Suicide induced by cytolytic activity controls the differentiation of memory CD8(+) T lymphocytes

Inefficient boosting of antitumor CD8(+) T cells by dendritic-cell vaccines is rescued by restricting T-cell cytotoxic functions

Dendritic cells (DCs) are powerful activators of primary and secondary immune responses and have promising activity as anticancer vaccines. However, various populations of immune cells, including natural killer cells, regulatory T cells and especially cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), can inhibit DC function through cytotoxic clearance. Spontaneous tumor-specific CTL responses are frequently observed in patients before immunotherapy, and it is unclear how such pre-existing responses may affect DC vaccines. We used an adoptive transfer model to show that DC vaccination fail to induce the expansion of pre-existing CTLs or increase their production of interferon γ (IFNγ). The expansion and effector differentiation of naïve host CD8⁺ T cells was also suppressed in the presence of CTLs of the same specificity. Suppression was caused by the cytotoxic functions of the adoptively transferred CTLs, as perforin-deficient CTLs could respond to DC vaccination by expanding and increasing IFNγ production. Proliferation and effector differentiation of host CD8⁺ T cells as well as resistance to tumor challenge were also significantly increased. Expression of perforin by antitumor CTLs was critical in regulating the survival of vaccine DCs, while FAS/FASL and TRAIL/DR5 had a significant, but comparatively smaller, effect. We conclude that perforin-expressing CTLs can suppress the activity of DC-based vaccines and prevent the expansion of naïve and memory CD8⁺ T cells as well as antitumor immune responses. We suggest that, paradoxically, temporarily blocking the cytotoxic functions of CTLs at the time of DC vaccination should result in improved vaccine efficiency and enhanced antitumor immunity.

The granzyme B-Serpinb9 axis controls the fate of lymphocytes after lysosomal stress

Cytotoxic lymphocytes (CLs) contain lysosome-related organelles (LROs) that perform the normal degradative functions of the lysosome, in addition to storage and release of powerful cytotoxins employed to kill virally infected or abnormal cells. Among these cytotoxins is granzyme B (GrB), a protease that has also been implicated in activation (restimulation)-induced cell death of natural killer (NK) and T cells, but the underlying mechanism and its regulation are unclear. Here we show that restimulation of previously activated human or mouse lymphocytes induces lysosomal membrane permeabilisation (LMP), followed by GrB release from LROs into the CL cytosol. The model lysosomal stressors sphingosine and Leu-Leu-methyl-ester, and CLs from gene-targeted mice were used to show that LMP releases GrB in both a time- and concentration-dependent manner, and that the liberated GrB is responsible for cell death. The endogenous GrB inhibitor Serpinb9 (Sb9) protects CLs against LMP-induced death but is decreasingly effective as the extent of LMP increases. We also used these model stressors to show that GrB is the major effector of LMP-mediated death in T cells, but that in NK cells additional effectors are released, making GrB redundant. We found that limited LMP and GrB release occurs constitutively in proliferating lymphocytes and in NK cells engaged with targets in vitro. In Ectromelia virus-infected lymph nodes, working NK cells lacking Sb9 are more susceptible to GrB-mediated death. Taken together, these data show that a basal level of LMP occurs in proliferating and activated lymphocytes, and is increased on restimulation. LMP releases GrB from LROs into the lymphocyte cytoplasm and its ensuing interaction with Sb9 dictates whether or not the cell survives. The GrB-Sb9 nexus may therefore represent an additional mechanism of limiting lymphocyte lifespan and populations.

Rapid and unidirectional perforin pore delivery at the cytotoxic immune synapse

The effective engagement of cytotoxic lymphocytes (CLs) with their target cells is essential for the removal of virus-infected and malignant cells from the body. The spatiotemporal properties that define CL engagement and killing of target cells remain largely uncharacterized due to a lack of biological reporters. We have used a novel live cell microscopy technique to visualize the engagement of primary human and mouse CL with their targets and the subsequent delivery of the lethal hit. Extensive quantitative real-time analysis of individual effector-target cell conjugates demonstrated that a single effector calcium flux event was sufficient for the degranulation of human CLs, resulting in the breach of the target cell membrane by perforin within 65-100 s. In contrast, mouse CLs demonstrated distinct calcium signaling profiles leading to degranulation: whereas mouse NKs required a single calcium flux event, CD8(+) T cells typically required several calcium flux events before perforin delivery. Irrespective of their signaling profile, every target cell that was damaged by perforin died by apoptosis. To our knowledge, we demonstrate for the first time that perforin pore delivery is unidirectional, occurring exclusively on the target cell membrane, but sparing the killer cell. Despite this, the CTL membrane was not intrinsically perforin resistant, as intact CTLs presented as targets to effector CTLs were capable of being killed by perforin-dependent mechanisms. Our results highlight the remarkable efficiency and specificity of perforin pore delivery by CLs.

