Characterization of Post-Transcriptionally Suppressed Transgene Expression That Confers Resistance to Tobacco Etch Virus Infection in Tobacco

Cross-protection: a century of mystery

Cross-protection is a phenomenon in which infection of a plant with a mild virus or viroid strain protects it from disease resulting from a subsequent encounter with a severe strain of the same virus or viroid. In this chapter, we review the history of cross-protection with regard to the development of ideas concerning its likely mechanisms, including RNA silencing and exclusion, and its influence on the early development of genetically engineered virus resistance. We also examine examples of the practical use of cross-protection in averting crop losses due to viruses, as well as the use of satellite RNAs to ameliorate the impact of virus-induced diseases. We also discuss the potential of cross-protection to contribute in future to the maintenance of crop health in the face of emerging virus diseases and related threats to agricultural production.

Passing the message on: inheritance of epigenetic traits

Epigenetic modifiers play an important role in genome organization, stability and the control of gene expression. Three research groups that are exploring the transfer of epigenetic information between generations have recently published papers. Mary Alleman et al. have shown that RNA-directed chromatin changes mediate paramutation in maize, and Minoo Rassoulzadegan et al. have demonstrated that RNA also plays a role in paramutation in mice. A new aspect of epigenetic regulation has been revealed by Jean Molinier et al. - they have demonstrated that the memory of exposure to stress is transferred through several generations.

Characterization of resistance in transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana encoding N-terminal deletion and assembly mutants of the tobacco etch potyvirus coat protein

The resistance of transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants encoding wild type, truncated and point mutants of the tobacco etch virus (TEV) coat protein (CP) was analyzed. After R1 plants from 45 transgenic lines were challenged with TEV, six percent of the lines exhibited high resistance, 38% exhibited low resistance, and the remainder were susceptible. The phenomenon of recovery and delay in symptom development was observed in 65% and 56% of the resistant and susceptible lines, respectively. Plants containing genes that encode sequences of two assembly-deficient mutants of TEV-CPDelta1-63 exhibited resistance to infection, suggesting that self-assembly of the CP is not responsible for resistance. Highly resistant lines accumulated low levels of transgene mRNA and non-detectable amounts of protein, and tissues accumulated lower amounts of transgene mRNA following recovery than before infection. In addition, co-suppression of replication of a recombinant tobamovirus containing the TEV-CPDelta1-63 sequence was observed in several lines, suggesting homology-dependent degradation of RNA, most likely through induction of post-transcriptional gene silencing. Plants not exhibiting high resistance via gene silencing exhibited moderate levels of resistance that is attributed to and/or affected by the CP molecule.

Cosuppression of eukaryotic release factor 1-1 in Arabidopsis affects cell elongation and radial cell division

The role of the eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1) in translation termination has previously been established in yeast; however, only limited characterization has been performed on any plant homologs. Here, we demonstrate that cosuppression of eRF1-1 in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) has a profound effect on plant morphology, resulting in what we term the broomhead phenotype. These plants primarily exhibit a reduction in internode elongation causing the formation of a broomhead-like cluster of malformed siliques at the top of the inflorescence stem. Histological analysis of broomhead stems revealed that cells are reduced in height and display ectopic lignification of the phloem cap cells, some phloem sieve cells, and regions of the fascicular cambium, as well as enhanced lignification of the interfascicular fibers. We also show that cell division in the fascicular cambial regions is altered, with the majority of vascular bundles containing cambial cells that are disorganized and possess enlarged nuclei. This is the first attempt at functional characterization of a release factor in vivo in plants and demonstrates the importance of eRF1-1 function in Arabidopsis.

Matrix attachment regions increase the efficiency and stability of RNA-mediated resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus in transgenic tobacco

Matrix attachment regions (MARs) are DNA elements that can increase and stabilize transgene expression. We investigated the effect of the RB7 MAR on transgenic virus resistance. Constructs for resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) with and without flanking RB7 MARs were used to transform tobacco and produce homozygous lines. The population with the MAR construct had a significantly higher percentage of TSWV resistant plants in the R1 generation than the nonMAR population. Each resistant line was advanced to the R4 generation, and significantly fewer MAR lines lost resistance over generations compared to the nonMAR population. Lines with TSWV resistance in growth chamber tests were also resistant in field trials. Two lines that were resistant in the R1 generation and susceptible in the R4 were examined in more detail in order to determine if transcriptional silencing of the transgene was occurring in the later generation. Short interfering 21-25 nt RNAs from the transgene that are characteristic of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) were present in the resistant R1 plants, but not the susceptible R4 plants, indicating that virus resistance was associated with PTGS of the transgene. Loss of resistance was accompanied by an increase in promoter methylation in both lines. In line M41, the transgene was fully silenced at the transcriptional level in the R4 as shown by nuclear run-on assays. In line NM13, transgene transcription and RNA accumulation was still present in the R4 generation, but the level of transcription was not sufficient to trigger PTGS, suggesting that this line may have partial transcriptional silencing. These results are consistent with the concept that MARs may prevent transcriptional silencing.

Plant pathology and RNAi: a brief history

This article describes the discovery of RNA-activated sequence-specific RNA degradation, a phenomenon now referred to as RNA silencing or RNA interference (RNAi). From 1992 to 1996, a series of articles were published on virus resistant transgenic plants expressing either translatable or nontranslatable versions of the coat protein gene of Tobacco etch virus (TEV). Certain transgenic plant lines were resistant to TEV but not to closely related viruses. In these plants a surprising correlation was observed: Transgenic plant lines with the highest degree of TEV resistance had actively transcribed transgenes but low steady-state levels of transgene RNA. Molecular analysis of these transgenic plants demonstrated the existence of a cellular-based, sequence-specific, posttranscriptional RNA-degradation system that was programmed by the transgene-encoded RNA sequence. This RNA-degradation activity specifically targeted both the transgene RNA and TEV (viral) RNA for degradation and was the first description of RNA-mediated gene silencing.

