Helper T lymphocyte unresponsiveness to cardiac allografts following transient depletion of CD4-positive cells. Implications for cellular and humoral responses

Cross-presentation of dead-cell-associated antigens by DNGR-1+ dendritic cells contributes to chronic allograft rejection in mice

The purpose of this study was to elucidate whether DC NK lectin group receptor-1 (DNGR-1)-dependent cross-presentation of dead-cell-associated antigens occurs after transplantation and contributes to CD8⁺ T cell responses, chronic allograft rejection (CAR), and fibrosis. BALB/c or C57BL/6 hearts were heterotopically transplanted into WT, Clec9a^-/- , or Batf3^-/- recipient C57BL/6 mice. Allografts were analyzed for cell infiltration, CD8⁺ T cell activation, fibrogenesis, and CAR using immunohistochemistry, Western blot, qRT² -PCR, and flow cytometry. Allografts displayed infiltration by recipient DNGR-1⁺ DCs, signs of CAR, and fibrosis. Allografts in Clec9a^-/- recipients showed reduced CAR (p < 0.0001), fibrosis (P = 0.0137), CD8⁺ cell infiltration (P < 0.0001), and effector cytokine levels compared to WT recipients. Batf3-deficiency greatly reduced DNGR-1⁺ DC-infiltration, CAR (P < 0.0001), and fibrosis (P = 0.0382). CD8 cells infiltrating allografts of cytochrome C treated recipients, showed reduced production of CD8 effector cytokines (P < 0.05). Further, alloreactive CD8⁺ T cell response in indirect pathway IFN-γ ELISPOT was reduced in Clec9a^-/- recipient mice (P = 0.0283). Blockade of DNGR-1 by antibody, similar to genetic elimination of the receptor, reduced CAR (P = 0.0003), fibrosis (P = 0.0273), infiltration of CD8⁺ cells (p = 0.0006), and effector cytokine levels. DNGR-1-dependent alloantigen cross-presentation by DNGR-1⁺ DCs induces alloreactive CD8⁺ cells that induce CAR and fibrosis. Antibody against DNGR-1 can block this process and prevent CAR and fibrosis.

Basophils Trigger Fibroblast Activation in Cardiac Allograft Fibrosis Development

Fibrosis is a major component of chronic cardiac allograft rejection. Although several cell types are able to produce collagen, resident (donor-derived) fibroblasts are mainly responsible for excessive production of extracellular matrix proteins. It is currently unclear which cells regulate production of connective tissue elements in allograft fibrosis and how basophils, as potential producers of profibrotic cytokines, are involved this process. We studied this question in a fully MHC-mismatched model of heart transplantation with transient depletion of CD4(+) T cells to largely prevent acute rejection. The model is characterized by myocardial infiltration of leukocytes and development of interstitial fibrosis and allograft vasculopathy. Using depletion of basophils, IL-4-deficient recipients and IL-4 receptor-deficient grafts, we showed that basophils and IL-4 play crucial roles in activation of fibroblasts and development of fibrotic organ remodeling. In the absence of CD4(+) T cells, basophils are the predominant source of IL-4 in the graft and contribute to expansion of myofibroblasts, interstitial deposition of collagen and development of allograft vasculopathy. Our results indicated that basophils trigger the production of various connective tissue elements by myofibroblasts. Basophil-derived IL-4 may be an attractive target for treatment of chronic allograft rejection.

Transient blockade of delta-like Notch ligands prevents allograft rejection mediated by cellular and humoral mechanisms in a mouse model of heart transplantation

Rejection remains a major clinical challenge limiting allograft survival after solid organ transplantation. Both cellular and humoral immunity contribute to this complication, with increased recognition of Ab-mediated damage during acute and chronic rejection. Using a mouse model of MHC-mismatched heart transplantation, we report markedly protective effects of Notch inhibition, dampening both T cell and Ab-driven rejection. T cell-specific pan-Notch blockade prolonged heart allograft survival and decreased IFN-γ and IL-4 production by alloreactive T cells, especially when combined with depletion of recipient CD8(+) T cells. These effects were associated with decreased infiltration by conventional T cells and an increased proportion of regulatory T cells in the graft. Transient administration of neutralizing Abs specific for delta-like (Dll)1/4 Notch ligands in the peritransplant period led to prolonged acceptance of allogeneic hearts, with superior outcome over Notch inhibition only in T cells. Systemic Dll1/4 inhibition decreased T cell cytokines and graft infiltration, germinal center B cell and plasmablast numbers, as well as production of donor-specific alloantibodies and complement deposition in the transplanted hearts. Dll1 or Dll4 inhibition alone provided partial protection. Thus, pathogenic signals delivered by Dll1/4 Notch ligands early after transplantation promote organ rejection through several complementary mechanisms. Transient interruption of these signals represents an attractive new therapeutic strategy to enhance long-term allograft survival.

