Late intra-patient tacrolimus trough level variability as a major problem in kidney transplantation: A Collaborative Transplant Study Report

Intrapatient tacrolimus variability is associated with medical nonadherence among pediatric kidney transplant recipients

Background

Long-term survival of kidney allografts is limited by multiple factors, including nonadherence. High intrapatient variability in tacrolimus levels (≥30%) is associated with de novo donor-specific antibody (dnDSA) formation, increased risk of rejection and graft loss.

Methods

We prospectively analyzed the association between tacrolimus intrapatient variability and nonadherence in pediatric kidney transplant recipients. We derived a composite adherence score from 0 to 3 points based on (1) Basel Assessment of Adherence to Immunosuppressive Medical Scale©; (2) healthcare team score; and (3) intentionally missed laboratory or clinic visits. A score of 1 or more was considered nonadherent. Tacrolimus 12 h trough levels, patient characteristics and clinical outcomes were collected. Tacrolimus IPV was calculated as the coefficient of variation.

Results

The nonadherent group had a significantly higher median tacrolimus intrapatient variability (31%) as compared to the adherent cohort (20%) (p < 0.001.) Tac IPV demonstrated strong predictive performance for adherence (AUC 0.772), with a particularly high sensitivity of 90% at thresholds up to 20%, offering a practical and actionable framework for assessing adherence-related risks in clinical practice.

Conclusions

Tacrolimus intrapatient variability may be a useful biomarker to identify nonadherence and high-risk patients, allowing for early interventions to prevent adverse graft outcomes.

The effect of the use of omeprazole versus famotidine on the kidney transplant function: a randomized controlled study

Tacrolimus is metabolized in the liver with the participation of cytochrome P450 isoforms 3A4 and 3A5 (CYP3A4, CYP3A5). Omeprazole, unlike famotidine, is a substrate and inhibitor of CYP2C19, CYP3A4, CYP3A5 enzymes. The aim of the study is to compare the effect of omeprazole and famotidine on the tacrolimus concentration and the kidney transplant function. A randomized study was conducted in 24 adult patients with stable kidney transplant function who received a standard triple immunosuppression regimen. Patients were assigned to the group I (n = 12) additionally receiving omeprazole (20 mg) or the group II (n = 12) receiving famotidine (20 mg). At the time of qualification and during follow-up visits, tacrolimus blood concentration and selected laboratory tests were performed. Statistical analysis was performed using the MedCalc system. The value of tacrolimus concentration in the blood increased after a year in the group I (7.27 ± 2.33 vs 9.20 ± 2.46 ng/mL, p = 0.0478). A reduction in tacrolimus dosage was observed after three years in the group I (3.56 ± 1.75 vs 2.78 ± 1.00 mg, p = 0.0440) and in the group II (2.72 ± 0.84 vs 2.10 ± 0.48 mg, p = 0.0051). There was significant difference in the percentage changes of glomerular filtration rate between the groups after 3 years of the study (- 5.56% vs 9.13%, p = 0.0343). Omeprazole significantly change the concentration of tacrolimus in the blood when administered together with tacrolimus after one year of observation. There was no effect of famotidine or omeprazole on the function of the kidney transplant. ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT05061303.

Association between salivary microbiota and tacrolimus pharmacokinetic variability in kidney transplant

Kidney transplantation (KT) serves as a highly effective treatment for end-stage renal disease (ESRD). Nonetheless, the administration of tacrolimus, a commonly used immunosuppressant in KT, faces challenges due to the lack of dependable biomarkers for its efficacy and the considerable variability in tacrolimus pharmacokinetics (TacIPV). In this study, 183 saliva samples from 48 KT recipients under tacrolimus therapy, alongside 9 healthy control samples, were subjected to 16S rRNA sequencing. The analysis revealed significant differences in the composition of salivary microbiota among KT recipients, patients with ESRD, and healthy controls. Moreover, trough blood concentrations (C0) of tacrolimus were associated with alterations in microbiota composition. Notably, Capnocytophage consistently exhibited a negative correlation in both group-level and individual trends. Furthermore, distinct taxa were identified that effectively distinguished recipients with varying TacIPV, as demonstrated by a cross-validation random forest model (mean AUC = 0.7560), with Anaerolinea emerging as a prominent contributor to the classifier. These findings suggest that salivary microbiota is closely linked to tacrolimus C0 levels and could aid clinicians in differentiating KT recipients based on TacIPV.

Optimum tacrolimus trough levels for enhanced graft survival and safety in kidney transplantation: a retrospective multicenter real-world evidence study

BACKGROUND

The current study aimed to determine the optimal tacrolimus trough levels for balancing graft survival and patient safety following kidney transplantation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study involving 11 868 kidney transplant recipients from five medical centers. The association between tacrolimus exposures (periodic mean trough level, coefficient of variability, time in therapeutic range) and composite allograft outcome (de novo donor-specific antibody, biopsy-proven rejection, kidney dysfunction, and graft failure), as well as safety outcomes (severe infection, cardiovascular events, malignancy, and mortality) were assessed. Data were sourced from Clinical Data Warehouses and analyzed using advanced statistical methods, including Cox marginal structural models with inverse probability treatment weighting.

RESULTS

Tacrolimus levels of 5.0-7.9 ng/ml and 5.0-6.9 ng/ml during the 2-12 month and 12-72 month post-transplantation periods, respectively, were associated with reduced risks of composite allograft outcomes. During the first post-transplant year, the adjusted hazard ratios (aHR) for composite allograft outcomes were 0.69 (95% CI 0.55-0.85, P <0.001) for 5.0-5.9 ng/ml; 0.81 (95% CI 0.67-0.98, P =0.033) for 6.0-6.9 ng/ml; and 0.73 (95% CI 0.60-0.89, P =0.002) for 7.0-7.9 ng/ml (compared to levels ≥8.0 ng/ml). For the 6-year composite outcomes, aHRs were 0.68 (95% CI 0.53-0.87, P =0.002) for 5.0-5.9 ng/ml and 0.65 (95% CI 0.50-0.85, P =0.001) for 6.0-6.9 ng/ml. These optimal ranges showed reduced rates of severe infection (6 years), malignancy (6 years), and mortality (1 year).

