Interruption of antiretroviral therapy blunts but does not abrogate CD4 T-cell responses to interleukin-2 administration in HIV infected patients

Effect of intermittent interleukin-2 therapy on CD4+ T-cell counts following antiretroviral cessation in patients with HIV

BACKGROUND

Interleukin (IL)-2 therapy impacts T-cell homeostasis. Whether IL-2 expanded CD4(+) T cells may persist following viral rebound has not been fully investigated.

METHODS

Patients with CD4(+) T cells 500/μl or more and HIV RNA less than 50 copies/ml were randomized to continue antiretroviral therapy (ART) either alone (n = 67) or combined with three IL-2 cycles (n = 81; 6 million units) twice daily for 5 days at weeks 0, 8, and 16 before stopping ART (week 24). Patients were followed up to 168 weeks.

RESULTS

At week 24, median CD4(+) T-cell counts were 1198 and 703 cells/μl in the IL-2 and control groups, respectively (P < 0.001). At week 72, 27% (IL-2 group) and 45% (control group; P = 0.03) of patients were in failure (defined as no interruption of ART at week 24, CD4 drop below 350 cells/μl or ART resumption). After week 24, a biphasic decline (before and after week 32) of CD4 was noted -106 and -7 cells/μl per month in controls and -234 and -17 in IL-2 group (all P ≤ 0.0001). At week 96, IL-2-expanded CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells remained higher than in the control group (26 vs. 16%, P = 0.006).

CONCLUSION

In IL-2-treated patients, CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells persisting despite viral replication allow a longer period of ART interruption.

Role of interleukin-2 in patients with HIV infection

Control of viral replication to below the level of quantification using combination antiretroviral therapy (ART) [cART] has led to a dramatic fall in mortality and morbidity from AIDS. However, despite the success of cART, it has become apparent that many patients do not achieve normalized CD4+ T-cell counts despite virological suppression to below the level of quantification (<50 copies/mL). Increasing data from cohort studies and limited data from clinical trials, such as the SMART study, have shown that higher CD4+ T-cell counts are associated with reductions in morbidity and mortality from both AIDS and serious non-AIDS (SNA) conditions, including cardiovascular disease. Enhancement of immune restoration over and above that achievable with ART alone, using a number of strategies including cytokine therapy, has been of interest for many years. The most studied cytokine in this setting is recombinant interleukin (IL)-2 (rIL-2). The purpose of this review is to describe the current status of rIL-2 as a therapeutic agent in the treatment of HIV-1 infection. The review focuses on the rationale underpinning the exploration of rIL-2 in HIV infection, summarizing the phase II and III findings of rIL-2 as an adjunctive therapy to ART and the phase II studies of rIL-2 as an antiretroviral-sparing agent. The phase II studies demonstrated the potential utility of continuous intravenous IL-2 and subsequently intermittent dosing with subcutaneous rIL-2 as a cytokine that could expand the CD4+ T-cell pool in HIV-1-infected patients without any significant detrimental effect on HIV viral load and with an acceptable adverse-effect profile. These data were utilized in designing the phase II studies of rIL-2 as an ART-sparing agent and, more importantly, the large phase III clinical endpoint studies of rIL-2 in HIV-1-infected adults, ESPRIT and SILCAAT. In the latter, subcutaneous rIL-2 was given intermittently (5 days of twice-daily dosing at 4.5-7.5 million international units per dose every 8 weeks) to HIV-1-infected adults receiving cART using an induction/maintenance strategy. Both studies explored the clinical benefit of intermittent subcutaneous rIL-2 with cART versus cART in HIV-infected adults with CD4+ T-cell counts > or = 300 cells/microL (ESPRIT study) and 50-299 cells/microL (SILCAAT study). Both studies showed that receipt of rIL-2 conferred no clinical benefit despite a significantly higher CD4+ T-cell count in the rIL-2 arms of both studies. Moreover, there was an excess of grade 4 clinical events in ESPRIT rIL-2 recipients. The results of the phase III clinical endpoint studies showed that rIL-2 has no place as a therapeutic agent in the treatment of HIV infection.

Virological rebound and its consequences during treatment interruption

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This paper provides an overview of the current knowledge on virological rebound during treatment interruption and its consequences in patients with chronic HIV-1 infection.