Recipient-derived EDA fibronectin promotes cardiac allograft fibrosis

Advances in donor matching and immunosuppressive therapies have decreased the prevalence of acute rejection of cardiac grafts; however, chronic rejection remains a significant obstacle for long-term allograft survival. While initiating elements of anti-allograft immune responses have been identified, the linkage between these factors and the ultimate development of cardiac fibrosis is not well understood. Tissue fibrosis resembles an exaggerated wound healing response, in which extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules are central. One such ECM molecule is an alternatively spliced isoform of the ubiquitous glycoprotein fibronectin (FN), termed extra domain A-containing cellular fibronectin (EDA cFN). EDA cFN is instrumental in fibrogenesis; thus, we hypothesized that it might also regulate fibrotic remodelling associated with chronic rejection. We compared the development of acute and chronic cardiac allograft rejection in EDA cFN-deficient (EDA(-/-)) and wild-type (WT) mice. While EDA(-/-) mice developed acute cardiac rejection in a manner indistinguishable from WT controls, cardiac allografts in EDA(-/-) mice were protected from fibrosis associated with chronic rejection. Decreased fibrosis was not associated with differences in cardiomyocyte hypertrophy or intra-graft expression of pro-fibrotic mediators. Further, we examined expression of EDA cFN and total FN by whole splenocytes under conditions promoting various T-helper lineages. Conditions supporting regulatory T-cell (Treg) development were characterized by greatest production of total FN and EDA cFN, though EDA cFN to total FN ratios were highest in Th1 cultures. These findings indicate that recipient-derived EDA cFN is dispensable for acute allograft rejection responses but that it promotes the development of fibrosis associated with chronic rejection. Further, conditions favouring the development of regulatory T cells, widely considered graft-protective, may drive production of ECM molecules which enhance deleterious remodelling responses. Thus, EDA cFN may be a therapeutic target for ameliorating fibrosis associated with chronic cardiac allograft rejection.

IL-6 promotes cardiac graft rejection mediated by CD4+ cells

IL-6 mediates numerous immunologic effects relevant to transplant rejection; however, its specific contributions to these processes are not fully understood. To this end, we neutralized IL-6 in settings of acute cardiac allograft rejection associated with either CD8(+) or CD4(+) cell-dominant responses. In a setting of CD8(+) cell-dominant graft rejection, IL-6 neutralization delayed the onset of acute rejection while decreasing graft infiltrate and inverting anti-graft Th1/Th2 priming dominance in recipients. IL-6 neutralization markedly prolonged graft survival in the setting of CD4(+) cell-mediated acute rejection and was associated with decreased graft infiltrate, altered Th1 responses, and reduced serum alloantibody. Furthermore, in CD4(+) cell-dominated rejection, IL-6 neutralization was effective when anti-IL-6 administration was delayed by as many as 6 d posttransplant. Finally, IL-6-deficient graft recipients were protected from CD4(+) cell-dominant responses, suggesting that IL-6 production by graft recipients, rather than grafts, is necessary for this type of rejection. Collectively, these observations define IL-6 as a critical promoter of graft infiltration and a shaper of T cell lineage development in cardiac graft rejection. In light of these findings, the utility of therapeutics targeting IL-6 should be considered for preventing cardiac allograft rejection.

Connective tissue growth factor promotes fibrosis downstream of TGFbeta and IL-6 in chronic cardiac allograft rejection

Cardiac transplantation is an effective treatment for multiple types of heart failure refractive to therapy. Although immunosuppressive therapeutics have increased survival rates within the first year posttransplant, chronic rejection (CR) remains a significant barrier to long-term graft survival. Indicators of CR include patchy interstitial fibrosis, vascular occlusion and progressive loss of graft function. Multiple factors have been implicated in the onset and progression of CR, including TGFbeta, IL-6 and connective tissue growth factor (CTGF). While associated with CR, the role of CTGF in CR and the factors necessary for CTGF induction in vivo are not understood. To this end, we utilized forced expression and neutralizing antibody approaches. Transduction of allografts with CTGF significantly increased fibrotic tissue development, though not to levels observed with TGFbeta transduction. Further, intragraft CTGF expression was inhibited by IL-6 neutralization whereas TGFbeta expression remained unchanged, indicating that IL-6 effects may potentiate TGFbeta-mediated induction of CTGF. Finally, neutralizing CTGF significantly reduced graft fibrosis without reducing TGFbeta and IL-6 expression levels. These findings indicate that CTGF functions as a downstream mediator of fibrosis in CR, and that CTGF neutralization may ameliorate fibrosis and hypertrophy associated with CR.

TGFbeta neutralization within cardiac allografts by decorin gene transfer attenuates chronic rejection

Chronic allograft rejection (CR) is the leading cause of late graft failure following organ transplantation. CR is a progressive disease, characterized by deteriorating graft function, interstitial fibrosis, cardiac hypertrophy, and occlusive neointima development. TGFbeta, known for its immunosuppressive qualities, plays a beneficial role in the transplant setting by maintaining alloreactive T cells in a hyporesponsive state, but has also been implicated in promoting graft fibrosis and CR. In the mouse vascularized cardiac allograft model, transient depletion of CD4(+) cells promotes graft survival but leads to CR, which is associated with intragraft TGFbeta expression. Decorin, an extracellular matrix protein, inhibits both TGFbeta bioactivity and gene expression. In this study, gene transfer of decorin into cardiac allografts was used to assess the impact of intragraft TGFbeta neutralization on CR, systemic donor-reactive T cell responses, and allograft acceptance. Decorin gene transfer and neutralization of TGFbeta in cardiac allografts significantly attenuated interstitial fibrosis, cardiac hypertrophy, and improved graft function, but did not result in systemic donor-reactive T cell responses. Thus, donor-reactive T and B cells remained in a hyporesponsive state. These findings indicate that neutralizing intragraft TGFbeta inhibits the cytokine's fibrotic activities, but does not reverse its beneficial systemic immunosuppressive qualities.

