A proposed methodology of health education for inherited genetic disorders: Bag and Ball technique

The life-threatening genetic blood disorder, thalassaemia, which causes decreased haemoglobin production, is preventable. Sociocultural determinants and the level of public health awareness must be used to adopt control measures of prevention. Identifying information gaps and educating the community about screening should be a priority, especially in areas with high disease burdens. A relevant health education technique, with which the audience can identify, can effectively bring understanding necessary effectively to sensitise the community. We propose the 'Bag and Ball' method, which includes role-play for health education specifically concerning inherited genetic disorders.

Combatting thalassemia in the United Arab Emirates

Thalassemia is a major health challenge in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), however previous studies have focused on genetics and molecular characterisation while neglecting culture and society. In this commentary, we discuss how tradition and religion in the UAE (e.g. consanguinity, endogamy, illegality of abortion and in vitro fertilisation, adoption restrictions), and limited academic research, affect the prevention and management of the blood disorder. It is suggested that changing attitudes towards traditional marriage practices, education and awareness campaigns targeting families and young people, and earlier genetic testing, are culturally acceptable solutions to curbing the high incidence of thalassemia in the UAE.

Comparison Of Knowledge Among Millennials Studying In Non-Medical Universities Regarding Premarital And Prenatal Thalassemia Screening Policies In Pakistan

Thalassemia awareness among the youth is vital for policy- making to reduce the disease burden in our country. A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted via simple random sampling technique for which data was collected from May 2020 to May 2021 through Google forms. Results showed that out of a total of 394 non-medical university students, the majority, i.e. 265 (67.3%), were not aware of prenatal screening. Majority, i.e. 117 (29.7%), agreed that the couple should be screened before marriage, and 190 (48.2%) strongly agreed, while 46 (11.7%) had no knowledge. Students, however, believed premarital screening was either unavailable, not possible, or expensive. Other reasons included custom and culture of arranged marriages and religious reasons. The query that if both the parents are carriers and the foetus has thalassemia major should they have an abortion, showed mixed results. The key to controlling thalassemia is awareness of future parents.

Cross-sectional study on knowledge, attitude and practice towards thalassaemia among Indonesian youth

INTRODUCTION

Thalassaemia is an inherited blood disorder, for which definitive treatments remain largely inaccessible. The recommended approach to reduce the disease burden is by prevention through screening. Currently, the implementation of thalassaemia preventive measures is poorly regulated in Indonesia. Thalassaemia prevention and education are best targeted to the youth, but information on their awareness towards thalassaemia is limited. This study aims to investigate the knowledge, attitude and practice (KAP) towards thalassaemia among Indonesian youth.

METHODS

This observational study took place between January and May 2021. An online questionnaire was disseminated to Indonesian youth aged 15-24. Eligible respondents included carriers, unaffected individuals and individuals with unknown carrier status. The questionnaire comprised 28 questions to assess KAP. A cut-off of 75% was used to categorise participant's KAP into poor or negative and good or positive. Descriptive statistics, χ² test, logistic regression and Pearson correlation were performed for data analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 906 responses were gathered, and 878 were analysed. Most respondents had poor knowledge (62.1%), positive attitude (83.3%) and poor practice (54.4%) towards thalassaemia. The results implied that respondents had limited understanding regarding the types of thalassaemia and the difference between asymptomatic carriers and individuals without the thalassaemia trait. Many (82.6%) believed they were not carrying thalassaemia trait despite the fact that most (95.7%) never got tested. Age, education, gender, residence and family income were key factors that correlated with or predicted the youth's KAP towards thalassaemia. Older respondents and women were more likely to have good KAP.

CONCLUSION

Thalassaemia screening targeted to the youth is urgently needed, and future interventions must consider sociodemographic factors that may affect how they perceive the disease. Social media appeals to the youth as an important source of information, but school, parents and health professionals should also be involved in delivering education about thalassaemia.

A nationwide survey of hospital-based thalassemia patients and standards of care and a preliminary assessment of the national prevention program in Sri Lanka

Objectives

Our aim was to describe the numbers and distribution of patients with different types of thalassemia and to assess the standards of care in all thalassemia treatment centers throughout Sri Lanka and the success of the ongoing prevention programme.

Methods

This cross-sectional island-wide survey was conducted by two trained medical graduates, who visited each thalassemia center to collect data from every patient, using a standardized form. Data was collected through review of patient registers and clinical records.

Results

We collected data on 1774 patients from 23 centers. 1219 patients (68.7%) had homozygous β-thalassemia, 360 patients (20.3%) had hemoglobin E β-thalassemia, and 50 patients (2%) had sickle β-thalassemia. There were unacceptably high serum ferritin levels in almost all centers. The annual number of births of patients with β-thalassaemia varied between 45–55, with little evidence of reduction over 19 years.

Conclusions

Central coordination of the treatment and ultimately prevention of thalassemia is urgently needed in Sri Lanka. Development of expert centers with designated staff with sufficient resources will improve the quality of care and is preferred to managing patients in multiple small units.

A web-based educational intervention module to improve knowledge and attitudes towards thalassaemia prevention in Malaysian young adults

BACKGROUND

Thalassaemia is a public health burden in Malaysia and its prevention faces many challenges. In this study, we aimed to assess the effectiveness of a web-based educational module in improving knowledge and attitudes about thalassaemia prevention amongst Malaysian young adults.

METHODS

We designed an interactive web-based educational module in the Malay language wherein videos were combined with text and pictorial visual cues. Malaysians aged 18-40 years old who underwent the module had their knowledge and attitudes assessed at baseline, post-intervention and at 6-month follow-up using a selfadministered validated questionnaire.

RESULTS

Sixty-five participants: 47 Malays (72.3%), 15 Chinese (23.1%), three Indians (4.6%) underwent the module. Questionnaires were completed at baseline (n=65), postintervention (n=65) and at 6-month follow-up (n=60). Out of a total knowledge score of 21, significant changes were recorded across three time-points- median scores were 12 at pre-intervention, 19 at post-intervention and 16 at 6-month follow-up (p<0.001). Post-hoc testing comparing preintervention and 6-month follow-up scores showed significant retention of knowledge (p<0.001). Compared to baseline, attitudes at 6-month follow-up showed an increased acceptance for "marriage avoidance between carriers" (pre-intervention 20%, 6-month follow-up 48.3%, p<0.001) and "prenatal diagnosis" (pre-intervention 73.8%, 6-month follow-up 86.2%, p=0.008). Acceptance for selective termination however, remained low without significant change (pre-intervention 6.2%, 6-month follow-up 16.7%, p=0.109).

CONCLUSION

A web-based educational module appears effective in improving knowledge and attitudes towards thalassaemia prevention and its incorporation in thalassaemia prevention programs is potentially useful in Malaysia and countries with a high internet penetration rate.

Frequency of carrier screening and preventive orientation among first degree relatives of Thalassaemia patients

OBJECTIVE

To get preliminary data regarding the prevention of thalassaemia major in future generations.