CONCLUSION

This multicenter study provides robust evidence for optimal tacrolimus trough levels during the periods 2-12 and 12-72 months following kidney transplantation.

The Number of Episodes of Subtherapeutic Tacrolimus Blood Level Is Independently Associated With Reduced Kidney Graft Survival

BACKGROUND

Tacrolimus blood level variability is associated with reduced graft survival among kidney transplant recipients. To date, no practical approach for reducing variability has been validated. We defined specific tacrolimus blood level patterns correlated with variability and evaluated their independent association with reduced graft survival.

METHODS

In this single-center retrospective study, we predefined 12 patterns that exhibited correlation with high tacrolimus blood level variability. Subsequently, we utilized a multivariate Cox proportional hazard model, in conjunction with the Akaike information criteria, to evaluate the association between the predefined patterns and decreased graft survival.

RESULTS

Our cohort included 1305 kidney transplant recipients. The primary outcome of this trial was graft loss, defined as the initiation of chronic dialysis or the need for retransplantation. The secondary outcome was the combination of death-censored graft loss and death with a functioning graft. During the study's follow-up period, there were 131 events of graft loss. The number of episodes of subtherapeutic tacrolimus level during the first-year posttransplantation was significantly associated with graft loss (HR 1.208 per episode, 95% CI 1.075-1.356, p = 0.001) and significantly improved the relative likelihood of the model compared to the multivariate model as demonstrated by the delta AIC value (8.256, p = 0.016).

CONCLUSION

In addition to increased tacrolimus blood level variability, the number of episodes of subtherapeutic tacrolimus levels is independently associated with decreased graft survival among kidney transplant recipients.

Assessing the Utility of a Genotype-Guided Tacrolimus Equation in African American Kidney Transplant Recipients: A Single Institution Retrospective Study

Tacrolimus metabolism is heavily influenced by the CYP3A5 genotype, which varies widely among African Americans (AA). We aimed to assess the performance of a published genotype-informed tacrolimus dosing model in an independent set of adult AA kidney transplant (KTx) recipients. CYP3A5 genotypes were obtained for all AA KTx recipients (n = 232) from 2010 to 2019 who met inclusion criteria at a single transplant center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA. Medical record data were used to calculate predicted tacrolimus clearance using the published AA KTx dosing equation and two modified iterations. Observed and model-predicted trough levels were compared at 3 days, 3 months, and 6 months post-transplant. The mean prediction error at day 3 post-transplant was 3.05 ng/mL, indicating that the model tended to overpredict the tacrolimus trough. This bias improved over time to 1.36 and 0.78 ng/mL at 3 and 6 months post-transplant, respectively. Mean absolute prediction error-a marker of model precision-improved with time to 2.33 ng/mL at 6 months. Limiting genotype data in the model decreased bias and improved precision. The bias and precision of the published model improved over time and were comparable to studies in previous cohorts. The overprediction observed by the published model may represent overfitting to the initial cohort, possibly limiting generalizability.

Tacrolimus intra-patient variability measures and its associations with allograft clinical outcomes in kidney transplantation

AIMS

Tacrolimus (Tac) is commonly prescribed in solid organ transplantation to prevent immune-mediated damage to the graft. However, its pharmacokinetics show substantial variability between and within patients. Intra-patient variability of tacrolimus (Tac-IPV) has emerged as a novel marker to predict transplant outcomes. Numerous studies report varying associations between Tac-IPV and clinical outcomes, with Tac-IPV measures showing wide discrepancies among these studies. This inconsistency could be a significant factor that influences the various outcomes reported in different studies. Our review comprehensively assesses the relationship between various Tac-IPV measures and their associations with clinical outcomes in transplant patients.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search was conducted using the PubMed and Embase databases, covering the period from 2004 to March 31, 2023. The search focused on studies that examined the relationship between Tac-IPV and clinical outcomes in kidney transplantation (KT). The inclusion criteria were specific to studies addressing Tac-IPV, including measures such as standard deviation (SD), coefficient of variation (CV), time-weighted coefficient of variability (CV), mean absolute deviation (MAD), and Tac variability score (TVS). Clinical outcomes included the development of de novo donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA), rejection episodes, graft loss, and graft failure.

RESULTS

Among the 33 studies that met the inclusion criteria, a notable proportion presented conflicting findings in their assessment of various Tac-IPV measures regarding dnDSA, rejection episodes, graft loss, and graft failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Most studies have identified a correlation between high Tac-IPV and poor clinical outcomes; however, this relationship is multifactorial. Influencing factors include the metabolic status of KT patients, the timing of Tac-IPV calculations, and the criteria for defining high and low Tac-IPV thresholds, including the size and selection method. CV, MAD, and TWCV are the metrics that are most frequently used to determine Tac-IPV. Additionally, most of the methods for establishing Tac-IPV thresholds typically employ receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and median values. It is also notable that studies examining the clinical significance of Tac-IPV often include tacrolimus levels measured six months after kidney transplantation.

A pharmacist-led intervention to improve kidney transplant recipient outcomes and identify patients at risk of highly variable trough tacrolimus levels: a cohort study

OBJECTIVES

Given the positive impact of appropriate medication management on graft outcome and therefore of patient survival and graft function, the pharmacist's role in the kidney transplantation team has evolved over recent decades. The primary objective of this study was to determine whether pharmacist-led intervention after kidney transplantation is associated with a lower graft rejection rate and intra-patient variation in tacrolimus trough concentrations (Cmin). The study's secondary objective was to develop a questionnaire to identify patients at risk for highly variable Cmin.

METHODS

We retrospectively analysed kidney transplant recipients at Rennes University Hospital (France) between January 2013 and December 2020. Patients who received pharmacist-led education (intervention group, n=139) were compared with patients who did not (control group, n=131), according to graft survival at 1 year post-transplant, coefficient of variation (%CV) for the tacrolimus Cmin, age, sex, length of hospital stay post-transplantation, body mass index, and Charlson Comorbidity Index. In the intervention group, a questionnaire assessing patient knowledge was introduced to compare scores with the %CV.

