Development of rheumatoid arthritis is not associated with two polymorphisms in the Crohn's disease gene CARD15

Systematic Review with Meta-analysis: The Impact of Co-occurring Immune-mediated Inflammatory Diseases on the Disease Course of Inflammatory Bowel Diseases

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Patients with inflammatory bowel diseases (IBDs) are at risk of developing a variety of other immune-mediated inflammatory diseases (IMIDs). The influence of co-occurring IMIDs on the disease course of IBD remains unknown. The aim of this study was therefore to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of the impact of IMIDs on phenotypic presentation and outcome in patients with IBD.

METHODS

PubMed and Embase were searched from their earliest records through December 2018 and updated in October 2019 for studies reporting proportions or ratios of IBD-related disease outcomes in patients with and without co-occurring IMIDs. Meta-analyses were performed to estimate summary proportions and risks of the main outcomes. PRISMA guidelines were used, and study quality was assessed according to the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

RESULTS

A total of 93 studies were identified, comprising 16,064 IBD patients with co-occurring IMIDs and 3,451,414 IBD patients without IMIDs. Patients with IBD and co-occurring IMIDs were at increased risk of having extensive colitis or pancolitis (risk ratio, 1.38; 95% Cl, 1.25-1.52; P < 0.01, I2 = 86%) and receiving IBD-related surgeries (risk ratio, 1.17; 95% Cl, 1.01-1.36; P = 0.03; I2 = 85%) compared with patients without IMIDs. Co-occurrence of IMIDs other than primary sclerosing cholangitis in patients with IBD was associated with an increased risk of receiving immunomodulators (risk ratio, 1.15; 95% Cl, 1.06-1.24; P < 0.01; I2 = 60%) and biologic therapies (risk ratio, 1.19; 95% Cl, 1.08-1.32; P < 0.01; I2 = 53%).

CONCLUSION

This meta-analysis found that the presence of co-occurring IMIDs influences the disease course of IBD, including an increased risk of surgery and its phenotypical expression.

Nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain containing 2: structure, function, and diseases

OBJECTIVES

To systematically review literature about the structure and function of nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain containing 2 (NOD2) and its disease association.

METHODS

The English literature was searched using keywords "NOD2" and "disease". Relevant original and review articles were reviewed.

RESULTS

NOD2 is an intracellular protein and shares similar molecular structure with NOD1, pyrin, and cryopyrin. There are more than 100 NOD2 gene mutations, some of which have been linked to diseases such as Crohn disease, Blau syndrome, and NOD2-associated autoinflammatory disease (NAID). The NOD2 variants located in the leucine-rich repeat (LRR) region are susceptible to Crohn disease, and the variants in the nucleotide-binding domain (NBD) and in between the NBD and LRR are associated with Blau syndrome and NAID, respectively. No disease association with the gene variants has been found in rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, ankylosing spondylitis, psoriasis/psoriatic arthritis, adult sarcoidosis, granulomatous polyangiitis, or multiple sclerosis. The potential association of the NOD2 variants with graft-versus-host-disease remains controversial. NOD2 functions mainly through RICK or RIP2 to activate p38 mitogen-activated protein kinases and NF-κB, resulting in inflammatory response, and enhanced autophagic activity. Biologic therapy may be beneficial for NOD2-associated diseases, and new drug development may be realized based upon the signaling pathways.

CONCLUSIONS

NOD2 gene mutations are associated with several diseases, and some of the mutations are of diagnostic value in Blau disease and NAID. To understand the NOD2 function, disease association, and its pathogenesis is important given the ever increasing clinical significance of NOD2.

Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and Nod-like receptors (NLRs) in inflammatory disorders

Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and Nod-like receptors (NLRs) are two major forms of innate immune sensors, which provide immediate responses against pathogenic invasion or tissue injury. Activation of these sensors induces the recruitment of innate immune cells such as macrophages and neutrophils, initiates tissue repair processes, and results in adaptive immune activation. Abnormalities in any of these innate sensor-mediated processes may cause excessive inflammation due to either hyper responsive innate immune signaling or sustained compensatory adaptive immune activation. Recent gene association studies appear to reveal strong associations of NLR gene mutations and development of several idiopathic inflammatory disorders. In contrast, TLR polymorphisms are less often associated with inflammatory disorders. Nevertheless, TLRs are up-regulated in the affected tissue of most inflammatory disorders, suggesting TLR signaling is involved in the pathogenesis of chronic and/or idiopathic inflammatory disorders. NLR signaling results in the formation of a molecular scaffold complex (termed an inflammasome) and orchestrates with TLRs to induce IL-1beta and IL-18, both of which are important mediators in the majority of inflammatory disorders. Therefore, understanding the roles of TLRs and NLRs in the pathogenesis of chronic and idiopathic inflammatory disorders may provide novel targets for the prevention and/or treatment of many common and uncommon diseases involving inflammation.

