Double cones in the avian retina form an oriented mosaic which might facilitate magnetoreception and/or polarized light sensing

Full-Length Cryptochrome 1 in the Outer Segments of the Retinal Blue Cone Photoreceptors in Humans and Great Apes Suggests a Role Beyond Transcriptional Repression

Mammalian cryptochrome 1 (CRY1) is a central player in the circadian transcription-translation feedback loop, crucial for maintaining a roughly 24-h rhythm. CRY1 was suggested to also function as a blue-light photoreceptor in humans and has been found to be expressed at the mRNA level in various cell types of the inner retina. However, attempts to detect CRY1 at the protein level in the human retina have remained unsuccessful so far. Using various C-terminal specific antibodies recognizing full-length CRY1 protein, we consistently detected selective labeling in the outer segments of short wavelength-sensitive (SWS1, "blue") cone photoreceptor cells across human, bonobo, and gorilla retinae. No other retinal cell types were stained, which is in contrast to what would be expected of a ubiquitous clock protein. Subcellular fractionation experiments in transfected HEK cells using a C-terminal specific antibody located full-length CRY1 in the cytosol and membrane fractions. Our findings indicate that human CRY1 has several different functions including at least one nonclock function. Our results also raise the likely possibility that several different versions of CRY1 exist in humans. We suggest that truncation of the C-terminal tail, maybe to different degrees, may affect the localization and function of human CRY1.

Comparative transcriptomic insights into the evolution of vertebrate photoreceptor types

To explore the molecular similarities and potential evolutionary origins of vertebrate photoreceptor types, we analyzed single-cell and -nucleus transcriptomic atlases from six vertebrate species: zebrafish, chicken, lizard, opossum, ground squirrel, and human. Comparative analyses identified conserved transcriptional signatures for the five ancestral photoreceptor types: red, blue, green, and UV cones, as well as rods. We further identified and validated molecular markers of the principal and accessory members of the tetrapod double cone. Comparative transcriptomics suggests that the principal member originated from ancestral red cones, although the origin of the accessory member is less clear. The gene expression variation among cone types mirrors their spectral order (red → green → blue → UV). We find that rods are highly dissimilar to all cone types, suggesting that rods may have diverged prior to the spectral diversification of cones.

Avian photoreceptor homologies and the origin of double cones

Birds possess the most complex photoreceptor system among vertebrates, with one rod and six cone types, including four single cones (violet, blue, green, and red) and two constituent cells of the double cone (DC-P and DC-A). The evolutionary relationships of avian photoreceptors to those of other vertebrate taxa have not been systematically explored. Here, we perform single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) on retinas of newly hatched chickens to trace cell-type homologies across species. Analysis of differentially expressed transcription factors (TFs) suggests that avian rods and single cone types correspond to cognate cell types in fish and placental mammals, whereas double cones have a distinct origin. We propose that DC-P arose from an ancestral red cone, as revealed by expression of the red cone cell fate determinants thyroid hormone receptor β (THRB) and SAMD7, whereas DC-A may have arisen from an ancestral blue cone, as suggested by expression of the blue cone TFs FOXQ2 and SKOR1. These expression signatures are shared by DC-P and DC-A of the green anole lizard (Anolis carolinensis), suggesting conservation throughout Sauropsida. Consistent with our hypothesis, CRISPR-mediated knockout of THRB causes loss of red cones and DC-P, but not DC-A, and the appearance of supernumerary rods and green cones, suggestive of direct transfating. Furthermore, cis-regulatory analysis suggests that separate enhancers control red cone opsin expression in DC-P and DC-A, consistent with distinct evolutionary origins. Taken together, our studies trace the evolutionary relationships of avian photoreceptors and suggest separate origins of DC-P and DC-A from ancestral red and blue cones, respectively.

