Natural killer activity in mice infected with Trypanosoma musculi

Impaired natural killer cell function as a consequence of aging

Alex Comfort wrote (1979): "... nobody needs long-lived mice." His point was, of course, that as much as possible, research should be done with humans "... who are the beneficiaries in mind ..." In this paper we hope to show that long-lived mice have been useful, if not essential, for conducting studies on the aging of innate immunity, specifically the NK cell component of the system. NK cells are activated early in the course of Trypanosoma musculi infections, which we employ as a model. We have generated evidence that the relatively severe infections of aged mice with T. musculi, are attributable, in part, to (a) functionally defective NK cells, the defect(s) being retained by LAK cells that arise from them, and (b) deficient amounts of IL-2 required to convert NK to LAK cells. Defective macrophages, which are the effector cells responsible for eliminating T. musculi, may also accumulate in aged animals. We postulate that the functionally deficient NK cells fail to generate adequate amounts of IFN gamma (and perhaps, TNF alpha) to optimally activate macrophages. This inadequacy can explain the weak ability of aged mice to control the early stage of T. musculi infection preceding the appearance of the more slowly-developing acquired immune response.

Innate control of the early course of infection in mice inoculated with Trypanosoma musculi

Infections of mice with Trypanosoma musculi result in marked suppression of acquired humoral immunity but rapid activation of splenic NK cell cytotoxicity. We show that both NK cells and activated peritoneal space (PS) macrophages (MP) participate in the innate immune control of T. musculi infections preceding escape of curative antibody production from suppression. Splenic NK cytotoxicity reaches a peak on Days 3-4 of infection and then rapidly declines. Rising cytotoxicity is paralleled by a rising number of NK cells. The decline in cytotoxicity occurs even though the number of splenic NK cells continues to rise. The critical role of NK cells in the control of the early course of T. musculi infection was demonstrated by the effects of either depleting NK cells (antiasialo GM1 treatment) or maintaining them in an activated state (poly(I:C) injections). The importance of MP in controlling the infection was suggested by studies involving proteose peptone elicited MP both in vivo and in culture. The results presented here strongly suggest that innate immunity involving NK cells and MP can control, but not cure, T. musculi infections. Whether this early innate response influences the subsequent acquired, curative response remains to be studied. Detailed analyses of innate immunity in this experimental infection should suggest new approaches to intervention in early pathogenic infections.

The role of natural killer cells in resistance to coccidiosis: investigations in a murine model

Natural killer (NK) activity, detected by the lysis of Yac-1 target cells, was examined in splenic and mesenteric lymph node (MLN) cells throughout the course of infection with Eimeria vermiformis in BALB/c and C57B1/6 (B6) mice. These strains are, respectively, relatively resistant and susceptible to primary infections, which render them equally, and completely, resistant to challenge. Resting levels of NK activity were higher in B6 than in BALB/c, and B6 responded earlier in the course of infection than BALB/c, but splenic peak values were higher in BALB/c; the pattern of response in MLN cells was similar in both strains, but the peak was higher in BALB/c. At the time (7 days p.i.) of peak NK response in BALB/c mice there was, depending upon the choice of NK-resistant/lymphokine-activated killer (LAK)-sensitive target cells, either little (P388D1), or no (P815) splenic LAK activity. Challenge of immunized BALB/c mice did not evoke a detectable NK response. Although the higher NK activity in BALB/c mice correlated with greater control of primary infection, depletion of NK activity (demonstrated in splenic cells) in vivo by treatment with anti-asialo GM1 antibodies did not greatly affect the course of infection. Furthermore, this treatment did not augment the exacerbation of infection produced by treatment with anti-interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) MoAb, indicating that, at least in this system, NK cells are not a fundamentally important source of this controlling cytokine of eimerian infections. The results suggest that NK cells may not greatly influence the outcome of coccidial infections.

MHC restricted and non-restricted killer lymphocytes

Cytotoxic lymphocytes are either MHC-restricted (cytotoxic T-cells) or nonrestricted (natural killer NK-cells), although cells of the monocyte/macrophage lineage are also cytotoxic, and lymphocytes or phagocytic cells expressing Fc-receptors for immunoglobulin can function as antibody-dependent killer cells (referred to as antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity: ADCC). Antigen-specific T-lymphocytes recognise their target antigen in the context of MHC class I components, focusing their attack only against those cells expressing the relevant antigen specificity on their cell surface. A more primitive and alternative mechanism exists whereby NK-cells, classified as large granular lymphocytes (LGL), are able to kill in a non-specific manner, not requiring prior sensitisation to antigen. Both antigen-specific T-cells and LGL mediate their cytotoxicity through the release of cytotoxic molecules at the target-effector cell interface. LGL also have a regulatory role in the immune system through the release of cytokines, and can be distinguished from T-lymphocytes by the expression of distinct phenotypic markers (CD16+, CD56+) and they lack CD3 antigen expression or rearranged alpha/beta or gamma/delta T-cell receptor gene products. Cytotoxic activity is positively regulated by interleukin-2 (IL-2) and interferon (IFN), whilst prostaglandins and transforming growth factor-beta (TGF beta) diminish activation and effector pathways. Cytotoxicity mediated by NK- and T-cell populations are principally involved in the defence against microbial infections and neoplasia; the abrogation of cytotoxicity either by direct interaction of 'suppressor factors' with effector cells, or indirectly by reducing cytokine production can inevitably lead to the proliferation of the disease.