Evolution of Crohn's disease-associated Nod2 mutations

Several lines of evidence have confirmed the importance of Nod2 mutations for disease susceptibility in Crohn's disease. For tracing Nod2 evolution, exons 4a, 4e, 8, and 12 mutations were screened in a collection of 1,064 DNA samples from 52 worldwide populations. The overall allele frequency was 7.5% for single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)5, 0.2% for SNP8, 0.3% for SNP12, and 0.4% for SNP13. Nod2 mutations are mainly Caucasian alleles with strong distribution dissimilarity between single populations and major geographical regions. This regional diversity of Nod2 mutations within Europe points to the regional existence of selection pressure (possibly through dairy-associated bacterial infections within Neolithic cattle farming populations). The SNP5 gradient between Africa and the Middle East and its absence in Asian and Native American populations indicate that the evolution of this variant occurred in the Middle East. As mutations in exons 4e, 8, and 12 were only found in association with SNP5, this variant may have allowed selection pressure to arise.

Prevalence of CARD15/NOD2 mutations in Caucasian healthy people

BACKGROUND

Crohn's disease (CD) has been associated with CARD15/NOD2 mutations in Caucasians. The R702W, G908R, and 1007fs mutations represent 82% of the mutated chromosomes. The relative risk of developing CD in homozygous or compound heterozygous people has been estimated as between 10 and 40 times that of the general population. This high risk may support the opinion that CARD15/NOD2 variants are strong CD risk factors at the individual and population levels.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

The allele and genotype frequencies were calculated for the R702W, G908R, and 1007fs mutations in 3,575 Caucasian healthy controls recruited by 15 groups distributed on three continents. Geographic homogeneity was tested and the observed proportion of double mutants was compared with the expected value using chi2 tests.

RESULTS

The allele frequencies of the R702W, G908R, and 1007fs mutations were 4.3% (3.6-4.9), 1.2% (0.8-1.6), and 2.3% (1.8-2.8), respectively, with large geographic fluctuations of the G908R, 1007fs, and wild-type alleles (P<0.0001). At the population level, no simple relationship was observed between mutation frequencies and the disease incidences in the studied populations. At the individual level, no significant deficit of double-dose mutation carriers among healthy controls was found, providing strong evidence that the penetrances of the most at-risk genotypes are low.

CONCLUSION

Altogether, these data confirm that CARD15/NOD2 acts in interaction with other unknown risk cofactors.

Inflammatory bowel disease genetics: Nod2

The inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD) are comprised of two major subphenotypes, Crohn's disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC). A significant role for genetic factors in IBD was established from epidemiologic studies and, more recently, the identification of well-established disease associations, notably the association of Nod2 (CARD15) polymorphisms with CD. The mapping to CD of Nod2 variants that alter protein function represents one of the earliest, most well-established, associations in complex genetic disorders. Since the initial discovery, genotype-phenotype correlations, definition of Nod2 expression and signaling pathways, association studies in other, related disorders, and features of Nod2 deficiency in murine models have been reported. Taken together, the Nod2 association to CD provides an illustrative model of the role of single gene variants in disease pathogenesis for common, complex multigenic disorders. Here we review general aspects of IBD genetics with particular focus on the role of Nod2 in CD.

