Legume-Rhizobium interactions: cowpea root exudate elicits faster nodulation response by Rhizobium species

The Role of Flavonoids in Nodulation Host-Range Specificity: An Update

Flavonoids are crucial signaling molecules in the symbiosis between legumes and their nitrogen-fixing symbionts, the rhizobia. The primary function of flavonoids in the interaction is to induce transcription of the genes for biosynthesis of the rhizobial signaling molecules called Nod factors, which are perceived by the plant to allow symbiotic infection of the root. Many legumes produce specific flavonoids that only induce Nod factor production in homologous rhizobia, and therefore act as important determinants of host range. Despite a wealth of evidence on legume flavonoids, relatively few have proven roles in rhizobial infection. Recent studies suggest that production of key "infection" flavonoids is highly localized at infection sites. Furthermore, some of the flavonoids being produced at infection sites are phytoalexins and may have a role in the selection of compatible symbionts during infection. The molecular details of how flavonoid production in plants is regulated during nodulation have not yet been clarified, but nitrogen availability has been shown to play a role.

Rapid Colored-Nodule Assay for Assessing Root Exudate-Enhanced Competitiveness of Bradyrhizobium japonicum

The effects of root exudate (RE) treatment on nodule occupancy by Bradyrhizobium japonicum were investigated by a rapid colored-nodule assay, which is based on the observation that B. japonicum L-110 and its antibiotically marked derivatives form dark-red nodules on certain soybean (Glycine max) cultivars, whereas other strains form beige nodules. The efficacy of the assay was confirmed by direct immunofluorescence and by antibiotic platings of nodule bacteria. Both logarithmic- and stationary-phase cultures of the reference strain, L-110Nal, were used in paired-competition studies with RE-treated or untreated cells of seven challenge strains. On the basis of field and greenhouse competition studies, these strains were placed into three competitiveness groups: high (AN-11, AN-16aStrRif, and AN-6), intermediate (AN-3 and 122SR), and low (I-110ARS and AN-18). Seedlings of G. max cv. Centennial were inoculated with two ratios of challenge to reference strain, 1:1 and 1:9, and nodule occupancy was determined after the V4 to V5 stage of ontogeny. Two of the strains showed increased occupancy in response to RE treatment at the 1:1 inoculation ratio. Logarithmic- and stationary-phase cultures of AN-6 showed increased occupancy, from 22 to 38% (P < 0.10) and from 23 59 39% (P < 0.05), respectively. While the maximum increase for stationary-phase cultures of AN-16aStrRif was from 34 to 47% (P < 0.05), logarithmic-phase cultures failed to respond to RE treatment. The results of these studies indicate that RE treatment increases the nodule occupancy of some, but not all, B. japonicum strains and that the colored-nodule assay could be rapidly and reliably used to determine the competitive ability of B. japonicum.

Alteration of the Trifoliin A-Binding Capsule of Rhizobium trifolii 0403 by Enzymes Released from Clover Roots

The effect of white clover root exudate on capsules of Rhizobium trifolii 0403 was examined. The clover lectin trifoliin A was detected in root exudate of two clover varieties by indirect immunofluorescence with antibody against this lectin purified from clover seed. Trifoliin A bound uniformly to encapsulated, heat-fixed cells during 1 h of incubation with root exudate. After 4 to 8 h of incubation, trifoliin A was only bound to one pole of the cells. Transmission electron microscopy showed that the capsule itself was altered. The disorganization of the acidic polymers of the capsule began in the equatorial center of the rod-shaped cell and then progressed toward the poles at unequal rates. Trifoliin A could no longer be detected on heat-fixed cells after 12 h of incubation with root exudate. However, trifoliin A was detected in situ on one pole of cells grown for 4 days in the clover root environment of Fahraeus slide cultures. Inhibition studies with the hapten 2-deoxy-d-glucose showed that trifoliin A in root exudate had a higher affinity for one of the cell poles. Immunoelectrophoresis was used to monitor the alteration of the extracellular polysaccharides from R. trifolii 0403 by concentrated root exudate. These polysaccharides were converted into products which eventually lost their ability to immunoprecipitate with homologous antibody. This progressive loss of antigenic reactivity proceeded more rapidly with root exudate from seedlings grown under nitrogen-free conditions than with root exudate from plants grown with 15 mM KNO(3). The root exudate, depleted of trifoliin A by immunoaffinity chromatography, was still able to alter the capsule of R. trifolii 0403. Reconstitution experiments showed that the substance(s) in root exudate which induced this alteration of the capsule was of a high molecular weight, heat labile, trypsin sensitive, and antigenically unrelated to trifoliin A. A variety of glycosidase activities were also detected in the fraction depleted of trifoliin A. These results suggest that enzymes in clover root exudate alter the trifoliin A-binding capsule in a way which would favor polar attachment of R. trifolii to clover root hairs.

