Effects of release factor context at UAA codons in Escherichia coli

Regulation of release factor expression using a translational negative feedback loop: a systems analysis

The essential eukaryote release factor eRF1, encoded by the yeast SUP45 gene, recognizes stop codons during ribosomal translation. SUP45 nonsense alleles are, however, viable due to the establishment of feedback-regulated readthrough of the premature termination codon; reductions in full-length eRF1 promote tRNA-mediated stop codon readthrough, which, in turn, drives partial production of full-length eRF1. A deterministic mathematical model of this eRF1 feedback loop was developed using a staged increase in model complexity. Model predictions matched the experimental observation that strains carrying the mutant SUQ5 tRNA (a weak UAA suppressor) in combination with any of the tested sup45(UAA) nonsense alleles exhibit threefold more stop codon readthrough than that of an SUQ5 yeast strain. The model also successfully predicted that eRF1 feedback control in an SUQ5 sup45(UAA) mutant would resist, but not completely prevent, imposed changes in eRF1 expression. In these experiments, the introduction of a plasmid-borne SUQ5 copy into a sup45(UAA) SUQ5 mutant directed additional readthrough and full-length eRF1 expression, despite feedback. Secondly, induction of additional sup45(UAA) mRNA expression in a sup45(UAA) SUQ5 strain also directed increased full-length eRF1 expression. The autogenous sup45 control mechanism therefore acts not to precisely control eRF1 expression, but rather as a damping mechanism that only partially resists changes in release factor expression level. The validated model predicts that the degree of feedback damping (i.e., control precision) is proportional to eRF1 affinity for the premature stop codon. The validated model represents an important tool to analyze this and other translational negative feedback loops.

Optimizing scaleup yield for protein production: Computationally Optimized DNA Assembly (CODA) and Translation Engineering™

Translation Engineering combined with synthetic biology (gene synthesis) techniques makes it possible to deliberately alter the presumed translation kinetics of genes without altering the amino acid sequence. Here, we describe proprietary technologies that design and assemble synthetic genes for high expression and enhanced protein production, and offers new insights and methodologies for affecting protein structure and function. We have patented Translation Engineering technologies to manage the complexity of gene design to account for codon pair usage, translational pausing signals, RNA secondary structure and user-defined sequences such as restriction sites. Failure to optimize for codon pair-encoded translation pauses often results in the relatively common occurrence of a slowly translated codon pair that slows the rate of protein elongation and decreases total protein production. Translation Engineering technology improves heterologous expression by tuning the gene sequence for translation in any well-characterized host, including cell-free expression techniques characterized by "broken"Escherichia coli systems used in kits for today's molecular tools market. In addition, we have patented a novel gene assembly method (Computationally Optimized DNA Assembly; CODA) that uses the degeneracy of the genetic code to design oligonucleotides with thermodynamic properties for self-assembly into a single, linear DNA product. Fast translational kinetics and robust protein expression are optimized in synthetic "Hot Rod" genes that are guaranteed to express in E. coli at high levels. These genes are optimized for codon usage and other properties known to aid protein expression, and importantly, they are engineered to be devoid of mRNA secondary structures that might impede transcription, and over-represented codon pairs that might impede translation. Hot Rod genes allow translating ribosomes and E. coli RNA polymerases to maintain coupled translation and transcription at maximal rates. As a result, the nascent mRNA is produced at a high level and is sequestered in polysomes where it is protected from degradation, even further enhancing protein production. In this review we demonstrate that codon context can profoundly influence translation kinetics, and that over-represented codon pairs are often present at protein domain boundaries and appear to control independent protein folding in several popular expression systems. Finally, we consider that over-represented codon pairs (pause sites) may be essential to solving problems of protein expression, solubility, folding and activity encountered when genes are introduced into heterologous expression systems, where the specific set of codon pairs controlling ribosome pausing are different. Thus, Translation Engineering combined with synthetic biology (gene synthesis) techniques may allow us to manipulate the translation kinetics of genes to restore or enhance function in a variety of traditional and novel expression systems.

