A limited association of generalized osteoarthritis with alleles at the type II collagen locus: COL2A1

Matrix metalloproteinase-3, vitamin D receptor gene polymorphisms, and occupational risk factors in lumbar disc degeneration

BACKGROUND

Lumbar disc degeneration (LDD) is a process that begins early in life, contributing to the development of low back pain. LDD is a consequence of a variety of factors, and its etiology remains poorly understood. Objectives to investigate occupational and genetic risk factors inducing lumbar disc degeneration, and to evaluate the possible association of genetic polymorphisms of matrix metalloproteinase 3 (MMP-3) and vitamin D receptor (VDR) with the severity of LDD in an Egyptian population.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

A case control study involving 84 LDD and 60 controls was carried out. Five types of work related factors were investigated by questionnaire, complete neurological examination for all subjects and MRI for the cases. Polymerase chain reaction and restriction fragment length polymorphism methods were applied to detect polymorphisms in MMP-3 Promoter (-1,171 6A/5A) (rs 731236) and VDR-Apa (rs 35068180).

RESULTS

We found that family history, back injury, smoking, high level of sitting, bending/twisting, physical workload, lifting, whole body vibration, mutant allele 5A of MMP-3 and mutant allele T of VDR were significantly associated with LDD (OR = 2.9, 3.1, 2.1, 11.1, 15.9, 11.7, 8.2, 12.6, 2.5 and 3.1 respectively, p < 0.05). Cases that carry allele 5A and/or allele T were associated with LDD severity.

CONCLUSION

LDD is closely associated in occurrence and severity with occupational, environmental risk factors and susceptibility genes namely MMP-3, and VDR (ApaI). This study throws light on the importance of screening for early detection of susceptible individuals and disease prevention.

Relationship between vitamin D receptor gene (VDR) polymorphisms, vitamin D status, osteoarthritis and intervertebral disc degeneration

The vitamin D endocrine system is involved in bony and cartilaginous metabolisms and alterations in the homeostasis of this system could be associated to pathological conditions of cartilaginous tissue. In this context, the presence of polymorphisms in the vitamin D receptor gene (VDR), in association with the susceptibility to common osteochondral diseases, was largely investigated. The aim of this review was to summarize data present in literature, analyzing the association of the VDR polymorphisms, vitamin D status and knee cartilage and intervertebral disc pathologies, trying to suggest links between the different specific pathologies analyzed. Concerning the association between VDR polymorphisms and cartilaginous tissue diseases, we found controversial reports. However, the great majority of papers reported an association with lumbar disc degeneration, whereas about half of the studies found an association with osteoarthritis. A further association between VDR polymorphisms (in linkage disequilibrium) and the presence of specific characteristics of these diseases, in particular the formation of osteophytes, was evidenced. Finally, the influence of vitamin D status on these pathologies was evaluated, trying to evidence the relation between the presence of particular genetic variants in the VDR and vitamin D levels or to show whether a particular vitamin D status could predispose to the development or progression of such diseases, however, no significant associations were found. In the future, given the role of vitamin D system in the cartilaginous tissue metabolism, it could be interesting to perform functional and tissue specific studies to analyze the interplay between the different VDR variants and its ligand.

Joint and bone assessment in hand osteoarthritis

Hand osteoarthritis (OA) is a common disease frequently affecting middle-aged women. Prevalence estimates for OA vary widely depending on the age and sex of the population studied, the assessment tools used, and the specific joint sites analyzed OA is characterized by the degradation of articular cartilage, subchondral bone changes and osteophyte formation at the joint margins leading to joint failure. The pathogenesis of the disease and its evolution are multifactorial involving biomechanical, metabolic, hormonal, and genetic factors. Moreover, the role of inflammation has recently been advanced as pivotal in OA onset and progression. In particular, an uncommon variant of hand OA, erosive hand OA, is characterized by inflammatory and degenerative interphalangeal proximal and distal joints. The diagnosis of different types of hand OA is centered on clinical and laboratory investigations which can distinguish the peculiar aspects of these forms. Joint and bone assessments in hand OA are widely studied but there is no agreement with regard to established parameters to make a definitive diagnosis. This report focuses on the laboratory and clinimetric assessments that can be used to distinguish hand OA subtypes and addresses the debatable association with low bone mineral density in osteoporosis.

