Quantal analysis of a decremental response at hair cell-afferent fibre synapses in the goldfish sacculus

Encoding sound in the cochlea: from receptor potential to afferent discharge

Ribbon-class synapses in the ear achieve analog to digital transformation of a continuously graded membrane potential to all-or-none spikes. In mammals, several auditory nerve fibres (ANFs) carry information from each inner hair cell (IHC) to the brain in parallel. Heterogeneity of transmission among synapses contributes to the diversity of ANF sound-response properties. In addition to the place code for sound frequency and the rate code for sound level, there is also a temporal code. In series with cochlear amplification and frequency tuning, neural representation of temporal cues over a broad range of sound levels enables auditory comprehension in noisy multi-speaker settings. The IHC membrane time constant introduces a low-pass filter that attenuates fluctuations of the receptor potential above 1-2 kHz. The ANF spike generator adds a high-pass filter via its depolarization-rate threshold that rejects slow changes in the postsynaptic potential and its phasic response property that ensures one spike per depolarization. Synaptic transmission involves several stochastic subcellular processes between IHC depolarization and ANF spike generation, introducing delay and jitter that limits the speed and precision of spike timing. ANFs spike at a preferred phase of periodic sounds in a process called phase-locking that is limited to frequencies below a few kilohertz by both the IHC receptor potential and the jitter in synaptic transmission. During phase-locking to periodic sounds of increasing intensity, faster and facilitated activation of synaptic transmission and spike generation may be offset by presynaptic depletion of synaptic vesicles, resulting in relatively small changes in response phase. Here we review encoding of spike-timing at cochlear ribbon synapses.

Voltage-Gated Calcium Channels: Key Players in Sensory Coding in the Retina and the Inner Ear

Calcium influx through voltage-gated Ca (Ca_V) channels is the first step in synaptic transmission. This review concerns Ca_V channels at ribbon synapses in primary sense organs and their specialization for efficient coding of stimuli in the physical environment. Specifically, we describe molecular, biochemical, and biophysical properties of the Ca_V channels in sensory receptor cells of the retina, cochlea, and vestibular apparatus, and we consider how such properties might change over the course of development and contribute to synaptic plasticity. We pay particular attention to factors affecting the spatial arrangement of Ca_V channels at presynaptic, ribbon-type active zones, because the spatial relationship between Ca_V channels and release sites has been shown to affect synapse function critically in a number of systems. Finally, we review identified synaptopathies affecting sensory systems and arising from dysfunction of L-type, Ca_V1.3, and Ca_V1.4 channels or their protein modulatory elements.

Kinetics of transmitter release at the calyx of Held synapse

Synaptic contacts mediate information transfer between neurons. The calyx of Held, a large synapse in the mammalian auditory brainstem, has been used as a model system for the mechanism of transmitter release from the presynaptic terminal for the last 20 years. By applying simultaneous recordings from pre- and postsynaptic compartments, the calcium-dependence of the kinetics of transmitter release has been quantified. A single pool of readily releasable vesicles cannot explain the time course of release during repetitive activity. Rather, multiple pools of vesicles have to be postulated that are replenished with distinct kinetics after depletion. The physical identity of vesicle replenishment has been unknown. Recently, it has become possible to apply total internal reflection fluorescent microscopy to the calyx terminal. This technique allowed the visualization of the dynamics of individual synaptic vesicles. Rather than recruitment of vesicles to the transmitter release sites, priming of tethered vesicles in the total internal reflection fluorescent field limited the number of readily releasable vesicles during sustained activity.

Bayesian Inference of Synaptic Quantal Parameters from Correlated Vesicle Release

Synaptic transmission is both history-dependent and stochastic, resulting in varying responses to presentations of the same presynaptic stimulus. This complicates attempts to infer synaptic parameters and has led to the proposal of a number of different strategies for their quantification. Recently Bayesian approaches have been applied to make more efficient use of the data collected in paired intracellular recordings. Methods have been developed that either provide a complete model of the distribution of amplitudes for isolated responses or approximate the amplitude distributions of a train of post-synaptic potentials, with correct short-term synaptic dynamics but neglecting correlations. In both cases the methods provided significantly improved inference of model parameters as compared to existing mean-variance fitting approaches. However, for synapses with high release probability, low vesicle number or relatively low restock rate and for data in which only one or few repeats of the same pattern are available, correlations between serial events can allow for the extraction of significantly more information from experiment: a more complete Bayesian approach would take this into account also. This has not been possible previously because of the technical difficulty in calculating the likelihood of amplitudes seen in correlated post-synaptic potential trains; however, recent theoretical advances have now rendered the likelihood calculation tractable for a broad class of synaptic dynamics models. Here we present a compact mathematical form for the likelihood in terms of a matrix product and demonstrate how marginals of the posterior provide information on covariance of parameter distributions. The associated computer code for Bayesian parameter inference for a variety of models of synaptic dynamics is provided in the Supplementary Material allowing for quantal and dynamical parameters to be readily inferred from experimental data sets.

Sharp Ca²⁺ nanodomains beneath the ribbon promote highly synchronous multivesicular release at hair cell synapses

Hair cell ribbon synapses exhibit several distinguishing features. Structurally, a dense body, or ribbon, is anchored to the presynaptic membrane and tethers synaptic vesicles; functionally, neurotransmitter release is dominated by large EPSC events produced by seemingly synchronous multivesicular release. However, the specific role of the synaptic ribbon in promoting this form of release remains elusive. Using complete ultrastructural reconstructions and capacitance measurements of bullfrog amphibian papilla hair cells dialyzed with high concentrations of a slow Ca²⁺ buffer (10 mM EGTA), we found that the number of synaptic vesicles at the base of the ribbon correlated closely to those vesicles that released most rapidly and efficiently, while the rest of the ribbon-tethered vesicles correlated to a second, slower pool of vesicles. Combined with the persistence of multivesicular release in extreme Ca²⁺ buffering conditions (10 mM BAPTA), our data argue against the Ca²⁺-dependent compound fusion of ribbon-tethered vesicles at hair cell synapses. Moreover, during hair cell depolarization, our results suggest that elevated Ca²⁺ levels enhance vesicle pool replenishment rates. Finally, using Ca²⁺ diffusion simulations, we propose that the ribbon and its vesicles define a small cytoplasmic volume where Ca²⁺ buffer is saturated, despite 10 mM BAPTA conditions. This local buffer saturation permits fast and large Ca²⁺ rises near release sites beneath the synaptic ribbon that can trigger multiquantal EPSCs. We conclude that, by restricting the available presynaptic volume, the ribbon may be creating conditions for the synchronous release of a small cohort of docked vesicles.