An emerging role for Serine Protease Inhibitors in T lymphocyte immunity and beyond

Serine proteases control a wide variety of physiological and pathological processes in multi-cellular organisms, including blood clotting, cancer, cell death, osmo-regulation, tissue re-modeling and immunity to infection. T lymphocytes are required for adaptive cell mediated immunity and serine proteases are not only important for effector function but also homeostatic regulation of cell numbers. Serine Protease Inhibitors (Serpins) are the physiological regulators of serine proteases activity. In this review, I will discuss the role of serpins in controlling the recognition of antigen, effector function and homeostatic control of T lymphocytes through the inhibition of physiological serine protease targets. An emerging view of serpins is that they are important promoters of cellular viability through their inhibition of executioner proteases. This will be discussed in the context of the T lymphocyte survival during effector responses and the development and persistence of long-lived memory T cells. The potent anti-apoptotic properties of serpins can also work against adaptive cell immunity by protecting viruses and tumors from eradication by cytotoxic T cells (CTL). Recent insights from knock-out mouse models demonstrate that these serpins also are required for hematological progenitor cells and so are critical for the development of lineages other than T lymphocytes. Given the emerging role of serpins in multiple aspects of lymphocyte immunity and blood development I will review the progress to date in developing new immunotherapeutic approaches based directly on serpins or knowledge gained from identifying their physiologically relevant protease targets.

Serine protease inhibitors and cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Serine proteases control a wide variety of physiological and pathological processes in multi-cellular organisms, including blood clotting, cancer, cell death, osmoregulation, tissue remodeling, and immunity to infection. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are required for adaptive cell-mediated immunity to intracellular pathogens by killing infected cells and through the development of memory T cells. Serine proteases not only allow a CTL to kill but also impose homeostatic control on CTL number. Serine protease inhibitors (serpins) are the physiological regulators of serine proteases' activity. In this review, I discuss the role of serpins in controlling the recognition of antigen, effector function, and homeostatic control of CTLs through the inhibition of physiological serine protease targets. An emerging view of serpins is that they are important promoters of cellular viability through their inhibition of executioner proteases. This view is discussed in the context of the T-lymphocyte survival during effector responses and the development and persistence of long-lived memory T cells. Given the important role serpins play in CTL immunity, I discuss the potential for developing new immunotherapeutic approaches based directly on serpins or knowledge gained from identifying their physiologically relevant protease targets.

Intrinsic and extrinsic control of effector T cell survival and memory T cell development

Following infection or vaccination T cells expand exponentially and differentiate into effector T cells in order to control infection and coordinate the multiple effector arms of the immune system. Soon after this expansion, the majority of antigen-specific T cells die to reattain homeostasis and a small pool of memory T cells forms to provide long-term immunity to subsequent re-infection. Our understanding of how this process is controlled has improved considerably over the recent years, but many questions remain outstanding. This review focuses on the recent advancements in this area with an emphasis on how the contraction of activated T cells is coordinately regulated by a combination of factors extrinsic and intrinsic to the activated T cells.

Perforin: more than just a pore-forming protein

Cellular apoptosis induced by T cells is mainly mediated by two pathways. One, granule exocytosis utilizes perforin/granzymes. The other involves signaling through death receptors of the TNF-alpha R super-family, especially FasL. Perforin plays a central role in apoptosis induced by granzymes. However, the mechanisms of perforin-mediated cytotoxicity are still not elucidated completely. Perforin is not only a pore-forming protein, but also performs multiple biological functions or perforin performs one biological function (cytolysis), but has multiple biological implications in the cellular immune responses, including regulation of proliferation of CD8+ CTLs.