Investigations in generalized osteoarthritis. Part 2: special histological features in generalized osteoarthritis (histological investigations in Heberden's nodes using a histological score)

OBJECTIVE

In accordance with the literature, our previous epidemiological, clinical and genetical investigations have confirmed a correlation between generalized osteoarthritis (GOA) and Heberden's nodes. Heberden's nodes can be considered as genetic markers for the existence of a generalized osteoarthritic predisposition. The present study's concern was to establish whether there are special histological features in this disease.

METHODS

Layered sections of 218 distal finger joints from 56 deceased persons were investigated using a histological-histochemical score modified by Mankin.

RESULTS

In Heberden's nodes, we found all the typical degradative sequences of the osteoarthritic process but also some specific modifications. The osteoarthritis (OA) starts with a subchondral ossification and manifests a reactive tidemark flaking. At this time, the surface of the cartilage is not yet destroyed. Later on, there is progression of general degradation. Significant differentiation from the control group is possible using a histological score.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with Heberden's nodes, the OA starts with the subchondral ossification. Heberden's nodes are the specific manifestation of GOA in the distal finger joints. Further studies are therefore required to assess whether the same pathogenetic mechanism can be seen in OA of the large joints in GOA.

Investigations in generalized osteoarthritis. Part 1: genetic study of Heberden's nodes

OBJECTIVE

Until the current molecular genetic investigations, all available data concerning the genetic predisposition to Heberden's nodes are based on a single investigation by Stecher in the 1940s. There is controversy in the literature about the correlation between Heberden's nodes and generalized osteoarthritis (GOA). Our own epidemiological and clinical investigations support this correlation. Therefore, the question arises as to whether the remarkable inheritance described by Stecher is correct and whether Heberden's nodes can indeed be used as a genetic marker for GOA.

METHODS

From our clinical trial on 106 patients with Heberden's arthritis, we could identify 88 families from index cases. Altogether, we included 931 family members over a maximum of four generations. First of all, the genealogical trees of the families were established. Subsequently, we examined the patients' hands in respect of Heberden's nodes and completed the genealogical trees during home visits.

RESULTS

In the 88 families analyzed, 152 patients with manifest Heberden's arthritis were listed (26 males, 126 females). The genealogical analysis of 156 descendants (74 males, 82 females) of 93 patients with Heberden's nodes suggests autosomal dominant inheritance. In view of the age-related manifestation and age pattern of the descendants, we postulate a heterozygous manifestation for women (dominant gene action) and only a homozygous manifestation for men (recessive gene action).

CONCLUSIONS

The genealogic analysis does not contrast with the quite remarkable inheritance described by Stecher but rather supports the hypothesis that manifestation is dominant in females and recessive in males. From our point of view, this heredity does not contradict latest genetic assays which show the possibility of genetic defects causing the hereditary osteoarthritis (OA).

The association of radiographic foot osteoarthritis and radiographic osteoarthritis at other sites

OBJECTIVE

To quantify the association between radiographic foot osteoarthritis (OA) and radiographic OA at four joints: second distal interphalangeal (DIP), third proximal interphalangeal (PIP), first carpometacarpal (CMC), and the knee.

METHODS

Data collected for the Clearwater Osteoarthritis Study (COS) were analyzed (N=3436). The study outcome was first metatarso-phalangeal joint (first MTP) OA status. The predictor variables were second DIP, third PIP, first CMC, and knee OA. The Kellgren and Lawrence scale determined OA status. The strength of the association between foot OA and other sites was further explored by unilateral and bilateral categories.