Role of T cell TGFbeta signaling and IL-17 in allograft acceptance and fibrosis associated with chronic rejection

Chronic allograft rejection (CR) is the main barrier to long-term transplant survival. CR is a progressive disease defined by interstitial fibrosis, vascular neointimal development, and graft dysfunction. The underlying mechanisms responsible for CR remain poorly defined. TGFbeta has been implicated in promoting fibrotic diseases including CR, but is beneficial in the transplant setting due to its immunosuppressive activity. To assess the requirement for T cell TGFbeta signaling in allograft acceptance and the progression of CR, we used mice with abrogated T cell TGFbeta signaling as allograft recipients. We compared responses from recipients that were transiently depleted of CD4(+) cells (that develop CR and express intragraft TGFbeta) with responses from mice that received anti-CD40L mAb therapy (that do not develop CR and do not express intragraft TGFbeta). Allograft acceptance and suppression of graft-reactive T and B cells were independent of T cell TGFbeta signaling in mice treated with anti-CD40L mAb. In recipients transiently depleted of CD4(+) T cells, T cell TGFbeta signaling was required for the development of fibrosis associated with CR, long-term graft acceptance, and suppression of graft-reactive T and B cell responses. Furthermore, IL-17 was identified as a critical element in TGFbeta-driven allograft fibrosis. Thus, IL-17 may provide a therapeutic target for preventing graft fibrosis, a measure of CR, while sparing the immunosuppressive activity of TGFbeta.

Critical role for IL-6 in hypertrophy and fibrosis in chronic cardiac allograft rejection

Chronic cardiac allograft rejection is the major barrier to long term graft survival. There is currently no effective treatment for chronic rejection except re-transplantation. Though neointimal development, fibrosis, and progressive deterioration of graft function are hallmarks of chronic rejection, the immunologic mechanisms driving this process are poorly understood. These experiments tested a functional role for IL-6 in chronic rejection by utilizing serial echocardiography to assess the progression of chronic rejection in vascularized mouse cardiac allografts. Cardiac allografts in mice transiently depleted of CD4+ cells that develop chronic rejection were compared with those receiving anti-CD40L therapy that do not develop chronic rejection. Echocardiography revealed the development of hypertrophy in grafts undergoing chronic rejection. Histologic analysis confirmed hypertrophy that coincided with graft fibrosis and elevated intragraft expression of IL-6. To elucidate the role of IL-6 in chronic rejection, cardiac allograft recipients depleted of CD4+ cells were treated with neutralizing anti-IL-6 mAb. IL-6 neutralization ameliorated cardiomyocyte hypertrophy, graft fibrosis, and prevented deterioration of graft contractility associated with chronic rejection. These observations reveal a new paradigm in which IL-6 drives development of pathologic hypertrophy and fibrosis in chronic cardiac allograft rejection and suggest that IL-6 could be a therapeutic target to prevent this disease.

OX40 costimulation prevents allograft acceptance induced by CD40-CD40L blockade

Disrupting the CD40-CD40L costimulation pathway promotes allograft acceptance in many settings. Herein, we demonstrate that stimulating OX40 overrides cardiac allograft acceptance induced by disrupting CD40-CD40L interactions. This effect of OX40 stimulation was dependent on CD4(+) T cells, which in turn provided help for CD8(+) T cells and B cells. Allograft rejection was associated with donor-reactive Th1 and Th2 responses and an unconventional granulocytic infiltrate and thrombosis of the arteries. Interestingly, OX40 stimulation induced a donor-reactive IgG class switch in the absence of CD40-CD40L interactions, and the timing of OX40 stimulation relative to transplantation affected the isotype of donor-reactive Ab produced. Inductive OX40 stimulation induced acute graft rejection, which correlated with both IgG1 and IgG2a deposition within the graft. Once graft acceptance was established following CD40-CD40L blockade, delayed OX40 stimulation did not induce acute allograft rejection despite priming of graft-reactive Th1 and Th2. Rather, chronic rejection was induced, which was characterized by IgG1 but not IgG2a deposition within the graft. These studies reveal both redundancy and key differences in function among costimulatory molecules that manifest in distinct pathologies of allograft rejection. These findings may help guide development of therapeutics aimed at promoting graft acceptance in transplant recipients.

Depleting T-cell subpopulations in organ transplantation

T-cell depletion strategies are an efficient therapy for the treatment of acute rejection after organ transplantation and have been successfully used as induction regimens. Although eliminating whole T cells blocks alloreactivity, this therapy challenges the development of regulatory mechanisms because it depletes regulatory cells and modifies the profile of T cells after homeostatic repopulation. Targeting T-cell subpopulations or selectively activated T cells, without modifying Treg cells, could constitute a pro-tolerogenic approach. However, the perfect molecular target that would be totally specific probably still needs to be identified. In this study, we have reviewed the biological activities of broad or specific T-cell depletion strategies as these contribute to the induction of regulatory cells and tolerance in organ transplantation.