Comparison of characteristics and function of translation termination signals between and within prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms

Six diverse prokaryotic and five eukaryotic genomes were compared to deduce whether the protein synthesis termination signal has common determinants within and across both kingdoms. Four of the six prokaryotic and all of the eukaryotic genomes investigated demonstrated a similar pattern of nucleotide bias both 5′ and 3′ of the stop codon. A preferred core signal of 4 nt was evident, encompassing the stop codon and the following nucleotide. Codons decoded by hyper-modified tRNAs were over-represented in the region 5′ to the stop codon in genes from both kingdoms. The origin of the 3′ bias was more variable particularly among the prokaryotic organisms. In both kingdoms, genes with the highest expression index exhibited a strong bias but genes with the lowest expression showed none. Absence of bias in parasitic prokaryotes may reflect an absence of pressure to evolve more efficient translation. Experiments were undertaken to determine if a correlation existed between bias in signal abundance and termination efficiency. In Escherichia coli signal abundance correlated with termination efficiency for UAA and UGA stop codons, but not in mammalian cells. Termination signals that were highly inefficient could be made more efficient by increasing the concentration of the cognate decoding release factor.

Predicting the efficiency of UAG translational stop signal through studies of physicochemical properties of its composite mono- and dinucleotides

In this study, we explored the problem of predicting the UAG stop-codon read-through efficiency. The reported nucleotide sequences were first converted into physicochemical property vectors before being presented to a machine learning algorithm. Two sets of physicochemical properties were applied: one for mononucleosides (in terms of steric bulk, hydrophobicity and electronics) and another for dinucleotides. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of how dinucleotides are converted into principle components derived from NMR chemical shift data. A few efficiency prediction models were then derived and a comparison between mononucleoside and dinucleotide-based models was shown. In the derived models, the coefficients of these property based predictors lend themselves to bio-physical interpretations, an advantage which is demonstrated in this study via a prediction model based on the steric bulk factor. Although it is quite simple, the steric bulk factor model explained well the effect of sequence variations surrounding the amber stop codon and the tRNA bearing UCCU anticodon. We further proposed new alternatives at position -1 and +4 of a UAG stop codon sequence to enhance the readthrough efficiency. This research may contribute to a better understanding of the readthrough mechanisms and may also help to study the normal translation termination process.

Selenocysteine codons decrease polysome association on endogenous selenoprotein mRNAs

BACKGROUND

Selenocysteine incorporation has been reported to be inefficient in all systems studied, including Escherichia coli, baculovirus-insect cell systems, rabbit reticulocyte in vitro translation systems, transiently transfected mammalian cells, and intact animals. Nonetheless, full-length selenoproteins containing up to 17 selenocysteine residues are produced in animals, indicating that the efficiency observed in manipulated systems might not accurately reflect the true efficiency of this process in nature.

RESULTS

To begin to address this apparent discrepancy, we have examined the polysome profiles of endogenously expressed selenoprotein mRNAs in a mammalian cell line, and compared them with nonselenoprotein mRNAs. We report that three selenoprotein mRNAs, type 1 deiodinase, glutathione peroxidase and selenoprotein P, are under-loaded with ribosomes, based on their predicted open reading frame sizes. The average numbers of ribosomes per mRNA correspond to the sizes predicted by termination at the UGA selenocysteine codons. Appropriate loading on the type 1 deiodinase mRNA is seen following substitution of a cysteine codon for the selenocysteine codon, indicating that the UGA codon confers a translational penalty on the mRNA. Surprisingly, ribosomal loading is also increased by the expression of eukaryotic release factors eRF1 and eRF3.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the presence of a selenocysteine codon confers a translational penalty on selenoprotein mRNAs, and that increased levels of release factors may alter the kinetics of termination.

Role of ribosome recycling factor (RRF) in translational coupling

RNA phage GA coat and lysis protein expression are translationally coupled through an overlapping termination and initiation codon UAAUG. Essential for this coupling are the proximity of the termination codon of the upstream coat gene to the initiation codon of the lysis gene (either a <3 nucleotide separation or physical closeness through a possible hairpin structure) but not the Shine-Dalgarno sequence. This suggests that the ribosomes completing the coat gene translation are exclusively responsible for translation of the lysis gene. Inactivation of ribosome recycling factor (RRF), which normally releases ribosomes at the termination codon, did not influence the expression of the reporter gene fused to the lysis gene. This suggests the possibility that RRF may not release ribosomes from the junction UAAUG. However, RRF is essential for correct ribosomal recognition of the AUG codon as the initiation site for the lysis gene.

Interaction between a mutant release factor one and P-site peptidyl-tRNA is influenced by the identity of the two bases downstream of the stop codon UAG

Termination efficiency of a mutant form of RF (release facor) 1, as compared to the wild-type enzyme, is influenced by the P-site peptidyl-tRNA if the termination signal is UAGA. This effect is weaker at the stronger termination signal UAGU. Similarly, low efficiency of the mutant RF1, together with certain peptidyl-tRNAs, can be increased by changing the second base of the 3'-flanking codon from C to G. The data suggest that the mutant RF1 interacts with the P-site peptidyl-tRNA in conjunction with the context at the 3'-side of the termination codon.