European Robin Cryptochrome-4a Associates with Lipid Bilayers in an Ordered Manner, Fulfilling a Molecular-Level Condition for Magnetoreception

Since the middle of the 20th century, long-distance avian migration has been known to rely partly on geomagnetic field. However, the underlying sensory mechanism is still not fully understood. Cryptochrome-4a (ErCry4a), found in European robin (Erithacus rubecula), a night-migratory songbird, has been suggested to be a magnetic sensory molecule. It is sensitive to external magnetic fields via the so-called radical-pair mechanism. ErCry4a is primarily located in the outer segments of the double-cone photoreceptor cells in the eye, which contain stacked and highly ordered membranes that could facilitate the anisotropic attachment of ErCry4a needed for magnetic compass sensing. Here, we investigate possible interactions of ErCry4a with a model membrane that mimics the lipid composition of outer segments of vertebrate photoreceptor cells using experimental and computational approaches. Experimental results show that the attachment of ErCry4a to the membrane could be controlled by the physical state of lipid molecules (average area per lipid) in the outer leaflet of the lipid bilayer. Furthermore, polarization modulation infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy allowed us to determine the conformation, motional freedom, and average orientation of the α-helices in ErCry4a in a membrane-associated state. Atomistic molecular dynamics studies supported the experimental results. A ∼ 1000 kcal mol-1 decrease in the interaction energy as a result of ErCry4a membrane binding was determined compared to cases where no protein binding to the membrane occurred. At the molecular level, the binding seems to involve negatively charged carboxylate groups of the phosphoserine lipids and the C-terminal residues of ErCry4a. Our study reveals a potential direct interaction of ErCry4a with the lipid membrane and discusses how this binding could be an essential step for ErCry4a to propagate a magnetic signal further and thus fulfill a role as a magnetoreceptor.

AAV-mediated transduction of songbird retina

Introduction

Genetic manipulation of murine retinal tissue through ocular administration of adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) has become a standard technique to investigate a multitude of mechanisms underlying retinal physiology. Resultantly, developments of recombinant viral vectors with improved transduction efficiency and further methodological improvements have mostly focused on murine tissue, whereas AAVs successfully targeting avian retinae have remained scarce.

Methodology

Using a custom-designed injection setup, we identified a viral serotype with the capability to successfully induce widespread transduction of the bird retina.

Results

Intravitreal administration of an AAV type 2/9 encoding for enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) in night-migratory European robins (Erithacus rubecula) resulted in transduction coverages of up to 60% within retinal tissue. Subsequent immunohistochemical analyses revealed that the AAV2/9-EGFP serotype almost exclusively targeted photoreceptors: rods, various single cones (UV, blue, green, and red cones), and both (accessory and principal) members of double cones.

Discussion

The consistently high and photoreceptor-specific transduction efficiency makes the AAV2/9 serotype a powerful tool for carrying out genetic manipulations in avian retinal photoreceptors, thus opening a wealth of opportunities to investigate physiological aspects underlying retinal processing in birds, such as physiological recordings and/or post-transductional behavioural readouts for future vision-related research.

Morphology and connectivity of retinal horizontal cells in two avian species

In the outer vertebrate retina, the visual signal is separated into intensity and wavelength information. In birds, seven types of photoreceptors (one rod, four single cones, and two members of the double cone) mediate signals to >20 types of second-order neurons, the bipolar cells and horizontal cells. Horizontal cells contribute to color and contrast processing by providing feedback signals to photoreceptors and feedforward signals to bipolar cells. In fish, reptiles, and amphibians they either encode intensity or show color-opponent responses. Yet, for the bird retina, the number of horizontal cell types is not fully resolved and even more importantly, the synapses between photoreceptors and horizontal cells have never been quantified for any bird species. With a combination of light microscopy and serial EM reconstructions, we found four different types of horizontal cells in two distantly related species, the domestic chicken and the European robin. In agreement with some earlier studies, we confirmed two highly abundant cell types (H1, H2) and two rare cell types (H3, H4), of which H1 is an axon-bearing cell, whereas H2-H4 are axonless. H1 cells made chemical synapses with one type of bipolar cell and an interplexiform amacrine cell at their soma. Dendritic contacts of H1-H4 cells to photoreceptors were type-specific and similar to the turtle retina, which confirms the high degree of evolutionary conservation in the vertebrate outer retina. Our data further suggests that H1 and potentially H2 cells may encode intensity, whereas H3 and H4 may represent color opponent horizontal cells which may contribute to the birds' superb color and/or high acuity vision.