RESULTS

For both genders, we found a significant, positive relationship between grade 2+ foot OA and second DIP, third PIP, first CMC, and knee OA. This relationship maintained its significance after adjustment for age, body mass index, and occupational history. Adjusted odds ratios ranged from 3.2 for the second DIP joint (P<0.0001) to 3.7 for the knee joint (P<0.0001). Relative to unilateral joint disease, co-existing bilateral disease yielded a significantly elevated risk for foot OA for all joints examined. While other studies have not specifically examined co-occurrence with foot OA, our findings are consistent with results from related studies.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a dearth of studies exploring foot OA. Our findings support the theory of a systemic etiology involved in the development of OA. Future epidemiological studies that further distinguish the relationship between OA at differing sites will provide an enhanced ability to describe the respective influences of mechanical and systemic factors in the development of this disease.

Association of two gene polymorphisms with osteoarthritis secondary to hip dysplasia

Two adjacent genes on the 12q chromosome, the alpha 1 chain of Type II collagen, and the vitamin D receptor, have been considered potentially related to the pathophysiology of osteoarthritis. Two restriction fragment length polymorphisms were detected in 50 healthy donors and in 143 patients having a total hip replacement for idiopathic osteoarthritis or osteoarthritis secondary to developmental hip dysplasia. The polymorphic sites of Type II collagen and vitamin D receptor were amplified by polymerase chain reaction, and the products were digested with PvuII and BsmI restriction enzymes, respectively. The results showed that medical history and clinical characteristics, including gender, familial history of osteoarthritis, other hip prosthesis, and how early in life implantation was done did not seem to be connected to a particular genotype. Significant results were found by assessing the two groups of diseases that led to hip arthroplasty, suggesting a possible link between some haplotypes and the risk of severe osteoarthritis in patients with hip dysplasia. These results indicate that genetic markers could contribute to the understanding of the natural history of this disease.

Genetics of primary generalized osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common joint disease with complex etiology, including biomechanical, biochemical, and genetic components. The genetics of primary idiopathic OA is likely complex as multiple susceptibility loci have been identified from genome-wide scans. The future lies in finer mapping of these chromosomal regions, association studies, and candidate gene analysis and identification, which should collectively give rise to an improved understanding of the genetic mutations and biological pathways which increase the risk of developing this common joint disorder.

Genetics of hand osteoarthritis

There is convincing epidemiological evidence for a strong hereditary component to hand osteoarthritis (OA). For example: (1) greater concordance for hand OA in monozygotic than in dizygotic twins, the estimated proportion of variance explained by genetic factors being as high as 0.59; and (2) a substantially increased risk of hand OA in first-degree relatives (siblings, parents, offspring) of subjects with hand OA. Such evidence clearly justifies a search for the genes involved. However, gene association studies in genetically complex polygenic conditions such as OA present many problems, including case definition, late age of phenotype expression and adjustment for other constitutional and environmental risk factors. Nevertheless, association studies of affected sibling pairs and nuclear families, using candidate gene and genome wide screening and transmission disequilibrium testing, suggest no association with candidates such as COL2A1 (responsible for some rare monogenic syndromes of premature generalized OA) but possible associations, currently not isolated, on chromosome 2q. Such ongoing work and subsequent gene-gene and gene-environment interaction studies are likely to give important, perhaps unexpected, insights into the pathogenesis of hand OA.

Genetic markers of osteoarticular disorders: facts and hopes

Osteoarthritis and osteoporosis are the two most common age-related chronic disorders of articular joints and skeleton, representing a major public health problem in most developed countries. Apart from being influenced by environmental factors, both disorders have a strong genetic component, and there is now considerable evidence from large population studies that these two disorders are inversely related. Thus, an accurate analysis of the genetic component of one of these two multifactorial diseases may provide data of interest for the other. However, the existence of confounding factors must always be borne in mind in interpreting the genetic analysis. In addition, each patient must be given an accurate clinical evaluation, including family history, history of drug treatments, lifestyle, and environment, in order to reduce the background bias. Here, we review the impact of recent work in molecular genetics suggesting that powerful molecular biology techniques will soon make possible both a rapid accumulation of data on the genetics of both disorders and the development of novel diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic approaches.

