Fluorescein transport across the human blood-retina barrier in the direction vitreous to blood. Quantitative assessment in vivo

Ocular Fluid Mechanics and Drug Delivery: A Review of Mathematical and Computational Models

The human eye is a complex biomechanical structure with a range of biomechanical processes involved in various physiological as well as pathological conditions. Fluid flow inside different domains of the eye is one of the most significant biomechanical processes that tend to perform a wide variety of functions and when combined with other biophysical processes play a crucial role in ocular drug delivery. However, it is quite difficult to comprehend the effect of these processes on drug transport and associated treatment experimentally because of ethical constraints and economic feasibility. Computational modeling on the other hand is an excellent means to understand the associated complexity between these aforementioned processes and drug delivery. A wide range of computational models specific to different types of fluids present in different domains of the eye as well as varying drug delivery modes has been established to understand the fluid flow behavior and drug transport phenomenon in an insilico manner. These computational models have been used as a non-invasive tool to aid ophthalmologists in identifying the challenges associated with a particular drug delivery mode while treating particular eye diseases and to advance the understanding of the biomechanical behavior of the eye. In this regard, the author attempts to summarize the existing computational and mathematical approaches proposed in the last two decades for understanding the fluid mechanics and drug transport associated with different domains of the eye, together with their application to modify the existing treatment processes.

Computational modeling of intraocular drug delivery supplied by porous implants

New and efficient drug delivery to the posterior part of the eye is a growing health necessity worldwide. Current treatment of eye diseases, such as age-related macular degeneration (AMD), relies on repeated intravitreal injections of drug-containing solutions. Such a drug delivery has major drawbacks including short drug life, significant medical service, and high medical cost. In this study, we explored a new approach to controlled drug delivery by introducing unique porous implants. Our computational modeling contained key physiological and anatomical traits. Incompressible flow in a porous media field, including the sclera, choroid, and retina layers, is governed by Darcy law and the time evolution of the drug concentration was solved via three convection-diffusion equations in the three layers, respectively. The computational model was validated by established results from independent studies and experimental data. Simulations of the IgG1 Fab drug delivery to the posterior eye were performed to evaluate the effectiveness of the porous implants for controlled delivery. Overall, our results indicate that drug therapeutic levels in the posterior eye sustain for eight weeks similarly to those using intravitreal injection. We first evaluated the effects of the porous implants on the drug delivery in the posterior layers. Subsequent simulations were carried out with varying porosity values in a porous episcleral implant. We found that the time evolution of drug concentration is distinctively correlated to drug source location and pore size. A correlation between porosity and fluid properties for selected porous implants was revealed for the first time in this study.

Increased serum proteins in non-exudative AMD retinas

The blood retinal barrier (BRB) closely regulates the retinal microenvironment. Its compromise leads to the accumulation of retinal fluid containing potentially harmful plasma components. While eyes with non-exudative age-related macular degeneration (AMD) were previously felt to have an intact BRB, we propose that the BRB in non-exudative AMD eyes may be subclinically compromised, allowing entry of retina-toxic plasma proteins. We test this hypothesis by measuring retinal levels of abundant plasma proteins that should not cross the intact BRB. Two cohorts of frozen, post mortem neurosensory retinas were studied by Western analysis. One cohort from Alabama had 4 normal controls and 4 eyes with various forms of AMD. Another cohort from Minnesota had 5 intermediate AMD eyes and 5 normals. Both cohorts were age/post mortem interval (PMI) matched. The non-exudative AMD retinas in the Alabama cohort had significantly higher levels of albumin and complement component 9 (C9) than normal controls. The positive control exudative AMD donor retina had higher levels of all but one serum protein. In both macular and peripheral neurosensory retina samples, intermediate AMD retinas in the Minnesota cohort had significantly higher levels of albumin, fibrinogen, IgG, and C9 than controls. Our results suggest that there may be moderate subclinical BRB leakage in non-exudative AMD. Potentially harmful plasma components including complement or iron could enter the neurosensory retina in AMD patients prior to advanced disease. Thus, therapies aiming to stabilize the BRB might have a role in the management of non-exudative AMD.