Silencing of the Aleurone-specific Ltp2-gus Gene in Transgenic Rice is Reversed by Transgene Rearrangements and Loss of Aberrant Transcripts

An Ltp2 promoter was isolated from barley as an aleurone-specific promoter, and its tissue specificity was maintained in transgenic rice. Expression of the Ltp2-gus gene in rice could be detected by X-gluc staining of the seeds. Previously, we reported the isolation of silenced plants in the R2 generation and the involvement of antisense gus transcripts in aleurone-specific Ltp2-gus gene silencing in transgenic rice, the L3.3 line. In the current study, we analyzed the L0.1 line, a sibling of the L3.3 line, and the partially revertant line from the L0.1 line accompanied by a transgene structural change. Strong silencing of the Ltp2-gus gene was detected over five generations in the L0.1 line. DNA and RNA analysis revealed that there were incomplete transgenes and that several aberrant RNAs that carried an antisense gus region were expressed in the L0.1 line. Determination of the transgene structure in the L0.1 line revealed that the partial antisense gus gene and the partial Ltp2 promoter region fused to the Ltp2 promoter were lacking in the revertants. RNA analysis demonstrated that the antisense gus and the promoter transcripts were produced and found in the poly(A)- fraction. Results of these analyses suggested that the observed aberrant transcripts, including antisense and promoter transcripts, were associated with Ltp2-gus silencing in the L0.1 line.

Silencing of ribosomal protein L3 genes in N. tabacum reveals coordinate expression and significant alterations in plant growth, development and ribosome biogenesis

The expression of ribosomal protein genes is coordinately regulated in bacteria, yeast, and vertebrates, so that equimolar amounts of ribosomal proteins accumulate for assembly into ribosomes. To understand how expression of ribosomal protein genes is regulated in plants, we altered expression of the large subunit ribosomal protein L3 (RPL3) genes in Nicotiana tabacum using post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). L3 is encoded by two genes, RPL3A and RPL3B, with 80.2% amino acid sequence identity in tobacco. Two types of 'hairpin' RNA (hpRNA) vectors carrying the RPL3A or RPL3B sequences in both sense and antisense orientation were generated in order to alter the expression level of both RPL3 genes. Tobacco plants transformed with a vector containing a 5'-terminal fragment of RPL3A gene displayed decreased RPL3A mRNA levels and a marked increase in the abundance of RPL3B mRNA. These results indicated that expression of the RPL3 genes is coordinately regulated in tobacco. The transgenic plants that contained higher levels of RPL3B mRNA exhibited leaf overgrowth and mottling. Epidermal cells of these plants were increased in number and decreased in size. The precursor rRNA (pre-rRNA) and the mature rRNAs accumulated in these plants, suggesting that ribosome biogenesis is upregulated. Tobacco plants transformed with an hpRNA vector harboring the full-length RPL3B cDNA exhibited efficient silencing of both RPL3A and RPL3B genes, reduced L3 levels, and an abnormal phenotype characterized by a delay in development, stunting, and inhibition of lateral root growth. L3 deficiency led to a reduction in cell number and an increase in cell size, suggesting that L3 positively regulates cell division. Decreasing RPL3 gene expression resulted in a decrease in accumulation of the pre-rRNA, establishing a prominent role for L3 in ribosome biogenesis in plants.

Translation start sequences affect the efficiency of silencing of Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-DNA oncogenes

Agrobacterium tumefaciens oncogenes cause transformed plant cells to overproduce auxin and cytokinin. Two oncogenes encode enzymes that convert tryptophan to indole-3-acetic acid (auxin): iaaM (tryptophan mono-oxygenase) and iaaH (indole-3-acetamide hydrolase). A third oncogene (ipt) encodes AMP isopentenyl transferase, which produces cytokinin (isopentenyl-AMP). Inactivation of ipt and iaaM (or iaaH) abolishes tumorigenesis. Because adequate means do not exist to control crown gall, we created resistant plants by introducing transgenes designed to elicit posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) of iaaM and ipt. Transgenes that elicit silencing trigger sequence-specific destruction of the inducing RNA and messenger RNAs with related sequences. Although PTGS has proven effective against a variety of target genes, we found that a much higher percentage of transgenic lines silenced iaaM than ipt, suggesting that transgene sequences influenced the effectiveness of PTGS. Sequences required for oncogene silencing included a translation start site. A transgene encoding a translatable sense-strand RNA from the 5' end of iaaM silenced the iaaM oncogene, but deletion of the translation start site abolished the ability of the transgene to silence iaaM. Silencing A. tumefaciens T-DNA oncogenes is a new and effective method to produce plants resistant to crown gall disease.

Sequence-, tissue-, and delivery-specific targeting of RNA during post-transcriptional gene silencing

Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants expressing an untranslatable version of the coat protein (CP) gene from the Tamarillo mosaic virus (TaMV) were either resistant to TaMV infection or recovered from infection. These phenotypes were the result of a post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) mechanism that targeted TaMV-CP sequences for degradation. The TaMV-CP sequences were degraded when present in the wild-type TaMV potyvirus, in transgene mRNA, or in chimeric viral vectors based on White clover mosaic virus. The more efficiently targeted region was mapped to a 134-nt segment. Differences were observed in the efficiency of targeting during cell-to-cell and long-distance movement of the chimeric viruses. However, the TaMV-CP sequences do not appear to be targeted for degradation when delivered by biolistics.