METHODS

This Knowledge Attitude Practices study was conducted at Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, Islamabad, Pakistan, from January to June 2016, using non-probability purposive sampling. Parents of children undergoing transfusion were interviewed. Questionnaires were used to collect demographics and data about awareness, attitude and frequency of screening among the first degree relatives of a thalassaemia major patient. SPSS 20 was used for data analysis.

RESULTS

Of the 270 respondents 240(88.9%) had utilised screening services for their asymptomatic children and had a positive attitude towards prevention, but 30(11.1%) families did not screen asymptomatic children for thalassaemia minor. Besides, 49(18.1%) families had more than one thalassaemia major child in their nuclear family, while, 3(1.1%) were unwilling to let their children undergo tests. Nine (3.3%) respondents said they will not ask a prospective daughter/son-in-law to get tested for thalassaemia minor, while 194(71.9%) respondents had had cousin marriages.

CONCLUSIONS

There were significant gaps in awareness among affected families.

Thalassemia in the United Arab Emirates: Why it can be prevented but not eradicated

Thalassemia is a genetic blood disorder that causes abnormal hemoglobin. Hemoglobin is a protein in red blood cells that carries oxygen and is made of two proteins from four α-globin genes and two β-globin genes. A defect in one or more of these genes causes thalassemia. The treatment of thalassemia mostly depends on life-long blood transfusions and removal of excessive iron from the blood stream. Such tremendous blood consumption puts pressure on the national blood stock in many countries. In particular, in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), various forms of thalassemia prevention have been used and hence, the substantial reduction of the thalassemia major population has been achieved. However, the thalassemia carrier population still remains high, which leads to the potential increase in the thalassemia major population through carrier-carrier marriages. In this work, we investigate the long-term impact and efficacy of thalassemia prevention measures via mathematical modeling at a population level. To our best knowledge, this type of assessment has not been done before and there is no mathematical model that has investigated such a problem for thalassemia or any blood disorders at a population level. By using UAE data, we perform numerical simulations of our model and conduct sensitivity analysis of parameter values to see which parameter values affect most the dynamics of our model. We discover that the prevention measures can contribute to reduce the prevalence of the disease only in the short term but not eradicate the disease in the long term.

The Effectiveness of Interventions for Non-Communicable Diseases in Humanitarian Crises: A Systematic Review

Background

Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are of increasing concern in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) affected humanitarian crises. Humanitarian agencies and governments are increasingly challenged with how to effectively tackle NCDs. Reviewing the evidence of interventions for NCDs in humanitarian crises can help guide future policies and research by identifying effective interventions and evidence gaps. The aim of this paper is to systematically review evidence on the effectiveness of interventions targeting NCDs during humanitarian crises in LMICs.

Methods

A systematic review methodology was followed using PRISMA standards. Studies were selected on NCD interventions with civilian populations affected by humanitarian crises in low- and middle-income countries. Five bibliographic databases and a range of grey literature sources were searched. Descriptive analysis was applied and a quality assessment conducted using the Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale for observational studies and the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool for experimental studies.

Results

The search yielded 4919 references of which 8 studies met inclusion criteria. Seven of the 8 studies were observational, and one study was a non-blinded randomised-controlled trial. Diseases examined included hypertension, heart failure, diabetes mellitus, chronic kidney disease, thalassaemia, and arthritis. Study settings included locations in the Middle East, Eastern Europe, and South Asia. Interventions featuring disease-management protocols and/or cohort monitoring demonstrated the strongest evidence of effectiveness. No studies examined intervention costs. The quality of studies was limited, with a reliance on observational study designs, limited use of control groups, biases associated with missing data and inadequate patient-follow-up, and confounding was poorly addressed.

Conclusions

The review highlights the extremely limited quantity and quality of evidence on this topic. Interventions that incorporate standardisation and facilitate patient follow-up appear beneficial. However, substantially more research is needed, including data on costs.

Results From The North Cyprus Thalassemia Prevention Program

Thalassemia was a serious health problem in Cyprus. The first scientific studies on thalassemia started in 1976 after a seminar which was organized by the Turkish Hematology Association. At the end of the seminar it was decided that a thalassemia prevention program would be effective to control this problem as thalassemia was a hereditary disease and possible to prevent. The aim was to stop the affected newborns and provide good treatment facilities to the existing thalassemic patients. In 1979, high risk families started to be screened for thalassemia. In 1980, premarital screening was made compulsory by law. In 1984, prenatal diagnosis was started with fetal blood sampling techniques. DNA techniques replaced fetal blood sampling in 1991. After prenatal diagnosis started in 1984, affected birth rates showed a sharp decrease in contrast to an average of 18-20 cases per year before the implementation of the "Thalassaemia Prevention Programme." Between 1991 to 2001, only five thalassemic babies were born, one in every 2-3 years. No thalassemic babies have been born in the last 5 years. Thalassemic patients live longer with a better quality of life because of more effective treatment modalities. A great majority of the patients are over 25 years old (66%), living and working as the normal population. Thirty-eight percent of them are married and have children.

Epidemiology of haemoglobin disorders in Europe: an overview

OBJECTIVE

As a result of global population movements, haemoglobin disorders (thalassaemias and sickle cell disorders) are increasingly common in the formerly non-indigenous countries of Northern and Western Europe and in the indigenous countries of Southern Europe. This article presents an overview of the changing picture and a method for assessing service needs.

METHOD

Data on country of birth or ethnic origin of residents are adjusted to obtain the estimated proportions of residents and births in non-indigenous groups at risk for haemoglobin disorders in European countries. The results are combined with prevalence data in each country of origin to obtain country prevalence estimates. Service indicators (annual tests or other interventions required to ensure equitable delivery of treatment and prevention) are then derived by country.

RESULTS

Haemoglobin disorders now occur at comparable frequency throughout Northern, Western and Southern Europe. Annually, there are more affected conceptions in Northern and Western than in Southern Europe, and sickle cell disorders are more common than thalassaemias. There is growing need for health policy-makers to support motivated professionals working to develop optimal patient care, carrier diagnosis, genetic counselling and access to prenatal diagnosis throughout the Region.

CONCLUSION

There is a strong case for pan-European collaboration on haemoglobin disorders to share policies, standards and the instruments required to support them. These include methods for needs assessment, service standards, education and information strategies and materials, and methods for evaluating service delivery.

Thalassemia in Iran: epidemiology, prevention, and management

PURPOSE

To determine the prevalence and geographic distribution of thalassemia and to evaluate the success of the thalassemia prevention and treatment programs in Iran.

METHODS

Data were obtained from the National Thalassemia Registry of Iran, Iranian Blood Transfusion Organization, genetic laboratories involved in prenatal diagnosis, related pharmaceutical companies, and centers performing bone marrow transplantation for thalassemic patients.

