional APC.

Microchimerism in thymus is associated with up-regulated T helper type 1 cytokine transcription during cardiac allograft rejection in rats

BACKGROUND

Intrathymic microchimerism (MC) is thought to be responsible for inducing allograft tolerance. However, the role of MC in the thymus gland after transplantation, particularly in the rejection response, is unknown. We investigated serial changes in intrathymic cytokine production associated with MC and allograft rejection.

METHODS

Donor-specific cell injection (DSI) and heterotopic heart transplantation (HTx) were performed in the fully allogeneic combination using DA rats (RT1a) as donors and WS rats (RT1k)as recipients. MC was checked by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using a donor RT1.Bbeta domain 1 region sequence-specific primers. Reverse transcription (RT)-PCR analysis of cytokine (interleukin [IL]-2, interferon-gamma, IL-4, and IL-10) profiles of the thymus was performed in animals given DSI, HTx, or DSI/HTx.

RESULTS

DSI alone resulted in an immediate development of MC, detected by PCR, in various organs including the thymus, spleen, liver, and blood, of most rats, lasting for over 2 months. However, DSI-induced MC selectively disappeared in the thymus on day 7 after grafting, several days before the rejection of cardiac allograft. RT-PCR analysis of cytokine profiles showed that the levels of Th1 (IL-2 and interferon-gamma) cytokines transcribed in the thymus were higher than in the spleen. MC reappeared in the thymus on day 21 after grafting, but was not associated with elevation of Th1 cytokine transcription when allograft was replaced by fibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Intrathymic MC does not always confer unresponsiveness to alloantigen, but can be eliminated after anti-donor response.

Human Endothelial Cells Effectively Costimulate Cytokine Production by, But Not Differentiation of, Naive CD4+ T Cells

We compared costimulatory signals provided by human endothelial cells (ECs) to those provided by conventional bone marrow-derived APCs, i.e., peripheral blood-adherent mononuclear cells (PBAMCs), by measuring their effects on cytokine production by naive or memory CD4+ T cells stimulated by PHA. In these assays, ECs effectively costimulate secretion of IL-2, IFN-γ, and IL-4 from both naive and memory CD4+ T cells, quantified by ELISA or intracellular cytokine staining. ECs, which lack B7 molecules, use predominantly leukocyte-function associated Ag 3 (LFA-3) to provide costimulation. ECs are comparable to or better than PBAMCs, which use both the LFA-3 and B7 molecules, at costimulating IL-2 and IL-4 production. ECs are less effective than PBAMCs at costimulating IFN-γ production by naive T cells. ECs do not secrete IL-12, and addition of exogenous IL-12 enables ECs to costimulate IFN-γ at a level comparable to that observed with PBAMCs. ECs do not promote differentiation of naive T cells to Th1-like cells, whereas PBAMCs do. Again, addition of exogenous IL-12 enables ECs to do so. Transfection of ECs to express B7-1 or B7-2 is less effective than IL-12 supplementation for restoring these responses. These experiments suggest that a deficiency in costimulation due to lack of B7 molecule expression does not fully explain the inability of ECs to activate resting naive CD4+ T cells.

Mouse mammary tumor virus production by thymic epithelial cells in vivo

Exogenous mouse mammary tumor viruses (MMTV) replicate in the mammary glands of infected females, and so infect the suckling pups. We have previously shown that the virus is rapidly disseminated to all the lymphoid organs, including the thymus. The present electron microscope immunohistochemical study describes the viral production site in the thymus. Viral buds and viral proteins were restricted to the thymus medullary epithelial cells. MMTV-encoded proteins were identified on the free viral particles and on the budding ones, the ribosomes, the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum, and on the membrane of the medullary type II epithelial cell vacuolar network. The thymus medullary epithelial cells can thus integrate the virus and allow viral replication. The results support earlier results indicating that in some experimental conditions, epithelial cells may be involved in MMTV-induced negative selection by showing that thymic epithelial cells do express MMTV-encoded proteins.