RECENT FINDINGS

After interruption of antiretroviral therapy, plasma viremia inevitably returns to individual pretherapy set point levels in almost all patients with chronic HIV infection. This virological rebound leads to a state of massive immune activation and consequently an increased turnover of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells resulting in a biphasic decay of T-helper cell numbers. Rebound has been shown to be associated with an increased risk of clinical events by some (albeit not all) randomized trials published during the last few months. Secondary consequences of immunologic deterioration include worsening of comorbidity (e.g. hepatitis and renal impairment) and an increased risk of cardiovascular disease as well as an elevated HIV transmission risk during treatment interruption. The individual course after treatment interruption cannot be predicted by any of the known surrogate markers.

SUMMARY

Treatment interruptions cannot be recommended in HIV-infected patients outside clinical trials, especially when profound immune deficiency is found to be preexisting.

Interleukin-2 cycling causes transient increases in high-sensitivity C-reactive protein and D-dimer that are not associated with plasma HIV-RNA levels

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of interleukin (IL)-2 treatment on inflammatory and thrombotic biomarkers in chronically HIV-infected adults receiving antiretroviral therapy.

METHODS

Cryopreserved plasma was evaluated retrospectively for C-reactive protein (CRP) and D-dimer at baseline, end of an IL-2 cycle, and long-term follow up from two randomized, controlled trials: 57 IL-2-naive adults receiving either three to six cycles of IL-2 as well as antiretroviral therapy (nucleoside analogues) or antiretroviral therapy alone for 12 months, and 40 IL-2-experienced adults on highly active antiretroviral therapy who either interrupted or continued therapy for 6 months after a baseline IL-2 cycle. High-sensitivity CRP (hsCRP) was measured by immunonephelometry (detection limit 0.175 mg/l) and D-dimer by latex agglutination (detection limit 0.20 mg/l). Median within-group differences and pre and post-IL-2 changes between groups were assessed via nonparametric Wilcoxon signed-rank and Mann-Whitney U-tests. Spearman's rank test was used to assess correlations between changes in hsCRP, D-dimer, and HIV-RNA viral load.

RESULTS

Significant increases in hsCRP (study 1: 138.6 mg/l; study 2: 58.9 mg/l) and D-dimer (study 1: 3.1 mg/l; study 2: 0.4 mg/l, all P < 0.0001) occurred by the end of the initial IL-2 cycle, returning to baseline by the end of study. No correlations were seen between changes in hsCRP or D-dimer and HIV-RNA, CD4 T-cell count, or proliferation (Ki67 expression). No thrombotic or cardiovascular serious adverse events occurred during these study periods.

CONCLUSION

IL-2 dosing caused transient increases in plasma hsCRP and D-dimer levels, regardless of HIV-RNA viral load, suggesting the possibility of increased risk for thrombotic events.

Inferiority of IL-2 alone versus IL-2 with HAART in maintaining CD4 T cell counts during HAART interruption: a randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate whether interleukin (IL)-2 in patients with chronic HIV infection can maintain CD4 T cell counts during 6 months of HAART interruption.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, controlled, open-label phase II noninferiority trial comparing IL-2 with HAART interruption or continuous HAART.

METHODS

Forty-one IL-2-experienced (three or more prior cycles) HIV-1-infected adults with CD4 cell count at least 500 cells/microl were randomized in the ratio 2: 1 to interrupted (I = 27) or continuous (C = 14) HAART for 6 months following an initial IL-2 cycle. Subsequent IL-2 cycles were triggered by CD4 T cell counts less than 90% of baseline. Immune, metabolic, and quality of life indices were compared (Mann-Whitney and Fisher's exact tests), defining noninferiority as a percentage difference (C- I) in treatment success (CD4 T cells > or =90% of baseline at 6 months) with a 95% confidence interval (CI) lower limit greater than -20%.

RESULTS

Demographic and immune parameters were similar between the groups at baseline. Median CD4 T cell count, HIV viral load, and treatment success differed significantly at 6 months (I: 866 cells/microl, 39,389 copies/ml, 48.1%; C: 1246 cells/microl, <50 copies/ml, 92.3%; P < or = 0.001). Group I was inferior to C (% difference = -44.2%; 95% CI: -64.2%, -11.2%; P = 0.013). Minor statistically significant differences in HgbA1c and energy level occurred at 6 months (I > C). Following HAART interruption, single cases of acute retroviral syndrome, secondary syphilis, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, and Kaposi's sarcoma recurrence were observed.

