Fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of orbital masses: a critical review of 51 cases

Primary lacrimal sac melanoma: a case report describing the novel use of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) for diagnosis, together with literature review and immunotherapy treatment update

Primary lacrimal sac melanoma (PLSM) is exceedingly rare and associated with high morbidity and mortality. Unfortunately, PLSM often presents insidiously resulting in delayed detection and poor prognosis. A 69-year-old Black man was suspected of having a lacrimal sac tumour following presentation with a left sided watery eye, bloody tears, and a lacrimal mass. Due to the patient's implantable pacemaker, defibrillator, and high anticoagulation, an ultrasound-guided FNAC was performed instead of incisional biopsy, revealing a PLSM. Diagnosis was confirmed following complete tumour resection with free flap reconstruction and neck dissection. Unfortunately, disease progression ensued despite further neck dissection and three cycles of both pembrolizumab and iplimumab. This is the first description of FNAC to accurately diagnose PLSM and highlights its use as an accurate, rapid, and minimally invasive technique that may allow an earlier screening diagnosis of lacrimal sac tumours. We also discuss the outcome of immunotherapy in recent similar cases.

Diagnosis of orbital mass lesions: clinical, radiological, and pathological recommendations

The orbit can harbor mass lesions of various cellular origins. The symptoms vary considerably according to the nature, location, and extent of the disease and include common signs of proptosis, globe displacement, eyelid swelling, and restricted eye motility. Although radiological imaging tools are improving, with each imaging pattern having its own differential diagnosis, orbital mass lesions often pose a diagnostic challenge. To provide an accurate, specific, and sufficiently comprehensive diagnosis, to optimize clinical management and estimate prognosis, pathological examination of a tissue biopsy is essential. Diagnostic orbital tissue biopsy is obtained through a minimally invasive orbitotomy procedure or, in selected cases, fine needle aspiration. The outcome of successful biopsy, however, is centered on its representativeness, processing, and interpretation. Owing to the often small volume of the orbital biopsies, artifacts in the specimens should be limited by careful peroperative tissue handling, fixation, processing, and storage. Some orbital lesions can be characterized on the basis of cytomorphology alone, whereas others need ancillary molecular testing to render the most reliable diagnosis of therapeutic, prognostic, and predictive value. Herein, we review the diagnostic algorithm for orbital mass lesions, using clinical, radiological, and pathological recommendations, and discuss the methods and potential pitfalls in orbital tissue biopsy acquisition and analysis.

Role of Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology as a Diagnostic Tool in Orbital and Adnexal Lesions

Purpose:

To evaluate the role of fine needle aspiration (FNAC) as a diagnostic tool in cases of orbital and ocular adnexal masses. Cytological findings were correlated with histopathological diagnosis wherever possible.

Methods:

FNAC was performed in 29 patients of different age groups presenting with orbital and ocular adnexal masses. Patients were evaluated clinically and investigated by non-invasive techniques before fine needle aspiration of the masses. Smears were analyzed by a cytologist in all cases. Further, results of cytology were compared with the histopathological diagnosis.

Results:

The age of patients ranged from 1 to 68 years (mean: 29.79±19.29). There were 14 males and 15 females with a male to female ratio of 0.93:1. Out of 29 cases, 26 aspirates were cellular. Cellularity was insufficient in three (10.34%) aspirates. Out of 26 cellular aspirates, 11 were non-neoplastic while 15 were neoplastic on cytology. Subsequent histopathologic examination was done in 21/26 cases. Concordance rate of FNAC in orbital and ocular adnexal mass lesions with respect to the precise histologic diagnosis was 90%.

Conclusion:

When properly used in well-indicated patients (in cases where a diagnosis cannot be made by clinical and imaging findings alone), FNAC of orbital and periorbital lesions is an invaluable and suitable adjunct diagnostic technique that necessitates close cooperation between the ophthalmologist and cytologist. However, nondiagnostic aspirates may sometimes be obtained, and an inconclusive FNAC should not always be ignored.

Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy in Orbital Lesions: A Retrospective Study of 225 Cases

PURPOSE

To describe and analyze results from the fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) technique, used as a diagnostic tool, in patients with orbital lesions.

DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

METHODS

setting: Institutional (Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm).

STUDY POPULATION

207 patients with 210 orbital lesions.

INTERVENTION

225 FNABs of the orbit.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Successful diagnosis from FNAB.

RESULTS

Of the 210 orbital lesions evaluated with FNAB, a successful cytologic diagnosis was achieved in 176 (84%). In more than half of the orbital lesions (54%), the FNAB diagnosis in addition to imaging appearance, clinical appearance, and clinical history provided sufficient information for treatment, and the patient did not require an incisional or excisional biopsy. Ninety-seven patients underwent additional excisional or incisional biopsy; FNAB diagnoses and the histopathologic diagnoses corresponded in 87% of the cases with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.84 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.76-0.90). The difference was statistically significant between the ability to make a successful cytologic FNAB diagnosis in palpable lesions vs nonpalpable lesions (successful diagnosis in 90% [CI = 85%-95%] vs 75% [CI = 66%-84%]; P < .01). Neither the orbital quadrant location, nor the radiologic appearance (diffuse vs encapsulated), nor size of the lesion affected the success of FNAB diagnoses (all P > .7). There was a complication in 6 cases (3%). All complications were temporary and none led to permanent damage.