Mechanism by which additional monoclonal antibody (mAB) injections overcome the requirement for thymic irradiation to achieve mixed chimerism in mice receiving bone marrow transplantation after conditioning with anti-T cell mABs and 3-Gy whole body irradiation

A relatively nontoxic method of conditioning mice has been developed recently that allows allogeneic bone marrow engraftment and specific skin allograft tolerance induction. This regiment included anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAbs administered on day -5, followed by 3-Gy whole body irradiation (WBI) and 7-Gy thymic irradiation (TI) on day 0. We have recently shown that the potential toxicity of this regimen can be further reduced by replacing TI with additional anti-T cell mAb injections before and after bone marrow transplantation. Mixed chimerism and prolonged donor-specific skin graft acceptance are induced in 90% of B10 mice conditioned with anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAbs on days -6 and -1 and 3-Gy WBI on day 0 without TI, but only in a small fraction of mice receiving a similar regimen, except that mAbs are given on day -5 only. To determine the mechanism of tolerance induction in the former group, we compared the two groups for the extent of thymocyte depletion, for the timing of development of intrathymic and extrathymic chimerism, and for clonal deletion of host-type thymocytes with TCR recognizing superantigens presented by donor class II molecules. The results suggest that administration of a second mAb injection depletes or inactivates residual host thymocytes that are capable of causing intrathymic rejection of donor hematopoietic cells even when peripheral engraftment is achieved. The presence of donor class II+ hematopoietic cells in the thymus on day 14 correlated with marked deletion of mature host-type V beta 11+ thymocytes that recognize donor I-E plus endogenous superantigen. This suggests that tolerance is achieved primarily through a central deletional mechanism when peripheral and intrathymic host T cells are adequately inactivated or depleted by mAbs and 3-Gy WBI. In addition, the higher incidence of early failure of peripheral chimerism in mice conditioned with a single injection rather than than two mAb injections prior to bone marrow transplantation suggests that nontolerant residual host thymocytes can also induce early peripheral rejection after mAbs have cleared from the circulation. This early rejection is prevented by the longer persistence of anti-T cell mAbs observed in mice receiving two pretransplant mAb injections. Thus, administration of sufficient depleting anti-T cells mAbs followed by 3-Gy WBI allows the induction of central deletional tolerance while minimizing the toxicity of the conditioning regimen.

Pancreatic islet allograft immunity and tolerance: the two-signal hypothesis revisited

The principle assumption of this discussion is that costimulation (CoS) forms the primary stimulus that compels T cells to mount a response to their specific antigen. However, this response can be either positive or negative, depending on the developmental stage of the T cell and the microenvironment in which the antigen and CoS are received. Thus, both immunity and tolerance may represent different outcomes of a two-signal process. We would emphasize that CoS is a functional term and not a strict molecular definition. While many molecular interactions have been described as providing CoS activity, notably those involving the B-7 family of cell surface molecules, it is not yet clear what combination(s) of non-antigen-specific signals may fulfil this function. This point is important because many studies have achieved tolerance through strategies designed to inhibit specific CoS molecules. However, it may be that differential signaling through distinct CoS molecules, rather than a global inhibition of CoS per se, plays a role in the generation of active tolerance in such studies (Bluestone 1995). A corollary of this notion is that antigen (signal 1) delivery to T cells is a null event and so is not an inherently paralysing signal. Of course, if signal 1 is not itself a tolerogenic signal, then other mechanisms are necessary to explain many empirical observations of tolerance to allogeneic or self antigens. This is best illustrated by those forms of functional tolerance to either alloantigens or self antigens that do not appear to be the result of clonal deletion/inactivation. It would be relatively simple to invoke a model of tolerance whereby the relevant tissue-destructive cell is eliminated or inactivated; such a model would preclude the necessity to suggest active regulatory mechanisms of tolerance. However, in several model systems, including our own observations concerning tolerance induction to APC-depleted islet allografts, tissue-destructive T cells can persist in recipients tolerant to allogeneic or self antigens. Furthermore, there are key examples in which tolerance demonstrates a dominant phenotype; that is, tolerant cells can regulate the activity of naive, non-tolerant cells. This latter observation points to the function of an active, regulatory form of tolerance. As such, we would emphasize that tolerance should not be defined as unresponsiveness since the tolerant state is the consequence of very active immune reactions.

