Pneumococcal meningitis in a pediatric intensive care unit: prognostic factors in a series of 49 children

Risk Factors for Death and Severe Neurological Sequelae in Childhood Bacterial Meningitis

INTRODUCTION

Acute bacterial meningitis (ABM) continues to be a challenge from a diagnostic and therapeutic point of view. Identifying severity risk factors and predictive scores may guide interventions to reduce poor outcome.

METHODS

Data from a retrospective study for ABM in children admitted to the Institute of Tropical Medicine in Paraguay was analyzed. ABM was defined as positive cerebrospinal fluid culture, positive latex agglutination, or identification of microorganism by real time-polymerase chain reaction. Univariate and multivariate analyses of risk factors at hospital admission that predicted major morbidity or death during hospitalization were performed. A point-based scoring system that included variables, which were clearly different among those who passed away, was constructed.

RESULTS

One hundred fourteen children hospitalized with ABM were eligible for the study. The mean age was 46 ± 57 months (range, 1-192 months). The observed mortality was 33% (38/114 patients). When a point-based scoring system was used, for score of 0 (n = 29) and 1 (n = 12), no death was observed. Among patients with a score of 2 (n = 14), 3 (n = 10 patients), 4 (n = 12 patients), and 5 (n = 13 patients), the mortality rate was 14.3%, 40%, 50%, and 53.8%, respectively. When the score was 6 or higher, the mortality rate was at least 63.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

The present score accurately discriminated the probability of death in children hospitalized with ABM, and it could be a useful tool to select candidates for admission to the intensive care unit and for adjunctive therapy in clinical trials.

Systematic Review: Incidence and Course of Hearing Loss Caused by Bacterial Meningitis: In Search of an Optimal Timed Audiological Follow-up

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to clarify the incidence and course of hearing loss after bacterial meningitis to optimize the audiological follow-up.

DATA SOURCES

The databases Embase, Medline (OvidSP), Web-of-science, Scopus, Cinahl, Cochrane, PubMed publisher, and Google Scholar were used. Only articles written in English were included.

STUDY SELECTION

Articles published from 1985 until March 2015 describing the incidence, risk factors, or course of hearing loss after meningitis were used.

DATA EXTRACTION

The quality of the studies was assessed on three aspects: quality of audiometry, number of patients, and methodological quality.

DATA SYNTHESIS

For each publication, data were entered in spreadsheet software for analysis. The data were analyzed and interpreted using best evidence synthesis.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall quality of the included studies was poor. A major drawback was the quality of the (description of) audiometry, severity, and timing of hearing loss.A systematic review of the literature showed an incidence of hearing loss (>25 ± 5  dB) of 14% and an incidence of 5% for profound hearing loss (>90  dB). Patients with initial normal hearing after meningitis showed stable normal hearing over time. However, initial hearing loss related to meningitis can improve or deteriorate over time.We therefore recommend early audiological testing of all patients who suffered bacterial meningitis. However, long-term audiological follow-up is only needed for patients with early onset hearing loss and not for patients with normal hearing at the first hearing test.

The burden of pneumococcal meningitis in Austrian children between 2001 and 2008

The present study was conducted to evaluate the burden of pneumococcal meningitis in Austrian children between 2001 and 2008. Clinical outcome was retrospectively analyzed both on discharge and on follow-up investigations. This study was based on a prospective multicentre surveillance study on hospitalized invasive pneumococcal infections in Austrian children with a total annual "study population" of about 399,000 children aged below 5 years per year. Between 2001 and 2008, 74 cases of pneumococcal meningitis were identified in children aged below 5 years. The mean annual incidence rate for pneumococcal meningitis was 2.3 per 100,000 children in this age group. In 57/74 children (mean age on admission 14.5 ± 13.3 months), outcome data on hospital discharge were available: 5 deaths (8.8%), 20 children (35.1%) with sequelae and 32 children (56.1%) without sequelae were observed. Sequelae on discharge included motor impairment in 8 children (14.0%), hearing impairment in 9 children (15.8%) and/or other complications in 14 children (24.6%). In 7/8 children with motor deficits, matching cerebral lesions were identified by neuroimaging: cerebral infarction in five children, cerebral vasculitis and cerebral abscess in one child each. In 40/57 children, long-term outcome (18.9 ± 20.2 months after discharge) could be assessed: 1 child (2.5%) died 9 months after hospital discharge, 11 children (27.5%) had one or two long-term sequelae and 28 children (70.0%) had no sequelae. Long-term sequelae included motor impairment in three children (7.5%), hearing impairment in nine children (22.5%) and other deficits in two children (5.0%).

CONCLUSION

Our study confirms that pneumococcal meningitis causes high mortality and severe long-term sequelae. On long-term follow-up, we observed improvements of motor impairment, but not of hearing impairment.

