The fitness landscape of a tRNA gene

Joint optimization of replicative rate and information storage set the letter size of primordial genetic alphabet

The simplest possible informational heteropolymer requires only a two-letter alphabet to be able to store information. The evolutionary choice of four monomers in the informational biomolecules RNA/DNA or their progenitors is intriguing, given the inherent difficulties in the simultaneous and localized prebiotic synthesis of all four monomers of progenitors of RNA/DNA from common precursors on early Earth. Excluding the scenario where a two-letter alphabet genome eventually expanded to include two more letters to code for more amino acids on teleological grounds, we show here that a replicatively superior heteropolymer sequence in an RNA-world-like scenario would have to be composed of at least four letters in order to predictably fold into a specific secondary structure, and hence must have out-competed the two-letter alphabet genomes. As a consequence of our earlier demonstration of the replicative rate advantage of maximal-nucleotide-skew sequences, in this follow-up article, we show that the competing constraints of maximum replicative rate and predictable secondary structure formation can be simultaneously satisfied only by maximally-skewed palindromic heteropolymer sequences composed of a minimum of four letters.

On the Probability of Reaching High Peaks in Fitness Landscapes by Adaptive Walks

Adaptive evolution can be described by an uphill walk in a fitness landscape. However, climbing the global peak in a multipeak landscape is improbable because of the high chance of being trapped at a local peak. Nonetheless, over three-quarters of simulated adaptive walks in the fitness landscape of the Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene were reported to end at the highest 14% of peaks, suggesting that biological systems may be substantially more evolvable than commonly thought. To investigate the cause and generality of this observation, we estimate in empirical and theoretical fitness landscapes the probability of reaching high peaks by adaptive walks (PHP), where high peaks refer to the highest 1, 5, 14, or 25% of all peaks. We find that (i) PHP varies substantially among landscapes, (ii) PHP in empirical landscapes is generally comparable to or smaller than that in same-size Rough Mount Fuji landscapes of similar ruggedness, and (iii) lowering landscape ruggedness boosts PHP. As observed in DHFR, we find in every examined landscape a positive correlation between the fitness of a peak and its basin size, which is the number of genotypes that can reach the peak through adaptive walks. Yet, this correlation does not guarantee a large PHP because of the influences of other factors. We conclude that evolvability depends on the specific fitness landscape and that the large PHP in the DHFR landscape is not a general property of empirical or theoretical fitness landscapes.

How much is Transcription-associated Mutagenesis Driving tRNA Microevolution?

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are among the most highly conserved and frequently transcribed genes. Recent studies have identified transcription-associated mutagenesis (TAM) as a significant contributor to sequence variation around tRNA loci. However, the extent to which TAM drives allelic variation in tRNAs remains unclear, largely due to the confounding effects of strong selection pressures to maintain their structural integrity. This complexity arises because TAM-induced mutations primarily involve nucleotide transitions, which tend to preserve base-pairing stability. To address this dichotomy at the population level, we analyzed tRNA allelic variation in contemporary Caenorhabditis elegans strains. We propose a model of tRNA microevolution driven by TAM and demonstrate that the observed secondary structure characteristics align with our predicted TAM-biased patterns. Furthermore, we developed a continuous Markov substitution model that incorporates TAM-specific mutational biases. This TAM-biased model fits the C. elegans tRNA data more effectively than standard models, such as the general time-reversible (GTR) model. Based on these results, we conclude that TAM plays a significant role in shaping tRNA allelic variation within populations. This finding is consistent with recent experimental studies on tRNA fitness in yeast but challenges prior theoretical and computational analyses that emphasize RNA base-pairing as a primary determinant in genotype-phenotype systems.

MMRT: MultiMut Recursive Tree for predicting functional effects of high-order protein variants from low-order variants

Protein sequences primarily determine their stability and functions. Mutations may occur at one, two, or three positions at the same time (low-order variants) or at multiple positions simultaneously (high-order variants), which affect protein functions. So far, low-order variants, such as single variants, double variants, and triple variants, have been well-studied through high-throughput experimental scanning techniques and computational prediction methods. However, research on high-order variants remains limited because of the difficulty of scanning an exponentially large number of potential variant combinations. Nonetheless, studying higher-order variants is crucial for understanding the pathogenesis of complex diseases, advancing protein engineering, and driving precision medicine. In this work, we introduce a novel deep learning model, namely MultiMut Recursive Tree (MMRT), to address this challenge of predicting the functional effects of high-order variants. MMRT integrates deep learning with a recursive tree framework to leverage the information from low-order variants to predict functional effects of high-order variants. We evaluated MMRT on datasets comprising 685,593 high-order variants. Our results (mean Spearman's correlation coefficient 0.55) demonstrated that MMRT outperformed three existing state-of-the-art methods: ESM (evolutionary scale modeling), DeepSequence, and ECNet (evolutionary context-integrated neural network). MMRT thus provides more accurate prediction of the functional effects of high-order protein variants, offering great potential for aiding the interpretation of variants in human disease studies.

The highly rugged yet navigable regulatory landscape of the bacterial transcription factor TetR

Transcription factor binding sites (TFBSs) are important sources of evolutionary innovations. Understanding how evolution navigates the sequence space of such sites can be achieved by mapping TFBS adaptive landscapes. In such a landscape, an individual location corresponds to a TFBS bound by a transcription factor. The elevation at that location corresponds to the strength of transcriptional regulation conveyed by the sequence. Here, we develop an in vivo massively parallel reporter assay to map the landscape of bacterial TFBSs. We apply this assay to the TetR repressor, for which few TFBSs are known. We quantify the strength of transcriptional repression for 17,765 TFBSs and show that the resulting landscape is highly rugged, with 2092 peaks. Only a few peaks convey stronger repression than the wild type. Non-additive (epistatic) interactions between mutations are frequent. Despite these hallmarks of ruggedness, most high peaks are evolutionarily accessible. They have large basins of attraction and are reached by around 20% of populations evolving on the landscape. Which high peak is reached during evolution is unpredictable and contingent on the mutational path taken. This in-depth analysis of a prokaryotic gene regulator reveals a landscape that is navigable but much more rugged than the landscapes of eukaryotic regulators.

Pleiotropy, epistasis and the genetic architecture of quantitative traits

Pleiotropy (whereby one genetic polymorphism affects multiple traits) and epistasis (whereby non-linear interactions between genetic polymorphisms affect the same trait) are fundamental aspects of the genetic architecture of quantitative traits. Recent advances in the ability to characterize the effects of polymorphic variants on molecular and organismal phenotypes in human and model organism populations have revealed the prevalence of pleiotropy and unexpected shared molecular genetic bases among quantitative traits, including diseases. By contrast, epistasis is common between polymorphic loci associated with quantitative traits in model organisms, such that alleles at one locus have different effects in different genetic backgrounds, but is rarely observed for human quantitative traits and common diseases. Here, we review the concepts and recent inferences about pleiotropy and epistasis, and discuss factors that contribute to similarities and differences between the genetic architecture of quantitative traits in model organisms and humans.

popDMS infers mutation effects from deep mutational scanning data

SUMMARY

Deep mutational scanning (DMS) experiments provide a powerful method to measure the functional effects of genetic mutations at massive scales. However, the data generated from these experiments can be difficult to analyze, with significant variation between experimental replicates. To overcome this challenge, we developed popDMS, a computational method based on population genetics theory, to infer the functional effects of mutations from DMS data. Through extensive tests, we found that the functional effects of single mutations and epistasis inferred by popDMS are highly consistent across replicates, comparing favorably with existing methods. Our approach is flexible and can be widely applied to DMS data that includes multiple time points, multiple replicates, and different experimental conditions.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

popDMS is implemented in Python and Julia, and is freely available on GitHub at https://github.com/bartonlab/popDMS.

