Turning T-cell receptor ? recombination on and off: more questions than answers

scTCR-seq and HTS reveal a special novel TRBD2-TRBJ1 rearrangement in mammalian TRB CDR3 repertoire

Mammalian T cell receptor (TCR) beta-chain (TRB) V-D-J rearrangement mainly follows the "12/23 rule", and the "D-J rearrangement preceding the V-(D-J) rearrangement". Owing to the physical position of the D-J-C cluster in the TRB locus, the TRBD2 (D2) gene cannot directly perform inversional rearrangement or deletional/loop-out rearrangement with the TRBJ1 (J1) gene. Our previous studies revealed a single reverse TRBV30 (TRBV31 in mice) gene in the mammalian TRB locus, which can cause indirect rearrangement of the D2 gene and J1 gene; however, the mechanism and proportion involved in germline gene rearrangement are unknown. We obtained TRB CDR3 repertoires of thymus and peripheral tissues from humans and mice by HTS and scTCR-seq and found that 14% of the rearrangements in which the D2 gene is involved are D2-J1 rearrangements (D2-J2 rearrangements account for approximately 86%). The mechanism is that the reverse V30 gene preferentially performs inversional rearrangement with the D2 gene (V30-D2), leading to V30-D2-J1 rearrangement in humans, or the reverse V30 gene preferentially performs inversional rearrangement with the D1 gene (V30-D1), allowing the forward V genes (Vx) to perform Vx-D2-J1 rearrangement. We further found that D2-J1 rearrangements were present in more than 24% and more than 15% of the D2 gene rearrangements in rhesus monkeys and bats, respectively. Moreover, in bovine containing D1J1C1, D3J3C3, and D2J2C2 clusters, more than 11% D3-J1 and D2-J1 rearrangements and more than 22% D2-J3 rearrangements were found. This study provides a new perspective and feasible solution for further research on the significance of the special V-D-J recombination pattern in the mammalian TRB locus and the CDR3 repertoire formed by D2-J1 rearrangement.

Single-Cell Multiomics Reveals TCR Clonotype-Specific Phenotype and Stemness Heterogeneity of T-ALL Cells

T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (T-ALL) is a heterogeneous malignant disease with high relapse and mortality rates. To characterise the multiomics features of T-ALL, we conducted integrative analyses using single-cell RNA, TCR and chromatin accessibility sequencing on pre- and post-treatment peripheral blood and bone marrow samples of the same patients. We found that there is transcriptional rewiring of gene regulatory networks in T-ALL cells. Some transcription factors, such as TCF3 and KLF3, showed differences in activity and expression levels between T-ALL and normal T cells and were associated with the prognosis of T-ALL patients. Furthermore, we identified multiple malignant TCR clonotypes among the T-ALL cells, where the clonotypes consisted of distinct combinations of the same TCR α and β chain per patient. The T-ALL cells displayed clonotype-specific immature thymocyte cellular characteristics and response to chemotherapy. Remarkably, T-ALL cells with an orphan TCRβ chain displayed the strongest stemness and resistance to chemotherapy. Our study provided transcriptome and epigenome characterisation of T-ALL cells categorised by TCR clonotypes, which may be helpful for the development of novel predictive markers to evaluate treatment effectiveness for T-ALL.

HTS and scRNA-seq revealed that the location and RSS quality of the mammalian TRBV and TRBJ genes impact biased rearrangement

The quality of Recombination signal sequences (RSSs), location, and genetics of mammalian V, D, and J genes synergistically affect the recombination frequency of genes; however, the specific regulatory mechanism and efficiency have not been elucidated. By taking advantage of single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) and high-throughput sequencing (HTS) to investigate V(D)J rearrangement characteristics in the CDR3 repertoire, we found that the distal and proximal V genes (or J genes) "to D" gene were involved in rearrangement significantly more frequently than the middle V genes (or J genes) in the TRB locus among various species, including Primates (human and rhesus monkey), Rodentia (BALB/c, C57BL/6, and Kunming mice), Artiodactyla (buffalo), and Chiroptera (Rhinolophus affinis). The RSS quality of the V and J genes affected their frequency in rearrangement to varying degrees, especially when the V-RSSs with recombination signal information content (RIC) score < -45 significantly reduced the recombination frequency of the V gene. The V and J genes that were "away from D" had the dual advantages of recombinant structural accessibility and relatively high-quality RSSs, which promoted their preferential utilization in rearrangement. The quality of J-RSSs formed during mammalian evolution was apparently greater than that of V-RSSs, and the D-J distance was obviously shorter than that of V-D, which may be one of the reasons for guaranteeing that the "D-to-J preceding V-to-DJ rule" occurred when rearranged. This study provides a novel perspective on the mechanism and efficiency of V-D-J rearrangement in the mammalian TRB locus, as well as the biased utilization characteristics and application of V and J genes in the initial CDR3 repertoire.

The Cyclin D3 Protein Enforces Monogenic TCRβ Expression by Mediating TCRβ Protein-Signaled Feedback Inhibition of Vβ Recombination

In jawed vertebrates, adaptive immunity depends on the process of V(D)J recombination creating vast numbers of T and B lymphocytes that each expresses unique Ag receptors of uniform specificity. The asynchronous initiation of V-to-(D)J rearrangement between alleles and the resulting protein from one allele signaling feedback inhibition of V recombination on the other allele ensures homogeneous receptor specificity of individual cells. Upon productive Vβ-to-DβJβ rearrangements in noncycling double-negative thymocytes, TCRβ protein signals induction of the cyclin D3 protein to accelerate cell cycle entry, thereby driving proliferative expansion of developing αβ T cells. Through undetermined mechanisms, the inactivation of cyclin D3 in mice causes an increased frequency of αβ T cells that express TCRβ proteins from both alleles, producing lymphocytes of heterogeneous specificities. To determine how cyclin D3 enforces monogenic TCRβ expression, we used our mouse lines with enhanced rearrangement of specific Vβ segments due to replacement of their poor-quality recombination signal sequence (RSS) DNA elements with a better RSS. We show that cyclin D3 inactivation in these mice elevates the frequencies of αβ T cells that display proteins from RSS-augmented Vβ segments on both alleles. By assaying mature αβ T cells, we find that cyclin D3 deficiency increases the levels of Vβ rearrangements that occur within developing thymocytes. Our data demonstrate that a component of the cell cycle machinery mediates TCRβ protein-signaled feedback inhibition in thymocytes to achieve monogenic TCRβ expression and resulting uniform specificity of individual αβ T cells.