RESULTS

In the intervention group, 1 year post-transplant graft survival was higher (95.7% vs 88.5%, p=0.0289) and patients had fewer variabilities in Cmin. The %CV was correlated with questionnaire scores (r=-0.9758, p<0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Pharmacist-led interventions may have contributed to improved graft survival and patient management of immunosuppressants. Because %CV correlates with the patient questionnaire score, its introduction could be useful in identifying kidney transplant patients who would benefit most from a pharmacist-led patient education.

Exploratory associations of tacrolimus exposure and clinical outcomes after lung transplantation: A retrospective, single center experience

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate the potential impact of tacrolimus (TAC) exposure on clinical outcomes after lung transplantation.

METHODS

This retrospective observational study enrolled a total of 228 lung transplant recipients. TAC trough levels (C0) were collected for 3 intervals: 0-3 months, 3-12 months, and 12-24 months. The intra-patient variability (IPV) was calculated using coefficient of variation. Genotyping of CYP3A5*3 (rs776746) was performed. Patients were further divided into groups based on the C0 cut-off value of 8 ng/mL and IPV cut-off value of 30%. Cox proportional hazards regression models were used to explore the potential impact of C0 and IPV on outcomes of interests, including de-novo donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA), chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD) and mortality.

RESULTS

The influence of CYP3A5*3 polymorphism was only significant for C0 and IPV during the first 3 months. Low C0 (< 8 ng/mL) at 3-12 months increased the risk of dnDSA (hazard ratio [HR] 2.696, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.046-6.953) and mortality (HR 2.531, 95% CI 1.368-4.685), while High IPV (≥ 30%) during this period was associated with an increased risk of mortality (HR 2.543, 95% CI 1.336-4.839). Patients with Low C0/High IPV combination had significantly higher risks for dnDSA (HR 4.381, 95% CI 1.279-15.008) and survival (HR 6.179, 95% CI 2.598-14.698), surpassing the predictive power provided by C0 or IPV alone.

CONCLUSION

A combination of Low C0/High IPV might be considered in categorizing patients towards risk of adverse clinical outcomes following lung transplantation.

Assessment of omeprazole and famotidine effects on the pharmacokinetics of tacrolimus in patients following kidney transplant-randomized controlled trial

Tacrolimus is metabolized in the liver with the participation of the CYP3A4 and CYP3A5 enzymes. Proton pump inhibitors are used in kidney transplant patients to prevent duodenal and gastric ulcer disease due to glucocorticoids. Omeprazole, unlike famotidine, is a substrate and inhibitor of the enzymes CYP2C19, CYP3A4, CYP3A5. The aim of this study was to compare the impact of omeprazole and famotidine on the pharmacokinetics of tacrolimus. A randomized, non-blinded study involving 22 stabilized adult kidney transplant patients was conducted. Patients received the standard triple immunosuppression regimen and omeprazole 20 mg (n = 10) or famotidine 20 mg (n = 12). The study material consisted of blood samples in which tacrolimus concentrations were determined using the Chemiluminescent Microparticle Immuno Assay method. A single administration of omeprazole increased tacrolimus concentrations at 2 h (day 2) = 11.90 ± 1.59 ng/mL vs. 2 h (day 1 - no omeprazole administration) = 9.40 ± 0.79 ng/mL (p = 0.0443). AUC0-6 amounted to 63.07 ± 19.46 ng × h/mL (day 2) vs. 54.23 ± 10.48 ng × h/mL (day 1), (p = 0.0295). AUC2-6 amounted to 44.32 ± 11.51 ng × h/mL (day 2) vs. 38.68 ± 7.70 ng × h/mL (day 1), (p = 0.0130). Conversely, no significant changes in values of pharmacokinetic parameters were observed for famotidine. Omeprazole significantly increases blood exposure of tacrolimus. The administration of famotidine instead of omeprazole seems safer for patients following kidney transplantation. Clinical Trial Registration: clinicaltrials.gov, identifier NCT05061303.

Impact of tacrolimus intra-patient variability in adverse outcomes after organ transplantation

Tacrolimus (Tac) is currently the most common calcineurin-inhibitor employed in solid organ transplantation. High intra-patient variability (IPV) of Tac (Tac IPV) has been associated with an increased risk of immune-mediated rejection and poor outcomes after kidney transplantation. Few data are available concerning the impact of high Tac IPV in non-kidney transplants. However, even in kidney transplantation, there is still a controversy whether high Tac IPV is indeed detrimental in respect to graft and/or patient survival. This may be due to different methods employed to evaluate IPV and distinct time frames adopted to assess graft and patient survival in those reports published up to now in the literature. Little is also known about the influence of high Tac IPV in the development of other untoward adverse events, update of the current knowledge regarding the impact of Tac IPV in different outcomes following kidney, liver, heart, lung, and pancreas tran splantation to better evaluate its use in clinical practice.

The Clinical Utility of Post-Transplant Monitoring of Donor-Specific Antibodies in Stable Renal Transplant Recipients: A Consensus Report With Guideline Statements for Clinical Practice

Solid phase immunoassays improved the detection and determination of the antigen-specificity of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) to human leukocyte antigens (HLA). The widespread use of SPI in kidney transplantation also introduced new clinical dilemmas, such as whether patients should be monitored for DSA pre- or post-transplantation. Pretransplant screening through SPI has become standard practice and DSA are readily determined in case of suspected rejection. However, DSA monitoring in recipients with stable graft function has not been universally established as standard of care. This may be related to uncertainty regarding the clinical utility of DSA monitoring as a screening tool. This consensus report aims to appraise the clinical utility of DSA monitoring in recipients without overt signs of graft dysfunction, using the Wilson & Junger criteria for assessing the validity of a screening practice. To assess the evidence on DSA monitoring, the European Society for Organ Transplantation (ESOT) convened a dedicated workgroup, comprised of experts in transplantation nephrology and immunology, to review relevant literature. Guidelines and statements were developed during a consensus conference by Delphi methodology that took place in person in November 2022 in Prague. The findings and recommendations of the workgroup on subclinical DSA monitoring are presented in this article.