A prospective study of risk factors for neurological complications in childhood bacterial meningitis

OBJECTIVE

To prospectively analyze the prognostic factors for neurological complications of childhood bacterial meningitis.

METHODS

This prospective study enrolled 77 children from 1 month until 16 years of age, treated for bacterial meningitis during the period of January 1, 2009 through December 31, 2010. 16 relevant predictors were chosen to analyze their association with the incidence of neurological complications. p-values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Of the 77 children treated for bacterial meningitis, 33 patients developed neurological complications (43%), and two children died (2.6%). The etiology of bacterial meningitis cases was proven in 57/77 (74%) cases: 32 meningococci, eight pneumococci, six Gram-negative bacilli, five H. influenzae, five staphylococci, and one S. viridans isolates were found. Factors found to be associated with increased risk of development of neurological complications were age < 12 months, altered mental status, seizures prior to admission, initial therapy with two antibiotics, dexamethasone use, presence of focal neurological deficit on admission and increased proteins in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) (p < 0.05). Initial pleocytosis > 5,000 cells/mm(3), pleocytosis > 5,000 cells/mm(3) after 48 hours, CSF/blood glucose ratio < 0.20, female gender, previous treatment with antibiotics, community-acquired infection, duration of illness > 48 hours, presence of comorbidity, and primary focus of infection were not associated with increased risk for the development of neurological complications.

CONCLUSION

Age < 12 months and severity of clinical presentation at admission were identified as the strongest predictors of neurological complications and may be of value in selecting patients for more intensive care and treatment.

Prognostic accuracy of five simple scales in childhood bacterial meningitis

BACKGROUND

In childhood acute bacterial meningitis, the level of consciousness, measured with the Glasgow coma scale (GCS) or the Blantyre coma scale (BCS), is the most important predictor of outcome. The Herson-Todd scale (HTS) was developed for Haemophilus influenzae meningitis. Our objective was to identify prognostic factors, to form a simple scale, and to compare the predictive accuracy of these scales.

METHODS

Seven hundred and twenty-three children with bacterial meningitis in Luanda were scored by GCS, BCS, and HTS. The simple Luanda scale (SLS), based on our entire database, comprised domestic electricity, days of illness, convulsions, consciousness, and dyspnoea at presentation. The Bayesian Luanda scale (BLS) added blood glucose concentration. The accuracy of the 5 scales was determined for 491 children without an underlying condition, against the outcomes of death, severe neurological sequelae or death, or a poor outcome (severe neurological sequelae, death, or deafness), at hospital discharge.

RESULTS

The highest accuracy was achieved with the BLS, whose area under the curve (AUC) for death was 0.83, for severe neurological sequelae or death was 0.84, and for poor outcome was 0.82. Overall, the AUCs for SLS were ≥0.79, for GCS were ≥0.76, for BCS were ≥0.74, and for HTS were ≥0.68.

CONCLUSIONS

Adding laboratory parameters to a simple scoring system, such as the SLS, improves the prognostic accuracy only little in bacterial meningitis.

Predicting sequelae and death after bacterial meningitis in childhood: a systematic review of prognostic studies

Background

Bacterial meningitis (BM) is a severe infection responsible for high mortality and disabling sequelae. Early identification of patients at high risk of these outcomes is necessary to prevent their occurrence by adequate treatment as much as possible. For this reason, several prognostic models have been developed. The objective of this study is to summarize the evidence regarding prognostic factors predicting death or sequelae due to BM in children 0-18 years of age.

Methods

A search in MEDLINE and EMBASE was conducted to identify prognostic studies on risk factors for mortality and sequelae after BM in children. Selection of abstracts, full-text articles and assessment of methodological quality using the QUIPS checklist was performed by two reviewers independently. Data on prognostic factors per outcome were summarized.

Results

Of the 31 studies identified, 15 were of moderate to high quality. Due to substantial heterogeneity in study characteristics and evaluated prognostic factors, no quantitative analysis was performed. Prognostic factors found to be statistically significant in more than one study of moderate or high quality are: complaints >48 hours before admission, coma/impaired consciousness, (prolonged duration of) seizures, (prolonged) fever, shock, peripheral circulatory failure, respiratory distress, absence of petechiae, causative pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae, young age, male gender, several cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) parameters and white blood cell (WBC) count.

Conclusions

Although several important prognostic factors for the prediction of mortality or sequelae after BM were identified, the inability to perform a pooled analysis makes the exact (independent) predictive value of these factors uncertain. This emphasizes the need for additional well-conducted prognostic studies.

Invasive pneumococcal disease in children prior to implementation of the conjugate vaccine in the Zurich region, Switzerland

OBJECTIVE

To describe symptoms, disease manifestations and outcome of invasive pneumococcal disease in children prior to implementation of the pneumococcal vaccine.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Analysis of children younger than 16 years of age with invasive pneumococcal disease (IPD; n = 119). Children with culture-confirmed IPD, without underlying illness at risk for invasive disease, were included.