Identification and cloning of Bradyrhizobium japonicum genes expressed strain selectively in soil and rhizosphere

The growth of Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA 110 and USDA 438 in soil extract-supplemented medium led to transcription of a large amount of DNA not expressed in basal medium. Strain USDA 438 was more competitive for the nodulation of soybean than strain USDA 110. To identify and isolate DNA regions which were expressed specifically in strain USDA 438 but not in strain USDA 110 in response to soil extract or soybean root exudate, we developed a subtractive RNA hybridization procedure. Several cosmid clones which showed strain-specific gene expression were isolated from a USDA 438 gene library. Two clones enhanced competitive nodulation when mobilized to USDA 110. The method described may be useful for identifying genes expressed in response to environmental stimuli or genes expressed differently in related microbial strains.

Isolation and Characterization of a Competition-Defective Bradyrhizobium japonicum Mutant

Tn 5 mutagenesis was coupled with a competition assay to isolate mutants of Bradyrhizobium japonicum defective in competitive nodulation. A double selection procedure was used, screening first for altered extracellular polysaccharide production (nonmucoid colony morphology) and then for decreased competitive ability. One mutant, which was examined in detail, was deficient in acidic polysaccharide and lipopolysaccharide production. The wild-type DNA region corresponding to the Tn 5 insertion was isolated, mapped, and cloned. A 3.6-kb region, not identified previously as functioning in symbiosis, contained the gene(s) necessary for complementation of the mutation. The mutant was motile, grew normally on minimal medium, and formed nodules on soybean plants which fixed almost as much nitrogen as the wild type during symbiosis.

Efficiency of Nodule Initiation and Autoregulatory Responses in a Supernodulating Soybean Mutant

We compared the formation of nodules on the primary roots of a soybean cultivar ( Glycine max (L.) Merr. cv. Bragg) and a supernodulating mutant derivative, nts382. Inoculation with Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA 110 at different times after seed imbibition showed that the roots acquired full susceptibility to infection only between 3 and 4 days postgermination. When the plants were inoculated with serial dilutions of a bacterial suspension, the number of nodules formed in the initially susceptible region of the roots was linearly dependent on the logarithm of the inoculum dose until an optimum dose was reached. At least 10-fold-lower doses were required to induce half-maximal nodulation responses on nts382 than on the wild type. However, at optimal doses, about six times as many nodules formed in the initially susceptible region of the roots in nts382. Since there was no appreciable difference in the apparent rates of nodule emergence, the increased efficiency of nodule initiation in the supernodulating mutant could have resulted from a lower threshold of response to bacterial symbiotic signals. Two inoculations (24 h apart) of G. max cv. Bragg revealed that there was a host-mediated regulatory response that suppressed nodulation in younger portions of the primary roots, as reported previously for other soybean cultivar- Bradyrhizobium combinations. Similar experiments with nts382 revealed a comparable suppressive response, but this response was not as pronounced as it was in the wild type. This and other results suggest that there are additional control mechanisms for nodulation that are different from the systemic autoregulatory control of nodulation altered in supernodulating mutants.

