Adenovirus type 12 E1B 19-kilodalton protein is not required for oncogenic transformation in rats

Almost famous: Human adenoviruses (and what they have taught us about cancer)

Papillomaviruses, polyomaviruses and adenoviruses are collectively categorized as the small DNA tumour viruses. Notably, human adenoviruses were the first human viruses demonstrated to be able to cause cancer, albeit in non-human animal models. Despite their long history, no human adenovirus is a known causative agent of human cancers, unlike a subset of their more famous cousins, including human papillomaviruses and human Merkel cell polyomavirus. Nevertheless, seminal research using human adenoviruses has been highly informative in understanding the basics of cell cycle control, gene expression, apoptosis and cell differentiation. This review highlights the contributions of human adenovirus research in advancing our knowledge of the molecular basis of cancer.

Cell transformation by the adenovirus oncogenes E1 and E4

Extensive studies on viral-mediated oncogenic transformation by human adenoviruses have revealed much of our current understanding on the molecular mechanisms that are involved in the process. To date, these studies have shown that cell transformation is a multistep process regulated by the cooperation of several adenoviral gene products encoded in the early regions 1 (E1) and 4 (E4). Early region 1A immortalizes primary rodent cells, whereas co-expression of early region protein 1B induces full manifestation of the transformed phenotype. Beside E1 proteins, also some E4 proteins have partial transforming activities through regulating many cellular pathways. Here, we summarize recent data of how adenoviral oncoproteins may contribute to viral transformation and discuss the challenge of pinpointing the underlying mechanisms.

E1A-Based Determinants of Oncogenicity in Human Adenovirus Groups A and C

A broad spectrum of genetic and molecular investigations carried out with group C, Ad2 and Ad5, and with group A, Ad12, have shown that early region1 (E1) gene products are sufficient for complete transformation of rodent cells in vitro by these viruses. During the past quarter century, the processes by which E1A proteins, in cooperation with E1B proteins, perturb the cell cycle and induce the transformed phenotype, have become well defined. Somewhat less understood is the basis for the differential oncogenicity of these two groups of viruses, and the processes by which the E1A proteins of Ad12 induce a tumorigenic phenotype in transformants resulting from infection of cells in vivo and in vitro. In this chapter we review previous findings and present new evidence which demonstrates that Ad12 E1A possesses two or more independent functions enabling it to induce tumors. One of these functions lies in its capacity to repress transcription of MHC class I genes, allowing the tumor cells to avoid lysis by cytotoxic T lymphocytes. We have shown that class I repression is mediated through increased binding of repressor COUP-TF and decreased binding of NF-kB to the class I enhancer. In addition to mediating immune escape, E1A also determines the susceptibility of transformants to Natural Killer (NK) cell lysis, and in this case, also, Ad12 transformants are not susceptible. By using Ad12 mutants containing chimeric E1A Ad12-Ad5 genes, point mutations, or a specific deletion, we have shown that the unique spacer region of Ad12 E1A is an oncogenic determinant, but is not required for transformation in vitro. Given that the E1A regions responsible for class I repression are first exon encoded, we have examined a set of cell lines transformed by these altered viruses, and have found that while they display greatly reduced tumorigenicity, they maintain a wildtype capacity to repress class I transcription. Whether the spacer contributes to NK evasion remains unresolved. Lastly, we discuss the properties of the Ad2/Ad5 E1A C-terminal negative modulator of tumorigenicity, and examine the effects on transformation, tumor induction and transformant tumorigenicity, when the Ad5 negative modulator is placed by chimeric construction in Ad12 E1A.

Cell transformation by human adenoviruses

The last 40 years of molecular biological investigations into human adenoviruses have contributed enormously to our understanding of the basic principles of normal and malignant cell growth. Much of this knowledge stems from analyses of their productive infection cycle in permissive host cells. Also, initial observations concerning the carcinogenic potential of human adenoviruses subsequently revealed decisive insights into the molecular mechanisms of the origins of cancer, and established adenoviruses as a model system for explaining virus-mediated transformation processes. Today it is well established that cell transformation by human adenoviruses is a multistep process involving several gene products encoded in early transcription units 1A (E1A) and 1B (E1B). Moreover, a large body of evidence now indicates that alternative or additional mechanisms are engaged in adenovirus-mediated oncogenic transformation involving gene products encoded in early region 4 (E4) as well as epigenetic changes resulting from viral DNA integration. In particular, detailed studies on the tumorigenic potential of subgroup D adenovirus type 9 (Ad9) E4 have now revealed a new pathway that points to a novel, general mechanism of virus-mediated oncogenesis. In this chapter, we summarize the current state of knowledge about the oncogenes and oncogene products of human adenoviruses, focusing particularly on recent findings concerning the transforming and oncogenic properties of viral proteins encoded in the E1B and E4 transcription units.