Sampling Strategies for Experimentally Mapping Molecular Fitness Landscapes Using High-Throughput Methods

Empirical studies of genotype-phenotype-fitness maps of proteins are fundamental to understanding the evolutionary process, in elucidating the space of possible genotypes accessible through mutations in a landscape of phenotypes and fitness effects. Yet, comprehensively mapping molecular fitness landscapes remains challenging since all possible combinations of amino acid substitutions for even a few protein sites are encoded by an enormous genotype space. High-throughput mapping of genotype space can be achieved using large-scale screening experiments known as multiplexed assays of variant effect (MAVEs). However, to accommodate such multi-mutational studies, the size of MAVEs has grown to the point where a priori determination of sampling requirements is needed. To address this problem, we propose calculations and simulation methods to approximate minimum sampling requirements for multi-mutational MAVEs, which we combine with a new library construction protocol to experimentally validate our approximation approaches. Analysis of our simulated data reveals how sampling trajectories differ between simulations of nucleotide versus amino acid variants and among mutagenesis schemes. For this, we show quantitatively that marginal gains in sampling efficiency demand increasingly greater sampling effort when sampling for nucleotide sequences over their encoded amino acid equivalents. We present a new library construction protocol that efficiently maximizes sequence variation, and demonstrate using ultradeep sequencing that the library encodes virtually all possible combinations of mutations within the experimental design. Insights learned from our analyses together with the methodological advances reported herein are immediately applicable toward pooled experimental screens of arbitrary design, enabling further assay upscaling and expanded testing of genotype space.

Genotype sampling for deep-learning assisted experimental mapping of a combinatorially complete fitness landscape

MOTIVATION

Experimental characterization of fitness landscapes, which map genotypes onto fitness, is important for both evolutionary biology and protein engineering. It faces a fundamental obstacle in the astronomical number of genotypes whose fitness needs to be measured for any one protein. Deep learning may help to predict the fitness of many genotypes from a smaller neural network training sample of genotypes with experimentally measured fitness. Here I use a recently published experimentally mapped fitness landscape of more than 260 000 protein genotypes to ask how such sampling is best performed.

RESULTS

I show that multilayer perceptrons, recurrent neural networks, convolutional networks, and transformers, can explain more than 90% of fitness variance in the data. In addition, 90% of this performance is reached with a training sample comprising merely ≈103 sequences. Generalization to unseen test data is best when training data is sampled randomly and uniformly, or sampled to minimize the number of synonymous sequences. In contrast, sampling to maximize sequence diversity or codon usage bias reduces performance substantially. These observations hold for more than one network architecture. Simple sampling strategies may perform best when training deep learning neural networks to map fitness landscapes from experimental data.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

The fitness landscape data analyzed here is publicly available as described previously (Papkou et al. 2023). All code used to analyze this landscape is publicly available at https://github.com/andreas-wagner-uzh/fitness_landscape_sampling.

Predictive evolutionary modelling for influenza virus by site-based dynamics of mutations

Influenza virus continuously evolves to escape human adaptive immunity and generates seasonal epidemics. Therefore, influenza vaccine strains need to be updated annually for the upcoming flu season to ensure vaccine effectiveness. We develop a computational approach, beth-1, to forecast virus evolution and select representative virus for influenza vaccine. The method involves modelling site-wise mutation fitness. Informed by virus genome and population sero-positivity, we calibrate transition time of mutations and project the fitness landscape to future time, based on which beth-1 selects the optimal vaccine strain. In season-to-season prediction in historical data for the influenza A pH1N1 and H3N2 viruses, beth-1 demonstrates superior genetic matching compared to existing approaches. In prospective validations, the model shows superior or non-inferior genetic matching and neutralization against circulating virus in mice immunization experiments compared to the current vaccine. The method offers a promising and ready-to-use tool to facilitate vaccine strain selection for the influenza virus through capturing heterogeneous evolutionary dynamics over genome space-time and linking molecular variants to population immune response.

Deep generative design of RNA family sequences

RNA engineering has immense potential to drive innovation in biotechnology and medicine. Despite its importance, a versatile platform for the automated design of functional RNA is still lacking. Here, we propose RNA family sequence generator (RfamGen), a deep generative model that designs RNA family sequences in a data-efficient manner by explicitly incorporating alignment and consensus secondary structure information. RfamGen can generate novel and functional RNA family sequences by sampling points from a semantically rich and continuous representation. We have experimentally demonstrated the versatility of RfamGen using diverse RNA families. Furthermore, we confirmed the high success rate of RfamGen in designing functional ribozymes through a quantitative massively parallel assay. Notably, RfamGen successfully generates artificial sequences with higher activity than natural sequences. Overall, RfamGen significantly improves our ability to design functional RNA and opens up new potential for generative RNA engineering in synthetic biology.

popDMS infers mutation effects from deep mutational scanning data

Deep mutational scanning (DMS) experiments provide a powerful method to measure the functional effects of genetic mutations at massive scales. However, the data generated from these experiments can be difficult to analyze, with significant variation between experimental replicates. To overcome this challenge, we developed popDMS, a computational method based on population genetics theory, to infer the functional effects of mutations from DMS data. Through extensive tests, we found that the functional effects of single mutations and epistasis inferred by popDMS are highly consistent across replicates, comparing favorably with existing methods. Our approach is flexible and can be widely applied to DMS data that includes multiple time points, multiple replicates, and different experimental conditions.

Cryo-EM structure and functional landscape of an RNA polymerase ribozyme

The emergence of an RNA replicase capable of self-replication is considered an important stage in the origin of life. RNA polymerase ribozymes (PR) - including a variant that uses trinucleotide triphosphates (triplets) as substrates - have been created by in vitro evolution and are the closest functional analogues of the replicase, but the structural basis for their function is poorly understood. Here we use single-particle cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and high-throughput mutation analysis to obtain the structure of a triplet polymerase ribozyme (TPR) apoenzyme and map its functional landscape. The cryo-EM structure at 5-Å resolution reveals the TPR as an RNA heterodimer comprising a catalytic subunit and a noncatalytic, auxiliary subunit, resembling the shape of a left hand with thumb and fingers at a 70° angle. The two subunits are connected by two distinct kissing-loop (KL) interactions that are essential for polymerase function. Our combined structural and functional data suggest a model for templated RNA synthesis by the TPR holoenzyme, whereby heterodimer formation and KL interactions preorganize the TPR for optimal primer-template duplex binding, triplet substrate discrimination, and templated RNA synthesis. These results provide a better understanding of TPR structure and function and should aid the engineering of more efficient PRs.

