Longitudinal microradiography: a non-destructive automated quantitative method to follow mineral changes in mineralised tissue slices

Indirect caries-preventive effect of silver diamine fluoride on adjacent dental substrate: A single-section demineralization study

This study assessed the indirect effect of 38% silver diamine fluoride (SDF) on demineralization of adjacent untreated sound and pre-demineralized enamel and dentine using a single-section model for digital transverse microradiography (TMR-D). Forty-eight bovine dentine single sections were demineralized, stratified (n = 12) according to integrated mineral loss (ΔZ), and treated with SDF or deionized water (DIW). Each "treated dentine" section was attached between untreated sound and pre-demineralized enamel or dentine and then subjected to demineralization. ΔZ and lesion depths (LD) of all specimens at baseline, 24 and 48 h demineralization, and after treatment of "treated dentine" were quantified using TMR-D. Fluoride in the demineralization solution of SDF clusters was determined using an ion-selective electrode. ΔZ and LD of sound and ΔZ of pre-demineralized enamel adjacent to SDF-treated dentine did not increase over time. All untreated dentine demineralized significantly; however, ΔZ of sound dentine adjacent to SDF-treated specimen was still significantly lower than control. SDF-treated dentine remineralized and released fluoride even after 48 h. Consistent with clinical findings, when applied only to demineralized teeth in this chemical model, 38% SDF completely inhibited demineralization in adjacent untreated sound enamel. Demineralization prevention was observed to a lesser extent in adjacent pre-demineralized enamel but not in dentine.

Remineralization of Demineralized Enamel and Dentine Using 3 Dentifrices-An InVitro Study

Objectives: To monitor the electrical resistance of artificially demineralized enamel and root dentine after exposure to different fluoridated dentifrices and, using transversal microradiography, to quantify remineralization. Materials and methods: This in-vitro blind investigation used 20 extracted teeth (four groups of five each). Each group was exposed to one test dentifrice [Colgate PreviDent (5000 ppm F), Colgate Winterfresh gel (1100 ppm F), Fluocaril Bi-Fluoré (2500 ppm F) and placebo (without fluoride)] three times daily for three minutes for 4 weeks. In between exposure to the test dentifrices, teeth were stored in a saliva storage solution. An Electrical Caries Monitor measured the electrical resistance at baseline and during the four-week test period at weekly intervals. The measurements were log transformed and Duncan's multiple range test applied. Remineralization was quantified using transversal microradiography. Results: Log mean (SD) electronic carries monitor (ECM) measurements in enamel at baseline and after 4 weeks of exposure to the test dentifrices were 4.07(1.53) and 3.87(0.90) (Placebo-Fluocaril), 4.11(1.86) and 4.64(1.43) (Colgate Winterfresh gel), 4.81(0.9) and 4.21(1.20) (Fluocaril Bi-Fluoré), and 4.60(0.88) and 3.76(0.9) (Colgate PreviDent). Corresponding measurements in dentine were 2.13(0.89) and 3.06(0.87) (Placebo-Fluocaril), 1.87(0.63) and 2.88(1.32) (Colgate Winterfresh gel), 2.47(1.20) and 1.65(0.60) (Fluocaril), and 2.16(0.00), and 2.34(1.07) for Colgate PreviDent. Lesion depth (µm) after microradiography in enamel was 100.1 (Placebo), 50.6 (Colgate Winterfresh gel), and 110.2 (Fluocaril, and 97.1 (Colgate PreviDent), and corresponding values in dentine were 169.7, 154.8, 183.7, and 153.5. The correlation of ECM and microradiographic parameters was negative (p < 0.05). Conclusion: Exposure of artificially demineralized enamel and root dentine to fluoridated dentifrices and saliva storage solution resulted in remineralization as follows: Colgate Winterfresh > Colgate PreviDent > Placebo-Fluocaril > Fluocaril Bi-Fluoré. Remineralization in teeth of the Placebo dentifrice group may be attributed to the presence of calcium and phosphate ions in the saliva storage solution.

The Effect of Copper on Demineralization of Dental Enamel

Previous studies have concluded that copper might inhibit enamel demineralization in vitro. Our aim was to assess the effect of copper (Cu2+), with and without amine fluoride, on human dental enamel under cariogenic challenge in situ. In a double-blind randomized four-leg crossover trial, 14 individuals wore a removable appliance containing 2 enamel slabs, 1 containing an artificial caries lesion. During each leg, the appliance was exposed twice daily to one of the test solutions: 1.25 mM CuSO4, amine fluoride (250 ppm F), copper and amine fluoride combined, or a placebo (water). A cariogenic challenge was provided in all cases by 5 daily exposures to 10% sucrose. Slabs were assessed before and after 21 days’ exposure by Knoop microhardness and transverse microradiography. Significantly less demineralization was observed with Cu2+ and fluoride in combination than with fluoride treatment alone (p < 0.05), whereas copper alone had no significant protective effect.

