Magnetic resonance studies of human hemoglobins and their implications to the structure-function relationships in human normal and abnormal hemoglobins

1H NMR study of dynamics and thermodynamics of heme rotational disorder in native and reconstituted hemoglobin A

The reaction of heme and apoprotein has been studied in detail in 1H NMR spectroscopy in order to elucidate the conditions for reconstitution of hemoglobin (Hb) to yield the native protein. The initially formed holoprotein exists as a mixture of isomers with individual subunits possessing the two heme orientations differing by a 180 degrees rotation about the alpha, gamma-meso axis [La Mar, G. N., Yamamoto, Y., Jue, T., Smith, K. M., & Pandey, R. K. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 3826-3831]. We characterize in detail herein the rates and mechanism of heme reorientation and show that the rates differ dramatically for met-aquo and met-azido derivatives and are highly pH dependent in both subunits in a fashion that allows selective equilibration in either subunit. Nonequilibrium mixtures of such isomers can be kinetically trapped in the met-azido form and stored in this metastable form for many months. With kinetically controlled heme orientationally disordered Hb, unambiguous assignment of 1H NMR resonances to individual subunits has been made for the met-azido derivative, which demonstrates approximately 2% and 10% equilibrium heme disorder in the alpha- and beta-subunits, respectively. Comparison of the 1H NMR spectra of various heme rotationally disordered Hb derivatives indicates that this disorder is observable in all forms studied, but is most easily recognized as heme disorder and most conveniently monitored in the met-azido complex. Structural consequences of heme disorder appear to manifest themselves much more strongly in peripheral than axial interactions at the heme. Preliminary studies reveal that both the rate of autoxidation of oxy-Hb and the azide affinity of met-aquo-Hb depend on the orientation of the heme.

A high-resolution proton nuclear-magnetic-resonance investigation of carp hemoglobin. Conformational differences between carp and human normal adult hemoglobins in solution

The high-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of carp hemoglobin have been compared to those of human normal adult hemoglobin. Carp deoxy and carbonmonoxy hemoglobins in the deoxy-type quaternary state exhibit two downfield exchangeable proton resonances as compared to four seen in human normal adult deoxyhemoglobin. This suggests that two of the hydrogen bonds present in human normal adult deoxyhemoglobin are absent or occur in very different environments in carp hemoglobin. One of the exchangeable proton resonances of carp hemoglobin, while present in the deoxy-type quaternary state of the carbonmonoxy and deoxy derivatives, is absent in the oxy-type quaternary state of both, in agreement with the assignments of these quaternary structures by other methods. The ring-current-shifted proton resonances (sensitive tertiary structural markers) of carp carbonmonoxyhemoglobin are substantially different from those of human normal adult hemoglobin. The aromatic proton resonance region of carp hemoglobin has fewer resonances than that of human normal adult hemoglobin, consistent with its much reduced histidine content. The hyperfine-shifted proximal histidyl NH-exchangeable proton resonances of carp hemoglobin suggest that during the transition from the oxy to the deoxy quaternary structure, there is a greater alteration in the heme pocket of one type of subunits (presumably the beta chain) than that in the other subunit. The present results suggest that there are differences in both tertiary and quaternary structures between carp and human normal adult hemoglobins which could contribute to the great differences in the functional properties between these two proteins.

A proton nuclear magnetic resonance investigation of histidyl residues in human normal adult hemoglobin