Switch from perforin-expressing to perforin-deficient CD8(+) T cells accounts for two distinct types of effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vivo

Although CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) exhibit both Fas ligand (FasL) -based and perforin-based lytic activities, the accepted hallmark of a fully active CTL remains its perforin killing machinery. Yet the origin, rationale for possessing both a slow-acting (FasL) and a fast-acting (perforin) killing mechanism has remained enigmatic. Here we have investigated perforin expression in CTL directly involved in acute tumour (i.e. leukaemias EL4 and L1210) allograft rejection occurring within the peritoneal cavity. We show that at the height of the immune response, the majority of conjugate-forming CD8(+) CTL express high levels of perforin messenger RNA and protein, and kill essentially via perforin. Later however, coinciding with complete rejection, fully cytocidal CTL emerge which exhibit a stark decrease in perforin and now kill preferentially via constitutively expressed FasL. Although late in emergence, and persistent, these powerful CTL are neither effector-memory nor memory CTL. This finding has implications for the monitoring of anti-transplant responses in clinical settings, based on assessing perforin expression in graft infiltrating CD8(+) T cells. The results show that as the immune response progresses in vivo, targeted cellular suicide mainly prunes high perforin-expressing CD8(+) cells, resulting in the gradual switch in effector CTL, from mostly perforin-based to largely Fas/FasL-based killers. Hence, two kinds of CD8(+) CTL have two killing strategies.

Clonal focusing of epitope-specific CD8+ T lymphocytes in rhesus monkeys following vaccination and simian-human immunodeficiency virus challenge

To afford the greatest possible immune protection, candidate human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) vaccines must generate diverse and long-lasting CD8(+) T lymphocyte responses. In the present study, we evaluate T-cell receptor Vbeta (variable region beta) gene usage and a CDR3 (complementarity-determining region 3) sequence to assess the clonality of epitope-specific CD8(+) T lymphocytes generated in rhesus monkeys following vaccination and simian-human immunodeficiency virus (SHIV) challenge. We found that vaccine-elicited epitope-specific CD8(+) T lymphocytes have a clonal diversity comparable to those cells generated in response to SHIV infection. Moreover, we show that the clonal diversity of vaccine-elicited CD8(+) T-lymphocyte responses is dictated by the epitope sequence and is not affected by the mode of antigen delivery to the immune system. Clonal CD8(+) T-lymphocyte populations persisted following boosting with different vectors, and these clonal cell populations could be detected for as long as 4 years after SHIV challenge. Finally, we show that the breadth of these epitope-specific T lymphocytes transiently focuses in response to intense SHIV replication. These observations demonstrate the importance of the initial immune response to SHIV, induced by vaccination or generated during primary infection, in determining the clonal diversity of cell-mediated immune responses and highlight the focusing of this clonal diversity in the setting of high viral loads. Circumventing this restricted CD8(+) T-lymphocyte clonal diversity may present a significant challenge in the development of an effective HIV vaccine strategy.

Differential survival of cytotoxic T cells and memory cell precursors

It is widely assumed that the development of memory CD8 T cells requires the escape of CTLs from programmed cell death. We show in this study that although serine protease inhibitor 6 (Spi6) is required to protect clonal bursts of CTLs from granzyme B-induced programmed cell death, it is not required for the development of memory cells. This conclusion is reached because memory cell precursors down-regulate both Spi6 and granzyme B, unlike CTLs, and they do not require Spi6 for survival. These findings suggest that memory CD8 T cells are derived from progenitors that are refractory to self-inflicted damage, rather than derived from fully differentiated CTLs.

Induction of cytotoxic granules in human memory CD8+ T cell subsets requires cell cycle progression

Memory CD8(+) T cell responses are thought to be more effective as a result of both a higher frequency of Ag-specific clones and more rapid execution of effector functions such as granule-mediated lysis. Murine models have indicated that memory CD8(+) T cells exhibit constitutive expression of perforin and can lyse targets directly ex vivo. However, the regulated expression of cytotoxic granules in human memory CD8(+) T cell subsets has been underexplored. Using intracellular flow cytometry, we observed that only a minor fraction of CD45RA(-)CD8(+) T cells, or of CD8(+) T cells reactive to EBV-HLA2 tetramer, expressed intracellular granzyme B (GrB). Induction of GrB-containing cytotoxic granules in both CD45RA(+) and CD45RA(-) cells was achieved by stimulation with anti-CD3/anti-CD28 mAb-coated beads, required at least 3 days, occurred after several rounds of cell division, and required cell cycle progression. The strongest GrB induction was seen in the CCR7(+) subpopulations, with poorest proliferation being observed in the CD45RA(-)CCR7(-) effector-memory pool. Our results indicate that, as with naive T cells, induction of cytotoxic granules in human Ag-experienced CD8(+) T cells requires time and cell division, arguing that the main numerical advantage of a memory T cell pool is a larger frequency of CTL precursors. The fact that granule induction can be achieved through TCR and CD28 ligation has implications for restoring lytic effector function in the context of antitumor immunity.

