Blood transfusion exposure in Denmark and Sweden

Using routine health-care data to search for unknown transfusion-transmitted disease: a nationwide, agnostic retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Identification and prevention of transfusion-transmitted disease is essential for blood transfusion safety. However, current surveillance systems are largely driven by reports of sentinel events, which is an approach that might be inadequate for identifying transmission of pathogens not known to be transmissible or pathogens with long incubation periods. Using a combination of health-data registers and blood-bank databases, we aimed to perform an agnostic search for potential transfusion-transmitted diseases and to identify unknown threats to the blood supply.

METHODS

In this nationwide, agnostic retrospective cohort study, we developed a systematic algorithm for performing a phenome-wide search for transfusion-transmitted disease without consideration of any a-priori suspicion of blood-borne transmissibility. We applied this algorithm to a nationwide Swedish transfusion database (SCANDAT-3S) to test for possible transmission of 1155 disease entities based on all relevant diagnostic coding systems in use during the period. We ascertained health outcomes of blood donors and transfusion recipients from the Swedish National Inpatient Register, Swedish Cause of Death Register, and Swedish Cancer Register. Analyses were two-pronged, studying both disease diagnosis concordance between donors and recipients and a possible shared increased disease risk among all recipients of a given donor. For both approaches, we used Cox proportional hazards regression models with time-dependent covariates. Adjustment for multiple comparisons was done using a false discovery rate method.

FINDINGS

The analyses included data on 1·72 million patients who had received 18·97 million transfusions (red blood cell, plasma, platelet, or whole blood units) between Jan 1, 1968, and Dec 31, 2017, from 1·04 million blood donors. The median follow-up was 4·5 (IQR 0·9-11·4) years for recipients and 18·5 (8·3-26·2) years for donors. We found evidence of transfusion-transmission for 15 diseases, of which 13 were validated using a second conceptually different approach. We identified transmission of viral hepatitis and its complications (eg, oesophageal varices) but also transmission of other conditions (eg, pneumonia of unknown origin). The diseases that could not be validated in this second approach, HIV and abnormal findings in specimens from male genital organs, were not statistically significant after adjustment for multiple testing. The effect sizes were small (close to 1) for other conditions.

INTERPRETATION

We find no strong evidence of unexpected, widespread transfusion-transmitted disease. This novel approach serves as a proof-of-concept for agnostic, data-driven surveillance for transfusion-transmitted disease using routinely collected blood-bank and health-care data.

FUNDING

Department of Health and Human Services, US National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, US National Institutes of Health, Swedish Research Council and Region Stockholm.

Population-Based Analysis of the Impact of Demographics on the Current and Future Blood Supply in the Saarland

Background

The federal state of Saarland (SL) is experiencing the fastest demographic change in the western part of Germany. In this study, we analyzed retrospective data on the current and future supply of red blood cell concentrates (RBC) in this region and compared it to the current and future RBC demand in SL hospitals.

Methods

The projection of the SL blood supply in 2030 was modeled based on SL demographics for age distribution and donation frequency of donors, and the RBC transfusion data for in-house patients. These results were compared to published data on the transfusion demand from the state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania (MV).

Results

For the period January 1 to December 31, 2017, a total of 43,205 whole blood donations were collected. The donation frequency in SL never exceeded 80 per 1,000 inhabitants and was well below the numbers in MV. Thirty-one percent of the donors were responsible for 53.5% of the donations, and donors older than 45 years of age contributed highly to the total blood supply. In addition, 40,614 RBC transfusions at 10 SL hospitals were analyzed representing nearly all RBC transfusions for in-house patients in this region. RBC transfusions per 1,000 inhabitants increased with age from 24 (50-54) to 140 (80-84) years. Facing an already existing structural deficit of nearly 8,200 RBC in 2017, the projection predicts a dramatic increase in the regional deficit to >18,300 RBC in 2030.

Conclusion

Our results on RBC demand in SL are comparable but not identical to those projected for the region of MV in eastern Germany. Due to the ongoing demographic changes in Germany as a whole, regular regional monitoring of RBC demand and the age structure of blood recipients and donors should be implemented to allow for better strategic planning in blood transfusion services and hospitals.

