Mapping of rRNA genes with integrable plasmids in Bacillus subtilis

Multiple Ribosomal RNA Operons in Bacteria; Their Concerted Evolution and Potential Consequences on the Rate of Evolution of Their 16S rRNA

Bacterial species differ greatly in the number and location of the rRNA operons which may be present in the bacterial chromosomes and plasmids. Most bacterial species contain more than one ribosomal RNA operon copy in their genomes, with some species containing up to 15 such copies. We review the number and location of the rRNA operons and discuss evolution of 16S rRNA (rrs) genes -which are considered as ultimate chronometers for phylogenetic classification- in bacteria with multiple copies of these genes. In these bacterial species, the rrs genes must evolve in concert and sequence changes generated by mutation or horizontal gene transfer must be either erased or spread to every gene copy to avoid divergence, as it occurs when they are present in different species. Analysis of polymorphic sites in intra-genomic rrs copies identifies putative conversion events and demonstrates that sequence conversion is patchy and occurs in small conversion tracts. Sequence conversion probably arises by a non-reciprocal transfer between two or more copies where one copy contributes only a small contiguous segment of DNA, whereas the other copy contributes the rest of the genome in a fairly well understood molecular process. Because concerted evolution implies that a mutation in any of the rrs copies is either eliminated or transferred to every rrs gene in the genome, this process should slow their evolution rate relative to that of single copy genes. However, available data on the rrs genes in bacterial genomes do not show a clear relationship between their evolution rates and the number of their copies in the genome.

Bacterial clade with the ribosomal RNA operon on a small plasmid rather than the chromosome

rRNA is essential for life because of its functional importance in protein synthesis. The rRNA (rrn) operon encoding 16S, 23S, and 5S rRNAs is located on the "main" chromosome in all bacteria documented to date and is frequently used as a marker of chromosomes. Here, our genome analysis of a plant-associated alphaproteobacterium, Aureimonas sp. AU20, indicates that this strain has its sole rrn operon on a small (9.4 kb), high-copy-number replicon. We designated this unusual replicon carrying the rrn operon on the background of an rrn-lacking chromosome (RLC) as the rrn-plasmid. Four of 12 strains close to AU20 also had this RLC/rrn-plasmid organization. Phylogenetic analysis showed that those strains having the RLC/rrn-plasmid organization represented one clade within the genus Aureimonas. Our finding introduces a previously unaddressed viewpoint into studies of genetics, genomics, and evolution in microbiology and biology in general.

Differential responses of Bacillus subtilis rRNA promoters to nutritional stress

The in vivo expression levels of four rRNA promoter pairs (rrnp(1)p(2)) of Bacillus subtilis were determined by employing single-copy lacZ fusions integrated at the amyE locus. The rrnO, rrnJ, rrnD, and rrnB promoters displayed unique growth rate regulation and stringent responses. Both lacZ activity and mRNA levels were highest for rrnO under all growth conditions tested, while rrnJ, rrnB, and rrnD showed decreasing levels of activity. During amino acid starvation induced by serine hydroxamate (SHX), only the strong rrnO and rrnJ promoters demonstrated stringent responses. Under the growth conditions used, the rrn promoters showed responses similar to the responses to carbon source limitation induced by α-methyl glucoside (α-MG). The ratio of P2 to P1 transcripts, determined by primer extension analysis, was high for the strong rrnO and rrnJ promoters, while only P2 transcripts were detected for the weak rrnD and rrnB promoters. Cloned P1 or P2 promoter fragments of rrnO or rrnJ were differentially regulated. In wild-type (relA(+)) and suppressor [relA(S)] strains under the conditions tested, only P2 responded to carbon source limitation by a decrease in RNA synthesis, correlating with an increase in (p)ppGpp levels and a decrease in the GTP concentration. The weak P1 promoter elements remain relaxed in the three genetic backgrounds [relA(+), relA, relA(S)] in the presence of α-MG. During amino acid starvation, P2 was stringently regulated in relA(+) and relA(S) cells, while only rrnJp(1) was also regulated, but to a lesser extent. Both the relA(+) and relA(S) strains showed (p)ppGpp accumulation after α-MG treatment but not after SHX treatment. These data reveal the complex nature of B. subtilis rrn promoter regulation in response to stress, and they suggest that the P2 promoters may play a more prominent role in the stringent response.