RESULTS

A total of 13,879 living patients have been registered, mostly from the northern and southern parts of Iran with the median age of 15 years. Twenty-three percent of patients were older than 20 years. The number of newly diagnosed cases has been decreased considerably after the start of the prevention program. Since the introduction of prenatal diagnosis, 2819 couples (2549 fetuses) have been tested, with only 6 false results. Elective abortion was not performed in 10 affected fetuses. Most common mutations detected were IVS II-1 and IVS I-5. In 2003, approximately 25% of the national blood products and 6 million vials of desferal were used for thalassemic patients. Overall, 340 patients have received allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, of those 46 patients deceased. Bloodborne infections have also been decreased significantly owing to the national screening of blood products for bloodborne viral infections.

DISCUSSION

Owing to the national prevention program and provided special care, the age distribution of thalassemic patients in Iran is getting adapted to a full prevention and treatment program and life expectancy of these patients has been increased considerably. This shift in the age distribution of thalassemia, a traditionally considered pediatric disease, will face us with new challenges and the health care system should be prepared for this new face of thalassemia.

Prenatal prevention for severe thalassemia disease at Srinagarind Hospital

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the results and cost-effectiveness of prenatal prevention measurement in severe thalassemia diseases at Srinagarind Hospital.

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive study.

SETTING

Antenatal care (ANC) Clinic, Srinagarind Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Khon Kaen University.

SUBJECTS

1,498 thalassemic screened pregnant women first presenting at ANC Clinic at gestational age less than 17 weeks.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

Medical records of thalassemic screened pregnant women between February 2002 and February 2005 were analyzed. Those with a value of mean corpuscular volume (MCV) less than 80 fl, or positive dichlorophenol indophenol precipitation test (KKU-DCIP Clear Reagent Kit) underwent hemoglobin (Hb) typing by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) together with thalassemia investigation (complete blood count, MCV and Hb typing) of their husbands and to identify couples at risk of 3 severe thalassemia diseases; Hb Bart's hydrops fetalis, homozygous, -thalassemia and, -thalassemia/ Hb E disease. Then they were advised to undergo DNA analysis and, if they had fetal risk, appropriate prenatal diagnosis was offered.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Number of affected fetuses detected by prenatal diagnosis.

RESULTS

Nine hundred and ninety six pregnant women (66.49%) were positive on screening. Of these, 642 (64.46%) had thalassemia investigation done with their spouses. There were 19 couples at risk (1.27% of total screened pregnant women) for having fetal severe thalassemia disease from initial laboratory results. Most of them were, -thalassemia/ Hb E diseases. We found only 10 pregnant women (52.63%) that had undergone prenatal diagnosis. The consequent results were two affected fetuses (20%), one was Hb Bart's hydrops fetalis, and the other was, o-thalassemia/ Hb E disease. In these cases, their parents decided to discontinue the pregnancy. Our prevention program could save 1.14 million bahts for the cost of treatment in two prevented severe thalassemia cases.

CONCLUSION

The prenatal prevention program of severe thalassemia disease at Srinagarind Hospital can effectively detect affected fetuses and reduce severe thalassemia disease, which is a major health problem in Thailand.

Thalassemia treatment and prevention in Uva Province, Sri Lanka: a public opinion survey

Due to its excessive cost thalassemia management is a major health care problem in Sri Lanka. The majority of doctors are using only desferrioxamine (DFO), in grossly inadequate doses mainly because of its unavailability. Deferiprone (L1), which is more affordable, is not used due to fear of toxicity, as previously reported. Arthropathy attributed to L1 has been observed in some patients, and has led to the discontinuation of the drug in all patients, without scientific rationale. The proposed thalassemia prevention project for Uva Province is based on prevention of marriages between carriers. This could be achieved by carrier screening and counseling of teenagers and adolescents well before they select their partners. In Sri Lanka, people find their marriage partners at their work place or universities, by themselves, or with the help of professional marriage brokers (they are called Kapuwa), through relatives and close friends. This process of finding a partner may also be helped by paper advertisements. However, in addition to the appearance and attitude of the prospective partner, the caste, social background and horoscope are major considerations in selecting a partner. Even when they select partners on their own at the work place or university, they keep these factors in the back of their minds to ensure social acceptance. Many relationships are given up due to objections and advice from parents when the caste or social background does not match. A horoscope is a written document that almost every child gets, written by a professional horoscope reader and depending on the time of birth. It is believed, according to the horoscope, that a person's attitudes, desires, future prospects of finding a suitable partner, could be predicted. It is rare to proceed with a marriage if the horoscope does not match. These customs are considered less seriously among educated people when they find their partner at the work place or university. The concept of thalassemia risk-free marriages advocates promotion of marriages where at least one partner is a non-carrier. Success of such a project could be monitored at the time of marriage. This opinion survey indicates that the public is motivated to promote carrier screening and the prevention of thalassemia.

Preimplantation genetics: Improving access to stem cell therapy

There has been progress in the application of stem cell transplantation for treatment of an increasing number of severe congenital and acquired bone marrow disorders, currently restricted by the availability of human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched related donors. Preimplantation HLA typing has recently been introduced to improve the access to stem cell therapy for inherited bone marrow failures. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) provides an option not only for avoiding an affected pregnancy with thalassemia and other inherited disorders but also for preselection of the HLA-compatible donors for affected siblings. Multiple short tandem repeat markers throughout the HLA region are applied for this purpose, allowing 100% accuracy of HLA typing, through picking up possible recombination in the HLA region, as well as the copy number of chromosome 6, which affect accuracy of preimplantation HLA typing. Present experience of preimplantation HLA typing includes preimplantation HLA typing in 180 cycles, 122 of which were done as part of PGD for Fanconi anemia, thalassemia, Wiscott-Aldrich syndrome, hyper-immunoglobulin M syndrome, hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia with immune deficiency, and X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy, and 58 for the sole purpose of HLA typing for leukemias and for aplastic and Diamond-Blackfan anemia. The applied method resulted in the accurate preselection and transfer of 100% HLA-matched embryos, yielding already three dozen clinical pregnancies and the birth of two dozen HLA-matched children to the siblings requiring stem cell transplantation. Successful therapy with HLA-matched stem cells, obtained from these PGD children, has been achieved already for Diamond-Blackfan anemia hypohidrotic ectodermal dysplasia with immune deficiency and thalassemia.

GPs' opinions of their role in prenatal genetic services: a cross-sectional survey

BACKGROUND

In the UK about 4.5% of the population carry cystic fibrosis, whilst in the inner city areas an even higher proportion carry one of the haemoglobin disorders such as thalassaemia. Couples who both carry the same recessive disorder have a 1 in 4 risk of an affected child in every pregnancy.

OBJECTIVES

To assess GPs' confidence in their ability to provide initial prenatal advice for couples carrying common autosomal recessive disorders (either the cystic fibrosis or thalassaemia gene), and their opinions of different approaches for referral to prenatal diagnostic services for such at-risk couples.

METHODS

A cross-sectional postal survey of all 644 GPs in 388 general practices in Nottinghamshire. Practices were randomly allocated to receive either the cystic fibrosis or the thalassaemia scenario survey. The survey questions predominantly used six-point Likert scales to assess confidence and opinions of prenatal services.