Characteristics of Recipients of Red Blood Cell Concentrates in a German Federal State

BACKGROUND

Annual transfusion rates in many European countries range between 25 and 35 red blood cell concentrates (RBCs)/1,000 population. It is unclear why transfusion rates in Germany are considerably higher (approx. 50-55 RBCs/1,000 population).

METHODS

We assessed the characteristics of transfusion recipients at all hospitals of the German federal state Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania during a 10-year longitudinal study.

RESULTS

Although 75% of patients received ≤4 RBCs/patient in 2015 (1 RBC: 11.3%; 2 RBCs: 42.6%; 3 RBCs: 6.3%; 4 RBCs: 15.0%), the mean transfusion index was 4.6 RBCs due to a minority of patients with a high transfusion demand. Two thirds of all RBCs were transfused to only 25% of RBC recipients. Consistently, male patients received a higher number of RBCs (2005: 54.2%; 2015: 56.8%) and had a higher mean transfusion index than female patients (mean 5.1 ± 7.2; median 2; inter-quartile range [IQR] 2-4 vs. mean 4.0 ± 5.8; median 2; IQR 2-4). The absolute transfusion demand decreased between 2005 and 2015 by 13.5% due to a composite of active reduction (clinical practice change) and population decline in the 65- to 75-year age group (lower birth rate cohort 1940-1950); however, with major differences between hospitals (range from -61.0 to +41.4%).

CONCLUSION

Transfusion demand in a population could largely be driven by patients with high transfusion demand. Different treatment practices in this group of patients probably add to the major differences in transfusion demand per 1,000 individuals between countries. The available data cannot prove this hypothesis. Implementation of a diagnosis-related group-based monitoring system is urgently needed to allow informative monitoring on the population level and meaningful comparisons between transfusion practices.

Prevalence and outcome of post-transfusion hepatitis C acquired at different ages and detected in look-back screening

OBJECTIVES

The prevalence of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection in Sweden is estimated to 0.5%. Before 1992, blood transfusion posed a risk of HCV transmission. The primary aim of this study was to estimate anti-HCV prevalence in Stockholm County among individuals receiving blood transfusions 1965-1991. The secondary aim was to study the effect of age at transfusion on the development of liver disease and treatment outcome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This is a retrospective analysis of individuals found to be anti-HCV tested positive in Stockholm County during a national screening campaign in Sweden 2008-2010. All anti-HCV-positive individuals were also HCV RNA tested. Data on age at transfusion, age at diagnosis, HCV genotype, viral load, fibrosis score, liver histology and antiviral treatment were recorded.

RESULTS

Out of 7473, 134 (1.8%) tested individuals were anti-HCV positive and 102 were HCV RNA positive resulting in a prevalence of chronic hepatitis C (CHC) of 1.4%. The rate of advanced liver damage was 18% (10/56). Patients younger than 19 years of age at transfusion were significantly more often started on antiviral treatment compared to adult patients, 65% vs 29% p < .001. No significant correlation was found between treatment outcome and gender or age at transfusion.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we found an anti-HCV prevalence of 1.8% which is considerably higher than the estimated prevalence in the Swedish general population (0.5%), and patients infected during childhood were more likely to receive antiviral treatment. Additional data on the HCV epidemic in Sweden are needed regarding prevalence and age distribution.

Epidemiology of chronic red-cell transfusion recipients in Sweden and Denmark-a 10 year follow-up study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Chronic red-cell transfusions may be an indispensable part of patient treatment and may require early intervention to avoid adverse transfusion effects. The population of chronic transfusion recipients including common diagnoses and survival remains poorly characterised. Thus, the objective was to examine the complete range of chronic transfusion recipients, including demographic and patient characteristics and survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients who received their first transfusion in Sweden or Denmark from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2010 were followed up for subsequent transfusion episodes until December 31, 2012. Data on patient characteristics at time of the first and subsequent transfusions were retrieved from the national registers. We estimated the proportion of transfused patients who experienced 20 or more red-cell transfusion episodes (with an episode defined as all transfusions received 4 days or less apart) and characterised this patient population with respect to diagnoses, demographics and survival.

