Developing a province-wide hip surveillance program for children with cerebral palsy: from evidence to consensus to program implementation: a mini-review

Incidence of hip problems in developmental central hypotonia: A scoping review

AIM

To describe what is known about hip problems in individuals with developmental central hypotonia.

METHOD

Searches were conducted in five databases to October 2023. Down syndrome was excluded from this analysis of less well-known genetic diagnoses. At least two reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, read full-text articles, and extracted data.

RESULTS

Of 89 full-text articles, 79 met inclusion criteria. Studies included 544 individuals aged 1 month to 63 years with Kabuki, 49, XXXXY, Prader-Willi, PURA, Koolen de Vries, Emanuel, TRPM3, Wolf-Hirschhorn, and other rare syndromes. Most diagnoses may be associated with a combination of differences in hip structure or stability that are evident at birth, or develop in early infancy, with increasing hip dysplasia and subluxation over time. Joint or ligamentous laxity was most reported along with hypotonia and hypermobility as risk factors. Limited data were identified about conservative or surgical intervention and outcomes in these populations.

INTERPRETATION

Children with significant hypotonia, with or without a confirmed genetic diagnosis, are at increased risk of hip problems that may be missed with standard neonatal screening. Ultrasound is recommended between 6 weeks and 6 months, and annual orthopaedic review with regular radiographs for older children and adults with significant and persistent hypotonia.

Description of Hip Deformities in 5-Year-Old Patients with Congenital Zika Virus Syndrome: A Cross-Sectional Study

Objective  To report on the most prevalent hip alterations in children older than 5 with congenital Zika virus syndrome (CZS) per clinical and radiographic examinations. Methods  Cross-sectional and retrospective study of 62 patients older than 5 with CZS. We extracted clinical data, including maximum abduction values, hip flexion contracture, gross motor function classification system (GMFCS) level, and radiographical data, including Reimers index (RI), femoral neck-shaft angle (FNSA), and acetabular index (AI), from medical records and radiographs and statistically evaluated them. Results  The mean age of children was 65.6 ± 4.1 months. Most patients (95.2%) presented GMFCS scores of IV and V. Slow hip abduction was 41.2 ± 19.5°. The Thomas test revealed a mean deviation of 16.1 ± 14.9°. The mean values of RI, FNSA, and AI were 54.1 ± 34.1%, 158 ± 11.9°, and 26.0 ± 8.12°, respectively. Patients with GMFCS III and IV had lower RI and AI than those with a score of V. Regarding FNSA, there was no statistical difference between groups. Patients who underwent tenotomy of the hip adductor muscles presented greater abduction but no relevant radiographic differences. Conclusion  There was a higher incidence of patients with hip luxation and more compromised functional degrees (GMFCS IV and V), and increased RI and AI in V. Operated patients presented abduction gain abduction but no radiographic improvement. Long-term studies are required to evaluate hip deformities in these subjects.

Hip Displacement After Triradiate Closure in Ambulatory Cerebral Palsy: Who Needs Continued Surveillance?

BACKGROUND

Hip surveillance in cerebral palsy (CP) is an accepted practice with evidence-based guidelines implemented. For the skeletally immature with open triradiate cartilage (TRC), recommendations for radiographic surveillance stemmed from population-based studies. For nonambulatory CP, progression of hip displacement after skeletal maturity has been reported; less is known for ambulatory CP. We aimed to determine the prevalence and risk factors associated with progressive hip displacement after TRC closure, a proxy for skeletal maturity, for ambulatory CP.

METHODS

This is a retrospective cohort study of patients with ambulatory CP (Gross Motor Function Classification System I-III), with unilateral or bilateral involvement, hypertonic motor type, regular hip surveillance (≥3 radiographs after age 10 yr, 1 before TRC closure, ≥1 after age 16 yr), and 2-year follow-up post-TRC closure. The primary outcome was migration percentage (MP). Other variables included previous preventative/reconstructive surgery, topographic pattern, sex, scoliosis, epilepsy, and ventriculoperitoneal shunt. An "unsuccessful hip" was defined by MP ≥30%, MP progression ≥10%, and/or requiring reconstructive surgery after TRC closure. Statistical analyses included chi-square and multivariate Cox regression. Kaplan-Meier survivorship curves were also determined. Receiver operating characteristic analysis was used to determine the MP threshold for progression to an "unsuccessful hip" after TRC closure.