Isotope-coded protein label based quantitative proteomic analysis reveals significant up-regulation of apolipoprotein A1 and ovotransferrin in the myopic chick vitreous

This study used isotope-coded protein label (ICPL) quantitative proteomics and bioinformatics analysis to examine changes in vitreous protein content and associated pathways during lens-induced eye growth. First, the vitreous protein profile of normal 7-day old chicks was characterized by nano-liquid chromatography electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry. A total of 341 unique proteins were identified. Next, myopia and hyperopia were induced in the same chick by attaching -10D lenses to the right eye and +10D lenses to the left eye, for 3 and 7 days. Protein expression in lens-induced ametropic eyes was analyzed using the ICPL approach coupled to LCMS. Four proteins (cystatin, apolipoprotein A1, ovotransferrin, and purpurin) were significantly up-regulated in the vitreous after 3 days of wearing -10D lenses relative to +10D lens contralateral eyes. The differences in protein expression were less pronounced after 7 days when the eyes approached full compensation. In a different group of chicks, western blot confirmed the up-regulation of apolipoprotein A1 and ovotransferrin in the myopic vitreous relative to both contralateral lens-free eyes and hyperopic eyes in separate animals wearing +10D lenses. Bioinformatics analysis suggested oxidative stress and lipid metabolism as pathways involved in compensated ocular elongation.

Filter-cultured ARPE-19 cells as outer blood-retinal barrier model

Retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) regulates drug transfer between posterior eye segment and blood circulation, but there is no established RPE cell model for drug delivery studies. We evaluated ARPE-19 filter culture model for this purpose. Passive permeability of 6-carboxyfluorescein, betaxolol and FITC-dextran (40kDa) and active transport of 6-carboxyfluorescein, sodium fluorescein, rhodamine 123, cyclosporine A and digoxin in ARPE-19 model were investigated and compared with isolated bovine RPE-choroid tissue. In addition, barrier properties, and mRNA expression of RPE-specific and melanogenesis-related genes (RPE65, VMD2, CRALBP, OTX-2, MITF-A, TRP-1, tyrosinase) were measured in various culture conditions. The filter grown ARPE-19 cell model showed reasonable barrier properties (TER close to 100Omegacm(2)), but its permeability was slightly higher than that of isolated bovine RPE/choroid specimens. In active transport studies the ARPE-19 model mimics qualitatively the permeability profile of bovine RPE-choroid, but ARPE-19 model underestimates the importance of active transport relative to passive diffusion. Long-term filter-cultured ARPE-19 cells expressed various RPE-specific and melanogenesis-related genes at higher levels than the ARPE-19 cells cultured short-term in flasks. ARPE-19 model can be used to study drug permeation processes in the RPE.

Computer modeling of drug delivery to the posterior eye: effect of active transport and loss to choroidal blood flow

PURPOSE

The direct penetration route following transscleral drug administration presents several barrier and clearance mechanisms-including loss to choroidal blood flow, active transport by the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), and loss to the conjunctival lymphatics and episcleral blood vessels. The objective of this research was to quantify the role of choroidal and episcleral losses.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A finite element model was created for drug distribution in the posterior human eye. The volumetric choroidal loss constant, active transport component and mass transfer from the scleral surface were unknown parameters in the model. The model was used to simulate drug distribution from a systemic source, and the results were compared to existing experimental results to obtain values for the parameters.

RESULTS

The volumetric choroidal loss constant, mass transfer coefficient from the scleral surface and active transport component were evaluated to be (2.0 +/- 0.6) x 10(-5) s(-1), (2.0 +/- 0.35) x 10(-5) cm/s and 8.54 x 10(-6) cm/s respectively.