CONCLUSION

IL-2 alone was inferior to IL-2 with HAART in maintaining baseline CD4 T cell counts. HAART interruption had a small impact on metabolic parameters and quality of life.

Distinctive in vitro effects of T-cell growth cytokines on cytomegalovirus-stimulated T-cell responses of HIV-infected HAART recipients

Functional immune reconstitution is limited after HAART, maintaining the interest in adjunctive immune-modulators. We compared in vitro the effects of the gamma-chain T-cell growth cytokines IL-2, IL-4, IL-7 and IL-15 on cytomegalovirus-stimulated cell-mediated immunity. IL-2 and IL-15 increased cytomegalovirus-specific lymphocyte proliferation in HAART recipients, whereas IL-4 and IL-7 did not. The boosting effect of IL-2 and IL-15 on proliferation correlated with their ability to prevent late apoptosis. However, IL-2 increased the frequency of cells in early apoptosis, whereas IL-15 increased the frequency of fully viable cells. Both IL-2 and IL-15 increased cytomegalovirus-induced CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell proliferation and the synthesis of Th1 and pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines. However, only IL-2 increased the frequency of regulatory T cells and Th2 cytokine production, both of which have the potential to attenuate antiviral immune responses. Overall, compared to other gamma-chain cytokines, IL-15 had the most favorable profile for boosting antiviral cell-mediated immunity.

The effect of continuous versus pericycle antiretroviral therapy on IL-2 responsiveness

BACKGROUND

Intermittent administration of interleukin-2 (IL-2) to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)- infected patients on antiretroviral therapy (ART) is capable of inducing significant increases in CD4 T cell counts as a result of increased T cell survival and decreased cell turnover. However, its role in the setting of ART interruptions (STI) is less well characterized. We sought to compare the effect of continuous (C) versus intermittent (P) ART on CD4 responses in patients undergoing IL-2 therapy.

METHODS

CD4 cell responses were compared in 25 patients who underwent IL-2 therapy during periods of continuous ART (n = 90 cycles) as well as during STI (n = 45 cycles). During STI, patients resumed ART for only 10 days surrounding each IL-2 cycle.

RESULTS

C cycles resulted in a significantly greater CD4 gain than P cycles (Delta156 cells/microL, 95% CI = 68-243). In multivariate analyses, baseline CD4/CD25 expression and treatment arm remained strong predictors of CD4 gain while CD8/CD38+, CD8/DR+, and CD4 Ki67+ phenotype were not predictive.

CONCLUSIONS

Continuous ART was associated with a statistically significantly greater CD4 cell response to IL-2 therapy than was intermittent ART. These observations may have important implications for the appropriate integration of IL-2 therapy into STI strategies.

TILT: a randomized controlled trial of interruption of antiretroviral therapy with or without interleukin-2 in HIV-1 infected individuals

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to see if structured treatment interruption (STI) could be supported safely with the use of two cycles of IL-2 (4.5 MIU q12h subcutaneously 5 days) before STI to prolong the time before therapy restarted.

METHODS

Subjects were randomly allocated to either A - continuous ART; B - continue for 9 weeks, then STI; restart with the same ART when the CD4 count falls below 200 cells; or C - two cycles of IL-2, 8 weeks apart, while still on ART; at week 9 stop ART and use a new cycle of IL-2 alone whenever the CD4 count falls < 300 cells. Patients were followed until week 105.

RESULTS

86 mostly white middle aged homosexual men with a baseline median CD4 count of 754 cells/ml (range 240-1400) and a nadir CD4 count of 268 cells/ml (range 62-822) enrolled. By 96 weeks there was a 66% probability of having restarted ART in arm B compared with 34% in arm C (p = 0.002; log rank test). New drugs were used in 60% in arm A, 57% in arm B and 45% in arm C. 4 subjects had a dose modification in the first cycle due to toxicity with 2 interrupting. There were 39 SAEs with 21 in arm C. There were no deaths.