Resistance to wheat streak mosaic virus in transgenic wheat engineered with the viral coat protein gene

Wheat (Triticum aestivum) plants were stably transformed with the coat protein (CP) gene of wheat streak mosaic virus (WSMV) by the biolistic method. Eleven independently transformed plant lines were obtained and five were analyzed for gene expression and resistance to WSMV. One line showed high resistance to inoculations of two WSMV strains. This line had milder symptoms and lower virus titer than control plants after inoculation. After infection, new growth did not show symptoms. The observed resistance was similar to the 'recovery' type resistance described previously using WSMV NIb transgene and in other systems. This line looked morphologically normal but had an unusually high transgene copy number (approximately 90 copies per 2C homozygous genome). Northern hybridization analysis indicated a high level of degraded CP mRNA expression. However, no coat protein expression was detected.

Relationship between small antisense RNAs and aberrant RNAs associated with sense transgene mediated gene silencing in tomato

We investigated the occurrence and properties of small sense and antisense RNAs and aberrant transcripts in transgenic tomato plants exhibiting post-transcriptional silencing of the endogenous polygalacturonase (PG) sense gene and a truncated homologous transgene. Small antisense RNAs, about 23 nucleotides in size, were present in the leaves and immature green fruit where the transgene was transcribed in the absence of transcripts from the fruit ripening-specific endogenous PG gene. This suggests that the small antisense RNAs were produced from the transgene, which was supported by their failure to hybridise with the 3' half of the endogenous PG gene, the region that was excluded from the transgene. The features of two aberrant RNAs, corresponding to the 5' and 3' halves of the endogenous gene, strongly suggest that they arise by endonucleolytic cleavage of endogenous PG mRNA. The region where cleavage occurs is associated with the preferential production of small RNAs from the 3' end of the transgene. These results suggest a model where small antisense RNAs generated from the 3' end of the transgene anneal to the endogenous mRNA, resulting in cleavage at or near the annealing regions.

Homology-dependent gene silencing mechanisms in fungi

Homology-dependent gene silencing (HDGS) is a ubiquitous phenomenon among fungi, plants, and animals. Gene silencing can be triggered and can affect artificially introduced nucleic acid molecules, both DNA and RNA, and/or can act on endogenous duplicated sequences. Although the various HDGS phenomena may be related each other, probably deriving from an ancestral defense mechanism, relevant differences do exist between different HDGS mechanisms. Especially in fungi, a variety of HDGS phenomena have been uncovered during the past 10 years: Gene inactivation of duplicated sequences can be achieved either through DNA-methylation and block of transcription or through sequence-specific degradation of mRNA. Moreover, duplicated sequences can also be specifically mutagenized. Studying HDGS in fungi gives us the opportunity to study such complex mechanisms in relatively simple organisms in which both genetic and biochemical approaches can be easily used.

A cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) RNA 1 transgene mediates suppression of the homologous viral RNA 1 constitutively and prevents CMV entry into the phloem

Resistance to Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) in tobacco lines transformed with CMV RNA 1 is characterized by reduced virus accumulation in the inoculated leaf, with specific suppression of accumulation of the homologous viral RNA 1, and by the absence of systemic infection. We show that the suppression of viral RNA 1 occurs in protoplasts from resistant transgenic plants and therefore is not due to a host response activated by the cell-to-cell spread of virus. In contrast, suppression of Tobacco rattle virus vectors carrying CMV RNA 1 sequences did not occur in protoplasts from resistant plants. Furthermore, steady-state levels of transgene mRNA 1 were higher in resistant than in susceptible lines. Thus, the data indicate that sequence homology is not sufficient to induce suppression. Grafting experiments using transgenic resistant or susceptible rootstocks and scions demonstrated that the resistance mechanism exhibited an additional barrier to phloem entry, preventing CMV from moving a long distance in resistant plants. On the other hand, virus from susceptible rootstocks could systemically infect grafted resistant scions via the phloem. Analysis of viral RNA accumulation in the infected scions showed that the mechanism that suppresses the accumulation of viral RNA 1 at the single-cell level was overcome. The data indicate that this transgene-mediated systemic resistance probably is not based on a posttranscriptional gene-silencing mechanism.

Gene silencing as an adaptive defence against viruses

Gene silencing was perceived initially as an unpredictable and inconvenient side effect of introducing transgenes into plants. It now seems that it is the consequence of accidentally triggering the plant's adaptive defence mechanism against viruses and transposable elements. This recently discovered mechanism, although mechanistically different, has a number of parallels with the immune system of mammals.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plum pox virus resistant transgenic European plum containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein gene

Transgenic plums containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein (PPV-CP) gene were inoculated with PPV. Infection was monitored by evaluating symptoms, ELISA, and IC-RT-PCR. Transgenic clone C5 was highly resistant to PPV during four years of testing and displayed characteristics typical of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS), including a high level of transgene transcription in the nucleus, low levels of transgene mRNA in the cytoplasm, a complex multicopy transgene insertion with aberrant copies, and methylation of the silenced PPV-CP transgene. The PPV-CP transgene was also methylated in seedlings of C5 and these seedlings were resistant to PPV. Our results show, for the first time, that PTGS functions as a mechanism for virus resistance in a woody perennial species.