Reverse transcription of 16S rRNA to monitor ribosome-synthesizing bacterial populations in the environment

Identification and quantification of phylogenetically defined bacterial populations in the environment are often performed using molecular tools targeting 16S rRNA. Fluorescence in situ hybridization has been used to monitor the expression and processing of rRNA by targeting the 3' tail of precursor 16S rRNA. To expand this approach, we employed reverse transcription of total RNA using primer S-D-Bact-0338-a-A-18. Length heterogeneity detected by slab gel analysis, denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) was used to differentiate the 5' tail of the precursor from mature 16S rRNA, and the relative abundance of the precursor compared to the abundance of mature 16S rRNA was shown to be a sensitive indicator of the physiologic state of Acinetobacter calcoaceticus ATCC 23055(T). Our results demonstrate that this is a sensitive and reliable method with a detection limit of 10 ng of single-stranded DNA. The assay was also used to differentiate among precursor 16S rRNA levels with mixed pure cultures, as well as to examine the response of a mixed activated sludge culture exposed to fresh growth medium and the antibiotic chloramphenicol. The results of this study demonstrate that this assay is a novel reverse transcription assay that simultaneously measures the mature and precursor 16S rRNA pools for mixed bacterial populations in an engineered environment. Furthermore, collection of the reverse transcription products derived from activated sludge samples by the DHPLC approach enabled identification of the active bacterial genera. Comparison of 16S and precursor 16S rRNA clone library results indicated that the precursor 16S rRNA library is a more sensitive indicator for active bacteria in engineered environmental samples.

Maturation and degradation of ribosomal RNA in bacteria

Ribosomal RNAs are the major components of ribosomes and are responsible for their catalytic activity. The three bacterial rRNAs (16S, 23S, and 5S) are cotranscribed as a single molecule that must be converted to the mature, functioning species through a series of nucleolytic processing events and base and sugar modifications that occur in the context of the assembling ribosome. One focus of this review is to examine the reactions that lead from the rRNA precursor to the mature species and to describe the ribonucleases (RNases) that carry out these processing reactions. rRNA, although usually stable in growing cells, also can be degraded if its assembly into ribosomes is aberrant or in response to certain stress conditions, such as starvation. The second focus of this review is to describe these degradative reactions, the RNases that carry them out, and the conditions that initiate the turnover process.

A cyanobacterial strain with all chromosomal rRNA operons inactivated: a single nucleotide mutation of 23S rRNA confers temperature-sensitive phenotypes

The presence of a multicopy chromosome, with each copy containing two rRNA operons (rrnA and rrnB), has been an obstacle to analysing mutated rRNA in Synechococcus PCC 7942. To create a system for expressing homogeneous mutated rRNA, the chromosomal rrn operons were sequentially inactivated and a final strain was successfully obtained with all the chromosomal rrn operons inactivated but carrying a replaceable multicopy plasmid containing a single rrn operon. The lag time required for growth response on dark/light shift of mutant strains with chromosomal rrnA or rrnB inactivated was increased 50 % over that of the wild-type strain; however, the presence of the plasmid-borne rrn operon restored the lag time. The doubling time of mutant strains carrying only a functional rrnB operon, but not strains carrying only a functional rrnA operon, was significantly longer than that of the wild-type strain. A strain in which essentially all the cellular 23S rRNA contained the mutation C2588A was temperature sensitive at 16 degrees C and 45 degrees C. Position C2588 is equivalent to C2611 of the peptidyltransferase centre in domain V of Escherichia coli 23S rRNA.

Characterization of Paenibacillus popilliae rRNA operons

The terminal 39 nucleotides on the 3' end of the 16S rRNA gene, along with the complete DNA sequences of the 5S rRNA, 23S rRNA, tRNA(Ile), and tRNA(Ala) genes were determined for Paenibacillus popilliae using strains NRRL B-2309 and Dutky 1. Southern hybridization analysis with a 16S rDNA hybridization probe and restriction-digested genomic DNA demonstrated 8 copies of the 16S rRNA gene in P. popilliae strains KLN 3 and Dutky 1. Additionally, the 23S rRNA gene in P. popilliae strains NRRL B-2309, KLN 3, and Dutky 1 was shown by I-CeuI digestion and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis of genomic DNA to occur as 8 copies. It was concluded that these 3 P. popilliae strains contained 8 rrn operons. The 8 operon copies were preferentially located on approximately one-half of the chromosome and were organized into 3 different patterns of genes, as follows: 16S-23S-5S, 16S-ala-23S-5S, and 16S-5S-ile-ala-23S-5S. This is the first report to identify a 5S rRNA gene between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes of a bacterial rrn operon. Comparative analysis of the nucleotides on the 3' end of the 16S rRNA gene suggests that translation of P. popilliae mRNA may occur in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli.