The Application of in Vitro Models to Research on Demineralization and Remineralization of the Teeth: Reaction Paper

Despite the advantages of in situ model studies, in vitro models are most important to provide insight into the mechanism of dental caries, the mechanisms of fluoride action, and profile screening.

In this reaction paper following Dr. White's review, the emphasis is, first, on the role of mobile fluoride (FL) in fluoride efficacy, the formation of "CaF2-like" material as fluoride reaction product, and on fluoride reaction product localization. Second, mineral assessment techniques are discussed. Finally, the main differences between caries lesion formation in vitro and in situ are considered.

Review of Fluoride Release and Secondary Caries Reduction by Fluoridating Composites

Secondary caries is one of the main reasons to replace restorations. Due to the pressure to eliminate or reduce the number of amalgam restorations in many countries, fluoride-releasing composites have gained in importance. This review limits itself to information relevant to secondary caries near fluoride-releasing anterior or posterior composites. Although many parameters are very important in composite functioning, a weak spot near a filling is always the interface and the locally present interfacial gap between the composite and the hard tissues, where secondary caries takes place due to plaque action. Relevant parameters such as the amount of fluoride released in vitro in μg.cm-2, the rate of fluoride release, and the period of fluoride release are compared for several composites. In vitro F release has been measured for some fluoridating composites for more than five years. Unfortunately, F release in vivo or in situ cannot be measured adequately.

The fluoride released by the composites considered is partly taken up by the surrounding tissues, partly released to the saliva, and partly efficacious in possible marginal gaps and defects. A major part of this paper pertains to in vitro, in situ, and in vivo secondary caries reduction experiments. In vitro caries reductions in the order of 40% from F-releasing composites vs. controls have been found. In in situ model investigations under plaque and saliva conditions, secondary caries reduction percentages of between 40 and 50% have been experimentally measured in gaps in enamel near F composites.

Techniques to Evaluate Dental Erosion: A Systematic Review of Literature

This article reviews different techniques for evaluating dental erosion, weighs the advantages and disadvantages of these techniques, and presents the latest trends in the study of dental erosion. In May 2014, an initial search was carried out in the PubMed/MEDLINE database of indexed journals from 1975 to 2013 using the following keywords: dental erosion; dental erosion In-vitro; and dental erosion in-vivo. Bibliographic citations from the papers found were then used to find other useful sources. The authors categorize the techniques into three classes: in-vitro, in-vivo and in-vitro/in-vivo. The article discusses the instrumentation required to use each of these techniques, as well as their rationale, merits and applications. The emergence of in-vitro/in-vivo techniques offers the potential to accurately quantify tooth wear in clinical situations. Cross-sectional as well as longitudinal studies show that these techniques will improve diagnosis, treatment planning and management of dental erosion.

Quantitative remineralization evolution kinetics of artificially demineralized human enamel using photothermal radiometry and modulated luminescence

Human molars were subjected to demineralization in acid gel followed by incubation in remineralization solutions without or with fluoride (1 or 1000 ppm). Photothermal radiometry (PTR) and modulated luminescence (LUM) frequency scans were performed prior to and during de/remineralization treatments. Transverse Micro-Radiography (TMR) analysis followed at treatment conclusion to determine mineral loss and lesion depth. The remineralization process illustrated a complex interplay between surface and subsurface mineral deposition, confining the thermal-wave centroid toward the dominating layer. Experimental amplitudes and phases were fitted to a coupled diffuse-photon-density-wave and thermal-wave theoretical model used to quantitatively evaluate evolving changes in thermal and optical properties of de/remineralized enamel lesions. Additional information obtained from the LUM data corroborated the remineralization kinetics affecting the PTR signals. The results pointed to enhanced effectiveness of subsurface lesion remineralization in the presence of fluoride.