Two Successive Inversional Vβ Rearrangements on a Single Tcrb Allele Can Contribute to the TCRβ Repertoire

Mammalian TCRβ loci contain 30 Vβ gene segments upstream and in the same transcriptional orientation as two DJCβ clusters, and a downstream Vβ (TRBV31) in the opposite orientation. The textbook view is upstream Vβs rearrange only by deletion and TRBV31 rearranges only by inversion to create VβDJCβ genes. In this study, we show in mice that upstream Vβs recombine through inversion to the DJCβ2 cluster on alleles carrying a preassembled Trbv31-DJCβ1 gene. When this gene is in-frame, Trbv5 evades TCRβ-signaled feedback inhibition and recombines by inversion to the DJCβ2 cluster, creating αβ T cells that express assembled Trbv5-DJCβ2 genes. On alleles with an out-of-frame Trbv31-DJCβ1 gene, most upstream Vβs recombine at low levels and promote αβ T cell development, albeit with preferential expansion of Trbv1-DJβ2 rearrangements. Finally, we show wild-type Tcrb alleles produce mature αβ T cells that express upstream Vβ peptides in surface TCRs and carry Trbv31-DJβ2 rearrangements. Our study indicates two successive inversional Vβ-to-DJβ rearrangements on the same allele can contribute to the TCRβ repertoire.

Chromosome choice for initiation of V-(D)-J recombination is not governed by genomic imprinting

V-(D)-J recombination generates the antigen receptor diversity necessary for immune cell function, while allelic exclusion ensures that each cell expresses a single antigen receptor. V-(D)-J recombination of the Ig, Tcrb, Tcrg and Tcrd antigen receptor genes is ordered and sequential so that only one allele generates a productive rearrangement. The mechanism controlling sequential rearrangement of antigen receptor genes, in particular how only one allele is selected to initiate recombination while at least temporarily leaving the other intact, remains unresolved. Genomic imprinting, a widespread phenomenon wherein maternal or paternal allele inheritance determines allele activity, could represent a regulatory mechanism for controlling sequential V-(D)-J rearrangement. We used strain-specific single-nucleotide polymorphisms within antigen receptor genes to determine if maternal vs paternal inheritance could underlie chromosomal choice for the initiation of recombination. We found no parental chromosomal bias in the initiation of V-(D)-J recombination in T or B cells, eliminating genomic imprinting as a potential regulator for this tightly regulated process.

Distinct requirement of Runx complexes for TCRβ enhancer activation at distinct developmental stages

A TCRβ enhancer, known as the Eβ enhancer, plays a critical role in V(D)J recombination and transcription of the Tcrb gene. However, the coordinated action of trans-acting factors in the activation of Eβ during T cell development remains uncharacterized. Here, we characterized the roles of Runx complexes in the regulation of the Eβ function. A single mutation at one of the two Runx binding motifs within the Eβ severely impaired Tcrb activation at the initiation phase in immature thymocytes. However, TCRβ expression level in mature thymocytes that developed under such a single Runx site mutation was similar to that of the control. In contrast, mutations at two Runx motifs eliminated Eβ activity, demonstrating that Runx complex binding is essential to initiate Eβ activation. In cells expressing Tcrb harboring rearranged V(D)J structure, Runx complexes are dispensable to maintain TCRβ expression, whereas Eβ itself is continuously required for TCRβ expression. These findings imply that Runx complexes are essential for Eβ activation at the initiation phase, but are not necessary for maintaining Eβ activity at later developmental stages. Collectively, our results indicate that the requirements of trans-acting factor for Eβ activity are differentially regulated, depending on the developmental stage and cellular activation status.

Long-Range Control of V(D)J Recombination & Allelic Exclusion: Modeling Views

Allelic exclusion of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T-cell receptor (TCR) genes ensures the development of B and T lymphocytes operating under the mode of clonal selection. This phenomenon associates asynchronous V(D)J recombination events at Ig or TCR alleles and inhibitory feedback control. Despite years of intense research, however, the mechanisms that sustain asymmetric choice in random Ig/TCR dual allele usage and the production of Ig/TCR monoallelic expressing B and T lymphocytes remain unclear and open for debate. In this chapter, we first recapitulate the biological evidence that almost from the start appeared to link V(D)J recombination and allelic exclusion. We review the theoretical models previously proposed to explain this connection. Finally, we introduce our own mathematical modeling views based on how the developmental dynamics of individual lymphoid cells combine to sustain allelic exclusion.

Regulation of Tcrb Gene Assembly by Genetic, Epigenetic, and Topological Mechanisms

The adaptive immune system endows mammals with an ability to recognize nearly any foreign invader through antigen receptors that are expressed on the surface of all lymphocytes. This defense network is generated by V(D)J recombination, a set of sequentially controlled DNA cleavage and repair events that assemble antigen receptor genes from physically separated variable (V), joining (J), and sometimes diversity (D) gene segments. The recombination process itself must be stringently regulated to minimize oncogenic translocations involving chromosomes that harbor immunoglobulin and T cell receptor loci. Indeed, V(D)J recombination is controlled at several levels, including tissue-, developmental stage-, allele-, and gene segment-specificity. These levels of control are imposed by a collection of architectural and regulatory elements that are distributed throughout each antigen receptor locus. Together, the genetic elements regulate developmental changes in chromatin, transcription, and locus topology that promote or disfavor long-range recombination. This chapter focuses on the cross talk between these mechanisms at the T cell receptor beta (Tcrb) locus, and how they sculpt a diverse TCRβ repertoire while maintaining monospecificity of this antigen receptor on each mature T lymphocyte. We also discuss how insights obtained from studies of Tcrb are more generally relevant to our understanding of gene regulation strategies employed by mammals.