RESULTS

IPD in 90 children (age: median 2, mean 3.2 years) included 15 with meningitis, 16 with septicaemia, 14 with bacteraemia, 24 with pneumonia and 21 with skin, bone and joint infections. Symptoms of IPD most often described were fever and gastrointestinal symptoms (abdominal pain, vomiting, or diarrhoea), and coughing. More than 90% of children with pneumonia were coughing. Most importantly, clinical signs significantly predictive for severe IPD included tachycardia for sepsis, tachypnea for pneumonia, and meningeal signs for meningitis. Leukocyte, neutrophil and platelet counts were lower and C-reactive protein concentrations were higher on admission in children with complicated than in children with uncomplicated IPD but, due to wide overlap of these numbers, the difference was not of prognostic help to predict clinical course and outcome. Overall, 40% of children with IPD manifested complications and IPD showed a mortality rate of 6.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

IPD is a serious disease with a high complication rate and mortality. The clinical signs tachycardia, tachypnea, and meningism were highly predictive for severe IPD. The initial clinical presentation and laboratory evaluation were mostly unpredictable with respect to complications and outcome in contrast to the clinical signs.

The risk of sequelae due to pneumococcal meningitis in high-income countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To determine the risk of various kinds of sequelae in survivors of meningitis due to Streptococcus pneumoniae, as well as the influence of co-factors such as study design, study population and treatment on this risk.

METHODS

MEDLINE, EMBASE and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) were searched from 1 September 1991 to 18 June 2009 for original articles on pneumococcal meningitis sequelae. Prevalence of sequelae was pooled using random effects meta-analysis. Studies were appraised for the influence of referral bias, external validity of study populations, testing procedure and publication bias.

RESULTS

Data were extracted from 63 studies involving 3408 pneumococcal meningitis survivors. The pooled prevalence of any reported sequelae from 48 studies was 31.7% (95% confidence interval 27.2-36.3%) using a random effects model (Cochran-Q = 277, p < 0.01). Differences in studies due to design, study population and treatment were not significant. The pooled prevalence of hearing loss, seizures, hydrocephalus, spasticity/paresis, cranial nerve palsies and visual impairment was 20.9% (17.1-24.7%), 6.5% (3.3-9.7%), 6.8% (3.3-10.2%), 8.7% (6.4-11.0%), 12.2% (5.3-19.1%) and 2.4% (0-5.7%) respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The burden of sequelae due to pneumococcal meningitis remains high in the reviewed studies.

Application of the pediatric risk of mortality (PRISM) score and determination of mortality risk factors in a tertiary pediatric intensive care unit

INTRODUCTION

To establish disease severity at admission can be performed by way of the mortality prognostic. Nowadays the prognostic scores make part of quality control and research. The Pediatric Risk of Mortality is one of the scores used in the pediatric intensive care units.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study is the utilization of the pediatric risk of mortality to determine mortality risk factors in a tertiary pediatric intensive care units.

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study, in a period of one year, at a general tertiary pediatric intensive care unit. The pediatric risk of mortality scores corresponding to the first 24 hours of hospitalization were recorded; additional data were collected to characterize the study population.

RESULTS

359 patients were included; the variables that were found to be risk factors for death were multiple organ dysfunction syndrome, mechanical ventilation, use of vasoactive drugs, hospital-acquired infection, parenteral nutrition and duration of hospitalization (p < 0,0001). Fifty-four patients (15%) died; median pediatric risk of mortality score was significantly lower in patients who survived (p=0,0001). The ROC curve yielded a value of 0.76 (CI 95% 0,69-0,83) and the calibration was shown to be adequate.

DISCUSSION

It is imperative for pediatric intensive care units to implement strict quality controls to identify groups at risk of death and to ensure the adequacy of treatment. Although some authors have shown that the PRISM score overestimates mortality and that it is not appropriate in specific pediatric populations, in this study pediatric risk of mortality showed satisfactory discriminatory performance in differentiating between survivors and non-survivors.

CONCLUSIONS

The pediatric risk of mortality score showed adequate discriminatory capacity and thus constitutes a useful tool for the assessment of prognosis for pediatric patients admitted to a tertiary pediatric intensive care units.

Test characteristics and interpretation of cerebrospinal fluid gram stain in children

BACKGROUND

Few data exist regarding the test characteristics of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) Gram stain among children at risk for bacterial meningitis, especially the rate of false positive Gram stain.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of children seen in the emergency department of Children's Hospital Boston who had CSF obtained between December 1992 and September 2005. Patients who had ventricular shunts, as well as those who received antibiotics before CSF was obtained were excluded. Test characteristics of CSF Gram stain were assessed using CSF culture as the criterion standard. Patients were considered to have bacterial meningitis if there was either: (1) growth of a pathogen, or (2) growth of a possible pathogen noted on the final CSF culture report and the patient was treated with a course of parenteral antibiotics for 7 days or more without other indication.