Quantitative evaluation of the kinetics of human enamel simulated caries using photothermal radiometry and modulated luminescence

Photothermal radiometry and modulated luminescence (PTR-LUM) is an emerging nondestructive methodology applied toward the characterization and quantification of dental caries. We evaluate the efficacy of PTR-LUM in vitro to detect, monitor, and quantify human enamel caries. Artificial caries are created in extracted human molars (n = 15) using an acidified gel system (pH 4.5) for 10 or 40 days. PTR-LUM frequency scans (1 Hz-1 kHz) are performed before and during demineralization. Transverse microradiography (TMR) analysis, the current gold standard, follows at treatment conclusion to determine the mineral loss and depth of the artificially demineralized lesions. A theoretical model is applied to PTR experimental data to evaluate the changes in optothermophysical properties of demineralized enamel as a function of time. Higher optical scattering coefficients and poorer thermophysical properties are characteristic of the growing demineralized lesions, as verified by TMR, where the generated microporosities of the subsurface lesion confine the thermal-wave centroid. Enhanced optical scattering coefficients of demineralized lesions result in poorer luminescence yield due to scattering of both incident and converted luminescent photons. PTR-LUM sensitivity to changes in tooth mineralization coupled with opto-thermophysical property extraction illustrates the technique's potential for nondestructive quantification of enamel caries.

Optothermophysical properties of demineralized human dental enamel determined using photothermally generated diffuse photon density and thermal-wave fields

Noninvasive dental diagnostics is a growing discipline since it has been established that early detection and quantification of tooth mineral loss can reverse caries lesions in their incipient state. A theoretical coupled diffuse photon density and thermal-wave model was developed and applied to photothermal radiometric frequency responses, fitted to experimental data using a multiparameter simplex downhill minimization algorithm for the extraction of optothermophysical properties from artificially demineralized human enamel. The aim of this study was to evaluate the reliability and robustness of the advanced fitting algorithm. The results showed a select group of optical and thermal transport parameters and thicknesses were reliably extracted from the computational fitting algorithm. Theoretically derived thicknesses were accurately predicted, within about 20% error, while the estimated error in the optical and thermal property evaluation was within the values determined from early studies using destructive analyses. The high fidelity of the theoretical model illustrates its efficacy, reliability, and applicability toward the nondestructive characterization of depthwise inhomogeneous sound enamel and complex enamel caries lesions.

Nondestructive Assessment of Early Tooth Demineralization Using Cross-Polarization Optical Coherence Tomography

New methods are needed for the nondestructive measurement of tooth demineralization and remineralization to monitor the progression of incipient caries lesions (tooth decay) for effective nonsurgical intervention and to evaluate the performance of anticaries treatments such as chemical treatments or laser irradiation. Studies have shown that optical coherence tomography (OCT) has great potential to fulfill this role since it can be used to measure the depth and severity of early lesions with an axial resolution exceeding 10 µm, it is easy to apply in vivo and it can be used to image the convoluted topography of tooth occlusal surfaces. In this paper, a review of the use of polarization-sensitive-OCT for the measurement of tooth demineralization is provided along with some recent results regarding improved methods for the detection of caries lesions in the earliest stages of development. Automated methods of analysis were used to measure the depth and severity of demineralized bovine enamel produced using simulated caries models that emulate demineralization in the mouth. Significant differences in the depth and integrated reflectivity from the lesions were detected after only a few hours of demineralization. These results demonstrate that cross-polarization-OCT is ideally suited for the nondestructive assessment of early demineralization.

Distortional effect of beam-hardening artefacts on microCT: a simulation study based on an in vitro caries model

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess quantitatively the degrading effect of artefacts caused by beam hardening on the microscopic computerized tomography (microCT) measurements of an in vitro caries model.

STUDY DESIGN

A simulation-based method was described, with which the degrading effect of microCT artefacts on certain parameters of the observed structure could be determined. Simulations were carried out with polychromatic and monochromatic X-ray source, and a linearization method with a second-order polynomial fit algorithm was used in specific cases to correct the beam hardening artefact. The virtual test object was a half-crown of a tooth with an artificial caries lesion.

RESULTS

For simulation with monochromatic X-ray source, the relative error of lesion depth and thickness measurements of the remineralized layer was found to be 1%-2%. For polychromatic X-ray source, and omitting beam hardening correction, the relative error exceeded 6%. After appropriate beam-hardening correction, the relative error of the measurement could be reduced to 1%-2%.

CONCLUSION

With the adjustment simulated in this study, microCT having polychromatic X-ray source resulted in the same level of error as with monochromatic source if the linearization method to correct the beam hardening was used. The presented simulation-based method is a useful way to determine artefact-caused distortions for other studies testing objects with different material and geometry.