Transplant acceptance following anti-CD4 versus anti-CD40L therapy: evidence for differential maintenance of graft-reactive T cells

Inductive therapy with anti-CD4 or anti-CD40L monoclonal antibodies (mAb) leads to long-term allograft acceptance but the immune parameters responsible for graft maintenance are not well understood. This study employed an adoptive transfer system in which cells from mice bearing long-term cardiac allografts following inductive anti-CD4 or anti-CD40L therapy were transferred into severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) allograft recipients. SCID recipients of cells from anti-CD4-treated mice (anti-CD4 cells) did not reject allografts while those receiving cells from anti-CD40L-treated mice (anti-CD40L cells) did reject allografts. Carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester (CFSE) labeling of transferred cells revealed that this difference was not associated with differential proliferative capacities of these cells in SCID recipients. Like cells from naïve mice, anti-CD40L cells mounted a Th1 response following transfer while anti-CD4 cells mounted a dominant Th2 response. Early (day 10) T-cell priming was detectable in both groups of primary allograft recipients but persisted to day 30 only in recipients treated with anti-CD4 mAb. Thus, anti-CD40L therapy appears to result in graft-reactive T cells with a naïve phenotype while anti-CD4 therapy allows progression to an altered state of differentiation. Additional data herein support the notion that anti-CD40L mAb targets activated, but not memory, cells for removal or functional silencing.

The classical complement pathway in transplantation: unanticipated protective effects of C1q and role in inductive antibody therapy

Though complement (C) deposition within the transplant is associated with allograft rejection, the pathways employed have not been established. In addition, evidence suggests that C-mediated cytolysis may be necessary for the tolerance-inducing activities of mAb therapies. Hence, we assessed the role of the classical C pathway in acute allograft rejection and its requirement for experimental mAb therapies. C1q-deficient (C1q-/-) recipients rejected allografts at a faster rate than wild-type (WT) recipients. This rejection was associated with exacerbated graft pathology but not with enhanced T-cell responses in C1q-/- recipients. However, the humoral response to donor alloantigens was accelerated in C1q-/- mice, as an early IgG response and IgG deposition within the graft were observed. Furthermore, deposition of C3d, but not C4d was observed in grafts isolated from C1q-/- recipients. To assess the role of the classical C pathway in inductive mAb therapies, C1q-/- recipients were treated with anti-CD4 or anti-CD40L mAb. The protective effects of anti-CD4 mAb were reduced in C1q-/- recipients, however, this effect did not correlate with ineffective depletion of CD4+ cells. In contrast, the protective effects of anti-CD40L mAb were less compromised in C1q-/- recipients. Hence, this study reveals unanticipated roles for C1q in the rejection process.

Analysis of the underlying cellular mechanisms of anti-CD154-induced graft tolerance: the interplay of clonal anergy and immune regulation

Although it has been shown that CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells (T(reg)) contribute to long-term graft acceptance, their impact on the effector compartment and the mechanism by which they exert suppression in vivo remain unresolved. Using a CD4(+) TCR transgenic model for graft tolerance, we have unveiled the independent contributions of anergy and active suppression to the fate of immune and tolerant alloreactive T cells in vivo. First, it is shown that anti-CD154-induced tolerance resulted in the abortive expansion of the alloreactive, effector T cell pool. Second, commensurate with reduced expansion, there was a loss of cytokine production, activation marker expression, and absence of memory T cell markers. All these parameters defined the tolerant alloreactive T cells and correlated with the inability to mediate graft rejection. Third, the tolerant alloreactive T cell phenotype that is induced by CD154 was reversed by the in vivo depletion of T(reg). Reversal of the tolerant phenotype was followed by rapid rejection of the allograft. Fourth, in addition to T(reg) depletion, costimulation of the tolerant alloreactive T cells or activation of the APC compartment also reverted alloreactive T cell tolerance and restored an activated phenotype. Finally, it is shown that the suppression is long-lived, and in the absence of anti-CD154 and donor-specific transfusion, these T(reg) can chronically suppress effector cell responses, allowing long-lived graft acceptance.

Mixed chimerism and transplantation tolerance

Establishment of mixed hematopoietic chimerism carries with it the induction of transplantation tolerance to any other tissue or organ from the same donor. This strategy has been studied extensively for induction of tolerance in mice. During the past decade, we have extended the same strategy, with modifications, to cynomolgus monkeys and most recently to renal transplant patients. In this report we review the evolution of these studies from preclinical applications to our current clinical experience with two therapeutic protocols sponsored by the Immune Tolerance Network. The first of these studies is for patients with myeloma and end-stage renal disease with an HLA-matched sibling donor; the second for patients with end-stage renal disease and HLA-mismatched donors. Although it is still early in the course of these studies, the results to date are very encouraging.