Real-life comparison of efficacy and safety profiles of two prolonged-release tacrolimus formulations in de novo kidney transplant recipients: 24 months of follow-up

INTRODUCTION

Calcineurin inhibitors constitute a cornerstone of immunosuppressive therapy in kidney transplant recipients. There are two main formulations of tacrolimus (Tac) which exhibit a prolonged-release mode of action: Advagraf® (MR-4) and Envarsus® (LCPT). However, they are not bioequivalent. Data comparing both once-daily prolonged-release formulations of Tac are insufficient.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study was to compare safety and efficacy profiles of once-daily LCPT and MR-4 formulations of tacrolimus in adult kidney transplant recipients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

An observational, cohort single-center study was performed. One hundred fifteen kidney transplant recipients transplanted between 2016 and 2019 were enrolled to the study (59 vs 56, Envarsus® vs Advagraf®, respectively). Safety and efficacy profiles were assessed.

RESULTS

Patient and graft survival at 12 and 24 months did not differ between the groups. There were no significant differences in serum creatinine at any timepoint. C/D ratio in the LCPT group was significantly higher at 12 and 24 months. Sepsis occurrence was more frequent in MR-4 group at 12 months.

CONCLUSION

Both prolonged-release formulations of tacrolimus are safe and effective in immunosuppressive therapy in kidney transplant recipients.

Comparison of Tacrolimus Intra-Patient Variability during 6-12 Months after Kidney Transplantation between CYP3A5 Expressers and Nonexpressers

A high intra-patient variability (IPV) of tacrolimus exposure is associated with poor long-term kidney transplantation outcomes. To assess the influence of cytochrome P450 (CYP) 3A5 genetic polymorphisms on tacrolimus IPV, 188 clinically stable kidney transplant recipients, who had received an immediate-release tacrolimus-based immunosuppressive regimen, were enrolled in this retrospective cohort study. Genotyping of CYP3A5*3 (rs776746) was performed and 110 (58.5%) were identified as CYP3A5 expressers and 78 (41.5%) as nonexpressers. Whole blood tacrolimus concentrations were analyzed by chemiluminescent microparticle immunoassay. Dose-adjusted trough tacrolimus concentrations (C0/D) measured at months 6, 9, and 12 were used to determine IPV. There were no significant differences in the IPV estimated by the coefficient of variation, the IPV calculated by mean absolute deviation method, and the proportions of recipients with the IPV estimated by the coefficient of variation of 30% or more between CYP3A5 expressers and nonexpressers (p = 0.613, 0.686, and 0.954, respectively). Tacrolimus C0/D in CYP3A5 expressers was approximately half of those in nonexpressers, overall (p < 0.001). In both CYP3A5 expressers and nonexpressers, tacrolimus C0/D increased gradually from month 6 to month 12 (p = 0.021). There was no evidence that the CYP3A5 polymorphisms significantly influence tacrolimus IPV during the 6 to 12 months after kidney transplantation.

Tacrolimus Monotherapy is Safe in Immunologically Low-Risk Kidney Transplant Recipients: A Randomized-Controlled Pilot Study

In this randomized-controlled pilot study, the feasibility and safety of tacrolimus monotherapy in immunologically low-risk kidney transplant recipients was evaluated [NTR4824, www.trialregister.nl]. Low immunological risk was defined as maximal 3 HLA mismatches and the absence of panel reactive antibodies. Six months after transplantation, recipients were randomized if eGFR >30 ml/min, proteinuria <50 mg protein/mmol creatinine, no biopsy-proven rejection after 3 months, and no lymphocyte depleting therapy given. Recipients were randomized to tacrolimus/mycophenolate mofetil (TAC/MMF) or to taper and discontinue MMF at month 9 (TACmono). 79 of the 121 recipients were randomized to either TACmono (n = 38) or TAC/MMF (n = 41). Mean recipient age was 59 years and 59% received a living donor transplant. The median follow-up was 62 months. After randomization, 3 TACmono and 4 TAC/MMF recipients experienced a biopsy-proven rejection. At 5 years follow-up, patient survival was 84% in TACmono versus 76% in TAC/MMF with death-censored graft survival of 97% for both groups and no differences in eGFR and proteinuria. Eleven TACmono recipients had an infectious episode versus 22 TAC/MMF recipients (p < 0.03). Donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies were not detected during follow-up in both groups. Tacrolimus monotherapy in selected immunologically low-risk kidney transplant recipients appears safe and reduces the number of infections.

Patterns in Tacrolimus Variability and Association with De Novo Donor-Specific Antibody Formation in Pediatric Kidney Transplant Recipients

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

High tacrolimus intrapatient variability has been associated with inferior graft outcomes in patients with kidney transplants. We studied baseline patterns of tacrolimus intrapatient variability in pediatric patients with kidney transplants and examined these patterns in relation to C1q-binding de novo donor-specific antibodies.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

All tacrolimus levels in participants who underwent kidney-only transplantation at a single pediatric center from 2004 to 2018 (with at least 12-month follow-up, followed until 2019) were analyzed to determine baseline variability. Intrapatient variability was defined using the coefficient of variation (SD/mean ×100%) of all samples in a 6-month moving window. Routine de novo donor-specific antibody measurements were available for a subgroup of patients transplanted in 2010-2018. Cox proportional hazards models using tacrolimus intrapatient variability as a time-varying variable were used to examine the association between intrapatient variability and graft outcomes. The primary outcome of interest was C1q-binding de novo donor-specific antibody formation.

RESULTS

Tacrolimus intrapatient variability developed a steady-state baseline of 30% at 10 months post-transplant in 426 patients with a combined 31,125 tacrolimus levels. Included in the outcomes study were 220 patients, of whom 51 developed C1q-binding de novo donor-specific antibodies. De novo donor-specific antibody formers had higher intrapatient variability, with a median of 38% (interquartile range, 28%-48%) compared with 28% (interquartile range, 20%-38%) for nondonor-specific antibody formers (P<0.001). Patients with high tacrolimus intrapatient variability (coefficient of variation >30%) had higher risk of de novo donor-specific antibody formation (hazard ratio, 5.35; 95% confidence interval, 2.45 to 11.68). Patients in the top quartile of tacrolimus intrapatient variability (coefficient of variation >41%) had the strongest association with C1q-binding de novo donor-specific antibody formation (hazard ratio, 11.81; 95% confidence interval, 4.76 to 29.27).