A phenomenological model of the synapse between the inner hair cell and auditory nerve: long-term adaptation with power-law dynamics

There is growing evidence that the dynamics of biological systems that appear to be exponential over short time courses are in some cases better described over the long-term by power-law dynamics. A model of rate adaptation at the synapse between inner hair cells and auditory-nerve (AN) fibers that includes both exponential and power-law dynamics is presented here. Exponentially adapting components with rapid and short-term time constants, which are mainly responsible for shaping onset responses, are followed by two parallel paths with power-law adaptation that provide slowly and rapidly adapting responses. The slowly adapting power-law component significantly improves predictions of the recovery of the AN response after stimulus offset. The faster power-law adaptation is necessary to account for the "additivity" of rate in response to stimuli with amplitude increments. The proposed model is capable of accurately predicting several sets of AN data, including amplitude-modulation transfer functions, long-term adaptation, forward masking, and adaptation to increments and decrements in the amplitude of an ongoing stimulus.

Synaptic ribbon enables temporal precision of hair cell afferent synapse by increasing the number of readily releasable vesicles: a modeling study

Synaptic ribbons are classically associated with mediating indefatigable neurotransmitter release by sensory neurons that encode persistent stimuli. Yet when hair cells lack anchored ribbons, the temporal precision of vesicle fusion and auditory nerve discharges are degraded. A rarified statistical model predicted increasing precision of first-exocytosis latency with the number of readily releasable vesicles. We developed an experimentally constrained biophysical model to test the hypothesis that ribbons enable temporally precise exocytosis by increasing the readily releasable pool size. Simulations of calcium influx, buffered calcium diffusion, and synaptic vesicle exocytosis were stochastic (Monte Carlo) and yielded spatiotemporal distributions of vesicle fusion consistent with experimental measurements of exocytosis magnitude and first-spike latency of nerve fibers. No single vesicle could drive the auditory nerve with requisite precision, indicating a requirement for multiple readily releasable vesicles. However, plasmalemma-docked vesicles alone did not account for the nerve's precision--the synaptic ribbon was required to retain a pool of readily releasable vesicles sufficiently large to statistically ensure first-exocytosis latency was both short and reproducible. The model predicted that at least 16 readily releasable vesicles were necessary to match the nerve's precision and provided insight into interspecies differences in synaptic anatomy and physiology. We confirmed that ribbon-associated vesicles were required in disparate calcium buffer conditions, irrespective of the number of vesicles required to trigger an action potential. We conclude that one of the simplest functions ascribable to the ribbon--the ability to hold docked vesicles at an active zone--accounts for the synapse's temporal precision.

Probing the mechanism of exocytosis at the hair cell ribbon synapse

Hearing relies on faithful synaptic transmission at the ribbon synapse of cochlear inner hair cells (IHCs). Postsynaptic recordings from this synapse in prehearing animals had delivered strong indications for synchronized release of several vesicles. The underlying mechanism, however, remains unclear. Here, we used presynaptic membrane capacitance measurements to test whether IHCs release vesicles in a statistically independent or dependent (coordinated) manner. Exocytic changes of membrane capacitance (deltaC(m)) were repeatedly stimulated in IHCs of prehearing and hearing mice by short depolarizations to preferentially recruit the readily releasable pool of synaptic vesicles. A compound Poisson model was devised to describe hair cell exocytosis and to test the analysis. From the trial-to-trial fluctuations of the deltaC(m) we were able to estimate the apparent size of the elementary fusion event (C(app)) at the hair cell synapse to be 96-223 aF in immature and 55-149 aF in mature IHCs. We also approximated the single vesicle capacitance in IHCs by measurements of synaptic vesicle diameters in electron micrographs. The results (immature, 48 aF; mature, 45 aF) were lower than the respective C(app) estimates. This indicates that coordinated exocytosis of synaptic vesicles occurs at both immature and mature hair cell synapses. Approximately 35% of the release events in mature IHCs and approximately 50% in immature IHCs were predicted to involve coordinated fusion, when assuming a geometric distribution of elementary sizes. In summary, our presynaptic measurements indicate coordinated exocytosis but argue for a lesser degree of coordination than suggested by postsynaptic recordings.

Time course and calcium dependence of transmitter release at a single ribbon synapse

At the first synapse in the auditory pathway, the receptor potential of mechanosensory hair cells is converted into a firing pattern in auditory nerve fibers. For the accurate coding of timing and intensity of sound signals, transmitter release at this synapse must occur with the highest precision. To measure directly the transfer characteristics of the hair cell afferent synapse, we implemented simultaneous whole-cell recordings from mammalian inner hair cells (IHCs) and auditory nerve fiber terminals that typically receive input from a single ribbon synapse. During a 1-s IHC depolarization, the synaptic response depressed >90%, representing the main source for adaptation in the auditory nerve. Synaptic depression was slightly affected by alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid receptor desensitization; however, it was mostly caused by reduced vesicular release. When the transfer function between transmitter release and Ca(2+) influx was tested at constant open probability for Ca(2+) channels (potentials >0 mV), a super linear relation was found. This relation is presumed to result from the cooperative binding of three to four Ca(2+) ions at the Ca(2+) sensor. However, in the physiological range for receptor potentials (-50 to -30 mV), the relation between Ca(2+) influx and afferent activity was linear, assuring minimal distortion in the coding of sound intensity. Changes in Ca(2+) influx caused an increase in release probability, but not in the average size of multivesicular synaptic events. By varying Ca(2+) buffering in the IHC, we further investigate how Ca(2+) channel and Ca(2+) sensor at this synapse might relate.

Enhanced information transmission with signal-dependent noise in an array of nonlinear elements

We have investigated information transmission in an array of threshold units that have signal-dependent noise and a common input signal. We demonstrate a phenomenon similar to stochastic resonance and suprathreshold stochastic resonance with additive noise and show that information transmission can be enhanced by a nonzero level of noise. By comparing system performance to one with additive noise we also demonstrate that the information transmission of weak signals is significantly better with signal-dependent noise. Indeed, information rates are not compromised even for arbitrary small input signals. Furthermore, by an appropriate selection of parameters, we observe that the information can be made to be (almost) independent of the level of the noise, thus providing a robust method of transmitting information in the presence of noise. These result could imply that the ability of hair cells to code and transmit sensory information in biological sensory systems is not limited by the level of signal-dependent noise.