CONCLUSION

Loss to the choroidal circulation was small compared to loss from the scleral surface. Active transport was predicted to induce periscleral movement of the drug, resulting in more rapid distribution and elevated drug concentrations in the choroid and sclera.

Drug transport in corneal epithelium and blood-retina barrier: emerging role of transporters in ocular pharmacokinetics

Corneal epithelium and blood-retina barrier (i.e. retinal capillaries and retinal pigment epithelium (RPE)) are the key membranes that regulate the access of xenobiotics into the ocular tissues. Corneal epithelium limits drug absorption from the lacrimal fluid into the anterior chamber after eyedrop administration, whereas blood-retina barrier restricts the entry of drugs from systemic circulation to the posterior eye segment. Like in general pharmacokinetics, the role of transporters has been considered to be quite limited as compared to the passive diffusion of drugs across the membranes. As the functional role of transporters is being revealed it has become evident that the transporters are widely important in pharmacokinetics. This review updates the current knowledge about the transporters in the corneal epithelium and blood-retina barrier and demonstrates that the information is far from complete. We also show that quite many ocular drugs are known to interact with transporters, but the studies about the expression and function of those transporters in the eye are still sparse. Therefore, the transporters probably have greater role in ocular pharmacokinetics than we currently realise.

Adenosine agonist regulation of outward active transport of fluorescein across retinal pigment epithelium in rabbits

To investigate the effect of an adenosine agonist, 2-5'-N-ethylcarboxamidoadenosine (NECA), on the outward active transport of fluorescein across the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) in rabbits. High (5x10(-4)-2x10(-3) M) and low (1x10(-5)-1x10(-4) M) concentrations of NECA or phosphate buffered saline (PBS) were intravitreously injected into Dutch-belted rabbits. Sodium fluorescein was injected intravenously 180 min after NECA. Differential vitreous fluorophotometry was performed 3 hr after the sodium fluorescein injection and the vitreal fluorescein/fluorescein monoglucuronide (F/FG) ratio then was calculated. The F/FG ratios are inversely proportional to the outward active transport of fluorescein across the RPE. Retinal detachments were induced by injection of PBS into the subretinal space after the intravitreous injection of low- or high-dose NECA or PBS, and the size of the blebs was monitored. In eyes that received a low-dose injection of NECA, the F/FG ratio was higher compared with controls (P<0.05); in eyes that received a high-dose intravitreal injection, the F/FG ratio was significantly lower compared with controls (P<0.05). The effect of low-dose NECA on the F/FG ratio was suppressed by the A2 receptor antagonist, ZM241385, and the effect of high-dose NECA was suppressed by the A1 receptor antagonist, 8-cyclopentyl-1, 3-dipropylxanthine. The A3 receptor antagonist MRS1191 did not influence the effect of low- or high-dose NECA. Intravitreal injection of high-dose NECA enhanced the reabsorption of subretinal fluid compared with PBS; however, low-dose NECA inhibited reabsorption of subretinal fluid (P<0.02 and 0.05, respectively). Intravitreous injection of high-dose NECA accelerates the active outward transport across the RPE via A1 receptors and low-dose NECA decelerates it via A2 receptors.

Effect of nucleotide P2Y2 receptor agonists on outward active transport of fluorescein across normal blood-retina barrier in rabbit

BACKGROUND

To evaluate the effect of nucleotide P2Y(2) receptor agonists INS542 and uridine 5'-triphosphate (UTP) on the outward active transport of fluorescein across rabbit blood-retina barrier (BRB) in vivo.

METHODS

Injection (0.1 ml) of INS542 (0.1 or 1mM), phosphate buffered solution, or UTP (1 or 10mM) was made in Dutch-belted rabbits. Differential vitreous fluorophotometry (DVF) was performed 3hr later and the fluorescein (F)/fluorescein monoglucuronide (FG) ratio was then calculated. F/FG ratios are inversely proportional to outward active transport of F across BRB at the level of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE). In another set of experiments, the effect of 0.1 ml vitreous injection of INS542 (1mM) on F/FG ratios was evaluated at different time points ranging from 0.5 to 48hr before conducting DVF.

