Limited effect of chromatin remodeling on D(beta)-to-J(beta) recombination in CD4+CD8+ thymocyte: implications for a new aspect in the regulation of TCR beta gene recombination

Differential regulation of proximal and distal Vbeta segments upstream of a functional VDJbeta1 rearrangement upon beta-selection

Developmental stage-specific regulation of transcriptional accessibility helps control V(D)J recombination. Vβ segments on unrearranged TCRβ alleles are accessible in CD4(-)/CD8(-) (double-negative [DN]) thymocytes, when they recombine, and inaccessible in CD4(+)/CD8(+) (double-positive [DP]) thymocytes, when they do not rearrange. Downregulation of Vβ accessibility on unrearranged alleles is linked with Lat-dependent β-selection signals that inhibit Vβ rearrangement, stimulate Ccnd3-driven proliferation, and promote DN-to-DP differentiation. Transcription and recombination of Vβs on VDJβ-rearranged alleles in DN cells has not been studied; Vβs upstream of functional VDJβ rearrangements have been found to remain accessible, yet not recombine, in DP cells. To elucidate contributions of β-selection signals in regulating Vβ transcription and recombination on VDJβ-rearranged alleles, we analyzed wild-type, Ccnd3(-/-), and Lat(-/-) mice containing a preassembled functional Vβ1DJCβ1 (Vβ1(NT)) gene. Vβ10 segments located just upstream of this VDJCβ1 gene were the predominant germline Vβs that rearranged in Vβ1(NT/NT) and Vβ1(NT/NT)Ccnd3(-/-) thymocytes, whereas Vβ4 and Vβ16 segments located further upstream rearranged at similar levels as Vβ10 in Vβ1(NT/NT)Lat(-/-) DN cells. We previously showed that Vβ4 and Vβ16, but not Vβ10, are transcribed on Vβ1(NT) alleles in DP thymocytes; we now demonstrate that Vβ4, Vβ16, and Vβ10 are transcribed at similar levels in Vβ1(NT/NT)Lat(-/-) DN cells. These observations indicate that suppression of Vβ rearrangements is not dependent on Ccnd3-driven proliferation, and DN residence can influence the repertoire of Vβs that recombine on alleles containing an assembled VDJCβ1 gene. Our findings also reveal that β-selection can differentially silence rearrangement of germline Vβ segments located proximal and distal to functional VDJβ genes.

Regulation of V(D)J recombination

Adaptive immunity is intimately linked to the expression of antigen-specific immunoglobulin and T cell receptor genes and their recombination assembly from germline V, D and J gene segments. This developmentally regulated process relies on the activity of the Rag1-Rag2 recombinase, on accessibility of target gene segments and on monoallelic gene activation. Recent studies have revealed new mechanisms that, along with recombinase activity and locus accessibility, are likely to contribute to the control of V(D)J recombination, including target-site bias by the recombinase, RNA processing and chromosome positioning.

Turning T-cell receptor ? recombination on and off: more questions than answers

Successful V(D)J recombination at the T-cell receptor beta (Tcrb) locus is critical for early thymocyte development. The locus is subject to a host of regulatory mechanisms that impart a strict developmental order to Tcrb recombination events and that insure that Tcrb recombination occurs in an allelically excluded fashion. Progress has been made in the understanding of the cis-acting control of Tcrb locus chromatin structure and the extent to which such accessibility control can account for the developmental regulation of Tcrb recombination. However, recent studies in our laboratory and elsewhere have made it abundantly clear that accessibility control is only part of the story, and multiple additional mechanisms impact both the developmental activation and inactivation of locus recombination events. Here we evaluate our current understanding of developmental regulation at the Tcrb locus. We highlight the many unresolved issues and we discuss how recent concepts emerging from studies of other antigen receptor loci may (or may not) help to resolve these issues.

The TCRbeta enhancer is dispensable for the expression of rearranged TCRbeta genes in thymic DN2/DN3 populations but not at later stages

The Ebeta enhancer has been shown to be dispensable for germline transcription of nonrearranged TCRbeta segments but appears to be required for TCRbeta V to DJ rearrangement. Ebeta dependency of the subsequent expression of VDJ-rearranged TCRbeta genes in thymic subpopulations has so far not been analyzed. We generated transgenic mice, using a Vbeta8.2Dbeta1Jbeta1.3-rearranged TCRbeta bacterial artificial chromosome, which lacked Ebeta, and monitored transgene expression by flow cytometry using Vbeta-specific mAbs and an IRES-eGFP reporter. Transgene expression was found in double negative (DN)2 and DN3 but not at later stages of thymopoesis. There was no toxicity associated with the transgene given that apoptosis in DN3, DN4 was not increased, and the number of DN4 cells generated from DN3 cells in reaggregate thymic organ cultures was not diminished. The transgenic TCRbeta gave rise to a pre-TCR, as suggested by its ability to suppress endogenous TCRbeta rearrangement, to facilitate beta-selection on a TCRbeta-deficient background and to inhibit gammadelta T cell lineage development. The results suggest that the Vbeta8.2 promoter is sufficient to drive expression of rearranged TCRbeta VDJ genes Ebeta independently in DN2/DN3 but not at later stages.