Spatial Regulation of V-(D)J Recombination at Antigen Receptor Loci

Lymphocytes express a diverse repertoire of antigen receptors, which are able to recognize a large variety of foreign pathogens. Functional antigen receptor genes are assembled by V(D)J recombination in immature B cells (Igh and Igk) and T cells (Tcr b and Tcra/d). V(D)J recombination takes place in the 3' proximal domain containing the D, J, and C gene segments, whereas 31 (Tcrb) to 200 (Igh) V genes are spread over a large region of 0.67 (Tcrb) to 3 (Igk) megabase pairs. The spatial regulation of V(D)J recombination has been best studied for the Igh locus, which undergoes reversible contraction by long-range looping in pro-B cells. This large-scale contraction brings distantly located VH genes into close proximity of the DJH-rearranged gene segment, which facilitates VH-DJH recombination. The B-cell-specific Pax5, ubiquitous YY1, and architectural CTCF/cohesin proteins regulate Igh locus contraction in pro-B cells by binding to multiple sites in the VH gene cluster. These regulators also control the pro-B-cell-specific activity of the distally located PAIR elements, which may be involved in the regulation of VH-DJH recombination by promoting locus contraction. Moreover, the large VH gene cluster of the Igh locus undergoes flexible long-range looping, which guarantees similar participation of all VH genes in VH-DJH recombination to generate a diverse antibody repertoire. Importantly, long-range looping is a more general regulatory principle, as other antigen receptor loci also undergo reversible contraction at the developmental stage, where they engage in V-(D)J recombination.

KDEL receptor 1 regulates T-cell homeostasis via PP1 that is a key phosphatase for ISR

KDEL receptors are responsible for retrotransporting endoplasmic reticulum (ER) chaperones from the Golgi complex to the ER. Here we describe a role for KDEL receptor 1 (KDELR1) that involves the regulation of integrated stress responses (ISR) in T cells. Designing and using an N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU)-mutant mouse line, T-Red (naïve T-cell reduced), we show that a point mutation in KDELR1 is responsible for the reduction in the number of naïve T cells in this model owing to an increase in ISR. Mechanistic analysis shows that KDELR1 directly regulates protein phosphatase 1 (PP1), a key phosphatase for ISR in naïve T cells. T-Red KDELR1 does not associate with PP1, resulting in reduced phosphatase activity against eIF2α and subsequent expression of stress responsive genes including the proapoptotic factor Bim. These results demonstrate that KDELR1 regulates naïve T-cell homeostasis by controlling ISR.

KDEL receptors are known to be involved in retrotransporting chaperones to the endoplasmic reticulum from the Golgi complex. Here the authors unravel a role of KDEL receptor 1 in regulating integrated stress responses in naïve T cells through its association with protein phosphatase 1.

Transcription-dependent generation of a specialized chromatin structure at the TCRβ locus

V(D)J recombination assembles Ag receptor genes during lymphocyte development. Enhancers at AR loci are known to control V(D)J recombination at associated alleles, in part by increasing chromatin accessibility of the locus, to allow the recombination machinery to gain access to its chromosomal substrates. However, whether there is a specific mechanism to induce chromatin accessibility at AR loci is still unclear. In this article, we highlight a specialized epigenetic marking characterized by high and extended H3K4me3 levels throughout the Dβ-Jβ-Cβ gene segments. We show that extended H3K4 trimethylation at the Tcrb locus depends on RNA polymerase II (Pol II)-mediated transcription. Furthermore, we found that the genomic regions encompassing the two DJCβ clusters are highly enriched for Ser(5)-phosphorylated Pol II and short-RNA transcripts, two hallmarks of transcription initiation and early transcription. Of interest, these features are shared with few other tissue-specific genes. We propose that the entire DJCβ regions behave as transcription "initiation" platforms, therefore linking a specialized mechanism of Pol II transcription with extended H3K4 trimethylation and highly accessible Dβ and Jβ gene segments.

Human Peripheral CD4(+) Vδ1(+) γδT Cells Can Develop into αβT Cells

The lifelong generation of αβT cells enables us to continuously build immunity against pathogens and malignancies despite the loss of thymic function with age. Homeostatic proliferation of post-thymic naïve and memory T cells and their transition into effector and long-lived memory cells balance the decreasing output of naïve T cells, and recent research suggests that also αβT-cell development independent from the thymus may occur. However, the sites and mechanisms of extrathymic T-cell development are not yet understood in detail. γδT cells represent a small fraction of the overall T-cell pool, and are endowed with tremendous phenotypic and functional plasticity. γδT cells that express the Vδ1 gene segment are a minor population in human peripheral blood but predominate in epithelial (and inflamed) tissues. Here, we characterize a CD4⁺ peripheral Vδ1⁺ γδT-cell subpopulation that expresses stem-cell and progenitor markers and is able to develop into functional αβT cells ex vivo in a simple culture system and in vivo. The route taken by this process resembles thymic T-cell development. However, it involves the re-organization of the Vδ1⁺ γδTCR into the αβTCR as a consequence of TCR-γ chain downregulation and the expression of surface Vδ1⁺Vβ⁺ TCR components, which we believe function as surrogate pre-TCR. This transdifferentiation process is readily detectable in vivo in inflamed tissue. Our study provides a conceptual framework for extrathymic T-cell development and opens up a new vista in immunology that requires adaptive immune responses in infection, autoimmunity, and cancer to be reconsidered.

Lineage-specific compaction of Tcrb requires a chromatin barrier to protect the function of a long-range tethering element

Majumder et al. explore the large-scale looping architecture of the Tcrb locus early in murine thymocyte development during the generation of TCRβ diversity. They dissect novel DNA regulatory elements controlling V to D-J recombination and identify within an insulator region a distally located CTCF-containing element functioning as a tether, which facilitates looping of distal Vβ to Dβ-Jβ regions and promotes locus contraction. A second CTCF-containing element, proximal to the Dβ-Jβ region, acts as a boundary, preventing the spread of active chromatin associated with Dβ-Jβ regions. Removal of the proximal boundary element impairs the locus contraction capabilities of the tethering element.