A rugged yet easily navigable fitness landscape

Fitness landscape theory predicts that rugged landscapes with multiple peaks impair Darwinian evolution, but experimental evidence is limited. In this study, we used genome editing to map the fitness of >260,000 genotypes of the key metabolic enzyme dihydrofolate reductase in the presence of the antibiotic trimethoprim, which targets this enzyme. The resulting landscape is highly rugged and harbors 514 fitness peaks. However, its highest peaks are accessible to evolving populations via abundant fitness-increasing paths. Different peaks share large basins of attraction that render the outcome of adaptive evolution highly contingent on chance events. Our work shows that ruggedness need not be an obstacle to Darwinian evolution but can reduce its predictability. If true in general, the complexity of optimization problems on realistic landscapes may require reappraisal.

The Boltzmann distributions of molecular structures predict likely changes through random mutations

New folded molecular structures can only evolve after arising through mutations. This aspect is modeled using genotype-phenotype maps, which connect sequence changes through mutations to changes in molecular structures. Previous work has shown that the likelihood of appearing through mutations can differ by orders of magnitude from structure to structure and that this can affect the outcomes of evolutionary processes. Thus, we focus on the phenotypic mutation probabilities φqp, i.e., the likelihood that a random mutation changes structure p into structure q. For both RNA secondary structures and the HP protein model, we show that a simple biophysical principle can explain and predict how this likelihood depends on the new structure q: φqp is high if sequences that fold into p as the minimum-free-energy structure are likely to have q as an alternative structure with high Boltzmann frequency. This generalizes the existing concept of plastogenetic congruence from individual sequences to the entire neutral spaces of structures. Our result helps us understand why some structural changes are more likely than others, may be useful for estimating these likelihoods via sampling and makes a connection to alternative structures with high Boltzmann frequency, which could be relevant in evolutionary processes.

Accurate prediction of functional effect of single amino acid variants with deep learning

The assessment of functional effect of amino acid variants is a critical biological problem in proteomics for clinical medicine and protein engineering. Although natively occurring variants offer insights into deleterious variants, high-throughput deep mutational experiments enable comprehensive investigation of amino acid variants for a given protein. However, these mutational experiments are too expensive to dissect millions of variants on thousands of proteins. Thus, computational approaches have been proposed, but they heavily rely on hand-crafted evolutionary conservation, limiting their accuracy. Recent advancement in transformers provides a promising solution to precisely estimate the functional effects of protein variants on high-throughput experimental data. Here, we introduce a novel deep learning model, namely Rep2Mut-V2, which leverages learned representation from transformer models. Rep2Mut-V2 significantly enhances the prediction accuracy for 27 types of measurements of functional effects of protein variants. In the evaluation of 38 protein datasets with 118,933 single amino acid variants, Rep2Mut-V2 achieved an average Spearman's correlation coefficient of 0.7. This surpasses the performance of six state-of-the-art methods, including the recently released methods ESM, DeepSequence and EVE. Even with limited training data, Rep2Mut-V2 outperforms ESM and DeepSequence, showing its potential to extend high-throughput experimental analysis for more protein variants to reduce experimental cost. In conclusion, Rep2Mut-V2 provides accurate predictions of the functional effects of single amino acid variants of protein coding sequences. This tool can significantly aid in the interpretation of variants in human disease studies.

Phenotype switching of the mutation rate facilitates adaptive evolution

The mutation rate plays an important role in adaptive evolution. It can be modified by mutator and anti-mutator alleles. Recent empirical evidence hints that the mutation rate may vary among genetically identical individuals: evidence from bacteria suggests that the mutation rate can be affected by expression noise of a DNA repair protein and potentially also by translation errors in various proteins. Importantly, this non-genetic variation may be heritable via a transgenerational epigenetic mode of inheritance, giving rise to a mutator phenotype that is independent from mutator alleles. Here, we investigate mathematically how the rate of adaptive evolution is affected by the rate of mutation rate phenotype switching. We model an asexual population with two mutation rate phenotypes, non-mutator and mutator. An offspring may switch from its parental phenotype to the other phenotype. We find that switching rates that correspond to so-far empirically described non-genetic systems of inheritance of the mutation rate lead to higher rates of adaptation on both artificial and natural fitness landscapes. These switching rates can maintain within the same individuals both a mutator phenotype and intermediary mutations, a combination that facilitates adaptation. Moreover, non-genetic inheritance increases the proportion of mutators in the population, which in turn increases the probability of hitchhiking of the mutator phenotype with adaptive mutations. This in turns facilitates the acquisition of additional adaptive mutations. Our results rationalize recently observed noise in the expression of proteins that affect the mutation rate and suggest that non-genetic inheritance of this phenotype may facilitate evolutionary adaptive processes.

Evolvability-enhancing mutations in the fitness landscapes of an RNA and a protein

Can evolvability-the ability to produce adaptive heritable variation-itself evolve through adaptive Darwinian evolution? If so, then Darwinian evolution may help create the conditions that enable Darwinian evolution. Here I propose a framework that is suitable to address this question with available experimental data on adaptive landscapes. I introduce the notion of an evolvability-enhancing mutation, which increases the likelihood that subsequent mutations in an evolving organism, protein, or RNA molecule are adaptive. I search for such mutations in the experimentally characterized and combinatorially complete fitness landscapes of a protein and an RNA molecule. I find that such evolvability-enhancing mutations indeed exist. They constitute a small fraction of all mutations, which shift the distribution of fitness effects of subsequent mutations towards less deleterious mutations, and increase the incidence of beneficial mutations. Evolving populations which experience such mutations can evolve significantly higher fitness. The study of evolvability-enhancing mutations opens many avenues of investigation into the evolution of evolvability.

Environment-dependent epistasis increases phenotypic diversity in gene regulatory networks

Mutations to gene regulatory networks can be maladaptive or a source of evolutionary novelty. Epistasis confounds our understanding of how mutations affect the expression patterns of gene regulatory networks, a challenge exacerbated by the dependence of epistasis on the environment. We used the toolkit of synthetic biology to systematically assay the effects of pairwise and triplet combinations of mutant genotypes on the expression pattern of a gene regulatory network expressed in Escherichia coli that interprets an inducer gradient across a spatial domain. We uncovered a preponderance of epistasis that can switch in magnitude and sign across the inducer gradient to produce a greater diversity of expression pattern phenotypes than would be possible in the absence of such environment-dependent epistasis. We discuss our findings in the context of the evolution of hybrid incompatibilities and evolutionary novelties.

Mutational scans reveal differential evolvability of Drosophila promoters and enhancers

Rapid enhancer and slow promoter evolution have been demonstrated through comparative genomics. However, it is not clear how this information is encoded genetically and if this can be used to place evolution in a predictive context. Part of the challenge is that our understanding of the potential for regulatory evolution is biased primarily toward natural variation or limited experimental perturbations. Here, to explore the evolutionary capacity of promoter variation, we surveyed an unbiased mutation library for three promoters in Drosophila melanogaster. We found that mutations in promoters had limited to no effect on spatial patterns of gene expression. Compared to developmental enhancers, promoters are more robust to mutations and have more access to mutations that can increase gene expression, suggesting that their low activity might be a result of selection. Consistent with these observations, increasing the promoter activity at the endogenous locus of shavenbaby led to increased transcription yet limited phenotypic changes. Taken together, developmental promoters may encode robust transcriptional outputs allowing evolvability through the integration of diverse developmental enhancers.