The immunobiology of inductive anti-CD40L therapy in transplantation: allograft acceptance is not dependent upon the deletion of graft-reactive T cells

CD40-CD40L costimulatory interactions are crucial for allograft rejection, in that treatment with anti-CD40L mAb markedly prolongs allograft survival in several systems. Recent reports indicate that costimulatory blockade results in deletion of graft-reactive cells, which leads to allograft tolerance. To assess immunologic parameters that were influenced by inductive CD40-CD40L blockade, cardiac allograft recipients were treated with multiple doses of the anti-CD40L mAb MR1, which was remarkably effective at prolonging allograft survival. Acute allograft rejection responses such as IL-2 producing helper cell priming, Th1 priming, and alloantibody production were abrogated by anti-CD40L treatment. Interestingly, the spleens of mice bearing long-term cardiac allografts following inductive anti-CD40L treatment retained precursor donor alloantigen-reactive CTL, IL-2 producing helper cells, and Th1 in numbers comparable to those observed in naïve mice. These mice retained the ability to reject donor-strain skin allografts, but were incapable of rejecting the original cardiac allograft, or a second donor-strain cardiac allograft. Further, differentiated effector cells were incapable of mediating rejection following adoptive transfer into mice bearing long-term allografts, suggesting that regulatory cell function, rather than effector cell deletion was responsible for long-term graft acceptance. Collectively, these data demonstrate that inductive CD40-CD40L blockade does not result in the deletion of graft-reactive T cells, but induces the maintenance of these cells in a quiescent precursor state. They further point to a tissue specificity of this hyporesponsiveness, suggesting that not all donor alloantigen-reactive cells are subject to this regulation.

Murine renal allografts: spontaneous acceptance is associated with regulated T cell-mediated immunity

It was shown >20 yr ago that mice will spontaneously accept renal allografts in the absence of immunosuppression, but the mechanism responsible for this is not understood. We transplanted DBA/2 (H-2(d)) kidneys into nephrectomized C57BL/6 (H-2(b)) mice, and the allografts were spontaneously accepted for >60 days without immunosuppression. In contrast, nonimmunosuppressed cardiac and skin allografts in the same strain combination are rejected within approximately 10 days. The accepted renal allografts have a prominent leukocytic infiltrate, suggesting an ongoing, local immune response. At 60 days post-transplant, the recipients of accepted renal allografts display DBA/2-reactive alloantibodies. They also display DBA/2-reactive delayed-type hypersensitivity responses that are actively counter-regulated by DBA/2-induced TGF-beta production, but not by IL-10 production. These data suggest that a donor-reactive, cell-mediated immune mechanism involving TGF-beta is associated with the spontaneous acceptance of renal allografts in mice.

Interleukin-2-producing helper T lymphocyte precursor frequency and rejection: a longitudinal cellular study after cardiac transplantation

Interleukin-2-producing helper T lymphocyte precursors (HTLp) in the recipient recognize donor alloantigen expressed by the transplanted organ. The frequency of these reactive cells in the peripheral blood was determined and correlated with rejection episodes. Endomyocardial biopsy is generally used to quantify cardiac allograft rejection and guide immunotherapy. While non-invasive techniques have been investigated, none of these has demonstrated sufficient sensitivity or specificity to replace myocardial biopsy. Twelve cardiac transplant recipients were assessed over a 1 year period using limiting dilution analysis, to determine the frequency of HTLp in response to cadaver donor splenocytes. The IL-2-dependent mouse cell line CTLL-2 was used to measure the IL-2 present and the precursor frequency was calculated using maximum likelihood estimation. In the months immediately post transplantation, six of the 12 recipients displayed an association with increases in HTLp frequency, which preceded histologically detectable rejection. The second six recipients had fewer rejection episodes and achieved 'acceptance' of their graft sooner. Once 'acceptance' was achieved, the association between IL-2 HTLp frequency and rejection was no longer apparent. The ability to identify two groups of patients on the basis of IL-2 HTLp frequency clearly highlights the heterogenous nature of the response to the graft and this emphasizes the need to monitor other cytokines, which may influence the functioning of effector T cells.

Cytokine regulation of chronic cardiac allograft rejection: evidence against a role for Th1 in the disease process

BACKGROUND

Transient depletion of CD4+ T cells in cardiac allograft recipients prolongs allograft survival; however, grafts exhibit signs of chronic rejection characterized by collagen deposition and neointima development. Although it is believed that Th1 cells promote acute graft rejection, the role of these cells in chronic rejection remains unclear. Hence, our study evaluated whether Th1 cells are associated with the development of chronic cardiac allograft rejection.

METHODS

Splenocytes obtained from C57BL/6 recipients bearing BALB/c hearts with signs of chronic rejection were adoptively transferred into C57BL/6 SCID cardiac allograft recipients. As a measure of Th1 function, interferon-y production was determined after restimulation of recipient splenocytes with donor alloantigens.

RESULTS

Transfer of splenocytes in SCID allograft recipients resulted in accelerated chronic rejection in the majority of mice. Characterization of these cells before transfer revealed hyporesponsive Th1 function. However, donor-specific proliferative responses and precursor interleukin-2 producing helper and cytotoxic T lymphocyte frequencies were comparable to that of naive splenocytes. Further, splenocytes obtained from SCID recipients with advanced signs of chronic rejection remained deficient in Th1 function, suggesting that Th1 are not involved in this disease process. This possibility was further supported by the development of chronic rejection in IL-12 knockout recipients. Finally, when splenocytes used for adoptive transfer retained Th1 function, transfer of these cells into SCID recipients resulted in acute allograft rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

We have established a model in which the mediators of chronic rejection may be further explored. In this system, the absence rather than the presence of donor-reactive Th1 is associated with chronic rejection. These data indicate that Th1-independent effector mechanisms are responsible for chronic rejection in this model.