Novel features of the XRN-family in Arabidopsis: evidence that AtXRN4, one of several orthologs of nuclear Xrn2p/Rat1p, functions in the cytoplasm

The 5'-3' exoribonucleases Xrn1p and Xrn2p/Rat1p function in the degradation and processing of several classes of RNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Xrn1p is the main enzyme catalyzing cytoplasmic mRNA degradation in multiple decay pathways, whereas Xrn2p/Rat1p functions in the processing of rRNAs and small nucleolar RNAs (snoRNAs) in the nucleus. Much less is known about the XRN-like proteins of multicellular eukaryotes; however, differences in their activities could explain differences in mRNA degradation between multicellular and unicellular eukaryotes. One such difference is the lack in plants and animals of mRNA decay intermediates like those generated in yeast when Xrn1p is blocked by poly(G) tracts that are inserted within mRNAs. We investigated the XRN-family in Arabidopsis thaliana and found it to have several novel features. First, the Arabidopsis genome contains three XRN-like genes (AtXRNs) that are structurally similar to Xrn2p/Rat1p, a characteristic unique to plants. Furthermore, our experimental results and sequence database searches indicate that Xrn1p orthologs may be absent from higher plants. Second, the lack of poly(G) mRNA decay intermediates in plants cannot be explained by the activity of the AtXRNs, because they are blocked by poly(G) tracts. Finally, complementation of yeast mutants and localization studies indicate that two of the AtXRNs likely function in the nucleus, whereas the third acts in the cytoplasm. Thus, the XRN-family in plants is more complex than in other eukaryotes, and, if an XRN-like enzyme plays a role in mRNA decay in plants, the likely participant is a cytoplasmic Xrn2p/Rat1p ortholog, rather than an Xrn1p ortholog.

Detailed characterization of the posttranscriptional gene-silencing-related small RNA in a GUS gene-silenced tobacco

Posttranscriptional gene-silencing phenomena such as cosuppression and RNA interference are associated with the occurrence of small, about 21-23 nt short RNA species homologous to the silenced gene. We here show that the small RNA present in silenced transgenic plants can easily be detected in total RNA isolated according to standard procedures. This will allow for the development of routine and early screenings for the presence of small RNA species and, therefore, gene silencing in transgenic plants. We further demonstrate that the small RNA fraction can be visualized with the SYBR Green II RNA stain, isolated from a gel, labeled and used as a specific probe. Using these approaches, we have fine-mapped the sequences of the GUS gene that are represented in the small RNA fraction of a GUS-silenced tobacco line containing an inverted repeat of the GUS gene. In this tobacco line, the silencing-associated small RNA is a mixture of fragments that cover the 3' two-thirds of the GUS coding region. The 5' coding and the 3' noncoding ends of the GUS mRNA are not represented in the small RNA fraction. The RNA fragments are not likely to be a primary synthesis product of an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, but rather degradation products from nuclease activity. Surprisingly, RNA isolated from wild-type, untransformed plants showed the presence of a similar-sized small RNA pool. This might indicate the existence of small RNA species from putative endogenous genes that are down regulated by a similar posttranscriptional gene-silencing mechanism. The possibility of isolating and labeling the small RNA pool from wild-type plants will provide a way to identify and study such putative genes.

RNA degradation and models for post-transcriptional gene-silencing

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) is a form of stable but potentially reversible epigenetic modification, which frequently occurs in transgenic plants. The interaction in trans of genes with similar transcribed sequences results in sequence-specific degradation of RNAs derived from the genes involved. Highly expressed single-copy loci, transcribed inverted repeats, and poorly transcribed complex loci can act as sources of signals that trigger PTGS. In some cases, mobile, sequence-specific silencing signals can move from cell to cell or even over long distances in the plant. Several current models hold that silencing signals are 'aberrant' RNAs (aRNA), which differ in some way from normal mRNAs. The most likely candidates are small antisense RNAs (asRNA) and double-stranded RNAs (dsRNA). Direct evidence that these or other aRNAs found in silent tissues can induce PTGS is still lacking. Most current models assume that silencing signals interact with target RNAs in a sequence-specific fashion. This results in degradation, usually in the cytoplasm, by exonucleolytic as well as endonucleolytic pathways, which are not necessarily PTGS-specific. Biochemical-switch models hold that the silent state is maintained by a positive auto-regulatory loop. One possibility is that concentrations of hypothetical silencing signals above a critical threshold trigger their own production by self-replication, by degradation of target RNAs, or by a combination of both mechanisms. These models can account for the stability, reversibility and multiplicity of silent states; the strong influence of transcription rate of target genes on the incidence and stability of silencing, and the amplification and systemic propagation of motile silencing signals.

Post-transcriptional gene-silencing: RNAs on the attack or on the defense?

Post-transcriptional gene-silencing (PTGS) was first discovered in plants and results from the sequence-specific degradation of RNA. Degradation can be activated by introducing transgenes, RNA viruses or DNA sequences that are homologous to expressed genes. A similar RNA degradation mechanism which is inducible by double-stranded RNA (dsRNAs), has been discovered recently in vertebrates, invertebrates and protozoa. dsRNAs may also be potent activators of PTGS in plants. PTGS is not cell autonomous, suggesting the synthesis of sequence-specific silencing signals which are not only moving through the plant but are also amplified and an RNA-directed RNA Polymerase which has recently been cloned from various plant species is a candidate enzyme for amplifying silencing signals. The natural role of PTGS seems to be as a defence against plant viruses, so what first appeared to be RNAs on the attack may now be considered RNAs on the defense. BioEssays 22:520-531, 2000.