RESULTS

A total of 17,569 eligible CSF specimens were collected among 16,036 patients during the 13-year study period. The median age of study subjects was 74 days. Seventy CSF specimens (0.4%) had organisms detected on Gram stain. The overall sensitivity of Gram stain to detect bacterial meningitis was 67% [42 of 63; 95% confidence interval (CI): 54-78] with a positive predictive value of 60% (42 of 70; 95% CI: 48-71). Most patients without bacterial meningitis have negative Gram stain [specificity 99.9% (17,478 of 17,506; 95% CI: 99.8-99.9)] with a negative predictive value of 99.9 (17,478 of 17,499; 95% CI: 99.8-99.9).

CONCLUSIONS

CSF Gram stain is appropriately used by physicians in risk stratification for the diagnosis and empiric treatment of bacterial meningitis in children. Although a positive Gram stain result greatly increases the likelihood of bacterial meningitis; the result may be because of contamination or misinterpretation in 40% of cases and should not, by itself, result in a full treatment course for bacterial meningitis.

Mortalité par méningites à pneumocoque chez l'enfant. Facteurs pronostiques à propos d'une série de 73 observations

OBJECTIVE

Despite advances in antibiotic therapy strategies and pediatric intensive care, prognosis of Streptococcus pneumoniae meningitis remains very poor. To determine the factors associated with hospital mortality of children with pneumococcal meningitis.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of 73 cases of childhood pneumococcal meningitis admitted in 4 teaching hospitals in the center of Tunisia during a 8-year period (1995-2002).

RESULTS

Hospital mortality was 13.7% (10 of 71 patients), and neurologic sequela were observed in 34.5% of survivors. Based on univariable analysis, five variables were associated with the outcome: Pediatric Risk of Mortality score (p < 0.001), coma (p=0.0009), use of mechanical ventilation (p=0.0001), convulsions (p = 0.0449), and shock (p=0.0085). In multivariable analysis, only 2 factors were independently associated with in-hospital mortality: Pediatric Risk of Mortality score and the use of mechanical ventilation. 11.8% of pneumococcal isolates were intermediate and resistant to penicillin. Non-susceptible pneumococcus strains to penicillin and the use of steroids were not associated significantly with the mortality rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Pneumococcal meningitis remains a devastating childhood disease. Two variables were independently associated with the in-hospital death in our series (high Pediatric Risk of Mortality score, and the use of mechanical ventilation). According to these data we may recommend the inclusion of vaccination against streptococcus pneumonia in the children's immunization program in Tunisia.

Controversies in the treatment of pneumococcal community-acquired pneumonia

Community-acquired pneumonia remains an important cause of disease and death both in the developed and the developing worlds, despite the ready availability of potent antimicrobial agents to which the organisms remain susceptible. Furthermore, disease management is complicated by emerging resistance of the common pathogens to the various classes of commonly prescribed antimicrobial agents. Much recent research in the field of community-acquired pneumonia has focused attention on optimal treatment, evaluating the impact of antibiotic resistance, as well as of antimicrobial choices, on the outcome of these infections. In addition, efforts have been directed towards finding adjunctive therapies to antibiotics that may improve the prognosis of these patients. This article reviews some of these research areas, highlighting controversies that still exist with regard to final recommendations, and in particular with regard to infections with Streptococcus pneumoniae, the most common bacterial cause of community-acquired pneumonia.

Strategies to prevent neuronal damage in paediatric bacterial meningitis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The mortality of bacterial meningitis can reach 30%, and up to 50% of survivors suffer from persisting neurological deficits as a consequence of the disease. The incidence of neurological sequelae of bacterial meningitis has not improved over the last decade. Adjunctive therapeutic options are limited, and ongoing research into the pathophysiology of brain damage in bacterial meningitis aims at providing the scientific basis for future development of more efficient adjunctive options.

RECENT FINDINGS

In a population with good access to health care, dexamethasone given before or at the time of initiation of antibiotic therapy acts beneficially in paediatric pneumococcal meningitis, but not in meningococcal meningitis. In experimental animal models, brain-derived neurotrophic factor protected against brain injury and improved hearing while melatonin, which has antioxidant properties among other effects, reduced neuronal death. Transgene technology can be used to provide new insights into the pathophysiology of the disease and to identify potential therapeutic targets.

SUMMARY

Although dexamethasone improves outcome of bacterial meningitis under defined circumstances, the morbidity of bacterial meningitis still remains unacceptably high. Experimental models may help to identify new therapeutic strategies to further improve the neurological outcome in young children suffering from bacterial meningitis.