A direct estimation of the context effect on the efficiency of termination

An in vitro assay in which terminating Escherichia coli ribosomes with different stop signals in the A-site compete for a limited amount of a release factor (RF1 or RF2) has been used to estimate the relative termination efficiencies at stop codons with different adjacent downstream nucleotides. The assay allows direct measurements of relative kcat/Km parameters for the productive association of release factors to ribosomes. The kcat/Km parameter is larger for UAA(U) than for UAA(C) programmed ribosomes and the difference in kcat/Km is much larger for RF2 (about 80%) than for RF1 (about 30%). These differences in the kcat/Km parameter are not affected by the addition of release factor RF3. The only discernible effect of RF3 is a considerable acceleration of RF1/2 recycling.The estimated kcat/Km parameters correlate well with the affinities of release factors for ribosomes programmed with different stop signals. These affinities were estimated from the extent of inhibition of ribosomal recycling by high concentrations of release factors in the absence of release factor RF3. The affinity for RF2 depends on the immediate downstream context of the stop codon in the translated mRNA and is about three times higher for UAA(U) than for UAA(C). The corresponding difference in affinities for RF1 is twofold. For all stop signals studied, the estimated affinity of RF2 for terminating ribosomes is much lower than that of RF1. It is also striking that the affinity of ribosomes for a chromosomally expressed RF2 is at least three times higher than for RF2 isolated from an overproducing E. coli strain.

Function of polypeptide chain release factor RF-3 in Escherichia coli. RF-3 action in termination is predominantly at UGA-containing stop signals

Two protein release factors (RFs) showing codon specificity, RF-1 (UAG, UAA) and RF-2 (UAA, UGA), are required for polypeptide chain termination in Escherichia coli. We recently reported the localization and characterization of the gene encoding RF-3 (prfC), a third protein component previously described as stimulating termination without codon specificity. RF-3 is a GTP-binding protein that displays much sequence similarity to elongation factor EF-G. In a termination assay in vitro, RF-3 lowers the Km for terminator trinucleotides and is thought to act in termination signal recognition. The gene prfC was identified by transposon insertion mutagenesis leading to enhanced nonsense suppression of UGA. We report here that (i) RF-3 inactivation significantly enhances the suppression of termination in vivo only at UGA-dependent stop signals; (ii) the codon-dependent contribution to the stimulation of fMet release in vitro by RF-3 is significantly greater with UGA termination triplet than UAG termination triplet; (iii) RF-3 increases dramatically the affinity of RF-2 to the UGA termination complex in vitro but not that of RF-1 to the UAG termination complex; (iv) RF-3 inactivation leads to a positive feedback on the autoregulation of RF-2 synthesis in vivo, dependent on the competition between frameshifting and termination. These findings are discussed in terms of the mechanism of involvement of RF-3 in translation termination.

Codon context and protein synthesis: enhancements of the genetic code

The sequence around stop codons strongly affects termination efficiency and the probability of alternative events to termination such as frameshifting and stop codon readthrough. Where tRNA suppressors of nonsense codons are present, both the efficiency of suppression and of the termination process appear to be affected by stop codon context. Since context can affect suppressor tRNA function directly, an influence on sense codon translation or suppression might be expected, but has not yet been clearly demonstrated. Statistical analyses of coding sequences indicate non-random contexts for both stop and sense codons, and non-random occurrence of codon pairs. Highly expressed genes show clear preferences among stop codons and their contexts, whereas inefficient stop signals are exploited in a variety of recoding processes.

Enhanced readthrough of opal (UGA) stop codons and production of Mycoplasma pneumoniae P1 epitopes in Escherichia coli

Expression of mycoplasma sequences in Escherichia coli is often hindered by an unusual mycoplasmal codon usage pattern: the UGA stop codon is utilized for tryptophan. This may result in the truncation of cloned proteins and may prevent the detection of products of many cloned genes. To circumvent this translation barrier, we have developed an expression system for the production of mycoplasma proteins in E. coli. The efficiency of an opal suppressor tRNA (trpT176) was augmented with other suppressor mutations (prfB3 or rrsB(SuUGA-delta C1054)) which influence termination events. System efficacy was analyzed by employing suppressor mutations in the expression of TGA-containing sequences from the P1 protein-encoding gene of Mycoplasma pneumoniae.