Caspase-mediated cleavage of adenovirus early region 1A proteins

Adenovirus 2 and 12 early region 1A (Ad2 and Ad12 E1A) proteins were cleaved during cisplatin-induced apoptosis of Ad-transformed rat and human cells. Cleavage was inhibited in the presence of caspase inhibitors such as Z-VAD-FMK. In Ad12 transformants both 13S and 12S E1A proteins were cleaved at a similar rate. In Ad2 transformants the E1A 13S component was appreciably less stable than the 12S component. In in vitro studies Ad2 and Ad12 E1A 13S and Ad2 12S proteins were rapidly cleaved by caspase 3 whereas Ad12 12S E1A and Ad12 13S E1A were rapidly degraded by caspase 7. Cleavage sites in Ad12 13S proteins for caspase 3 have been determined. Initial cleavage occurred at D24 and D150; this was followed by cleavage at D204 and D242. Caspase-3-mediated cleavage of Ad12 13S E1A destroyed its ability to bind to CBP and TBP but interaction between C terminal E1A polypeptides and CtBP was observed. During viral infection Ad5 and Ad12 E1A 12S proteins were markedly more stable than 13S proteins but no difference was observed in Ad E1A levels in the absence or presence of the caspase inhibitors Z-VAD-FMK or Z-D(OMe)-E(OMe)-V-D(OMe)-CH(2)F. Limited caspase 3 and 10 activation occurred during infection with the E1B 19K(-) virus Ad2 pm1722 but little or no activation of caspase 3 was observed during wt virus infection. Examination of protein cleavage during viral infection of A549 cells showed proteolysis of lamin B and PARP in response to Ad5 wt and Ad2 pm1722. Protein degradation in response to both viruses was partially inhibited by Z-VAD-FMK. Following infection of human skin fibroblasts lamin B was degraded, although only limited changes in PARP levels were observed. We have concluded that Ad E1A is cleaved by caspases during apoptosis but not during viral infection. However, some of the processes commonly associated with apoptosis occur during viral infection, particularly with E1B 19K(-) mutants, although apoptosis per se is not evident.

The replicative capacities of large E1B-null group A and group C adenoviruses are independent of host cell p53 status

Recent reports suggest that an early region 1B (E1B) 55, 000-molecular-weight polypeptide (55K)-null adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) mutant (dl1520) can replicate to the same extent as wild-type (wt) Ad5 in cells either deficient or mutated in p53, implicating p53 in limiting viral replication in vivo. In contrast, we show here that the replicative capacity of Ad5 dl1520 is wholly independent of host cell p53 status, as is the replicative capacity of comparable Ad12 E1B 54K-null adenoviruses (Ad12 dl620 and Ad12 hr703). Furthermore, we show that there is no requirement for complex formation between p53 and Ad5 E1B 55K or Ad12 E1B 54K for a productive infection, such that wt Ad5 and wt Ad12 will both replicate in cells which are null for p53. In addition, we find that these Ad5 and Ad12 mutant viruses induce S phase irrespective of the p53 status of the cell and that, therefore, S-phase induction does not correlate with the replicative capacity of the virus. Interestingly, the replicative capacities of the large E1B-null adenoviruses correlated positively with the ability to express E1B 19K and were related to the ability to repress premature adenovirus-induced apoptosis. Infection of primary human cells indicated that Ad5 dl1520, wt Ad5, and wt Ad12 replicated better in cycling normal human skin fibroblasts (HSFs) than in quiescent HSFs. Thus, the cell cycle status of the host cell, upon infection, also influences viral yield.