High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy at 250 MHz has been used to titrate 22 individual surface histidyl residues (11 per alpha beta dimer) of human normal adult hemoglobin in both the deoxy and the carbon monoxy forms. The proton resonances of beta 2, beta 143, and beta 146 histidyl residues are assigned by a parallel 1H NMR titration of appropriate mutant and chemically modified hemoglobins. The pK values of the 22 histidyl residues investigated are found to range from 6.35 to 8.07 in the deoxy form and from 6.20 to 7.87 in the carbon monoxy form, in the presence of 0.1 M Bis-Tris or 0.1 M Tris buffer in D2O with chloride ion concentrations varying from 5 to 60 mM at 27 degrees C. Four histidyl residues in the deoxy form and one histidyl residue in the carbon monoxy form are found to have proton nuclear magnetic resonance titration curves that deviate greatly from that predicted by the simple proton dissociation equilibrium of a single ionizable group. The proton nuclear magnetic resonance data are used to ascertain the role of several surface histidyl residues in the Bohr effect of hemoglobin under the above-mentioned experimental conditions. Under these experimental conditions, we have found that (i) the beta 146 histidyl residues do not change their electrostatic environments significantly upon binding of ligand to deoxyhemoglobin and, thus, their contribution to the Bohr effect is negligible, (ii) the beta 2 histidyl residues have a negative contribution to the Bohr effect, and (iii) the total contribution of the 22 histidyl residues investigated here to the Bohr effect is, in magnitude, comparable to the Bohr effect observed experimentally. These results suggest that the molecular mechanism of the Bohr effect proposed by Perutz [Perutz, M.F. (1970) Nature (London) 228, 726-739] is not unique and that the detailed mechanism depends on experimental conditions, such as the solvent composition.

A proton nuclear magnetic resonance investigation of proximal histidyl residues in human normal and abnormal hemoglobins. A probe for the heme pocket

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 250 MHz has been used to investigate the conformations of proximal histidyl residues of human normal adult hemoglobin, hemoglobin Kempsey [beta 99(G1) Asp leads to Asn], hemoglobin Osler [beta 145(HC2) Tyr leads to Asp], and hemoglobin McKees Rocks [beta 145(HC2) Tyr leads to Term] around neutral pH in H2O at 27 degrees C, all in the deoxy form. Two resonances that occur between 58 and 76 ppm downfield from the water proton signal have been assigned to the hyperfine shifted proximal histidyl NH-exchangeable protons of the alpha- and beta-chains of deoxyhemoglobin. These two resonances are sensitive to the quaternary state of hemoglobin, amino acid substitutions in the alpha 1 beta 2-subunit interface and in the carboxy-terminal region of the beta-chain, and the addition of organic phosphates. The experimental results show that there are differences in the heme pockets among these four hemoglobins studied. The structural and dynamic information derived from the hyperfine shifted proximal histidyl NH-exchangeable proton resonances complement that obtained from the ferrous hyperfine shifted and exchangeable proton resonances of deoxyhemoglobin over the spectral region from 5 to 20 ppm downfield from H2O. The relationship between these findings and Perutz's stereochemical mechanism for the cooperative oxygenation of hemoglobin is discussed.

Probing the energetics of proteins through structural perturbation: sites of regulatory energy in human hemoglobin

The sites of energy transduction within the human hemoglobin molecule for the regulation of oxygen affinity have been determined by an extensive study of the molecule's energetic response to structural alteration at individual amino acid residues. For 22 mutant and chemically modified hemoglobins we have determined the total free energy used by the tetrameric molecule for alteration of oxygen affinity at the four binding steps. The results imply that the regulation of oxygen binding affinity is due to energy changes which are mostly localized at the alpha 1 beta 2 interface. They also indicate a high degree of "internal cooperativity" within this contact region--i.e., the structural perturbations at individual residue sites are energetically coupled. Cooperativity in ligand binding is thus a reflection of cooperativity at a deeper level--that of the protein-protein interactions within the alpha 1 beta 2 interfacial domain.