Early recognition in the Rhizobium meliloti-alfalfa symbiosis: root exudate factor stimulates root adsorption of homologous rhizobia

Adsorption of Rhizobium meliloti to alfalfa roots before their infection and nodule formation shows the specificity of the symbiotic association (G. Caetano-Anollés and G. Favelukes, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 52:377-382, 1986). The time course of specific adsorption of R. meliloti (10(3) to 10(4) cells per ml) to roots shows an initial lag period of 3 h, suggesting that either or both symbionts must become conditioned for the adsorption process. Preincubation of R. meliloti L5-30 for 3 h with dialyzed alfalfa root exudate (RE) markedly increased early adsorption of rhizobia to alfalfa roots. The activity in RE was linked to a nondialyzable, thermolabile, trypsin-sensitive factor(s), very different from the root-exuded flavonoid compounds also involved in early Rhizobium-legume interactions. The lack of activity in the RE from plants grown in 5 mM NO3- suggested its negative regulation by the nitrogen nutritional status of the plant. Preincubation of R. meliloti with heterologous clover RE did not stimulate adsorption of rhizobial cells to roots. A short pretreatment of RE with homologous (but not heterologous) strains eliminated the stimulatory activity from solution. The stimulation of adsorption of R. meliloti to alfalfa roots was strongly dependent on the growth phase of the rhizobia, being greater at the late exponential stage. Nevertheless, the capacity of R. meliloti L5-30 to eliminate from solution the stimulatory activity in RE appeared to be constitutive in the rhizobia. The low concentration of rhizobial cells used in these experiments was critical to detect the stimulation of adsorption. The early interaction of spontaneously released alfalfa root macromolecular factor(s) and free-living R. meliloti, which shows the specificity and regulatory properties characteristic of infection and nodulation, would be an initial recognition event in the rhizosphere which triggers the process of symbiotic association.

Effects of Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Soybean ( Glycine max (L.) Merr.) Phosphorus Nutrition on Nodulation and Dinitrogen Fixation

Cells of Bradyrhizobium japonicum were grown in media containing either 1.0 mM or 0.5 μM phosphorus. In growth pouch experiments, infection of the primary root of soybean ( Glycine max (L.) Merr.) by B. japonicum USDA 31, 110, and 142 was significantly delayed when P-limited cells were applied to the root. In a greenhouse experiment, B. japonicum USDA 31, 110, 122, and 142 grown with sufficient and limiting P were used to inoculate soybeans which were grown with either 5 μM or 1 mM P nutrient solution. P-limited cells of USDA 31 and 110 formed significantly fewer nodules than did P-sufficient cells, but P-limited cells of USDA 122 and 142 formed more nodules than P-sufficient cells. The increase in nodule number by P-limited cells of USDA 142 resulted in significant increases in both nodule mass and shoot total N. In plants grown with 1 mM P, inoculation with P-limited cells of USDA 110 resulted in lower total and specific nitrogenase activities than did inoculation with P-sufficient cells. Nodule numbers, shoot dry weights, and total N and P were all higher in plants grown with 1 mM P, and plants inoculated with USDA 31 grew poorly relative to plants receiving strains USDA 110, 122, and 142. Although the effects of soybean P nutrition were more obvious than those of B. japonicum P nutrition, we feel that it is important to develop an awareness of the behavior of the bacterial symbiont under conditions of nutrient limitation similar to those found in many soils.

Enhanced nodule initiation on alfalfa by wild-typeRhizobium meliloti co-inoculated withnod gene mutants and other bacteria

Nodule formation on alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) roots was determined at different inoculum dosages for wild-typeRhizobium meliloti strain RCR2011 and for various mutant derivatives with altered nodulation behavior. The number of nodules formed on the whole length of the primary roots was essentially constant regardless of initial inoculum dosage or subsequent bacterial multiplication, indicative of homeostatic regulation of total nodule number. In contrast, the number of nodules formed in just the initially susceptible region of these roots was sigmoidally dependent on the number of wild-type bacteria added, increasing rapidly at dosages above 5·10(3) bacteria/plant. This behavior indicates the possible existence of a threshold barrier to nodule initiation in the host which the bacteria must overcome. When low dosages of the parent (10(3) cells/plant) were co-inoculated with 10(6) cells/plant of mutants lacking functionalnodA, nodC, nodE, nodF ornodH genes, nodule initiation was increased 10- to 30-fold. Analysis of nodule occupancy indicated that these mutants were able to help the parent (wild-type) strain initiate nodules without themselves occupying the nodules. Co-inoculation withR. trifolii orAgrobacterium tumefaciens cured of its Ti plasmid also markedly stimulated nodule initiation by theR. meliloti parent strain. Introduction of a segment of the symbiotic megaplasmid fromR. meliloti intoA. tumefaciens abolished this stimulation.Bradyrhizobium japonicum and a chromosomal Tn5 nod(-) mutant ofR. meliloti did not significantly stimulate nodule initiation when co-inoculated with wild-typeR. meliloti. These results indicate that certainnod gene mutants and members of theRhizobiaceae may produce extracellular "signals" that supplement the ability of wild-typeR. meliloti cells to induce crucial responses in the host.