A large X-chromosomal deletion is associated with microphthalmia with linear skin defects (MLS) and amelogenesis imperfecta (XAI)

A female patient is described with clinical symptoms of both microphthalmia with linear skin defects (MLS or MIDAS) and dental enamel defects, having an appearance compatible with X-linked amelogenesis imperfecta (XAI). Genomic DNA was purified from the patient's blood and semiquantitative multiplex PCR revealed a deletion encompassing the amelogenin gene (AMELX). Because MLS is also localized to Xp22, genomic DNA was subjected to array comparative genomic hybridization, and a large heterozygous deletion was identified. Histopathology of one primary and one permanent molar tooth showed abnormalities in the dental enamel layer, and a third tooth had unusually high microhardness measurements, possibly due to its ultrastructural anomalies as seen by scanning electron microscopy. This is the first report of a patient with both of these rare conditions, and the first description of the phenotype resulting from a deletion encompassing the entire AMELX gene. More than 50 additional genes were monosomic in this patient.

An Automated Digital Microradiography System for Assessing Tooth Demineralization

Digital Transverse microradiography (TMR) offers several advantages over film based methods including real-time image acquisition, excellent linearity with exposure, and it does not require expensive specialized film. The purpose of this work was to demonstrate that a high-resolution digital microradiography system can be used to measure the volume percent mineral loss for sound and demineralized enamel and dentin thin sections from 150-350-μm in thickness. A custom fabricated digital microradiography system with ~ 2-μm spatial resolution consisting of a digital x-ray imaging camera, a computerized high-speed motion control system and a high-intensity copper Kα; x-ray source was used to determine the volume percent mineral content of sound and demineralized tooth sections. The volume percent mineral loss was compared with cross-sectional microhardness measurements on sound extracted human teeth. The correlation between microhardness and microradiography was excellent (Pr=0.99) for section thickness ranging from 59-319-μm (n=13). The attenuation was linear with varying exposure time from 1-10 seconds. Digital TMR is an effective and rapid method for the assessment of the mineral content of enamel and dentin thin sections.

Transversal Wavelength-Independent Microradiography, a Method for Monitoring Caries Lesions over Time, Validated with Transversal Microradiography

This paper describes a microradiographic method for measuring mineral concentration in a transversal geometry with thick (< or =3.2 mm) sections: transversal wavelength-independent microradiography (T-WIM). It was tested on bovine enamel and dentin samples in vitro, and the results were validated with those of transversal microradiography (TMR). 48 enamel and 48 dentin samples (3.2 x 3.2 x 1.5 mm) were embedded in acrylic resin, randomly divided into six groups of 8 dentin or 8 enamel samples, and demineralized for 0 (sound control), 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 weeks. For T-WIM, samples were imaged on film with polychromatic 40-kV Cu X-rays with an Al (0.25 mm)/Ni (0.02 mm) filter together with an aluminium/zinc step wedge. TMR slices (about 80 mum for enamel and about 130 mum for dentine) were subsequently cut from the centre of the samples and subjected to TMR. Microradiographs from both methods were digitized and image analysis software was used to calculate lesion depth and mineral loss. The relations between T-WIM and TMR results for mineral loss (DeltaZ) and lesion depth were nearly linear (r > or = 0.96) for both enamel and dentin. The slopes of the regression lines were between 0.99 and 1.02 except for DeltaZ in dentine, which was 0.89. It was concluded that T-WIM is a suitable method for TMR on thick samples.

Longitudinal study of the three-dimensional development of subsurface enamel lesions during in vitro demineralisation

A longitudinal study was made of the 3D development of subsurface enamel lesions in whole human molars. X-ray microtomography (XMT) was used to measure the 3D distribution of linear attenuation coefficients in the tissue at 8-15 stages during cumulative times of 36-107 days demineralisation through approximately 1-mm-wide windows. Although lesion morphology was consistent with preferential anisotropic dissolution parallel to enamel prisms at the advancing front, detail (at a scale of approximately 100 microm) varied in relation to exposed surface sites separated by <1 mm. The distribution of mineral in the most superficial region varied across the exposed face of each lesion. Within lesions, localised foci of low mineral concentration (at a scale of approximately 200 microm) retained their general form through successive stages of demineralisation before coalescing. The most advanced regions within a lesion seemed to correspond with surface regions with lowest mineral concentration. These findings indicate that local variations in fractional pore volume of partially demineralised enamel influence the subsequent spatial development of lesions.

Detection of in vitro demineralization adjacent to restorations using quantitative light induced fluorescence (QLF)

AIM

Quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) is a technique for the detection, quantification, and longitudinal monitoring of early carious lesions. The technique is non-destructive and can be used in vivo. Using the natural fluorescence of teeth, and the loss of such fluorescence in demineralized enamel, QLF is a repeatable and valid optical caries monitor. Previously used in smooth and occlusal surfaces, the purpose of this pilot study was to determine if QLF could detect, and longitudinally monitor, demineralization adjacent to a range of restorative materials.