Gene regulation relies on dynamic changes in three-dimensional chromatin conformation, which are shaped by composite regulatory and architectural elements. However, mechanisms that govern such conformational switches within chromosomal domains remain unknown. We identify a novel mechanism by which cis-elements promote long-range interactions, inducing conformational changes critical for diversification of the TCRβ antigen receptor locus (Tcrb). Association between distal Vβ gene segments and the highly expressed DβJβ clusters, termed the recombination center (RC), is independent of enhancer function and recruitment of V(D)J recombinase. Instead, we find that tissue-specific folding of Tcrb relies on two distinct architectural elements located upstream of the RC. The first, a CTCF-containing element, directly tethers distal portions of the Vβ array to the RC. The second element is a chromatin barrier that protects the tether from hyperactive RC chromatin. When the second element is removed, active RC chromatin spreads upstream, forcing the tether to serve as a new barrier. Acquisition of barrier function by the CTCF element disrupts contacts between distal Vβ gene segments and significantly alters Tcrb repertoires. Our findings reveal a separation of function for RC-flanking regions, in which anchors for long-range recombination must be cordoned off from hyperactive RC landscapes by chromatin barriers.

The ataxia telangiectasia mutated and cyclin D3 proteins cooperate to help enforce TCRβ and IgH allelic exclusion

Coordination of V rearrangements between loci on homologous chromosomes is critical for Ig and TCR allelic exclusion. The Ataxia Telangietasia mutated (ATM) protein kinase promotes DNA repair and activates checkpoints to suppress aberrant Ig and TCR rearrangements. In response to RAG cleavage of Igκ loci, ATM inhibits RAG expression and suppresses further Vκ-to-Jκ rearrangements to enforce Igκ allelic exclusion. Because V recombination between alleles is more strictly regulated for TCRβ and IgH loci, we evaluated the ability of ATM to restrict biallelic expression and V-to-DJ recombination of TCRβ and IgH genes. We detected greater frequencies of lymphocytes with biallelic expression or aberrant V-to-DJ rearrangement of TCRβ or IgH loci in mice lacking ATM. A preassembled DJβ complex that decreases the number of TCRβ rearrangements needed for a productive TCRβ gene further increased frequencies of ATM-deficient cells with biallelic TCRβ expression. IgH and TCRβ proteins drive proliferation of prolymphocytes through cyclin D3 (Ccnd3), which also inhibits VH transcription. We show that inactivation of Ccnd3 leads to increased frequencies of lymphocytes with biallelic expression of IgH or TCRβ genes. We also show that Ccnd3 inactivation cooperates with ATM deficiency to increase the frequencies of cells with biallelic TCRβ or IgH expression while decreasing the frequency of ATM-deficient lymphocytes with aberrant V-to-DJ recombination. Our data demonstrate that core components of the DNA damage response and cell cycle machinery cooperate to help enforce IgH and TCRβ allelic exclusion and indicate that control of V-to-DJ rearrangements between alleles is important to maintain genomic stability.

Epigenetics and the adaptive immune response

Cells of the adaptive immune response undergo dynamic epigenetic changes as they develop and respond to immune challenge. Plasticity is a necessary prerequisite for the chromosomal dynamics of lineage specification, development, and the immune effector function of the mature cell types. The alterations in DNA methylation and histone modification that characterize activation may be integral to the generation of immunologic memory, thereby providing an advantage on secondary exposure to pathogens. While the immune system benefits from the dynamic nature of the epigenome, such benefit comes at a cost - increased likelihood of disease-causing mutation.

Regulation of TCRβ allelic exclusion by gene segment proximity and accessibility

Ag receptor loci are regulated to promote allelic exclusion, but the mechanisms are not well understood. Assembly of a functional TCR β-chain gene triggers feedback inhibition of V(β)-to-DJ(β) recombination in double-positive (DP) thymocytes, which correlates with reduced V(β) chromatin accessibility and a locus conformational change that separates V(β) from DJ(β) gene segments. We previously generated a Tcrb allele that maintained V(β) accessibility but was still subject to feedback inhibition in DP thymocytes. We have now further analyzed the contributions of chromatin accessibility and locus conformation to feedback inhibition using two novel TCR alleles. We show that reduced V(β) accessibility and increased distance between V(β) and DJ(β) gene segments both enforce feedback inhibition in DP thymocytes.

Differential regulation of proximal and distal Vbeta segments upstream of a functional VDJbeta1 rearrangement upon beta-selection

Developmental stage-specific regulation of transcriptional accessibility helps control V(D)J recombination. Vβ segments on unrearranged TCRβ alleles are accessible in CD4(-)/CD8(-) (double-negative [DN]) thymocytes, when they recombine, and inaccessible in CD4(+)/CD8(+) (double-positive [DP]) thymocytes, when they do not rearrange. Downregulation of Vβ accessibility on unrearranged alleles is linked with Lat-dependent β-selection signals that inhibit Vβ rearrangement, stimulate Ccnd3-driven proliferation, and promote DN-to-DP differentiation. Transcription and recombination of Vβs on VDJβ-rearranged alleles in DN cells has not been studied; Vβs upstream of functional VDJβ rearrangements have been found to remain accessible, yet not recombine, in DP cells. To elucidate contributions of β-selection signals in regulating Vβ transcription and recombination on VDJβ-rearranged alleles, we analyzed wild-type, Ccnd3(-/-), and Lat(-/-) mice containing a preassembled functional Vβ1DJCβ1 (Vβ1(NT)) gene. Vβ10 segments located just upstream of this VDJCβ1 gene were the predominant germline Vβs that rearranged in Vβ1(NT/NT) and Vβ1(NT/NT)Ccnd3(-/-) thymocytes, whereas Vβ4 and Vβ16 segments located further upstream rearranged at similar levels as Vβ10 in Vβ1(NT/NT)Lat(-/-) DN cells. We previously showed that Vβ4 and Vβ16, but not Vβ10, are transcribed on Vβ1(NT) alleles in DP thymocytes; we now demonstrate that Vβ4, Vβ16, and Vβ10 are transcribed at similar levels in Vβ1(NT/NT)Lat(-/-) DN cells. These observations indicate that suppression of Vβ rearrangements is not dependent on Ccnd3-driven proliferation, and DN residence can influence the repertoire of Vβs that recombine on alleles containing an assembled VDJCβ1 gene. Our findings also reveal that β-selection can differentially silence rearrangement of germline Vβ segments located proximal and distal to functional VDJβ genes.