CONCLUSIONS

FNAB proved effective and exceedingly safe. With the current healthcare climate of minimally invasive surgery and cost control, FNAB should be considered as a valid alternative to open surgery in the evaluation and management of orbital lesions.

Role of fine needle aspiration cytology in the diagnosis of orbital masses: A study of 41 cases

BACKGROUND

Complexity in the anatomy of orbit and the fear of globe rupture are the main challenges faced in the diagnosis and typing of orbital masses. Fine needle aspiration cytology can be used as an initial investigative procedure in the evaluation of orbital masses, which in turn can aid the clinician to plan the treatment modalities. A close cooperation between ophthalmologist and pathologist adds to the success of the procedure.

AIM

The study was conducted in an attempt to evaluate the role of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the diagnosis of orbital lesions as a cost-effective diagnostic technique, and to assess its diagnostic efficacy by comparing it with histopathological diagnosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was conducted on 50 patients, over a period of 3 years, who had presented with anterior orbital mass lesions with or without proptosis, and with those having accessible mass lesions. Patients with proptosis without anterior orbital masses, proptosis due to dysthyroid ophthalmopathy, arteriovenous fistulas, hamartomas and choristomas were excluded from the study. FNAC procedure was done after explaining about the procedure to the patient, and in the presence of an ophthalmologist.

RESULTS

Majority of patients belonged to the age group 50-59 years. Male: female ratio was 1.05: 1. The most common lesion on FNAC was non-Hodgkins lymphoma, [13 cases (31.7%)]. 11 (26.8%) cases out of this were confirmed to be non-Hodgkins lymphoma on histopathologic examination. Two cases turned out to be inflammatory pseudotumor.

CONCLUSIONS

FNAC can be done in all palpable orbital mass lesions with minimal risk and complications, with close cooperation between ophthalmologist and pathologist. A good degree of correlation was obtained between FNAC and histopathology, which was assessed by kappa statistics.

Fine-needle aspiration cytology of orbital and eyelid lesions

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) of orbital lesions is now increasingly popular. Because of its unique location and the occurrence of varieties of lesions, diagnosis of orbital lesion is a challenge to the cytopathologists. FNAC of orbital and eyelid tumors is a suitable diagnostic technique that necessitates close co-operation between the ophthalmologist and pathologist. No radical procedure should be planned on the basis of FNAC, but it allows the diagnosis of a new primary lesion or the recurrence or metastasis of a tumor and can be done to identify lesions that require either specific medical therapy, as in nonresectable, inflammatory, and lymphoid tumors, or limited surgery for benign resectable neoplasms. With the help of various ancillary techniques a definitive diagnosis is possible on orbital and adnexal lesions. It is essential to have a detailed knowledge on the FNAC of these lesions and their potential pitfalls. In this present review, we have discussed various orbital lesions, their clinical presentations, cytomorphology, and ancillary techniques to confirm the diagnosis.

Spectrum of orbital and ocular adnexal lesions: an analysis of 389 cases diagnosed by fine needle aspiration cytology

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the scope and the limitations of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in orbital and ocular adnexal lesions. This study was a retrospective audit of 389 cases of orbital and ocular adnexal lesions subjected to FNAC over a period of 12 years (1998-2009). The cyto-smears were reviewed and the lesions were categorized under different diagnostic categories in adult and pediatric population. Three hundred and one adult patients (age ≥15 years) and 88 pediatric patients (age ≤14 years) constituted the study group. In the adult population, there were 23.3% cases of infectious and lymphoproliferative lesions and 12.6% of benign cysts. In the pediatric population, 18.2% cases had infectious and lymphoproliferative lesions and 8% had benign cysts. Various benign tumors (9.6% in adults) included pleomorphic adenoma, meningioma, and schwannoma. Benign vascular tumors predominated in the pediatric population. A majority of malignant tumors in adults were lymphoreticular malignancies (12.6%); non-Hodgkin's lymphoma being the most common followed by malignant epithelial tumors (10.3%). Nearly 3.6% cases of soft tissue/bone sarcomas and 6.3% of metastatic tumors were seen in adult population. However, most of the orbital tumors in the pediatric population were malignant small blue round cell tumors (33%). FNAC is a cost-effective technique with good diagnostic value in the assessment of ophthalmic lesions, especially when sampling and interpretation are performed by experienced personnel in the light of clinico-radiological information.

Adenocarcinoma metastasis causing discrete extraocular muscle enlargement

BACKGROUND

Discrete extraocular muscle (EOM) metastasis is rarely reported. Clinical signs and symptoms of EOM metastasis can often be indistinguishable from primary idiopathic orbital myositis, posing a significant clinical challenge.

