Genetic counseling and genetic heterogeneity in the thalassemias

The Problem of Borderline Hemoglobin A2 Levels in the Screening for β-Thalassemia Carriers in Sardinia

BACKGROUND

The increase in HbA2 is the most important parameter for the identification of thalassemia carriers. However, in routine screening for hemoglobinopathies, some cases are difficult to classify because the level of HbA2 is not typically elevated. In this work, we report the results of a molecular investigation on a cohort of subjects with borderline HbA2.

METHODS

All subjects with a β-thalassemia carrier partner and a borderline percentage level of HbA2 were investigated for the presence of a pathological mutation in the β-globin gene. All negative subjects were screened for both the KLF1 mutation and the presence of ααα/ or αααα/ alleles. The subjects with reduced MCV and/or MCH were also screened for deletional and nondeletional α-globin gene defects.

RESULTS

Various β-globin mutations and KLF1 gene defects are the most common genetic determinants responsible for this phenotype in our population.

CONCLUSION

KLF1 mutations are important in a screening program for hemoglobinopathies. An increase in HbF in association with borderline HbA2 levels is a useful but not exclusive marker that suggests the investigation of this gene. On the basis of our findings, we are able to suggest the molecular procedure to use in a population characterized by a high prevalence of thalassemia carriers.

Control of beta-thalassaemia by carrier screening, genetic counselling and prenatal diagnosis: the Sardinian experience

Homozygous beta-thalassaemia in a number of at-risk populations (Greek and Turkish Cypriots, Greeks, Continental Italians and Sardinians) has been prevented at the population level by programmes based on carrier screening, genetic counselling and prenatal diagnosis. The Sardinian experience is based on a 20-year programme. Voluntary screening has been offered to prospective parents and, primarily, to women with an ongoing pregnancy. Education of the population at large, training of health personnel, and use of posters and informative booklets have been critical elements for the success of the programme. Genetic counselling has been carried out in a non-directive manner following well-established guidelines. The use of extended family screening magnified the efficacy of the screening programme, allowing the identification of the large majority of parents at risk by screening only 13% of the population at child-bearing age. Following counselling, the large majority of parents accepted prenatal diagnosis. Definition of the parents' mutation and prenatal diagnosis were carried out by a number of PCR-based procedures. The programme was effective, as indicated by the reduction of the birth rate of thalassaemia major from 1:250 live births to 1:4000.

Alpha-thalassemia carrier identification by DNA analysis in the screening for thalassemia

Differentiation between heterozygous alpha-thalassemia and several phenotypically resembling alleles at the beta-globin gene cluster such as coinherited delta- and beta-thalassemia or gammadelta beta-thalassemia is a critical step in genetic counseling. In this paper we report our experience in the identification of the alpha-thalassemia carrier state using polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based methods, and the feasibility and simplification of screening for thalassemia using this approach. Alpha-globin genotype was determined by PCR-based method in 526 adult subjects with reduced mean corpuscular volume (MCV) and mean corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH), normal hemoglobin A2 and F, and normal serum iron. To verify the reliability of the protocol used, in 68 of these subjects we performed globin chain synthesis analysis and in 101 we determined alpha-globin genotype by Southern blot analysis. Five hundred twenty-one (99%) of 526 subjects examined were identified as carriers of one or two alpha-thalassemia alleles. The identification of the alpha-thalassemia carrier state may be fast and accurate by PCR-based method, avoiding other cumbersome and expensive methods such as globin chain synthesis and Southern blot analysis.

A 12-year preventive program for beta-thalassemia in Northern Sardinia

From 1980 to 1991, 6.3% of the adult population of the province of Sassari, Northern Sardinia, underwent voluntary beta-thalassemia screening. Of the 28,000 subjects examined, 15.7% proved to be heterozygotes for beta-thalassemia. In addition, the screening of 7500 students in 26 villages in Sassari province fixed the frequency of beta-thalassemia in this part of Sardinia at 10.4%. Of the 539 couples at risk to be expected from this figure, the screening detected 43% (234). The data suggest that inductive screening played a major role in the efficiency of this preventive beta-thalassemia program. Follow up of 221 pregnancies found to be at risk for homozygous beta-thalassemia and referred to the Antenatal Diagnosis Service, Cagliari, Southern Sardinia, showed that antenatal diagnosis was carried out in 80% of them. The overall percentage of couples refusing antenatal diagnosis was 10.8%, but over the years the acceptance rate for the procedure increased from 87% to 96%. Atypical hematological findings in 1.5% of 468 members of the couples at risk required globin chain synthesis and molecular analyses to define the precise beta-thalassemia genotype. Heterogeneous "mild" beta-thalassemia mutations as well as coexisting delta-thalassemia were found in silent type I and type II beta-thalassemia carriers which, without chain synthesis and DNA investigations, would have escaped detection.