Epigenetic control of Tcrb gene rearrangement

V(D)J recombination assembles antigen receptor genes from germline V, D and J segments during lymphocyte development. In αβT-cells, this leads to the subsequent expression of T-cell receptor (TCR) β and α chains. Generally, V(D)J recombination is closely controlled at various levels, including cell-type and cell-stage specificities, order of locus/gene segment recombination, and allele usage to mediate allelic exclusion. Many of these controls rely on the modulation of gene accessibility to the recombination machinery, involving not only biochemical changes in chromatin arrangement and structural modifications of chromosomal organization and positioning, but also the refined composition of the recombinase targets, the so-called recombination signal sequences. Here, we summarize current knowledge regarding the regulation of V(D)J recombination at the Tcrb gene locus, certainly one for which these various levels of control and regulatory components have been most extensively investigated.

Position-dependent silencing of germline Vß segments on TCRß alleles containing preassembled VßDJßCß1 genes

The genomic organization of TCRbeta loci enables Vbeta-to-DJbeta2 rearrangements on alleles with assembled VbetaDJbetaCbeta1 genes, which could have deleterious physiologic consequences. To determine whether such Vbeta rearrangements occur and, if so, how they might be regulated, we analyzed mice with TCRbeta alleles containing preassembled functional VbetaDJbetaCbeta1 genes. Vbeta10 segments were transcribed, rearranged, and expressed in thymocytes when located immediately upstream of a Vbeta1DJbetaCbeta1 gene, but not on alleles with a Vbeta14DJbetaCbeta1 gene. Germline Vbeta10 transcription was silenced in mature alphabeta T cells. This allele-dependent and developmental stage-specific silencing of Vbeta10 correlated with increased CpG methylation and decreased histone acetylation over the Vbeta10 promoter and coding region. Transcription, rearrangement, and expression of the Vbeta4 and Vbeta16 segments located upstream of Vbeta10 were silenced on alleles containing either VbetaDJbetaCbeta1 gene; sequences within Vbeta4, Vbeta16, and the Vbeta4/Vbeta16-Vbeta10 intergenic region exhibited constitutive high CpG methylation and low histone acetylation. Collectively, our data indicate that the position of Vbeta segments relative to assembled VbetaDJbetaCbeta1 genes influences their rearrangement and suggest that DNA sequences between Vbeta segments may form boundaries between active and inactive Vbeta chromatin domains upstream of VbetaDJbetaCbeta genes.

TCR beta allelic exclusion in dynamical models of V(D)J recombination based on allele independence

Allelic exclusion represents a major aspect of TCRbeta gene assembly by V(D)J recombination in developing T lymphocytes. Despite recent progress, its comprehension remains problematic when confronted with experimental data. Existing models fall short in terms of incorporating into a unique distribution all the cell subsets emerging from the TCRbeta assembly process. To revise this issue, we propose dynamical, continuous-time Markov chain-based modeling whereby essential steps in the biological procedure (D-J and V-DJ rearrangements and feedback inhibition) evolve independently on the two TCRbeta alleles in every single cell while displaying random modes of initiation and duration. By selecting parameters via fitting procedures, we demonstrate the capacity of the model to offer accurate fractions of all distinct TCRbeta genotypes observed in studies using developing and mature T cells from wild-type or mutant mice. Selected parameters in turn afford relative duration for each given step, hence updating TCRbeta recombination distinctive timings. Overall, our dynamical modeling integrating allele independence and noise in recombination and feedback-inhibition events illustrates how the combination of these ingredients alone may enforce allelic exclusion at the TCRbeta locus.

Posttranscriptional silencing of VbetaDJbetaCbeta genes contributes to TCRbeta allelic exclusion in mammalian lymphocytes

Feedback inhibition of V(D)J recombination enforces Ag receptor allelic exclusion in mammalian lymphocytes. Yet, in-frame VbetaDJbeta exons can assemble on both alleles in human and mouse alphabeta T lineage cells. To elucidate mechanisms that enforce TCRbeta allelic exclusion in such cells, we analyzed Vbeta expression and rearrangement in mice containing a functional Vbeta14DJbeta1.5Cbeta1 gene (Vbeta14(NT)) and/or Vbeta8.2DJbeta1.1Cbeta1 transgene (Vbeta8(Tg)). The majority of Vbeta14(NT) and Vbeta8(Tg) alphabeta T lineage cells expressed only Vbeta14(+) or Vbeta8(+) TCRbeta-chains, respectively, and lacked Vbeta rearrangements on wild-type TCRbeta loci. However, endogenous Vbeta rearrangements and alphabeta T lineage cells expressing endogenous Vbetas from wild-type alleles alone or with the prerearranged Vbeta in cell surface TCRbeta-chains were observed in Vbeta14(NT) and Vbeta8(Tg) mice. Although nearly all Vbeta8(Tg):Vbeta14(NT) thymocytes and splenic alphabeta T cells expressed Vbeta8(+) TCRbeta-chains, only half of these lymphocytes expressed Vbeta14(+) TCRbeta-chains, even though similar steady-state levels of Vbeta14(NT) mRNA were expressed in Vbeta8(+)Vbeta14(+) and Vbeta8(+)Vbeta14(-) populations. Our data demonstrated that posttranscriptional silencing of functionally assembled endogenous VbetaDJbetaCbeta genes can enforce TCRbeta allelic exclusion and reveal another mechanism that contributes to the development of lymphocytes with monospecific Ag receptors.

Epigenetic regulation of antigen receptor gene rearrangement

V(D)J recombination assembles antigen-specific immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor variable region genes from germline V, D, and J segments during lymphocyte development. Regulation of this site-specific DNA rearrangement process occurs with respect to the cell type and stage of differentiation, order of locus recombination, and allele usage. Many of these controls are mediated via the modulation of gene accessibility to the V(D)J recombinase. Here, we summarise recent advances regarding the impact of nuclear organisation and epigenetic-based mechanisms on the regulation of V(D)J recombination.