RESULTS

Seventy-six patients (39.5% female) met the inclusion criteria, mean follow-up 4.7±2.1 years after TRC closure. Sixteen (21.1%) patients had an unsuccessful hip outcome. By chi-square analysis, diplegia ( P =0.002) and epilepsy ( P =0.04) were risk factors for an unsuccessful hip. By multivariate analysis, only first MP after TRC closure ( P <0.001) was a significant risk factor for progression to an unsuccessful hip; MP ≥28% being the determined threshold (receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, area under curve: 0.845, P <0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of MP progression after skeletal maturity is relatively high (21%), similar to nonambulatory CP. Annual hip surveillance radiographs after TRC closure should continue for Gross Motor Function Classification System I-III with an MP ≥28% after TRC closure, especially for bilateral CP and epilepsy.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

More than 20 years of experience with Dega transiliac osteotomy in the treatment of dislocated hip joints in children with cerebral palsy

Cerebral palsy in children, which is the result of a nonprogressing damage to the central nervous system, causes motor and posture disorders that change with age. The level of child activity correlates with the hip dislocation risk. It most often affects nonwalking patients and those with tetraparesis or oblique pelvis. The aim of the study was to assess the effectiveness and clinical value of Dega pelvic osteotomy with accompanying directional femoral bone osteotomy after minimum of 20 years from surgery of patients with cerebral palsy. The conducted research was retrospective and concerned the children operated at our Hospital. The assessment was carried out in 346 children with spastic hip during the years 1993-2000. The inclusion criteria were applied: unilateral dislocation of the hip, the observation period of at least 20 years, pelvic osteotomy by Dega method and combined with varus derotation femur osteotomy. The analysis involved fifteen patients. The follow-up period was minimum 20 years (20-27 years). The average migration percentage decreased from 88% down to 25%, and an improved range of mobility was observed in the operated joint after surgery. However, the range of mobility was again significantly reduced during the last control examination after a minimum of 20 years. In all hips, the degenerative joint disease was present. Pelvic transiliac osteotomy, according to Dega, with VDRO, ensures very effective correction of the deficit in femoral head coverage by the acetabulum in the upper, lateral and posterior parts. However, it does not prevent the development of the early degenerative disease of the joint.

Femoral Head Deformity Associated With Hip Displacement in Nonambulatory Cerebral Palsy: Results at Skeletal Maturity

BACKGROUND

Maintaining femoral head shape (FHS) and acetabular sphericity are important goals in preventing long-term osteoarthritis in hips in children with cerebral palsy (CP). As acetabular morphology has been widely studied, our objective was to determine FHS in CP after triradiate cartilage (TRC) closure, a proxy for skeletal maturity, and the risk factors associated with residual deformity and osteoarthritis.

METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study, patients with CP [Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) IV to V], minimum 4 yearly hip radiographs after age 10 years, and at least 1 radiograph after age 16 years, were included. Primary outcome was FHS (Rutz), stratified as "less severe" (Rutz A to B) and "more severe" (Rutz C to D). Secondary outcomes included migration percentage (MP), age at TRC closure, previous reconstructive (femoral with/without pelvic osteotomies) surgery, previous intrathecal baclofen, Tönnis osteoarthritis grade, and GMFCS level. Statistical analyses included χ 2 analysis and multiple logistic regression.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty-three patients (326 hips) met the inclusion criteria, with TRC closure at age 14.0 (SD: 1.8) years. At final follow-up of 4.4 (SD: 2.4) years after TRC closure, 17% (55 hips), had a "more severe" FHS. From TRC closure to final follow-up, the frequencies of "less severe" hips decreased (-10%, P <0.001), while "more severe" increased (+115%, P <0.001). In multiple regression analysis, MP at TRC closure was the only significant risk factor associated with a "more severe" FHS at final follow-up ( P =0.03). Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis determined MP≥30.5% to be associated with a "more severe" FHS at final follow-up ( P <0.009). The FHS was not affected by reconstructive surgery, sex, GMFCS level, or intrathecal baclofen use. "Less severe" hips had lower Tönnis grades (0 to 1) compared with "more severe" hips (Tönnis grades 2 to 3) at final follow-up ( P <0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