Efficient nuclear localization and immortalizing ability, two functions dependent on the adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) E1A second exon, are necessary for cotransformation with Ad5 E1B but not with T24ras

Expression of adenovirus type 5 E1A 12S is sufficient to immortalize primary baby rat kidney cells, but another viral or cellular oncogene, such as E1B or T24ras, is necessary for complete transformation. The regions of 12S sufficient for T24ras cotransformation have been well characterized and are located in the first exon. The second exon is dispensable for ras cotransformation, although it contains a region which appears to modulate the transforming phenotype. The same 12S first exon regions important in ras transformation are also necessary for E1B transformation. Analysis of an extensive series of second exon deletion and amino acid point mutations demonstrated that mutations affecting either the efficient nuclear localization and/or the immortalizing ability of the 12S protein also prevented cooperation with E1B. In general, the entire C-terminal half of 12S, including the nuclear localization signal, was necessary for efficient cotransformation with E1B. In addition to the differences between T24ras and E1B regarding 12S regions necessary for cotransformation, the characteristics of E1B-cotransformed foci differed from those of T24ras. The E1B foci took longer to appear and had a much slower growth rate. No hypertransformed foci were produced with E1B cotransfections, and established E1A-E1B lines exhibited minimal growth in soft agar compared with that of E1A-T24ras lines.

Constructing chimeric type 12/type 5 adenovirus E1A genes and using them to identify an oncogenic determinant of adenovirus type 12

The E1A gene of highly oncogenic type 12 adenovirus (Ad12) possesses a segment unique to this serotype and comprising 60 base pairs contiguous with and separating conserved regions 2 and 3 in the gene. A similar but slightly longer segment is also present in the E1A gene of highly oncogenic simian adenovirus type 7 (D. Kimelman, J. S. Miller, D. Porter, and B. E. Roberts, J. Virol. 53:399-409, 1985). This segment is missing entirely from the E1A gene of type 5 adenovirus, which is nononcogenic. To test the hypothesis that this unique separating or "spacer" region influences the oncogenicity of Ad12, we constructed ClaI and SmaI restriction sites on either side of it, which allowed reciprocal exchange between this and the equivalent cassette from type 5 adenovirus E1A, bounded by the same restriction sites intrinsic to that gene. The resultant Ad12-based chimeric viruses, ch702 and ch704, in which the spacer region is replaced with (in-frame) type 5 sequence, grow normally on human A549 cells and display wild-type transformation frequencies on baby rat and mouse kidney cells. In contrast, the oncogenic capacity of these chimeric viruses, as measured by tumor induction following virus inoculation in Hooded Lister rats, is greatly reduced. Likewise, cells transformed by ch702 and ch704 display reduced tumorigenicity compared with wild-type transformants in syngeneic rats. These results, coupled with recent preliminary tests using a mutant with a point mutation in this region, support the view that the unique spacer region of type 12 is an oncogenic determinant of this virus.

Absence of an essential regulatory influence of the adenovirus E1B 19-kilodalton protein on viral growth and early gene expression in human diploid WI38, HeLa, and A549 cells

Mutations in the gene encoding the adenovirus (Ad) early region 1B 19-kDa protein (the 19K gene) result in multiple phenotypic effects upon infection of permissive human cells. It has been reported, for example, that Ad type 2 (Ad2) and Ad5 with mutations in the 19K gene (19K-defective mutants) have a marked growth advantage compared with wild-type virus in human diploid WI38 cells (E. White, B. Faha, and B. Stillman, Mol. Cell. Biol. 6:3763-3773, 1986), and it was proposed that this host range phenotype stems from the large increase in viral early gene expression reported to occur in the mutant-infected cells. These observations gave rise to the hypothesis that the 19-kDa protein (the 19K protein) normally functions as a negative regulator of Ad early gene expression and growth. We have tested this hypothesis and find that Ad5 and Ad12 wild-type viruses grow as efficiently as their respective 19K-defective mutants, in1 and dl337 and pm700 and in700, in WI38 and other human cell types. Neither the accumulation of E1A cytoplasmic mRNAs nor the synthesis of E1A and other viral early proteins in these cells is altered as a result of these mutations in the 19K gene, and we conclude that the 19K protein does not play an essential role in regulating viral early gene expression or viral growth in human cells.

