Error rate for HLA-B antigen assignment by serology: implications for proficiency testing and utilization of DNA-based typing methods

Correlation and agreement between eplet mismatches calculated using serological, low-intermediate and high resolution molecular human leukocyte antigen typing methods

Structural human leukocyte antigen (HLA) matching at the eplet level can be identified by HLAMatchmaker, which requires the entry of four-digit alleles. The aim of this study was to evaluate the agreement between eplet mismatches calculated by serological and two-digit typing methods compared to high-resolution four-digit typing. In a cohort of 264 donor/recipient pairs, the evaluation of measurement error was assessed using intra-class correlation to confirm the absolute agreement between the number of eplet mismatches at class I (HLA-A, -B, C) and II loci (HLA-DQ and -DR) calculated using serological or two-digit molecular typing compared to four-digit molecular typing methods. The proportion of donor/recipient pairs with a difference of >5 eplet mismatches between the HLA typing methods was also determined. Intra-class correlation coefficients between serological and four-digit molecular typing methods were 0.969 (95% confidence intervals [95% CI] 0.960–0.975) and 0.926 (95% CI 0.899–0.944), respectively; and 0.995 (95% CI 0.994–0.996) and 0.993 (95% CI 0.991–0.995), respectively between two-digit and four-digit molecular typing methods. The proportion of donor/recipient pairs with a difference of >5 eplet mismatches at class I and II loci was 4% and 16% for serological versus four-digit molecular typing methods, and 0% and 2% for two-digit versus four-digit molecular typing methods, respectively. In this small predominantly Caucasian population, compared with serology, there is a high level of agreement in the number of eplet mismatches calculated using two-compared to four-digit molecular HLA-typing methods, suggesting that two-digit typing may be sufficient in determining eplet mismatch load in kidney transplantation.

Matching for Human Leukocyte Antigens (HLA) in corneal transplantation - to do or not to do

As many patients with severe corneal disease are not even considered as candidates for a human graft due to their high risk of rejection, it is essential to find ways to reduce the chance of rejection. One of the options is proper matching of the cornea donor and recipient for the Human Leukocyte Antigens (HLA), a subject of much debate. Currently, patients receiving their first corneal allograft are hardly ever matched for HLA and even patients undergoing a regraft usually do not receive an HLA-matched graft. While anterior and posterior lamellar grafts are not immune to rejection, they are usually performed in low risk, non-vascularized cases. These are the cases in which the immune privilege due to the avascular status and active immune inhibition is still intact. Once broken due to infection, sensitization or trauma, rejection will occur. There is enough data to show that when proper DNA-based typing techniques are being used, even low risk perforating corneal transplantations benefit from matching for HLA Class I, and high risk cases from HLA Class I and probably Class II matching. Combining HLA class I and class II matching, or using the HLAMatchmaker could further improve the effect of HLA matching. However, new techniques could be applied to reduce the chance of rejection. Options are the local or systemic use of biologics, or gene therapy, aiming at preventing or suppressing immune responses. The goal of all these approaches should be to prevent a first rejection, as secondary grafts are usually at higher risk of complications including rejections than first grafts.

HLA-A2, HLA-B44 and HLA-DR15 are associated with lower risk of BK viremia

BACKGROUND

Human leucocyte antigens (HLAs) modulate immunity to polyomavirus BK (BKV). Identification of HLAs that alter the course of infection will facilitate risk stratification, and customization of pre-emptive intervention strategies.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective cohort study with 998 kidney transplant patients with BKV infection status confirmed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Clinical parameters and donor-recipient matching for specific HLAs were examined in relation to occurrence of viremia. An emphasis was placed on donor-recipient matching rather than the actual frequency of specific HLA-alleles, since a successful immune response requires sharing of HLAs between a virus-infected target cell and the anti-viral effector cell.

RESULTS

Using multivariate statistics, low risk of BK viremia was associated with matching of HLA-A2 [hazard ratio (HR) 0.51, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.28-0.85], HLA-B44 (HR 0.31, 95% CI 0.076-0.85) and HLA-DR15 (HR 0.35, 95% CI 0.084-0.93) (P < 0.05), whereas high risk of viremia was associated with male gender (HR 2.38, 95% CI 1.46-4.09, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

HLAs that associated with a lower predisposition to the development of BK viremia have been identified. Evaluation of donor-recipient mismatching for these HLAs could potentially be used to (i) fine tune virus screening strategies for BKV in individual patients and (ii) facilitate discovery of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and II binding peptides that can elicit clinically meaningful BKV-specific immunity.