The positional effect of Eβ on Vβ genes of TCRβ chain in the ordered rearrangement and allelic exclusion

In the TCRbeta gene locus, the Vbeta, Dbeta and Jbeta gene segments are assembled in a tightly ordered manner. To investigate the positional effects of TCRbeta enhancer (Ebeta) on the recombination processes of the Vbeta genes, we utilized beta(LD) mice lacking 70% of the TCRbeta locus, leaving four Vbeta genes at the 5' side and, consequently, the Vbeta10 gene moves into the Ebeta regulatory region. In this mutant mouse, the Vbeta10 gene showed direct Vbeta-to-Dbeta and Vbeta-to-Jbeta recombination, although the Dbeta-to-Jbeta joining was still predominant. Interestingly, these two aberrant recombination processes were barely suppressed when beta(LD) mice were crossed with TCRbeta transgenic mice, whereas V(D)J recombination of the Vbeta10 gene was sufficiently suppressed. These results suggest that the positional effects of Ebeta on the Vbeta genes may enable the recombination potential to increase prior to Dbeta-to-Jbeta joining and that such aberrant recombination may be free from allelic suppression.

Regulation of T cell receptor beta allelic exclusion at a level beyond accessibility

Allelic exclusion of V(beta)-to-DJ(beta) recombination depends on asynchronous rearrangement of alleles of the gene encoding T cell receptor beta in double-negative thymocytes and feedback inhibition that is maintained in double-positive thymocytes. Feedback is thought to be enforced through downregulation of V(beta) accessibility. In an attempt to override this negative regulation, we introduced the enhancer of the gene encoding T cell receptor alpha into the V(beta) gene cluster downstream of V(beta)12. In double-negative thymocytes, the introduced enhancer had no measurable effect on accessibility, but V(beta)12 rearrangement was stimulated and V(beta)12 allelic exclusion was partially subverted. In contrast, double-positive thymocytes showed increased V(beta) transcription and accessibility, but feedback inhibition of V(beta)-to-DJ(beta) recombination remained intact. Our results indicate additional regulatory constraints on V(beta)-to-DJ(beta) recombination that operate beyond the accessibility barrier.

Increase of TCR V beta accessibility within E beta regulatory region influences its recombination frequency but not allelic exclusion

Seventy percent of the murine TCRbeta locus (475 kb) was deleted to generate a large deleted TCRbeta (beta(LD)) allele to investigate a possible linkage between germline transcription, recombination frequency, and allelic exclusion of the TCR Vbeta genes. In these beta(LD/LD) mice, the TCRbeta gene locus contained only four Vbeta genes at the 5' side of the locus, and consequently, the Vbeta10 gene was located in the original Dbeta1-Jbeta1cluster within the Ebeta regulatory region. We showed that the frequency of recombination and expression of the Vbeta genes are strongly biased to Vbeta10 in these mutant mice even though the proximity of the other three 5'Vbeta genes was also greatly shortened toward the Dbeta-Jbeta cluster and the Ebeta enhancer. Accordingly, the germline transcription of the Vbeta10 gene in beta(LD/LD) mice was exceptionally enhanced in immature double negative thymocytes compared with that in wild-type mice. During double negative-to-double positive transition of thymocytes, the level of Vbeta10 germline transcription was prominently increased in beta(LD/LD) recombination activating gene 2-deficient mice receiving anti-CD3epsilon Ab in vivo. Interestingly, however, despite the increased accessibility of the Vbeta10 gene in terms of transcription, allelic exclusion of this Vbeta gene was strictly maintained in beta(LD/LD) mice. These results provide strong evidence that increase of Vbeta accessibility influences frequency but not allelic exclusion of the TCR Vbeta rearrangement if the Vbeta gene is located in the Ebeta regulatory region.

Assessing the role of the T cell receptor beta gene enhancer in regulating coding joint formation during V(D)J recombination

To assess the role of the T cell receptor (TCR) beta gene enhancer (Ebeta) in regulating the processing of VDJ recombinase-generated coding ends, we assayed TCRbeta rearrangement of Ebeta-deleted (DeltaEbeta) thymocytes in which cell death is inhibited via expression of a Bcl-2 transgene. Compared with DeltaEbeta, DeltaEbeta Bcl-2 thymocytes show a small accumulation of TCRbeta standard recombination products, including coding ends, that involves the proximal Dbeta-Jbeta and Vbeta14 loci but not the distal 5' Vbeta genes. These effects are detectable in double negative pro-T cells, predominate in double positive pre-T cells, and correlate with regional changes in chromosomal structure during double negative-to-double positive differentiation. We propose that Ebeta, by driving long range nucleoprotein interactions and the control of locus expression and chromatin structure, indirectly contributes to the stabilization of coding ends within the recombination processing complexes. The results also illustrate Ebeta-dependent and -independent changes in chromosomal structure, suggesting distinct modes of regulation of TCRbeta allelic exclusion depending on the position within the locus.