NOD2/CARD15 disease associations other than Crohn's disease

At this moment, few confirmed associations between NOD2 mutations and diseases other than Crohn's disease (CD) and Blau syndrome (BS) have been reported, but research is ongoing in several fields where a genetic susceptibility factor and/or a role for the innate immune system is suspected. Whether the Crohn's-associated CARD15 mutations lead to a loss or gain of function of the NOD2 receptor is subject to controversy, and by which mechanisms this change in function might increase the susceptibility to CD is still under investigation. The possible involvement of NOD2/CARD15 in the pathogenesis of certain diseases with already (partially) unraveled pathophysiologic mechanisms might contribute to our further understanding of NOD2/CARD15 and its function in CD. We review studies on the association of CARD15 variants with diseases other than CD. The association of NOD2/CARD15 mutations with CD and BS, and possibly also early onset sarcoidosis, suggests a role for the gene in the development of granulomata and granulomatous diseases, possibly by inappropriate activation of the immune system. The data from the oncology field suggest that this inappropriate activation might even lead to uncontrolled proliferation of certain cell types. The studies in allergic diseases and atopy are the largest so far, and the association of NOD2/CARDI5 mutations with atopic phenotypes might be an indication that CARD15 also plays a role in the Th2 pathway. Finally, transplantation studies indicate that the genetic background of a patient should be taken into account when considering hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, given the increased risk of mortality and graft versus host disease observed. Whether NOD2 variants are also associated with an increased risk for infections and sepsis in patients receiving immunosuppressive therapies is unclear.

NOD2 allele variants in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Recent reports have proven the importance of genetic factors and inflammation in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis (RA). In the current study, the frequency of NOD2/CARD15 gene variants (R702W, G908R, and L1007fsinsC) was examined in a group of 243 RA patients and 220 healthy controls. There were no statistically significant differences in distribution of NOD2 variant alleles between RA patients and controls. Moreover, there was no significant association between NOD2 variant alleles and joint erosions, extraarticular manifestations, rheumatoid factor, number of swollen and tender joints, and erythrocyte sedimentation rate. The results of the present study suggest that NOD2 allele variants have no significant influence on RA susceptibility, activity, and severity.

Genetics of rheumatoid arthritis

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a heterogeneous autoimmune disorder of unknown cause with variable clinical expression. About 70% of patients are women. Genetic factors play an important role and likely account for about 60% of disease susceptibility and expression. The association with the HLA-DRB1 gene is the best understood, although several non-HLA loci have been linked to RA, including the 18q21 region of the TNFRSR11A gene, which encodes the receptor activator of nuclear factor kappaB, important in bone resorption in RA. Genetic factors are also important in the treatment of RA because the activity of enzymes relevant in the metabolism of drugs such as methotrexate and azathioprine, including methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase and thiopurine methyltransferase, are in part genetically determined.

Evidence for common genetic control in pathways of inflammation for Crohn's disease and psoriatic arthritis

OBJECTIVE

Clinical, pharmacologic, and epidemiologic evidence supports the hypothesis that common genetic pathways may underlie inflammatory diseases. In a previous study, a Crohn's disease gene, CARD15, was demonstrated to be associated with psoriatic arthritis (PsA). Recently, a functional haplotype of 2 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) mapping to the organic cation transporter (OCTN) genes, SLC22A4 and SLC22A5, was identified as a second Crohn's disease susceptibility locus. The SLC22A4 gene has also been associated with rheumatoid arthritis. This study was undertaken to further elucidate associations of PsA with Crohn's disease susceptibility genes.

METHODS

Association with CARD15 and OCTN was investigated in UK Caucasian patients with PsA (n = 472) and population controls (n = 594), using 5' allelic discrimination assays (TaqMan). Two SNPs in OCTN, forming a haplotype previously associated with Crohn's disease, were also tested in patients with psoriasis (n = 218) and patients with early undifferentiated inflammatory arthritis (n = 386). Allele and estimated haplotype frequencies were compared between patients and controls.

RESULTS

No association of PsA with CARD15 was detected. In contrast, a functional SNP mapping to the promoter region of SLC22A5 (rs2631367) was associated with PsA (for CC versus GG, odds ratio 1.65, 95% confidence interval 1.13-2.41, uncorrected P = 0.005). In addition, the haplotype associated with Crohn's disease was also associated with PsA (P = 0.001). No association was detected in the cohort with psoriasis alone or in the cohort with undifferentiated inflammatory arthritis.

CONCLUSION

The OCTN haplotype previously associated with Crohn's disease is also associated with PsA, suggesting that these 2 diseases may share some common genetic control in pathways of inflammation.