CASE REPORT

A case of a 61-year-old man with acute-onset unilateral periorbital pain and diplopia is presented. Magnetic resonance imaging showed an isolated edematous superior rectus/levator muscle complex with an isointense T2-weighted signal, supporting a diagnosis of orbital myositis. He was started on corticosteroids, with resolution of pain and improved motilities. Subsequently, his condition worsened. Repeat imaging results suggested the possibility of neoplastic infiltration of the muscle because of the newly demonstrated hyperintensity of the T2-weighted signal and perineural extension along the trigeminal nerve. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy showed adenocarcinoma cytology in the muscle.

CONCLUSIONS

This case illustrates discrete adenocarcinoma metastasis of an EOM, initially displaying characteristics predominantly consistent with orbital myositis. There is a paucity of epidemiologic data on EOM cancer, and clinical characteristics are derived only from a selection of case reports in the literature. Thus, the predominant features of global orbital metastatic cancer versus primary inflammation are highlighted in this presentation. This case shows that the variable characteristics of each process prohibit identification of any clinical feature that would prove pathognomonic for either disorder. The varied practice philosophies and standard of care regarding the proper time to biopsy are reviewed. This case shows the importance of early referral for orbital biopsy, even in the presentation of isolated, discretely edematous, and painful EOM enlargement.

Fine-needle aspiration cytology and immunocytochemistry of orbital masses

A series of 85 fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies from orbital space occupying lesions of 82 patients are reviewed. A total of 32 benign lesions and 49 malignant lesions were conclusively diagnosed. In two cases the aspirates were insufficient for diagnosis. Of two cases, which were cytologically suspicious for lymphoma, a repeat FNA resulted in a conclusive diagnosis of lymphoma in one case, while the second case proved to be a pseudotumor on an open biopsy material. Of the 32 benign lesions seven were fibrosis, six pseudotumors, four epidermal cysts, four meningiomas, and three pleomorphic adenomas. The remaining cases included two hematomas, one granuloma, three inflammations, and one malformation. In 43 of 49 malignant tumors cytomorphology was corroborated with immunocytochemistry. Thirty five of these were low- or high-grade lymphomas, nine metastases, two sarcomas, two plasmacytomas, and one chloroma. All lymphomas were of B phenotype with monoclonal light chain expression. The rate of cell proliferation as measured by Ki-67 immunostaining varied between 4-25% and 30-80% for low- and high-grade lymphomas, respectively. These results confirm previous reports on the usefulness of FNA biopsy in diagnosing orbital masses and emphasize the value of immunocytochemistry in tumor characterization.

Fine needle aspiration biopsy in orbital lesions

PURPOSE. The study was performed to evaluate the efficacy of fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in orbital lesions. METHODS. Seventeen patients with orbital masses who had been fully investigated by non-invasive techniques participated in this study. FNAB was performed by standard technique, as an outpatient procedure, with ultrasound guidance in lesions posterior to the equator. A trained cytologist analysed all the smears. RESULTS. Specific results were obtained in 14 of the 17 (82%) patients studied by FNAB. Ten cases were neoplastic (8 malignant and 2 benign), 3 were inflammatory and 1 was a case of histiocytosis X. In 3/17 cases the results were non-specific. These were treated as pseudotumours and responded well to systemic steroids. In 7 cases the clinical and radiological diagnosis was confirmed by FNAB. Non-invasive investigations like USG, CT and MRI, however, failed to provide accurate diagnosis in the other 7 (41%) cases. In these patients, FNAB yielded a pathological diagnosis (histiocytosis X, cryptococcosis, non Hodgkin's lymphoma, adenocarcinoma, pleomorphic adenoma, Schwannoma and cysticercosis), helping us to modify treatment with an excellent response. No significant complications were encountered following the aspiration biopsies. CONCLUSION. FNAB proved to be a reliable method for distinguishing between malignant and non-malignant lesions. It was found to be rapid, accurate, cost-effective, safe and a valuable addition to ultrasound, CT scan and MRI in the diagnosis of orbital lesions. This tool may help in avoiding a traumatic surgical intervention.

Orbital mass lesions: US-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy--experience in 37 patients

PURPOSE

To evaluate the safety and effectiveness of using ultrasonographic (US) guidance for performing fine-needle aspiration biopsies of orbital mass lesions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-seven patients with mass lesions in the orbit underwent US-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy. Computed tomographic scans were available in all patients. In 19 patients, the lesions were located in posterior orbit, whereas in 18 patients the lesions were located in (n = 3) or extended up to (n = 15) the anterior compartment. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy was performed with 22-25-gauge needles and use of the freehand technique.

RESULTS

Needle biopsies were performed safely and easily, and real-time US monitoring of the needle position was used to avoid injury to the eyeball. No major complications were encountered. Diagnostic specimens were obtained in 29 (78%) of the 37 patients, and 19 benign and 10 malignant disease processes were diagnosed. In eight patients (22%), an appropriate diagnosis could not be made, as aspiration samples yielded insufficient tissue.

CONCLUSION

US provides safe and effective guidance for performing fine-needle aspiration biopsy in orbital mass lesions and is especially useful in deep-seated nonpalpable retrobulbar lesions.