Activation of autoreactive T-lymphocytes by cultured syngeneic glomerular mesangial cells

The capacity of intrinsic, glomerular mesangial cells (MC) to cause an autoreactive response of syngeneic lymphocytes in vitro are presented. Initial experiments demonstrated the MHC class II dependent capacity of MC to present exogenous antigen to sensitized lymph node lymphocytes (LN) and to activate naive, allogeneic LN in the absence of a nominal antigen. However, the most striking finding of the present investigation was that mouse MC (C57BL/6 or DBA/2) augmented a significant activation of naive, syngeneic lymphocytes. The extent of the proliferative lymphocyte response was comparable to that observed after stimulation with allogeneic MC. Moreover, during syngeneic coculture substantial amounts of interferon bioactivity were generated. Equipotent concentrations of rm IFN-gamma were sufficient to induce class II MHC expression of mouse MC. In control experiments the macrophage cell line, IC-21 (C57BL/6), or freshly prepared DBA/2 mouse peritoneal macrophages did not elicit a syngeneic LN response. Using MC, which had not been pretreated, the MC-specific LN stimulation occurred after prolonged periods of coculture. The stimulation index (S.I.) was 9.77 after 144 hours compared with LN controls (S.I. = 1). However, a 48 hour pretreatment of MC with either rm IFN-gamma alone or in combination with rh TNF-alpha and/or the continuous presence of rm IL-1 alpha during coculture periods from 72 to 144 hours substantially enhanced the proliferative LN response. Analysis of non-adherent LN by flow cytometry (FACS) after 96 or 120 hours coculture with MC revealed an increased ratio of Thy1.2+ to B220+ cells with a predominant rise of L3T4+ T-helper cells compared to Lyt2+ cytotoxic T-cells. Furthermore, immune fluorescence microscopy showed that a fraction of Thy1.2+ lymphoblasts adhered to MC. FACS analysis of these adherent LN after detachment demonstrated that in comparison to cocultures with untreated MC, cocultures of LN with IFN-gamma/TNF-alpha pre-treated MC resulted in a 24.4% increase of Thy1.2+ cells, with 89% of these being L3T4+ T-helper lymphocytes. In conclusion, autoreactivity of preferentially T-helper cells to cocultured glomerular MC was shown, which may represent a useful model of T-lymphocyte dependent glomerulonephritis.

Intrathymic and extrathymic tolerance in bone marrow chimeras

Parent-->F1 bone marrow (BM) chimeras provide a useful model for studying self tolerance induction. When prepared with supralethal irradiation (1300 cGy) and conditioned with anti-T cell antibodies, parent-->F1 BM chimeras are devoid of host BM-derived cells; host H-2 expression is apparent in both the intrathymic and extrathymic environments but is limited to non BM-derived cells. When parent-->F1 chimeras are injected with T cells from normal parental strain mice, the expression of host H-2 antigens on nonprofessional APC might be expected to induce tolerance through induction of clonal anergy. In practice, this does not occur. Instead, a small proportion of the injected T cells is induced to proliferate and differentiate into effector cells. Tolerance is not seen. Similarly, tolerance is not apparent when thymectomized parent-->F1 chimeras are given parental strain thymus grafts. These findings suggest that the expression of host H-2 antigens in the post-thymic environment of chimeras is not intrinsically tolerogenic for mature T cells or recent thymic emigrants. Interestingly, post-thymic tolerance does occur when parental strain T cells differentiate in the endogenous thymus of chimeras. Thus, when mature CD8+ cells are prepared from thymus vs lymph nodes (LN) of parent-->F1 chimeras, tolerance to host class I antigens is more marked in LN than thymus; this applies to cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors, generated by limiting dilution analysis. It would appear therefore that many of the host-reactive CTL precursors generated in the thymus of chimeras undergo tolerance induction (deletion or irreversible inactivation) in the post-thymic environment. We suggest that such tolerance is a reflection of a covert form of tolerance induced in the thymus: intrathymic contact with host antigens on thymic epithelial cells (TEC) in chimeras does not delete typical CTL precursors, but these cells are rendered "semi-tolerant". When cultured in vitro in the presence of lymphokines, the cells are able to recover and differentiate into CTL. In vivo, however, the cells recognize antigen in the periphery in the relative absence of lymphokines and the cells die. Although host class I expression on TEC in chimeras deletes only a small proportion of CTL precursors, contact with TEC induces strong tolerance of CD8+ cells in terms of helper-independent proliferative responses in vitro and induction of lethal graft-versus-host disease in vivo. We postulate that these latter responses are controlled by high-affinity T cells, whereas typical CTL generated in LDA are predominantly low-affinity cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Development of alpha beta T cells