TCR beta feedback signals inhibit the coupling of recombinationally accessible V beta 14 segments with DJ beta complexes

Ag receptor allelic exclusion is thought to occur through monoallelic initiation and subsequent feedback inhibition of recombinational accessibility. However, our previous analysis of mice containing a V(D)J recombination reporter inserted into Vbeta14 (Vbeta14(Rep)) indicated that Vbeta14 chromatin accessibility is biallelic. To determine whether Vbeta14 recombinational accessibility is subject to feedback inhibition, we analyzed TCRbeta rearrangements in Vbeta14(Rep) mice containing a preassembled in-frame transgenic Vbeta8.2Dbeta1Jbeta1.1 or an endogenous Vbeta14Dbeta1Jbeta1.4 rearrangement on the homologous chromosome. Expression of either preassembled VbetaDJbetaC beta-chain accelerated thymocyte development because of enhanced cellular selection, demonstrating that the rate-limiting step in early alphabeta T cell development is the assembly of an in-frame VbetaDJbeta rearrangement. Expression of these preassembled VbetaDJbeta rearrangements inhibited endogenous Vbeta14-to-DJbeta rearrangements as expected. However, in contrast to results predicted by the accepted model of TCRbeta feedback inhibition, we found that expression of these preassembled TCR beta-chains did not downregulate recombinational accessibility of Vbeta14 chromatin. Our findings suggest that TCRbeta-mediated feedback inhibition of Vbeta14 rearrangements depends on inherent properties of Vbeta14, Dbeta, and Jbeta recombination signal sequences.

The structure and functional analysis of canine T-cell receptor beta region

VDJ recombination is a key process in T-cell receptor (TCR) and immunoglobulin (Ig) molecules development. Comparison of ENSEMBL and GenBank database information revealed major differences in dog T-cell receptor beta (TRB) region annotations. ENSEMBL based genomic alignment of dog TRB sequence with human sequence and annotation showed a very similar structure of TRB. However, there is only one cluster of DJC segments in dogs. In dog, 38 V segments are followed by 1 D segment, 6 J segments and 1 C segment. Like humans and mice, dogs have another V segment opposite in orientation downstream of the C segment. V segments anticipated were analyzed using the RT-PCR and capillary electrophoresis. Thirty-one of them were identified in samples of thymus and spleen RNA and thus believed to be subjected to chromosomal rearrangement and RNA splicing. We identified and analyzed probable structure of canine TCR beta region, which is different when compared to sequences published in GenBank or ENSEMBL databases.

Mechanics of T cell receptor gene rearrangement

The four T cell receptor genes (Tcra, Tcrb, Tcrg, Tcrd) are assembled by V(D)J recombination according to distinct programs during intrathymic T cell development. These programs depend on genetic factors, including gene segment order and recombination signal sequences. They also depend on epigenetic factors. Regulated changes in chromatin structure, directed by enhancers and promoter, can modify the availability of recombination signal sequences to the RAG recombinase. Regulated changes in locus conformation may control the synapsis of distant recombination signal sequences, and regulated changes in subnuclear positioning may influence locus recombination events by unknown mechanisms. Together these influences may explain the ordered activation and inactivation of T cell receptor locus recombination events and the phenomenon of Tcrb allelic exclusion.

Initiation of V(D)J recombination by Dbeta-associated recombination signal sequences: a critical control point in TCRbeta gene assembly

T cell receptor (TCR) β gene assembly by V(D)J recombination proceeds via successive Dβ-to-Jβ and Vβ-to-DJβ rearrangements. This two-step process is enforced by a constraint, termed beyond (B)12/23, which prohibits direct Vβ-to-Jβ rearrangements. However the B12/23 restriction does not explain the order of TCRβ assembly for which the regulation remains an unresolved issue. The initiation of V(D)J recombination consists of the introduction of single-strand DNA nicks at recombination signal sequences (RSSs) containing a 12 base-pairs spacer. An RSS containing a 23 base-pairs spacer is then captured to form a 12/23 RSSs synapse leading to coupled DNA cleavage. Herein, we probed RSS nicks at the TCRβ locus and found that nicks were only detectable at Dβ-associated RSSs. This pattern implies that Dβ 12RSS and, unexpectedly, Dβ 23RSS initiate V(D)J recombination and capture their respective Vβ or Jβ RSS partner. Using both in vitro and in vivo assays, we further demonstrate that the Dβ1 23RSS impedes cleavage at the adjacent Dβ1 12RSS and consequently Vβ-to-Dβ1 rearrangement first requires the Dβ1 23RSS excision. Altogether, our results provide the molecular explanation to the B12/23 constraint and also uncover a ‘Dβ1 23RSS-mediated’ restriction operating beyond chromatin accessibility, which directs Dβ1 ordered rearrangements.

Early steps of V(D)J rearrangement: insights from biochemical studies of RAG-RSS complexes

V(D)J recombination is initiated by the synapsis and cleavage of a complementary (12/23) pair of recombination signal sequences (RSSs) by the RAG1 and RAG2 proteins. Our understanding of these processes has been greatly aided by the development of in vitro biochemical assays of RAG binding and cleavage activity. Accumulating evidence suggests that synaptic complex assembly occurs in a step-wise manner and that the RAG proteins catalyze RSS cleavage by mechanisms similar to those used by bacterial transposases. In this chapter we will review the molecular mechanisms of RAG synaptic complex assembly and 12/23-regulated RSS cleavage, focusing on recent advances that shed new light on these processes.