Transgene translatability increases effectiveness of replicase-mediated resistance to cucumber mosaic virus

Transgenic tobacco plants expressing an altered form of the 2a replicase gene from the Fny strain of Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) exhibit suppressed virus replication and restricted virus movement when inoculated mechanically or by aphid vectors. Additional transformants have been generated which contain replicase gene constructs designed to determine the role(s) of transgene mRNA and/or protein in resistance. Resistance to systemic disease caused by CMV, as well as delayed infection, was observed in several lines of transgenic plants which were capable of expressing either full-length or truncated replicase proteins. In contrast, among plants which contained nontranslatable transgene constructs, only one of 61 lines examined exhibited delays or resistance. Once infected, plants never recovered, regardless of transgene translatability. Transgenic plants exhibiting a range of resistance levels were examined for transgene copy number, mRNA and protein levels. Although ribonuclease protection assays demonstrated that transgene mRNA levels were very low, resistant lines had consistently more steady-state transgene mRNA than susceptible lines. Furthermore, chlorotic or necrotic local lesions developed on the inoculated leaves of transgenic lines containing translatable transgenes, but not on inoculated leaves of lines containing nontranslatable transgenes. These results demonstrate that translatability of the transgene and possibly expression of the transgene protein itself facilitates replicase-mediated resistance to CMV in tobacco.

Posttranscriptional gene silencing of gn1 in tobacco triggers accumulation of truncated gn1-derived RNA species

Posttranscriptional silencing of basic beta-1,3-glucanase genes in the tobacco line T17 is manifested by reduced transcript levels of the gn1 transgene and homologous, endogenous basic beta-1,3-glucanase genes. An RNA ligation-mediated rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RLM-RACE) technique was used to compare the 3' termini of gn1 RNAs present in expressing (hemizygous and young homozygous) and silenced (mature homozygous) T17 plants. Full-length, polyadenylated gn1 transcripts primarily accumulated in expressing plants, whereas in silenced T17 plants, mainly 3'-truncated, nonpolyadenylated gn1 RNAs were detected. The relative abundance of these 3'-truncated gn1 RNA species gradually increased during the establishment of silencing in homozygous T17 plants. Similar 3'-truncated, nonpolyadenylated gn1 RNA products were observed in an independent case of beta-1,3-glucanase posttranscriptional gene silencing. This suggests that these 3'-truncated gn1 RNAs are a general feature of tobacco plants showing posttranscriptional silencing of the gn1 transgene.

Expression and sequence requirements for nitrite reductase co-suppression

We have previously reported that the introduction of a full-length tobacco nitrite reductase Nii1 cDNA under the control of the 35S promoter triggers co-suppression of endogenous Nii genes in 25% of tobacco transformants. Here we show that introduction of chimeric Nii1-uidA, uidA-Nii1 and Nii1-uidA-Nii1 transgenes carrying 186 bp of the 5' end and/or 241 bp of the 3' end of the Nii1 cDNA do not trigger co-suppression of endogenous Nii genes. In addition, we show that when introduced by crossing or transformation into co-suppressed transgenic tobacco lines carrying full-length Nii1 transgenes, these chimeric transgenes are not silenced. These results therefore suggest that the 5' and 3' ends of the Nii1 cDNA are not sufficient to trigger co-suppression and are not targets for homology-dependent RNA degradation. Surprisingly, co-suppression was released in a double transformant obtained by introduction of one of these constructs into the co-suppressed transgenic tobacco line 461-2.1 homozygous for a full-length Nii1 transgene, and in one plant regenerated from untransformed leaf discs (plant 461-2.1*). The reappearance of co-suppression at very low frequency (less than 10(-3)) in the F2 progeny of plant 461-2.1* and the apparent absence of structural modification of the transgene locus suggest a metastable epigenetic modification. The steady-state level of Nii mRNAs in the plant 461-2-.1* was higher than in wild-type plants but lower than in hemizygous plants 461-2.1 which never trigger silencing. These results therefore confirm that transcription of the transgene above a particular threshold is required to trigger co-suppression.

Connections between virus movement, macromolecular signaling and assimilate allocation

Studies originating with plant viruses led to the concept that plasmodesmata potentiate the cell-to-cell trafficking of viral and endogenous proteins and nucleoprotein complexes. In this article, we develop the theme that, at the tissue/organ level, cell-to-cell trafficking of information molecules enables non-cell-autonomous control over a range of processes, whereas at the organismal level, the phloem serves as an information superhighway. The capacity to deliver proteins and nucleoprotein complexes, over long distances, allowed for the development of a viral surveillance/resistance mechanism, as well as the integration of processes at the whole-plant level.

Turnip mosaic potyvirus resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana derived by post-transcriptional gene silencing

The coat protein (CP) gene of turnip mosaic potyvirus isolate ESC8 (TuMV-ESC8) was cloned and sequenced. Comparisons of the 867-nucleotide (nt) CP region with those of 11 TuMV isolates showed 86.7-89.3% nucleotide identity and 92.4-95.5% amino acid identity. The CP gene was cloned into a plant expression vector and transformed into Nicotiana benthamiana plants via Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated leaf disk transformation. Progeny from R0 lines was screened for resistance to TuMV-ESC8. Five of 29 tested lines showed TuMV protection in more than 50% of their progeny. Interestingly, some of the resistant plants transformed with the CP gene of TuMV displayed mild mosaicism in the new growing leaves at the later stages of evaluation; but these mosaic symptoms disappeared when the leaves were fully expanded. Collective data from steady-state RNA analysis and nuclear run-on assay of a line showed that the resistance was RNA-mediated through the post-transcriptional gene silencing mechanism.