Genotype-phenotype correlations in beta-thalassemias

In this paper we review the molecular basis of the marked heterogeneity of the thalassemia syndromes as well as the relative implications for carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis. The classical phenotype of heterozygous beta-thalassemia may be modified by a number of environmental and genetic interacting factors--among which the most relevant are: (1) coinheritance of alpha-thalassemia, which may normalize the red blood cell indices; (2) the presence of a mild beta-thalassemia mutation; (3) cotransmission of delta-thalassemia which may reduce the increase of HbA2 typical of heterozygous beta-thalassemia to normal values and (4) the presence of a silent mutation which can be defined only by imbalanced beta-globin chain synthesis. A number of molecular mechanisms are able to produce the non transfusion dependent attenuated forms of thalassemia syndromes referred to as thalassemia intermedia. The most common are homozygosity for mild beta-thalassemia mutations, coinheritance with homozygous beta-thalassemia of alpha-thalassemia or genetic determinants able to sustain a continuous production of HbF in adult life or the presence of heterozygosity for hyperunstable globin variants.

Screening and prenatal diagnosis of the haemoglobinopathies

In this paper we have reviewed the social and technical aspects of carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis of the inherited haemoglobinopathies. The characteristics of programmes based on carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis ongoing in a number of at-risk Mediterranean populations have been described. The most relevant and common aspects of these programmes are the continuous educational campaign directed to the population at large, the voluntary basis and non-directive counselling. The target population has been most commonly couples before or after marriage. The vast majority of couples counselled accepted prenatal diagnosis. All programmes have encountered a high degree of success as indicated by the marked reduction in the birth rate of infants with thalassaemia major. No significant adverse effects have been reported. A programme with similar characteristics and for which the preliminary results are encouraging, is operating for sickle cell anaemia in the Cuban population. In a population with high frequency of hydrops fetalis, screening for deletion alpha-thalassaemia is recommended to prevent the negative effects on a pregnant woman of the presence of an hydropic fetus. Thalassaemia carrier screening is now carried out by automatic red cell indices and HbA2 determination. Definition of atypical cases may require iron studies, globin chain synthesis determination and/or alpha, beta- and delta-globin gene analysis. Identification of the carrier state is followed by definition of the mutation on enzymatically amplified DNA. Known mutations may be detected by restriction endonuclease analysis, non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, allele-specific primers or allele-specific probes. The most promising procedures, which are also amenable to complete automation are reverse oligonucleotide hybridization and primer-specific amplification. Unknown mutations are defined by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis, and chemical mismatch cleavage analysis followed by direct sequencing. The same methods on enzymatically amplified chorionic villus DNA are used for prenatal diagnosis. The potential pitfall resulting from maternal contamination can be avoided by careful dissection of the maternal decidua from the chorion and by the simultaneous amplification of a suitable polymorphism.

Heterozygous beta-thalassemia: relationship between the hematological phenotype and the type of beta-thalassemia mutation

In this study we have correlated the severity of the hematological features to the type of the beta-thalassemia mutation [codon 39 (C----T), IVS-I nt 110 (G----A), IVS-I nt 1 (G----A), IVS-I nt 6 (T----C), IVS-II nt 745 (C----G), -87 (C----G) and beta 6 (-1 bp)], in a group of beta-thalassemia heterozygotes of Italian descent in whom we excluded the presence of iron deficiency or deletion alpha-thalassemia. The beta-thalassemia mutation was defined by dot blot analysis on amplified DNA with allelic specific oligonucleotide probes. We found that a) heterozygotes for beta+ IVS-I nt 6 and beta+ -87 mutations produce larger and better hemoglobinized red blood cells, and b) heterozygotes for beta+ IVS-I nt 6 and beta+ IVS-I nt 110 mutations have a less marked increase of Hb A2 levels as compared to heterozygotes for the other mutations investigated. These findings indicate that milder beta-thalassemia mutations such as the beta+ IVS-I nt 6 and beta+ -87, express also in the heterozygous state a milder phenotype as compared to beta o-thalassemia or severe beta+ thalassemia (beta+ IVS-I, nt 110). The Hb A2 levels, on the other hand, were not related to the severity of the mutation because of less marked increase was found in a mild (beta+ IVS-I nt 6) as well in a severe (beta+ IVS-I nt 110) mutation. From the practical point of view these findings should be adequately considered in carrier screening and genetic counselling.