Developing T cells in the thymus are subject to a screening process, through interactions with thymic stromal cells, from which T cells with appropriate T-cell receptors are selected. The recent generation of T-cell receptor transgenic mice and mice homozygous for disrupted T-cell receptor genes have now supplied tools that improve the prospect for a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms of this thymic selection process. In addition these model systems appear to indicate a role for a, not yet fully characterized, pre-T cell receptor complex in survival and further differentiation of pre-T cells.

Tolerance of CD8+ T cells developing in parent-->F1 chimeras prepared with supralethal irradiation: step-wise induction of tolerance in the intrathymic and extrathymic environments

Tolerance of CD8+ cells was examined in parent-->F1 bone marrow chimeras (BMC) prepared with supralethal irradiation; host class I expression in the chimeras was limited to non-BM-derived cells. In terms of helper-independent proliferative responses in vitro and induction of graft-vs.-host disease on adoptive transfer, CD8+ cells from long-term chimeras showed profound tolerance to host antigens irrespective of whether the cells were prepared from the thymus or from spleen or lymph nodes. By limiting dilution analysis, cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors specific for host antigens were rare in the extrathymic lymphoid tissues. In the thymus, by contrast, host-specific CTL precursors were only slightly less frequent than in normal parental strain mice. These host-specific CD8+ cells survived when BMC thymocytes were transferred intravenously to a neutral environment, i.e., to donor strain mice. When transferred to further BMC hosts, however, most of the host-reactive cells disappeared. Collectively, the data suggest that tolerance of CD8+ cells in BMC hosts occurs in both the intrathymic and extrathymic environments. In the thymus, contact with host antigens on thymic epithelial cells deletes CD8+ cells controlling helper-independent proliferative responses and in vivo effector functions but spares typical helper-dependent CTL precursors. After export from the thymus, most of the CTL precursors are eliminated after contacting host antigens on stromal cells in the extrathymic environment.

T cell tolerance and self/nonself discrimination

T cell tolerance to self antigens is at least partly a reflection of clonal deletion of immature T cells in the thymus. Although it is well accepted that intrathymic tolerance is primarily a reflection of T cell contact with bone-marrow (BM)-derived antigen-presented cells (APC), evidence is presented that thymic epithelial cells (TEC) can contribute to tolerance induction. Studies with thymocytes from BM chimeras suggest that selective contact with antigen on TEC induces clonal deletion of a subset of high-affinity T cells; these cells are primarily responsible for in vivo effector functions such as allograft rejection and induction of lethal graft-versus-host disease. Intrathymic contact with TEC fails to delete the typical low-affinity T cells which mediate cytotoxic responses in vitro when cultured with lymphokines. Deletion of these low-affinity T cells appears to require contact with BM-derived APC. Despite the evidence that self tolerance involves clonal deletion in the thymus, it is often stated that backup mechanisms for tolerance induction must exist in the post-thymic environment, but this has yet to be proved. The competing argument is that normal self/nonself discrimination is solely a reflection of intrathymic tolerance: the failure of T cells to react against tissue-specific antigens is not a reflection of post-thymic tolerance but simply that T cells and tissue-specific antigens are kept segregated.

Binding of T cell receptor to major histocompatibility complex class II-peptide complexes at the single-cell level results in the induction of antigen unresponsiveness (anergy)

Using dispersion cultures performed in semi-solid medium we demonstrate here that the interaction of T cell antigen receptor molecules with Ia-peptide complexes on the same cell surface results in T cell activation, without the production of lymphokines. This recognition of antigen at the single-cell level, induced a state of anergy which was not due to a decrease of surface T cell antigen receptor/CD3 complexes. The induction of anergy by peptide could not be prevented by the addition of various co-stimulatory signals, including antibodies to CD28, or CD2, high doses of interleukin-2 or phorbol ester.

