Cloned antigens and antiidiotypes

Quality of Recombinant Protein Determines the Amount of Autoreactivity Detected against the Tumor-Associated Epithelial Cell Adhesion Molecule Antigen: Low Frequency of Antibodies against the Natural Protein

The human epithelial cell adhesion molecule (EpCAM) is expressed on normal epithelial cells and is overexpressed in most carcinomas. EpCAM-targeted immunotherapy has been tried in several clinical studies. High titers of autoantibodies against EpCAM have been reported by different authors. We have generated large amounts of purified protein in S2 Drosophila cells (S2-EpCAM) with a purity of >96%. In contrast, the protein produced in baculovirus-dependent systems (baculo-EpCAM) that has been used in previous studies shows a purity of 79%. (1)H nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of S2-EpCAM is typical of folded protein, whereas the baculo-EpCAM sample shows a spectrum corresponding to a partially unfolded protein. Using S2-EpCAM, denatured S2-EpCAM, and baculo-EpCAM, we measured EpCAM Abs of different isotypes in the serum of healthy controls and cancer patients. We found Ab titers against EpCAM in a much lower percentage of sera as published previously, and support the hypothesis that Ab reactivity in some published studies might be due to reactivity against denatured protein, to contaminating proteins in the baculovirus preparations, and to reactivity with BSA. Tetanus toxoid-reactive IgG Abs are present in 1000-fold higher titers compared with EpCAM-reactive Abs. Only IgA Abs were found in higher proportions and in higher concentrations than tetanus toxoid-specific Abs. Our study shows that EpCAM only rarely induces autoantibodies against native protein and emphasizes the importance of using extremely purified Ag preparations when evaluating Abs against tumor-associated Ags.

Recombinant CD63/ME491/neuroglandular/NKI/C-3 antigen inhibits growth of established tumors in transgenic mice

Attempts to vaccinate against tumors can be hindered by the induction of immunological tolerance to the target Ag as a result of Ag expression on normal tissues. In this study, we find that transgenic mice expressing the melanoma-associated Ag CD63/ME491/neuroglandular/NKI/C-3 on their normal tissues do, in fact, exhibit immunological tolerance to the Ag, recapitulating the conditions in cancer patients. In these mice, growth of murine melanoma cells expressing the Ag after gene transfer was inhibited by immunization with Ag-expressing recombinant vaccinia virus combined with IL-2, but not by immunization with the protein alone, anti-idiotypic Abs, or irradiated tumor cells. The effect of the recombinant virus was demonstrated both for nonestablished and established tumors. Infiltration with both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T lymphocytes was significantly more extensive in tumors from experimental mice than in tumors from control mice. MHC class I-positive, but not class I-negative, tumors were inhibited by the vaccine, suggesting that MHC class I-restricted T lymphocytes play a role in the antitumor effects. Abs did not appear to be involved in the vaccine effects. CD63 was immunogenic in 2 of 13 melanoma patients, pointing to the potential of this Ag, combined with IL-2, as a vaccine for melanoma patients.

Expression of an antigen homologous to the human CO17-1A/GA733 colon cancer antigen in animal tissues

The CO17-1A/GA733 antigen is associated with human carcinomas and some normal epithelial tissues. This antigen has shown promise as a target in approaches to passive and active immunotherapy of colorectal cancer. The relevance of animal models for studies of immunotherapy targeting this antigen in patients is dependent on the expression of the antigen on normal animal tissues. Immunohistoperoxidase staining with polyclonal rabbit antibodies to the human antigen revealed the human homologue on normal small intestine, colon and liver of mice, rats and non-human primates, whereas mouse monoclonal antibodies to the CO17-1A or GA733 epitopes on the human antigen did not detect the antigen. Polyclonal rabbit antibodies, elicited by the murine antigen homologue derived from recombinant baculovirus-infected insect cells, immunoprecipitated the antigen from mouse small intestine, colon, stomach, kidney and lung. The isolated recombinant murine protein bound polyclonal, but not monoclonal, antibodies to the human CO17-1A/GA733 antigen, and recombinant human antigen bound polyclonal antibodies elicited by the murine antigen homologue. Thus, the antigen homologue expressed by animal tissues is similar, but not identical, to the human antigen. These results have important implications for experimental active and passive immunotherapy targeting the CO17-1A/GA733 antigen.

Animal models of human-derived cancer vaccines

Preclinical cancer vaccine studies must address vaccine safety, immunogenicity, and efficacy, as well as mechanism of vaccine action. Animal models of vaccines employing human tumor-associated antigen or epitopes (TAA, TAE) differ fundamentally from those employing tumor-specific antigens or epitopes (TSA, TSE). TSA and TSE vaccines will most likely demonstrate similar toxicity, immunogenicity, and efficacy in both tumor-bearing animals and patients. In contrast, TAA/TAE immunizations may have to overcome a host's immunological tolerance to TAA/TAE expressed not only on tumor, but also on normal tissues; immunity to TAA/TAE will potentially target normal tissues and thus may induce autoimmunity. Various experimental models for human-derived TAA/TAE vaccines have been developed. These models include transgenic mice, mice with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID), and non-human primates. Recently, unique animal models of TAA/TAE cancer vaccines have been developed, taking advantage of the discovery of animal tissue antigens with significant sequence homologies to human TAA/TAE. These models mimic perhaps most closely the situation in cancer patients.