RESULTS

Among 893 117 first time red-cell transfusion recipients, 6157 (0·7%) experienced 20 or more episodes in total. The most common diagnoses among these patients were haematologic malignancies followed by non-haematologic malignancies and non-malignant blood and immune system related diseases. On average, chronically transfused patients had a median survival of less than 1 year following their 20th transfusion episode.

CONCLUSION

This study provides an overview of patient characteristics related to repeat red-cell transfusions and of the amount of red-cell transfusion episodes administered during a 10-year period in two countries. Patients who become chronically transfused suffer from diseases with poor prognosis.

Profiles of blood and blood component transfusion recipients in Zimbabwe

BACKGROUND

There are limited published data on the characteristics of blood transfusion recipients in sub-Saharan Africa. This study describes the demographic characteristics of blood transfusion recipients and patterns of blood and blood component use in Zimbabwe.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data on the characteristics of the blood transfusion recipients (age, sex, blood group), blood components received (type, quantity), discharge diagnoses and outcomes following transfusion (discharge status, duration of stay in hospital), were retrospectively collected from four major hospitals for the period from January 1, 2012 to December 31, 2012. Diagnoses were grouped into broad categories according to the disease headings of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10). Surgical procedures were grouped into broad categories according to organ system using ICD-9.

RESULTS

Most of the 1,793 transfusion recipients studied were female (63.2%) and in the reproductive age group, i.e. 15-49 years (65.3%). The median age of the recipients was 33 years (range, 0-93). The majority of these recipients (n=1,642; 91.6%) received a red blood cell transfusion. The majority of the patients were diagnosed with conditions related to pregnancy and childbirth (22.3%), and diseases of blood and blood-forming organs (17.7%). The median time spent in hospital was 8 days (range, 0-214) and in-hospital mortality was 15.4%.

DISCUSSION

Our sample of blood transfusion recipients were fairly young and most of them received red blood cell transfusions. The majority of patients in the reproductive age group received blood transfusions for pregnancy and childbirth-related diagnoses.

One size will never fit all: the future of research in pediatric transfusion medicine

There is concern at the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) and among transfusion medicine specialists regarding the small number of investigators and studies in the field of pediatric transfusion medicine (PTM). Accordingly, the objective of this article is to provide a snapshot of the clinical and translational PTM research considered to be of high priority by pediatricians, neonatologists, and transfusion medicine specialists. Included is a targeted review of three research areas of importance: (i) transfusion strategies, (ii) short- and long-term clinical consequences, and (iii) transfusion-transmitted infectious diseases. The recommendations by PTM and transfusion medicine specialists represent opportunities and innovative strategies to execute translational research, observational studies, and clinical trials of high relevance to PTM. With the explosion of new biomedical knowledge and increasingly sophisticated methodologies over the past decade, this is an exciting time to consider transfusion medicine as a paradigm for addressing questions related to fields such as cell biology, immunology, neurodevelopment, outcomes research, and many others. Increased awareness of PTM as an important, fertile field and the promotion of accompanying opportunities will help establish PTM as a viable career option and advance basic and clinical investigation to improve the health and wellbeing of children.

Monitoring compliance with transfusion guidelines in hospital departments by electronic data capture

BACKGROUND

The practice of transfusing red blood cells is still liberal in some centres suggesting a lack of compliance with guidelines recommending transfusion of red blood cells at haemoglobin levels of 6-8 g/dL in the non-bleeding patient. Few databases provide ongoing feedback of data on pre-transfusion haemoglobin levels at the departmental level. In a tertiary care hospital, no such data were produced before this study. Our aim was to establish a Patient Blood Management database based on electronic data capture in order to monitor compliance with transfusion guidelines at departmental and hospital levels.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Hospital data on admissions, diagnoses and surgical procedures were used to define the populations of patients. Data on haemoglobin measurements and red blood cell transfusions were used to calculate pre-transfusion haemoglobin, percentage of transfused patients and transfusion volumes.