Efficiency of nodule initiation in cowpea and soybean

When serial dilutions of a suspension of Bradyrhizobium japonicum strain 138 were inoculated onto both soybean and cowpea roots, the formation of nodules in the initially susceptible region of the roots of both hosts was found to be linearly dependent on the log of the inoculum dosage until an optimum dosage was reached. Approximately 30- to 100-fold higher dosages were required to elicit half-maximal nodulation on cowpea than on soybean in the initially susceptible zone of the root. However, at optimal dosages, about six times as many nodules formed in this region on cowpea roots than on soybean roots. There was no appreciable difference in the apparent rate of nodule initiation on these two hosts nor in the number of inoculum bacteria in contact with the root. These results are consistent with the possibility that cowpea roots have a substantially higher threshold of response to symbiotic signals from the bacteria than do soybean roots. Storage of B. japonicum cells in distilled water for several weeks did not affect their viability or efficiency of nodule initiation on soybean. However, the nodulation efficiency of these same cells on cowpea diminished markedly over a 2 week period. These differential effects of water storage indicate that at least some aspects of signal production by the bacteria during nodule initiation are different on the two hosts. Mutants of B. japonicum 138 defective in synthesis of soybean lectin binding polysaccharide were defective in their efficiency of nodule initiation on soybean but not on cowpea. These results also suggest that B. japonicum may produce different substances to initiate nodules on these two hosts.

Two host-inducible genes of Rhizobium fredii and characterization of the inducing compound

Random transcription fusions with Mu d1(Kan lac) generated three mutants in Rhizobium fredii (strain USDA 201) which showed induction of beta-galactosidase when grown in root exudate of the host plants Glycine max, Phaseolus vulgaris, and Vigna ungliculata. Two genes were isolated from a library of total plasmid DNA of one of the mutants, 3F1. These genes, present in tandem on a 4.2-kilobase HindIII fragment, appear in one copy each on the symbiotic plasmid and do not hybridize to the Rhizobium meliloti common nodulation region. They comprise two separate transcriptional units coding for about 450 and 950 nucleotides, both of which are transcribed in the same direction. The two open reading frames are separated by 586 base pairs, and the 5H regions of the two genes show a common sequence. No similarity was found with the promoter areas of Rhizobium trifolii, R. meliloti, or Bradyrhizobium japonicum nif genes and with any known nodulation genes. Regions homologous to both sequences were detected in EcoRI digests of genomic DNAs from B. japonicum USDA 110, USDA 122, and 61A76, but not in genomic DNA from R. trifolii, Rhizobium leguminosarum, or Rhizobium phaseoli. Mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance analysis indicated that the inducing compound has properties of 4',7-dihydroxyisoflavone, daidzein. These results suggest that, in addition to common nodulation genes, several other genes appear to be specifically induced by compounds in the root exudate of the host plants.

Effect of lectin on nodulation by wild-type Bradyrhizobium japonicum and a nodulation-defective mutant

The nodulation characteristics of wild-type Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA 110 and mutant strain HS111 were examined. Mutant strain HS111 exhibits a delayed-nodulation phenotype, a result of its inability to initiate successful nodulation promptly following inoculation of the soybean root. Previously, we showed that the defect in initiation of infection leading to subsequent nodulation which is found in HS111 can be phenotypically reversed by pretreatment with soybean root exudate or soybean seed lectin. This effect is not seen after pretreatment with root exudates and lectins obtained from other plant species. Treatment of strain HS111 with as little as 10 soybean seed lectin molecules per bacterium (3.3 X 10 (-12) M) resulted in enhancement of nodule formation. Pretreatment of wild-type B. japonicum USDA 110 with soybean root exudate or seed lectin increased nodule numbers twofold on 6-week-old plants. Wild-type strain USDA 110 cells inoculated at 10(4) cells per seedling exhibited a delay in initiation of infection leading to subsequent nodulation. Wild-type cells pretreated in soybean root exudates or seed lectin did not exhibit a delay in nodulation at this cell concentration. Mutant strain HS111 pretreated in seed lectin for 0 or 1 h, followed by washing with the hapten D-galactose to remove the lectin, exhibited a delay in initiation of nodulation. Phenotypic reversal of the delayed-nodulation phenotype exhibited by strain HS111 was seen if incubation was continued for an additional 71 h in plant nutrient solution following 1 h of lectin pretreatment. Reversal of the delayed-nodulation phenotype of HS111 through lectin pretreatment was prevented by chloramphenicol or rifampin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Induction of Rhizobium meliloti nodC expression by plant exudate requires nodD