CONCLUSIONS

High tacrolimus intrapatient variability was strongly associated with de novo donor-specific antibody formation.

High Tacrolimus Intrapatient Variability and Subtherapeutic Immunosuppression are Associated With Adverse Kidney Transplant Outcomes

BACKGROUND

Kidney transplant recipients with high intrapatient variability (IPV) in tacrolimus (Tac) exposure experience more rejection and reduced graft survival. To understand the underlying pathophysiology of this association, the authors investigated whether patients with high tacrolimus IPV have a more activated immune system than patients with low IPV. In addition, exposure to tacrolimus and mycophenolic acid (MPA) was studied in relation to rejection and graft survival.

METHODS

At the time of patient inclusion (5-7 years post-transplantation), the frequency of donor-reactive cells was determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and the development of donor-specific anti-Human Leukocyte Antigen antibodies (DSA) was measured by Luminex Single Antigen assay. Tacrolimus IPV was retrospectively calculated between 6 and 12 months and the exposure to tacrolimus and MPA was determined between 1 and 5 years post-transplantation.

RESULTS

A total of 371 kidney transplant recipients were included in this study, of whom 56 developed a rejection episode after 12 months and 60 experienced graft failure after 5-7 years. No correlations were found between tacrolimus IPV or immunosuppression exposure and the number of donor-reactive cells after 5 years of transplantation. DSA were detected more often in patients with low exposure to both tacrolimus and MMF [4/21 (19%) versus 17/350 (4.9%), P = 0.04]. In this cohort, neither tacrolimus IPV nor low overall immunosuppression exposure was associated with a higher incidence of rejection. However, regression analysis showed that a higher tacrolimus IPV was associated with an increased incidence of graft failure (odds ratio = 1.03, P = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

This study verifies the relationship between high tacrolimus IPV and impaired kidney allograft survival in long-term follow-up. DSA was also found to be more prevalent in patients with subtherapeutic concentrations of tacrolimus and MPA. An increased prevalence of donor-specific alloreactivity is yet to be demonstrated in patients with high IPV.

Association of intraindividual tacrolimus variability with de novo donor-specific HLA antibody development and allograft rejection in pediatric kidney transplant recipients with low immunological risk

BACKGROUND

Tacrolimus (Tac) intraindividual variability (TacIPV) in pediatric kidney transplant patients is only poorly understood. We investigated the impact of TacIPV on de novo donor-specific HLA antibodies (dnDSA) development and allograft rejection in Caucasian pediatric recipients of a living or deceased donor kidney with low immunological risk.

METHODS

This was a single-center retrospective study including 48 pediatric kidney transplant recipients. TacIPV was calculated based on coefficient of variation (CV%) 6-12 months posttransplant. TacIPV cutoff was set at the median (25%). Outcome parameters were dnDSA development and rejection episodes.

RESULTS

In total, 566 Tac levels were measured with median 11.0 (6.0-17.0) measurements per patient. The cutoff of 25% corresponded to the median CV% in our study cohort (25%, IQR 18-35%) and was comparable to cutoffs determined by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. High TacIPV was associated with higher risk of dnDSA development (HR 3.4, 95% CI 1.0-11.1, P = 0.047; Kaplan-Meier analysis P = 0.018) and any kind of rejection episodes (HR 4.1, 95% CI 1.1-14.8, P = 0.033; Kaplan-Meier analysis P = 0.010). There was a clear trend towards higher TacIPV below the age of 6 years. TacIPV (CV%) was stable over time. A TacIPV (CV%) cutoff of 30% or IPV quantification by mean absolute deviation (MAD) showed comparable results.

CONCLUSIONS

High TacIPV is associated with an increased risk of dnDSA development and rejection episodes > year 1 posttransplant even in patients with low immunological risk profile. Therefore, in patients with high TacIPV, potential causes should be addressed, and if not resolved, changes in immunosuppressive therapy should be considered. A higher resolution version of the Graphical abstract is available as Supplementary information.

Tacrolimus trough levels in kidney transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

It is very important that kidney transplant recipients (KTRs) take immunosuppressive drugs to prevent graft rejection. This study aimed to identify the tacrolimus trough levels (TTL)-mean, TTL-standard deviation (SD), and TTL- coefficient of variation (CV) as well as factors affecting these values over a 2-year period in clinically stable patients > 5 years after kidney transplantation (KT).

METHODS

This retrospective study analyzed data from 248 adult outpatients > 5 years after KT. Medical chart data, including TTL, graft rejection, and tacrolimus dose change during a 2-year period, between January 2017 and December 2018, were collected. Multivariable regression analyses were conducted to determine the factors influencing the TTL-mean, TTL-SD, and TTL-CV.

RESULTS

The TTL-mean, TTL-SD, and TTL-CV were 6.00 ± 1.07 ng/mL, 1.51 ± 1.09 ng/mL, and 0.25 ± 0.14, respectively. The TTL-mean, TTL-SD, and TTL-CV did not differ according to sex, type of donor, retransplant, pretransplant kidney disease, body mass index, or posttransplant time; hence, they are stable in kidney transplant recipients > 5 years after KT. The higher the TTL-mean, the higher the TTL-SD. Age and the TTL-SD significantly predicted the TTL-mean (p < .001). Tacrolimus dose change and the TTL-mean significantly predicted the TTL-SD (p < .001). Tacrolimus dose change significantly predicted the TTL-CV (p = .008).

CONCLUSION

In clinically stable KTRs, TTL-SD and TTL-CV change sensitively in relation to tacrolimus dose changes. Therefore, changes in TTL-SD and TTL-CV in stable KTRs with no tacrolimus dose change require medical interest and attention.