HLA-A2, HLA-B44 and HLA-DR15 are associated with lower risk of BK viremia

BACKGROUND

Human leucocyte antigens (HLAs) modulate immunity to polyomavirus BK (BKV). Identification of HLAs that alter the course of infection will facilitate risk stratification, and customization of pre-emptive intervention strategies.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective cohort study with 998 kidney transplant patients with BKV infection status confirmed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Clinical parameters and donor-recipient matching for specific HLAs were examined in relation to occurrence of viremia. An emphasis was placed on donor-recipient matching rather than the actual frequency of specific HLA-alleles, since a successful immune response requires sharing of HLAs between a virus-infected target cell and the anti-viral effector cell.

RESULTS

Using multivariate statistics, low risk of BK viremia was associated with matching of HLA-A2 [hazard ratio (HR) 0.51, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.28-0.85], HLA-B44 (HR 0.31, 95% CI 0.076-0.85) and HLA-DR15 (HR 0.35, 95% CI 0.084-0.93) (P < 0.05), whereas high risk of viremia was associated with male gender (HR 2.38, 95% CI 1.46-4.09, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

HLAs that associated with a lower predisposition to the development of BK viremia have been identified. Evaluation of donor-recipient mismatching for these HLAs could potentially be used to (i) fine tune virus screening strategies for BKV in individual patients and (ii) facilitate discovery of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and II binding peptides that can elicit clinically meaningful BKV-specific immunity.

Strategies and technical challenges in allele level Class II typing in 2578 bone marrow transplantation donor-recipient pairs

Human leukocyte antigen typing of 2578 donor-recipient pairs whose transplantation was facilitated by the National Marrow Donor Program allowed for an in-depth analysis of the accuracy of high-volume allele level testing data. The methods employed provided allele level typing at DRB1/3/5, DQA1, DQB1, DPA1, and DPB1 using sequence-specific oligonucleotide probe hybridization (SSOPH), polymerase chain reaction (PCR) restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis, sequence specific PCR, and direct sequence-based typing (SBT). Each typing was independently tested by two laboratories in Phase 1, and in subsequent phases targeted samples were typed in duplicate by SBT to monitor typing quality. Comparison with prior transplant center typing was also evaluated. SSOPH detected discrepancies ranged from 0.6% at DPB1 to 5.1% at DQB1 in Phase 1. The majority of discrepancies, 62%, resulted from human error such as sample handling, result interpretation, or clerical errors. Alleles that are frequently discrepant have been identified in this predominantly white population.

Real-Time PCR Using Fluorescent Resonance Emission Transfer Probes for HLA-B Typing

HLA genotyping by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has some inherent labor-intensive and effort-demanding limitations. To overcome them, we have developed a real-time PCR with hybridization probes approach able to obtain a medium-low resolution HLA-B genotyping with fewer tubes and probes and with a shorter time requirement. Our strategy used 18 simultaneous reactions amplifying HLA-B alleles and an internal control. Monitorization of both amplifications in each tube is performed by the simultaneous application of two fluorescent resonance emission transfer probes: the first probe, different for each tube, is specific for the HLA-B locus and the second probe detects the control gene. A medium-low resolution (300 HLA-B allelic groups) typing is obtained for each sample by analyzing the melting curve patterns. Because some alleles may be determined without using the complete set of reactions, we present an alternative strategy: a first round of seven reactions and, according to the result, a second (or third) round of PCRs to solve the ambiguities. This method was validated in pretyped clinical samples and the results were completely concordant. Moreover, fewer ambiguous results were obtained. In summary, we present a new, faster, and more accurate method than currently used PCR techniques to type HLA-B alleles.

Quality control of a national bone marrow donor registry: results of a pilot study and proposal for a standardized approach