The E1B 19-kilodalton protein is not essential for transformation of rodent cells in vitro by adenovirus type 5

The newly constructed adenovirus type 5 mutant in1 carries a single AT base pair insertion immediately after nucleotide position 1715 in the E1B gene sequence which destroys the proximal AUG normally present in E1B messages and prevents production of intact E1B 19-kDa protein in infected cells. We have used in1, variants of in1 containing mutant alleles of viral genes known to enhance transformation frequency, and adenovirus type 5 mutant dl337 (S. Pilder, J. Logan, and T. Shenk, J. Virol. 52:664-671, 1984), in which the sequence between nucleotides 1770 and 1916 within the 19-kDa reading frame is deleted, to test the generally accepted hypothesis that this E1B protein is essential for the transformation of rodent cells and maintenance of the transformed phenotype. We find that these mutants transform rat embryo cells, rat kidney and mouse kidney primary cells, and cells of the 3Y1 rat line with decreased frequencies only when virus is added to these various cells at high input multiplicities of infection. In contrast, when lower doses of virus are used, the mutants transform with wild-type frequencies. Cells infected with higher doses of mutant virus show increased levels of DNA degradation and cell killing compared with those of cells infected with the same levels of wild-type virus, and these effects most likely contribute to the decreased transformation frequencies observed. On the basis of these results and the results of phenotypic analyses of numerous transformants, we propose that the E1B 19-kDa protein is not required for induction and/or maintenance of transformed-cell characteristics in rodent cells infected with adenovirus type 5.

Adenovirus type 12 early region 1B proteins and metabolism of early viral mRNAs

Early region 1B (E1B) of human adenoviruses encodes two major proteins. The 19-kDa polypeptide appears to prevent E1A-induced cytolysis and DNA degradation. The larger E1B product of approximately 55 kDa, which is essential for viral replication, plays a role in the accumulation and stability of viral mRNAs and the late shutoff of host metabolism. For serotype 12 (Ad12), this 482-residue (482R) protein is essential for viral DNA replication. In the present report we have used a series of mutants to examine the roles of Ad12 482R and the 19-kDa, 163R protein in the metabolism of early viral mRNAs. No specific effects on the accumulation of early (or late) mRNAs were detected with any of the mutants affecting 163R. With mutant dl42, which encodes an altered 482R product that lacks residues 114-155, both viral DNA replication and late viral protein synthesis were defective. Accumulation of E1A transcripts in the nucleus and cytoplasm resembled wt. The levels of mRNAs from early regions E1B, E2A and E3 at later times during infection were somewhat lower than those of wt, but this decrease may have been due to the absence of progeny viral DNA in dl42-infected cells. However, the accumulation of both E2B and E4 mRNAs at all times was severely reduced. These data suggested that the requirement of 482R for Ad12 DNA replication may be related to its specific role in the metabolism of E2B and E4 mRNAs that encode products necessary for viral DNA synthesis.

Overexpression of the E1B 55-kilodalton (482R) protein of human adenovirus type 12 appears to permit efficient transformation of primary baby rat kidney cells in the absence of the E1B 19-kilodalton protein

To analyze the structure and function of the E1B 19,000-molecular-weight protein (19K protein) (163R) of human adenovirus type 12, mutants were produced at various positions across the 163R-coding sequence. Viruses bearing mutations within the first 100 or so amino acids yielded unstable 163R-related products, induced DNA degradation and enhanced cytopathic effect (cyt/deg phenotype) in KB cells, and transformed primary rodent cells at much lower efficiencies than wild-type (wt) virus. Deletion of the final 16 residues at the carboxy terminus had no phenotypic effect. Alteration of residue 105 reduced transforming efficiency significantly, suggesting that this region of 163R is functionally important. Disruption of the AUG initiation codon at nucleotide 1542 blocked production of 163R completely but resulted in higher levels of E1B 55K-482R protein synthesis and a transforming efficiency similar to that of wt virus. These data suggested that while 163R is of some importance, normal transforming efficiencies can be obtained in its absence if 482R is overexpressed.

Fastidious human adenovirus type 40 can propagate efficiently and produce plaques on a human cell line, A549, derived from lung carcinoma

Human adenovirus type 40 (Ad40) cannot propagate in conventional established human cell lines such as KB or HeLa cells. However, it has been shown that Ad40 DNA replicates in KB18 cells which express Ad2 E1B genes, suggesting that Ad40 is defective in the E1B gene function in KB or HeLa cells. We show here that Ad40 can propagate and produce plaques on A549 cells which do not contain Ad E1B genes. Our experiments show that the levels of replication of Ad40 DNA and production of infectious Ad40 virus in A549 cells are the same as or higher than those in 293 or KB18 cells. Dot blot analysis shows that the levels of Ad40 E1A and E1B mRNAs expressed in A549 cells at early to intermediate times postinfection are at least 10-fold higher than those in KB or KB18 cells. Northern (RNA) blot analysis shows that large E1B mRNA species (approximately 24S to 26S) are synthesized prior to the onset of DNA replication in A549 cells. No E1B mRNA species are synthesized in KB or KB18 cells at early times postinfection, and no differences in the expression of E1B mRNAs are seen between KB and KB18 cells. The experiment suggests that A549 cells have a cellular factor(s) which activates Ad40 E1B mRNA synthesis and that the E1B mRNA synthesis helps Ad40 propagation. In contrast, Ad40 can propagate in KB18 cells by using Ad2 E1B gene products that are constitutively expressed in this cell line. Furthermore, this result shows that Ad40 cannot propagate in KB cells because of the failure in the expression of E1B genes at early times postinfection.