Detection of sequence variability of the collagen type IIalpha 1 3' variable number of tandem repeat

The variable number of tandem repeat (VNTR) 3' of the collagen type II (COL2A1) gene has been shown to be highly variable with a complex molecular structure. In a previous pilot experiment we observed discordance between methods to genotype this informative marker. To further investigate the extent and molecular nature of this discordance, we genotyped a random sample of 207 Caucasian individuals with two genotyping methods and sequenced new alleles. We compared single-strand (SS) analysis, which is based on detection of size differences between the different alleles, and heteroduplex analysis (HA), which is sensitive to both size and sequence differences. Overall, 26% of discordance between the two methods was detected. Approximately two thirds of this discordance was caused by subdivision of SS-alleles 13R1 and 14R2 into HA-alleles 4A + 4B and 3B + 3C, respectively. Sequence analysis of the COL2A1 VNTR alleles 4B and 3C showed that these alleles differed in sequence, but not in size, from already described SS-alleles, which explains why they escape detection by SS. The 4B allele is a frequent allele in the population (14%) and is, therefore, important to distinguish in association studies. We conclude that HA is a reliable method when the described optimized electrophoretic conditions are used. HA is a sensitive genotyping method to document allelic diversity at this locus, which can distinguish more alleles compared to the SS method.

Adjacent genes, for COL2A1 and the vitamin D receptor, are associated with separate features of radiographic osteoarthritis of the knee

OBJECTIVE

To study the association of the COL2A1 genotype, in relation to the vitamin D receptor (VDR) genotype, with features of radiographic osteoarthritis (ROA) in a population of elderly men and women.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, we analyzed a population-based sample of 851 men and women ages 55-80 years from a large cohort study, the Rotterdam Study. We determined the prevalence of ROA of the knee according to the Kellgren/Lawrence (K/L) score and features of ROA (presence of osteophytes and narrowing of the joint space [JSN]) without considering clinical parameters of the disease. Genotypes were determined at a variable-number tandem repeats marker 1 kb downstream of the COL2A1 gene using a newly developed heteroduplexing method. The VDR genotype was previously determined by a direct molecular haplotyping polymerase chain reaction method to establish the phase of alleles at 3 adjacent restriction fragment length polymorphisms for Bsm I, Apa I, and Taq I.

RESULTS

We found the COL2A1 genotype to be associated with a 2-fold increased risk for JSN, but not with osteophytes or the K/L score. We had previously found the VDR genotype to be associated with osteophytes and the K/L score, but not with JSN. When the COL2A1 genotype was analyzed in combination with the VDR genotype, we found evidence suggesting that the presence of haplotypes of the 2 genes was associated with increased risk for ROA.

CONCLUSION

Our findings demonstrate that both the COL2A1 gene and the VDR gene are involved in ROA, but in separate features. The COL2A1 genotype is associated with JSN, while the VDR genotype is associated with osteophytes.

Lack of association between osteoarthritis of the hip and gene polymorphisms of VDR, COL1A1, and COL2A1 in postmenopausal women

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate whether DNA polymorphisms of the VDR (vitamin D receptor), COL1A1 (alpha1 type I collagen), and COL2A1 (alpha1 type II collagen) genes, which have previously been linked to bone mineral density (BMD) and/or osteoarthritis (OA), are also associated with OA of the hip (OAH).

METHODS

Genotype frequency distributions were compared between a group of 239 elderly healthy female controls and a group of 75 female OAH patients who underwent total hip replacement. All participants underwent BMD measurements of the total body, lumbar spine, and femoral neck. Mutation detection was done using polymerase chain reaction followed by restriction enzyme digestion. Polymorphisms were detected by digestion with Bsm I for VDR, Acc B7I for COL1A1, and Pvu II for COL2A1.

RESULTS

None of the genotype frequency distributions of any of the examined polymorphisms was significantly different between the OAH group and the control group. No significant differences in BMD variables were observed after stratification of the subjects according to the examined genotypes within each study group.