METHODS

Fifteen previously extracted lower third molars were selected based upon the lack of any visible demineralization. A single burr hole was placed on the buccal surface and the cavity restored with amalgam, composite, compomer, glass ionomer or a temporary filling material. The buccal surface was then coated in an acid resistant nail varnish leaving an exposed area around the restoration and also a similar sized control region. The teeth had QLF images taken at baseline and were then subjected to a demineralizing buffer, further QLF images were subsequently taken at 72 and 144 h. Transverse microradiography was used to confirm the presence of early, subsurface lesions at the completion of the cycle (144 h). QLF images were analyzed by a single blinded examiner and values for change in radiance fluorescence were computed. These values were recorded as loss of radiance fluorescence loss integrated over area of lesion and expressed as DeltaQ.

RESULTS

The appearance of each material under QLF and the change in fluorescence is described. Amalgam, glass ionomer and the temporary material all exhibited reduced fluorescence, while composite and compomer showed increased fluorescence, when compared with surrounding enamel. There was no change in fluorescence of the materials when subjected to experimental demineralizing conditions. Readings at 72 and 144 h demonstrated demineralization adjacent to the restorations and at the exposed control. Significant differences were detected between baseline, 72 and 144 h using ANOVA on all restorations with the exception of compomer where significance was noted between baseline and 144 h, p>0.05.

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study has demonstrated the ability for QLF to detect and monitor secondary caries. Analysis techniques should be based upon the subtraction of baseline DeltaQ scores from subsequent images. Further research is required to assess the ability of QLF to detect secondary lesions in vivo.

Detection of in vitro demineralization of primary teeth using quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF)

INTRODUCTION

With the advent of remineralizing therapies and the new, conservative approach to restoration placement, interest in detecting and monitoring subclinical, precavitated lesions has increased. The increased understanding of clinicians about the processes of primary and secondary prevention and the detection of lesions to which these therapies may be applied, is one of the current goals in caries management. Quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) is a new method for the detection of very early caries.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the ability of QLF to detect and longitudinally monitor in vitro enamel demineralization. To present the device to the paediatric community and present future in vivo uses of the device.

DESIGN

An in vitro study with combined in vivo pilot.

SAMPLE AND METHODS

Twelve previously extracted, caries free, primary molars were selected and prepared. Two teeth were randomly selected as controls. Teeth were prepared by gentle pumicing and coating in an acid-resistant nail-varnish, except for an exposed window on the buccal surface. QLF baseline images were taken and the teeth then exposed to a demineralizing solution. Teeth were removed at regular intervals (24, 48, 72, 96, 120, and 144 h), air-dried and QLF images taken. QLF images were analysed by a single, blinded examiner (to control, to length of exposure). Mineral loss, as measured by DeltaQ, was recorded.

RESULTS

Demineralization was noted in all experimental teeth by 48 h, and within 24 h in six teeth. The QLF successfully monitored the increase in mineral loss over time (P < 0.05). The detected lesions were not visible clinically until 144 h and then in only the most severe lesions. No demineralization was detected by QLF in control teeth. The device was user- and patient-friendly in vivo, detecting subclinical lesions.

CONCLUSION

Detection of very early mineral loss and subsequent monitoring of this loss is possible in primary teeth using QLF. The device is well suited to use in paediatric dentistry and offers applications for both clinicians and researchers. The determination of the status of carious lesions (active/inactive) will be possible with readings taken at recall appointments.

Determination of mineral concentration in dental enamel from X-ray attenuation measurements

The mineral content of dental enamel is commonly measured by X-ray attenuation experiments. Most studies have used contact microradiography in which intensities are measured with photographic film which is convenient and gives high spatial resolution. However photon counting intensity measurements are to be preferred in many experiments (longitudinal and scanning microradiography, and microtomography), as illustrated here, because they have a larger dynamic range and greater sensitivity to small intensity changes. Additionally, the detector and specimen are well separated which allows the pseudo-continuous study of de- and remineralization. The mineral content is often quoted as 95 wt% or 87 vol% hydroxyapatite for permanent human enamel. This determination from attenuation experiments requires accurate values of elemental mass attenuation coefficients and a number of assumptions. The effects of possible choices of these are considered and it is shown that the most important is the density of enamel mineral used in conversion of wt% to vol%. If the density is taken as 2.99 g cm(-3), as recently suggested (J.C. Elliott, Dental Enamel, Ciba Foundation Symposium 205, Wiley, Chichester, pp. 54-72, 1997), instead of 3.15 g cm(-3) as for hydroxyapatite, the calculated vol% is approximately 93 instead of approximately 87.

