The effects of E mu, 3'alpha (hs 1,2) and 3'kappa enhancers on mutation of an Ig-VDJ-Cgamma2a Ig heavy gene in cultured B cells

The IgH Eµ-MAR regions promote UNG-dependent error-prone repair to optimize somatic hypermutation

Intoduction

Two scaffold/matrix attachment regions (5'- and 3'-MARs_Eµ ) flank the intronic core enhancer (cEµ) within the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus (IgH). Besides their conservation in mice and humans, the physiological role of MARs_Eµ is still unclear and their involvement in somatic hypermutation (SHM) has never been deeply evaluated.

Methods

Our study analyzed SHM and its transcriptional control in a mouse model devoid of MARs_Eµ , further combined to relevant models deficient for base excision repair and mismatch repair.

Results

We observed an inverted substitution pattern in of MARs_Eµ -deficient animals: SHM being decreased upstream from cEµ and increased downstream of it. Strikingly, the SHM defect induced by MARs_Eµ -deletion was accompanied by an increase of sense transcription of the IgH V region, excluding a direct transcription-coupled effect. Interestingly, by breeding to DNA repair-deficient backgrounds, we showed that the SHM defect, observed upstream from cEµ in this model, was not due to a decrease in AID deamination but rather the consequence of a defect in base excision repair-associated unfaithful repair process.

Discussion

Our study pointed out an unexpected "fence" function of MARs_Eµ regions in limiting the error-prone repair machinery to the variable region of Ig gene loci.

Requirement for enhancer specificity in immunoglobulin heavy chain locus regulation

The intronic Emicro enhancer has been implicated in IgH locus transcription, VDJ recombination, class switch recombination, and somatic hypermutation. How Emicro controls these diverse mechanisms is still largely unclear, but transcriptional enhancer activity is thought to play a central role. In this study we compare the phenotype of mice lacking the Emicro element (DeltaEmicro) with that of mice in which Emu was replaced with the ubiquitous SV40 transcriptional enhancer (SV40eR mutation) and show that SV40e cannot functionally complement Emu loss in pro-B cells. Surprisingly, in fact, the SV40eR mutation yields a more profound defect than DeltaEmicro, with an almost complete block in micro0 germline transcription in pro-B cells. This active transcriptional suppression caused by enhancer replacement appears to be specific to the early stages of B cell development, as mature SV40eR B cells express micro0 transcripts at higher levels than DeltaEmicro mice and undergo complete DNA demethylation at the IgH locus. These results indicate an unexpectedly stringent, developmentally restricted requirement for enhancer specificity in regulating IgH function during the early phases of B cell differentiation, consistent with the view that coordination of multiple independent regulatory mechanisms and elements is essential for locus activation and VDJ recombination.

The biochemistry of somatic hypermutation

Affinity maturation of the humoral response is mediated by somatic hypermutation of the immunoglobulin (Ig) genes and selection of higher-affinity B cell clones. Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is the first of a complex series of proteins that introduce these point mutations into variable regions of the Ig genes. AID deaminates deoxycytidine residues in single-stranded DNA to deoxyuridines, which are then processed by DNA replication, base excision repair (BER), or mismatch repair (MMR). In germinal center B cells, MMR, BER, and other factors are diverted from their normal roles in preserving genomic integrity to increase diversity within the Ig locus. Both AID and these components of an emerging error-prone mutasome are regulated on many levels by complex mechanisms that are only beginning to be elucidated.

AID mutates a non-immunoglobulin transgene independent of chromosomal position

It is unknown how activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) targets immunoglobulin (Ig) genes during somatic hypermutation. Results to date are difficult to interpret: while some results argue that Ig genes have special sequences that mobilize AID, other work shows that non-Ig transgenes mutate. In this report, we have examined the effects of the intronic mu enhancer on the somatic hypermutation rates of a retroviral vector. For this analysis, we used centroblast-like Ramos cells to capture as much of the natural process as possible, used AIDhi and AIDlow Ramos variants to ensure that mutations are AID induced, and measured mutation of a GFP-provirus to achieve greater sensitivity. We found that mutation rates of the non-Ig provirus were AID-dependent, were similar at different genomic loci, but were approximately 10-fold lower than the V-region suggesting that AID can mutate non-Ig genes at low rates. However, the intronic mu enhancer did not increase the mutation rates of the provirus. Interestingly, exogenous over-expression of AID revealed that the V-region mutation rate can be saturated by lower levels of AID than the provirus, suggesting that selective mutation of Ig sequences is compromised in cells that over-express AID.