Mechanisms underlying the temporal precision of sound coding at the inner hair cell ribbon synapse

Our auditory system is capable of perceiving the azimuthal location of a low frequency sound source with a precision of a few degrees. This requires the auditory system to detect time differences in sound arrival between the two ears down to tens of microseconds. The detection of these interaural time differences relies on network computation by auditory brainstem neurons sharpening the temporal precision of the afferent signals. Nevertheless, the system requires the hair cell synapse to encode sound with the highest possible temporal acuity. In mammals, each auditory nerve fibre receives input from only one inner hair cell (IHC) synapse. Hence, this single synapse determines the temporal precision of the fibre. As if this was not enough of a challenge, the auditory system is also capable of maintaining such high temporal fidelity with acoustic signals that vary greatly in their intensity. Recent research has started to uncover the cellular basis of sound coding. Functional and structural descriptions of synaptic vesicle pools and estimates for the number of Ca(2+) channels at the ribbon synapse have been obtained, as have insights into how the receptor potential couples to the release of synaptic vesicles. Here, we review current concepts about the mechanisms that control the timing of transmitter release in inner hair cells of the cochlea.

Structure and function of the hair cell ribbon synapse

Faithful information transfer at the hair cell afferent synapse requires synaptic transmission to be both reliable and temporally precise. The release of neurotransmitter must exhibit both rapid on and off kinetics to accurately follow acoustic stimuli with a periodicity of 1 ms or less. To ensure such remarkable temporal fidelity, the cochlear hair cell afferent synapse undoubtedly relies on unique cellular and molecular specializations. While the electron microscopy hallmark of the hair cell afferent synapse — the electron-dense synaptic ribbon or synaptic body — has been recognized for decades, dissection of the synapse’s molecular make-up has only just begun. Recent cell physiology studies have added important insights into the synaptic mechanisms underlying fidelity and reliability of sound coding. The presence of the synaptic ribbon links afferent synapses of cochlear and vestibular hair cells to photoreceptors and bipolar neurons of the retina. This review focuses on major advances in understanding the hair cell afferent synapse molecular anatomy and function that have been achieved during the past years.

Few CaV1.3 channels regulate the exocytosis of a synaptic vesicle at the hair cell ribbon synapse

Hearing relies on faithful sound coding at hair cell ribbon synapses, which use Ca2+-triggered glutamate release to signal with submillisecond precision. Here, we investigated stimulus-secretion coupling at mammalian inner hair cell (IHC) synapses to explore the mechanisms underlying this high temporal fidelity. Using nonstationary fluctuation analysis on Ca2+ tail currents, we estimate that IHCs contain approximately 1700 Ca2+ channels, mainly of CaV1.3 type. We show by immunohistochemistry that the CaV1.3 Ca2+ channels are localized preferentially at the ribbon-type active zones of IHCs. We argue that each active zone holds approximately 80 Ca2+ channels, of which probably <10 open simultaneously during physiological stimulation. We then manipulated the Ca2+ current by primarily changing single-channel current or open-channel number. Effects on exocytosis of the readily releasable vesicle pool (RRP) were monitored by membrane capacitance recordings. Consistent with the high intrinsic Ca2+ cooperativity of exocytosis, RRP exocytosis changed nonlinearly with the Ca2+ current when varying the single-channel current. In contrast, the apparent Ca2+ cooperativity of RRP exocytosis was close to unity when primarily manipulating the number of open channels. Our findings suggest a Ca2+ channel-release site coupling in which few nearby CaV1.3 channels impose high nanodomain [Ca2+] on release sites in IHCs during physiological stimulation. We postulate that the IHC ribbon synapse uses this Ca2+ nanodomain control of exocytosis to signal with high temporal precision already at low sound intensities.

Transfer characteristics of the hair cell's afferent synapse

The sense of hearing depends on fast, finely graded neurotransmission at the ribbon synapses connecting hair cells to afferent nerve fibers. The processing that occurs at this first chemical synapse in the auditory pathway determines the quality and extent of the information conveyed to the central nervous system. Knowledge of the synapse's input-output function is therefore essential for understanding how auditory stimuli are encoded. To investigate the transfer function at the hair cell's synapse, we developed a preparation of the bullfrog's amphibian papilla. In the portion of this receptor organ representing stimuli of 400-800 Hz, each afferent nerve fiber forms several synaptic terminals onto one to three hair cells. By performing simultaneous voltage-clamp recordings from presynaptic hair cells and postsynaptic afferent fibers, we established that the rate of evoked vesicle release, as determined from the average postsynaptic current, depends linearly on the amplitude of the presynaptic Ca(2+) current. This result implies that, for receptor potentials in the physiological range, the hair cell's synapse transmits information with high fidelity.

Frequency selectivity of synaptic exocytosis in frog saccular hair cells

The ability to respond selectively to particular frequency components of sensory inputs is fundamental to signal processing in the ear. The frog (Rana pipiens) sacculus, which is used for social communication and escape behaviors, is an exquisitely sensitive detector of sounds and ground-borne vibrations in the 5- to 200-Hz range, with most afferent axons having best frequencies between 40 and 60 Hz. We monitored the synaptic output of saccular sensory receptors (hair cells) by measuring the increase in membrane capacitance (deltaC(m)) that occurs when synaptic vesicles fuse with the plasmalemma. Strong stepwise depolarization evoked an exocytic burst that lasted 10 ms and corresponded to the predicted capacitance of all docked vesicles at synapses, followed by a 20-ms delay before additional vesicle fusion. Experiments using weak stimuli, within the normal physiological range for these cells, revealed a sensitivity to the temporal pattern of membrane potential changes. Interrupting a weak depolarization with a properly timed hyperpolarization increased deltaC(m). Small sinusoidal voltage oscillations (+/-5 mV centered at -60 mV) evoked a deltaC(m) that corresponded to 95 vesicles per s at each synapse at 50 Hz but only 26 vesicles per s at 5 Hz and 27 vesicles per s at 200 Hz (perforated patch recordings). This frequency selectivity was absent for larger sinusoidal oscillations (+/-10 mV centered at -55 mV) and was largest for hair cells with the smallest sinusoidal-stimuli-evoked Ca2+ currents. We conclude that frog saccular hair cells possess an intrinsic synaptic frequency selectivity that is saturated by strong stimuli.