Stimulation of mature unprimed CD8+ T cells by semiprofessional antigen-presenting cells in vivo

To test whether unprimed CD8+ cells can recognize class I alloantigens presented selectively on non-bone marrow (BM)-derived cells, unprimed parental strain CD8+ cells were transferred to long-term parent-->F1 BM chimeras prepared with supralethal irradiation. Host class I expression in the chimeras was undetectable on BM-derived cells and, in spleen, was limited to low-level staining of vascular endothelium and moderate staining of follicular dendritic cells (a population of nonhemopoietic cells in germinal centers). Despite this restricted expression of antigen, acute blood-to-lymph recirculation of parental strain T cells through the chimeras led to selective trapping of 95% of CD8+ cells reactive to normal F1 spleen antigen presenting cells (APC) in vitro. Subsequently, a small proportion of the trapped cells entered cell division and gave rise to effector cells expressing strong host-specific CTL activity. The activation of host-specific CD8+ cells was also prominent in double-irradiated chimeras, and cell separation studies showed that the effector cells were generated from resting precursor cells rather than from memory-phenotype cells. It is suggested that the non-BM-derived cells in the chimeras acted as semiprofessional APC. These cells were nonimmunogenic for most host-reactive CD8+ cells but were capable of stimulating a small subset of high-affinity T cells. The possible relevance of the data to the prolonged immunogenicity of vascularized allografts in humans is discussed.

Two subsets of epithelial cells in the thymic medulla

Information was sought on the features of epithelial cells in the murine thymic medulla. The expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules on medullary epithelium was defined by light microscopy with the aid of bone marrow chimeras and MHC-transgenic mice. A proportion of medullary epithelial cells was found to show conspicuously high expression of conventional MHC (H-2) class I (K, D, L) and class II (I-A, I-E) molecules. These cells express a high density of the Y-Ae epitope, a complex of an E alpha peptide and I-Ab molecules found on typical bone marrow-derived cells. MHC+ medullary epithelial cells show limited expression of I-O molecules, a class of atypical nonpolymorphic MHC-encoded class II molecules present on B cells. Other medullary epithelial cells express a high density of I-O molecules but show little or no expression of typical MHC class I or II molecules. MHC and I-O expression thus appear to subdivide medullary epithelial cells into two phenotypically distinct subsets. This applies in adults. In the embryonic thymus most medullary epithelial cells express both types of molecules.

Thymus-grafted SCID mice show transient thymopoiesis and limited depletion of V beta 11+ T cells

To seek direct evidence for the notion that stem cells in the thymus need to be constantly replenished from the bone marrow (BM), fetal (day 15) thymuses from normal BALB/c mice were grafted into T and B cell-deficient C.B-17 SCID mice (both H-2d, I-E+). The thymus grafts in these mice showed normal thymopoiesis for the first 3 wk postgrafting but then developed sudden atrophy with near complete loss of CD4+8+ cells by 4-5 wk. Such atrophy was not seen when the thymus-grafted mice were cotransplanted with normal BM cells. The lymph nodes of SCID mice receiving thymus grafts alone contained mature T cells but virtually no B cells. This lack of B cells was associated with aberrant I-E-restricted V beta deletion: the depletion of V beta 3+ and V beta 5+ T cells was near complete, whereas V beta 11+ cells showed only marginal depletion.

The role of cell division in the induction of clonal anergy

The interaction of antigen with lymphocyte antigen receptors can result in either clonal expansion or unresponsiveness (anergy). In 1970, Bretscher and Cohn proposed a two-signal model of lymphocyte activation to explain this paradox: antigen receptor occupancy alone could induce unresponsiveness whereas antigen receptor occupancy plus a costimulatory signal could induce immunity. Here, Marc Jenkins reviews in vitro and in vivo manifestations of clonal anergy and evaluates the ability of the two-signal model to explain these phenomena.

Regulation of autoimmunity

Despite the prevalence of self-reactive T cells, the healthy organism is not in a state of all-out war. Potent regulatory mechanisms exist at every level to permit the successful integration of the various aspects of the immune system, allowing only minor skirmishes, which ordinarily can be neutralized.