Vbeta cluster sequences reduce the frequency of primary Vbeta2 and Vbeta14 rearrangements

T-cell receptor (TCR) beta variable region exons are assembled from numerous gene segments in a highly ordered and regulated manner. To elucidate mechanisms and identify cis-acting elements that control Vbeta rearrangement, we generated an endogenous TCR-beta allele with only the Vbeta2, Vbeta4, and Vbeta14 segments. We found that alphabeta T lineage cells containing this Vbeta(2-4-14) allele and a wild-type TCR-beta allele developed normally, but exhibited a significant increase in Vbeta2(+) and Vbeta14(+) cells. To quantify Vbeta rearrangements on the Vbeta(2-4-14) allele, we generated alphabeta T-cell hybridomas and analyzed TCR-beta rearrangements. Despite the deletion of almost all Vbeta segments and 234 kb of Vbeta cluster sequences, the Vbeta(2-4-14) allele exhibited only a slight decrease in Vbeta rearrangement as compared with the wild-type TCR-beta allele. Thus, cis-acting control elements essential for directing Vbeta rearrangement across large chromosomal distances are not located within the Vbeta cluster. We also found a significant increase in the frequency of Vbeta rearrangements involving Vbeta2 and Vbeta14, but not Vbeta4, on the Vbeta(2-4-14) allele. Collectively, our data suggest that Vbeta cluster sequences reduce the frequency of Vbeta2 and Vbeta14 rearrangements by competing with the productive coupling of accessible Vbeta2 and Vbeta14 segments with DJbeta1 complexes.

Regulation of Tcrb recombination ordering by c-Fos-dependent RAG deposition

Antigen receptor variable-(diversity)-joining (V(D)J) recombination at the locus encoding the T cell antigen receptor-beta (Tcrb) is ordered, with D(beta)-to-J(beta) assembly preceding V(beta)-to-DJ(beta) joining. The molecular mechanism underlying this 'preferred' order of rearrangement remains unclear. Here we show that the D(beta) 23-base pair recombination signal sequence (D(beta) 23-RSS) contains a specific AP-1 transcription factor-binding site bound by AP-1 and its component c-Fos expressed at a specific stage. Cell-based recombination assays suggested that c-Fos interacted directly with the RAG recombinase and enhanced its deposition to D(beta) 23-RSSs, thus conferring the priority of DJ(beta) recombination. Loss of c-Fos decreased Tcrb recombination efficiency and disrupted recombination ordering in vivo. Our results show an unexpected function for c-Fos as a direct regulator of Tcrb recombination, rather than its usual function as a transcription regulator, and provide new insight into the mechanisms of recombination ordering.

Initiation of allelic exclusion by stochastic interaction of Tcrb alleles with repressive nuclear compartments

Studies of antigen-receptor loci have linked directed monoallelic association with pericentromeric heterochromatin to the initiation or maintenance of allelic exclusion. Here we provide evidence for a fundamentally different basis for T cell antigen receptor-beta (Tcrb) allelic exclusion. Using three-dimensional immunofluorescence in situ hybridization, we found that germline Tcrb alleles associated stochastically and at high frequency with the nuclear lamina or with pericentromeric heterochromatin in developing thymocytes and that such interactions inhibited variable-to-diversity-joining (V(beta)-to-D(beta)J(beta)) recombination before beta-selection. The introduction of an ectopic enhancer into Tcrb resulted in fewer such interactions and impaired allelic exclusion. We propose that initial V(beta)-to-D(beta)J(beta) recombination events are generally monoallelic in developing thymocytes because of frequent stochastic, rather than directed, interactions of Tcrb alleles with repressive nuclear compartments. Such interactions may be essential for Tcrb allelic exclusion.

Productive coupling of accessible Vbeta14 segments and DJbeta complexes determines the frequency of Vbeta14 rearrangement

To elucidate mechanisms that regulate Vbeta rearrangement, we generated and analyzed mice with a V(D)J recombination reporter cassette of germline Dbeta-Jbeta segments inserted into the endogenous Vbeta14 locus (Vbeta14(Rep)). As a control, we first generated and analyzed mice with the same Dbeta-Jbeta cassette targeted into the generally expressed c-myc locus (c-myc(Rep)). Substantial c-myc(Rep) recombination occurred in both T and B cells and initiated concurrently with endogenous Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangements in thymocytes. In contrast, Vbeta14(Rep) recombination was restricted to T cells and initiated after endogenous Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangements, but concurrently with endogenous Vbeta14 rearrangements. Thus, the local chromatin environment imparts lineage and developmental stage-specific accessibility upon the inserted reporter. Although Vbeta14 rearrangements occur on only 5% of endogenous TCRbeta alleles, the Vbeta14(Rep) cassette underwent rearrangement on 80-90% of alleles, supporting the suggestion that productive coupling of accessible Vbeta14 segments and DJbeta complexes influence the frequency of Vbeta14 rearrangements. Strikingly, Vbeta14(Rep) recombination also occurs on TCRbeta alleles lacking endogenous Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangements, indicating that Vbeta14 accessibility per se is not subject to allelic exclusion.

A critical lineage-nonspecific role for pTalpha in mediating allelic and isotypic exclusion in TCRbeta-transgenic mice

Although it is well established that early expression of TCRbeta transgenes in the thymus leads to efficient inhibition of both endogenous TCRbeta and TCRgamma rearrangement (also known as allelic and "isotypic" exclusion, respectively) the role of pTalpha in these processes remains controversial. Here, we have systematically re-evaluated this issue using three independent strains of TCRbeta-transgenic mice that differ widely in transgene expression levels, and a sensitive intracellular staining assay that detects endogenous TCRVbeta expression in individual immature thymocytes. In the absence of pTalpha, both allelic and isotypic exclusion were reversed in all three TCRbeta-transgenic strains, clearly demonstrating a general requirement for pre-TCR signaling in the inhibition of endogenous TCRbeta and TCRgamma rearrangement. Both allelic and isotypic exclusion were pTalpha dose dependent when transgenic TCRbeta levels were subphysiological. Moreover, pTalpha-dependent allelic and isotypic exclusion occurred in both alphabeta and gammadelta T cell lineages, indicating that pre-TCR signaling can potentially be functional in gammadelta precursors. Finally, levels of endogenous RAG1 and RAG2 were not down-regulated in TCRbeta-transgenic immature thymocytes undergoing allelic or isotypic exclusion. Collectively, our data reveal a critical but lineage-nonspecific role for pTalpha in mediating both allelic and isotypic exclusion in TCRbeta-transgenic mice.