Variation in 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer regions among Bacillus subtilis 168 isolates

The genome of the Bacillus subtilis 168-type strain contains 10 ribosomal RNA (rRNA) operons. In the intergenic spacer region (ISR) between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes, five rRNA operons, rrnI-H-G and rrnJ-W, lack a trinucleotide signature region. Precise determination of molecular weight (MW), using electrospray mass spectrometry (MS), of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products from a segment of the ISR from the 168-type strain and B. subtilis 168-like strain 23071 demonstrated 114 and 111 basepair (bp) PCR products (due to the presence or absence of the insert in the operons) as predicted from sequence. However, PCR of the ISR segment for five other B. subtilis 168 isolates generated only a 114 bp PCR product, suggesting the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in all rRNA operons for these strains. Additional genetic variability between the seven B. subtilis 168 isolates was demonstrated by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of the rRNA operons, with three distinct patterns found upon Southern blot analysis. The 168-type strain and three others (23066, 23067, and 23071) exhibited the same Southern pattern. Thus, operon deletion is not responsible for the absence of a 111 bp product on MS analysis for strains 23066 and 23067. Restriction analysis confirmed the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in the ISR of all rRNA operons for five B. subtilis 168 isolates; sequencing of rrnW/H from a representative strain also upheld this finding. These results help provide a better understanding of variations in sequence, operon number and chromosomal organization, both within a genome and among isolates of B. subtilis subgroup 168. It is also hypothesized that the presence of the trinucleotide insert in certain rRNA operons may play a role in rRNA maturation and protein synthesis.

Charged tmRNA but not tmRNA-mediated proteolysis is essential for Neisseria gonorrhoeae viability

tmRNA, through its tRNA and mRNA properties, adds short peptide tags to abnormal proteins, targeting these proteins for proteolytic degradation. Although the conservation of tmRNA throughout the bacterial kingdom suggests that it must provide a strong selective advantage, it has not been shown to be essential for any bacterium. We report that tmRNA is essential in Neisseria gonorrhoeae. Although tagging per se appears to be required for gonococcal viability, tagging for proteolysis does not. This suggests that the essential roles of tmRNA in N.gonorrhoeae may include resolving stalled translation complexes and/or preventing depletion of free ribosomes. Although derivatives of N.gonorrhoeae expressing Escherichia coli tmRNA as their sole tmRNA were isolated, they appear to form colonies only after acquiring an extragenic suppressor(s).

Construction and initial characterization of Escherichia coli strains with few or no intact chromosomal rRNA operons

The Escherichia coli genome carries seven rRNA (rrn) operons, each containing three rRNA genes. The presence of multiple operons has been an obstacle to many studies of rRNA because the effect of mutations in one operon is diluted by the six remaining wild-type copies. To create a tool useful for manipulating rRNA, we sequentially inactivated from one to all seven of these operons with deletions spanning the 16S and 23S rRNA genes. In the final strain, carrying no intact rRNA operon on the chromosome, rRNA molecules were expressed from a multicopy plasmid containing a single rRNA operon (prrn). Characterization of these rrn deletion strains revealed that deletion of two operons was required to observe a reduction in the growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio. When the number of deletions was extended from three to six, the decrease in the growth rate was slightly more than the decrease in the rRNA/protein ratio, suggesting that ribosome efficiency was reduced. This reduction was most pronounced in the Delta7 prrn strain, in which the growth rate, unlike the rRNA/protein ratio, was not completely restored to wild-type levels by a cloned rRNA operon. The decreases in growth rate and rRNA/protein ratio were surprisingly moderate in the rrn deletion strains; the presence of even a single operon on the chromosome was able to produce as much as 56% of wild-type levels of rRNA. We discuss possible applications of these strains in rRNA studies.