Tolerance Induction by Anti-CD2 Plus Anti-CD3 Monoclonal Antibodies: Evidence for an IL-4 Requirement

Anti-CD2 mAb plus anti-CD3 mAb induce alloantigen specific tolerance. We sought to determine whether Th2 cytokines are involved in the induction of tolerance in this model. Addition of anti-IL-4 mAb or anti-IL-10 mAb to anti-CD2 plus anti-CD3 treatment abrogated tolerance and resulted in graft survivals of 26 ± 4 and 25 ± 5 days, respectively. Splenocytes from the anti-IL-4 mAb and anti-IL-10 groups had greater proliferation in response to alloantigen than either tolerant or naive groups. Cytokine analysis of MLR supernatants showed increased IL-10 in the tolerant group and increased IFN-γ in the anti-IL-4 mAb treated group. Donor-specific alloantibody responses in untreated immune animals had a predominantly Th1 (IgG2a) alloantibody response, while the tolerogenic regimen reduced the ratio of IgG2a:IgG1 titers. The addition of anti-IL-4 mAb to the tolerogenic regimen partly restored the Th1-related IgG2a response. Tolerance did not develop in IL-4 knockout animals treated with anti-CD2 plus anti-CD3 (mean graft survival, 27 ± 5 days). Restoration of IL-4 to IL-4 knockout animals by gene transfer with plasmid DNA resulted in prolongation of survival to 46 ± 7 days, while adoptive transfer of wild-type splenocytes into IL-4 knockout recipients resulted in indefinite graft survival (&gt;60 days) and indefinite survival of second donor-type grafts. IL-10 gene transfer to IL-4 knockout recipients did not prolong graft survival (28 ± 4). These results demonstrate that tolerance in this model is mediated at least in part by Th2-type cells that secrete IL-4, promote IL-10 and IgG1 production, and inhibit alloantigen reactivity.

Cardiac allograft tolerance: failure to develop in interleukin-4-deficient mice correlates with unusual allosensitization patterns

BACKGROUND

The development of long-term allograft survival and understanding the mechanism(s) by which it is induced are major goals of experimental transplantation. Studies by several different investigators have provided conflicting evidence for the role of interleukin (IL)-4 in the process of allograft rejection or long-term allograft survival. These studies examine the role of IL-4 in experimental cardiac allograft rejection and in inducing long-term allograft survival. A possible mechanism for long-term allograft maintenance via alternative allosensitization is discussed.

METHODS

Adult IL-4-intact or IL-4-deficient (knockout, KO) C57BL/6 (B6) mice were transplanted with heterotopic DBA/2 cardiac allografts and immunosuppressed either with gallium nitrate (GN), or the anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody, GK1.5. Cellular allosensitization was assessed by testing the allograft recipients for donor-reactive delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. The presence of antigen-driven suppressive mechanisms was assessed using a linked unresponsiveness (bystander suppression) DTH assay.

RESULTS

In general, the results were the same with either GN or GK1.5. We observed that (1) IL-4 is not required for acute allograft rejection or allogeneic DTH responses in nonsuppressed mice, (2) IL-4 is required for long-term allograft survival in immunosuppressed mice, (3) immunosuppression creates a requirement for IL-4 in major histocompatibility complex self-restricted, but not allorestricted, DTH responses, and (4) the development of alloantigen-dependent linked DTH unresponsiveness (bystander suppression) in allograft recipients requires IL-4.

CONCLUSION

In summary, these studies demonstrate a common requirement for IL-4 during the development of long-term allograft survival and the concurrent development of alloantigen-dependent DTH down-regulation in cardiac allograft recipients after immunosuppression.

Inhibition of the alloantibody response by CD95 ligand

We investigated the effect of Fas/APO1-ligand (CD95L) gene transfer on allogeneic immune responses in vivo. A colon carcinoma cell line from BALB/c mice, CT26, was stably transfected with a vector encoding mouse CD95L and was inoculated into C57BL/6 mice. CD95L expression markedly reduced allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocyte and helper T lymphocyte activity directed toward CT26. Strikingly, expression of CD95L on these allogeneic tumors completely inhibited the generation of alloantibodies of both IgM and IgG subclasses. Thus, CD95L inhibited alloantibody production and conferred localized immune suppression through this mechanism. These results provide insight into the role of CD95L in regulating the alloantibody response and the generation of local immune responses.

Prolonged murine cardiac allograft acceptance: characteristics of persistent active alloimmunity after treatment with gallium nitrate versus anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody

We have treated DBA/2-->C57BL/6 murine cardiac allograft recipients with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody or with gallium nitrate to promote long-term (>60 days) allograft survival. Within this period, all grafts developed histologic evidence of ongoing vascular and parenchymal tissue remodeling, including interstitial fibrosis and neointimal hyperplasia, which are characteristic of chronic allograft rejection. To evaluate residual alloimmunity associated with the pharmacologic avoidance of acute graft rejection and the development of chronic tissue remodeling, we subjected these graft recipients to a battery of histologic and immunologic tests. Similar test results were obtained for graft recipients treated with either of the two immunosuppressive agents. All long-surviving allografts displayed histologic evidence of ongoing microvascular endothelial activation and interstitial leukocytic infiltration. Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction analyses demonstrated intragraft expression of mRNAs for interleukin (IL)-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor, interferon-gamma, and transforming growth factor-beta. All recipients had limiting dilution analysis-detectable, graft-reactive cytolytic T lymphocytes and helper T lymphocytes in their spleens and grafts, and all produced high titers of graft-reactive alloantibodies. In general, these observations indicate that (1) a similar immune status is achieved in long-surviving allografts and their recipients when either anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody or gallium nitrate was used for antirejection therapy, (2) this immune status is characterized by continuous, long-term inflammatory and immune processes that are qualitatively similar to those observed during acute allograft rejection, and (3) no specific immune responses developed selectively in long-term graft recipients to account for the avoidance of acute graft rejection or the development of chronic tissue remodeling in the graft.