Posttranscriptional gene silencing in transgenic sugarcane. Dissection Of homology-dependent virus resistance in a monocot that has a complex polyploid genome

RNA-mediated, posttranscriptional gene silencing has been determined as the molecular mechanism underlying transgenic virus resistance in many plant virus-dicot host plant systems. In this paper we show that transgenic virus resistance in sugarcane (Saccharum spp. hybrid) is based on posttranscriptional gene silencing. The resistance is derived from an untranslatable form of the sorghum mosaic potyvirus strain SCH coat protein (CP) gene. Transgenic sugarcane plants challenged with sorghum mosaic potyvirus strain SCH had phenotypes that ranged from fully susceptible to completely resistant, and a recovery phenotype was also observed. Clones derived from the same transformation event or obtained after vegetative propagation could display different levels of virus resistance, suggesting the involvement of a quantitative component in the resistance response. Most resistant plants displayed low or undetectable steady-state CP transgene mRNA levels, although nuclear transcription rates were high. Increased DNA methylation was observed in the transcribed region of the CP transgenes in most of these plants. Collectively, these characteristics indicate that an RNA-mediated, homology-dependent mechanism is at the base of the virus resistance. This work extends posttranscriptional gene silencing and homology-dependent virus resistance, so far observed only in dicots, to an agronomically important, polyploid monocot.

Stochastic and nonstochastic post-transcriptional silencing of chitinase and beta-1,3-glucanase genes involves increased RNA turnover-possible role for ribosome-independent RNA degradation

Stochastic and nonstochastic post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in Nicotiana sylvestris plants carrying tobacco class I chitinase (CHN) and beta-1,3-glucanase transgenes differs in incidence, stability, and pattern of expression. Measurements with inhibitors of RNA synthesis (cordycepin, actinomycin D, and alpha-amanitin) showed that both forms of PTGS are associated with increased sequence-specific degradation of transcripts, suggesting that increased RNA turnover may be a general feature of PTGS. The protein synthesis inhibitors cycloheximide and verrucarin A did not inhibit degradation of CHN RNA targeted for PTGS, confirming that PTGS-related RNA degradation does not depend on ongoing protein synthesis. Because verrucarin A, unlike cycloheximide, dissociates mRNA from ribosomes, our results also suggest that ribosome-associated RNA degradation pathways may not be involved in CHN PTGS.

Mitotic stability of infection-induced resistance to plum pox potyvirus associated with transgene silencing and DNA methylation

Plum pox potyvirus (PPV) infection of transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants that expressed the PPV NIb RNA replicase carrying a Gly to Val mutation at the GDD motif (NIbV lines) induced a phenotype of virus resistance and transgene silencing, which was not transmissible to the progeny after self-fertilization (H. S. Guo and J. A. García, Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:160-170, 1997). Here, we demonstrate that the induced resistance of NIbV plants is mitotically stable after plant propagation by grafting and by in vitro regeneration. Virus replication or residual virus RNA seem not to be required to maintain transgene silencing and virus resistance. Analysis by PCR (polymerase chain reaction) amplification after treatment with methylation-sensitive restriction nucleases indicates that DNA methylation is associated with establishment and maintenance of transgene silencing and virus resistance. Restoration of transgene activity and susceptibility to PPV in sexual progeny correlated with resetting of transgene DNA methylation. On the basis of these and other published results, we present a general model for post-transcriptional gene silencing in which RNA signals, generated either by a silenced nuclear gene or by virus replication, both activate a specific cytoplasmic RNA degradation pathway and induce changes (in particular, DNA methylation) in homologous nuclear genes that switch them from an active to a silenced status.

Silencing of an aleurone-specific gene in transgenic rice is caused by a rearranged transgene

In rice, silencing of the aleurone-specific Ltp2-gus transgene, causing easily detectable staining patterns on the grain surface, offers a convenient tool to study quantitative aspects of gene silencing in monocots. In this paper we analyzed phenotypes, occurrence, inheritance and environmental effects on the silencing. We also report on the cloning of transgenes, determination of their structure and analysis of transcripts from the transgene loci. The results show that various patterns of silencing appeared in the R2 generation at which most of the transgenes became homozygous and that they were inherited for five generations. In addition, silencing independently occurred in three generations and reversion to full expression was also found. Cloning of transgenes from a silenced L3.3 line demonstrated that this line carried two transgene loci: one carried an intact Ltp2-gus gene and the other carried a rearranged transgene in which part of the gus gene was in the antisense orientation. Analysis of gus transcripts indicated that partial antisense RNA derived from the rearranged transgene was present in silenced lines and was polyadenylated but that it was absent in non-silenced lines. RNA analyses suggested that the Ltp2-gus silencing in the aleurone layer was post-transcriptional and that it may be caused by interaction of partial antisense gus transcripts with normal sense transcripts. Possible involvement of antisense transcripts in post-transcriptional silencing is discussed.

Production of aberrant promoter transcripts contributes to methylation and silencing of unlinked homologous promoters in trans

Previous work has suggested that de novo methylation of plant nuclear genes can be triggered by an RNA-DNA interaction. To test whether transcription of a promoter would induce de novo methylation and silencing of unlinked genes driven by the same promoter, a chimeric 'gene' consisting of a nopaline synthase promoter (NOSpro) positioned downstream of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter (35Spro) and flanked at the 3' end by a NOS terminator (NOSter) was constructed and introduced into the genome of a plant that normally expresses an unmethylated NOSpro-neomycinphosphotransferase (nptII) gene. Transformants were tested for kanamycin resistance and NOSpro RNA synthesis. Most produced a full-length polyadenylated NOSpro RNA, which did not induce silencing or methylation at the NOSpro-nptII target gene. One, however, contained truncated non-polyadenylated NOSpro RNA; in this plant, the NOSpro-nptII gene became silenced and methylated in the NOSpro region. Molecular analysis of the NOSpro silencing locus revealed two incomplete copies of the 35Spro-NOSpro gene arranged as an inverted repeat with NOSpro sequences at the center. Reducing NOSpro transcription by crossing a 35Spro-silencing locus partially reactivated nptII gene expression and decreased NOSpro methylation at the target locus, thus implicating aberrant NOSpro RNA in this trans-silencing phenomenon.