Intrapatient Variability in Tacrolimus Trough Levels Over 2 Years Affects Long-Term Allograft Outcomes of Kidney Transplantation

This study aimed to determine the impact of tacrolimus (TAC) trough level (C0) intrapatient variability (IPV) over a period of 2 years after kidney transplantation (KT) on allograft outcomes. In total, 1,143 patients with low immunologic risk were enrolled. The time-weighted coefficient variability (TWCV) of TAC-C0 was calculated, and patients were divided into tertile groups (T1: < 24.6%, T2: 24.6%–33.7%, T3: ≥ 33.7%) according to TAC-C0-TWCV up to post-transplant 1^st year. They were classified into the low/low, low/high, high/low, and high/high groups based on a TAC-C0-TWCV value of 33.7% during post-transplant 0–1^st and 1^st–2^nd years. The allograft outcomes among the three tertile and four TAC-C0-TWCV groups were compared. The T3 group had the highest rate of death-censored allograft loss (DCGL), and T3 was considered an independent risk factor for DCGL. The low/low group had the lowest and the high/high group had the highest risk for DCGL. Moreover, patients with a mean TAC-C0 of ≥5 ng/ml in the high/high group were at the highest risk for DCGL. Thus, TAC-IPV can significantly affect allograft outcomes even with a high mean TAC-C0. Furthermore, to improve allograft outcomes, a low TAC-IPV should be maintained even after the first year of KT.

Adherence in pediatric renal recipients and its effect on graft outcome, a single-center, retrospective study

BACKGROUND

In recent years, treatment-adherence gained increasing attention in nearly every area of medicine including transplant medicine. Medication adherence following solid organ transplantation is known to be indispensable for a satisfactory allograft survival.

METHODS

We examined 60 patients between the ages of four months and 20 years who underwent kidney transplantation at Hannover Medical School between January 2011 and August 2017. Age at transplantation varied from 4 months to 20 years. 12 patients (20%) already underwent their second solid organ transplantation. 5 patients (8.3%) had a combined kidney-liver-transplantation. We used two different methods for rating adherence: An objective one based on the coefficient of variation (CoV%) of immunosuppressant trough levels, and a subjective questionnaire answered by the patients themselves, their parents or legal custodians, the treating pediatrician, as well as by the attending psychologist.

RESULTS

The CoV% in our study was by-trend higher in those patients who suffered from a biopsy-proven rejection (x̅_CoV% = 35.7, σ _CoV% = 30.1 in patients with rejection vs. x̅ _CoV% = 26.0, σ _CoV% = 10.5 in patients without rejection). Furthermore, the psychologist's assessment correlated significantly both with rejections as well as with the formation of de novo donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA) while the pediatrician's rating showed no correlation (P_rejections  = 0.005 and P_dnDSA  = 0.03 for psychologist's rating vs. P_rejections  = 0.50 and P_dnDSA  = 0.50 for pediatrician).

CONCLUSIONS

Apart from underlining the importance of medication adherence, the present research stresses the role of a multi-disciplinary treatment approach to support pediatric renal transplant recipients and their families.

Tacrolimus variability score outperforms coefficient of variation in predicting clinical outcomes of living kidney transplantation

AIMS

Intrapatient variability (IPV) was previously defined as coefficient of variation (CV) or standard deviation of tacrolimus (Tac) exposure while none of them was easily being interpreted and translated into clinical practice after kidney transplantation.

METHODS

We developed a novel Tac variability score (TVS) to evaluate IPV by calculating the frequency of clinically significant changes of Tac trough levels after kidney transplantation. Multivariate Cox proportional analyses were conducted to compare the impact of TVS and CV on transplant outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 1343 patients were divided into high TVS (>0.30) and low TVS (<0.30) groups, and low CV (<0.30) and high CV (>0.30) groups. Univariate analyses showed that high TVS (hazard ratio [HR]: 2.323, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.455-3.709) and high CV (HR: 1.606, 95%CI: 1.044-2.471) were associated with inferior graft survival. However, only TVS was an independent predictor for graft failure in multivariate analyses (HR: 1.972, 95%CI: 1.2-3.24), and the correlation maintained in high CV (P = .020) and low CV (P = .037) subgroups, while CV failed to predict graft loss in neither low (P = .387) nor high TVS (P = .600) subgroups. In addition, TVS had a higher correlation with graft survival in patients with Tac exposure within the therapeutic range and the correlation was less influenced by mean Tac trough levels.

CONCLUSION

TVS is a novel measure of Tac IPV with higher correlation with graft survival and more convenience in clinical use than CV after kidney transplantation.

Adoption of a novel smart mobile-health application technology to track chronic immunosuppression adherence in solid organ transplantation: Results of a prospective, observational, multicentre, pilot study

BACKGROUND

Low adherence to chronic immunosuppression is associated with suboptimal transplantation outcomes. Mobile-health technology is a promising tool to monitor medication adherence, but data on patient engagement to these tools are lacking.

METHODS

Prospective, observational, multicenter, 2-phase trial in kidney and liver transplant recipients, investigating the degree of engagement to TrackYourMed^® (TYM), a novel m-Health technology with a QR code-scan app to track immunosuppression adherence and its association with drug monitoring.

RESULTS

Out of 204 consecutive transplant patients, 90 patients were eligible to participate. 61 (68%) used TYM regularly, 21 (23%) never or barely used it, 5 (5.5%) were irregular users, and 3 (3.3%) were lost to follow-up. 6-month total correct intakes (CIN) ranged between 69%-76%, 12%-19% intakes were out-of-time (OUT), and 9%-12% were missed (MIS). Notably, a rate of intakes out of the scheduled time higher than 20% in the 6 days prior to blood immunosuppressant trough levels was associated with a higher intra-patient variability (17 IQR 13-21% vs. 29 IQR 23%-36%, p = .001), and with a higher dose-adjustment (p < .001). At 1 year, 53(59%) patients were still active users of TYM.

CONCLUSIONS

Implementing m-Health technologies promoting immunosuppression adherence may be useful for a relevant number of transplant patients and help transplant physicians identifying erratic immunosuppression adherence.