RESULTS

The model dataset include 33,587 admissions, of which 10% had received at least one unit of red blood cells. Haemoglobin measurements preceded 96.7% of the units transfused. The median pre-transfusion haemoglobin was 8.9 g/dL (interquartile range 8.2-9.7) at the hospital level. In only 6.5% of the cases, transfusion was initiated at 7.3 g/dL or lower as recommended by the Danish national transfusion guideline. In 27% of the cases, transfusion was initiated when the haemoglobin level was 9.3 g/dL or higher, which is not recommended. A median of two units was transfused per transfusion episode and per hospital admission. Transfusion practice was more liberal in surgical and intensive care units than in medical departments.

DISCUSSION

We described pre-transfusion haemoglobin levels, transfusion rates and volumes at hospital and departmental levels, and in surgical subpopulations. Initial data revealed an extensive liberal practice and low compliance with national transfusion guidelines, and identified wards in need of intervention.

Cost of allogeneic blood transfusion

Blood is a scarce and costly resource to society. Therefore, it is important to understand the costs associated with blood, blood components, and blood transfusions. Previous studies have attempted to account for the cost of blood but, because of different objectives, perspectives, and methodologies, they may have underestimated the true (direct and indirect) costs associated with transfusions. Recognizing these limitations, a panel of experts in blood banking and transfusion medicine gathered at the Cost of Blood Consensus Conference to identify a set of key elements associated with whole blood collection, transfusion processes, follow-up, and to establish a standard methodology in estimating costs. Activity-based costing (ABC), the proposed all-inclusive reference methodology, is expected to produce standard and generalizable estimates of the cost of blood transfusion, and it should prove useful to payers, buyers, and society (all of whom bear the cost of blood). In this article, we argue that the ABC approach should be adopted in future cost-of-transfusion studies. In particular, we address the supply and demand dilemma associated with blood and blood components; evaluate the economic impact of transfusion-related adverse outcomes on overall blood utilization; discuss hemovigilance as it contributes not to the expense, but also the safety of transfusion; review previous cost-of-transfusion studies; and summarize the ABC approach and its utility as a methodology for estimating transfusion costs.

High risk of transfusion-induced alloimmunization of patients with inflammatory bowel disease

BACKGROUND

Anemia is highly prevalent in inflammatory bowel disease patients, and red blood cell transfusion is often indicated already at reproductive age. Both transfusion and pregnancy may induce red cell alloantibodies, potentially complicating further transfusions and pregnancies. As recent evidence suggests that inflammation may promote red cell antibody induction, the alloimmunization risk of these patients after allogenic erythrocyte exposure was investigated.

METHODS

Red cell alloantibody status and clinical data were analyzed in 193 inflammatory bowel disease patients with a history of transfusion or pregnancy, and compared with transfused controls with noninflammatory diseases (n=357).

RESULTS

In transfused patients with inflammatory bowel disease, a 2.5-fold-increased red cell antibody prevalence was found (10/119, 8.4%), compared with transfused sex-matched controls with noninflammatory diseases (12/357, 3.4%; P=.023). Patients with inflammatory bowel disease had fewer transfusions (mean 3.0 vs 4.2, P=.003) but higher C-reactive protein levels during transfusion than controls (mean 8.4 vs 5.4 mg/dL, P <.001). The red cell antibodies of inflammatory bowel disease patients were clinically significant, directed against different Rh, Kell, Duffy, or Lutheran blood group antigens, and associated with higher number of transfusions (odds ratio 1.57; 95% confidence interval, 1.03-2.39). Conversely, immunomodulatory therapy during transfusion showed negative association (odds ratio 0.12; 95% confidence interval, 0.02-0.61). Only 1.4% of inflammatory bowel disease patients with pregnancy alone had antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with inflammatory bowel disease exhibited a very high risk of transfusion-induced red cell alloimmunization, possibly potentiated by inflammation. Aside from a restrictive transfusion strategy, the implementation of prophylactic blood group phenotype matching of red cell concentrates (not only for ABO and RhD but also RhCcEe, Kell, Kidd, Duffy) could prevent antibody induction and associated complications in these patients.