Complex regulation of somatic hypermutation by cis-acting sequences in the endogenous IgH gene in hybridoma cells

To create high-affinity antibodies, B cells target a high rate of somatic hypermutation (SHM) to the Ig variable-region genes that encode the antigen-binding site. This mutational process requires transcription and is triggered by activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), which converts deoxycytidine to deoxyuridine. Mistargeting of AID to non-Ig genes is thought to result in the malignant transformation of B cells, but the mechanism responsible for targeting SHM to certain DNA regions and not to others is largely unknown. Cis-acting elements have been proposed to play a role in directing the hypermutation machinery, but the motifs required for targeting SHM have been difficult to identify because many of the candidate elements, such as promoters or enhancers, are also required for transcription of Ig genes. Here we describe a system in cultured hybridoma cells in which transcription of the endogenous heavy-chain Ig gene continues in the absence of the core intronic enhancer (Emu) and its flanking matrix attachment regions (MARs). When AID is expressed in these cells, SHM occurred at the WT frequency even when Emu and the MARs were absent together. Interestingly, SHM occurred at less than the WT frequency when Emu or the MARs were individually absent. Our results suggest that these intronic regulatory elements can exert a complex influence on SHM that is separable from their role in regulating transcription.

Retroviral vectors to monitor somatic hypermutation

The recent expansion of studies on hypermutation may benefit from a fast and uncomplicated way to measure mutation rates. In this paper we compare different retroviral vector designs for monitoring hypermutation in vivo. Retroviral vectors combine a high transduction rate with integration at random sites within the host cell genome, thus equalizing positional effects on the reporter gene. The vectors contain a reporter gene with a premature TAG termination codon; upon reversion, a full-length fluorescent protein is expressed. Any single point mutation at the amber codon activates the reporter--except the transition from G to A, which only creates the stop codon TAA. In the construct, the reporter gene is followed by an internal ribosome entry site and a second marker that allows selection of stably transduced cells. As a reporter gene, we tested the green and yellow fluorescence proteins (GFP and YFP); and various proteins with red fluorescence (dsRed). The second marker was either a drug resistance gene, or a second fluorescent protein. We also introduced various cis-acting enhancer elements into the reporter construct, to study the simultaneous activity of enhancers on transcription and hypermutation. We found that GFP as a reporter, combined with a drug selection marker, gave the most consistent and convenient mutation rate measurements. DsRed is a good alternative to GFP, but variants with greater fluorescence intensity are needed when combined with green fluorescence measurements. We also confirm that no immunoglobulin specific sequence is needed to target hypermutation. Depending on their position in these ectopically expressed constructs, enhancers can have positive or negative effects on hypermutation.

Somatic hypermutation of the AID transgene in B and non-B cells

Somatic hypermutation (SHM) of the Ig genes is required for affinity maturation of the humoral response to foreign antigens. Activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), which is specifically expressed in germinal center centroblasts, is indispensable for this process. Expression of AID is sufficient to activate SHM in hybridomas, non-B cells, and Escherichia coli, suggesting that it initiates the mutational process by deaminating DNA. However, the cis-acting sequences that are responsible for targeting AID activity to the variable (V) region of Ig genes are unknown. Here we show that expression of AID in B cell lines (i.e., Burkitt's lymphoma Ramos and hybridoma P1-5) not only causes hypermutation of Ig sequences, but also of the AID transgene itself. Because it is possible that B cell-specific transacting factors bind to and recruit the "mutator" to the AID transgene, we tested whether the AID transgene can mutate in non-B cells. Indeed, we show that expression of AID in Chinese hamster ovary cells causes SHM of both the Ig and AID transgenes. These data suggest that high transcription rates alone may predispose any gene to mutation by AID but do not preclude that there are specific B cell factors that account for the extremely high rate of V mutation in vivo and its targeting to the V region.

Mutation detection of immunoglobulin V-regions by DHPLC

One of the key features in the affinity maturation of antibodies is somatic hypermutation of the variable regions of immunoglobulin genes. The mutations that occur in immunoglobulin genes are detected by direct sequencing of cloned polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products. The frequencies of mutations in vivo are generally high enough to provide sufficient numbers of point mutations in order to generate large databases that can be analyzed in various ways. Recently, the mechanisms of variable (V)-region hypermutation have been studied in tissue culture systems and transgenic mice where mutation occurs at frequencies that are approximately 10-fold lower than the estimated in vivo rate. Identifying mutations by brute force sequencing of PCR products in comparative studies is limiting when trying to determine if there are statistically significant differences. Here we describe a high throughput technique that can facilitate the identification of immunoglobulin V-regions that contain one or more mutations before sequencing. This technique, known as denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC), utilizes a standard HPLC apparatus with a column that binds double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). In this study, we have successfully detected approximately 90% of previously sequenced mutated V-regions by DHPLC. Our results show that we were able to detect mutations throughout a 321-base pair (bp) region of the Ricin 45 immunoglobulin (Ig) V-region. Also, with the use of this assay, we have been able to detect mutations in multiple clones of different immunoglobulin genes.