Unrelated hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is a recognized therapy for hematological diseases and over 8 million HLA-typed donors are ready to donate. Increased international exchanges and rapid requests through the Bone Marrow Donor Worldwide (BMDW) ask for standardized quality assurance. Since no such standards have been established to date, we tested a pilot program in order to evaluate donor availability and quality of HLA typing of the Swiss Registry. The 18500 donors of the registry have been analyzed by serology for HLA-AB and by molecular typing for HLA-DR. Through three successive annual quality control (QC) exercises, a total of 114 donor requests were sent to 13 blood transfusion centers responsible for donor recruitment asking for a blood sample. Donors were randomly selected according to recruitment periods (1988-1993; 1994-1997; 1998-2000), and to homozygosity for HLA-A and/or -B antigens. An additional 80 frozen blood samples from the repository corresponding to the three periods (n=26) and to the 2001 period (n=54) were also included in the HLA study. HLA-AB typings were done by polymerase chain reaction-sequence specific primers (PCR-SSP) and all discrepancies were retyped. The results showed that 79 samples provided by 69.3% of the requested donors were received within 14 days, and 19 samples (16.7%) were received in >14 days. Altogether, an 86% rate of donor availability was observed, independent of the recruitment period. Among the requested donors, 16 (14%) were not available: for medical reasons (two), for personal reasons (eight), for loss (one), and for an unknown reason (five). The HLA-A/B DNA typing results of 166 homozygous and 12 heterozygous blood samples showed that 437/439 (99.5%) of the assigned A/B antigens were correct. However in 36/178 donors (20.2%) an HLA-A or -B antigen had been missed (34 donors) or misassigned (two donors) by serology, with a decreasing discrepancy rate of 30% (1988-1993) to 18.5% in 2001. Assuming that HLA-A or -B homozygotes are found in 10-15% of the donors and that correct assignments have been observed in nearly 100% of the donors, an overall error rate of 4-5% would be expected for the national registry HLA-AB typing. These data show that standardized quality control for donor availability and HLA typing is feasible, and we propose that this model could be applied to the registries participating in bone marrow donor worldwide.

Rapid and simultaneous HLA class I (-A, -B and -C loci) DNA typing using the microtitre plate-reverse hybridization assay (MRHA)

We have established a precise, rapid, simple and practical HLA class I DNA typing method using the microtitre plate-reverse hybridization assay (MRHA), which enables us to perform simultaneous DNA typing of the HLA-A, -B and -C loci using the same PCR parameters and hybridization conditions. PCR-amplified products for the HLA-A, -B and -C loci were hybridized, respectively, with sequence-specific oligonucleotide (SSO) probes, which were immobilized covalently onto a microtitre plate, in hybridization buffer containing formamide at 37 degrees C. After washing at room temperature, the bound PCR products were detected by peroxidase-conjugate streptavidine followed by colour development such as enzyme immunoassay (EIA). In addition to the simple thermoregulation for hybridization and postwashing, strong positive signals, low background and high reproducibility, this DNA typing method enabled simultaneous typing of the HLA-A, -B and -C loci using a single microtitre plate as in HLA serotyping. The assignment of the HLA genotype was easily achieved by automated colorimetric reading and computer software, based on the cut-off value (threshold) established for each probe. For routine HLA class I typing, it may be possible to replace serological typing with the HLA class I DNA typing system using our MRHA method.

Identification and nucleotide sequence of a new null allele, HLA B*3540N

We report the definition of an HLA class I null allele that has been identified within the B35 group by a combination of serological and molecular typing. This allele, which has been named B*3540N, was detected in a French, potential unrelated hematopoietic stem cell donor of unknown ethnic origin, selected as a probable match for an Irish patient. The presence of the null allele was initially determined by the absence of B35 reactivity by serological typing, in contrast to positive reactions by PCR-SSP and PCR-SSO typing. Subsequent sequencing of clones containing the full genomic sequence of the B*35 allele identified a single nucleotide deletion within exon 4 which resulted in the introduction of a stop codon downstream within exon 4.

Molecular typing of HLA-A, -B, and DRB using a high throughput micro array format

The goal of this study was to develop a DNA micro array procedure for molecular human leukocyte antigen (HLA) typing of a large number of samples. DNA was isolated from peripheral blood samples and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplified for HLA-A, -B, and -DRB. Amplified DNA samples were spotted on silane-treated glass slides using a micro array spotter. The spotter was capable of spotting multiple slides with up to 9216 samples per slide or 2304 samples in quadruplicate. The allele specific oligo nucleotide probes for HLA-A, -B, and -DRB were labeled with the fluorescent dye Cy3, while a control probe, to quantitate the total amount of PCR product in a sample, was labeled with Cy5. Each slide was hybridized with a mixture of an allele specific Cy3 probe plus the control Cy5 probe. Following hybridization and wash, the amount of probe hybridizing to each DNA sample on the slide was measured with a micro array scanner. A computer program was used for image analysis, to calculate the average Cy3/Cy5 ratios and to identify the positive and negative samples. In turn, this information was used to determine the HLA phenotype of each sample. There was very good concordance between the results obtained for all three loci using Cy-labeled probes as compared with those previously obtained by chemiluminescent detection of alkaline phosphatase labeled probes. This methodology has the potential of greatly simplifying HLA molecular typing of large number of samples.