Silencing of beta-1,3-glucanase genes in tobacco correlates with an increased abundance of RNA degradation intermediates

Post-transcriptional gene silencing of beta-1,3 glucanase genes in the transgenic tobacco line T17 is characterised by an increased turnover and, as a consequence, reduced levels of gn1 transgene and endogenous beta-1,3 glucanase mRNAs. Here, additional gn1 RNAs, both larger and smaller than the full-length messenger, are shown to accumulate in silenced plants of the transgenic tobacco line T17. The longer-than-full-length gn1 RNAs are the result of cryptic processing of the gn1 messenger. The small gn1 RNAs in silenced plants correspond to distal and proximal parts of the mature gn1 messenger. The proximal RNA products are intact at their 5' extremity, but terminate at different positions at the 3'-end. The distal RNA products contain a poly(A) tail and are truncated to various positions at the 5'-end. These observations indicate that degradation of the mature gn1 transcript does not start at the 5'- or 3'-end, but rather are consistent with degradation of the gn1 transcript starting with an endonucleolytic cleavage followed by internal exonuclease digestion. Importantly, the truncated products are more abundant in silenced plants than in expressing plants. This suggests, together with the previously reported silencing-related increased gn1 mRNA turnover and the similar rates of gn1 transcription in silenced and expressing T17 plants, that the predominant decay route for the gn1 transcripts differs between silenced and expressing conditions.

A counterdefensive strategy of plant viruses: suppression of posttranscriptional gene silencing

Posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in plants inactivates some aberrant or highly expressed RNAs in a sequence-specific manner in the cytoplasm. A silencing mechanism similar to PTGS appears to function as an adaptive antiviral response. We demonstrate that the P1/HC-Pro polyprotein encoded by tobacco etch virus functions as a suppressor of PTGS. A locus comprised of a highly expressed beta-glucuronidase (GUS) transgene was shown to exhibit PTGS. Genetic crosses and segregation analyses revealed that a P1/ HC-Pro transgene suppressed PTGS of the GUS sequence. Nuclear transcription assays indicated that the silencing suppression activity of P1/HC-Pro was at the posttranscriptional level. These data reveal that plant viruses can condition enhanced susceptibility within a host through interdiction of a potent defense response.

Transgenically expressed cucumber mosaic virus RNA 1 simultaneously complements replication of cucumber mosaic virus RNAs 2 and 3 and confers resistance to systemic infection

Tobacco plants transformed with a cDNA copy of RNA 1 of the Fny strain of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) promoted the asymptomatic accumulation of inoculated viral RNAs 2 and 3, which could be detected in noninoculated leaves, suggesting that the transgene also permitted viral long-distance movement. Typical symptoms of infection appeared later and correlated with the appearance of viral RNA 1 regenerated from the transgenic mRNA. Although all R0-generation plants were susceptible to Fny-CMV, one line displaying variable susceptibility to the virus in R1-and R2-generations led to selected R3-generation lines with systemic resistance to Fny-CMV. In the inoculated leaves of resistant plants, a dramatic decrease in the accumulation of viral RNA 1 was observed, relative to susceptible plants. No viral RNAs were detected in noninoculated leaves of the resistant plants, but such leaves were susceptible to infection. Furthermore, these leaves could sustain replication of inoculated CMV RNAs 2 and 3, indicating that a complete transgene-silencing had not been induced. Although a transgene-mediated, CMV RNA 1-suppression occurred in the inoculated leaf of resistant plants, the absence of a complete systemically acquired silencing suggests the existence of additional interferences with viral infection that prevented systemic infection by viral RNAs 2 and 3.

Arabidopsis mutants impaired in cosuppression

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (cosuppression) results in the degradation of RNA after transcription. A transgenic Arabidopsis line showing post-transcriptional silencing of a 35S-uidA transgene and uidA-specific methylation was mutagenized using ethyl methanesulfonate. Six independent plants were isolated in which uidA mRNA accumulation and beta-glucuronidase activity were increased up to 3500-fold, whereas the transcription rate of the 35S-uidA transgene was increased only up to threefold. These plants each carried a recessive monogenic mutation that is responsible for the release of silencing. These mutations defined two genetic loci, called sgs1 and sgs2 (for suppressor of gene silencing). Transgene methylation was distinctly modified in sgs1 and sgs2 mutants. However, methylation of centromeric repeats was not affected, indicating that sgs mutants differ from ddm (for decrease in DNA methylation) and som (for somniferous) mutants. Indeed, unlike ddm and som mutations, sgs mutations were not able to release transcriptional silencing of a 35S-hpt transgene. Conversely, both sgs1 and sgs2 mutations were able to release cosuppression of host Nia genes and 35S-Nia2 transgenes. These results therefore indicate that sgs mutations act in trans to impede specifically transgene-induced post-transcriptional gene silencing.