Killer cells in human cutaneous leishmaniasis

In French Guiana, American cutaneous leishmaniasis is localized in the skin. The host response appears to be effective since few extra- or intracellular organisms can be found in tissue lesions, and we never observed any cutaneous dissemination or visceral involvement. However, this response is not fully effective since lesions may last for months. By using immunoperoxidase techniques and monoclonal antibodies directed against various cell populations, we examined the local immune response in skin biopsies. We found a high percentage of cells with the K/NK phenotype, a variable but usually high percentage of cells with the T cell phenotype bearing TAC receptors, and moderate numbers of monocytes and B cells. These results suggest that K/NK cells could play a role in the local control of parasite dissemination.

Age-associated decline in natural killer (NK) activity reflects primarily a defect in function of NK cells

The possible role that natural killer (NK) cells might play in the control of tumors and certain infections prompted an investigation of the status of NK cells in aged mice of two inbred strains (C3H and C57BL/6). The frequency of NK cells in young-adult and aged mice was assessed by two methods that provided accurate estimates of the relative numbers of NK cells: (a) a functional assay procedure from which the number of lytic units could be estimated, and (b) a target-cell (YAC-1 tumor cells) binding procedure. The frequency of NK cells in the spleens of untreated mice as well as in mice infected with Trypanosoma musculi, the latter a powerful NK cell activating agent, was determined. In both strains of mice the frequency of functionally-competent NK cells declined significantly with age, to a greater extent in C3H than in C57BL/6 mice. Similarly, the potential to generate NK cells upon parasite activation was significantly less in aged than in young mice and the reduced potential was more apparent in C3H than in C57BL/6 mice. In contrast, the target cell-binding procedure showed only a modest decline in the frequency of NK cells in the spleens of aged mice of either strain. It appears, therefore, that the decline in NK activity during aging is a reflection of loss of competence to lyse targets rather than a major decline in the actual numbers of NK cells.

Genetic resistance to murine cryptococcosis: the beige mutation (Chédiak-Higashi syndrome) in mice

The influence of the bgJ and bg2J mutations on the susceptibility of mice to experimental cryptococcosis was studied in inbred mice of the C57BL/6J and C3H/HeJ strains. Although infected animals with the bg/bg genotype had a significantly shorter lifespan than bg/+ or +/+ animals, C3H/He beige-2J mice were less susceptible than C57BL/6 beige-J mice when compared with nonbeige mice of similar background. On days 18 and 19 after infection, quantitation of cryptococci in the brain, liver, and spleen revealed that the overall burden of organisms in infected C57BL/6 beige-J mice was in excess of one log unit above that found in the brain, liver, and spleen of infected C57BL/6 +/+ mice. At that time, C57BL/6 beige-J mice showed a 53% increase in mean brain weight, a 67.8% decrease in mean liver weight, and a 58.6% decrease in mean spleen weight, when compared with uninfected animals of the same age and genetical lineage. The corresponding figures for C57BL/6 +/+ mice were a 32% increase in mean brain weight, a 41.4% decrease in mean liver weight, and a 23.4% decrease in mean spleen weight. From these data, it is concluded that the beige mutation in mice is associated with increased susceptibility to cryptococcosis, the accrued susceptibility of the beige mutant is related to more rapid changes in the weight profile of the target organs as well as to a higher rate of growth or decreased clearance of Cryptococcus neoformans or both, and other autosomal genes are likely to be involved in the genetic control of susceptibility to murine cryptococcosis.

Interaction of African trypanosomes with the immune system

African trypanosomes cause disease in man and domestic animals. The parasites have the ability to escape immune control by two means: by antigenic variation of the surface glycoprotein coat so that waves of variant parasites arise and by inducing a general immunosuppression affecting immune responses to the parasite as well as to parasite-unrelated antigens. The cellular basis of the immune dysfunction will be discussed in relation to a mouse model system - it is the result of proliferative stimuli to T- or B-cells which then become refractory to selection by antigen and normal control signals. Recent experiments have focused on macrophages as important direct target cells for parasite action. We have obtained no evidence for a parasite derived mitogen acting directly on B- or T-cells. In vitro cell proliferation is associated with accessory cells and relates only to T-cells. During infection, macrophages become activated with changes in receptor expression and mediator release, so that there is, for example, spontaneous IL-1 release (with a role in T- and possibly in B-cell proliferation) and several-fold increases in PGE2 secretion, with its immunosuppressive activities. We also find parasitaemia-associated release of alpha-beta and gamma interferon by various cells which in turn influences immune function. The active parasite component is associated with parasite membranes, but its nature has not been further defined. We proposed that the macrophage changes provide a general pathway causing immune dysfunction associated with many infections, be they parasitic or caused by other invading organisms.