Apoptosis in murine cardiac grafts

Apoptosis, or the induction of programmed cell death, is a mechanism commonly used by cytotoxic T cells to cause target cell lysis. We evaluated the frequency and distribution of apoptotic cells in DBA/2-->DBA/2 heterotopic cardiac isografts, acutely rejecting DBA/2-->C57BL/6 cardiac allografts, and accepted, 60 day DBA/2-->C57BL/6 allografts from mice treated with anti-CD4 Mab (GK1.5) or gallium nitrate (GN). Apoptosis was identified in histologic sections via TUNEL analysis of nuclear DNA fragmentation. We observed the following. (1) Cardiac isografts display no detectable TUNEL+ cells. (2) Rejecting cardiac allografts display rare (<1% of nucleated cells/field), diffuse TUNEL+ cells, peaking on day 3 and declining to 50% of peak by the day of rejection (approximately day 10), and TUNEL+ cells were localized to regions of cellular infiltrate rather than myocyte regions. (3) Accepted cardiac allografts display relatively high numbers of TUNEL+ cells localized in and around the large cardiac arteries (about 20% of nucleated cells/periarterial field). These arteries often showed evidence of transplant vascular sclerosis characteristic of chronic allograft rejection. While a few TUNEL+ cells were found in the arterial tissue, most were observed in the periarterial cellular infiltrate. Similar frequencies and distributions of TUNEL+ cells were observed in grafts that were accepted due to treatment with the anti-CD4 mAb GK 1.5 or gallium nitrate. In general, apoptosis did not correlate with graft failure or parenchymal cell damage, suggesting that cytotoxic T cell-mediated destruction of graft tissues is rare in cardiac allografts. While apoptosis does not appear to be indicative of acute rejection, the characteristic periarterial clustering of apoptosis in accepted grafts may be indicative of immunoregulatory processes that maintain graft acceptance or repair processes that promote chronic vascular remodeling.

Allogeneic class I MHC requirement for alloantigen-reactive helper T-lymphocyte responses in vivo. Evidence for indirect presentation of alloantigen

The mechanisms by which host T cells recognize transplant-associated alloantigens in vivo have not been established. Two alloantigen presentation pathways may be used: (1) allogeneic class I and class II MHC molecules may be recognized directly by host CD8+ and CD4+ cells, respectively, or (2) allogeneic MHC molecules may be processed as foreign peptide and presented by host antigen-presenting cells to CD4+ cells in the context of self class II proteins. In this study, the sponge matrix allograft model was used to examine the relative contributions of these alloantigen presentation pathways to CD4+ T-cell activation in vivo. Limiting dilution analysis was used to quantify the localization of interleukin-2-producing helper T lymphocytes (HTL) following implantation of sponge allografts. Allografts either were disparate at both class I and class 11, or were derived from beta2-microglobulin knockout (beta2M-/-) mice, which express class II but are deficient in class I. Two measures of in vivo HTL function were monitored: (1) the accumulation of HTL within the allograft (a process that is dependent upon antigen-driven cytokine production), and (2) the development of cytolytic alloantibodies. After implantation of sponge allografts expressing both class I and class II, HTL were readily detectable in the allograft, and cytolytic alloantibodies were present in the serum. When mice were implanted with beta2M-/- sponge allografts, HTL failed to infiltrate these class I-deficient allografts, and alloantibodies were not detectable in the sera of recipients of beta2M-/- sponge allografts. This in vivo requirement for class I expression was not reflected by traditional in vitro measures of HTL function; cells obtained from lymphoid tissues mounted a mixed lymphocyte response and produced interleukin-2 when stimulated with beta2M-/- splenocytes in vitro. One possible interpretation of these data is that in vivo HTL functions are dependent upon the presence of class I-reactive CD8+ T cells. However, HTL readily infiltrated grafts expressing both class I and class II when recipients depleted of CD8+ T cells, and alloantibodies were produced. These observations support the idea that indirect presentation of allogeneic class I molecules plays a critical role in regulating CD4+ HTL functions associated with allograft rejection in vivo.