FHS at skeletal maturity was not influenced by prior reconstructive surgery but was negatively affected when MP≥30.5% at the time of TRC closure. The extent of residual femoral head deformity correlated with the severity of osteoarthritis at final follow-up.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Do supports and barriers to routine clinical assessment for children with cerebral palsy change over time? A mixed methods study

PURPOSE

To understand how healthcare professionals' perceptions of supports and barriers to routine clinical assessment, for children aged 3-18 years with cerebral palsy, evolved in the presence of a knowledge translation intervention.

METHODS

A prospective longitudinal mixed-methods study was completed. The intervention comprised knowledge brokers, an e-evidence library, locally provided education and embedding routine clinical assessment in practice. Healthcare professionals from five disability services completed the Supports and Barriers Questionnaire and focus groups at baseline, 6, 12 and 24 months. Quantitative data were analysed descriptively and qualitative data using longitudinal framework analysis.

RESULTS

Questionnaire ratings indicated participants felt supported in implementing routine assessment over time. Subtle differences emerged from the longitudinal framework analysis. Participants shifted from 'adopting' to 'embedding' and 'maintaining' routine assessment. Integration of assessment was impacted by a new national disability funding model. Participants highlighted the need to maintain skills and for unambiguous, sustained communication between the organisation, clients, and stakeholders. If, how and why families engaged with routine assessment developed over time.

CONCLUSIONS

After an initial focus on pragmatic implementation issues, over time healthcare professionals began to reflect more on the complexities of children and families' engagement with assessment and the impact on the therapist-child-family relationship. Trial registration: This trial was not a controlled healthcare intervention and was registered retrospectively: ACTRN12616001616460. The protocol of the trial was published in 2015.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATIONHealthcare professionals can be supported over time to embed routine clinical assessment using multifaceted knowledge translation interventions.It takes time and ongoing support for healthcare professionals to embed, maintain and begin to adapt the routine clinical assessment to fit with policy, organisational context and the needs and wishes of children and families.Understanding and tailoring knowledge translation approaches to the policy context are essential.Even in the context of major policy shifts, it is possible to harness the commitment of organisations and professionals to improve their services in line with evidence-based approaches.

Hip Surveillance and Management of Hip Displacement in Children with Cerebral Palsy: Clinical and Ethical Dilemmas

Hip displacement is the second most common musculoskeletal deformity in children with cerebral palsy. Hip surveillance programs have been implemented in many countries to detect hip displacement early when it is usually asymptomatic. The aim of hip surveillance is to monitor hip development to offer management options to slow or reverse hip displacement, and to provide the best opportunity for good hip health at skeletal maturity. The long-term goal is to avoid the sequelae of late hip dislocation which may include pain, fixed deformity, loss of function and impaired quality of life. The focus of this review is on areas of disagreement, areas where evidence is lacking, ethical dilemmas and areas for future research. There is already broad agreement on how to conduct hip surveillance, using a combination of standardised physical examination measures and radiographic examination of the hips. The frequency is dictated by the risk of hip displacement according to the child's ambulatory status. Management of both early and late hip displacement is more controversial and the evidence base in key areas is relatively weak. In this review, we summarise the recent literature on hip surveillance and highlight the management dilemmas and controversies. Better understanding of the causes of hip displacement may lead to interventions which target the pathophysiology of hip displacement and the pathological anatomy of the hip in children with cerebral palsy. We have identified the need for more effective and integrated management from early childhood to skeletal maturity. Areas for future research are highlighted and a range of ethical and management dilemmas are discussed.