This article is part of the theme issue ‘Interdisciplinary approaches to predicting evolutionary biology’.

Mapping the in vivo fitness landscape of a tethered ribosome

Fitness landscapes are models of the sequence space of a genetic element that map how each sequence corresponds to its activity and can be used to guide laboratory evolution. The ribosome is a macromolecular machine that is essential for protein synthesis in all organisms. Because of the prevalence of dominant lethal mutations, a comprehensive fitness landscape of the ribosomal peptidyl transfer center (PTC) has not yet been attained. Here, we develop a method to functionally map an orthogonal tethered ribosome (oRiboT), which permits complete mutagenesis of nucleotides located in the PTC and the resulting epistatic interactions. We found that most nucleotides studied showed flexibility to mutation, and identified epistatic interactions between them, which compensate for deleterious mutations. This work provides a basis for a deeper understanding of ribosome function and malleability and could be used to inform design of engineered ribosomes with applications to synthesize next-generation biomaterials and therapeutics.

Widespread epistasis among beneficial genetic variants revealed by high-throughput genome editing

The phenotypic effect of any genetic variant can be altered by variation at other genomic loci. Known as epistasis, these genetic interactions shape the genotype-phenotype map of every species, yet their origins remain poorly understood. To investigate this, we employed high-throughput genome editing to measure the fitness effects of 1,826 naturally polymorphic variants in four strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. About 31% of variants affect fitness, of which 24% have strain-specific fitness effects indicative of epistasis. We found that beneficial variants are more likely to exhibit genetic interactions and that these interactions can be mediated by specific traits such as flocculation ability. This work suggests that adaptive evolution will often involve trade-offs where a variant is only beneficial in some genetic backgrounds, potentially explaining why many beneficial variants remain polymorphic. In sum, we provide a framework to understand the factors influencing epistasis with single-nucleotide resolution, revealing widespread epistasis among beneficial variants.

What Has Genomics Taught An Evolutionary Biologist?

Genomics, an interdisciplinary field of biology on the structure, function, and evolution of genomes, has revolutionized many subdisciplines of life sciences, including my field of evolutionary biology, by supplying huge data, bringing high-throughput technologies, and offering a new approach to biology. In this review, I describe what I have learned from genomics and highlight the fundamental knowledge and mechanistic insights gained. I focus on three broad topics that are central to evolutionary biology and beyond-variation, interaction, and selection-and use primarily my own research and study subjects as examples. In the next decade or two, I expect that the most important contributions of genomics to evolutionary biology will be to provide genome sequences of nearly all known species on Earth, facilitate high-throughput phenotyping of natural variants and systematically constructed mutants for mapping genotype-phenotype-fitness landscapes, and assist the determination of causality in evolutionary processes using experimental evolution.

RNA sequence to structure analysis from comprehensive pairwise mutagenesis of multiple self-cleaving ribozymes

Self-cleaving ribozymes are RNA molecules that catalyze the cleavage of their own phosphodiester backbones. These ribozymes are found in all domains of life and are also a tool for biotechnical and synthetic biology applications. Self-cleaving ribozymes are also an important model of sequence-to-function relationships for RNA because their small size simplifies synthesis of genetic variants and self-cleaving activity is an accessible readout of the functional consequence of the mutation. Here, we used a high-throughput experimental approach to determine the relative activity for every possible single and double mutant of five self-cleaving ribozymes. From this data, we comprehensively identified non-additive effects between pairs of mutations (epistasis) for all five ribozymes. We analyzed how changes in activity and trends in epistasis map to the ribozyme structures. The variety of structures studied provided opportunities to observe several examples of common structural elements, and the data was collected under identical experimental conditions to enable direct comparison. Heatmap-based visualization of the data revealed patterns indicating structural features of the ribozymes including paired regions, unpaired loops, non-canonical structures, and tertiary structural contacts. The data also revealed signatures of functionally critical nucleotides involved in catalysis. The results demonstrate that the data sets provide structural information similar to chemical or enzymatic probing experiments, but with additional quantitative functional information. The large-scale data sets can be used for models predicting structure and function and for efforts to engineer self-cleaving ribozymes.

Deep mutational scanning: A versatile tool in systematically mapping genotypes to phenotypes

Unveiling how genetic variations lead to phenotypic variations is one of the key questions in evolutionary biology, genetics, and biomedical research. Deep mutational scanning (DMS) technology has allowed the mapping of tens of thousands of genetic variations to phenotypic variations efficiently and economically. Since its first systematic introduction about a decade ago, we have witnessed the use of deep mutational scanning in many research areas leading to scientific breakthroughs. Also, the methods in each step of deep mutational scanning have become much more versatile thanks to the oligo-synthesizing technology, high-throughput phenotyping methods and deep sequencing technology. However, each specific possible step of deep mutational scanning has its pros and cons, and some limitations still await further technological development. Here, we discuss recent scientific accomplishments achieved through the deep mutational scanning and describe widely used methods in each step of deep mutational scanning. We also compare these different methods and analyze their advantages and disadvantages, providing insight into how to design a deep mutational scanning study that best suits the aims of the readers' projects.

Higher-order epistasis and phenotypic prediction

One core goal of genetics is to systematically understand the mapping between the DNA sequence of an organism (genotype) and its measurable characteristics (phenotype). Understanding this mapping is often challenging because of interactions between mutations, where the result of combining several different mutations can be very different than the sum of their individual effects. Here we provide a statistical framework for modeling complex genetic interactions of this type. The key idea is to ask how fast the effects of mutations change when introducing the same mutation in increasingly distant genetic backgrounds. We then propose a model for phenotypic prediction that takes into account this tendency for the effects of mutations to be more similar in nearby genetic backgrounds.

Contemporary high-throughput mutagenesis experiments are providing an increasingly detailed view of the complex patterns of genetic interaction that occur between multiple mutations within a single protein or regulatory element. By simultaneously measuring the effects of thousands of combinations of mutations, these experiments have revealed that the genotype–phenotype relationship typically reflects not only genetic interactions between pairs of sites but also higher-order interactions among larger numbers of sites. However, modeling and understanding these higher-order interactions remains challenging. Here we present a method for reconstructing sequence-to-function mappings from partially observed data that can accommodate all orders of genetic interaction. The main idea is to make predictions for unobserved genotypes that match the type and extent of epistasis found in the observed data. This information on the type and extent of epistasis can be extracted by considering how phenotypic correlations change as a function of mutational distance, which is equivalent to estimating the fraction of phenotypic variance due to each order of genetic interaction (additive, pairwise, three-way, etc.). Using these estimated variance components, we then define an empirical Bayes prior that in expectation matches the observed pattern of epistasis and reconstruct the genotype–phenotype mapping by conducting Gaussian process regression under this prior. To demonstrate the power of this approach, we present an application to the antibody-binding domain GB1 and also provide a detailed exploration of a dataset consisting of high-throughput measurements for the splicing efficiency of human pre-mRNA 5′ splice sites, for which we also validate our model predictions via additional low-throughput experiments.