Replication of putative candidate-gene associations with rheumatoid arthritis in >4,000 samples from North America and Sweden: association of susceptibility with PTPN22, CTLA4, and PADI4

Candidate-gene association studies in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have lead to encouraging yet apparently inconsistent results. One explanation for the inconsistency is insufficient power to detect modest effects in the context of a low prior probability of a true effect. To overcome this limitation, we selected alleles with an increased probability of a disease association, on the basis of a review of the literature on RA and other autoimmune diseases, and tested them for association with RA susceptibility in a sample collection powered to detect modest genetic effects. We tested 17 alleles from 14 genes in 2,370 RA cases and 1,757 controls from the North American Rheumatoid Arthritis Consortium (NARAC) and the Swedish Epidemiological Investigation of Rheumatoid Arthritis (EIRA) collections. We found strong evidence of an association of PTPN22 with the development of anti-citrulline antibody-positive RA (odds ratio [OR] 1.49; P=.00002), using previously untested EIRA samples. We provide support for an association of CTLA4 (CT60 allele, OR 1.23; P=.001) and PADI4 (PADI4_94, OR 1.24; P=.001) with the development of RA, but only in the NARAC cohort. The CTLA4 association is stronger in patients with RA from both cohorts who are seropositive for anti-citrulline antibodies (P=.0006). Exploration of our data set with clinically relevant subsets of RA reveals that PTPN22 is associated with an earlier age at disease onset (P=.004) and that PTPN22 has a stronger effect in males than in females (P=.03). A meta-analysis failed to demonstrate an association of the remaining alleles with RA susceptibility, suggesting that the previously published associations may represent false-positive results. Given the strong statistical power to replicate a true-positive association in this study, our results provide support for PTPN22, CTLA4, and PADI4 as RA susceptibility genes and demonstrate novel associations with clinically relevant subsets of RA.

Crohn's disease associated CARD15 (NOD2) variants are not involved in the susceptibility to type 1 diabetes

Three variants in the caspase recruitment domain 15/nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain 2 (CARD15/NOD2) gene have been shown to be associated with Crohn's disease (CD). There is a strong support for shared genetic determinants between various autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. In particular, linkage of type 1 diabetes (T1D) and other autoimmune and inflammatory diseases has been reported on chromosome 16, encompassing the region containing the CARD15 gene. We therefore considered this gene as a good candidate for the T1D locus mapped to this region, and we tested the three CARD15 variants in the susceptibility to T1D in two independent settings: family based association analysis in Scandinavian multiplex families that we previously showed to be linked to this region, and case/control association study in a large cohort of French diabetic patients. We found no evidence for association of these variants with T1D overall, nor in subgroups of patients with or without the major risk genotypes at HLA-DRB1, at insulin (INS), or positive or negative for autoantibodies specific to other autoimmune diseases. Our results do not support a role for CD-associated CARD15 variants in the susceptibility to T1D, and suggest that another gene is responsible for the shared susceptibility between autoimmune and inflammatory diseases mapping to this region.

Analysis of CARD15/NOD2 haplotypes fails to identify common variants associated with rheumatoid arthritis susceptibility

OBJECTIVES

The CARD15/NOD2 gene product plays an important role in host response to bacterial lipopolysaccharides and bacterial muramyl dipeptide via activation of NF-kappaB in monocytes. Mutations in CARD15 are associated with Crohn's disease (CD), a chronic inflammatory bowel disease. In this study we sought to determine whether CD-associated mutations or any common variants of this gene might contribute to susceptibility to another chronic inflammatory disease, rheumatoid arthritis (RA).

METHODS

We genotyped 376 Caucasian RA cases and 376 ethnically matched healthy controls for three CD-associated CARD15 mutations. We also genotyped these 752 individuals for 12 common CARD15 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), determined the linkage disequilibrium structure of the gene, and compared the frequencies of the common CARD15 haplotypes in the RA cases and controls.

RESULTS

None of the CD-associated mutations or the CARD15 SNPs was associated with susceptibility to RA. We also found no significant difference in the frequencies of any of the common haplotypes of the CARD15 gene in RA patients and controls. Our haplotype analysis was consistent with earlier observations that all three CD-associated variants independently arose on the same ancestral haplotype.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that CARD15 variants are not associated with RA susceptibility.

Caspase recruitment domain 15 mutations and rheumatic diseases

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this article is to review the foundational work and current developments on a group of rheumatic disorders associated with mutations in the caspase recruitment domain 15/nucleotide oligomerization domain 2 gene.