Granzyme B Proteolyzes Receptors Important to Proliferation and Survival, Tipping the Balance toward Apoptosis

Granzyme B is critical to the ability of natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes to induce efficient cell death of virally infected or tumor cell targets. Although granzyme B can cleave and activate caspases to induce apoptosis, granzyme B can also cause caspase-independent cell death. Thirteen prospective granzyme B substrates were identified from a cDNA expression-cleavage screen, including Hsp70, Notch1, fibroblast growth factor receptor-1 (FGFR1), poly-A-binding protein, cAbl, heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein H', Br140, and intersectin-1. Validation revealed that Notch1 is a substrate of both granzyme B and caspases, whereas FGFR1 is a caspase-independent substrate of granzyme B. Proteolysis of FGFR1 in prostate cancer cells has functionally relevant consequences that indicate its cleavage may be advantageous for granzyme B to kill prostate cancer cells. Therefore, granzyme B not only activates pro-death functions within a target, but also has a previously unidentified role in inactivating pro-growth signals to cause cell death.

Serine protease inhibitor 6 protects cytotoxic T cells from self-inflicted injury by ensuring the integrity of cytotoxic granules

How cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) kill intracellular pathogens without killing themselves has been a recurring question ever since their discovery. By using mice deficient in Serine Protease Inhibitor 6 (Spi6), we show that by inhibiting granzyme B (GrB), Spi6 protects CTLs from self-inflicted injury. Infection with either Lymphocytic Choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) or Listeria monocytogenes (LM) revealed increased apoptosis and diminished survival of Spi6 knockout (KO) CTLs, which was cell autonomous and could be corrected by GrB deficiency. Spi6 KO mice in turn were impaired in their ability to clear LCMV infection. Spi6 KO CTLs revealed a breakdown in the integrity of cytotoxic granules, increased cytoplasmic GrB, and ensuing apoptosis. We conclude that Spi6 protects CTLs from suicide caused by GrB-mediated breakdown of cytotoxic granules.

Homeostasis of the memory T cell pool

Memory T cells are critical for the establishment of long-term immunity. The number of memory T cells formed at the conclusion of the primary response is strongly influenced by the number of effector T cells generated in the response, but some factors can additionally enhance the efficiency and quality of memory cell recruitment. Homeostasis of the memory T cell pool depends on cytokine-mediated regulation of cell survival and proliferation. This review discusses factors that influence both the development and the maintenance of the memory T cell pool.

Selective expression of the interleukin 7 receptor identifies effector CD8 T cells that give rise to long-lived memory cells

A major unanswered question is what distinguishes the majority of activated CD8 T cells that die after an acute viral infection from the small fraction (5-10%) that survive to become long-lived memory cells. In this study we show that increased expression of the interleukin 7 receptor alpha-chain (IL-7Ralpha) identifies the effector CD8 T cells that will differentiate into memory cells. IL-7R(hi) effector cells contained increased amounts of antiapoptotic molecules, and adoptive transfer of IL-7R(hi) and IL-7R(lo) effector cells showed that IL-7R(hi) cells preferentially gave rise to memory cells that could persist and confer protective immunity. Thus, selective expression of IL-7R identifies memory cell precursors, and this marker may be useful in predicting the number of memory T cells generated after infection or immunization.

Functional Segregation of the TCR and Antigen-MHC Complexes on the Surface of CTL

As CTL adhere to and lyze their targets, they extract cognate Ag-MHC and represent this on their own cell surface. Whether such self-presented cognate Ag stimulate the TCR of a CTL is uncertain. To analyze this, we examined TCR capping in response to self-presented Ag. We found that OVA peptide-specific OT-1 CTL that were pulsed with cognate peptide Ag did not cap their TCR, implying that the autologously presented MHC-Ag complex does not normally stimulate the TCR. However, this functional separation of the TCR and its ligand on the cell surface was not absolute. Treatment of Ag-pulsed OT-1 CTL with agents that alter cell surface charge, including trypsin, papain, tunicamycin, neuraminidase, and polybrene, allowed Ag-specific TCR capping. The TCR capped together with the restricting MHC molecule on the surface of the cell, implying an interaction between the TCR and cell-associated Ag. Further, the treated CTL underwent a time- and dose-dependent suicidal death that was both Fas- and perforin-dependent. Therefore, our results indicate that the association of the TCR with its MHC-peptide ligand on the surface of a CTL is normally proscribed by biophysical properties of the plasma membrane. Overcoming this restriction allows TCR stimulation and induces CTL effector functions and cell suicide.