Fitness landscape analysis of a tRNA gene reveals that the wild type allele is sub-optimal, yet mutationally robust

Fitness landscape mapping and the prediction of evolutionary trajectories on these landscapes are major tasks in evolutionary biology research. Evolutionary dynamics is tightly linked to the landscape topography, but this relation is not straightforward. Here, we analyze a fitness landscape of a yeast tRNA gene, previously measured under four different conditions. We find that the wild type allele is sub-optimal, and 8–10% of its variants are fitter. We rule out the possibilities that the wild type is fittest on average on these four conditions or located on a local fitness maximum. Notwithstanding, we cannot exclude the possibility that the wild type might be fittest in some of the many conditions in the complex ecology that yeast lives at. Instead, we find that the wild type is mutationally robust (“flat”), while more fit variants are typically mutationally fragile. Similar observations of mutational robustness or flatness have been so far made in very few cases, predominantly in viral genomes.

Experimental exploration of a ribozyme neutral network using evolutionary algorithm and deep learning

A neutral network connects all genotypes with equivalent phenotypes in a fitness landscape and plays an important role in the mutational robustness and evolvability of biomolecules. In contrast to earlier theoretical works, evidence of large neutral networks has been lacking in recent experimental studies of fitness landscapes. This suggests that evolution could be constrained globally. Here, we demonstrate that a deep learning-guided evolutionary algorithm can efficiently identify neutral genotypes within the sequence space of an RNA ligase ribozyme. Furthermore, we measure the activities of all 2¹⁶ variants connecting two active ribozymes that differ by 16 mutations and analyze mutational interactions (epistasis) up to the 16th order. We discover an extensive network of neutral paths linking the two genotypes and reveal that these paths might be predicted using only information from lower-order interactions. Our experimental evaluation of over 120,000 ribozyme sequences provides important empirical evidence that neutral networks can increase the accessibility and predictability of the fitness landscape.

Neutral networks, which are sets of genotypes connected via single mutations that share the same phenotype, are important for evolvability. Here, the authors provide experimental evidence of a neutral network in an RNA enzyme using a high-throughput assay and deep learning.

Predicting higher-order mutational effects in an RNA enzyme by machine learning of high-throughput experimental data

Ribozymes are RNA molecules that catalyze biochemical reactions. Self-cleaving ribozymes are a common naturally occurring class of ribozymes that catalyze site-specific cleavage of their own phosphodiester backbone. In addition to their natural functions, self-cleaving ribozymes have been used to engineer control of gene expression because they can be designed to alter RNA processing and stability. However, the rational design of ribozyme activity remains challenging, and many ribozyme-based systems are engineered or improved by random mutagenesis and selection (in vitro evolution). Improving a ribozyme-based system often requires several mutations to achieve the desired function, but extensive pairwise and higher-order epistasis prevent a simple prediction of the effect of multiple mutations that is needed for rational design. Recently, high-throughput sequencing-based approaches have produced data sets on the effects of numerous mutations in different ribozymes (RNA fitness landscapes). Here we used such high-throughput experimental data from variants of the CPEB3 self-cleaving ribozyme to train a predictive model through machine learning approaches. We trained models using either a random forest or long short-term memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network approach. We found that models trained on a comprehensive set of pairwise mutant data could predict active sequences at higher mutational distances, but the correlation between predicted and experimentally observed self-cleavage activity decreased with increasing mutational distance. Adding sequences with increasingly higher numbers of mutations to the training data improved the correlation at increasing mutational distances. Systematically reducing the size of the training data set suggests that a wide distribution of ribozyme activity may be the key to accurate predictions. Because the model predictions are based only on sequence and activity data, the results demonstrate that this machine learning approach allows readily obtainable experimental data to be used for RNA design efforts even for RNA molecules with unknown structures. The accurate prediction of RNA functions will enable a more comprehensive understanding of RNA fitness landscapes for studying evolution and for guiding RNA-based engineering efforts.

Synonymous mutations in representative yeast genes are mostly strongly non-neutral

Synonymous mutations in protein-coding genes do not alter protein sequences and are thus generally presumed to be neutral or nearly neutral^1-5. Here, to experimentally verify this presumption, we constructed 8,341 yeast mutants each carrying a synonymous, nonsynonymous or nonsense mutation in one of 21 endogenous genes with diverse functions and expression levels and measured their fitness relative to the wild type in a rich medium. Three-quarters of synonymous mutations resulted in a significant reduction in fitness, and the distribution of fitness effects was overall similar-albeit nonidentical-between synonymous and nonsynonymous mutations. Both synonymous and nonsynonymous mutations frequently disturbed the level of mRNA expression of the mutated gene, and the extent of the disturbance partially predicted the fitness effect. Investigations in additional environments revealed greater across-environment fitness variations for nonsynonymous mutants than for synonymous mutants despite their similar fitness distributions in each environment, suggesting that a smaller proportion of nonsynonymous mutants than synonymous mutants are always non-deleterious in a changing environment to permit fixation, potentially explaining the common observation of substantially lower nonsynonymous than synonymous substitution rates. The strong non-neutrality of most synonymous mutations, if it holds true for other genes and in other organisms, would require re-examination of numerous biological conclusions about mutation, selection, effective population size, divergence time and disease mechanisms that rely on the assumption that synoymous mutations are neutral.

A Family of Fitness Landscapes Modeled through Gene Regulatory Networks

Fitness landscapes are a powerful metaphor for understanding the evolution of biological systems. These landscapes describe how genotypes are connected to each other through mutation and related through fitness. Empirical studies of fitness landscapes have increasingly revealed conserved topographical features across diverse taxa, e.g., the accessibility of genotypes and "ruggedness". As a result, theoretical studies are needed to investigate how evolution proceeds on fitness landscapes with such conserved features. Here, we develop and study a model of evolution on fitness landscapes using the lens of Gene Regulatory Networks (GRNs), where the regulatory products are computed from multiple genes and collectively treated as phenotypes. With the assumption that regulation is a binary process, we prove the existence of empirically observed, topographical features such as accessibility and connectivity. We further show that these results hold across arbitrary fitness functions and that a trade-off between accessibility and ruggedness need not exist. Then, using graph theory and a coarse-graining approach, we deduce a mesoscopic structure underlying GRN fitness landscapes where the information necessary to predict a population's evolutionary trajectory is retained with minimal complexity. Using this coarse-graining, we develop a bottom-up algorithm to construct such mesoscopic backbones, which does not require computing the genotype network and is therefore far more efficient than brute-force approaches. Altogether, this work provides mathematical results of high-dimensional fitness landscapes and a path toward connecting theory to empirical studies.