Measurement of enamel remineralization using microradiography and confocal microscopy. A correlational study

Tooth minerals are lost and regained constantly in a normal, human oral environment. Different methods have been developed to measure this gain and loss in enamel minerals; however, these methods deal with different problems, such as being time consuming or involving the use of X-rays. The aim of this study was to determine if remineralization measured in a thin enamel section (TS) by transversal microradiography (MR) can be reliably monitored by measuring lesion parameters (area, total and average dye fluorescence) on the same TS or on half a tooth (HT) with confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM). Thirty-six human enamel specimens were demineralized for 96h, and then half of each specimen was covered with an acid-resistant nail varnish. Specimens were divided into three groups (12/group) and subjected for 20 days to a cyclic remineralization regimen with consisted daily of a 4-hour acid challenge, four 1-min treatment periods with 0, 250 or 1,100 ppm F dentifrice slurries (1:2; dentifrice:water) and 20 h in pooled, human saliva, at room temperature. Specimens were cut and analyzed by MR, then stained with a fluorescent dye (0.1mM rhodamine B) for 1 h and analyzed using CLSM. Both MR and CLSM detected significantly greater remineralization (p<0.05) in the specimens treated with the fluoride-containing dentifrices than in the specimens treated with 0 ppm F. Significant differences were detected between specimens treated witht the fluoride-containing dentifrices by MR and CLSM (HT area and total fluorescence). Statistically significant (p<0.05) Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated between the MR and CLSM data: difference in MR mineral content (DeltaM) versus HT lesion area = 0.71; DeltaM versus HT total fluorescence = 0.70; DeltaM versus HT average fluorescence = 0.61; DeltaM versus TS lesion area = 0.88; DeltaM versus TS total fluorescence = 0.63, and DeltaM versus TS average fluorescence = 0.40. It is concluded that confocal microscopy in either TS or HT may provide valid surrogates (area and total fluorescence) for MR measurements in enamel remineralization studies.

Rates of mineral loss in human enamel during in vitro demineralization perpendicular and parallel to the natural surface

Human enamel is a structurally anisotropic material. The aim of this study was to investigate whether this structural anisotropy is reflected in the demineralization behaviour of enamel. Kinetics of demineralization of in vitro caries lesions with the direction of acid attack perpendicular to the natural surface of dental enamel from human premolar teeth were compared with kinetics when demineralized parallel to this surface. Pairs of enamel samples from the same tooth were demineralized under identical conditions. Loss of mineral with time was very nearly linear for both directions (consistent with the rate-controlling step being reaction at the advancing front rather than transport processes), but the perpendicular rate was, on average, about 14% higher than the parallel rate. The rate of demineralization parallel to the surface increased from the natural surface to the enamel-dentine junction by 10-25%, depending on sample. The origin of fine structure and slight departures from linearity in the loss of mineral with time plots are discussed. Mineral masses per unit area were determined from absorption of a 15-microm diameter X-ray beam using photon (AgKalpha) counting methods.

Experimental intra-oral caries models in fluoride research

The use of experimental intra-oral caries models has increased in fluoride research. This paper focuses on the pre-clinical intra-oral models, the in situ and in vivo models, the various types, their benefits and disadvantages. Both preparation and sterilization of the hard tissue substrates can affect the substrates and therefore the results. Care needs to be taken that dentine samples are not exposed to drying and consequently shrinking during preparation and evaluation. Sterilization by gamma-radiation is at present the least tissue-damaging method. The most realistic experimental model is the in vivo model, followed by the in situ model using specimens with natural surfaces. The most accurate and direct evaluation technique for demineralization and remineralization studies is quantitative transversal microradiography, whereas confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) is the most sensitive qualitative evaluation technique. Other evaluation techniques discussed are microhardness testing and the iodine permeability test. In light of the present skewed caries situation in western countries we suggest that fluoride research focuses on experimental caries models that can mimic severe cariogenic challenge. Testing of fluoride combinations and dosages that can prevent lesion development rather than promote remineralization would then be a practical consequence.

Scanning microradiographic studies of rates of in vitro demineralization in human and bovine dental enamel

The aim was to measure frequently and with precision the local integrated mineral loss through small areas of the natural surface of human and bovine enamel during in vitro demineralization using an X-ray photon-counting system (scanning microradiography). The method used was an adaptation of photographic longitudinal microradiography in which the attenuation of X-rays through the enamel is measured in the direction of acid attack, i.e., normal to the enamel surface. The mass of mineral (assumed to be hydroxyapatite) per unit exposed area was measured over 15 microm dia. circles at a series of positions as a function of time in blocks of human and bovine enamel immersed in 0.1 mol/l acetic acid buffered to pH 4.0 with NaOH. There was an initial period (approx. 45 h for human, approx. 75 h for bovine enamel) during which the mineral loss with time was sigmoidal, followed by a nearly linear loss for the remainder of the experiment, in some cases up to 500 h. The initial sigmoidal period may be due to properties of surface enamel or be associated with the development of a surface layer overlying subsurface demineralization. The essentially constant rate of mineral loss after the surface layer has formed confirms earlier observations and is consistent with a rate-limiting process occurring at the dissolving enamel surfaces of the advancing front, and not by transport of ions within the lesion. Small perturbations from a linear loss were seen, which were approximately periodic for human enamel. The slope of the linear period was rather constant within one human or bovine block, but variable between blocks without a clear distinction between human and bovine enamel.