RESULTS

The questionnaire was returned by 62% (397) of GPs. Only 23% (91) were confident in providing prenatal advice to the at-risk carrier couples. GPs were more confident about advising cystic fibrosis carriers than thalassaemia carriers (P = 0.01). The least popular approach to prenatal service provision was direct referral to prenatal services after counselling with 52% (194) scoring this as useful, whilst 60.5% (233) of GPs scored referral to the obstetric services with the prenatal diagnosis organised by the obstetrician as useful.

CONCLUSIONS

GPs perceive that they lack the confidence to provide basic prenatal genetic advice to women at risk of the commonest recessive disorders, with particularly low confidence where the couple both carry thalassaemia. A significant knowledge gap was demonstrated by the poor awareness of the importance of rapid referral to prenatal diagnostic services.

[The Bianco and Silvestroni archive]

The Bianco and Silvestroni archive contains documents referring to the scientific and medico-social activity of the two researchers. Documents illustrate the aims and methods of campaigns directed to the control of thalassemia in Italy, obtained through the creation of a specific institution and the involvement of schools and families. A second group of documents refers to the scientific activity of the two scientists in the field of hematology and genetics.

Thalassemia: The Continued Challenge

This overview describes the history of transfusion therapy and consequent iron overload in thalassemia. It emphasizes the importance of measurement of hepatic iron and reviews the history of chelation therapy. It briefly describes the discoveries of the genetic basis of thalassemia and the application of that knowledge in prenatal diagnosis. The review goes on to emphasize pharmaceutical efforts to induce fetal hemoglobin synthesis in thalassemic red cells and ends with a discussion of oral iron chelators, stem cell transplant, and the status of gene therapy.

Keynote Address: The Challenge of Thalassemia for the Developing Countries

The thalassemias occur at some of their highest frequencies in the developing countries, particularly those of Asia. In many countries, facilities for the control of these conditions are extremely limited. Although a great deal can be done to help the situation by developing further North-South and South-South partnerships for disseminating better practice, the major problem for the future lies in the unwillingness of governments and international health agencies to accept that the thalassemias present a health burden comparable to that of other major diseases in the developing countries. However, preliminary analyses suggest that, at least in the case of Asia, this is not true. Further work of this nature, together with more detailed frequency and economic data, are required to provide solid evidence for the health burden posed by thalassemia in the developing world. Unless this is done, the large populations of patients with thalassemia in these countries will continue to be neglected.

Prenatal Diagnosis of Hemoglobinopathies in Ontario, Canada

In 1989, the Province of Ontario established a molecular diagnostic laboratory for carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis of hemoglobinopathies. Over the past 15 years, the laboratory has provided prenatal diagnosis for 672 pregnancies at-risk for severe hemoglobinopathies: 276 (41%) for homozygous beta-thalassemia or hemoglobin (Hb) E/beta-thalassemia, 211 (31%) for homozygous alpha 0-thalassemia (Hb Bart's hydrops fetalis), and/or Hb H disease, and 185 (28%) for various sickling disorders (Hb SS, Hb SC, Hb S/beta-thalassemia). Despite the availability of services for carrier screening, genetic counseling, and prenatal diagnosis, there has been only a modest reduction in the overall incidence of hemoglobinopathies in Ontario.

Antenatal screening for haemoglobinopathies in primary care: a whole system participatory action research project

BACKGROUND

The usual system for antenatal screening for haemoglobinopathies permits termination only late in the second trimester of pregnancy.

AIM

To evaluate a system where pregnant women are screened in general practice, and to develop a model of care pathway or whole system research able to bring into view unexpected effects of health service innovation.

DESIGN OF STUDY

A whole system participatory action research approach was used. Six purposefully chosen general practices screened women who attended with a new pregnancy. Data of gestational age of screening were compared with two control groups. Qualitative data were gathered through workshops, interviews and feedback to the project steering group. At facilitated annual workshops participants from all parts of the care pathway produced a consensus about the meaning of the data as a whole.

SETTING

Six general practices in north London.

METHOD

A whole system participatory action research approach allowed stakeholders from throughout the care pathway to pilot the innovation and reflect on the meaning and significance of quantitative and qualitative data.

RESULTS

The gestational age of screening in general practice was 4.1 weeks earlier (95% confidence interval (CI) = 3.41 to 4.68) than in hospital clinics (P<0.001), and 2.9 weeks earlier (95% CI = 2.07 to 3.65) than in community midwife clinics (P <0.001). However, only 35% of pregnant women in the study were screened in the practices. Changes required throughout the whole care pathway make wider implementation more difficult than at first realised. The cost within general practice is greater than initially appreciated owing to a perceived need to provide counselling about other issues at the same time. Practitioners considered that other ways of early screening should be explored, including preconceptual screening. The research approach was able to bring into view unexpected effects of the innovation, but health workers were unfamiliar with the participatory processes.

CONCLUSION

Antenatal screening for haemoglobinopathies in general practice lowers the gestational age at which an at-risk pregnancy can be identified. However, widespread implementation of such screening may be too difficult.

Estimating the attitude of immigrants toward primary prevention of the hemoglobinopathies

OBJECTIVES

We conducted population specific confidential enquiries among immigrants who had never experienced hemoglobinopathies, to study the reliability of this approach in estimating the wish for primary prevention by prenatal diagnosis and selective abortion.

METHODS

We collected data from Surinamese Hindustanis (n = 119), Surinamese and Antillean Afro-Americans (n = 105) and North Africans (mainly Moroccans) (n = 102), living in Holland. We also interviewed 105 informed individuals of different ethnicities, all members of the multi-ethnic patients and carriers' organization 'OSCAR Nederland'.

RESULTS

On average, 68% of the Surinamese Hindustanis and 42% of the Surinamese Afro-Americans were in favor of selective abortion in case of affected pregnancy. Remarkably, 77% of the last group wanted to be tested for carrier diagnostics and 67% declared to have knowledge of the disease before they were informed. Only 16% of the Moroccans were in favor of selective abortion in case of an affected fetus, while 79% wanted to have blood analysis to establish their carrier status.

CONCLUSIONS

The apparently limited wish for selective abortion expressed by Moroccans is in contrast with the high number of illegal abortions reported among married women in Morocco (39%). The wish for selective abortion among informed members of the patients' organization was more than 80%.

Iranian national thalassaemia screening programme

Iran's experience shows that genetic screening can be successful in lower resource countries and also provides some lessons for high resource nations

Assessing Ethnicity in Preconception Counseling: Genetics-What Nurse Practitioners Need to Know

PURPOSE

To define and discuss five genetic disorders--Tay-Sachs, sickle cell anemia, Canavan's disease, thalassemia, and cystic fibrosis (CF)--and to explain the importance of the nurse practitioner's (NP's) assessment of clients' ethnicity during preconception counseling, which should address these genetic conditions.

DATA SOURCES

Review of literature from professional journals, professional organizations' Web sites, guidelines from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the National Institute of Health Consensus Statement, and the authors' professional clinical experience.