Anti-human immunodeficiency virus-gag CD8+ memory T cells generated in vitro from Listeria-immunized mice

The goal of vaccination is the generation of immune memory, an immune state that permits rapid and intense recall responses to a pathogen. Considerable effort is being made to understand the nature of memory T cells. We report here that by extending the length of in vitro culture following a single restimulation with specific peptide, preparations of highly enriched, highly active antigen-specific CD8+ memory T cells could be obtained. These cultures were begun with splenocytes from mice primed by infection either with an attenuated strain of Listeria monocytogenes or vaccinia virus, both expressing the human immunodeficiency virus-1-gag gene. In the cultures, antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity reached a maximum at about 9 days and thereafter fell to negligible values. Concomitant with the fall of CTL activity, however, we observed enrichment for a subset of CD11ahigh antigen-specific gag-tetramerpos CD8+ T cells. The cells showed little or no 4-hr CTL activity, but had high delayed (18-hr) CTL activity, and very high cytolytic activity after restimulation. They rapidly expressed interferon-gamma production. Their growth and survival after sorting was completely dependent on interleukin-2 or -15. As few as 5000 of the fluorescence-activated cell sorting-purified cells protected recipients against challenge 3 months after transfer. In response to the challenge, the cells repopulated lymphoid and non-lymphoid organs and showed a sizeable increase in number. The cells therefore demonstrate high protective activity for long periods of time. These cultured cells are thus a potential source of enriched natural memory T cells for reperfusion studies and in which the mechanisms that underlie the generation, differentiation and persistence of memory can be examined.

A novel tumour model system for the study of long-term protective immunity and immune T cell memory

We present a novel non-transgenic system to be used for studies on anti-tumour adoptive immunotherapy (ADI) and long-term T cell memory. Tumour-reactive donor immune cells against lacZ-transfected syngeneic tumour cells (ESbL-Gal) were generated from a naíve T cell repertoire in DBA/2 mice by a well-established priming/restimulation protocol, and transferred to tumour-inoculated athymic nu/nu mice. The donor immune cells efficiently mediated protective anti-tumour immunity involving both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells, and anti-metastatic effects were stronger in 4.5 Gy pre-irradiated than in non-irradiated tumour-inoculated hosts. Long-term persistence of beta-galactosidase (Gal)-specific T cells was shown ex vivo by tetramer staining of CD8(+) T cells specific for an immunodominant Gal epitope. Resistance of treated nu/nu mice against tumour rechallenge revealed the existence of long-term protective immune memory.

Activation-induced cell death in human T cells is a suicidal process regulated by cell density but superantigen induces T cell fratricide

Repeated ligation of the TCR results in apoptosis (activation-induced cell death; AICD). Superantigens such as Staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) are particularly efficient at inducing AICD in T cells. We investigated whether apoptosis in human T cell subsets was due to fratricide (killing of neighboring cells) or suicide (cell autonomous death). AICD of Th1, Th2, Tc1, and Tc2 effector cells was dramatically enhanced at low cell densities and could be observed in single cell microcultures. AICD was unaffected by adhesion molecules or neighboring cells undergoing AICD, confirming the predominance of a suicidal mechanism. However, SEB was able to induce fratricidal apoptosis of type 1, but not type 2 cells. Fratricide was also observed when unstimulated T cells were exposed to activated Tc1 effector cells. Thus, AICD is tightly regulated to allow clonal T cell expansion and memory cell generation, but superantigens may subvert this process by allowing T cell fratricide.

Effector and memory T-cell differentiation: implications for vaccine development

Recent work shows that after stimulation with antigen, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells embark on a programme of proliferation that is closely linked with the acquisition of effector functions and leads ultimately to memory-cell formation. Here, we discuss the signals required for commitment to this programme of development and the factors that might influence its progression. Models of the pathways of effector and memory T-cell differentiation are discussed, and we highlight the implications of this new understanding for the optimization of vaccine strategies.