Role of the beta 146 histidyl residue in the alkaline Bohr effect of hemoglobin

High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy has been used to investigate the effects of inorganic anions, such as phosphate or chloride, on the alkaline Bohr effect of normal human adult hemoglobin. By monitoring the chemical shift of the C2 proton of the beta 146 histidyl residue as a function of pH, we have determined its pK values in both ligated and unligated forms. In the presence of 0.1 M Bis-Tris buffer (with chloride ion concentration ranging from 0.005 to 0.06 M) in D2O at 27 degrees C, the pK value of the beta 146 histidine of deoxyhemoglobin is 7.98 +/- 0.03 and that of (carbon monoxy)hemoglobin is 7.85 +/- 0.03. However, in the presence of 0.2 M phosphate and 0.2 M NaCl in D2O at 27 degrees C, the corresponding pK values are 8.08 and 7.14, as previously reported by this laboratory [Kilmartin, J. V., Breen, J. J., Roberts, G. C. K., & Ho, C. (1973) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 70, 1246-1249]. This large difference in the pK value between the deoxy and carbon monoxy forms in the presence of 0.2 M phosphate and 0.2 M NaCl was interpreted as direct support for (1) the breaking of an intrasubunit salt bridge between beta 146 histidine and beta 94 aspartate when the hemoglobin molecule undergoes the quaternary structural transition as proposed by Perutz [Perutz, M. F. (1970) Nature (London) 228, 726-739] and (2) Perutz's suggestion that the beta 146 histidine is one of the amino acid residues responsible for the alkaline Bohr effect. The absence of a large change in the pK value of the beta 146 histidine in the presence of 0.1 M Bis-Tris buffer implies that (1) the above-mentioned intrasubunit salt bridge is not broken in going from the deoxy to the carbon monoxy form and (2) the beta 146 histidyl residue does not contribute significantly to the alkaline Bohr effect under these conditions. We have also found that in measuring the oxygen affinity of hemoglobin as a function of pH in the presence of 0.1 M Bis-Tris or 0.2 M phosphate plus 0.2 M NaCl (both in D2O), there is no significant difference in the alkaline Bohr effect in these two media. Hence, our results suggest that the detailed molecular mechanism for the Bohr effect depends on the experimental conditions.

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance and biochemical studies of oxygenation of human adult hemoglobin in deuterium oxide

The proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of human adult deoxyhemoglobin in D2O in the region from 6 to 20 ppm downfield from the proton resonance of residual water shows a number of hyperfine shifted proton resonances that are due to groups on or near the alpha and beta hemes. The sensitivity of these resonances to the ligation of the heme groups and the assignment of these resonances to the alpha and beta chains provide an opportunity to investigate the cooperative oxygenation of an intact hemoglobin molecule in solution. By use of the nuclear magnetic resonance correlation spectroscopy technique, at least two resonances, one at approximately 18 ppm downfield from HDO due to the beta chain and the other at approximately 12 ppm due to the alpha chain, can be used to study the binding of oxygen to the alpha and beta chains of hemoglobin. The present results using approximately 12% hemoglobin concentration in 0.1 M Bistris buffer at pD 7 and 27 degrees C with and without organic phosphate show that there is no significant line broadening on oxygenation (from 0 to 50% saturation) to affect the determination of the intensities or areas of these resonances. It is found that the ratio of the intensity of the alpha-heme resonance at 12 ppm to that of the beta-heme resonance at 18 ppm is constant on oxygenation in the absence of organic phosphate but decreases in the presence of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate or inositol hexaphosphate, with the effect of the latter being the stronger. On oxygenation, the intensities of the alpha-heme resonance at 12 ppm and of the beta-heme resonance at 18 ppm decreases more than the total number of deoxy chains available as measured by the degree of O2 saturation of hemoglobin. This shows the sensitivity of these resonances to structural changes which are believed to occur in the unligated subunits upon the ligation of their neighbors in an intact tetrameric hemoglobin molecule. A comparison of the nuclear magnetic resonance data with the populations of the partially saturated hemoglobin tetramers (i.e., hemoglobin with one, two, or three oxygen molecules bound) leads to the conclusion that in the presence of organic phosphate the hemoglobin molecule with one oxygen bound maintains the beta-heme resonance at 18 ppm but not the alpha-heme resonance at 12 ppm. These resluts suggest that some cooperativity must exist in the deoxy quaternary structure of the hemoglobin molecule during the oxygenation process. Hence, these results are not consistent with the requirements of two-state concerted models for the oxygenation of hemoglobin. In addition, we have investigated the effect of D2O on the oxygenation of hemoglobin by measuring the oxygen dissociation curves of normal adult hemoglobin as a function of pH in D2O andH2O media. We have found that (1) the pH dependence of the oxygen equilibrium of hemoglobin (the Bohr effect) in higher pH in comparison to that in H2O medium and (2) the Hill coefficients are essentially the same in D2O and H2O media over the pH range from 6.0 to 8.2...