CONCLUSIONS

The goal of preconception counseling is to identify potential or actual medical, psychological, or social conditions that may affect the mother or fetus. NPs are often the health care providers that initiate preconception counseling to women in varied primary care settings. NPs must be familiar with ethnicity-related inheritable conditions in order to provide appropriate client information and education and to implement testing and, when needed, referral for genetic counseling to individuals and families at risk for genetic disorders such as Tay-Sachs, Canavan's disease, CF, sickle cell anemia, and thalassemia.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

NPs providing health care to women of child-bearing age should assess the client's use of contraception and intent for future pregnancy. Preconception counseling when indicated should be initiated to all women to increase their potential for healthy pregnancy outcomes. Although a comprehensive personal, family, medical, and psychosocial history and initiation of folic acid are the mainstays of preconception counseling, assessment for risk of ethnicity-related genetic conditions must also be included in prepregnancy health care.

A simplified screening strategy for thalassaemia and haemoglobin E in rural communities in south-east Asia

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate a simple screening strategy for thalassaemia and haemoglobin (Hb) E in a prevention and control programme for thalassaemia in rural communities with limited resources.

METHODS

Blood samples from 301 Thai-Khmer participants were screened for thalassaemia and Hb E using a combined modified one-tube osmotic fragility (OF) test and a modified dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIP) precipitation test. Results were evaluated with standard haematological analyses including erythrocyte indices, Hb typing and quantification and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of alpha-globin and beta-globin genes.

FINDINGS

Participants were divided into four groups according to the results of the combined tests. Altogether, 104 of 301 participants (34.6%) had negative results on both tests; 48 (15.9%) were positive on the OF test but not the DCIP test; 40 (13.3%) were negative on the OF test but positive on DCIP test; and 109 (36.2%) were positive on both tests. No carrier of clinically significant forms of thalassaemia (alpha(o)-thalassaemia, beta-thalassaemia) or Hb E was found among the group that had negative results for both tests. All participants with Hb E had positive DCIP tests. Carriers of alpha+-thalassaemia or Hb Constant Spring could generate either positive or negative OF test results but they all had negative DCIP tests. Using both tests as a preliminary screening for the three important groups of carriers gave a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 69.8%. The positive predictive value of the combined test was 77.2%. The negative predictive value was 100%. Further evaluation of the screening system by local staff at three community hospitals found a sensitivity of 98.1-100% and a specificity of 65.4-88.4% with positive predictive values of 75.0-86.9% and negative predictive values of 98.1-100%.

CONCLUSION

A combined test using OF and DCIP could be used as an effective preliminary screening alternative to an electronic blood cell count for identifying carriers with alpha(o)-thalassaemia, beta-thalassaemia and Hb E. The strategy should prove useful for population screening in prevention and control programmes in rural communities in south-east Asia where laboratory facilities and economic resources are limited.

Prevention of thalassemia: experiences from Samui Island

Thalassemia is one of the most important genetic disorders in Thailand. A model for prevention of thalassemia by combining 4 strategies including education, carrier screening, counseling and prenatal diagnosis was developed by a thalassemia task force. A thalassemia work group was formed in order to develop a mechanism to integrate the model for real use on Samui Island where thalassemia is common and a specific disease oriented program is required. 200 health professionals working on Samui Island participated in the thalassemia educational courses. The specific training courses were also provided for obstreticians, medical technologists and counselors. A team of well-trained health professionals was established to manage public education. Information booklets, posters, brochures and mass media including spot radio and newspapers were used as educational materials. For carrier screening, blood samples of pregnant women from all health care organizations on Samui Island were collected and screened for thalassemia carriers by using the osmotic fragility (OF) test/the dichlorophenol indophenol precipitation (DCIP) tests at Samui Hospital. Samples with positive results were sent to the Regional Medical Sciences Center in Surat Thani for thalassemia diagnosis. When a carrier was identified, her spouse was offered testing. For at-risk couples, details of the disorder were included in counseling to help them reach a decision that was right to them, in the context of their unique medical, moral and social situations. Amniotic fluid samples were collected for prenatal diagnosis. All patient information was registered by using computer software. After 1 year of integration by using facilities of the Ministry of Public Health service system, a wide range of problems were identified. They underlined the need for effective health service structure co-operation, adequate education of responsible health professionals, explicit policies and a clear line of responsibility at local, regional and national levels for service development and quality management. It is hoped that all information conducted in the present study will be useful to health authorities to develop an explicit policy and promote the health service structure co-operation in the country that will finally lead to successfully reducing the frequency of severe thalassemia in the future.

Prevention and control of thalassemia at Saraburi Regional Hospital

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the program in prevention and control of thalssemia among pregnant women and their spouses, prevention of new cases by screening tests, confirmatory test, genetic counselling, prenatal diagnosis, and selective abortion.

SUBJECTS

The pregnant women, attending antenatal care unit, Saraburi center hospital, as well as their spouses. 1 January 2000-31 December 2001

METHOD

As part of the antenatal care assessment, pregnant women before 16 weeks gestation were screened, with pre- and post-test counselling, by osmotic fragility (OF) and dichorophenol indophenol precipitate (DCIP) tests, and confirmed by complete blood count (CBC), mean corpuscular volume (MCV), hemoglobin typing and polymerase chain reaction for alphathal1 (PCR alphathal1) if any of two screening tests was positive. The husbands of those who were carriers of severe thalassemia were encouraged to have thalassemia screening and confirmation. When both the pregnant women and their husbands were carriers of severe thalassemia, the pregnant women would voluntarily perform the prenatal diagnosis. Termination of pregnancy would be offered when the fetus had severe thalassemia.

RESULTS

There were 3,739 from 4,214 women (88.7% of all antenatal women), who participated in the program. OF and/or DCIP were positive in 1,742 of 3,739 subjects (46.5%). Of those, 960 from 1,742 (55.1%), had husbands who were willing to have the testing, and OF and/or DCIP were positive in 443 of 960 cases (46.1%). The confirmatory tests revealed carrier and disease of thalassemia, and hemoglobinopathies in 931 of 1,742 women (53.9%), and 135 of 960 husbands (14.0%). The 20 couples who had the possibility of having severe thalassemic newborns, were strongly advised to have prenatal diagnosis. The 12 risk pregnancies had been performed cordocentesis. Finally 3 of 12 (25.0%) fetuses were documented to have severe thalassemia and all of them decided to have selective abortion.

CONCLUSIONS

The screening model for thalassemia carriers by using the combination of OF and DCIP is the easy screening model. It can be done quickly, it is inexpensive, therefore it is suitable for large numbers of population screening. The systematic screening, confirmatory of thalassemia diagnosis and prenatal diagnosis are the measure of thalassemia prevention and control, and aims to decrease the number of newborns with severe thalassemia.

A community-based thalassemia prevention and control model in northern Thailand

OBJECTIVE

To describe a community-based model for prevention and control of thalassemias and haemoglobinopathies in northern Thailand.

DESIGN

Operational research composed of two components. First, a model to test whether thalassemic cases and carriers could be retrospectively detected from school children. Second, a model for prevention of prospective cases of thalassemic babies among pregnant women.

SETTING

Phan District of Chiang Rai Province in northern Thailand.