Transmission between type II hair cells and bouton afferents in the turtle posterior crista

Synaptic activity was recorded with sharp microelectrodes during rest and during 0.3-Hz sinusoidal stimulation from bouton afferents identified by their efferent-mediated inhibitory responses. A glutamate antagonist, 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (CNQX) decreased quantal size (qsize) while lowering external Ca(2+) decreased quantal rate (qrate). Miniature excitatory postsynaptic potentials (mEPSPs) had effective durations (qdur) of 3.5-5 ms. Their timing was consistent with Poisson statistics. Mean qsizes ranged in different units from 0.25 to 0.73 mV and mean qrates from 200 to 1,500/s; there was an inverse relation across the afferent population between qrate and qsize. qsize distributions were consistent with the independent release of variable-sized quanta. Channel noise, measured during AMPA-induced depolarizations, was small compared with quantal noise. Excitatory responses were larger than inhibitory responses. Peak qrates, which could approach 3,000/s, led peak excitatory mechanical stimulation by 40 degrees . Quantal parameters varied with stimulation phase with qdur and qsize being maximal during inhibitory stimulation. Voltage modulation (vmod) was in phase with qrate and had a peak depolarization of 1.5-3 mV. On average, 80% of vmod was accounted for by quantal activity; the remaining 20% was a nonquantal component that persisted in the absence of quantal activity. The extracellular accumulation of glutamate and K(+) are potential sources of nonquantal transmission and may provide a basis for the inverse relation between qrate and qsize. Comparison of the phases of synaptic and spike activity suggests that both presynaptic and postsynaptic mechanisms contribute to variations across afferents in the timing of spikes during sinusoidal stimulation.

Evidence that rapid vesicle replenishment of the synaptic ribbon mediates recovery from short-term adaptation at the hair cell afferent synapse

We have employed both in vitro patch clamp recordings of hair cell synaptic vesicle fusion and in vivo single unit recording of cochlear nerve activity to study, at the same synapse, the time course, control, and physiological significance of readily releasable pool dynamics. Exocytosis of the readily releasable pool was fast, saturating in less than 50 ms, and recovery was also rapid, regaining 95% of its initial amplitude following a 200-ms period of repolarization. Longer depolarizations (greater than 250 ms) yielded a second, slower kinetic component of exocytosis. Both the second component of exocytosis and recovery of the readily releasable pool were blocked by the slow calcium buffer, EGTA. Sound-evoked afferent synaptic activity adapted and recovered with similar time courses as readily releasable pool exhaustion and recovery. Comparison of readily releasable pool amplitude, capture distances of calcium buffers, and number of vesicles tethered to the synaptic ribbon suggested that readily releasable pool dynamics reflect the depletion of release-ready vesicles tethered to the synaptic ribbon and the reloading of the ribbon with vesicles from the cytoplasm. Thus, we submit that rapid recovery of the cochlear hair cell afferent fiber synapse from short-term adaptation depends on the timely replenishment of the synaptic ribbon with vesicles from a cytoplasmic pool. This apparent rapid reloading of the synaptic ribbon with vesicles underscores important functional differences between synaptic ribbons in the auditory and visual systems.

Large releasable pool of synaptic vesicles in chick cochlear hair cells

Hearing requires the hair cell synapse to maintain notable temporal fidelity (< or =1 ms) while sustaining neurotransmitter release for prolonged periods of time (minutes). Here we probed the properties and possible anatomical substrate of prolonged neurotransmitter release by using electrical measures of cell surface area as a proxy for neurotransmitter release to study hair cell exocytosis evoked by repetitive stimuli. We observed marked depression of exocytosis by chick tall hair cells. This exocytic depression cannot be explained by calcium current inactivation, presynaptic autoinhibition by metabotropic glutamate receptors, or postsynaptic receptor desensitization. Rather, cochlear hair cell exocytic depression resulted from the exhaustion of a functional vesicle pool. This releasable vesicle pool is large, totaling approximately 8,000 vesicles, and is nearly 10 times greater than the number of vesicles tethered to synaptic ribbons. Such a large functional pool suggests the recruitment of cytoplasmic vesicles to sustain exocytosis, important for maintaining prolonged, high rates of neural activity needed to encode sound.

Depolarization redistributes synaptic membrane and creates a gradient of vesicles on the synaptic body at a ribbon synapse

We used electron tomography of frog saccular hair cells to reconstruct presynaptic ultrastructure at synapses specialized for sustained transmitter release. Synaptic vesicles at inhibited synapses were abundant in the cytoplasm and covered the synaptic body at high density. Continuous maximal stimulation depleted 73% of the vesicles within 800 nm of the synapse, with a concomitant increase in surface area of intracellular cisterns and plasmalemmal infoldings. Docked vesicles were depleted 60%-80% regardless of their distance from the active zone. Vesicles on the synaptic body were depleted primarily in the hemisphere facing the plasmalemma, creating a gradient of vesicles on its surface. We conclude that formation of new synaptic vesicles from cisterns is rate limiting in the vesicle cycle.

The responses of single units in the inferior colliculus of the guinea pig to damped and ramped sinusoids

Temporal asymmetry can have a pronounced effect on the perception of a sinusoid. For instance, if a sinusoid is amplitude modulated by a decaying exponential that restarts every 50 ms, (a damped sinusoid) listeners report a two-component percept: a tonal component corresponding to the carrier and a drumming component corresponding to the envelope modulation period. When the amplitude modulation is reversed in time (a ramped sinusoid) the perception changes markedly; the tonal component increases while the drumming component decreases. The long-term Fourier energy spectra are identical for damped and ramped sinusoids with the same exponential half-life. Modelling studies suggest that this perceptual asymmetry must occur central to the peripheral stages of auditory processing (Patterson and Irino, 1998). To test this hypothesis, we have recorded the responses of single units in the inferior colliculus of the anaesthetised guinea pig. We divided single units into three groups: onset, on-sustained and sustained, based on their temporal adaptation properties to suprathreshold tone bursts at the unit's best frequency. The asymmetry observed in the neural responses of single units was quantified in two ways: a simple total spike count measure and a ratio of the tallest bin of the modulation period histogram to the total number of spikes. Responses were more diverse than those observed with similar stimuli in a previous study in the ventral cochlear nucleus (Pressnitzer et al., 2000). The main results were: (1) The shape of the responses of on-sustained units to ramped sinusoids resembled the shape of the responses to damped sinusoids. This is in contrast to the response shapes in the VCN, which were always similar to the stimulating sinusoid. (2) Units classified as onsets often responded only to the damped stimuli. (3) All units display significant asymmetry in discharge rate for at least one of the half-lives tested and 20% showed significant response asymmetry over all of the half-lives tested. (4) A summary population measure of temporal asymmetry based on total spike count reveals the same pattern of results as that obtained psychophysically using the same stimuli (Patterson, 1994a).