Hip Displacement After Triradiate Cartilage Closure in Nonambulatory Cerebral Palsy: Who Needs Continued Radiographic Surveillance?

BACKGROUND

Recommendations with regard to the need for continued hip surveillance after skeletal maturity are based on expert opinion rather than evidence. This study aimed to determine the prevalence of and risk factors associated with progressive hip displacement in cerebral palsy (CP) after triradiate cartilage (TRC) closure.

METHODS

Patients who had spastic nonambulatory CP (Gross Motor Function Classification System IV to V) and hypertonic (spastic or mixed-type) motor type and follow-up of at least 2 years after TRC closure were included. The primary outcome variable was the hip migration percentage (MP). The secondary outcome variables included patient age at the time of TRC closure, prior preventative or reconstructive surgery, a prior intrathecal baclofen pump, history of scoliosis, history of epilepsy, a prior gastrostomy tube, a previous tracheostomy, and gender. An unsuccessful hip outcome was defined as a hip with an MP of ≥40% and/or requiring a reconstructive surgical procedure after TRC closure.

RESULTS

In this study, 163 patients met the inclusion criteria, with a mean follow-up of 4.8 years (95% confidence interval [CI], 4.4 to 5.1 years) after TRC closure at a mean patient age of 14.0 years (95% CI, 13.7 to 14.3 years). Of these hips, 22.1% (36 of 163) had an unsuccessful hip outcome. In multivariate analysis, the first MP at TRC closure (hazard ratio [HR] per degree, 1.04; p < 0.001) and pelvic obliquity (HR per degree, 1.06; p = 0.003) were independent risk factors for an unsuccessful hip outcome, but gender was not found to be significant (HR for male gender, 1.7 [95% CI, 0.8 to 3.58; p = 0.16]; female gender was the reference). However, the mean survival time for progression to an unsuccessful hip outcome was longer for female patients at 9.2 years [95% CI, 8.1 to 10.2 years]) compared with 6.2 years (95% CI, 5.6 to 6.9 years) for male patients (p = 0.02). There was also a significant improvement in survivorship for prior reconstructive surgical procedures (p = 0.002). The survivorship in patients who underwent reconstructive surgery performed at a patient age of ≥6 years was significantly higher compared with those who underwent surgery performed at <6 years of age (p < 0.05). A first MP at TRC closure of ≥35% was associated with an unsuccessful hip outcome, as determined by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis (p < 0.001; area under the ROC curve of 0.891, sensitivity of 81%, and specificity of 94%).

CONCLUSIONS

The risk factors for the progression of hip displacement after TRC closure in patients with CP included a higher MP and increased pelvic obliquity; there was decreased survivorship for male patients and patients with no prior reconstructive surgery. Patients with these risk factors and/or an MP of ≥35% at TRC closure should have continued radiographic surveillance to detect late hip displacement.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic Level III . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Acquired Hip Dysplasia in Children with Congenital Zika Virus Infection in the First Four Years of Life

Acquired hip dysplasia has been described in children with cerebral palsy (CP); periodic surveillance is recommended in this population to prevent hip displacement and dislocation. Children with congenital zika syndrome (CZS) may present a spectrum of neurological impairments with changes in tonus, posture, and movement similar to children with CP. However, the relationship between CZS and hip dysplasia has not been characterized. In this prospective cohort study, we aimed to describe the occurrence of hip dysplasia in patients with CZS. Sixty-four children with CZS from 6 to 48 months of age were included and followed at a tertiary referral center in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, with periodic radiologic and clinical hip assessments. Twenty-six (41%) patients were diagnosed with hip dysplasia during follow-up; mean age at diagnosis was 23 months. According to the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS), 58 (91%) patients had severe impairment (GMFCS IV and V) at the first evaluation. All patients with progression to hip dysplasia had microcephaly and were classified as GMFCS IV or V. Pain and functional limitation were reported by 22 (84%) caregivers of children with hip dysplasia. All patients were referred to specialized orthopedic care; eight (31%) underwent surgical treatment during follow-up. Our findings highlight the importance of implementing a hip surveillance program and improving access to orthopedic treatment for children with CZS in order to decrease the chances of dysplasia-related complications and improve quality of life.