Tacrolimus intrapatient variability in solid organ transplantation: A multiorgan perspective

BACKGROUND

Tacrolimus therapy in solid organ transplant (SOT) recipients is challenging due to its narrow therapeutic window and pharmacokinetic variability both between patients and within a single patient. Intrapatient variability (IPV) of tacrolimus trough concentrations has become a novel marker of interest for predicting transplant outcomes. The purpose of this review is to evaluate the association of tacrolimus IPV with graft and patient outcomes and identify interventions to improve IPV in SOT recipients.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was performed using PubMed and Embase from database inception to September 20, 2020. Studies were eligible only if they evaluated an association between tacrolimus IPV and transplant outcomes. Both pediatric and adult studies were included. Measures of variability were limited to standard deviation, coefficient of variation, and time in therapeutic range.

RESULTS

Forty-four studies met the inclusion criteria. Studies were published between 2008 and 2020 and were observational in nature. Majority of data were published in adult kidney transplant recipients and identified an association with rejection, de novo donor specific antibody (dnDSA) formation, graft loss, and patient survival. Evaluation of IPV-directed interventions was limited to small preliminary studies.

CONCLUSIONS

High tacrolimus IPV has been associated with poor outcomes including acute rejection, dnDSA formation, graft loss, and patient mortality in SOT recipients. Future research should prospectively explore IPV-directed interventions to improve transplant outcomes.

Association of graft survival with tacrolimus exposure and late intra-patient tacrolimus variability in pediatric and young adult renal transplant recipients-an international CTS registry analysis

Adolescent and young adult age is a high-risk window with an alarmingly increased likelihood of premature kidney graft loss due to immunological rejection. Using the large database of the Collaborative Transplant Study, we analyzed whether a more intense and less variable exposure to tacrolimus could counteract this young age-related enhanced immunoreactivity. Kidney graft recipients aged 12-23 years (n = 964) with a 1-year tacrolimus trough level between 4.0 and 10.9 ng/ml had a 5-year graft survival rate of 85.1%, significantly better than the poor 66.1% rate in patients with a trough level below 4.0 ng/ml who showed a 2.38-fold increased risk of graft loss in the multivariable analysis (P < 0.001). This association was not apparent in young children aged 0-11 years (n = 455) and less pronounced in adults aged 24-34 years (n = 1466). However, an intra-patient variability of tacrolimus (IPV) trough level ≥1.5 at post-transplant years 1 and 2 was associated with an increased graft loss risk in both 12- to 23-year-old and 0- to 11-year-old recipients (P < 0.001 and P = 0.045). Patients with high IPV made up as many as 30% of kidney graft recipients, indicating that a more intense and less variable exposure to tacrolimus could improve graft survival strongly in this high-risk group.

Meeting Regulatory Requirements for Drugs with a Narrow Therapeutic Index: Bioequivalence Studies of Generic Once-Daily Tacrolimus

Despite growing clinical confidence in generics and their potential to reduce long-term healthcare costs, the transplant community have had real concerns about the use of generic immunosuppressants. One such immunosuppressant is tacrolimus, a cornerstone of lifelong treatment for patients who have undergone a solid organ transplant. Tacrolimus has a narrow therapeutic index (NTI), giving rise to questions about the potential for clinically relevant altered drug exposure. Its use in transplant patients also gives rise to questions about the most discriminative subject population for bioequivalence studies. The recognised need for stringent criteria to support approval of generic drugs with an NTI led the European Medicines Association and Health Canada to provide detailed information on requirements for bioequivalence studies and introduce tighter bioequivalence limits for these drugs, including tacrolimus. The aim of this article is to illustrate how regulatory guidance is implemented during the clinical development of generic immunosuppressants, using a generic, once-daily prolonged-release formulation of tacrolimus as an example.

Evidence for the alloimmune basis and prognostic significance of Borderline T cell-mediated rejection

Prognostic biomarkers of T cell-mediated rejection (TCMR) have not been adequately studied in the modern era. We evaluated 803 renal transplant recipients and correlated HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch alloimmune risk categories (low, intermediate, high) with the severity, frequency, and persistence of TCMR. Allograft survival was reduced in recipients with Banff Borderline (hazard ratio [HR] 2.4, P = .003) and Banff ≥ IA TCMR (HR 4.3, P < .0001) including a subset who never developed de novo donor-specific antibodies (P = .002). HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch alloimmune risk categories were multivariate correlates of Banff Borderline and Banff ≥ IA TCMR and correlated with the severity and frequency of rejection episodes. Recipient age, HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category, and cyclosporin vs tacrolimus immunosuppression were independent correlates of Banff Borderline and Banff ≥ IA TCMR. In the subset treated with tacrolimus (720/803) recipient age, HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category, and tacrolimus coefficient of variation were independent correlates of TCMR. The correlation of HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch category with TCMR, including Borderline, provides evidence for their alloimmune basis. HLA-DR/DQ molecular mismatch may represent a precise prognostic biomarker that can be applied to tailor immunosuppression or design clinical trials based on individual patient risk.

Impacts of High Intra- and Inter-Individual Variability in Tacrolimus Pharmacokinetics and Fast Tacrolimus Metabolism on Outcomes of Solid Organ Transplant Recipients

Tacrolimus is a first-line calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) and an integral part of the immunosuppressive strategy in solid organ transplantation. Being a dose-critical drug, tacrolimus has a narrow therapeutic index that necessitates periodic monitoring to maintain the drug’s efficacy and reduce the consequences of overexposure. Tacrolimus is characterized by substantial intra- and inter-individual pharmacokinetic variability. At steady state, the tacrolimus blood concentration to daily dose ratio (C/D ratio) has been described as a surrogate for the estimation of the individual metabolism rate, where a low C/D ratio reflects a higher rate of metabolism. Fast tacrolimus metabolism (low C/D ratio) is associated with the risk of poor outcomes after transplantation, including reduced allograft function and survival, higher allograft rejection, CNI nephrotoxicity, a faster decline in kidney function, reduced death-censored graft survival (DCGS), post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorders, dyslipidemia, hypertension, and cardiovascular events. In this article, we discuss the potential role of the C/D ratio in a noninvasive monitoring strategy for identifying patients at risk for potential adverse events post-transplant.