Adaptation in hair cells

Hair cells adapt to sustained deflections of the hair bundle via Ca(2+)-dependent negative feedback on the open probability of the mechanosensitive transduction channels. A model posits that adaptation relieves the input to the transduction channels--force applied by elastic tip links between stereocilia--by repositioning the insertions of the links in the stereocilium. The tip link insertion and transduction channel are dragged by myosins moving on the stereocilium's actin core. This model accounts for many aspects of adaptation in hair cells of the frog saccule, where adaptation time constants are tens of milliseconds. Adaptation in hair cells of the turtle cochlea is much faster, possibly reflecting a more direct mechanism such as Ca2+ binding to the transduction channel. Adaptation mechanisms attenuate the transduction current at low frequencies and may be tuned to different corner frequencies according to the stimulus demands of the inner ear organ. Other sites of adaptation in the inner ear include accessory structures, voltage-dependent properties of hair cells, and afferent transmitter release. A remaining challenge is to understand how these processes work together to shape the output of the inner ear to natural stimuli.

Synaptic depression and the kinetics of exocytosis in retinal bipolar cells

The capacitance technique was used to investigate exocytosis at the ribbon synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells from the goldfish retina. When the Ca(2+) current was activated strongly, the rapidly releasable pool of vesicles (RRP) was released with a single rate-constant of approximately 300-500 sec(-1). However, when the Ca(2+) current was activated weakly by depolarization in the physiological range (-45 to -25 mV), exocytosis from the RRP occurred in two phases. After the release of 20% or more of the RRP, the rate-constant of exocytosis fell by a factor of 4-10. Thus, synaptic depression was caused by a reduced sensitivity to Ca(2+) influx, as well as simple depletion of the RRP. In the resting state, the rate of exocytosis varied with the amplitude of the Ca(2+) current raised to the power of 2. In the depressed state, the sensitivity to Ca(2+) influx was reduced approximately fourfold. The initial phase of exocytosis accelerated e-fold for every 2.1 mV depolarization over the physiological range and averaged 120 sec(-1) at -25 mV. The synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells therefore responds to a step depolarization in a manner similar to a high-pass filter. This transformation appears to be determined by the presence of rapidly releasable vesicles with differing sensitivities to Ca(2+) influx. This might occur if vesicles were docked to the plasma membrane at different distances from Ca(2+) channels. These results suggest that the ribbon synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells may be a site of adaptation in the retina.

Synaptic depression and the kinetics of exocytosis in retinal bipolar cells

The capacitance technique was used to investigate exocytosis at the ribbon synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells from the goldfish retina. When the Ca(2+) current was activated strongly, the rapidly releasable pool of vesicles (RRP) was released with a single rate-constant of approximately 300-500 sec(-1). However, when the Ca(2+) current was activated weakly by depolarization in the physiological range (-45 to -25 mV), exocytosis from the RRP occurred in two phases. After the release of 20% or more of the RRP, the rate-constant of exocytosis fell by a factor of 4-10. Thus, synaptic depression was caused by a reduced sensitivity to Ca(2+) influx, as well as simple depletion of the RRP. In the resting state, the rate of exocytosis varied with the amplitude of the Ca(2+) current raised to the power of 2. In the depressed state, the sensitivity to Ca(2+) influx was reduced approximately fourfold. The initial phase of exocytosis accelerated e-fold for every 2.1 mV depolarization over the physiological range and averaged 120 sec(-1) at -25 mV. The synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells therefore responds to a step depolarization in a manner similar to a high-pass filter. This transformation appears to be determined by the presence of rapidly releasable vesicles with differing sensitivities to Ca(2+) influx. This might occur if vesicles were docked to the plasma membrane at different distances from Ca(2+) channels. These results suggest that the ribbon synapse of depolarizing bipolar cells may be a site of adaptation in the retina.

The performance of synapses that convey discrete graded potentials in an insect visual pathway

Synapses from nonspiking neurons transmit small graded changes in potential, but variability in their postsynaptic potential amplitudes has not been extensively studied. At synapses where the presynaptic signal is an all-or-none spike, the probabilistic manner of neurotransmitter release causes variation in the amplitudes of postsynaptic potentials. I have measured the reliability of the operation of synapses that convey small graded potentials between pairs of identified large, second-order neurons in the locust ocellar system. IPSPs are mediated by small rebound spikes, which are graded in amplitude, in the presynaptic neuron. A transfer curve plotting amplitudes of spikes against amplitudes of IPSPs has a characteristic S shape with a linear central portion where IPSP amplitude is between -0.2 and -0.6 as large as spike amplitude but shows appreciable scatter. Approximately half of the scatter is attributable to background noise, most of which originates in photoreceptors and persists in darkness. The remaining noise is intrinsic to the synapse itself and is usually 0.3-0.7 mV in amplitude. It limits the resolution with which two spike amplitudes can be distinguished from one another to approximately 2 mV and, because the linear part of the transfer curve occupies approximately 10 mV in spike amplitudes, limits the number of discrete signal levels that can be conveyed across the synapse to approximately five. The amplitude of the noise is constant throughout the synaptic operating range, which means it is unlikely that presynaptic membrane potential controls transmitter release by setting a single probability level for quantal release.