Immunosuppressive effects of an HLA class I-derived peptide in a rat cardiac allograft model

B7.75-84, a 10-amino-acid peptide derived from the HLA-B7 molecule, prolongs rat heterotopic cardiac allograft survival time (GST) when used with cyclosporine in the Lewis-to-ACI strain combination. We evaluated the ability of B7.75-84 to prolong GST in other strain combinations without cyclosporine and studied the effect of B7.75-84 on the immune response in the Wistar-Furth (WF)-to-ACI strain combination. GST was markedly prolonged in most low-responder (ACI) recipients but only slightly prolonged in the high-responder (Lewis) recipient. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and helper T lymphocyte (HTL) limiting dilution assays (LDA) were performed 10 days after cardiac allografts from WF donors were placed in ACI recipients treated with B7.75-84. HTL-LDA assays at 10 days posttransplant showed a slight decrease in HTL precursor frequency and a decrease in their IL-2 production in B7.75-84 treated recipients with prolonged GST in response to donor antigen as well as third-party (Lewis) antigen. CTL-LDA assays at day 10 showed no difference in CTL precursor frequency among treated recipients but did show a significant decrease in CTL killing activity against donor cells in recipients with prolonged GST. No significant difference in CTL killing activity was seen against third- party cells. Antibody analysis was performed at day 8 in treated recipients. Serum from B7.75-84-treated recipients with prolonged graft survival generally showed no detectable IgG antibody response against donor MHC class I antigen. All B7.75-84 treated recipients showed a strong IgM response against donor antigen regardless of allograft outcome. Our results suggest that the immunosuppressive effect of B7.75-84 in rats is greater using a low-responder RT1 haplotype. Furthermore, B7.75-84 induces a nonspecific decrease in HTL function while producing a donor-specific decrease in CTL function and a diminished antidonor MHC class I IgG response.

Prevention of murine cardiac allograft rejection with gallium nitrate. Comparison with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody

Gallium nitrate (GN) was evaluated for its ability to interfere with a cute rejection of DBA/2-->C57BL/6 heterotopic cardiac allografts, in comparison with the depleting anti-CD4 mAb, GK1.5. The administration of GN for 30 days (s.c. 30 mg/kg elemental gallium on days 0 and 3, 10 mg/kg every third day) resulted in >60-day graft survival in 78% (25 of 32) of the graft recipients, whereas 2 perioperative injections of anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) resulted in >60-day graft survival in 58% (24 of 41) of the graft recipients. Serum gallium levels peaked at about 2000 ng/ml after 2-3 weeks of treatment and decreased to about 300 ng/ml by day 60, a level that was maintained for at least 30 more days. During the early posttransplant period, 25% of GN-treated grafts, but not anti-CD4 mAb-treated grafts, exhibited an unusual, transient reduction in graft impulse strength, suggesting a transient rejection response. Macroscopically, the long-surviving (>60 days) grafts from either treatment group exhibited none of the features of rejecting allografts. Histologically, they exhibited minor edema and rare epicardial inflammation but no tissue necrosis. However, there were vascular changes in allografts from GN-treated mice, including altered endothelial morphology, associated with moderate intimal hyperplasia and mild perivascular leukocytic infiltration. Allografts from anti-CD4 mAb-treated mice exhibited prominent neointimal hyperplasia associated with endothelial morphologic changes and prominent vascular and perivascular leukocytic infiltration. In general, both GN and anti-CD4 mAb promoted long-term allograft survival, but these allografts displayed the histopathologic signs of ongoing inflammation and chronic allograft rejection.

T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire in alloimmune responses

A large number of alloantigenic determinants could be generated by both the direct and indirect alloantigen presentation pathways. Hence, a heterogeneous population of T cells expressing a wide variety of receptors would be expected to respond to this diverse array of alloantigenic determinants. However, T cells expressing highly restricted T cell receptor (TCR) variable genes have been reported in a variety of alloimmune responses. A similar phenomenon has been observed in a wide variety of other immune responses, from those induced by superantigens, to very specific responses induced by a single peptide presented by a single MHC molecule. Given this scenario, the limited number of T cell clones which dominate an allograft rejection response, or for that matter an autoimmune response or a tumor specific response, could be therapeutically targeted by virtue of the selected TCR expression.

Dissociation of mouse cardiac transplant rejection and donor alloantigen-specific T cell responsiveness

Mouse hearts transplanted into MHC disparate donors are usually rejected 1 week after placement. It is widely accepted that alloantigen-reactive helper T lymphocytes (HTL) and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are the key mediators of acute allograft rejection. This report demonstrates that the presence or absence of 'traditional' graft-reactive HTL and CTL is not necessarily related to allograft survival. In these studies, donor/recipient combinations disparate only at MHC or only at minor histocompatibility (mH) loci were employed. Allograft survival was monitored, donor-reactive IL-2 (interleukin-2) producing HTL and CTL were quantified by modified limiting dilution analysis, and serum levels of cytolytic alloantibody were determined. C57BL/10 hearts (H-2b) transplanted into B10.BR (H-2k) recipients (full MHC disparity) enjoyed prolonged survival despite massive infiltration of the allograft by donor-reactive HTL and CTL. IgM, but not IgG, donor-reactive alloantibody was present in the sera of these mice. Hence, traditional IL-2 producing HTL and CTL were not capable of mediating acute graft rejection, nor of providing help for alloantibody isotype switching in this MHC disparate combination. In contrast, C3H/HeN (H-2k) hearts transplanted into B10.BR (H-2k) recipients (mH disparity only) were acutely rejected. Donor-reactive HTL and CTL were rare or not detectable in these recipients, and cytolytic alloantibody was not detectable. Similar observations were made when B10.BR hearts were transplanted into C3H/HeN recipients. Interestingly, treatment of recipients with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody prevented rejection of mH disparate allografts. Therefore, CD4+ T cells were required for rejection of mH disparate allografts, but this process was independent of detectable IL-2 production or CTL function. Hence, the significance of monitoring 'traditional' T cell functions should be questioned in certain donor/recipient combinations.