Current and Future Approaches to Classify VUSs in LGMD-Related Genes

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) has revealed large numbers of genetic variants in LGMD-related genes, with most of them classified as variants of uncertain significance (VUSs). VUSs are genetic changes with unknown pathological impact and present a major challenge in genetic test interpretation and disease diagnosis. Understanding the phenotypic consequences of VUSs can provide clinical guidance regarding LGMD risk and therapy. In this review, we provide a brief overview of the subtypes of LGMD, disease diagnosis, current classification systems for investigating VUSs, and a potential deep mutational scanning approach to classify VUSs in LGMD-related genes.

Expression level is a major modifier of the fitness landscape of a protein coding gene

The phenotypic consequence of a genetic mutation depends on many factors including the expression level of a gene. However, a comprehensive quantification of this expression effect is still lacking, as is a further general mechanistic understanding of the effect. Here, we measured the fitness effect of almost all (>97.5%) single-nucleotide mutations in GFP, an exogenous gene with no physiological function, and URA3, a conditionally essential gene. Both genes were driven by two promoters whose expression levels differed by around tenfold. The resulting fitness landscapes revealed that the fitness effects of at least 42% of all single-nucleotide mutations within the genes were expression dependent. Although only a small fraction of variation in fitness effects among different mutations can be explained by biophysical properties of the protein and messenger RNA of the gene, our analyses revealed that the avoidance of stochastic molecular errors generally underlies the expression dependency of mutational effects and suggested protein misfolding as the most important type of molecular error among those examined. Our results therefore directly explained the slower evolution of highly expressed genes and highlighted cytotoxicity due to stochastic molecular errors as a non-negligible component for understanding the phenotypic consequence of mutations.

AMaLa: Analysis of Directed Evolution Experiments via Annealed Mutational Approximated Landscape

We present Annealed Mutational approximated Landscape (AMaLa), a new method to infer fitness landscapes from Directed Evolution experiments sequencing data. Such experiments typically start from a single wild-type sequence, which undergoes Darwinian in vitro evolution via multiple rounds of mutation and selection for a target phenotype. In the last years, Directed Evolution is emerging as a powerful instrument to probe fitness landscapes under controlled experimental conditions and as a relevant testing ground to develop accurate statistical models and inference algorithms (thanks to high-throughput screening and sequencing). Fitness landscape modeling either uses the enrichment of variants abundances as input, thus requiring the observation of the same variants at different rounds or assuming the last sequenced round as being sampled from an equilibrium distribution. AMaLa aims at effectively leveraging the information encoded in the whole time evolution. To do so, while assuming statistical sampling independence between sequenced rounds, the possible trajectories in sequence space are gauged with a time-dependent statistical weight consisting of two contributions: (i) an energy term accounting for the selection process and (ii) a generalized Jukes-Cantor model for the purely mutational step. This simple scheme enables accurately describing the Directed Evolution dynamics and inferring a fitness landscape that correctly reproduces the measures of the phenotype under selection (e.g., antibiotic drug resistance), notably outperforming widely used inference strategies. In addition, we assess the reliability of AMaLa by showing how the inferred statistical model could be used to predict relevant structural properties of the wild-type sequence.

Unbiased inference of the fitness landscape ruggedness from imprecise fitness estimates

Fitness landscapes map genotypes to their corresponding fitness under given environments and allow explaining and predicting evolutionary trajectories. Of particular interest is the landscape ruggedness or the unevenness of the landscape, because it impacts many aspects of evolution such as the likelihood that a population is trapped in a local fitness peak. Although the ruggedness has been inferred from a number of empirically mapped fitness landscapes, it is unclear to what extent this inference is affected by fitness estimation error, which is inevitable in the experimental determination of fitness landscapes. Here, we address this question by simulating fitness landscapes under various theoretical models, with or without fitness estimation error. We find that all eight examined measures of landscape ruggedness are overestimated due to imprecise fitness quantification, but different measures are affected to different degrees. We devise a method to use replicate fitness measures to correct this bias and show that our method performs well under realistic conditions. We conclude that previously reported fitness landscape ruggedness is likely upward biased owing to the negligence of fitness estimation error and advise that future fitness landscape mapping should include at least three biological replicates to permit an unbiased inference of the ruggedness.

A prion accelerates proliferation at the expense of lifespan

In fluctuating environments, switching between different growth strategies, such as those affecting cell size and proliferation, can be advantageous to an organism. Trade-offs arise, however. Mechanisms that aberrantly increase cell size or proliferation-such as mutations or chemicals that interfere with growth regulatory pathways-can also shorten lifespan. Here we report a natural example of how the interplay between growth and lifespan can be epigenetically controlled. We find that a highly conserved RNA-modifying enzyme, the pseudouridine synthase Pus4/TruB, can act as a prion, endowing yeast with greater proliferation rates at the cost of a shortened lifespan. Cells harboring the prion grow larger and exhibit altered protein synthesis. This epigenetic state, [BIG+] (better in growth), allows cells to heritably yet reversibly alter their translational program, leading to the differential synthesis of dozens of proteins, including many that regulate proliferation and aging. Our data reveal a new role for prion-based control of an RNA-modifying enzyme in driving heritable epigenetic states that transform cell growth and survival.

Experimental Resurrection of Ancestral Mammalian CPEB3 Ribozymes Reveals Deep Functional Conservation

Self-cleaving ribozymes are genetic elements found in all domains of life, but their evolution remains poorly understood. A ribozyme located in the second intron of the cytoplasmic polyadenylation binding protein 3 gene (CPEB3) shows high sequence conservation in mammals, but little is known about the functional conservation of self-cleaving ribozyme activity across the mammalian tree of life or during the course of mammalian evolution. Here, we use a phylogenetic approach to design a mutational library and a deep sequencing assay to evaluate the in vitro self-cleavage activity of numerous extant and resurrected CPEB3 ribozymes that span over 100 My of mammalian evolution. We found that the predicted sequence at the divergence of placentals and marsupials is highly active, and this activity has been conserved in most lineages. A reduction in ribozyme activity appears to have occurred multiple different times throughout the mammalian tree of life. The in vitro activity data allow an evaluation of the predicted mutational pathways leading to extant ribozyme as well as the mutational landscape surrounding these ribozymes. The results demonstrate that in addition to sequence conservation, the self-cleavage activity of the CPEB3 ribozyme has persisted over millions of years of mammalian evolution.

Applications of Deep Mutational Scanning in Virology

Several recently developed high-throughput techniques have changed the field of molecular virology. For example, proteomics studies reveal complete interactomes of a viral protein, genome-wide CRISPR knockout and activation screens probe the importance of every single human gene in aiding or fighting a virus, and ChIP-seq experiments reveal genome-wide epigenetic changes in response to infection. Deep mutational scanning is a relatively novel form of protein science which allows the in-depth functional analysis of every nucleotide within a viral gene or genome, revealing regions of importance, flexibility, and mutational potential. In this review, we discuss the application of this technique to RNA viruses including members of the Flaviviridae family, Influenza A Virus and Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2. We also briefly discuss the reverse genetics systems which allow for analysis of viral replication cycles, next-generation sequencing technologies and the bioinformatics tools that facilitate this research.