Antenatal diagnosis of beta-thalassemia in Sardinia

This paper reviews the characteristics and the results of 15 years of experience with a preventive program, based on carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis, designed to control thalassemia major in the Sardinian population. The education of the population about thalassemia and the modalities for its prevention was accomplished via the mass media. Carrier screening was carried out voluntarily on couples of child-bearing age. Prenatal diagnosis was initially carried out by fetal blood analysis; since 1983, it has been done by DNA analysis on non-amplified or amplified DNA. Different chorionic villous sampling procedures have been used. Nowadays, we have adopted the transabdominal approach because, in our experience, it seems to be associated with a low risk (2%) of fetal mortality. At the present time, the beta-thalassemia mutations are detected directly by dot-blot analysis of amplified DNA with 32P- or horseradish peroxidase-labeled allele-specific oligonucleotide probes. Two oligonucleotide probes, one complementary to the codon-39 nonsense mutation, which accounts for 95.7% of the beta-thalassemia chromosomes in the Sardinian population, and the other complementary to the frameshift at codon 6, which is the second most common mutation in our population (2.1%), allow us to make prenatal diagnosis in the large majority of cases. Notwithstanding a careful dissection of maternal decidua from chorionic villi, co-amplification of maternal sequence was detected in 4 out of 425 cases tested by this procedure. In order to avoid this pitfall, the simultaneous amplification of highly polymorphic VNTR (variable number of tandem repeats) segments could be used. On the whole we have so far carried out 2711 prenatal tests: 1130 by fetal blood analysis, 1156 by oligonucleotide hybridization on electrophoretically separated DNA fragments, and 425 by dot-blot analysis on amplified DNA with allele-specific oligonucleotide probes. Two errors occurred by fetal blood analysis and none by DNA analysis. The incidence of thalassemia major declined from 1:250 live births in the absence of prevention to 1:1000 after the establishment of this program, indicating that carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis are effective means for preventing thalassemia major at the population level.

Molecular analysis of atypical beta-thalassemia heterozygotes

This paper reviews the molecular pathology of a heterogeneous group of beta-thalassemia heterozygotes which may be referred to as atypical beta-thalassemia. This group includes four different categories of heterozygous beta-thalassemia, which are characterized, respectively, by (1) normal MCV and MCH; (2) normal Hb A2; (3) normal MCV, MCH, and Hb A2 and imbalanced globin chain synthesis only or, (4) the presence of clinical manifestations. The first group is represented by a limited proportion of double heterozygotes for alpha- and beta-thalassemia. The second group includes two categories. One category is double heterozygotes for delta- and beta-thalassemia with the delta-thalassemia mutation in cis or in trans to beta-thalassemia. A number of delta-thalassemia mutations which produce this phenotype by interacting with beta-thalassemia have been described. The other category within the second group is heterozygotes for some mild beta(+)-thalassemia mutations. Within the third group, conclusive evidence for a mutation within the beta-globin gene cluster producing the silent beta-thalassemia phenotype has been obtained solely for a C----T substitution at -101 within the CACCC box of the beta-globin gene. Possible candidates are the complex rearrangements (-T, +ATA; -T, +ATATA) found at position -530 from the cap site. In the group of thalassemic hemoglobinopathies, a series of mutations mostly located in the third exon and producing elongated or truncated molecules have been recently reported. Most of the mutations are silent at the protein level, produce inclusion bodies in peripheral erythrocytes, and show a dominant transmission pattern or occur sporadically.