Tertiary structure variability within the quaternary states of hemoglobin: a spin label study

Using variable temperature techniques, the spin label spectral resolution of hemoglobin labeled at the beta93 cysteines with N-(1-oxyl-2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinyl)iodonacetamide has been greatly enhanced. The effects of different ligands, inositol hexaphosphate, pH and salt concentration upon spin labeled ferrous and ferric hemoglobin indicate that the beta chain tertiary structure exhibits considerable variability within the oxy and deoxy quaternary structures. From these studies ligand and spin state changes both appear to be of significance in producing structural changes; binding of inositol hexaphosphate then produces further structural changes secondary in amplitude.

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of hemoglobins Osler (beta145HC2 Tyr replaced by Asp) and McKee Rocks (beta145HC2 Tyr replaced by term): an assignment for an important tertiary structural probe in hemoglobin

High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of deoxyhemoglobins Osler (beta145HC2 Tyr replaced by Asp) and McKees Rocks (beta 145HC2 Tyr replaced by term) indicate that these hemoglobins are predominately in the oxy quaternary structure in 0.1 M [bis(2-hydroxyethyl)imino]-tris(hydroxymethyl) methane buffer at pH 7. Upon the addition of inositol hexaphosphate, the proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of these hemoglobins become similar to those characteristic of a hemoglobin molecule in the deoxy quaternary structure. The exchangeable proton resonance which is found at -6.4 ppm from H2O in the spectrum of normal human adult deoxyhemoglobin is absent in the spectra of these two mutant hemoglobins. Consequently we believe the hydrogen bond between the hydroxyl group of tyrosine-beta145HC2 and the carboxyl oxygen of valine-beta98FG5 gives rise to this resonance. This assignment allows us to use the -6.4ppm resonance as an important tertiary structural probe in the investigation of the cooperative oxygenation of hemoglobin.

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of hemoglobin Providence (beta82EF6 Lys replaced by Asn or Asp): a residue involved in anion binding

High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of hemoglobins Providence-Asn (beta82EF6 Lys replaced by Asn) and Providence-Asp (beta82EF6 Lys replaced by Asp) show that different amino acid substitutions at the same position in the hemoglobin molecule have different effects on the structure of the protein molecule. Hemoglobin Providence-Asp appears to be in a low-affinity tertiary structure in both the deoxy and carbonmonoxy forms. Deoxyhemoglobin Providence-Asn has its beta heme resonance shifted downfield slightly from its position in normal adult hemoglobin; however, the tertiary structures of the heme pocket of hemoglobins A and Providence-Asn are very similar when both proteins are in the carbonmonoxy form. These results are consistent with the oxygen equilibrium measurements of Bonaventura, J., et al. [(1976) J. Biol. Chem. 251, 7563] which show that both Hb Providence-Asn and Hb Providence-Asp have oxygen affinities lower than normal adult hemoglobin, with Hb Providence-Asp having the lowest. Our studies of the effects of sodium chloride on the hyperfine shifted proton resonances of deoxyhemoglobins A, Providence-Asn, and Providence-Asp indicate that the beta82EF6 lysine is probably one, but not the only binding site for chloride ions.