The performance of synapses that convey discrete graded potentials in an insect visual pathway

Synapses from nonspiking neurons transmit small graded changes in potential, but variability in their postsynaptic potential amplitudes has not been extensively studied. At synapses where the presynaptic signal is an all-or-none spike, the probabilistic manner of neurotransmitter release causes variation in the amplitudes of postsynaptic potentials. I have measured the reliability of the operation of synapses that convey small graded potentials between pairs of identified large, second-order neurons in the locust ocellar system. IPSPs are mediated by small rebound spikes, which are graded in amplitude, in the presynaptic neuron. A transfer curve plotting amplitudes of spikes against amplitudes of IPSPs has a characteristic S shape with a linear central portion where IPSP amplitude is between -0.2 and -0.6 as large as spike amplitude but shows appreciable scatter. Approximately half of the scatter is attributable to background noise, most of which originates in photoreceptors and persists in darkness. The remaining noise is intrinsic to the synapse itself and is usually 0.3-0.7 mV in amplitude. It limits the resolution with which two spike amplitudes can be distinguished from one another to approximately 2 mV and, because the linear part of the transfer curve occupies approximately 10 mV in spike amplitudes, limits the number of discrete signal levels that can be conveyed across the synapse to approximately five. The amplitude of the noise is constant throughout the synaptic operating range, which means it is unlikely that presynaptic membrane potential controls transmitter release by setting a single probability level for quantal release.

Organization of AMPA receptor subunits at a glutamate synapse: a quantitative immunogold analysis of hair cell synapses in the rat organ of Corti

Sensitive and high-resolution immunocytochemical procedures were used to investigate the spatial organization of AMPA receptor subunits (GluR1-4) at the synapse between the inner hair cells and the afferent dendrites in the rat organ of Corti. This is a synapse with special functional properties and with a presynaptic dense body that defines the center of the synapse and facilitates its morphometric analysis. A quantitative postembedding immunocytochemical analysis was performed on specimens that had been embedded in a metachrylate resin at low temperature after freeze substitution. Single- and double-labeling procedures indicated that GluR2/3 and GluR4 subunits were colocalized throughout the postsynaptic density, with a maximum distance of 300 nm from the presynaptic body and with higher concentrations peripherally than centrally. No receptor immunolabeling was found at extrasynaptic membranes, but some GluR4 subunits appeared to be expressed presynaptically. The synapses between outer hair cells and afferent dendrites were devoid of labeling. The present data indicate that AMPA receptor subunits are inserted into the postsynaptic membrane in a very precise manner and that their density increases on moving away from the center of the synapse.

Organization of AMPA receptor subunits at a glutamate synapse: a quantitative immunogold analysis of hair cell synapses in the rat organ of Corti

Sensitive and high-resolution immunocytochemical procedures were used to investigate the spatial organization of AMPA receptor subunits (GluR1-4) at the synapse between the inner hair cells and the afferent dendrites in the rat organ of Corti. This is a synapse with special functional properties and with a presynaptic dense body that defines the center of the synapse and facilitates its morphometric analysis. A quantitative postembedding immunocytochemical analysis was performed on specimens that had been embedded in a metachrylate resin at low temperature after freeze substitution. Single- and double-labeling procedures indicated that GluR2/3 and GluR4 subunits were colocalized throughout the postsynaptic density, with a maximum distance of 300 nm from the presynaptic body and with higher concentrations peripherally than centrally. No receptor immunolabeling was found at extrasynaptic membranes, but some GluR4 subunits appeared to be expressed presynaptically. The synapses between outer hair cells and afferent dendrites were devoid of labeling. The present data indicate that AMPA receptor subunits are inserted into the postsynaptic membrane in a very precise manner and that their density increases on moving away from the center of the synapse.

Masking and suppression in auditory nerve fibers of the goldfish, Carassius auratus

The responses of single fibers of the auditory nerve of the goldfish (Carassius auratus) were recorded in response to two tones of different duration (20 ms 'signals' and 200 ms 'maskers') presented simultaneously or non-simultaneously. A single tone may produce excitation, adaptation, and suppression in auditory nerve fibers. For fibers with characteristic frequencies (CF) in the 200 to 400 Hz range, frequencies well above CF tend to produce suppression. If the net response to the masker tone is excitation, an added excitatory signal tone tends to increment the response in a way predictable from the rate-level function for the masker. A masker can attenuate the response to a signal as a result of a compressive and saturating response to the masker, and as a result of a low signal-to-masker ratio. If the net response to a masker tone is suppression, it effectively subtracts from signal excitation, causing 'suppressive masking.' In non-spontaneous fibers, suppression, additive excitatory effects, and adaptation can be revealed by responses to the signal in the absence of spike responses to the masker. In general, the ability of one tone (the masker) to reduce the response to a second tone (the signal) is greater in non-spontaneous fibers than in spontaneous fibers. These results also show that estimates of the frequency selectivity of many goldfish auditory nerve fibers will depend on whether the response of the fiber is defined by excitation, suppression, or both. The response of many fibers with CF in the 200-400 Hz region, as defined by excitation, can be masked or suppressed by a broad range of frequencies covering the effective hearing range of the goldfish.

Suppression and excitation in auditory nerve fibers of the goldfish, Carassius auratus

The suppression of background spike activity in the absence of deliberate acoustic stimulation occurs in fibers of the goldfish saccular nerve tuned in the region of 250 Hz. Suppression is most robust in the frequency range between 450 and 1050 Hz, the range of CF for the mid- and high-frequency saccular fibers. Suppression of background activity tends to occur following the suppressor tone offset ('off-suppression'), even though the spike response during the suppressor is below the background rate. This suggests that the suppressor tone is excitatory at the level of the hair cells and their synapses onto saccular afferents. Tones at the low- frequency edge of the suppression region may show net excitation at low intensity levels, and net suppression at higher levels. This suggests that the spike response observed is the result of the relative strengths of excitatory and suppressive effects which operate simultaneously. The magnitude and frequency of best suppression tends to increase with stimulus intensity. A suppressing tone produces transient excitation at onset. In fibers with high levels of spontaneous activity, a spike response 'rebound' often occurs 20 to 50 ms following the suppressing tone offset. These 'on' and 'off' effects are not due to energy 'splatter' in the stimulus domain. Suppression by tones can also be observed in non-spontaneous fibers when the background spike activity is evoked by noise. In these cases, however, off-suppression following a suppressed response and the 'rebound' seldom occurs. Possible sites of suppression are the hair cells and their synapses, the spike-initiation zones of the saccular afferents, and efferent inhibition. The most likely site seems to be the spike-initiation zones of saccular afferents. An important consequence of suppression for hearing is the sharpening of frequency response areas for low frequency fibers, and the partial preservation of frequency analysis in saccular fibers stimulated well above threshold.