Encapsulation of ribozymes inside model protocells leads to faster evolutionary adaptation

Functional biomolecules, such as RNA, encapsulated inside a protocellular membrane are believed to have comprised a very early, critical stage in the evolution of life, since membrane vesicles allow selective permeability and create a unit of selection enabling cooperative phenotypes. The biophysical environment inside a protocell would differ fundamentally from bulk solution due to the microscopic confinement. However, the effect of the encapsulated environment on ribozyme evolution has not been previously studied experimentally. Here, we examine the effect of encapsulation inside model protocells on the self-aminoacylation activity of tens of thousands of RNA sequences using a high-throughput sequencing assay. We find that encapsulation of these ribozymes generally increases their activity, giving encapsulated sequences an advantage over nonencapsulated sequences in an amphiphile-rich environment. In addition, highly active ribozymes benefit disproportionately more from encapsulation. The asymmetry in fitness gain broadens the distribution of fitness in the system. Consistent with Fisher's fundamental theorem of natural selection, encapsulation therefore leads to faster adaptation when the RNAs are encapsulated inside a protocell during in vitro selection. Thus, protocells would not only provide a compartmentalization function but also promote activity and evolutionary adaptation during the origin of life.

From genotypes to organisms: State-of-the-art and perspectives of a cornerstone in evolutionary dynamics

Understanding how genotypes map onto phenotypes, fitness, and eventually organisms is arguably the next major missing piece in a fully predictive theory of evolution. We refer to this generally as the problem of the genotype-phenotype map. Though we are still far from achieving a complete picture of these relationships, our current understanding of simpler questions, such as the structure induced in the space of genotypes by sequences mapped to molecular structures, has revealed important facts that deeply affect the dynamical description of evolutionary processes. Empirical evidence supporting the fundamental relevance of features such as phenotypic bias is mounting as well, while the synthesis of conceptual and experimental progress leads to questioning current assumptions on the nature of evolutionary dynamics-cancer progression models or synthetic biology approaches being notable examples. This work delves with a critical and constructive attitude into our current knowledge of how genotypes map onto molecular phenotypes and organismal functions, and discusses theoretical and empirical avenues to broaden and improve this comprehension. As a final goal, this community should aim at deriving an updated picture of evolutionary processes soundly relying on the structural properties of genotype spaces, as revealed by modern techniques of molecular and functional analysis.

Quantifying the Evolutionary Constraints and Potential of Hepatitis C Virus NS5A Protein

RNA viruses, such as hepatitis C virus (HCV), influenza virus, and SARS-CoV-2, are notorious for their ability to evolve rapidly under selection in novel environments. It is known that the high mutation rate of RNA viruses can generate huge genetic diversity to facilitate viral adaptation. However, less attention has been paid to the underlying fitness landscape that represents the selection forces on viral genomes, especially under different selection conditions. Here, we systematically quantified the distribution of fitness effects of about 1,600 single amino acid substitutions in the drug-targeted region of NS5A protein of HCV. We found that the majority of nonsynonymous substitutions incur large fitness costs, suggesting that NS5A protein is highly optimized. The replication fitness of viruses is correlated with the pattern of sequence conservation in nature, and viral evolution is constrained by the need to maintain protein stability. We characterized the adaptive potential of HCV by subjecting the mutant viruses to selection by the antiviral drug daclatasvir at multiple concentrations. Both the relative fitness values and the number of beneficial mutations were found to increase with the increasing concentrations of daclatasvir. The changes in the spectrum of beneficial mutations in NS5A protein can be explained by a pharmacodynamics model describing viral fitness as a function of drug concentration. Overall, our results show that the distribution of fitness effects of mutations is modulated by both the constraints on the biophysical properties of proteins (i.e., selection pressure for protein stability) and the level of environmental stress (i.e., selection pressure for drug resistance).

IMPORTANCE Many viruses adapt rapidly to novel selection pressures, such as antiviral drugs. Understanding how pathogens evolve under drug selection is critical for the success of antiviral therapy against human pathogens. By combining deep sequencing with selection experiments in cell culture, we have quantified the distribution of fitness effects of mutations in hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5A protein. Our results indicate that the majority of single amino acid substitutions in NS5A protein incur large fitness costs. Simulation of protein stability suggests viral evolution is constrained by the need to maintain protein stability. By subjecting the mutant viruses to selection under an antiviral drug, we find that the adaptive potential of viral proteins in a novel environment is modulated by the level of environmental stress, which can be explained by a pharmacodynamics model. Our comprehensive characterization of the fitness landscapes of NS5A can potentially guide the design of effective strategies to limit viral evolution.

A two-step PCR assembly for construction of gene variants across large mutational distances

Construction of empirical fitness landscapes has transformed our understanding of genotype-phenotype relationships across genes. However, most empirical fitness landscapes have been constrained to the local genotype neighbourhood of a gene primarily due to our limited ability to systematically construct genotypes that differ by a large number of mutations. Although a few methods have been proposed in the literature, these techniques are complex owing to several steps of construction or contain a large number of amplification cycles that increase chances of non-specific mutations. A few other described methods require amplification of the whole vector, thereby increasing the chances of vector backbone mutations that can have unintended consequences for study of fitness landscapes. Thus, this has substantially constrained us from traversing large mutational distances in the genotype network, thereby limiting our understanding of the interactions between multiple mutations and the role these interactions play in evolution of novel phenotypes. In the current work, we present a simple but powerful approach that allows us to systematically and accurately construct gene variants at large mutational distances. Our approach relies on building-up small fragments containing targeted mutations in the first step followed by assembly of these fragments into the complete gene fragment by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). We demonstrate the utility of our approach by constructing variants that differ by up to 11 mutations in a model gene. Our work thus provides an accurate method for construction of multi-mutant variants of genes and therefore will transform the studies of empirical fitness landscapes by enabling exploration of genotypes that are far away from a starting genotype.

The genotype-phenotype landscape of an allosteric protein

Allostery is a fundamental biophysical mechanism that underlies cellular sensing, signaling, and metabolism. Yet a quantitative understanding of allosteric genotype-phenotype relationships remains elusive. Here, we report the large-scale measurement of the genotype-phenotype landscape for an allosteric protein: the lac repressor from Escherichia coli, LacI. Using a method that combines long-read and short-read DNA sequencing, we quantitatively measure the dose-response curves for nearly 105 variants of the LacI genetic sensor. The resulting data provide a quantitative map of the effect of amino acid substitutions on LacI allostery and reveal systematic sequence-structure-function relationships. We find that in many cases, allosteric phenotypes can be quantitatively predicted with additive or neural-network models, but unpredictable changes also occur. For example, we were surprised to discover a new band-stop phenotype that challenges conventional models of allostery and that emerges from combinations of nearly silent amino acid substitutions.

Specificity of RNA Folding and Its Association with Evolutionarily Adaptive mRNA Secondary Structures

The secondary structure is a fundamental feature of both noncoding and messenger RNAs. However, our understanding of the secondary structure of mRNA, especially that of the coding regions, remains elusive, likely due to translation and the lack of RNA-binding proteins that sustain the consensus structure, such as those that bind to noncoding RNA. Indeed, mRNA has recently been found to adopt diverse alternative structures, the overall functional significance of which remains untested. We hereby approached this problem by estimating the folding specificity, i.e., the probability that a fragment of RNA folds back to the same partner once refolded. We showed that the folding specificity of mRNA is lower than that of noncoding RNA and exhibits moderate evolutionary conservation. Notably, we found that specific rather than alternative folding is likely evolutionarily adaptive since specific folding is frequently associated with functionally important genes or sites within a gene. Additional analysis in combination with ribosome density suggests the ability to modulate ribosome movement as one potential functional advantage provided by specific folding. Our findings revealed a novel facet of the RNA structurome with important functional and evolutionary implications and indicated a potential method for distinguishing the mRNA secondary structures maintained by natural selection from molecular noise.