Comparison of retinol binding protein 1 with cone specific G-protein as putative effector molecules in cryptochrome signalling

Vision and magnetoreception in navigating songbirds are strongly connected as recent findings link a light dependent radical-pair mechanism in cryptochrome proteins to signalling pathways in cone photoreceptor cells. A previous yeast-two-hybrid screening approach identified six putative candidate proteins showing binding to cryptochrome type 4a. So far, only the interaction of the cone specific G-protein transducin α-subunit was investigated in more detail. In the present study, we compare the binding features of the G-protein α-subunit with those of another candidate from the yeast-two-hybrid screen, cellular retinol binding protein. Purified recombinant European robin retinol binding protein bound retinol with high affinity, displaying an EC50 of less than 5 nM, thereby demonstrating its functional state. We applied surface plasmon resonance and a Förster resonance transfer analysis to test for interactions between retinol binding protein and cryptochrome 4a. In the absence of retinol, we observed no robust binding events, which contrasts the strong interaction we observed between cryptochrome 4a and the G-protein α-subunit. We conclude that retinol binding protein is unlikely to be involved in the primary magnetosensory signalling cascade.

Comparative transcriptomic insights into the evolutionary origin of the tetrapod double cone

The tetrapod double cone is a pair of tightly associated cones called the "principal" and the "accessory" member. It is found in amphibians, reptiles, and birds, as well as monotreme and marsupial mammals but is absent in fish and eutherian mammals. To explore the potential evolutionary origins of the double cone, we analyzed single-cell and -nucleus transcriptomic atlases of photoreceptors from six vertebrate species: zebrafish, chicken, lizard, opossum, ground squirrel, and human. Computational analyses separated the principal and accessory members in chicken and lizard, identifying molecular signatures distinguishing either member from single cones and rods in the same species. Comparative transcriptomic analyses suggest that both the principal and accessory originated from ancestral red cones. Furthermore, the gene expression variation among cone subtypes mirrors their spectral order (red → green → blue → UV), suggesting a constraint in their order of emergence during evolution. Finally, we find that rods are equally dissimilar to all cone types, suggesting that they emerged before the spectral diversification of cones.

Migratory birds can extract positional information from magnetic inclination and magnetic declination alone

Migratory birds are able to navigate over great distances with remarkable accuracy. The mechanism they use to achieve this feat is thought to involve two distinct steps: locating their position (the 'map') and heading towards the direction determined (the 'compass'). For decades, this map-and-compass concept has shaped our perception of navigation in animals, although the nature of the map remains debated. However, some recent studies suggest the involvement of the Earth's magnetic field in the map step. Here, we tested whether migratory songbirds, Eurasian reed warblers (Acrocephalus scirpaceus), can determine their position based on two magnetic field components that are also associated with direction finding, i.e. magnetic inclination and magnetic declination. During a virtual magnetic displacement experiment, the birds were exposed to altered magnetic inclination and magnetic declination values that would indicate a displacement from their natural migratory corridor, but the total intensity of the field remained unchanged, creating a spatial mismatch between these components. The response was a change in the birds' migratory direction consistent with a compensatory re-orientation. This suggests that birds can extract positional as well as directional information from these cues, even when they are in conflict with another component of the magnetic field. It remains to be seen whether birds use the total intensity of Earth's magnetic field for navigation.

Species-specific circuitry of double cone photoreceptors in two avian retinas

In most avian retinas, double cones (consisting of a principal and accessory member) outnumber other photoreceptor types and have been associated with various functions, such as encoding luminance, sensing polarized light, and magnetoreception. However, their down-stream circuitry is poorly understood, particularly across bird species. Analysing species differences is important to understand changes in circuitry driven by ecological adaptations. We compare the ultrastructure of double cones and their postsynaptic bipolar cells between a night-migratory European robin and non-migratory chicken. We discover four previously unidentified bipolar cell types in the European robin retina, including midget-like bipolar cells mainly connected to one principal member. A downstream ganglion cell reveals a complete midget-like circuit similar to a circuit in the peripheral primate retina. Additionally, we identify a selective circuit transmitting information from a specific subset of accessory members. Our data highlight species-specific differences in double cone to bipolar cell connectivity, potentially reflecting ecological adaptations.