RESULTS

F/FG ratios obtained 3hr after intravitreal injection were as follows (mean+/-standard error): 0.49+/-0.14 (0.1mM INS542), 0.19+/-0.04 (1mM INS542), 0.48+/-0.09 (PBS), 0.40+/-0.08 (1mM UTP) and 0.36+/-0.05 (10mM UTP). The F/FG ratio for 1mM INS542 was significantly lower than in the other groups (P<0.05). In the time course experiments, a significant decrease in the F/FG ratios was observed between 1 and 12hr following administration of INS542 when compared with F/FG ratios obtained in the contralateral (untreated) eye.

CONCLUSION

Intravitreal administration of INS542 (but not UTP) enhances outward active transport of F across RPE in intact rabbit eye, indicating that activation of P2Y(2) receptors in vivo directly stimulates RPE active transport.

Computer simulation of convective and diffusive transport of controlled-release drugs in the vitreous humor

PURPOSE

Biodistribution of drugs in the eye is central to the efficacy of pharmaceutical ocular therapies. Of particular interest to us is the effect of intravitreal transport on distribution of controlled-released drugs within the vitreous.

METHODS

A computer model was developed to describe the three-dimensional convective-diffusive transport of drug released from an intravitreal controlled release source. Unlike previous studies, this work includes flow of aqueous from the anterior to the posterior of the vitreous. The release profile was based on in vitro release of gentamicin from poly(L-lactic acid) microspheres into vitreous.

RESULTS

For small drugs, convection plays a small role, but for large (slower diffusing) drugs, convection becomes more important. For the cases studied, the predicted ratio of drug reaching the retina to drug cleared by the aqueous humor was 2.4 for a small molecule but 13 for a large molecule. Transport in neonatal mouse eye, in contrast, was dominated by diffusion, and the ratio decreased to 0.39.

CONCLUSIONS

The interaction among convection, diffusion, and geometry causes significant differences in biodistribution between large and small molecules or across species. These differences should be considered in the design of delivery strategies or animal studies.

Diabetic macular oedema: the effect of photocoagulation on fluorescein transport across the blood-retinal barrier

BACKGROUND/AIM

The visual loss secondary to diabetic macular oedema can be controlled to some extent by photocoagulation, though the mechanism of action is largely unknown. The purpose of the present study was to quantitate the effect of photocoagulation on the blood-retinal barrier using fluorescein as a tracer of passive and active transport.

METHODS

A prospective study of 46 eyes in 34 patients with clinically significant macular oedema (CSMO) examined by vitreous fluorometry before and 6 months after macular photocoagulation treatment.

RESULTS

In 23 eyes CSMO was not present at follow up (responding eyes), in another 23 other eyes CSMO was still present (non-responding eyes). With reference to the presence or absence of CSMO at follow up, the passive transport (permeability) for responding eyes decreased after photocoagulation in contrast with an increase in non-responding eyes; the difference between the groups at follow up was significant (p=0.03). The active transport for responding eyes decreased slightly at follow up, while it increased for non-responding eyes; the difference between the groups at follow up was not significant (p=0.09).

CONCLUSION

Following photocoagulation a reduction of diabetic macular oedema, defined as disappearance of CSMO, is paralleled by a decrease of the passive permeability while the hypothesis of an increase in the active transport from the retina to the blood could not be supported by this study.

Diabetic macular oedema: a comparison of vitreous fluorometry, angiography, and retinopathy

AIM

To evaluate the relation between the quantitative measurement of vitreous fluorescein with fluorescein angiography and retinopathy in diabetic patients with and without clinically significant macular oedema (CSMO).