CONCLUSION

In Belgian postmenopausal women, the examined polymorphisms of the candidate genes VDR, COL1A1, and COL2A1 do not significantly contribute to an increased prevalence of OAH or to differences in BMD.

Investigation of the association of the CRTM and CRTL1 genes with radiographically evident osteoarthritis in subjects from the Rotterdam study

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether radiographically evident osteoarthritis (ROA) in 55-65-year-old men and women is associated with specific alleles or genotypes of the cartilage matrix protein (CRTM) and cartilage link protein (CRTL1) genes.

METHODS

Cases were selected from a population-based study on the presence of ROA of the knee or hip. Further radiographic analysis included scoring for spine and hand ROA. Controls, selected from the same population, were free of ROA in all joints.

RESULTS

The CRTM locus was significantly associated with hip ROA in men (odds ratio 0.50, 95% confidence interval 0.26-0.95). A significant association between ROA and the CRTL1 gene was not observed.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that the CRTM locus may play a role in the sex- and joint site-specific pattern of ROA development.

Association of early osteoarthritis of the knee with a Taq I polymorphism of the vitamin D receptor gene

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether a polymorphism of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) gene, already associated with osteoporosis, might also relate to the risk of osteoarthritis (OA).

METHODS

A population cohort of 351 postmenopausal women (ages 45-64 years) was studied using anteroposterior radiographs of the knee, which were graded for OA according to the Kellgren and Lawrence classification system. The VDR genotype was determined by using polymerase chain reaction and by digestion with the restriction enzyme Taq I.

RESULTS

The VDR allele "T" was associated with an increased risk of knee OA compared with the "t" allele, with an odds ratio of 2.82 (95% confidence interval 1.16-6.85; P = 0.02). A dominant pattern of risk was suggested. The frequency of the VDR genotype differed significantly between OA cases and controls (P = 0.03 by Fisher's exact test).

CONCLUSION

A Taq I polymorphism of the VDR gene appears to be associated with an increased risk of knee OA. This is the first genetic locus that has been shown to influence the risk of early knee OA within the general population.

Vitamin D receptor genotype is associated with radiographic osteoarthritis at the knee

Osteoporosis and osteoarthritis are age-related disorders of the skeleton with genetic components. Low bone density is a risk factor for osteoporotic fracture while osteoarthritis is associated with increased bone density. The 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 receptor (VDR) gene locus was previously found to be associated with bone density. We therefore studied the relationship between radiographic osteoarthritis at the knee and VDR genotype in a population-based sample (n = 846), using molecular haplotyping of anonymous intragenic DNA polymorphisms. Radiographic osteoarthritis was defined using the Kellgren score, which is based on the assessment of osteophytes and joint space narrowing (JSN). We show that one VDR haplotype allele is significantly overrepresented in individuals with knee osteoarthritis and associated with a 2.27-fold increased relative risk (95% confidence interval 1.46, 3.52). Adjustment for bone density at the femoral neck did not change these results, indicating that the association is not mediated by bone density. The association appeared to be largely explained by the presence of osteophytes rather than JSN. Our results indicate a role of the VDR gene in the pathogenesis of osteophytes while linkage disequilibrium with another nearby gene, i.e., the collagen type IIa1 gene encoding the most abundant protein in cartilage, might contribute to the association.

Pathogenesis and treatment of osteoarthritis

OA represents the final common pathway of a number of pathologic processes. The challenge is to define and classify the subsets of OA to understand the causes and to devise specific therapies. Effective chondroprotective therapies will be most useful when applied to high-risk individuals before the emergence of symptomatic OA. This will be feasible only with an improved understanding of the complex interaction of genes and environment in the OA disease process. Moreover, identifying the heritable bases of this disease will provide insight into the molecular mechanisms of the complex pathway that results in OA. Clinicians who encounter and treat OA patients can look forward to the development of more effective and innovative therapies based on a rapidly improving understanding of OA.