Induced suppression in spike responses to tone-on-noise stimuli in the auditory nerve of the pigeon

Spike potentials were recorded from single, afferent fibres in the pigeon auditory nerve. Pure-tone stimuli were presented in quiet and in combination with wide band noise. Presented alone, tones produced tuned response areas; noise generally drove spike rate to well above the spontaneous rate measured in quiet. When presented in combination with noise, tones up to 75 dB SPL at frequencies far from the fibre's response area had no effect on the noise-driven spike rate. As the tone frequency was shifted towards the response area, from above or below CF, suppression of the noise-driven spike rate became stronger until the tone reached the edge of the response area. Suppression of the noise-driven rate was directly proportional to the level of the tone. Within the area of response to the tone, tone-driven spike rates generally were unchanged or variably decreased (occasionally slightly increased) by tone-on-noise stimulation, depending on the relation of the tone frequency to CF and the level of the tone relative to that of the noise. Tuning properties were unaffected. It is suggested that in the pigeon, the suppression of driven spike rate during presentation of combination stimuli, which is common to all fibres, depends on the same mechanism as the suppression of spontaneous firing by tones that is observed in a proportion of fibres (Temchin, A.N. (1988), J. Comp. Physiol. A 163, 99-115; Hill et al., (1989) Hear. Res. 39, 37-48).

Excitation and suppression of primary auditory fibres in the pigeon

Spike potentials were recorded from single fibres in the auditory nerve of the pigeon. In fibres with recognizable responses to sound, spontaneous activity and properties of responses to tonal stimuli were studied in quiet background conditions. Mean spontaneous rate in the sample of fibres was 35 spikes/s. Tuning of spike response to tones was manifest as a single peak in rate at each sound pressure level (SPL) in the frequency-intensity plane. The majority of fibres showed only excitation of spike rate above spontaneous rate. Post stimulus time histograms (PSTs) in such cases were typical of excitatory responses, previously described in birds and mammals showing pronounced adaptation and post-stimulus suppression of spike rate. In most cases of excitation-only responses, however, slopes of rate functions depended on stimulus frequency. Close to characteristic frequency (CF), slopes tended to decrease with increasing SPL, whereas away from CF, slopes tended to increase with SPL. In a minority of excitation-only responses, slopes of rate functions were parallel. In some fibres, tones adjacent to the response area caused overt suppression of spontaneous firing. For these fibres, the slopes of rate functions were more-strongly frequency-dependent, being negative at low SPL when rate suppression occurred. Suppression of spontaneous activity at low SPL was non-monotonic and quite different from suppression of spike rate at stimulus intensities above rat saturation. In PSTs of suppressed spontaneous activity, rebound occurred at the termination of the tone. The results clarify previous observations of suppression of primary auditory responses in birds. We conclude that responses in the majority of auditory fibres in the pigeon are the product of opposing excitatory and suppressive influences in the cochlea, generated by single tones in quite.

Stages of degradation of timing information in the cochlea: a comparison of hair-cell and nerve-fiber responses in the alligator lizard

Responses to clicks and tone bursts of hair cells and nerve fibers in the free-standing region of the alligator lizard cochlea were compared. The objective was to determine the extent to which the hair-cell processes that produce the receptor potential are also responsible for the attenuation of the synchronized responses of nerve fibers. The AC component of the receptor potential of these hair cells has a high-frequency attenuation of 20 dB/decade [Holton and Weiss (1983) J. Physiol. 345, 205-240], whereas the synchronized response of cochlear neurons is attenuated at a rate of least 80 dB/decade [Rose and Weiss (1988) Hear. Res. 33, 151-166]. Therefore, the processes that link the receptor potential to the nerve discharge act as a lowpass filter with a high-frequency attenuation of at least 60 dB/decade. This could be obtained from a cascade of at least three first-order lowpass filter processes.

Antagonistic effects of perilymphatic calcium and magnesium on the activity of single cochlear afferent neurons

The dependence of the spontaneous and sound driven activity of single cochlear nerve fibers on the calcium and magnesium content of the perilymph was studied by perfusion of the perilymphatic space. It was possible to study these effects under steady-state conditions by continuously perfusing scala tympani at low rates while simultaneously recording from units in the chinchilla auditory nerve. Preparations were stable for many hours. As previously reported [Robertson and Johnstone (1979) Pflügers Arch. 380, 7-12], perfusion with solutions containing elevated concentrations of magnesium reduces both the spontaneous and driven activity. When calcium was eliminated from the perfusate, activity was completely abolished for stimuli with sound pressure levels below 100 dB. During partial blocks, a relatively frequency-independent threshold elevation was seen for frequencies well below the characteristic frequency (CF) of the unit, with greater elevations closer to CF. When the threshold elevation at CF was 30-40 dB, the width of the 'tip' portion of the tuning curve was reduced, resembling that of naturally-occurring units with low spontaneous rates of discharge. These effects are similar to that of raising the criterion for response during threshold measurement and are probably related to a frequency-dependent nonlinearity exhibited by the motion of the basilar membrane. The dynamic range for the growth of average rate with level was increased and saturation was shifted to higher stimulus levels during elevated magnesium perfusion. Raising the calcium content of the perfusate increased both spontaneous and driven rates, even in the saturated portion of the rate-intensity plot. Under these conditions, the response of the unit may more directly correspond to the intracellular potential of the presynaptic hair cell. It is argued that the primary site of divalent cation interaction is in the control of transmitter release. Inner hair cells of the mammalian cochlea apparently do not release transmitter in the absence of a calcium influx. The size of the pool of 'readily-available' transmitter appears to be influenced by divalent cations. Even though this synapse is probably specialized for the transmission of auditory signals, the mechanism of synaptic transmission is probably not fundamentally different from that of other well-characterized synapses.