METHODS

In a prospective cross sectional study, passive permeability and active, outward transport of fluorescein across the blood-retinal barrier were quantitated with vitreous fluorometry in 61 eyes from 48 patients with CSMO and 22 fellow eyes without CSMO, after exclusion of eyes with previous macular laser treatment and vitreous liquification. All patients were recruited from the university hospital's outpatient clinic. Retinopathy and fluorescein angiograms were evaluated on 60 degree photographs.

RESULTS

The passive permeability in CSMO was significantly correlated with the severity of leakage on fluorescein angiograms (r=0.73), the level of retinopathy (r=0.61), and visual acuity (r=0.45). Significant differences between eyes with CSMO and eyes without CSMO were found for passive permeability (p<0.001), fluorescein leakage (p<0.001), visual acuity (p=0.02), and retinopathy (p=0.002).

CONCLUSION

Passive permeability of fluorescein quantitated with vitreous fluorometry was correlated both with semiquantitative fluorescein angiography and retinopathy, and a significant increase in passive permeability was found when comparing eyes with CSMO to eyes without CSMO. No such pattern was found for the active transport indicating that passive and not the outward, active transport is the factor of most importance in the development of CSMO.

Passive permeability and outward active transport of fluorescein across the blood-retinal barrier in early ARM

AIM

To study the passive and active transport of fluorescein across the blood-retina barrier in early age related maculopathy (ARM) (soft drusen > 63 microm, hyperpigmentation and/or hypopigmentation in patients above 50 years of age).

METHODS

15 patients and 10 healthy subjects were included. Morphological changes were graded from 30 degrees fundus photographs using a simplified version of the epidemiological ARM study group classification system. Differential vitreous spectrofluorophotometry was used to assess the transport properties of the blood-retina barrier (that is, passive permeability and unidirectional permeability caused by outward active transport from the vitreous to the blood).

RESULTS

The passive permeability of the patient group was not significantly different from that of the control group. Four patients with passive permeability more than 3 SD above the mean of the control group (mean 1.8 (SD 0.7) nm/s, range 1.0-3.0 nm/s, data normally distributed) all had centrally located drusen > 500 microm and superjacent pigment clumps of 63-500 microm in diameter. There was no significant difference between the unidirectional permeabilities for the patient group and for the control group (mean 47.4 (29.3) nm/s, range 12.7-91.1 nm/s).

CONCLUSION

There was no significant difference in the passive permeability and in the unidirectional permeability of fluorescein. However, the study may indicate that the combination of very large drusen and superjacent pigment clumps in ARM may be associated with a deterioration of the blood-retina barrier.

The fast oscillation of the electrooculogram reveals sensitivity of the human outer retina/retinal pigment epithelium to glucose level

The effect of acute blood glucose elevations on human outer retinal function was examined. Electrooculograms were recorded as the background light cycled on/off with a 2-min period, eliciting rapid changes in the corneo-retinal standing potential known as the fast-oscillation of the electrooculogram. Recordings were made while subjects fasted and after they consumed 100 g of D-glucose. In all subjects, blood glucose levels strongly affected fast oscillation amplitude, which reflects photoreceptor-driven changes in RPE cell chloride concentration. The sensitivity of RPE metabolism to glucose fluctuations may relate to changes in the blood-retinal barrier that are known to occur in diabetes (e.g. macular edema).