Analysis of tumor necrosis factor-alpha promoter polymorphism in type 1 diabetes: HLA-B and -DRB1 alleles are primarily associated with the disease in Japanese

Polymorphisms in the 5'-flanking region of the tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha gene were examined to study the genetic background of type 1 diabetes in Japanese. Five different biallelic polymorphisms were examined in 136 type 1 diabetic patients and 300 control subjects. The frequencies of individuals carrying TNF-alpha-857T allele (designated as TNFP-D allele) or -863A/-1,031C allele (designated as TNFP-B allele) were significantly increased in the patients as compared with the controls. Since these TNF-alpha alleles are in linkage disequilibria with certain DRB1 and HLA-B alleles, two-locus analyses were carried out. The TNFP-D allele did not increase the risk in either the presence or absence of the DRB1*0405 or HLA-B54 allele, while the DRB1*0405 and HLA-B54 alleles per se could confer susceptibility in both the TNFP-D allele-positive and -negative populations. Moreover, an odds ratio was remarkably elevated in the population carrying both DRB1*0405 and HLA-B54. Similarly, the TNFP-B allele did not show significant association with the disease in either the HLA-B61-positive or -negative population, while the HLA-B61 allele could significantly increase the risk in the TNFP-B allele-positive population. These data suggest that the associations of TNFP-D and -B alleles may be secondary to their linkage disequilibria with the susceptible HLA class I and class II alleles. Because HLA-B and DRB1 genes were independently associated, both of these genes may be contributed primarily to the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes in Japanese.

A special report: histocompatibility testing guidelines for hematopoietic stem cell transplantation using volunteer donors. Quality Assurance and Donor Registries Working Groups of the World Marrow Donor Association

The World Marrow Donor Association has formulated guidelines for establishing the extent and quality of histocompatibility testing for unrelated donor registries, umbilical cord blood banks, and transplant centers involved in international exchange of hematopoietic stem cells for allogeneic transplantation. Registry and cord blood bank guidelines suggest that, at a minimum, initial HLA typing should be performed for three HLA loci, HLA-A, -B, and -DR, at low resolution/split antigen level. DNA-based testing methods should be utilized for HLA-DR typing. DNA-based testing for HLA-A and -B should replace serologic testing of new volunteer donors and cord blood units as robust protocols and reagents become available to the laboratories. Transplant center guidelines for typing of patient, family and to confirm the HLA types of potential unrelated donors should include, at the minimum, typing HLA-A, B, and -DR loci using primarily DNA-based testing methods at allele level resolution for DRB1 and low resolution/split antigen level for HLA-A and -B. It is strongly recommended that the typing of a patient and the selected donor be performed using the same set of reagents, methodology, and interpretation criteria with fresh tissue samples to ensure HLA identity. Guidelines for laboratory accreditation, approaches to quality assurance and quality control for HLA testing, and suggestions for the format of the HLA database of donor types are also outlined.

DNA Typing for HLA-A and HLA-B Identifies Disparities Between Patients and Unrelated Donors Matched by HLA-A and HLA-B Serology and HLA-DRB1

High incidences of graft failure and graft-versus-host disease in the recipients of bone marrow transplantations (BMT) from unrelated donors (URD) may reflect the existence of allelic disparities between the patient and the URD despite apparent HLA identity at HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 loci. To identify the extent and pattern of allelic disparities at HLA-A and HLA-B loci, 128 patients and 484 potential URD were evaluated by DNA typing. DNA typing for HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 was performed at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. HLA-A and HLA-B serotyping on URD was provided by the registries. By original typing (serology for HLA-A and HLA-B; DNA typing for DRB1) 187, 164, and 133 URD were 6/6, 5/6, and 4/6 matches, respectively. Following DNA typing, however, only 52.9% of the originally 6/6 matched URD remained 6/6, while 38.5%, 7.5%, and 1.1% were found to be 5/6, 4/6, and 3/6 matches. The level of disparity was higher in the originally 5/6 (P&lt; .01) and 4/6 (P &lt; .01) matched URD. A higher level of disparity was seen for HLA-B as compared to HLA-A. In addition, a serotype related variation was also noticed. For example, 24.1% of HLA-A2 and 60.1% of HLA-B35 seromatched URD were genotypically disparate, but no disparities were seen for HLA-A1 and HLA-B8. A higher percentage of HLA-A (67.4%) compared with HLA-B (35.4%) serologic homozygous URD remained genotypically homozygous (P = .01). The level of allelic disparity was lower (P &lt; .01 for 6/6; P = .02 for 5/6) if the patient had one of the 15 most common haplotypes (A1B8DR3, A2B7DR15, A3B7DR15, etc) in comparison to the rest of the group. Outcome studies will answer the question whether these disparities are associated with a higher rate of immunological complications seen with URD-BMT.

