Determining the appropriate pretreatment procedures and the utility of liver tissue for bulk stable isotope (δ13 C and δ15 N) studies in sharks

Lipid Extraction and Sample Preservation Techniques for Stable Isotope Analysis and Ecological Assays

Lipid extraction is an important component of many ecological and ecotoxicological measurements. For instance, percent lipid is often used as a measure of body condition, under the assumption that those individuals with higher lipid reserves are healthier. Likewise, lipids are depleted in ¹³C compared with protein, and it is consequently a routine to remove lipids prior to measuring carbon isotopes in ecological studies so that variation in lipid content does not obscure variation in diet. We provide detailed methods for two different protocols for lipid extraction: Soxhlet apparatus and manual distillation. We also provide methods for polar and non-polar solvents. Neutral (non-polar) solvents remove some lipids but few non-lipid compounds whereas polar solvents remove not only most lipids but also many non-lipid compounds. We discuss each of the methods and provide guidelines for best practices. We recommend that for stable isotope analysis, researchers test for a relationship between the change in the carbon stable isotope ratio and the amount of lipid extracted to see if the degree of extraction has an impact on isotope ratios. Stable isotope analysis is widely used by ecologists, and we provide a detailed methodology that minimizes known biases.

Lipid extraction has tissue-dependent effects on isotopic values (δ34 S, δ13 C, and δ15 N) from different marine predators

RATIONALE

The use of sulfur isotopes to study trophic ecology in marine ecosystems has increased in the past decade. Unlike other commonly used isotopes (e.g., carbon), sulfur can better discriminate benthic and pelagic productivity. However, how lipid extraction affects sulfur isotopic values has not been assessed, despite its frequent use to remove lipid effects on δ¹³ C values.

METHODS

We used white muscle and liver samples from two species of sharks and skin samples from two species of pinnipeds (sea lion and fur seal) to assess the effects of lipid extraction on stable isotope values for δ³⁴ S, δ¹³ C, and δ¹⁵ N. Isotopic values were determined using a continuous flow-isotope ratio mass spectrometer coupled to an elemental analyzer.

RESULTS

Lipid extraction significantly decreased δ³⁴ S values in shark tissues, more so for liver than muscle (-4.6 ± 0.9‰ vs -0.8 ± 0.3‰, average change), with nearly no change in their standard deviations. Lipid extraction did not affect δ³⁴ S values from pinniped skin samples (0.2 ± 0.8‰, average change). After lipid extraction, consistent increases in δ¹³ C values (0.2‰-7.3‰) were detected as expected, especially in tissue with high lipid content (C:N >4). After lipid extraction, significant increases in δ¹⁵ N values (0.5‰-1.4‰) were found in shark muscle and liver tissues. For pinniped skin samples, δ¹⁵ N values were not significantly lower after lipid extraction (-0.4‰ to -0.1‰).

CONCLUSIONS

Lipid extraction did not have a strong impact on δ³⁴ S values of shark muscle and pinniped skin (≤1‰). However, our results suggest it is essential to consider the effects of lipid extraction when interpreting results from δ³⁴ S values of shark liver tissue, as they significantly depleted values relative to bulk tissue (~5‰). This may reflect selective removal of sulfolipids and glutathione present in higher concentrations in the liver than in muscle and skin and requires further investigation.