Classification and genetic characterization of pattern-forming Bacilli

One of the more natural but less commonly studied forms of colonial bacterial growth is pattern formation. This type of growth is characterized by bacterial populations behaving in an organized manner to generate readily identifiable geometric and predictable morphologies on solid and semi-solid surfaces. In our first attempt to study the molecular basis of pattern formation in Bacillus subtilis, we stumbled upon an enigma: some strains used to describe pattern formation in B. subtilis did not have the phenotypic or genotypic characteristics of B. subtilis. In this report, we show that these strains are actually not B. subtilis, but belong to a different class of Bacilli, group I. We show further that commonly used laboratory strains of B. subtilis can co-exist as mixed cultures with group I Bacilli, and that the latter go unnoticed when grown on frequently used laboratory substrates. However, when B. subtilis is grown under more stringent semiarid conditions, members of group I emerge in the form of complex patterns. When B. subtilis is grown under less stringent and more motile conditions, B. subtilis forms its own pattern, and members of group I remain unnoticed. These findings have led us to revise some of the mechanistic and evolutionary hypotheses that have been proposed to explain pattern growth in Bacilli.

rRNA operon multiplicity in Escherichia coli and the physiological implications of rrn inactivation

Here we present evidence that only five of the seven rRNA operons present in Escherichia coli are necessary to support near-optimal growth on complex media. Seven rrn operons are necessary, however, for rapid adaptation to nutrient and temperature changes, suggesting it is the ability to adapt quickly to changing environmental conditions that has provided the selective pressure for the persistence of seven rrn operons in E. coli. We have also found that one consequence of rrn operon inactivation is a miscoordination of the concentrations of initiation factor IF3 and ribosomes.

A relA(S) suppressor mutant allele of Bacillus subtilis which maps to relA and responds only to carbon limitation

The histidine analog 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole (AT) was used for the selection of spontaneous AT-resistant revertants of a relA mutant of Bacillus subtilis. One of these revertants, L3, showed a unique phenotype; it did not respond to amino acid starvation, like the relA mutant, but it did respond to glucose starvation by the accumulation of (p)ppGpp, unlike its parent. Genetic analysis revealed that this suppressor mutant (relA(S)) allele mapped to the relA locus at 239 degrees on the B. subtilis chromosome.

Physical mapping of stable RNA genes in Bacillus subtilis using polymerase chain reaction amplification from a yeast artificial chromosome library

A new approach for mapping genes which utilizes yeast artificial chromosome clones carrying parts of the Bacillus subtilis genome and the polymerase chain reaction technique is described. This approach was used to physically map stable RNA genes of B. subtilis. Results from over 400 polymerase chain reactions carried out with the yeast artificial chromosome clone library, using primers specific for the genes of interest and designed from published sequences, were collected. The locations of 10 known rRNA gene regions (rrnO, rrnA, rrnE, rrnD, rrnB, rrnJ-rrnW, and rrnI-rrnH-rrnG) have been determined by this method, and these results correlate with those observed by standard genetic mapping. All rRNA operons, except rrnB, are found between 0 and 90 degrees, while rrnB has been placed in the area of 270 degrees on the chromosome map. Also localized were the tRNA gene clusters associated with the following ribosomal operons: rrnB (21 tRNAs), rrnJ (9 tRNAs), rrnD (16 tRNAs), and rrnO and rrnA (2 internal tRNAs). A previously unmapped four-tRNA gene cluster, trnY, a tRNA gene region that is not associated with a ribosomal operon, was found near the origin of replication. The P-RNA gene, important for processing of tRNAs, was found between map locations 197 and 204 degrees.

Two tRNA gene clusters associated with rRNA operons rrnD and rrnE in Bacillus subtilis

Sequence analysis of cloned rescued DNA fragments from a Bacillus subtilis strain with an inserted recombinant plasmid in ribosomal operon rrnE revealed the presence of two tRNA genes for Met and Asp at the 3' end of the operon. Probing chromosomal DNA from a strain carrying a plasmid inserted in rrnD with a fragment containing the genetically unassigned cluster of 16 tRNA genes revealed that the cluster is located immediately following the rrnD operon. Our findings show that all 10 rrn operons in B. subtilis are associated with tRNA gene clusters.

Structure and organization of ribosomal DNA

Three trends are seen in the organization of ribosomal DNA genes during evolution: 1) gradual separation and separability of the regulation of transcription of 5S and larger subunit rRNAs; 2) retention of a transcription unit containing both large and small rRNAs; and 3) clustering of genes for both 5S and 18S-28S rDNAs, with the possible association of other 'non-rDNA' in the clusters of 18S-28S rDNA genes by the time mammals evolve.