Blood-retina barrier permeability is independent of trace substance lipid solubility in retinitis pigmentosa and in the healthy eye

Differential ocular spectrofluorometry was used to assess the passive permeability of the blood-retina barrier in healthy subjects and in patients with retinitis pigmentosa by determination of the rate of inward leakage of fluorescein and fluorescein glucuronide after intravenous injection of fluorescein. In five healthy subjects we found permeabilities of 1.3 (0.6-2.8) nm/s [log-mean (range)] for fluorescein and 1.3 (0.6-3.1) nm/s for fluorescein glucuronide. Six patients with retinitis pigmentosa all had a markedly increased blood-retina barrier leakage, with inward permeabilities of 8.2 (3.4-25) nm/s for fluorescein and 8.2 (5.6-27) nm/s for fluorescein glucuronide. Since no detectable difference was found between the permeabilities of the two tracers the passive permeability of the blood-retina barrier appears to be independent of the 18-fold difference in lipid solubility between the two tracers, both in retinitis pigmentosa and in healthy subjects. Presumably, the structural substrate for leakage of small hydrophilic molecules through the blood-retina barrier is a water-filled pore, since diffusion through lipid cellular membranes would favor fluorescein over its more water soluble glucuronide.

Permeability of the blood-retinal barrier in healthy humans. European Concerted Action on Ocular Fluorometry

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to compare the inward permeability of the blood-retinal barrier in healthy subjects from six European cities.

METHODS

Seventy-two healthy subjects (age 20-70 years) were selected. At 30 min and 60 min after fluorescein injection, fluorescein mass in vitreous was calculated from the concentrations measured along the optical axis of the eye. Non-protein-bound fluorescein (NPBF) concentrations were measured in plasma prepared from blood samples taken 7, 15 and 55 min after injection. Blood-retinal barrier permeability (PBRB) was calculated from the vitreous fluorescein mass and the time integral of NPBF and was corrected for the autofluorescence of ocular tissue and for lenticular light transmittance.

RESULTS

Mean PBRB values +/- SD (nm.s-1) were 2.07 +/- 0.54 (Coimbra), 2.01 +/- 0.43 (Frankfurt), 2.24 +/- 0.50 (Ghent), 2.37 +/- 0.56 (Herlev), 1.89 +/- 0.44 (Leiden) and 1.74 +/- 0.38 (Porto). Differences between centers were not significant (P > 0.35). Measurements were reproducible and independent of the time after fluorescein injection (P > 0.50). A PBRB higher than 3.16 nm.s-1 or a value which had increased by 32% was considered abnormal (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

PBRB values were similar in all centers. The results demonstrate that this is a highly sensitive and reliable method for measuring the permeability of the blood-retinal barrier.

Transient transport across an inhomogeneous blood-retina barrier

A mathematical model for transport across the blood-retina barrier and diffusion into the vitreous body of the human eye is formulated. The eye is modeled as a sphere, the surface of which represents the blood-retina barrier. The equations of the model are solved analytically, using an expansion in spherical harmonics and inversion of the Laplace transform in the time variable. The numerical properties of the solution are investigated and the applicability of the model to the analysis of data from three-dimensional vitreous fluorometry is discussed.

Probenecid inhibition of the outward transport of fluorescein across the human blood-retina barrier

The effect of probenecid on the outward transport of fluorescein from vitreous to blood was studied in 13 insulin-dependent diabetic patients with background retinopathy in a randomised double-masked placebo controlled cross-over study. Fluorescein and fluorescein glucuronide was separated in the vitreous and in plasma by differential spectrofluorometry. The data for fluorescein were analysed using a simplified mathematical model of the eye. The inward permeability was estimated from data obtained 1 h after injection and the outward transport from data obtained 7 h after injection. During placebo treatment the mean inward permeability was 3.75 x 10(-7) cm/sec and the mean outward permeability was 2.25 x 10(-5) cm/sec. During probenecid treatment the mean inward permeability was 3.34 x 10(-7) cm/sec and the mean outward permeability was 1.44 x 10(-5) cm/sec. Thus, we found no significant change in inward permeability (p = 0.5879), whereas a significant decrease of 36% was found in the outward permeability of fluorescein (p = 0.0171). The demonstration that the outward permeability, which is more than 100-fold higher than the inward permeability in the healthy eye, is significantly decreased by probenecid, demonstrates that active transport is involved in movement of fluorescein across the blood-retina barrier from the vitreous to the plasma.