Mechanisms of depression of splenic natural killer cell function in C57BL/6 mice infected with Leishmania donovani

C57BL/6 mice chronically infected with the protozoan parasite Leishmania donovani exhibit profoundly depressed splenic natural killer (NK) cell activity as measured by in vitro cytolysis of lymphoma target cells. Injection of infected mice with an interferon (IFN) inducer or in vitro treatment of infected splenocytes with IFN, a phorbol ester, or indomethacin failed to restore their NK activity to the degree shown by age-matched, uninfected mice. Fractionation of infected splenocytes by nylon wool, Sephadex G-10, or carbonyl iron and magnetism treatments was also unable to effect an increase in NK activity. Addition of infected splenocytes to uninfected ones in in vitro NK assays suppressed the NK activity of the latter, and the suppression could be partially or wholly abrogated by prior fractionation of infected splenocytes by the methods noted above. In vitro treatment of infected splenocytes with concanavalin A revealed the presence of NK activity in these cell populations. The results indicate that splenocytes in L. donovani-infected mice become insensitive to IFN stimulation; and the impairment of another, possibly IFN-independent pathway of NK-cell activation may also contribute to the observed L. donovani-induced depression in splenic NK activity in C57BL/6 mice.

Interaction between murine natural killer cells and trypanosomes of different species

The involvement of natural killer (NK) cells in the immunological resistance of mice to murine-specific Trypanosoma musculi was evaluated. Murine NK cells were found to be unable to kill or inhibit T. musculi or to protect recipients from infection. In addition, the ability of spleen cells from normal mice and from mice on day 3 of T. musculi infection, at the time of maximum NK augmentation, to kill Trypanosoma cruzi and Trypanosoma lewisi was evaluated. Spleen cells from normal mice displayed significant killing of both T. cruzi and T. lewisi. Furthermore, augmented spleen cells from T. musculi-infected mice were considerably more effective than normal spleen cells in killing both T. cruzi and T. lewisi. The activity of NK cells toward YAC-1 tumor target cells was inhibited in a dose-dependent fashion by either live T. musculi or extracts of T. musculi, but not by extracts of rat-specific T. lewisi. The results suggest that well-adapted protozoan parasites may be nonsusceptible to the natural cell-mediated resistance mechanisms of their hosts. Their nonsusceptibility could result from the ability to elaborate substances that either inactivate NK cells or block NK cell interaction with complementary sites on the parasite surface.

Splenic natural killer-cell activity in mice infected with Leishmania donovani

Several strains of inbred mice were infected with the protozoan parasite Leishmania donovani, and, at several points during the infection, spleens of groups of these mice were tested for natural killer (NK)-cell activity vs lymphoma target cells in vitro and were evaluated for parasite burdens. Generally, elevated followed by normal (compared to uninfected control mice) or subnormal NK responses occurred as the result of infection. Elevated NK responses were not accompanied by high circulating levels of interferon, yet infected mice responded to an injection of an interferon inducer with interferon production as great as control mice. No consistent correlations among susceptibility phenotype to L. donovani infection, spontaneous NK activity phenotype, and infection-induced NK activation/depression patterns were detected among the various strains of mice.

Age-associated impairment of murine natural killer activity

Natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity may be critical in the resistance displayed by animals and humans to tumors and various pathogenic microorganisms. Because the frequency of tumors and infections increases markedly in aging populations, we have compared the natural killer (NK) competence of lymphoid tissues (spleen, bone marrow) and of peritoneal cells of young adult and aged mice. Spontaneous NK activity was much lower, and the rate of target cell lysis was much less, in aged mice. The level of NK activity was only modestly increased in old, compared to young, mice when they were exposed to Trypanosoma musculi, an organism that provides strong stimulation of NK activity. Restricted NK activity of aged mice was not attributable to suppressor cells. The NK effector cells in old mice were characterized as being nonadherent to plastic, completely susceptible to lysis by complement plus an antiserum against specificity NK 1.2, and only slightly affected by treatment with antiserum against specificity Thy-1.2. Two indirect methods were employed to assess the relative frequency of splenic NK cells at the time of maximal stimulation by T. musculi: a cytotoxicity assay with antiserum against NK 1.2 and a binding assay involving monolayers of YAC-1 tumor target cells. Similar results were obtained in both assays, indicating that at maximal stimulation about 10% of the total spleen cells of both young and old mice were NK cells. We conclude (cautiously) that the functional efficiency of aged NK cells is impaired and that this defect may account, in part, for reduced ability of aged individuals to resist certain types of cancer and certain pathogenic microorganisms.