The soil bacterium Rhizobium meliloti invades and establishes a symbiosis with host plants such as alfalfa. Bacterial nodulation (nod) genes are required for this invasion, but their mechanism of action and the timing of their expression are not known. We have used translational lacZ fusions to monitor expression of nodD and nodC, which are located in the cluster of four nod genes on the R. meliloti megaplasmid (pSym). nodD is expressed at comparable levels by broth-grown bacterial cells and by cells exposed to exudates from aseptically grown plants. Activity of the nodC-lacZ protein fusion in broth-grown bacterial cells is very low. nodC-lacZ activity is increased approximately equal to 30-fold by plant exudate when nodD is expressed at a high level but not when nodD expression is low. Both fusions show differences in expression when borne on inc-P vectors as compared to when located on the pSym megaplasmid. nodD expression from vector-borne copies of the nod segment and response of nodC to plant exudate appear to require additional loci on the megaplasmid. Our results suggest that regulation of bacterial nod gene expression is an important control mechanism early in the symbiosis, and that the biochemical nature of some nod gene products may be cryptic except in cells grown in the presence of plant exudate.

Host recognition in the Rhizobium-soybean symbiosis : evidence for the involvement of lectin in nodulation

Rhizobium japonicum mutant strain HS111 was previously shown to be defective in the rate of initiation of infection leading to subsequent nodule formation (1984 Plant Physiol 74: 84-89). Mutant strain HS111's defect in nodulation can be phenotypically reversed to wild type levels by pretreatment with root exudates from all soybean varieties that have been tested. The data indicate that lectin-Rhizobium interaction is necessary for the phenotypic reversal of the nodulation characteristics of mutant strain HS111. Pretreatment of strain HS111 with soybean seed lectin mimics the effect of root exudate pretreatment. In addition, the presence of 30 millimolar d-galactose, a hapten of soybean seed lectin, in the root exudate or soybean seed lectin pretreatment solution prevents enhancement of nodulation of strain HS111. Pretreatment of mutant strain HS111 in soybean root exudate which has had galactose-specific lectin(s) removed by affinity chromatography (affinity eluate) results in no enhancement of nodulation by strain HS111. Lectin(s) subsequently removed from the affinity column possesses 100% of the stimulatory activity originally found in the root exudate. Pretreatment of strain HS111 in root exudate from a soybean seed line (T102) known to lack seed lectin due to an insertion in the structural gene results in the reversal of the defective nodulation phenotype. This latter result indicates that the lectin found in soybean root exudate is genetically distinct from the seed lectin. It is apparently this root lectin that is involved in nodulation.