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of hemoglobin M Milwaukee and their implications concerning the mechanism of cooperative oxygenation of hemoglobin

Hemoglobin M Milwaukee (beta67E11 Val leads to Glu) is a naturally occurring valency hybrid containing two permanently oxidized hemes on the beta chains. In this mutant, the two abnormal beta chains cannot combine with ligands whereas the two alpha chains are normal and can combine with oxygen with a Hill coefficient varying from 1.1 to 1.3 [Udem et al. (1970), J Mol. Biol. 48, 489]. High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 250 MHz has been used to investigate the exchangeable, ring-current shifted, ferrous and ferric hyperfine shifted resonances of Hb M Milwaukee in the absence and presence of organic phosphates. The alpha-heme environment, as manifested by the ring-current shifted resonances in the liganded form as well as the ferrous hyperfine shifted resonances in unliganded form, and subunit interactions, as manifested by the exchangeable resonances, are similar in Hb M Milwaukee to those in normal adult human hemoglobin. Organic phosphates can partially or completely inhibit the structural transformation which normally accompanies the binding of oxygen or carbon monoxide to Hb M Milwaukee. Upon stepwise addition of oxygen to deoxy Hb M Milwaukee, the hyperfine shifted resonance spectra of ferric beta chains show features which cannot be attributed to either fully deoxy or oxy species. However, the spectra for partially oxygenated Hb M Milwaukee can be described as an appropriately weighted average of the spectra of sero, singly, and doubly oxygenated species. The ferric hyperfine shifted resonance spectrum of the singly oxygenated intermediate has been calculated by a method employing least-squares analysis of the spectra of partially oxygenated Hb M Milwaukee at several values of oxygen saturation. The spectrum of this intermediate exhibits features which cannot be accounted for by a two-structure model. The present results are consistent with a sequential model for the oxygenation of this mutant hemoglobin. In view of the similarities between normal adult hemoglobin and Hb M Milwaukee, it is suggested that a two-state concerted allosteric model does not provide an adequate description of the structure-function relationship in normal adult hemoglobin.

Haemoglobin Radcliffe (alpha2beta299(Gi)Ala): a high oxygen-affinity variant causing familial polycythaemia

Three members of an Oxfordshire family have polycythaemia. In each case their whole-blood oxygen affinity is increased. This is due to a previously undescribed haemoglobin variant which has been named haemoglobin Radcliffe (alpha2beta299(Gl)Ala). In addition to having a high oxygen affinity haemoglobin Radcliffe shows virtually no haem-haem interaction and a diminished Bohr effect. It is synthesized at the same rate and is as stable as haemoglobin A. X-ray analysis indicates that crystals of deoxyhaemoglobin Radcliffe are isomorphous with those of deoxyhaemoglobin A. Solutions of haemoglobin Radcliffe were also studied by high-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The structure/function relationships of haemoglobin Radcliffe are discussed in the light of these studies.

Nuclear magnetic resonance study of heme-heme interaction in hemoglobin M Milwaukee: implications concerning the mechanism of cooperative ligand binding in normal hemoglobin

Hemoglobin M Milwaukee (beta 67E11 val leads to Glu) is a naturally occurring valency hybrid containing two permanently oxidized hemes in the beta-chains. In this mutant, the two abnormal beta-chains cannot combine with oxygen, whereas the two alpha-chains are normal and can combine with oxygen cooperatively with a Hill coefficient of approximately 1.3. High-resolution proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 250 MHz has been used to investigate the hyperfine shifted resonances of the abnormal ferric beta-chains of Hb M Milwaukee over the spectral region from -30 to -60 parts per million from water at pD 7 and 30 degrees.