SUBJECTS

Component one: 5,617 preschool children and 21,123 school children were screened during May and July 1997. Component two: 256 pregnant women, 16 weeks or less gestation were screened during January and December 1997.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

Component one: Sub-district public health officers and school teachers were trained to use pictures and simple clinical examination to detect suspected thalassemics among preschool and school children. Suspected cases were then referred for further clinical examination and blood testing. Blood smear examination was done at the Phan Community Hospital but Hb typing lusing on electrophoresis was done at the provincial hospital. The cellulose acetate was sent for re-reading at the Department of Medical Sciences. Component two: Osmotic fragility (OF) and dichlorophenol-indolephenol (DCIP) tests were abol in pregnant women (< or = 16 weeks of gestation) in the Phan Community Hospital. If OF test was positive, Hb typing was done at a regional medical sciences center. Their spouses were also located and tested for Hb typing. Prenatal diagnosis was done and therapeutic abortion was offered, if indicated.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Cases, carriers, suspected cases, Hb typing, OF and DCIP tests.

RESULTS

In Component one: 26,740 children were screened of whom 893 cases were suspected. Out of those suspected, 296 (33.2%) were normal, 140 (15.6%) were diseased, and 457 (51.2%) were carriers. 56 cases had major thalassemia diseases. Their parents were counseled. Forty couples were determined to need some form of family planning and 39 (97.5%) accepted. In Component two: 256 pregnant women were screened and 56 were found to be carriers. Only 45 husbands could be located and Hb typed. Five couples were determined to require prenatal diagnosis (PND). One happened to undergo therapeutic abortion because of HIV infection in the mother without PND. Of the four who underwent PND, one was found to have a fetus with major thalassemia. However, this couple refused therapeutic abortion because of religious reasons.

CONCLUSION

This study combined both prospective and retrospective approaches and can be considered successful. However, as the only available option for pregnant women with affected fetuses is therapeutic abortion, this makes it difficult to expand the program because abortion may not be acceptable in certain communities. In addition, this model requires PND and other laboratory and clinical facilities as backups. Such backups may not be available in certain settings.

Genetic Blood Disorders Survey in the Sultanate of Oman

The Genetic Blood Disorders Survey is the first community-based survey in the Arabic world and the Middle East to determine the prevalence of the most common genetic blood disorders. The objective of the survey was to determine the prevalence of the most common genetic blood disorders reported among Omani children under 5 years of age in order to provide the planners and policy-makers with reliable information suitable for formulating health policies, planning, and evaluation. The survey was designed, executed, and financed by the Ministry of Health of the Sultanate of Oman. To reduce costs and save effort and time, data collection for the survey was implemented with the Gulf Family Health Survey (GFHS). The GFHS in the Sultanate of Oman is a research project undertaken by the Council of Health Ministers of the Gulf Co-operation Council States. The six member countries have participated in this GFHS project. A total of 6103 households were interviewed. From these households 6342 children under 5 years of age were taken by their parents to neighbourhood hospitals or health centres for blood collection. Fifty-one per cent of the sample were male and 49 per cent were female. Among the child respondents, 17.9 per cent were in the age group 0 to < 1 year, 20.3 per cent were in the age group 1 to < 2 years, 21.1 per cent were in the age group 2 to < 3 years, 20.5 per cent were in the age group 3 to < 4 years, and 20.2 per cent were in the age group 4 to 5 years. Fifty-five per cent of the mothers of the children studied were illiterate, 9 per cent could read and write but had less than primary education, 20 per cent had completed primary school, 9 per cent had attended preparatory school, 5 per cent had attended secondary school, 1 per cent had had intermediate education, while 0.6 per cent had completed university or higher education. The results of this survey revealed that haemoglobinopathies are prevalent in Oman; the prevalence of sickle cell trait was 6 per cent, and of beta-thalassaemia 2 per cent. The prevalence of sickle cell and homozygous beta-thalassaemia were 0.2 and 0.07 per cent, respectively. Other abnormal haemoglobins (Hb) have been detected in this survey; HbD (0.6 per cent), HbE (0.3 per cent), HbC (0.02 per cent). Combination of sickle cell with other abnormal Hb was also detected at low prevalence. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) enzyme deficiency had a high prevalence in Oman, being 25 per cent in males and 10 per cent in females. Among the children studied, three-quarters (74.5 per cent) were found to be free from haemoglobinopathies and G6PD normal, the rest (25.5 per cent), either had haemoglobinopathies (7.5 per cent), G6PD deficiency (16 per cent) or a combination of G6PD deficiency with at least one abnormal Hb (2 per cent). The prevalence of total haemoglobinopathies in Oman was 9.5 per cent. The prevalence of sickle cell trait varied between regions, North Sharqiya had the highest prevalence of 10 per cent. Dakhiliya (9 per cent), followed by Muscat and South Batinah 8 and 7.9 per cent, respectively. The prevalence of sickle cell trait declined by a half in Musandam, South Sharqiya, Dhahira, and North Batinah (4.7, 3.9, 3.9, and 2.9 per cent respectively). Dhofar had the lowest prevalence of 0.2 per cent and no cases of sickle cell trait were found in the Al-Wousta region in the sample selected. The prevalence of beta-thalassaemia trait ranged from 3.9 to 0.2 per cent. Three regions had high rates: North Batinah (3.9 per cent), Muscat (2.8 per cent), and Dakhiliya (2 per cent). The other five regions in the Sultanate have lower rates: Dhahira (1.7 per cent), Musandam (1.6 per cent), South Batinah (1.5 per cent), South Sharqiya (1.2 per cent), and North Sharqiya (1.1 per cent). The prevalence of beta-thalassaemia trait in Dhofar was 0.2 per cent and no cases were detected in the Al-Wousta region. The prevalence of G6PD deficiency reached 29 per cent in Dakhiliya, 26 per cent in South Batinah, 21 per cent in Dhahira, 19 per cent in Muscat and 17 per cent in North Sharqiya and North Batinah. The prevalence declined to 10 per cent in Musandam, 9 per cent in South Sharqiya, Dhofar had the lowest prevalence of 2 per cent and no cases of G6PD deficiency were found in Al-Wousta. The male to female ratio was 2.5:1. In all regions of the Sultanate, prevalence of G6PD deficiency in males were more than twice those in females. From the above rates, it could be calculated that in the whole Sultanate 44,733 children under 5 years of age have G6PD deficiency, 14,306 have sickle cell trait, 474 have sickle cell disease, 5393 have beta-thalassaemia trait, and 175 have beta-thalassaemia major. The study showed that the mean Hb level of children under 5 years of age was 10.9 g/dl for both males and females; the mean Hb level for males was 10.89 g/dl and for females 10.99 g/dl, the difference between males and females was significant. The study revealed that half of the children under 5 years of age were anaemic. Mild anaemia was predominant (46 per cent), while moderate and severe anaemia were 4 and 0.2 per cent respectively. The status of anaemia among children improved with age; mild anaemia was prevalent in 65 per cent of children between ages 0 to < or = 1 years then decreased with age until it reached 30 per cent at 4-5 years of age. The survey produced the first normal haematological indices for children under 5 years of age to be used as a reference in the country. The blood picture of the normal subjects in the survey showed that the mean Hb value for males was 11.9 g/dl and for females 11.8 g/dl. The children had reduced values of MCH and MCV compared to normal international values, the reason for this could be alpha-thalassaemia or iron deficiency. The children maintained high values of HbF (more than 1.2 per cent) even after their first birthday. HbF reached its normal level at 5 years of age. Marriage of first cousins among the parents of the children studied under 5 years of age was 34 per cent. Total consanguinity rate including second cousin relationships and beyond was 58 per cent. We recommend that a national prevention programme for genetic blood disorders be formulated by the authorities. The programme could be included in the Ministry of Health 5-year health development programme for prevention of non-communicable diseases which already exists.