Fitness landscape of a dynamic RNA structure

RNA structures are dynamic. As a consequence, mutational effects can be hard to rationalize with reference to a single static native structure. We reasoned that deep mutational scanning experiments, which couple molecular function to fitness, should capture mutational effects across multiple conformational states simultaneously. Here, we provide a proof-of-principle that this is indeed the case, using the self-splicing group I intron from Tetrahymena thermophila as a model system. We comprehensively mutagenized two 4-bp segments of the intron. These segments first come together to form the P1 extension (P1ex) helix at the 5' splice site. Following cleavage at the 5' splice site, the two halves of the helix dissociate to allow formation of an alternative helix (P10) at the 3' splice site. Using an in vivo reporter system that couples splicing activity to fitness in E. coli, we demonstrate that fitness is driven jointly by constraints on P1ex and P10 formation. We further show that patterns of epistasis can be used to infer the presence of intramolecular pleiotropy. Using a machine learning approach that allows quantification of mutational effects in a genotype-specific manner, we demonstrate that the fitness landscape can be deconvoluted to implicate P1ex or P10 as the effective genetic background in which molecular fitness is compromised or enhanced. Our results highlight deep mutational scanning as a tool to study alternative conformational states, with the capacity to provide critical insights into the structure, evolution and evolvability of RNAs as dynamic ensembles. Our findings also suggest that, in the future, deep mutational scanning approaches might help reverse-engineer multiple alternative or successive conformations from a single fitness landscape.

Idiosyncratic epistasis creates universals in mutational effects and evolutionary trajectories

Patterns of epistasis and shapes of fitness landscapes are of wide interest because of their bearings on a number of evolutionary theories. The common phenomena of slowing fitness increases during adaptations and diminishing returns from beneficial mutations are believed to reflect a concave fitness landscape and a preponderance of negative epistasis. Paradoxically, fitness decreases tend to decelerate and harm from deleterious mutations shrinks during the accumulation of random mutations-patterns thought to indicate a convex fitness landscape and a predominance of positive epistasis. Current theories cannot resolve this apparent contradiction. Here, we show that the phenotypic effect of a mutation varies substantially depending on the specific genetic background and that this idiosyncrasy in epistasis creates all of the above trends without requiring a biased distribution of epistasis. The idiosyncratic epistasis theory explains the universalities in mutational effects and evolutionary trajectories as emerging from randomness due to biological complexity.

DiMSum: an error model and pipeline for analyzing deep mutational scanning data and diagnosing common experimental pathologies

Deep mutational scanning (DMS) enables multiplexed measurement of the effects of thousands of variants of proteins, RNAs, and regulatory elements. Here, we present a customizable pipeline, DiMSum, that represents an end-to-end solution for obtaining variant fitness and error estimates from raw sequencing data. A key innovation of DiMSum is the use of an interpretable error model that captures the main sources of variability arising in DMS workflows, outperforming previous methods. DiMSum is available as an R/Bioconda package and provides summary reports to help researchers diagnose common DMS pathologies and take remedial steps in their analyses.

Genotype networks of 80 quantitative Arabidopsis thaliana phenotypes reveal phenotypic evolvability despite pervasive epistasis

We study the genotype-phenotype maps of 80 quantitative phenotypes in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana, by representing the genotypes affecting each phenotype as a genotype network. In such a network, each vertex or node corresponds to an individual's genotype at all those genomic loci that affect a given phenotype. Two vertices are connected by an edge if the associated genotypes differ in exactly one nucleotide. The 80 genotype networks we analyze are based on data from genome-wide association studies of 199 A. thaliana accessions. They form connected graphs whose topography differs substantially among phenotypes. We focus our analysis on the incidence of epistasis (non-additive interactions among mutations) because a high incidence of epistasis can reduce the accessibility of evolutionary paths towards high or low phenotypic values. We find epistatic interactions in 67 phenotypes, and in 51 phenotypes every pairwise mutant interaction is epistatic. Moreover, we find phenotype-specific differences in the fraction of accessible mutational paths to maximum phenotypic values. However, even though epistasis affects the accessibility of maximum phenotypic values, the relationships between genotypic and phenotypic change of our analyzed phenotypes are sufficiently smooth that some evolutionary paths remain accessible for most phenotypes, even where epistasis is pervasive. The genotype network representation we use can complement existing approaches to understand the genetic architecture of polygenic traits in many different organisms.

Targeted mutagenesis of multiple chromosomal regions in microbes

Directed evolution allows the effective engineering of proteins, biosynthetic pathways, and cellular functions. Traditional plasmid-based methods generally subject one or occasionally multiple genes-of-interest to mutagenesis, require time-consuming manual interventions, and the genes that are subjected to mutagenesis are outside of their native genomic context. Other methods mutagenize the whole genome unselectively which may distort the outcome. Recent recombineering- and CRISPR-based technologies radically change this field by allowing exceedingly high mutation rates at multiple, predefined loci in their native genomic context. In this review, we focus on recent technologies that potentially allow accelerated tunable mutagenesis at multiple genomic loci in the native genomic context of these target sequences. These technologies will be compared by four main criteria, including the scale of mutagenesis, portability to multiple microbial species, off-target mutagenesis, and cost-effectiveness. Finally, we discuss how these technical advances open new avenues in basic research and biotechnology.

Global fitness landscapes of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence

Shine-Dalgarno sequences (SD) in prokaryotic mRNA facilitate protein translation by pairing with rRNA in ribosomes. Although conventionally defined as AG-rich motifs, recent genomic surveys reveal great sequence diversity, questioning how SD functions. Here, we determined the molecular fitness (i.e., translation efficiency) of 4⁹ synthetic 9-nt SD genotypes in three distinct mRNA contexts in Escherichia coli. We uncovered generic principles governing the SD fitness landscapes: (1) Guanine contents, rather than canonical SD motifs, best predict the fitness of both synthetic and endogenous SD; (2) the genotype-fitness correlation of SD promotes its evolvability by steadily supplying beneficial mutations across fitness landscapes; and (3) the frequency and magnitude of deleterious mutations increase with background fitness, and adjacent nucleotides in SD show stronger epistasis. Epistasis results from disruption of the continuous base pairing between SD and rRNA. This “chain-breaking” epistasis creates sinkholes in SD fitness landscapes and may profoundly impact the evolution and function of prokaryotic translation initiation and other RNA-mediated processes. Collectively, our work yields functional insights into the SD sequence variation in prokaryotic genomes, identifies a simple design principle to guide bioengineering and bioinformatic analysis of SD, and illuminates the fundamentals of fitness landscapes and molecular evolution.