RECENT FINDINGS

To date, there are at least 10 arthritic conditions for which specific genetic mutations have been demonstrated. They include familial Mediterranean fever; tumor necrosis factor receptor associated periodic syndrome; hyper immunoglobulin D syndrome; neonatal onset multisystemic inflammatory disease; pyogenic arthritis pyoderma gangrenosum and acne; Muckle-Wells syndrome; familial cold autoinflammatory syndrome; immunodysregulation, polyendocrinopathy, enteropathy, X-linked syndrome; Crohn's disease; and familial and sporadic sarcoid granulomatous arthritis. This review focuses on recent progress in the last two diseases and the caspase recruitment domain 15 genetic defects with which they are associated. Up to 50% of patients with familial granulomatous arthritis (Blau's syndrome), 90% of those with sporadic granulomatous arthritis (early-onset sarcoidosis), and 40% of individuals with Crohn's disease have documented mutations in the caspase recruitment domain 15 gene.

SUMMARY

Although histologically, Crohn's disease and familial and sporadic sarcoid granulomatous arthritis are distinct from rheumatoid arthritis because of the defining presence (albeit in not all cases) of non-caseating granulomata in the synovial and intestinal tissues, respectively, they still represent a promising model of both chronic synovitis and uveitis. In addition, once the actual mechanism is discovered by which defects of the caspase recruitment domain 15 gene product lead to chronic arthritis, it may uncover unsuspected biologic targets for therapeutics.

Pattern recognition receptors and their involvement in the pathogenesis of arthritis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Pattern recognition receptors are germ-line encoded receptors that recognize specific pathogen-associated molecules, thereby allowing the innate immune system to distinguish self from nonself structures. Pattern recognition receptors mediate activation of different signaling pathways, resulting in the production of proinflammatory cytokines and the expression of antimicrobial genes. Additionally, pattern recognition receptors play a central role in the activation and direction of the adaptive immune response. This review summarizes recent advances in research trying to elucidate the link between different pattern recognition receptors and inflammatory autoimmune disorders.

RECENT FINDINGS

The best known pattern recognition receptors, the toll-like receptors, are involved in the regulation of inflammation during infectious diseases. They affect apoptotic pathways and dendritic cell maturation, and interact with B-cell receptors in priming T-cell responses to host-derived DNA. This brought toll-like receptors and other pattern recognition receptors into focus as potential players in the induction of autoimmune diseases. Indeed, several inflammatory autoimmune diseases have been linked during the past few years to defects or polymorphisms of genes encoding pattern recognition receptors.

SUMMARY

The discovery of toll-like receptors and other groups of pattern recognition receptors, such as the caspase recruitment domains or the triggering receptors expressed by myeloid cells, allowed one to draw an increasingly complex picture of immune responses to pathogens. The growing evidence for an involvement of pattern recognition receptors in the pathogenesis of autoimmune disorders warrants further investigation of the expression and function of pattern recognition receptors to develop novel therapeutics for diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis.

Unravelling the complex genetics of inflammatory bowel disease

The rapid pace of progress in molecular genetics over the past 15 years--since the seminal description of the polymerase chain reaction--has led to the identification of the genes involved in many single gene disorders. These successes in the laboratory have already led directly to clinical applications in diagnosis, pharmacogenetics, and the development of new therapies. Progress in unravelling the genetics of complex diseases has been less straightforward. However, real excitement has followed the identification of the NOD 2/CARD 15 gene as an important determinant of susceptibility to Crohn's disease.(1,)(2) Not only has this finding provided a proof of principle for the technique of genome-wide scanning in complex disorders, but the discovery also has given real insight into the primary pathophysiology involved in chronic inflammatory bowel disease. The background to this discovery and its implications form the basis for the present article.

Enteropathic arthritis

Enteropathic arthritis is a form of arthritis associated with the chronic inflammatory bowel diseases, ulcerative colitis, and Crohn's disease. This form of arthritis is classified as one of the group of seronegative spondyloarthropathies, which also includes psoriatic arthritis, reactive arthritis, and idiopathic ankylosing spondylitis. Joint involvement also occurs with other gastrointestinal diseases such as Whipple's disease, celiac disease, and following intestinal bypass surgery for morbid obesity. In these conditions, abnormal bowel permeability and immunologic and genetic influences are probably involved in the pathogenesis of the joint disease, although the exact mechanisms remain uncertain.