Expression of T-cell receptor genes during early T-cell development

Lymphoid cell development is an ordered process that begins in the embryo in specific sites and progresses through multiple differentiative steps to production of T- and B-cells. Lymphoid cell production is marked by the rearrangement process, which gives rise to mature cells expressing antigen-specific T-cell receptors (TCR) and immunoglobulins (Ig). While most transcripts arising from TCR or Ig loci reflect fully rearranged genes, germline transcripts have been identified, but these have always been thought to have no specific purpose. Germline transcription from either unrearranged TCR or unrearranged Ig loci was commonly associated with an open chromatin configuration during VDJ recombination. Since only early T and B cells undergo rearrangement, the association of germline transcription with the rearrangement process has served as an appropriate explanation for expression of these transcripts in early T- and B-cell progenitors. However, germline TCR-V beta 8.2 transcripts have now been identified in cells from RAG(-/-) mice, in the absence of the VDJ rearrangement event and recombinase activity. Recent data now suggest that germline TCR-V beta transcription is a developmentally regulated lymphoid cell phenomenon. Germline transcripts could also encode a protein that plays a functional role during lymphoid cell development. In the least, germline transcripts serve as markers of early lymphoid progenitors.

T cell development: better living through chromatin

T lymphocyte development is directed by a gene-expression program that occurs in the complex nucleoprotein environment of chromatin. This review examines basic principles of chromatin regulation and evaluates ongoing progress toward understanding how the chromatin template is manipulated to control gene expression and gene recombination in developing thymocytes. Special attention is devoted to the loci encoding T cell receptors alpha and beta, T cell coreceptors CD4 and CD8, and the enzyme terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase. The properties of SATB1, a notable organizer of thymocyte chromatin, are also addressed.

Reversible contraction by looping of the Tcra and Tcrb loci in rearranging thymocytes

Reversible contraction of immunoglobulin loci juxtaposes the variable (V) genes next to the (diversity)-joining-constant ((D)JC) gene domain, thus facilitating V-(D)J recombination. Here we show that the T cell receptor beta (Tcrb) and T cell receptor alphadelta (Tcra-Tcrd) loci also underwent long-range interactions by looping in double-negative and double-positive thymocytes, respectively. Contraction of the Tcrb and Tcra loci occurred in rearranging thymocytes and was reversed at the next developmental stage. Decontraction of the Tcrb locus probably prevented further V(beta)-DJ(beta) rearrangements in double-positive thymocytes by separating the V(beta) genes from the DJC(beta) domain. In most double-negative cells, one Tcrb allele was recruited to pericentromeric heterochromatin. Such allelic positioning may facilitate asynchronous V(beta)-DJ(beta) recombination. Hence, pericentromeric recruitment and locus 'decontraction' seem to contribute to the initiation and maintenance of allelic exclusion at the Tcrb locus.

Restriction of endogenous T cell antigen receptor beta rearrangements to Vbeta14 through selective recombination signal sequence modifications

T cell antigen receptor (TCR)beta V(D)J variable region exon assembly is ordered, with Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangements occurring before joining of Vbetas to a DJbeta complex. Germ-line V(D)J segments are flanked by recombination signal (RS) sequences, which consist of heptamers and nonamers separated by a spacer of 12 (12-RS) or 23 (23-RS) bp. V(D)J recombination is restricted by the 12/23 rule; joining occurs only between gene segments flanked by 12-RSs and 23-RSs. Vbeta segments have 23-RSs and Jbeta segments 12-RSs, which based on the 12/23 rule should allow direct joining. However, Vbeta segments rearrange only to DJbeta complexes and not Jbeta segments, because of restrictions beyond 12/23 (B12/23) that make the Vbeta23-RS incompatible with the Jbeta12-RS. To determine whether direct Vbeta to Jbeta joining occurs if flanking RSs are B12/23 compatible, we generated mice whose lymphocytes contained replacement of the Vbeta1412-RS with the 3'Dbeta112-RS on a TCRbeta allele lacking Dbeta segments (the Jbeta1(M6) allele). Mice heterozygous for the Jbeta1(M6) allele had dramatically increased Vbeta14(+) thymocyte and T cell numbers and decreased numbers of cells expressing other Vbetas. This altered Vbeta repertoire resulted from direct Vbeta14 to Jbeta1 rearrangements on the Jbeta1(M6) allele. Mice harboring lymphocytes homozygous for Jbeta1(M6) allele developed normal thymocyte and T cell numbers with all expressing Vbeta14. Our findings show that selective RS modifications enforce rearrangement of a specific Vbeta gene segment and demonstrate the importance of B12/23 mechanisms for ensuring generation of diverse TCRbeta repertoires.

ATM deficiency disrupts Tcra locus integrity and the maturation of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes

Mutations in ATM (ataxia-telangiectasia mutated) cause ataxia-telangiectasia (AT), a disease characterized by neurodegeneration, sterility, immunodeficiency, and T-cell leukemia. Defective ATM-mediated DNA damage responses underlie many aspects of the AT syndrome, but the basis for the immune deficiency has not been defined. ATM associates with DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), and some evidence suggests that ATM may regulate V(D)J recombination. However, it remains unclear how ATM loss compromises lymphocyte development in vivo. Here, we show that T-cell receptor β (TCRβ)–dependent proliferation and production of TCRβlow CD4+CD8+ (DP) thymocytes occurred normally in Atm−/− mice. In striking contrast, the postmitotic maturation of TCRβlow DP precursors into TCRβint DP cells and TCRβhi mature thymocytes was profoundly impaired. Furthermore, Atm−/− thymocytes expressed abnormally low amounts of TCRα mRNA and protein. These defects were not attributable to the induction of a BCL-2–sensitive apoptotic pathway. Rather, they were associated with frequent biallelic loss of distal Va gene segments in DP thymocytes, revealing that ATM maintains Tcra locus integrity as it undergoes V(D)J recombination. Collectively, our data demonstrate that ATM loss increases the frequency of aberrant Tcra deletion events, which compromise DP thymocyte maturation and likely promote the generation of oncogenic TCR translocations.