Effects of aluminum (III) and fluoride on the demineralization of bovine enamel: a longitudinal microradiographic study

Longitudinal microradiography has been used to determine inhibiting effects of aluminum (III), Al, and fluoride on mineral loss from slices of bovine enamel exposed to a demineralizing solution 4 h daily for 35 days. Inhibitor treatment was 5 min four times daily. For the remaining time, the samples were immersed in a neutral calcium phosphate solution which allowed neither remineralization nor demineralization. This study indicates that a 1-mM (27 ppm) solution of Al in a 0.1-M lactate solution, pH 5, has an inhibitory effect on the in vitro demineralization of bovine enamel. Application of this solution alternating with 20 mM (380 ppm) fluoride gave the same total inhibition as treatment with 20 mM fluoride alone.

Demineralization and remineralization evaluation techniques

This paper compares the experimental techniques utilized to assess the de- or remineralization of enamel or dentin in intra-oral studies. In in situ studies, it is important for one to know how much mineral has been lost or gained, and where the loss or gain occurred. The main emphasis in this paper is on techniques suitable for direct or indirect mineral quantification. The measuring techniques considered are microradiography, iodine absorptiometry, various microhardness tests, polarized light, light-scattering, iodide permeability, and wet chemical analysis. The various techniques are compared concerning suitability for the determination of mineral content in vol% (or wt%), mineral changes in vol% micron (or kg.m-2), and mineral distributions. Furthermore, sample preparation, the importance of protein penetration, nominal mineral loss range, the estimated mineral loss threshold, and the applicability to dentin are compared and considered. It is concluded that, although more than ten techniques are available for the measurement of changes after de- or remineralization in situ, transverse microradiography is the most practical technique for the direct and quantitative measurement of mineral content, mineral changes, and mineral distributions. Cross-sectional microhardness testing and light-scattering are also practical indirect techniques for quantitative mineral loss (or gain) determination in intra-oral studies.

A review of quantitative methods for studies of mineral content of intra-oral caries lesions

Modern prospective caries studies require the measurement of small changes in tooth mineral content. Quantitative measurements of changes in mineral content in a single caries lesion is desirable. Quantitative methods can be either destructive or non-destructive. The latter type permits longitudinal studies to be conducted. Various methods available for the analysis of lesion parameters are reviewed. The basic principle of each method is summarized, and its characteristics are discussed. For each method, the correlation between the measured parameter and mineral loss, the useful range of mineral loss, the discrimination threshold, and the repeatability, are presented. Where such quantities were not available in the original papers, they were calculated from literature data. A comprehensive table of specifications of all methods is given.

Wavelength-independent microradiography used for quantification of mineral changes in thin enamel and dentin samples with natural surfaces, pseudo-thick tooth sections, and whole teeth

Tests of the efficacy of therapeutic agents for caries repair or prevention in vitro or in situ should be performed as realistically as possible. This implies the non-destructive assessment of mineral changes in whole teeth. In this study, Wavelength-independent Microradiography (WIM), a non-destructive form of microradiography that uses polychromatic x-rays, was tested for its use in following mineral changes during demineralization of whole teeth. Since the method was, in a previous paper, only tested on flat samples of about 0.3 mm in thickness, the present study aimed to adapt and test WIM for use on thicker samples. This was done in three steps: In the first step, natural surfaces were introduced. The mineral content of enamel and dentin samples about 0.3 mm in thickness and with natural (curved) surfaces was determined by WIM, and the result was compared with mineral measurements performed with Longitudinal Microradiography (LMR). A correlation of 0.98 was found for both the enamel and the dentin samples. In the second step, the thickness of whole teeth was added. Thick tooth sections were simulated by addition of a 5-mm block of dentin to such thin enamel and dentin samples. Mineral measurements with WIM of the samples plus the dentin block were compared with mineral measurements of the thin samples (without block). A correlation of 0.97 was found for enamel, and one of 0.90 was found for dentin. Finally, in a third step, the demineralization of whole premolars was followed as a function of time.