Adaptation in the input-output relation of the synapse made by the barnacle's photoreceptor

A study was made of synaptic transmission between the four median photoreceptors of the giant barnacle (Balanus nubilus) and their post-synaptic cells (I-cells). Simultaneous intracellular recordings were made from the presynaptic terminal region of a photoreceptor and from the soma of an I-cell. The photoreceptor's membrane potential provided feed-back to bath electrodes that passed current into the receptors' axons, permitting the voltage to be controlled at the point of arborization of their presynaptic terminals. Simultaneous recordings from a second photoreceptor showed that its voltage tracked the first. Step depolarizations of the receptors from their dark resting potential (about -60 mV) caused hyperpolarizations of the I-cell that reached a peak, then decayed to a plateau value. The amplitude of the I-cell's response grew with presynaptic depolarizations, saturating at presynaptic values 10-20 mV depolarized from dark rest. Step hyperpolarizations of the receptors from dark rest evoked depolarizations of the I-cell consisting of an initial peak, which varied greatly in amplitude and wave form from preparation to preparation, followed by a plateau. The presence of this post-synaptic response indicates that transmitter is released continuously from the receptors at their dark resting potential. An input-output relation of the synapse was obtained by presenting step depolarizations from a holding potential of -80 mV, where steady-state transmitter release is shut off. The relation is sigmoidal; in the exponentially rising phase of the curve, a 5-11 mV presynaptic change produces a 10-fold change in post-synaptic response. When the presynaptic holding potential was set at values ranging from -80 to -40 mV, the relation between the I-cell's response and the absolute potential to which the receptor was stepped shifted along the presynaptic voltage axis. The slopes of the input-output relations were roughly parallel or increased as the photoreceptors were held more depolarized. This observation limits the possible mechanisms of the shift.

A model for signal transmission in an ear having hair cells with free-standing stereocilia. I. Empirical basis for model structure

No adequate theory for the signal-transmission properties of the peripheral auditory system exists for any vertebrate ear. Because the mammalian ear seems to pose conceptual and technical problems that complicate the development of an adequate theory, it is worthwhile to investigate simpler ears. The ear of the alligator lizard is simpler than mammalian ears in several respects: the motion of the basilar membrane is approximately independent of longitudinal position and is approximately linearly related to the sound pressure at the tympanic membrane; in a large region of the cochlea the hair cells have free-standing stereocilia that are not in contact with a tectorial membrane; the receptor potential of these hair cells is related to the sound pressure at the tympanic membrane in a relatively simple manner; the cochlear-nerve fiber responses from this region do not exhibit two-tone rate suppression. Also, the relative accessibility of this ear has enabled measurement of several response variables: tympanic-membrane volume velocity, extracolumella velocity, basilar-membrane velocity, hair-cell stereociliary displacement, hair-cell receptor potentials, and cochlear-nerve-fiber discharges. A model is developed to represent these results in terms of underlying anatomical structures and physiological mechanisms.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adaptation effects on amplitude modulation detection: behavioral and neurophysiological assessment in the goldfish auditory system

The ability of goldfish to detect the presence of amplitude modulations (AM) impressed on 200, 570 and 800 Hz tones was measured under stimulus conditions producing intermittent, short-term adaptation and continuous, long-term adaptation. Sensitivity to AM under intermittent conditions increased as a function of modulation rate, with thresholds of AM detection occurring between 10 and 25% modulation at 10 Hz and around 2% modulation at 100 Hz. AM sensitivity was independent of carrier frequency and did not change under randomly varying intensity changes. Under long-term adaptation, thresholds of AM detection ranged from 1.3% at 100 Hz to 2.1% at 10 Hz, showing increased sensitivity and less dependence on modulation rate. The effects of overall intensity on AM sensitivity were the same for both conditions, with sensitivity being relatively independent of overall signal level at 10 Hz modulation and dependent on level at 100 Hz. The responses of goldfish auditory neurons to modulated and unmodulated signals were measured under stimulus conditions similar to those for behavioral studies. Single saccular neurons responded to modulated signals with both an increase in average rate above that evoked by the unmodulated signal and with phase-locking to the AM envelope. Rate increments and phase-locking responses were observed in neurons showing significant short-term adaptation to the unmodulated signal, whereas neurons showing no increase in rate or synchronization to the AM envelope showed little or no adaptation to the unmodulated signal. The effects of overall intensity, modulation rate and adaptation duration on neural responses were similar to behaviorally measured effects. These results show that adaptation affects AM detection and that phase-locking to the AM envelope is the most likely basis for behavioral detection.

The auditory neurophonic: basic properties

In anesthetized cats an AC signal or neurophonic can be recorded from the auditory nerve and from the scalp when the cochlea is stimulated with low frequency tones. This study examines some of the basic properties of the auditory neurophonics. The auditory nerve signal, termed the auditory nerve neurophonic (ANN), was differentially recorded with a pair of platinum-iridium ball electrodes placed on either side of the auditory nerve as it exits the internal meatus. The signal recorded from the scalp, termed the frequency following response (FFR), was recorded with silver wire. For purposes of comparison the round window-recorded cochlear microphonic was also examined under identical stimulus conditions. Several measures of the response to acoustic stimulation were taken for each recording configuration. Among these were total response amplitude as a function of stimulus level, spectral component amplitude and phase as a function of stimulus level, fundamental component amplitude as a function of stimulus frequency, response amplitude as a function of time after stimulus onset, response amplitude as a function of forward masker intensity. By all these measures the neurophonic responses are signals that are distinct from the CM and share many of the properties of single units in the auditory nerve. In addition, micro-injections of kainic acid into the cochlear nucleus leave these responses largely unaffected, while tetrodotoxin injections into the cochlea greatly diminish both neurophonic responses, while leaving the CM largely intact. From these results, we conclude that at stimulus levels below 90 dB SPL the ANN is almost entirely neural in origin, while the FFR is certainly largely neural, that is, that both responses are quite distinct from the CM. We also conclude that they represent a spatial summation of neural activity in the auditory nerve, probably arising from the phase-locked response of single units to low frequency stimuli. In addition to demonstrating that the neurophonics are neural responses, we have begun the process of relating their properties to the distributed phase-locked activity in the auditory nerve.

Components of cochlear electric responses in the alligator lizard

Electric responses to clicks and tones were recorded at the round windows of anesthetized alligator lizards before and after tetrodotoxin (TTX) was added to scala tympani. By combining click responses obtained in the presence and absence of TTX and at high and low click repetition rates, we trisected click responses into three components: (1) a rate-insensitive, TTX-insensitive component (that we identify as the cochlear microphonic potential or CM); (2) a rate-sensitive, TTX-sensitive component (that we identify as the neural component); (3) a rate-sensitive, TTX-resistant component (which has not been identified previously and which we call component X). Component X is generated in the inner ear and has a latency between that of the CM and the neural component. Several possible origins for component X are discussed of which the most likely is that component X represents the compound post-synaptic potential of the nerve terminals. Measurements of responses to tones in the presence and absence of TTX demonstrate that the contribution of the neural component to the response is appreciable below 1.5 kHz and negligible above this frequency.