Adaptive evolution and loss of a putative magnetoreceptor in passerines

Migratory birds possess remarkable accuracy in orientation and navigation, which involves various compass systems including the magnetic compass. Identifying the primary magnetosensor remains a fundamental open question. Cryptochromes (Cry) have been shown to be magnetically sensitive, and Cry4a from a migratory songbird seems to show enhanced magnetic sensitivity in vitro compared to Cry4a from resident species. We investigate Cry and their potential involvement in magnetoreception in a phylogenetic framework, integrating molecular evolutionary analyses with protein dynamics modelling. Our analysis is based on 363 bird genomes and identifies different selection regimes in passerines. We show that Cry4a is characterized by strong positive selection and high variability, typical characteristics of sensor proteins. We identify key sites that are likely to have facilitated the evolution of an optimized sensory protein for night-time orientation in songbirds. Additionally, we show that Cry4 was lost in hummingbirds, parrots and Tyranni (Suboscines), and thus identified a gene deletion, which might facilitate testing the function of Cry4a in birds. In contrast, the other avian Cry (Cry1 and Cry2) were highly conserved across all species, indicating basal, non-sensory functions. Our results support a specialization or functional differentiation of Cry4 in songbirds which could be magnetosensation.

Eagle eyed or bird brained?

The importance of the visual system to birds for behaviours from feeding, mate choice, flying, navigation and determination of seasons, together with the presence of photoreceptors in the retina, the pineal and the brain, render the avian visual system a particularly fruitful model for understanding of eye-brain interactions. In this review we will particularly focus on the pigeon, since here we have a brain stereotactically mapped and a genome fully sequenced, together with a particular bird, the homing pigeon, with remarkable ability to navigate over hundreds of miles and return to exactly the same roosting site with exceptional precision. We might denigrate the avian species by the term bird brained, but here are animals with phenomenal abilities to use their exceptional vision, their eagle eyedness, to best advantage.

Dimerization of European Robin Cryptochrome 4a

Homo-dimer formation is important for the function of many proteins. Although dimeric forms of cryptochromes (Cry) have been found by crystallography and were recently observed in vitro for European robin Cry4a, little is known about the dimerization of avian Crys and the role it could play in the mechanism of magnetic sensing in migratory birds. Here, we present a combined experimental and computational investigation of the dimerization of robin Cry4a resulting from covalent and non-covalent interactions. Experimental studies using native mass spectrometry, mass spectrometric analysis of disulfide bonds, chemical cross-linking, and photometric measurements show that disulfide-linked dimers are routinely formed, that their formation is promoted by exposure to blue light, and that the most likely cysteines are C317 and C412. Computational modeling and molecular dynamics simulations were used to generate and assess a number of possible dimer structures. The relevance of these findings to the proposed role of Cry4a in avian magnetoreception is discussed.

Immunohistochemical characterization of bipolar cells in four distantly related avian species

Visual (and probably also magnetic) signal processing starts at the first synapse, at which photoreceptors contact different types of bipolar cells, thereby feeding information into different processing channels. In the chicken retina, 15 and 22 different bipolar cell types have been identified based on serial electron microscopy and single-cell transcriptomics, respectively. However, immunohistochemical markers for avian bipolar cells were only anecdotally described so far. Here, we systematically tested 12 antibodies for their ability to label individual bipolar cells in the bird retina and compared the eight most suitable antibodies across distantly related species, namely domestic chicken, domestic pigeon, common buzzard, and European robin, and across retinal regions. While two markers (GNB3 and EGFR) labeled specifically ON bipolar cells, most markers labeled in addition to bipolar cells also other cell types in the avian retina. Staining pattern of four markers (CD15, PKCα, PKCβ, secretagogin) was species-specific. Two markers (calbindin and secretagogin) showed a different expression pattern in central and peripheral retina. For the chicken and European robin, we found slightly more ON bipolar cell somata in the inner nuclear layer than OFF bipolar cell somata. In contrast, OFF bipolar cells made more ribbon synapses than ON bipolar cells in the inner plexiform layer of these species. Finally, we also analyzed the photoreceptor connectivity of selected bipolar cell types in the European robin retina. In summary, we provide a catalog of bipolar cell markers for different bird species, which will greatly facilitate analyzing the retinal circuitry of birds on a larger scale.