Adsorption of slow- and fast-growing rhizobia to soybean and cowpea roots

Roots of soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr. cv Hardee) and cowpea (Vigna unguiculata [L.] Walp. cv Pink Eye Purple Hull) were immersed in suspensions containing 10(4)Rhizobium cells per milliliter of a nitrogen-free solution. After 30 to 120 minutes the roots were rinsed, and the distal 2-centimeter segments excised and homogenized. Portions of the homogenates then were plated on a yeast-extract mannitol medium for bacterial cell counts. The adsorption capacities of four slow-growing rhizobia and a fast-growing R. meliloti strain varied considerably. Adsorption was independent of plant species and of the abilities of the Rhizobium strains to infect and nodulate. R. lupini 96B9 had the greatest adsorption capacity, and Rhizobium sp. 3G4b16 the least. Rhizobium sp. 229, R. japonicum 138, and R. meliloti 102F51 were intermediate, except on cowpea, where the adsorption of strain 102F51 was similar to that of strain 3G4b16. The initial adsorption rates of bacteria cultured in synthetic media and in the presence of soybean roots were about the same. Addition of soybean lectin to the bacterial inoculum failed to influence initial adsorption rates. Both treatments, however, reduced the numbers of bacteria that bound after incubation with roots for 120 minutes. The relationship between the logarithm of the number of strain 138 cells bound per soybean root segment and the logarithm of the density of bacteria in the inoculum was linear over five orders of magnitude. Binding of strain 138 to soybean roots was greatest at room temperature (27 degrees C) and substantially attenuated at both 4 and 37 degrees C. Although R. lupini 96B9 strongly rejected a model hydrophobic plastic surface, there were no simple correlations between bacterial binding to model hydrophobic and hydrophilic plastic surfaces and bacterial adsorption to roots.

Host recognition in the Rhizobium-soybean symbiosis: detection of a protein factor in soybean root exudate which is involved in the nodulation process

The mechanism of host-symbiont recognition in the soybean-Rhizobium symbiosis was investigated utilizing mutants of R. japonicum defective in nodulation. Soybeans were grown in clear plastic growth pouches allowing the identification of the area on the root most susceptible to Rhizobium nodulation; the area between the root tip (RT) and smallest emergent root hair (SERH). The location of nodules in relation to this developing zone is an indication of the rate of nodule initiation. Nodules were scored as to the distance from the RT mark made at the time of inoculation. Seventy-eight per cent of the plants nodulate above the RT mark when inoculated with the wild type R. japonicum strain 3I1b110 with the average distance of the uppermost nodule being approximately 2 millimeters above the RT mark. These data indicate that the wild type strain initiates nodulation rapidly within the RT-SERH zone following inoculation. However, inoculation with the slow-to-nodulate mutant strain HS111 resulted in 100% of the plants nodulating only below the RT mark with the average distance of the uppermost nodule being approximately 56 millimeters below the RT mark. Thus, mutant strain HS111 is defective in the ability to rapidly initiate infection leading to nodulation within the RT-SERH zone. The location of the nodules suggest that stain HS111 must ;adapt' to the root environment before nodulation can occur. To test this, strain HS111 was incubated in soybean root exudate prior to inoculation. In this case, 68% of the plants nodulated above the RT mark with the average distance of the uppermost nodule being approximately 1 millimeter below the RT mark. Experiments indicated that the change in nodule initiation by strain HS111 brought about by incubation in soybean root exudate was due to a phenotypic, rather than a genotypic change. The half-time of root exudate incubation for strain HS111 necessary for optimal nodulation enhancement was less than 6 hours. Heat sensitivity and trypsin sensitivity of the nodulation enhancement factor(s) in soybean root exudate indicate a protein was involved in the reversal of the delay in nodulation by mutant strain HS111.

Effects of culture age on symbiotic infectivity of Rhizobium japonicum

The infectivity of the soybean symbiont Rhizobium japonicum changed two- to fivefold with culture age for strains 110 ARS, 138 Str Spc, and 123 Spc, whereas culture age had relatively little effect on the infectivity of strains 83 Str and 61A76 Str. Infectivity was measured by determining the number of nodules which developed on soybean primary roots in the zone which contained developing and preemergent root hairs at the time of inoculation. Root cells in this region of the host root are susceptible to Rhizobium infection, but this susceptibility is lost during acropetal development and maturation of the root cells within a period of 4 to 6 h (T. V. Bhuvaneswari, B. G. Turgeon, and W. D. Bauer, Plant Physiol. 66:1027-1031, 1980). Profiles of nodulation frequency at different locations on the root were not affected by the age of the R. japonicum cultures, indicating that culture age affected the efficiency of Rhizobium infection rather than how soon infections were initiated after inoculation. Inoculum dose-response experiments also indicated that culture age affected the efficiency of infection. Two strains, 61A76 Str and 83 Str, were relatively inefficient at all culture ages, particularly at low inoculum doses. Changes in infectivity with culture age were reasonably well correlated with changes in the proportion of cells in a culture capable of binding soybean lectin. Suspensions of R. japonicum in water were found to retain their viability and infectivity.