Unilateral versus bilateral reconstructive hip surgery in children with cerebral palsy: A survey of pediatric orthopedic surgery practice and decision-making

PURPOSE

This study explored whether surgeons favor unilateral or bilateral reconstructive hip surgery in children with cerebral palsy who have unilateral hip displacement.

METHODS

An invitation to participate in an anonymous, online survey was sent to 44 pediatric orthopedic surgeons. The case of an 8 year old at Gross Motor Function Classification System level IV with migration percentages of 76% and 22% was described. Surgeons selected their surgical treatment of choice and provided their rationale. Respondents were also asked to list and rank radiographic parameters used for decision-making and multidisciplinary team members involved in decision-making.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight orthopedic surgeons from nine countries with a mean 21.3 years (range, 5-40 years) of experience completed the survey. A "bilateral VDROs with a right pelvic osteotomy (PO) was selected by 68% (19/28) of respondents; risk of contralateral subluxation (9/19; 47%) and maintaining symmetry (7/19; 37%) were the most common rationales for bilateral surgery. The remaining 32% (9/28) chose a 'right VDRO with a right PO'" with most of these (8/9; 89%) stating the left hip was sufficiently covered. Of 31 radiographic parameters identified, migration percentage, acetabular angle/index, Shenton line, neck shaft angle, and presence of open/closed triradiate growth plates were the most common. Physical therapists (68%) and physiatrists (43%) were most likely to be involved in pre-operative surgical consultation.

CONCLUSION

There is a lack of agreement on management of the contralateral hip in children with unilateral hip displacement. Further studies comparing patient important outcomes following unilateral and bilateral surgery are required.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

V.

A Review of Radiology Reports From Hip Surveillance Radiographs for Children With Cerebral Palsy

BACKGROUND

Measurement of migration percentage (MP) is fundamental to successful hip surveillance for children with cerebral palsy (CP). In British Columbia, Canada, children enrolled in the province's hip surveillance program get radiographs at the province's tertiary care pediatric hospital or their local community hospital. This study aimed to review the radiology reporting of images completed as part of hip surveillance.

METHODS

Pelvis radiographs completed between September 2015 and December 2019 of 960 children enrolled in the province's hip surveillance program were included. MP values measured by the program coordinator and corresponding value measured by the facility's radiologist, when present, were retrieved. Agreement in MP between the program coordinator and the radiologist was measured using Bland-Altman plots and intraclass correlation coefficients. Radiology reports for images completed at community facilities that prompted a referral to a pediatric orthopaedic surgeon, when reviewed by the hip surveillance team, were further reviewed for qualitative comments.

RESULTS

In total, 1849 radiographs were reviewed with 69.3% (1282) completed at the pediatric hospital and 30.7% (567) at 64 different hospitals or clinics. MP was reported for 20.6% (264/1282) of radiographs completed at the pediatric hospital and 3.0% (17/567) of the radiographs completed at community hospitals. Bland-Altman plot analyses found a MP mean difference of 1.2% (95% confidence interval=0.6%-1.8%) between the program coordinator and all radiologist reports with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.88 (95% confidence interval=0.86-0.90). There were 47 radiographs completed at community hospitals that resulted in a referral to a pediatric orthopaedic surgeon after review by the hip surveillance team. Eleven of these reports stated normal or unremarkable findings.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiologic reporting of images completed for hip surveillance for children with CP was inadequate to allow for the detection of hip displacement. Reporting of MP was rare, particularly in community hospitals. If radiology reporting will be utilized for hip surveillance in children with CP, education of radiologists is required.

Hip Surveillance for Children with Cerebral Palsy: A Survey of Orthopaedic Surgeons in India

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to assess Indian orthopaedic surgeons' current practices and beliefs regarding hip surveillance for children with cerebral palsy (CP), to determine potential support for developing hip surveillance guidelines, and to identify knowledge gaps and key obstacles to guideline implementation in India.