Epigenetic mechanisms that regulate antigen receptor gene expression

Functional immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor genes are generated from germline V, D and J gene segments by a series of site-specific recombination events. This process is regulated by the availability of recombination machinery and by the ordered accessibility of appropriate target gene segments. Recent studies highlight the importance of chromatin remodelling and locus positioning for controlling antigen receptor gene expression and recombination.

Modifications of histone cores and tails in V(D)J recombination

The organization of chromatin and modifications to the tails of histone proteins are thought to be important in regulating the rearrangement of V, D and J gene segments, which encode immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors. A recent study shows that methylated lysine 79 in the core region of histone H3 also plays a role by providing a euchromatic 'mark' that may regulate access of the V(D)J recombinase.

T cell receptor (TCR) alpha/delta locus enhancer identity and position are critical for the assembly of TCR delta and alpha variable region genes

T cell receptor (TCR) delta and alpha variable region genes are assembled from germ-line gene segments located in a single chromosomal locus in which TCR delta segments are situated between TCR alpha segments. The TCR alpha enhancer (E alpha) located at the 3' end of the TCR alpha/delta locus functions over a long chromosomal distance to promote TCR alpha rearrangement and maximal TCR delta expression; whereas the TCR delta enhancer (E delta) is located among the TCR delta segments and functions with additional element(s) to mediate TCR delta rearrangement. We used gene-targeted mutation to evaluate whether the identity of E alpha and the position of E delta are critical for the developmental stage-specific assembly of TCR delta and alpha variable region genes. Specific replacement of E alpha with E delta, the core E alpha element (E alpha C), or the Ig heavy chain intronic enhancer (iE mu), all of which promote accessibility in the context of transgenic V(D)J recombination substrates, did not promote a significant level of TCR alpha rearrangement beyond that observed in the absence of E alpha. Therefore, the identity and full complement of E alpha-binding sites are critical for promoting accessibility within the TCR alpha locus. In the absence of the endogenous E delta element, specific replacement of E alpha with E delta also did not promote TCR delta rearrangement. However, deletion of intervening TCR alpha/delta locus sequences to restore the inserted E delta to its normal chromosomal position relative to 5' sequences rescued TCR delta rearrangement. Therefore, unlike E alpha, E delta lacks ability to function over the large intervening TCR alpha locus and or E delta function requires proximity to additional upstream element(s) to promote TCR delta accessibility.

Differential regulation between gene expression and histone H3 acetylation in the variable regions of the TCRbeta locus

Histone acetylation is suggested to regulate gene expression in the TCR loci. Using R2CD3 mouse model, we previously showed that germline transcription of the TCRbeta chain gene is discrete between 5' Vbeta regions and Dbeta-Jbeta-Cbeta clusters plus Vbeta14 region. In this study, we investigated a role of histone H3 acetylation in transcriptional regulation of the TCRbeta locus. Our results showed that DN-DP transition is accompanied by significant promotion of histone H3 acetylation in both Dbeta-Jbeta-Cbeta cluster and Vbeta14 region, correlating with up-regulation of germline transcription. Surprisingly, termination of germline transcription of the 5' Vbeta regions was inversely correlated with histone H3 hyperacetylation. Moreover, histone H3 acetylation showed equivalent level in both functionally rearranged Vbeta region with active transcription and unrearranged Vbeta region without transcription in mature T cells. These results suggest that histone acetylation is not a sole limiting factor in both terminating germline Vbeta transcription during DN-DP transition and maintaining functionally rearranged Vbeta gene expression.

Inactivation of Notch1 impairs VDJbeta rearrangement and allows pre-TCR-independent survival of early alpha beta Lineage Thymocytes

Notch proteins influence cell fate decisions in many developmental systems. During lymphoid development, Notch1 signaling is essential to direct a bipotent T/B precursor toward the T cell fate, but the role of Notch1 at later stages of T cell development remains controversial. We have recently reported that tissue-specific inactivation of Notch1 in immature (CD44(-) CD25(+)) thymocytes does not affect subsequent T cell development. Here, we demonstrate that loss of Notch1 signaling at an earlier (CD44(+)CD25(+)) developmental stage results in severe perturbation of alpha beta but not gamma delta lineage development. Immature Notch1(-/-) thymocytes show impaired VDJ beta rearrangement and aberrant pre-TCR-independent survival. Collectively, our data demonstrate that Notch1 controls several nonredundant functions necessary for alpha beta lineage development.

The mechanism and regulation of chromosomal V(D)J recombination

V(D)J recombination is of fundamental importance to the generation of diverse antigen receptor repertoires. We review our current understanding of the V(D)J recombination reaction and how it is regulated during lymphocyte development. We also discuss how defects in the mechanism or regulation of V(D)J recombination can lead to human disease.