Blood transfusion utilization and recipient survival at Hospital das Clinicas in São Paulo, Brazil

BACKGROUND

The characteristics of blood recipients including diagnoses associated with transfusion and posttransfusion survival are unreported in Brazil. The goals of this analysis were: 1) to describe blood utilization according to clinical diagnoses and patient characteristics and 2) to determine the factors associated with survival of blood recipients.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A retrospective cross-sectional analysis was conducted on all inpatients in 2004. Data came from three sources: The first two files consist of data about patient characteristics, clinical diagnosis, and transfusion. Analyses comparing transfused and nontransfused patients were conducted. The third file was used to determine survival recipients up to 3 years after transfusion. Logistic regression was conducted among transfused patients to examine characteristics associated with survival.

RESULTS

In 2004, a total of 30,779 patients were admitted, with 3835 (12.4%) transfused. These patients had 10,479 transfusions episodes, consisting of 39,561 transfused components: 16,748 (42%) red blood cells, 15,828 (40%) platelets (PLTs), and 6190 (16%) plasma. The median number of components transfused was three (range, 1-656) per patient admission. Mortality during hospitalization was different for patients whose admissions included transfusion or not (24% vs. 4%). After 1 year, 56% of transfusion recipients were alive. The multivariable model of factors associated with mortality after transfusion showed that the most significant factors in descending order were hospital ward, increasing age, increasing number of components transfused, and type of components received.

CONCLUSION

Ward and transfusion are markers of underlying medical conditions and are associated with the probability of survival. PLT transfusions are common and likely reflect the types of patients treated. This comprehensive blood utilization study, the first of its kind in Brazil, can help in developing transfusion policy analyses in South America.

Demographic profile of blood donors at three major Brazilian blood centers: results from the International REDS-II study, 2007 to 2008

BACKGROUND

The profile of blood donors changed dramatically in Brazil over the past 20 years, from remunerated to nonremunerated and then from replacement to community donors. Donor demographic data from three major blood centers establish current donation profiles in Brazil, serving as baseline for future analyses and tracking longitudinal changes in donor characteristics.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Data were extracted from the blood center, compiled in a data warehouse, and analyzed. Population data were obtained from the Brazilian census.

RESULTS

During 2007 to 2008, there were 615,379 blood donations from 410,423 donors. A total of 426,142 (69.2%) were from repeat (Rpt) donors and 189,237 (30.8%) were from first-time (FT) donors. Twenty percent of FT donors returned to donate in the period. FT donors were more likely to be younger, and Rpt donors were more likely to be community donors. All were predominantly male. Replacement donors still represent 50% of FT and 30% of Rpt donors. The mean percentage of the potentially general population who were donors was approximately 1.2% for the three centers (0.7, 1.5, and 3.1%). Adjusting for the catchment's area, the first two were 2.1 and 1.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

Donors in the three Brazilian centers tended to be younger with a higher proportion of males than in the general population. Donation rates were lower than desirable. There were substantial differences in sex, age, and community/replacement status by center. Studies on the safety, donation frequencies, and motivations of donors are in progress to orient efforts to enhance the availability of blood.

One-year period prevalence of blood transfusion

Transfusion practice is reported to differ considerably between countries. Comparisons often rely on transfusion rates, incidence - or prevalence rates. In this paper, the one-year period prevalence rate (1-YPPR) of transfusion of red cells (RBC) is presented. Transfusion data, demographic data and patient data were retrospectively combined to calculate sex and diagnosis specific and age standardized 1-YPPR s of RBC transfusion for the complete population in a Danish county. During the calendar year of 2006, 4427 patients received RBC transfusion in Funen County. The crude 1-YPPR of RBC transfusion was 9.2/1000 citizens. Most of the transfused patients had a main diagnosis of neoplasm (22% of recipients), diseases of the circulatory system (15%), the digestive system (15%), injuries (13%) and diseases of the blood (8%). Age standardization reversed the relation between sex specific 1-YPPRs, yielding a statistically significantly higher 1-YPPR in males (6.8/1000) vs. females (6.3/1000). The method for calculating a diagnosis specific 1-YPPR of transfusion of RBC is presented and proposed as an option for comparison of transfusion practice with other transfusion centres. The crude and the diagnosis specific 1-YPPR s are found to increase with age. Thus, age standardization of crude prevalence rates is necessary for meaningful comparisons between populations.