The C-T substitution in the distal CACCC box of the beta-globin gene promoter is a common cause of silent beta thalassaemia in the Italian population

This paper describes four families of Italian descent in each of which the propositus had the clinical phenotype of thalassaemia intermedia, resulting from the compound heterozygous state for high HbA2 beta thalassaemia and type I silent beta thalassaemia. Direct sequencing on amplified DNA and/or oligonucleotide analysis detected, in all families but one, the compound heterozygous state for codon 39 nonsense mutation and the C-T substitution at position -101 in the distal CACCC box of the beta-globin gene promoter (beta th-101). Members of these families who are heterozygous for high HbA2 beta thalassaemia showed the codon 39 nonsense mutation, while those with the clinical phenotype of silent beta thalassaemia had the beta th-101 mutation. In the remaining family, the propositus and one of his siblings had the compound heterozygous state for a molecularly undefined high HbA2 beta thalassaemia and the beta th-101 mutation in combination with the triple alpha globin gene arrangement. These patients showed a more severe thalassaemia intermedia like clinical phenotype as compared to those with the same beta-globin genotype and a normal alpha-globin gene arrangement. In the families investigated the beta th-101 was always associated with haplotype I. A group of patients with thalassaemia intermedia from Southern Italy, either homozygous or heterozygous for haplotype I and in whom previous studies had failed to define the mutation in one of the beta thalassaemia globin genes, were screened by oligonucleotide analysis for the presence of the beta th-101. Three out of nine were positive. These results indicate that the beta th-101 mutation is a common cause of the type I silent beta thalassaemia phenotype in the Southern Italian population.

Pitfalls in genetic counselling for beta-thalassemia: an individual with 4 different thalassemia mutations

This paper describes a complex combination of four thalassemia genes (delta(+), beta(0), nondeletion and deletion alpha-thalassemia) in the spouse of a typical high Hb A2 beta-thalassemia carrier presenting for genetic counselling. This complex gene combination resulted in a hematological phenotype, characterized by thalassemia-like red cell indices, normal Hb A2 and Hb F levels and slightly reduced alpha/beta globin chain synthesis ratio, and therefore not indicative for the presence of beta-thalassemia trait. Family studies in combination with alpha-globin gene mapping, haplotype analysis at the beta-globin gene cluster and definition of the beta-thalassemia mutation by oligonucleotide hybridization led us to identify a beta-thalassemia mutation, to define the molecular basis for this phenotype and give the appropriate genetic counselling.

Molecular characterization of a normal Hb A2 beta-thalassaemia determinant in a Sardinian family

In this study we have carried out haplotype analysis at the beta-globin gene cluster and defined the beta-thalassaemia mutations in a large Sardinian family, ascertained through a proband with thalassaemia major, in which several members were carriers of a beta-thalassaemia allele characterized by microcytosis, hypochromia and normal Hb A2 levels (type 2 normal Hb A2 heterozygous beta-thalassemia). The proband was a compound heterozygote for the beta zero 39 and the beta + IVS-2, nt 745 mutations and all the beta-thalassaemia heterozygotes with normal Hb A2 showed the beta + IVS-2, nt 745 mutation, always associated with haplotype VII. Because of the consistent association of a specific beta-thalassaemia mutation and normal Hb A2 levels, we postulate that this beta-thalassaemia chromosome carries a delta gene (delta-thalassaemia) which is unable to increase the delta-globin output in response to beta-thalassaemia.

Results of programmes for antenatal detection of thalassemia in reducing the incidence of the disorder

The characteristics and the effectiveness of programmes designed to prevent beta-thalassemia major present in high frequency in several areas of the world such as Cyprus, Greece and Sardinia are reviewed. All these programmes are based on heterozygote detection, counselling and foetal diagnosis. The target population for screening have been couples at marriage, conception or early pregnancy. Awareness of the problem and involvement of the population was achieved via mass-media or personal approaches through lectures or discussions. Parent's Association were consulted and have been actively involved. Information leaflets have been made available to prospective couples at several critical areas. Education on thalassemias was introduced into the school curriculum. Counselling was based on a private interview at which the several options available were discussed with the individual carrier or the couple. Prenatal diagnosis was chosen by the large majority of couples counselled. All these programmes resulted in a decline of thalassemia major births by 50-97%. The reasons for residual cases were mostly lack of information and, less frequently, misdiagnoses or refusal of fetal diagnoses.