Isotope Substitution Effects on the Magnetic Compass Properties of Cryptochrome-Based Radical Pairs: A Computational Study

The biophysical mechanism of the magnetic compass sense of migratory songbirds is thought to rely on the photochemical reactions of flavin-containing radical pairs in cryptochrome proteins located in the birds' eyes. A consequence of this hypothesis is that the effect of the Earth's magnetic field on the quantum yields of reaction products should be sensitive to isotopic substitutions that modify the hyperfine interactions in the radicals. In this report, we use spin dynamics simulations to explore the effects of 1H → 2H, 12C → 13C, and 14N → 15N isotopic substitutions on the functioning of cryptochrome 4a as a magnetic direction sensor. Two main conclusions emerge. (1) Uniform deuteration of the flavin chromophore appears to be the best way to boost the anisotropy of the magnetic field effect and to change its symmetry. (2) 13C substitution of three of the 12 flavin carbons, in particular C4, C4a, and C8α, seems to be the best recipe for attenuating the anisotropy. These predictions should give insight into the factors that control the magnetic sensitivity once spectroscopic techniques are available for measuring magnetic field effects on oriented protein samples.

Kinetics of cone specific G-protein signaling in avian photoreceptor cells

Cone photoreceptor cells of night-migratory songbirds seem to process the primary steps of two different senses, vision and magnetoreception. The molecular basis of phototransduction is a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor pathway starting with the photoexcitation of rhodopsin or cone opsin thereby activating a heterotrimeric G protein named transducin. This interaction is well understood in vertebrate rod cells, but parameter describing protein-protein interactions of cone specific proteins are rare and not available for migratory birds. European robin is a model organism for studying the orientation of birds in the earth magnetic field. Recent findings showed a link between the putative magnetoreceptor cryptochrome 4a and the cone specific G-protein of European robin. In the present work, we investigated the interaction of European robin cone specific G protein and cytoplasmic regions of long wavelength opsin. We identified the second loop in opsin connecting transmembrane regions three and four as a critical binding interface. Surface plasmon resonance studies using a synthetic peptide representing the second cytoplasmic loop and purified G protein α-subunit showed a high affinity interaction with a K _D value of 21 nM. Truncation of the G protein α-subunit at the C-terminus by six amino acids slightly decreased the affinity. Our results suggest that binding of the G protein to cryptochrome can compete with the interaction of G protein and non-photoexcited long wavelength opsin. Thus, the parallel presence of two different sensory pathways in bird cone photoreceptors is reasonable under dark-adapted conditions or during illumination with short wavelengths.

Magnetoreceptory Function of European Robin Retina: Electrophysiological and Morphological Non-Homogeneity

The avian magnetic compass allows orientation during migration and is shown to function properly under short-wavelength but not long-wavelength visible light. Therefore, the magnetoreceptive system is assumed to be light- and wavelength-dependent and localized in the retina of the eye. Putative candidates for the role of primary magnetosensory molecules are the cryptochromes that are known to be expressed in the avian retina and must be able to interact with phototransduction proteins. Previously, we reported that in migratory birds change in magnetic field direction induces significant effects on electroretinogram amplitude in response to blue flashes, and such an effect was observed only in the nasal quadrant of the retina. Here, we report new electroretinographic, microscopic and microspectrophotometric data on European robins, confirming the magnetosensitivity of the retinal nasal quadrant after applying the background illumination. We hypothesized that magnetoreceptive distinction of this region may be related to its morphology and analyzed the retinal distribution and optical properties of oil droplets, the filtering structures within cones. We found that the nasal quadrant contains double cones with the most intensely colorized oil droplets compared to the rest of the retina, which may be related to its magnetosensory function.