Termination of translation in bacteria may be modulated via specific interaction between peptide chain release factor 2 and the last peptidyl-tRNA(Ser/Phe)

The 5' context of 671 Escherichia coli stop codons UGA and UAA has been compared with the context of stop-like codons (UAC, UAU and CAA for UAA; UGG, UGC, UGU and CGA for UGA). We have observed highly significant deviations from the expected nucleotide distribution: adenine is over-represented whereas pyrimidines are under-represented in position -2 upstream from UAA. Uridine is over-represented in position -3 upstream from UGA. Lysine codons are preferable immediately prior to UAA. A complete set of codons for serine and the phenylalanine UUC codon are preferable immediately 5' to UGA. This non-random codon distribution before stop codons could be considered as a molecular device for modulation of translation termination. We have found that certain fragment of E. coli release factor 2 (RF2) (amino acids 93-114) is similar to the amino acid sequences of seryl-tRNA synthetase (positions 10-19 and 80-93) and of beta (small) subunit (positions 72-94) of phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from E. coli. Three-dimensional structure of E. coli seryl-tRNA synthetase is known [1]: Its N-terminus represents an antiparallel alpha-helical coiled-coil domain and contains a region homologous to RF2. On the basis of the above-mentioned results we assume that a specific interaction between RF2 and the last peptidyl-tRNA(Ser/Phe) occurs during polypeptide chain termination in prokaryotic ribosomes.

Influence of codon context on UGA suppression and readthrough

We studied the influence of the codon context on UGA suppression by a suppressor tRNA and on UGA readthrough by a normal tRNA in Escherichia coli. This was done by a series of constructs where only the immediate context of the TGA codon was varied by only one nucleotide at a time. For both UGA suppression and UGA readthrough the codon context had a similar influence according to the following rules. (1) The nature of the nucleotide immediately adjacent to the 3' side of the UGA is an important determinant; at that position the level of UGA translation is influenced by the nucleotides in the order A greater than G greater than C greater than U. (2) At extremely high or low levels of UGA translation this influence of the adjacent 3' nucleotide is not seen. (3) In all cases, the nature of both the nucleotide immediately adjacent to the 5' side of the codon and that following the base adjacent to the 3' side of the codon have little effect, if any, on UGA translation. The varying influence of the codon context effect on UGA translation is discussed in relation to its role in gene expression.

tRNA anticodons with the modified nucleoside 2-methylthio-N6-(4-hydroxyisopentenyl)adenosine distinguish between bases 3' of the codon

The modified nucleoside 2-methylthio-N6-(4-hydroxyisopentenyl)adenosine (ms2io6A) is present immediately to the 3' side of the anticodon (position 37) in tRNAs that read codons starting with uridine and hence include amber (UAG) suppressor tRNAs. We have used strains of Salmonella typhimurium that differ only in their ability to synthesize ms2io6A in order to determine specifically how this modified nucleoside influences the efficiency of amber suppression in two codon contexts differing by only which base is 3' of the codon. The results show that the presence of the modified nucleoside ms2io6A not only improves the efficiency of the suppressor tRNAs but also allows them to distinguish between at least two bases 3' of the codon. Thus, the presence of ms2io6A reduces the intrinsic codon context sensitivity of the tRNA and specifically counteracts an unfavourable nucleotide on the 3' side of the codon. The possible codon-anticodon interactions responsible for this effect are discussed.

The signal for a leaky UAG stop codon in several plant viruses includes the two downstream codons

Expression of the RNA replicase domain of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) and certain protein-coding regions in other plant viruses, is mediated by translational readthrough of a leaky UAG stop codon. It has been proposed that normal tobacco tyrosine tRNAs are able to read the UAG codon of TMV by non-conventional base-pairing but recent findings that stop codons can also be bypassed as a result of extended translocational shifts (tRNA hopping) have encouraged a re-examination. In light of the alternatives, we investigated the sequences flanking the leaky UAG codon using an in vivo assay in which bypass of the stop codon is coupled to the transient expression of beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter genes in tobacco protoplasts. Analysis of GUS constructions in which codons flanking the stop were altered allowed definition of the minimal sequence required for read through as UAG-CAA-UUA. The effects of all possible single-base mutations in the codons flanking the stop indicated that 3' contexts of the form CAR-YYA confer leakiness and that the 3' context permits read through of UAA and UGA stop codons as well as UAG. Our studies demonstrate a major role for the 3' context in the read through process and do not support a model in which teh UAG is bypassed exclusively as a result of anticodon-codon interactions. No evidence for tRNA hopping was obtained. The 3' context apparently represents a unique sequence element that affects translation termination.