Student screening for inherited blood disorders in Bahrain

In Bahrain and neighbouring countries inherited disorders of haemoglobin, i.e. sickle-cell disease, thalassaemias and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) deficiency, are common. As part of the National Student Screening Project to determine the prevalence of genetic blood disorders and raise awareness among young Bahrainis, we screened 11th-grade students from 38 schools (5685 students), organized lectures and distributed information about these disorders. Haemoglobin electrophoresis, high performance liquid chromatography, blood grouping and G6PD deficiency testing were performed. Prevalences were: 1.2% sickle-cell disease; 13.8% sickle-cell trait; 0.09% beta-thalassaemia; 2.9% beta-thalassaemia trait; 23.2% G6PD deficiency; 1.9% G6PD deficiency carrier. Health education, carrier screening and premarital counselling remain the best ways to reduce disease incidence with potentially significant financial savings and social and health benefits.

Feasibility of thalassaemia control by extended family screening in Indian context

Thalassaemia is one of the most common genetic disorders in India. Its control is possible by screening of general population for carrier status and by antenatal diagnosis in couples at risk of having a child with thalassaemia. This study explored the feasibility of screening the extended family to detect carriers to prevent birth of thalassaemic children and identified the barriers to its acceptance. One hundred parents with thalassaemic child on a regular hypertransfusion programme were interviewed using a pre-designed questionnaire. The results showed that 96% of them were more willing to share information on their thalassaemic children with relatives and friends. Relatives of 62 parents accepted the risk of being a carrier, and 14 families got themselves tested for it so far. Another 34 families could not get themselves tested due to non-availability of screening facilities in the nearby town, high cost of the test, and lack of sufficient motivation. It is concluded that, by and large, parents have no reservations in sharing information on their affected children with their relatives, but the communication needs to be improved for all families to accept the risk of having a thalassaemic child. There is also a need to make the screening more readily available and to motivate high-risk groups through awareness-raising programmes.

Preventation of thalassemia in Australia

Screening for thalassemia and other hemoglobinopathies in the major maternity hospitals in Melbourne, Australia has shown that 6% of the patient population carries a clinically significant genetic abnormality. The most common of these are beta-thalassemia (3%). HbS (1.8%), HbE (0.5%) and alpha0 thalassemia (0.4%). Approximately 60 prenatal diagnoses for the clinically significant combinations of these abnormal genes are performed annually in the 2 major centers of Melbourne and Sydney. The majority of these prenatal diagnoses are for beta-thalassemia major (65%). whilst 11% are for Bart's hydrops fetalis, 8% for HbE/beta-thalassemia. 6% for HbS/beta-thalassemia, 2% for sickle cell anemia and the remaining 8% for other combinations of thalassemia/hemoglobinopathies. Of the 178 patients with beta-thalassemia major, sickle cell disease or beta-thalassemia in combination with HbE or HbS, only 5 are less than 5 years old, reflecting both the success of the screening program and the increasing acceptance by couples of 1st trimester prenatal diagnosis.

Genetic counseling for thalassemia in Thailand: problems and solutions

Thalassemia, a hereditary anemia, has been a major public health problem in Thailand and Southeast Asia for decades, yet the prevalence of thalassemia in Thailand is not decreasing due to lack of awareness of this disease in Thai population, which implied that genetic counseling was a failure. We determined the problems and obstacles in thalassemia counseling in Thailand and proposed the possible solutions in order to deliver genetic counseling and services to the communities more efficiently. A survey in thalassemia services was carried out in 12 hospitals; 9 in Bangkok, 3 in the North, Northeast, and South of Thailand respectively, by using questionnaire designed to assess the healthcare system, characteristics of target population, methods of genetic counseling, knowledge and attitudes of counselors, thalassemia support group, and researches in thalassemia, in a cross-sectional descriptive research design. The main problems in genetic counseling for thalassemia in Thailand are the followings; thalassemia problems not visible to the administrators, unorganized teamwork and services, lack of knowledge and inadequate numbers of counselors, lack of thalassemia support group, and inadequate researches in thalassemia prevention and control. The possible solutions are proposed. This study has pointed out the unseen problems and obstacles, along with the solutions in genetic counseling, given correctly, will help create awareness of thalassemia impact on health and socioeconomics in the Thai population. Thus, genetic counseling, with well-established guidelines, is a critical component for the success of prevention and control of thalassemia in Thailand.

Prevention and control of thalassemia in Ramathibodi Hospital, Thailand

Eight thousand seven hundred and thirty-six pregnant women were screened for thalassemia and hemoglobinopathies by mean corpuscular volume less than 80 femtolitres (fl). Three thousand six hundred and seventy women (42%) were MCV less than 80 fl. In this group there were 2,390 women (70%) who had positive Hb typing by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) such as beta-thalassemia major, beta-thalassemia hemoglobin E disease, beta-thalassemia trait, heterozygous and homozygous hemoglobin E, alpha-thalassemia-1 trait and hemoglobin H disease and 77% of their partners came and had hemoglobin typing done. Seventy-five couples at risk for having severely affected thalassemia fetuses were detected from this screening program. Prenatal diagnosis was performed in 58 couples (77.3%). Eight affected fetuses were detected. All pregnancies with affected fetuses except one with beta-thalassemia/HbE were terminated. There were 3 fetal losses (6%) as the result of prenatal diagnosis procedure.

Informed choice in genetic screening for thalassaemia during pregnancy: audit from a national confidential inquiry

OBJECTIVE

National audit of informed choice in antenatal screening for thalassaemia.

DESIGN

Audit from the UK Confidential Enquiry into Counselling for Genetic Disorders.

SETTING

Thalassaemia module of the UK Confidential Enquiry into Counselling for Genetic Disorders.

SUBJECTS

138 of 156 couples who had had a pregnancy affected by a major beta thalassaemia from 1990 to 1994.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

How and when genetic risk was identified for each couple, and whether and when prenatal diagnosis was offered.

RESULTS

Risk was detected by screening before or during the first pregnancy in 49% (68/138) of couples and by diagnosis of an affected child in 28% (38/138) of couples. Prenatal diagnosis was offered in 69% (274/400) of pregnancies, ranging from 94% (122/130) for British Cypriots to 54% (80/149) for British Pakistanis and from 90% in the south east of England to 39% in the West Midlands. Uptake of prenatal diagnosis was 80% (216/274), ranging from 98% (117/120) among British Cypriots in either the first or second trimester to 73% (35/48) among British Pakistanis in the first trimester and 39% (11/28) in the second trimester. A demonstrable service failure occurred in 28% (110/400) of pregnancies, including 110 of 126 where prenatal diagnosis was not offered and 48 of 93 that ended with an affected liveborn infant.