Relevance of donor-specific antibody monitoring after kidney transplantation: Findings from the Collaborative Transplant Study and the Heidelberg Transplant Center

Monitoring of donor-specific HLA antibodies (DSA) has become part of the clinical routine in kidney transplantation. This paper gives a brief overview on data from the Collaborative Transplant Study (CTS) and the Heidelberg Transplant Center on the clinical relevance of post-transplant DSA monitoring in patients undergoing renal transplantation. The obtained findings underline the importance of DSA monitoring in the post-operative course in immunologically high-risk patients and patients with deterioration of graft function. Especially in patients with a pre-activated immune system, a gap in the immunosuppressive therapy appear to lead to persistence, reappearance or de novo occurrence of strong, complement-activating DSA, resulting in severe antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and, without timely intervention, in AMR-related graft loss.

Predictive engines based on pharmacokinetics modelling for tacrolimus personalized dosage in paediatric renal transplant patients

The development of predictive engines based on pharmacokinetic-physiological mathematical models for personalised dosage recommendations is an immature field. Nevertheless, these models are extensively applied during the design of new drugs. This study presents new advances in this subject, through a stable population of patients who underwent kidney transplantation and were prescribed tacrolimus. We developed 2 new population pharmacokinetic models based on a compartmental approach, with one following the physiologically based pharmacokinetic approach and both including circadian modulation of absorption and clearance variables. One of the major findings was an improved predictive capability for both models thanks to the consideration of circadian rhythms, both in estimating the population and in Bayesian individual customisation. This outcome confirms a plausible mechanism suggested by other authors to explain circadian patterns of tacrolimus concentrations. We also discovered significant intrapatient variability in tacrolimus levels a week after the conversion from a fast-release (Prograf) to a sustained-release formulation (Advagraf) using adaptive optimisation techniques, despite high adherence and controlled conditions. We calculated the intrapatient variability through parametric intrapatient variations, which provides a method for quantifying the mechanisms involved. We present a first application for the analysis of bioavailability changes in formulation conversion. The 2 pharmacokinetic models have demonstrated their capability as predictive engines for personalised dosage recommendations, although the physiologically based pharmacokinetic model showed better predictive behaviour.

Transplanting the Elderly: Mandatory Age- and Minimal Histocompatibility Matching

Worldwide over 40% of patients receiving renal replacement therapy (RRT) are aged 65 years or older, a number that is still increasing. Renal transplantation is the preferred RRT, providing substantial survival benefit over those remaining on dialysis, including the elderly. Only 3% of patients aged 65 years or older accepted on the waiting list actually received a kidney transplant offer within the Eurotransplant allocation region. To increase the chance for elderly to receive a timely kidney transplant, the Eurotransplant Senior Program was introduced. The ESP supports local allocation of older kidneys to older donors in order to decrease cold ischemia time, while disregarding former exchange principles based on matching for HLA antigens. As a consequence, more elderly received a kidney transplant and a relative higher incidence of acute rejection resulted in additional courses of high steroids and/or depleting antibody therapy. Since death with a functioning graft due to infections is the dominant reason of graft loss in elderly, more intense clinical immunosuppression to prevent or treat acute rejection is not a very attractive option. Therefore in elderly kidney transplant candidates, we advocate reintroduction of minimal histocompatibility criteria (i.e., HLA-DR matching) followed by age-matching with mandatory local/regional allocation to also facilitate short cold ischemia.

Impact of low tacrolimus exposure and high tacrolimus intra-patient variability on the development of de novo anti-HLA donor-specific antibodies in kidney transplant recipients

Introduction: De novo donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA) directed against HLA are a major contributing factor to the chronic deterioration of renal allograft function. Several factors, including the degree of HLA matching, younger recipient age, and past sensitization events have been shown to increase the risk for the development of dnDSA. The development of dnDSA is also strongly associated with modifications in the immunosuppressive regimen, non-adherence, and under-immunosuppression.Areas covered: Tacrolimus is widely used after solid organ transplantation (SOT) and in recent years, both a high intra-patient variability in tacrolimus exposure and low tacrolimus exposure have been found to be associated with a higher risk of dnDSA development in kidney transplant recipients. This article provides an overview of current findings published in the recent 5 years regarding the relationship between tacrolimus exposure and variation therein and the development of dnDSA.Expert opinion: In this review, we describe how combining data on tacrolimus intra-patient variability and mean pre-dose concentration may be an effective tool to identify kidney transplant recipients who are at higher risk of developing dnDSA.

Efficacy and safety of tacrolimus in de novo pediatric transplant recipients randomized to receive immediate- or prolonged-release tacrolimus

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

This multicenter trial compared immediate-release tacrolimus (IR-T) vs prolonged-release tacrolimus (PR-T) in de novo kidney, liver, and heart transplant recipients aged <16 years. Each formulation had similar pharmacokinetic (PK) profiles. Follow-up efficacy and safety results are reported herein.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients, randomized 1:1, received once-daily, PR-T or twice-daily, IR-T within 4 days of surgery. After a 4-week PK assessment, patients continued randomized treatment for 48 additional weeks. At Year 1, efficacy assessments included the number of clinical acute rejections, biopsy-confirmed acute rejection (BCAR) episodes (including severity), patient and graft survival, and efficacy failure (composite of death, graft loss, BCAR, or unknown outcome). Adverse events were assessed throughout.

RESULTS

The study included 44 children. At Year 1, mean ± standard deviation tacrolimus trough levels were 6.6 ± 2.2 and 5.4 ± 1.6 ng/mL, and there were 2 and 7 acute rejection episodes in the PR-T and IR-T groups, respectively. No cases of graft loss or death were reported during the study. The overall efficacy failure rate was 18.2% (PR-T n = 1; IR-T n = 7).

CONCLUSIONS

In pediatric de novo solid organ recipients, the low incidence of BCAR and low efficacy failure rate suggest that PR-T-based immunosuppression is effective and well tolerated to 1-year post-transplantation.