Codon context

The analysis of coding sequences reveals nonrandomness in the context of both sense and stop codons. Part of this is related to nucleotide doublet preference, seen also in non-coding sequences and thought to arise from the dependence of mutational events on surrounding sequence. Another nonrandom context element, relating the wobble nucleotides of successive codons, is observed even when doublet preference, codon usage and bias in amino acid doublets are all allowed for. Several phenomena related to protein synthesis have been shown in vivo to be affected by the nucleotide sequence around codons. Thus, nonsense and missense suppression, elongation rate, precision of tRNA selection and polypeptide chain termination are all affected by codon context. At present, it remains unclear how these phenomena may influence the evolution of nonrandomness in the context of codons in natural sequences.

Third position base changes in codons 5' and 3' adjacent UGA codons affect UGA suppression in vivo

The base sequence around nonsense codons affects the efficiency of nonsense codon suppression. Published data, comparing different nonsense sites in a mRNA, implicate the two bases downstream of the nonsense codon as major determinants of suppression efficiency. However, the results we report here indicate that the nature of the contiguous upstream codon can also affect nonsense suppression, as can the third (wobble) base of the contiguous downstream codon. These conclusions are drawn from experiments in which the two Ser codons UCU233 and UCG235 in a nonsense mutant form (UGA234) of the trpA gene in Escherichia coli have been replaced with other Ser codons by site-directed mutagenesis. Suppression of these trpA mutants has been studied in the presence of a UGA nonsense suppressor derived from glyT. We speculate that the non-site-specific effects of the two adjacent downstream bases may be largely at the level of the termination process, whereas more site-specific or codon-specific effects may operate primarily on the activity of the suppressor tRNA.

The signal for the termination of protein synthesis in procaryotes

The sequences around the stop codons of 862 Escherichia coli genes have been analysed to identify any additional features which contribute to the signal for the termination of protein synthesis. Highly significant deviations from the expected nucleotide distribution were observed, both before and after the stop codon. Immediately prior to UAA stop codons in E. coli there is a preference for codons of the form NAR (any base, adenine, purine), and in particular those that code for glutamine or the basic amino acids. In contrast, codons for threonine or branched nonpolar amino acids were under-represented. Uridine was over-represented in the nucleotide position immediately following all three stop codons, whereas adenine and cytosine were under-represented. This pattern is accentuated in highly expressed genes, but is not as marked in either lowly expressed genes or those that terminate in UAG, the codon specifically recognised by polypeptide chain release factor-1. These observations suggest that for the efficient termination of protein synthesis in E. coli, the 'stop signal' may be a tetranucleotide, rather than simply a tri-nucleotide codon, and that polypeptide chain release factor-2 recognises this extended signal. The sequence following stop codons was analysed in genes from several other procaryotes and bacteriophages. Salmonella typhimurium, Bacillus subtilis, bacteriophages and the methanogenic archaebacteria showed a similar bias to E. coli.

Context specific misreading of phenylalanine codons

It has previously been shown that the phenylalanine codon UUC encoding residue 8 of the Escherichia coli argI gene product, ornithine transcarbamylase, is misread as leucine at a high frequency during phenylalanine starvation. However, no misreading of the UUU encoding residue 3 was observed under these conditions. Using oligonucleotide-directed, site-specific mutagenesis, we have constructed mutants where these codons have been changed. Using these mutant argI genes we see a high level of mistranslation at position 8 during phenylalanine starvation whether the codon is UUU or UUC. With either codon at position 3 we see no leucine substitution. We also constructed a gene with a leucine codon at position 3. The product of this latter mutated gene is stable and active, indicating that preferential turnover of mistranslated protein is not obscuring an otherwise high rate of misreading. This would seem to indicate that it is the context rather than the particular phenylalanine codon which is important in determining these misreading levels.

Aminoglycoside suppression at UAG, UAA and UGA codons in Escherichia coli and human tissue culture cells

We have compared the suppression of nonsense mutations by aminoglycoside antibiotics in Escherichia coli and in human 293 cells. Six nonsense alleles of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (cat) gene, in the vector pRSVcat, were suppressed by growth in G418 and paromomycin. Readthrough at UAG, UAA and UGA codons was monitored with enzyme assays for chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT), in stably transformed bacteria and during transient expression from the same plasmid in human 293 tissue culture cells. We have found significant differences in the degree of suppression amongst three UAG codons and two UAA codons in different mRNA contexts. However, the pattern of these effects are not the same in the two organisms. Our data suggest that context effects of nonsense suppression may operate under different rules in E. coli and human cells.