CONCLUSIONS

The primary aim of the trial was to gain experience in using IL-2. IL-2 delayed restarting drugs and fewer new drugs were used.

Long-term effects of intermittent interleukin-2 therapy in chronic HIV-infected patients (ANRS 048-079 Trials)

OBJECTIVE

Interleukin (IL)-2 therapy leads to significant CD4 cell increases in HIV-infected patients. Since phase III trials are ongoing, studies supporting the long-term feasibility of this strategy are needed.

METHODS

We studied the long-term outcomes of 131 patients treated with IL-2 in two studies initiated either before (ANRS 048) or following (ANRS 079) the advent of HAART.

RESULTS

At the last assessment (median follow-up 3.4 years), these patients experienced a gain of 428 cells/microl and a decrease in plasma HIV RNA to 1.70 log10 copies/ml. In both studies, high CD4 cell counts were maintained with a median of ten 5-day cycles of subcutaneous IL-2. Median time since the last cycle was 2 years. At last assessment, 59% of 048 patients maintained a non-HAART regimen. Detailed analysis at week 170 showed that median CD4 cell counts were 856 (048) and 964 (079) cells/microl. This corresponded to a gain from baseline of 515 (048) and 627 (079) cells/microl. The median viral load decreases from baseline and corresponded to 1.70 (048) and 1.88 (079) log10 copies/ml. Comparisons across the studies showed that CD4 gains and viral load changes were similar whether HAART or non-HAART was used. The frequency of cycling, but not CD4 cell counts, viral loads or antiviral regimen at baseline, was predictive of long-term CD4 gain (P = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Altogether, these observations support IL-2 as a long-term therapeutic strategy in HIV infection.

A pilot study evaluating time to CD4 T-cell count <350 cells/mm(3) after treatment interruption following antiretroviral therapy +/- interleukin 2: results of ACTG A5102

BACKGROUND

Although an intermittent antiviral treatment (ART) strategy may limit long-term toxicity and cost, there is concern about the risk for virologic failure, selection of drug resistance mutations, and disease progression. By boosting CD4 T-cell counts, interleukin 2 (IL-2) could safely prolong the duration of treatment interruption (TI) in a CD4-driven strategy.

METHODS

The AIDS Clinical Trials Group (ACTG) study A5102 evaluated 3 cycles of IL-2 before TI, on clinical and immunologic outcomes, using a CD4 T-cell count of <350 cells/mm as the threshold for restarting ART. Forty-seven HIV-infected subjects on potent ART with CD4 T-cell counts of > or =500 cells/mm or more and HIV RNA levels of less than 200 copies/mL were randomized to arm A (ART + three 5-day cycles of IL-2 at 4.5 million U, Sc, BID every 8 weeks, n = 23) or arm B (ART alone, n = 24) for 18 weeks (step 1). At the end of step 1, subjects with a CD4 T-cell count of > or =500 cells/mm or more stopped ART until a CD4 count of <350 cells/mm (step 2). CD4 T-cell count, time to return of viremia, and the emergence of drug resistance mutations after TI were compared between study arms.

RESULTS

IL-2 recipients maintained higher CD4 counts during TI for 48 weeks with a waning of the CD4 effect by 72 weeks. A sustained CD4 T-cell count of more than 350 cells/mm and more durable TI were associated with a higher nadir CD4 T-cell count before ART and higher naive CD4 T-cell count at entry. After TI, a higher viral set point and drug resistance mutations at virologic rebound were associated with a shorter time to CD4 T-cell count of less than 350 cell/mm. There were no differences in the magnitude of virologic rebound (at week 8 of step 2, median log10 HIV RNA level was 4.23 for arm A and 4.21 for arm B) or the steady-state HIV-1 RNA level after week 8.

CONCLUSIONS

IL-2 before TI did not prolong time to CD4 of less than 350 cells/mm. A TI strategy utilizing a CD4 T-cell threshold of less than 350 cells/mm for restarting ART appears generally safe with most subjects in both arms remaining off ART for more than 1 year. Implications of our results for TI strategies include the potential advantage of starting ART at higher CD4 T-cell levels while avoiding any drug resistance and evaluating immunomodulators or drugs to reduce T-cell activation and HIV-1 RNA rebound during the TI.