CONCLUSION

Although antenatal screening and counselling for haemoglobin disorders are standard practices in the United Kingdom, they are delivered inadequately and inequitably. An explicit national policy is needed, aiming to make prenatal diagnosis in the first trimester available to all couples and including ongoing national audit.

Prepregnancy testing for single-gene disorders by polar body analysis

Preventive measures for single-gene disorders are currently based on carrier screening in pregnancy and prenatal diagnosis. Although this has been extremely effective for preventing new cases of common inherited conditions, the major limitation is still termination of 25% of wanted pregnancies following detection of affected fetuses. To overcome this important problem, we developed a method for prepregnancy genetic testing that involves DNA analysis of the first and second polar bodies, which are extruded during maturation and fertilization of oocytes. We offered this option to 28 couples at risk for having children with single-gene disorders. Fifty clinical cycles were performed from these patients for the following conditions: 20 for cystic fibrosis, 18 for thalassemia, 6 for sickle cell disease, 2 each for Gaucher disease and LCHAD (long-chain 3-hydroxyacyl-COA dehydrogenase deficiency), and 1 each for hemophilia B and phenylketonuria. Oocytes obtained from these patients using in vitro fertilization procedures (IVF) were tested by a sequential multiplex nested PCR analysis of the first and second polar body to detect the gene involved simultaneously with linked polymorphic markers. A total of 191 of 399 oocytes with predicted genotype were mutation free and preselected for fertilization and transfer. In all but three cycles, one to three unaffected embryos with predicted unaffected genotypes were transferred, resulting in 20 pregnancies, from which 19 healthy children have been born. The follow-up analysis of embryos resulting from oocytes with predicted affected genotype, confirmed the diagnosis in 97% of cases, demonstrating the reliability of prepregnancy diagnosis of single-gene defects by polar body analysis.

Cost-benefit analysis of a national thalassaemia prevention programme in Israel

OBJECTIVE

In Israel (population 5.7 million) there are around 200 known living subjects with thalassaemia major, of whom around 80% are from the northern district. This study aims at examining the costs and benefits of a national screening programme to prevent thalassaemia in Israel.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The lifetime healthcare costs of caring for a person born with thalassaemia major are $284,154. The costs of the home infusion service (33.1%) actually exceed the costs of the chelating agent itself (22.1%). The remaining 44.8% of costs are due to stay in hospital, operations, outpatient visits, laboratory tests, therapists, etc. Lost earnings and premature mortality costs account for a further $51,843 and $141,944 respectively for each case. A national screening programme would cost $900,197 and prevent around 13.4 homozygotes being born, at a cost of $67,369 for each birth prevented. The benefit-cost ratio of the programme to the health services is 4.22:1, which increases to 6.01:1 when a societal perspective is taken. However, around 13.0 homozygote births are still expected to occur, the majority owing to lack of compliance of patients at various stages in the screening process. The addition of a national health education programme for the higher risk non-Jewish population either nationally or in selected regions will incur extra costs, which may be covered by increased benefits as a result of better compliance with the screening programme.

CONCLUSION

Israel should start to provide a nationwide thalassaemia screening programme as the monetary benefits to society (and even to the health services alone) will exceed the screening programmes costs.

Screening for thalassemia: an economics viewpoint

Thalassemia presents individual, social and economic burdens: a key question is whether medical and economic viewpoints converge or not. Using precise molecular probes, prenatal diagnosis of the various thalassemia genotypes is available in the case of parents who are known carriers, so identified because of a previous affected child or a positive family genetic history. However, the ideal option of prevention of the birth of a first affected child requires community screening. The only practical approach thereto is prenatal screening of women in early pregnancy at ante-natal clinics (ANC). The initial steps (OF, DCIP) are simple, cheap and easily coupled with standard prenatal procedures. In the second phase, spouse screening, compliance is suboptimal and involves non-routine opportunity costs. Subsequent steps (secondary screening of positive pairs, genotyping of positives, and fetal diagnosis [PND]) represent greater costs to provider and consumer, and, as they are relatively expensive, reduced compliance at each step if the major part of the economic burden (direct and indirect costs) is to be borne by the consumer. Thus, only a proportion of cases is likely to face the final decision to terminate pregnancy or not. Some broad estimates of costs of each phase (ANC-->PND) have been made for comparison with the estimated costs of case management of the several thalassemia disease classes for their projected lifetimes, while several more detailed studies are in progress to fine tune the real costs (direct and indirect) of diagnosis. In a purely economic sense the situation presents opportunity to consider trade-offs between PND and disease case management, in terms of benefit:cost ratio. Viewed from a health systems vantage point this ratio depends substantially on compliance, as the system must consider the cost of caring for all thalassemia cases, including those births which could have been avoided by optimal compliance. In ideal circumstances the rough estimates indicate a probable benefit:cost ratio > 1, supporting the notion of community-based screening. Such a result, however, compares procedures in a short, finite time frame (diagnosis) with a less predictable, longer life-time (case management), requiring bureaucratic flexibility (if the public provider is to pay) or family emotional/fiscal investment (if the consumer is to pay) or both (cost-sharing): either way there is an inescapable element of long term investment planning that requires squaring off of the emotional, social and fiscal ingredients in the equation. In this sense the thalassemia syndromes represent an example of decision-making pathways involved in assessing and handling chronic disease burdens at family, community and national levels: at the latter level regional incidence varies considerably, a geopolitical factor which may require differential demographic planning.

Thalassemic syndromes in Latium: epidemiological evaluation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

After the first National Census of transfusion-dependent thalassemics (1984), in 1992 the Italian Association of Pediatric Hematology and Oncology and the National Health Institute organized its 3rd edition. Here, results concerning Latium are presented and discussed.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Data for Latium, as in the rest of Italy, were collected by a single reference center; among all eventual care centers for thalassemia initially contacted, only those with patients were sent data forms. For new cases, a questionnaire was submitted to parents to obtaining social data, and information on their knowledge of thalassemia.

RESULTS

Collected data were divided into 2 groups: old cases, before June 30, 1988, and new cases, between July 1, 1988 and December 31, 1992. On the whole, 262 transfusion-dependent thalassemics (127 m., 135 f.) could be counted. Sixteen percent were affected with thalassemia intermedia, severe enough as to need regular transfusions. New patients (last 5 years): the birth of almost 80% of them was due to combined mistakes of parents and doctors. Disease evolution: 19/262 patients had been submitted to BMT (presently transfusion-free). Causes of death: 22 patients died in the considered period, mostly for cardiologic complications.

INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS

Data emerging from censuses on specific pathologies of high social impact (such as thalassemia) may help health plans to rationalize public expenditure, especially by improving working conditions of care centers.