METHODS

An anonymous, cross-sectional online survey was sent to approximately 350 Paediatric Orthopaedic Society of India (POSI) members who were queried on their practices and beliefs about hip surveillance for children with CP, as well as perceived challenges and requirements for the successful implementation of hip surveillance guidelines in the Indian context.

RESULTS

Out of 107 responses obtained from POSI members, almost all (96.2%) agreed that hip displacement requires standardized monitoring, using surveillance and surgery to prevent hip dislocation. Approximately half (51.5%) of respondents reported using existing hip surveillance guidelines, with most (41.2%) using the Australian guidelines. Almost all (97%) surgeons indicated that hip surveillance guidelines in India are needed, with 100% expressing interest in following guidelines specific to India. Respondents most frequently indicated late referrals to orthopaedics (81.2%), loss of patients to follow-up (78.2%), and lack of resources (43.6%) as challenges to successful hip surveillance in India. Perceived requirements for implementation included developing Indian-specific guidelines (83.2%) as well as educating surgeons (56.4%), physiotherapists/pediatricians (90.1%), and families (82.2%).

CONCLUSION

Orthopaedic surgeons practicing in India understand the importance of preventing hip dislocations in children with CP through hip surveillance and timely surgical intervention. The results demonstrated strong support for the development of hip surveillance guidelines designed specifically for the Indian healthcare system.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s43465-021-00432-3.

Hip surgery and radiology reporting for children with cerebral palsy prior to initiation of a hip surveillance program

PURPOSE

Hip displacement impacts quality of life for many children with cerebral palsy (CP). While early detection can help avoid dislocation and late-stage surgery, formalized surveillance programs are not ubiquitous. This study aimed to examine: 1) surgical practices around pediatric hip displacement for children with CP in a region without formalized hip surveillance; and 2) utility of MP compared to traditional radiology reporting for quantifying displacement.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review examined hip displacement surgeries performed on children with CP between 2007-2016. Surgeries were classified as preventative, reconstructive, or salvage. Pre- and post-operative migration percentage (MP) was calculated for available radiographs using a mobile application and compared using Wilcoxon Signed Ranks test. MPs were also compared with descriptions in the corresponding radiology reports using directed and conventional content analyses.

RESULTS

Data from 67 children (115 surgical hips) were included. Primary surgery types included preventative (63.5% hips), reconstructive (36.5%), or salvage (0%). For the 92 hips with both radiology reports and radiographs available, reports contained a range of descriptors that inconsistently reflected the retrospectively-calculated MPs.

CONCLUSION

Current radiology reporting practices do not appear to effectively describe hip displacement for children with CP. Therefore, standardized reporting of MP is recommended.

Physical Therapists Are Key to Hip Surveillance for Children with Cerebral Palsy: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Knowledge Translation to Support Program Implementation

AIMS

Physical and occupational therapists play a key role in the implementation of hip surveillance for children with cerebral palsy (CP) in British Columbia, Canada. We aimed to develop and assess a knowledge translation strategy to support the implementation of a provincial hip surveillance program.

METHODS

Pediatric therapists were invited to participate in an anonymous survey assessing hip surveillance knowledge and learning needs. Based on these results, educational materials were developed. Two years later, one year following the launch of the hip surveillance program, the survey was repeated to assess learning, knowledge use, and barriers to enrollment.

RESULTS

The initial survey was completed by 102 therapists; 74 therapists completed the second survey. Multifaceted educational strategies, including web-based learning, in-person education, email notifications, and print materials that targeted knowledge gaps were developed. Upon re-evaluation, knowledge increased on all questions. At follow-up, 45 therapists had enrolled a child, indicating knowledge use. Barriers to enrollment included lack of a CP diagnosis, parents or physicians not agreeing to enrollment, time requirements, and lack of space to complete the clinical exam.

CONCLUSIONS

Targeted knowledge translation strategies were successful in meeting the educational requirements of a large group of therapists in a vast geographic area.