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance studies of hemoglobin Malmö: implications of mutations at homologous positions of the alpha and beta chains

The abnormal human hemoglobin Malmö (beta97FG4 His leads to Gln) has been studied and its properties are compared with those of normal adult hemoglobin A. The data presented here show that the ring-current shifted proton resonances of both HbCO and HbO2 Malmö are very different from the corresponding forms of Hb A. The hyperfine shifted proton resonances of deoxy-Hb Malmö do not differ drastically from those of deoxy-Hb A. This result, together with the finding that the exchangeable proton resonances of the deoxy form of the two hemoglobins are similar, suggests that unliganded Hb Malmö can assume a deoxy-like quaternary structure both in the absence and presence of organic phosphates We have also compared the properties of Hb Malmö with those of Hb Chesapeake (alpha92FG4 Arg leads to Leu). This allows us to study the properties of two abnormal human hemoglobins with mutations at homologous positions of the alpha and beta chains in the three-dimenstional structure of the hemoglobin molecule. Our present results suggest that the mutaion at betaFG4 has its greatest effect on the teritiary structure of the heme pocket of the liganded forms of the hemoglobin while the mutation at alphaFG4 alters the deoxy structure of the hemoglogin molecule but does not alter the teriary structure of the heme pockets of the liganded form of the hemoglobin molecule. Both hemoglobins undergo a transition from the deoxy (T) to the oxy (R) quaternary structure upon ligation. The abnormally high oxygen affinities and low cooperativities of these two hemoglobins must therefore be due to either the structural differences which we have observed and/or to an altered transition between the T and R structures.

A proton nuclear magnetic resonance study of the quaternary structure of human homoglobins in water

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of human hemoglobins in water reveal several exchangeable protons which are indicators of the quaternary structures of both the liganded and unliganded molecules. A comparison of the spectra of normal human adult hemoglobin with those of mutant hemoglobins Chesapeake (FG4alpha92 Arg yields Leu), Titusville (G1alpha94 Asp yields Asn), M Milwaukee (E11beta67 Val yields Glu), Malmo (FG4beta97 His yields Gln), Kempsey (G1beta99 Asp yields Asn), Yakima (G1beta99 Asp yields His), and New York (G15beta113 Val yields Glu), as well as with those of chemically modified hemoglobins Des-Arg(alpha141), Des-His(beta146), NES (on Cys-beta93)-Des-Arg(alpha141), and spin-labeled hemoglobin [Cys-beta93 reacted with N-(1-oxyl-2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinyl)iodoacetamide], suggests that the proton in the important hydrogen bond between the tyrosine at C7alpha42 and the aspartic acid at G1beta99, which anchors the alpha1beta2 subunits of deoxyhemoglobin (a characteristic feature of the deoxy quaternary structure), is responsible for the resonance at -9.4 ppm from water at 27 degrees. Another exchangeable proton resonance which occurs at -6.4 ppm from H2O is a spectroscopic indicator of the deoxy structure. A resonance at -5.8 ppm from H2O, which is an indicator of the oxy conformation, is believed to originate from the hydrogen bond between the aspartic acid at G1alpha94 and the asparagine at G4beta102 in the alpha1beta2 subunit interface (a characteristic feature of the oxy quaternary structure). In the spectrum of methemoglobin at pH 6.2 both the -6.4- and the -5.8ppm resonances are present but not the -9.4-ppm resonance. Upon the addition of inositol hexaphosphate to methemoglobin at pH 6.2, the usual resonance at -9.4 ppm is shifted to -10 ppm and the resonance at 6.4 ppm is not observed. In the spectrum of methemoglobin at pH greater than or equal to 7.6 with or without inositol hexaphosphate, the resonance at -5.8 ppm is present, but not those at -10 and -6.4 ppm, suggesting that methemoglobin at high pH has an oxy-like structure. Two resonances (at -8.2 and -7.3 ppm) which remain invariant in the two quaternary structures could come from exchangeable protons in the alpha1beta1 subunit interface and/or other exchangeable protons in the hemoglobin molecule which undergo no conformational changes during the oxygenation process. These exchangeable proton resonances serve as excellent spectroscopic probes of the quaternary structures of the subunit interfaces in studies of the molecular mechanism of cooperative ligand binding to hemoglobin.