Transgenes are dispensable for the RNA degradation step of cosuppression

Cosuppression results in the degradation of RNA from host genes and homologous transgenes after transcription in the nucleus. By using grafting experiments, we have shown previously that a systemic signal mediates the propagation of cosuppression of Nia host genes and 35S-Nia2 transgenes from silenced 35S-Nia2 transgenic stocks to nonsilenced 35S-Nia2 transgenic scions but not to wild-type scions. Here, we examined the requirements for triggering and maintenance of cosuppression in various types of scions. Grafting-induced silencing occurred in 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines over-accumulating Nia mRNA whether they are able to spontaneously trigger cosuppression or not and in 35S-Nia2 transgene-free plants over-accumulating host Nia mRNA caused by metabolic derepression. When grafting-induced silenced scions were removed from the silenced stocks and regrafted onto wild-type plants, silencing was not maintained in the 35S-Nia2 transgene-free plants and in the 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines that are not able to trigger cosuppression spontaneously. Conversely, silencing was maintained in the 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines that are able to trigger cosuppression spontaneously. Our results indicate that the presence of a 35S-Nia2 transgene is dispensable for the RNA degradation step of posttranscriptional silencing when host Nia mRNA over-accumulate above the level of wild-type plants. They also suggest that grafting-induced RNA degradation does not result in the production of the systemic silencing signal required for spontaneous triggering and maintenance.

Initiation and maintenance of virus-induced gene silencing

The phytoene desaturase (PDS) gene of Nicotiana benthamiana was silenced in plants infected with potato virus X (PVX) vectors carrying PDS inserts, and a green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene was silenced in plants infected with PVX-GFP. This virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is post-transcriptional and cytoplasmic because it is targeted against exons rather than introns of PDS RNA and against viral RNAs. Although PDS and GFP RNAs are most likely targeted through the same mechanism, the VIGS phenotypes differed in two respects. PDS mRNA was targeted by VIGS in all green tissue of the PVX-PDS-infected plant, whereas PVX-PDS was not affected. In contrast, VIGS of the GFP was targeted against PVX-GFP. Initially, VIGS of the GFP was initiated in all green tissues, as occurred with PDS VIGS. However, after 30 days of infection, the GFP VIGS was no longer initiated in newly emerging leaves, although it was maintained in tissue in which it had already been initiated. Based on these analyses, we propose a model for VIGS in which the initiation of VIGS is dependent on the virus and maintenance of it is virus independent.

Initiation and maintenance of virus-induced gene silencing

The phytoene desaturase (PDS) gene of Nicotiana benthamiana was silenced in plants infected with potato virus X (PVX) vectors carrying PDS inserts, and a green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene was silenced in plants infected with PVX-GFP. This virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is post-transcriptional and cytoplasmic because it is targeted against exons rather than introns of PDS RNA and against viral RNAs. Although PDS and GFP RNAs are most likely targeted through the same mechanism, the VIGS phenotypes differed in two respects. PDS mRNA was targeted by VIGS in all green tissue of the PVX-PDS-infected plant, whereas PVX-PDS was not affected. In contrast, VIGS of the GFP was targeted against PVX-GFP. Initially, VIGS of the GFP was initiated in all green tissues, as occurred with PDS VIGS. However, after 30 days of infection, the GFP VIGS was no longer initiated in newly emerging leaves, although it was maintained in tissue in which it had already been initiated. Based on these analyses, we propose a model for VIGS in which the initiation of VIGS is dependent on the virus and maintenance of it is virus independent.

The DNA methylation locus DDM1 is required for maintenance of gene silencing in Arabidopsis

To investigate the relationship between cytosine methylation and gene silencing in Arabidopsis, we constructed strains containing the ddm1 hypomethylation mutation and a methylated and silenced PAI2 tryptophan biosynthetic gene (MePAI2) that results in a blue fluorescent plant phenotype. The ddm1 mutation had both an immediate and a progressive effect on PAI gene silencing. In the first generation, homozygous ddm1 MePAI2 plants displayed a weakly fluorescent phenotype, in contrast to the strongly fluorescent phenotype of the DDM1 MePAI2 parent. After two generations of inbreeding by self-pollination, the ddm1/ddm1 lines became nonfluorescent. The progressive loss of fluorescence correlated with a progressive loss of methylation from the PAI2 gene. These results indicate that methylation is necessary for maintenance of PAI gene silencing and that intermediate levels of DNA methylation are associated with intermediate gene silencing. The results also support our earlier hypothesis that ddm1 homozygotes act as "epigenetic mutators" by accumulating heritable changes in DNA methylation that can lead to changes in gene expression.

A model for RNA-mediated gene silencing in higher plants

Homology-dependent gene silencing (HdGS) which is the generic term for transcriptional gene silencing (TGS), post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) and RNA-mediated virus-resistance (RmVR) has been shown to frequently occur in transgenic plants. The role of RNA as a target and initiator of PTGS and RmVR is more and more manifested. Because TGS is assumed to be induced by a DNA-DNA interaction-mediated promoter methylation, a possible involvement of RNA in TGS was not really considered up to now. In this review we attempt to demonstrate that all three types of HdGS could be triggered by one RNA-based mechanism. A model proposing TGS as a consequence of RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) and a refined mRNA threshold mechanism are presented. In contrast to the view that high amounts of mRNA are required we assume that the concentration of RNAs that can serve as efficient templates for a plant-encoded RNA-directed RNA polymerase (RdRP) plays a key role in HdGS and possibly also in natural gene regulation of non-transformed cells. According to this idea a particular information must be encoded to render mRNA turn-over products a suitable RdRP substrate. It will be discussed that such a mechanism could account for the silencing phenomena of poorly transcribed transgenes. Finally, an explanation for the coherency between PTGS and DNA methylation is documented.

Controlling gene expression in transgenics

The repertoire of cis-regulatory elements has increased to a level of sophistication that offers considerable spatial and temporal control over transgene expression. Recent advances made with transgenes have revealed that the control of their expression is also influenced by factors that range from transgene copy number and arrangement to nuclear architecture and chromosomal location. These factors must now be included with the standard considerations of transcriptional and translational enhancers of gene expression during transgene design.