Genetic structure and DNA sequences at junctions involved in the rearrangements of Bacillus subtilis strains carrying the trpE26 mutation

Studies on the region upstream to ribosomal operon rrnD of Bacillus subtilis led to the characterization of two of the four chromosomal junctions involved in the rearrangements (a translocation and an inversion) of the strains carrying the trpE26 mutation. Genetic analysis, by integrative mapping, showed linkage of rrnD to cysB and hisA (both on segment A) in the trpE26-type strains. Physical analysis showed that the region upstream to rrnD is now linked to the trpE-ilvA chromosome segment as demonstrated by analyzing restriction site-polymorphism between 168 and trpE26-type strains. Similar experiments confirmed the previous genetic data on linkage in these areas in strains carrying novel rearrangements derived from the trpE26-type strains: stable merodiploids and inversions. The nucleotide sequence of the area 5' to rrnD in both types of strains (168 and trpE26), the region downstream of the citG gene and the region carrying the trpE26 mutation (made available to us by D. Henner) provided evidence for the molecular basis of the differences in structure, allowed the identification of the break points and revealed the presence of a polypurine region upstream to rrnD as seen in other systems in B. subtilis. No extensive homology was found between pairs of junctions so far sequenced. The models proposed by C. Anagnostopoulos for the role of DNA sequences of intrachromosomal homology involved in the transfer of the trpE26 mutation and the formation of novel arrangements require therefore reevaluation.

Construction, transfer and properties of a novel temperature-sensitive integrable plasmid for genomic analysis of Staphylococcus aureus

As an alternative approach to genetic transfer and analysis, a novel integrable plasmid system was developed that should prove useful for mapping and cloning various genes in Staphylococcus aureus and other Gram-positive bacteria. The use of a restriction-deficient recipient strain and an improved protocol for protoplast plasmid transformation facilitated direct cloning of a recombinant plasmid (pPQ126) in S. aureus NCTC 8325-4. Plasmid pPQ126 (13.6 kb) is a novel, temperature-sensitive integrable plasmid containing genes encoding resistance to erythromycin and chloramphenicol (from plasmid pTV1ts), and resistance to gentamicin (from transposon Tn4001). When introduced into an appropriate recipient strain at the permissive temperature (30 degrees C), pPQ126 replicates autonomously. Integration of pPQ126 is directed into homologous chromosomal target sequences (chromosomal insertions of Tn551 or Tn4001) by growing a population of cells containing autonomous pPQ126 in the presence of gentamicin, erythromycin, and chloramphenicol at 39 degrees C (nonpermissive temperature). Elevated temperature both selects for and maintains pPQ126 as an integrated replicon. Integration of pPQ126 occurs at significantly reduced frequency in a recombination-deficient host, and does not occur in the absence of host chromosomal homology. Integrated pPQ126 excises from the chromosome under permissive conditions (30 degrees C), and excision results in derivatives of pPQ126 that harbour DNA of chromosomal origin.

Chromosomal organization of rRNA operons in Bacillus subtilis

Integrative mapping with vectors containing ribosomal DNA sequences were used to complete the mapping of the 10 rRNA gene sets in the endospore forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis. Southern hybridizations allowed the assignment of nine operons to distinct BclI restriction fragments and their genetic locus identified by transductional crosses. Nine of the ten rRNA gene sets are located between 0 and 70 degrees on the genomic map. In the region surrounding cysA14, two sets of closely spaced tandem clusters are present. The first (rrnJ and rrnW) is located between purA16 and cysA14 closely linked to the latter; the second (rrnI, rrnH and rrnG) previously mapped within this area is located between attSPO2 and glpT6. The operons at or near the origin of replication (rrnO,rrnA and rrnJ,rrnW) represent "hot spots" of plasmid insertion.

Instability of rRNA operons in Bacillus subtilis

Many laboratory strains of Bacillus subtilis contain 9 rather than 10 rRNA operons due to deletions occurring within the rrnJ-rrnW or rrnI-rrnH-rrnG gene cluster. These operons are members of two sets of closely spaced clusters located in the cysA-aroI region. Analysis of rescued DNA from integrants with insertions into rrnG and rrnH indicated that these tandemly arranged operons allowed frequent deletions of an rrn operon equivalent. These events may arise spontaneously by intrachromosomal recombination or by simultaneous double crossovers with a multimeric integrative plasmid.