Wavelength-independent microradiography: a method for non-destructive quantification of enamel and dentin mineral concentrations using polychromatic x-rays

Wavelength-independent Microradiography (WIM), described in this paper, used polychromatic, high-energy (less than or equal to 60 kV) x-rays for determination of mineral concentrations in tooth material non-destructively. This was done with the aid of a reference step-wedge made of 94% aluminum, 6% zinc. The mass attenuation coefficient of this material has a wavelength-independent ratio to the mass attenuation coefficients of enamel and dentin. With this method, mineral concentrations of enamel and dentin samples, with a thickness up to 500 microns, were determined at 20- and at 60-kV tube voltage. The samples were demineralized for 72 and 144 h and measured again. Comparison of the data showed that mineral quantification was within 1.5%, independent of the x-rays used. Finally, these mineral concentrations--obtained from the Wavelength-independent Microradiography--were compared with measurements of the same samples by Longitudinal Microradiography. A correlation of 0.99 was found for enamel and one of 0.96 for dentin.

Root hard-tissue demineralization rate measured by 125I absorptiometry: comparison with lesion-depth measurements

The aim of the present study was to compare demineralization of root hard tissue, monitored by 125I absorptiometry, with lesion-depth measurements under polarized light microscopy. The intact roots of ten human molars, which had not been exposed to the oral environment, were divided into 39 cementum/dentin blocks and exposed to a buffer solution of pH 4.5 containing 2.2 mmol/L calcium and inorganic phosphate. After demineralization for 3.5, 7, 14, and 21 days, transmission measurements by 125I absorptiometry were performed, and one block from each tooth was taken out of the solution for lesion-depth measurement. The results showed a high degree of correlation (r = 0.952) between lesion depth and change in transmission, with a more rapid increase initially in both variables. A linear relationship with the square root of time was found. Conversion of transmission data to lesion-depth data was possible when this caries model system was used on cementum dentin blocks.

Optical quantification of caries-like lesions in vitro by use of a fluorescent dye

An experimental method was developed for measurement of the fluorescence intensity of a dye that was introduced into caries-like lesions in vitro. A distinct pattern of change of fluorescence intensity with time appeared, displaying a plateau value and a peak value for each measurement. Both plateau and peak values showed a linear correlation with calcium loss, as measured with longitudinal microradiography. The correlation coefficients were r = 0.87 for plateau values and r = 0.89 for peak values. The difference in scattering by dry and wet caries lesions was also measured with the same equipment, which showed a linear correlation with calcium loss of r = -0.53.

In vitro root caries progression measured by 125I absorptiometry: comparison with chemical analysis

Radiation from a 125I source and a non-image-forming detector was used for non-destructive measurements of root caries progression. Blocks were cut parallel to the cementum surface of unexposed human roots. These blocks were then individually demineralized in under-saturated calcium phosphate solutions over an 84-hour period. In order for the in vitro root surface demineralization to be followed, the changes in transmission (delta T) through the blocks were measured, by 125I absorptiometry, eight times during the course of the experiment. Chemical analyses of the calcium output (delta Ca) from the blocks into the demineralizing solutions were also performed, and the rate of demineralization (Vdem) was calculated from these values. The precision of 125I absorptiometry was calculated from 176 duplicate transmission measurements, and the coefficient of variation was found to be 0.20%. The correlation coefficient between delta T and total delta Ca for each of 22 cementum/dentin blocks ranged between r = 0.934 and r = 0.998. The progression of root hard-tissue lesions observed by these two methods and by the calculated Vdem was found to be proportional to the square and cubic roots of time. The study shows that 125I absorptiometry can be used for continuous non-destructive measurements of root hard-tissue demineralization in vitro.

A method of semi-quantitative microradiographic analysis of root surface lesion remineralization

The purpose of this study was to present a modified photometer based digital analysis system for image enhanced microradiographic semi-quantitation of reactions of demineralization and remineralization of root surface lesions. The system was used to determine effects of fluoride on abraded root surface dentin in vitro. Lesions of 30-40 micron depth were produced during 18 h exposure of 180 micron thick single sections in solution of 3 mM Ca (Ca/P 1.67) and 30 mM lactic acid at pH 5.1. Mean mineral content of the lesions was 32% relative to adjacent sound dentin. Exposure of 20 h in the same acid with 5 mM Ca (Ca/P 1.67) and 0.12 mM NaF at pH 6.1 restored the mean mineral content to 76% of normal and increased the resistance of the lesions to demineralization. Remineralization and subsequent demineralization characteristics indicated the growth of fluorapatites on residual minerals in the dentin lesions. The microradiographic analysis system proved to be sensitive and critical in these studies.