Expression and interactions of human adenovirus oncoproteins

Images

Differential requirement for adenovirus type 12 E1A gene products in oncogenic transformation

During the early period of infection, adenovirus type 12 E1A gene is expressed as overlapping, spliced mRNAs of 12 and 13S, which encode in-frame proteins of 235 and 266 amino acid residues (235R and 266R), respectively. To define the functions of these related products in the infection of human cells and transformation of rodent cells, we created single T-to-C transitions at the second base of each mRNA intron which specifically prevent splicing of the respective mRNAs. Mutant pm712 expresses only the 13S mRNA and 266R protein, while pm713 expresses only the 12S mRNA and 235R protein. By using these mutants, we showed that only the larger product is required for growth in human cells, including growth-arrested W138 cells, that the capacity to activate other viral genes (in human cells, at least) lies primarily with that protein, and that the 266R product is not required for autoregulation of its own transcription. In the presence of the 266R protein the 235R product was not required for complete and efficient transformation of a variety of rodent cells or for direct induction of tumors in rats, whereas in its absence the smaller product was insufficient for transformation or tumor induction. Finally, we showed that transformants resulting from infection of rodent cells with pm712 possess a fully-transformed phenotype and are tumorigenic. Previous studies with group C adenoviruses led to the conclusion that both E1A products are required for complete transformation; we conclude that with oncogenic serotype 12, only the 266R product is required for this process.

Separate regions of an adenovirus E1B protein critical for different biological functions

The E1B region of Ad12 encodes two major proteins, the 482R (55K) and 163R (19K). In this report we showed that the E1B 482R is multifunctional, in that its structure may somehow contribute to its own stability, in viral DNA and virus replication, in transformation of primary cells, and in tumorigenicity. Deletion of the first 24 amino acids and of aa residues 114-155 (dl42) results in an instability of the 55K protein. The N-terminal 24 aa residues (pm1852) or amino acids residues 80-96 (dl17) are not required for viral DNA or virus replication, whereas amino acid residues between 114 and 155 (dl42) are absolutely necessary for viral DNA synthesis. Deletion of amino acid residues 1-24, 80-96, and 114-155 (dl42) greatly reduces the transforming ability of both virus and plasmids containing any one of these deletions. One of the critical regions for tumorigenicity residues within amino acid residues 80-96, since cells transformed by this plasmid are nontumorigenic. On the other hand the region bounded by amino acid residues 114-155 (dl42) is not required for tumorigenicity in immunocompetent animals.

Complementation of enteric adenovirus type 40 for lytic growth in tissue culture by E1B 55K function of adenovirus types 5 and 12

The enteric adenovirus type 40 strain Dugan (Ad40) cannot be passaged in HeLa cells, but will grow in 293 cells, which express Ad5 E1 functions. To determine the reason for this limited host range, KB cell lines expressing Ad2 E1A, E1B, or E1A + E1B (L. E. Babiss, C. S. H. Young, P. B. Fisher, and H. S. Ginsberg, 1983, J. Virol. 46, 454-465) have been tested for their ability to support Ad40 replication. Only cell lines which supply E1B functions, but not those expressing E1A alone, are permissive for Ad40, suggesting that Ad40 may require some function supplied by E1B or induced in E1B-containing cells. In coinfection assays Ad40 complements Ad5 dl312 (delta E1A) but not Ad5 dl313 (delta E1B) and is itself complemented by dl312 but not by dl313. Mutants of Ad2 and Ad12 with lesions in E1B 55K or 19K protein have been used to further delineate the requirements for Ad40 growth in HeLa cells. For mutants lacking 55K function there is minimal complementation in either direction, whereas those lacking only the 19K product are able to complement Ad40.