Population haplotype analysis and evolutionary relations of the COL2A1 gene

We have determined the allele frequencies and pairwise linkage disequilibria of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) distributed over the entire COL2A1 gene (spanning 23.6 kb) in a population of unrelated Dutch Caucasians. Pairwise linkage disequilibrium analysis of RFLP sites between exon 5B and 51 indicated a high degree of partly positive (the rare alleles of both loci are associated) and partly negative (the rare allele is associated with the common allele) linkage disequilibrium. The high degree of linkage disequilibrium enabled the assignment of 13 out of 128 possible haplotypes with 7 RFLPs. An evolutionary tree of these haplotypes was derived using a minimum spanning tree approach, indicating at least two ancestral haplotypes. Our data indicate that disease related population studies involving the COL2A1 gene should include a minimum of 4 RFLPs (D9, A9, H33, P51) to obtain 98% of possible haplotypes occurring.

Genetic aspects of familial osteoarthritis

Images

Multiallelic polymorphism of the cartilage collagen gene: no association with osteoarthrosis

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether any of the type II collagen alleles are associated with generalised osteoarthrosis or osteoarthrosis of the finger joints in the genetically isolated Finnish population.

METHODS

Two patient cohorts with evidence for only primary osteoarthrosis and a cohort of healthy control subjects were selected from the Helsinki University Central Hospital and the Rheumatism Foundation Hospital in Finland. Forty one patients with primary generalised osteoarthrosis, 49 patients with osteoarthrosis of the finger joints, and 48 control subjects were included. Two markers of the type II collagen gene, a PvuII polymorphism and a VNTR polymorphism, were analysed from each subject.

RESULTS

Four different alleles of the VNTR marker were observed and the relative risks associated with the different VNTR alleles varied between 0.39 and 1.24 among the patients with generalised osteoarthrosis and between 0.67 and 2.33 among the patients with osteoarthrosis of the finger joints. The PvuII polymorphism detected two different alleles and the associated relative risks were 0.82 and 1.82 for the patients with generalised osteoarthrosis, and 1.04 and 0.96 for the patients with osteoarthrosis of the finger joints.

CONCLUSIONS

A major predisposing allele of the type II collagen gene as the causative factor for osteoarthrosis could be excluded in this population. A spectrum of mutations associated with different alleles of this gene could not be excluded, however. Further, these two forms of cartilage disease can be caused by gene defects with reduced penetrance and the effect of such an allele is easily masked under the high frequency of normal alleles.

Collagens and their abnormalities in a wide spectrum of diseases

Collagens are a family of extracellular matrix proteins that play a dominant role in maintaining the structural integrity of various tissues. Nineteen collagen types containing altogether more than 30 distinct polypeptide chains have now been identified, and their genes have been found to be dispersed among at least 12 chromosomes. Mutations in collagen genes or deficiencies in the activities of specific post-translational enzymes of collagen synthesis have been characterized in many heritable disorders such as osteogenesis imperfecta, several chondrodysplasias, several subtypes of the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, the X-linked Alport syndrome and dystrophic forms of epidermolysis bullosa. In addition, collagen mutations have been found in certain common diseases, namely osteoporosis, osteoarthrosis and aortic aneurysms, and it is now evident that subsets of patients with these diseases have defects in types I, II or III collagen, respectively, as a predisposing factor. Mutations have so far been identified in only six of the more than 30 collagen genes, and thus research into collagen defects is only in its early stages. Transgenic mice have been shown to offer an excellent tool for investigating the consequences of mutations in collagen genes and identifying additional diseases caused by collagen defects. Excessive collagen accumulation also poses a common problem in medicine, leading to fibrosis with impairment of the normal functioning of the affected tissue. This has prompted attempts to develop drugs which inhibit collagen synthesis. Prolyl 4-hydroxylase would seem a particularly suitable target for antifibrotic therapy, and several compounds are now known that inhibit this enzyme. In particular, derivatives of pyridine 2,4-dicarboxylate have been shown to inhibit hepatic collagen accumulation in rats with two models of liver fibrosis.