DNA Typing for HLA-A and HLA-B Identifies Disparities Between Patients and Unrelated Donors Matched by HLA-A and HLA-B Serology and HLA-DRB1

High incidences of graft failure and graft-versus-host disease in the recipients of bone marrow transplantations (BMT) from unrelated donors (URD) may reflect the existence of allelic disparities between the patient and the URD despite apparent HLA identity at HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 loci. To identify the extent and pattern of allelic disparities at HLA-A and HLA-B loci, 128 patients and 484 potential URD were evaluated by DNA typing. DNA typing for HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 was performed at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. HLA-A and HLA-B serotyping on URD was provided by the registries. By original typing (serology for HLA-A and HLA-B; DNA typing for DRB1) 187, 164, and 133 URD were 6/6, 5/6, and 4/6 matches, respectively. Following DNA typing, however, only 52.9% of the originally 6/6 matched URD remained 6/6, while 38.5%, 7.5%, and 1.1% were found to be 5/6, 4/6, and 3/6 matches. The level of disparity was higher in the originally 5/6 (P< .01) and 4/6 (P < .01) matched URD. A higher level of disparity was seen for HLA-B as compared to HLA-A. In addition, a serotype related variation was also noticed. For example, 24.1% of HLA-A2 and 60.1% of HLA-B35 seromatched URD were genotypically disparate, but no disparities were seen for HLA-A1 and HLA-B8. A higher percentage of HLA-A (67.4%) compared with HLA-B (35.4%) serologic homozygous URD remained genotypically homozygous (P = .01). The level of allelic disparity was lower (P < .01 for 6/6; P = .02 for 5/6) if the patient had one of the 15 most common haplotypes (A1B8DR3, A2B7DR15, A3B7DR15, etc) in comparison to the rest of the group. Outcome studies will answer the question whether these disparities are associated with a higher rate of immunological complications seen with URD-BMT.

HLA-Cw alleles associated with HLA extended haplotypes and C2 deficiency

There are four MHC-linked complement genes, BF, C2, C4A and C4B, that are inherited as single DNA units, known as complotypes. Extended haplotypes were initially defined by studying the distribution of complotypes in relation to HLA-B and HLA-DR loci in Caucasian families. In order to analyze the distribution of HLA-Cw alleles in relation to extended haplotypes, we studied a large panel of MHC homozygous and heterozygous cell lines representing previously described Caucasian-derived extended haplotypes and 14 patients with complete C2 deficiency. HLA alleles were assigned using sequence-specific oligonucleotide probe hybridization (SSOP). Family analysis served to assign haplotypes for heterozygous samples. We found distinctive HLA-Cw alleles for each independent extended haplotype. Their association in each instance was statistically significant. All patients with C2 deficiency carrying the haplotype [HLA-B18, S042, DR2] were associated with HLA-Cw*1203. These conserved allelic combinations may become an important tool for the study of human evolution and may contribute to the expeditious selection of prospective donors in clinical transplantation.

Typing of HLA-B*15 alleles using sequence-specific primers

We have developed a DNA based typing method to detect 38 known B*15 alleles using sequence-specific primers (PCR-SSP). This method involves 38 primers and 39 PCR-SSP reactions with results that can be obtained in 3 hours. The method is easy, fast and suitable for clinical typing for bone marrow and organ transplantation. We have typed 106 HLA-B15 samples using this method. For homozygous HLA-B15 samples, some B*15 allele combinations need to be resolved by additional PCR reactions not included in this article. The method allows the detection of potential new alleles requiring sequencing for confirmation, and it is useful to resolve unusual serological reaction patterns for different HLA-B15 serological specificities. In addition, it could be used to resolve ambiguous PCR-SSOP typing results and for recognition of mismatches in serologically matched unrelated individuals.