The V(D)J recombinational and transcriptional activities of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain intronic enhancer can be mediated through distinct protein-binding sites in a transgenic substrate

Recombination may occur in the absence of transcription in the immunoglobulin heavy chain recombination centre

Developing B cells undergo V(D)J recombination to generate a vast repertoire of Ig molecules. V(D)J recombination is initiated by the RAG1/RAG2 complex in recombination centres (RCs), where gene segments become accessible to the complex. Whether transcription is the causal factor of accessibility or whether it is a side product of other processes that generate accessibility remains a controversial issue. At the IgH locus, V(D)J recombination is controlled by Eμ enhancer, which directs the transcriptional, epigenetic and recombinational events in the IgH RC. Deletion of Eμ enhancer affects both transcription and recombination, making it difficult to conclude if Eμ controls the two processes through the same or different mechanisms. By using a mouse line carrying a CpG-rich sequence upstream of Eμ enhancer and analyzing transcription and recombination at the single-cell level, we found that recombination could occur in the RC in the absence of detectable transcription, suggesting that Eμ controls transcription and recombination through distinct mechanisms. Moreover, while the normally Eμ-dependent transcription and demethylating activities were impaired, recruitment of chromatin remodeling complexes was unaffected. RAG1 was efficiently recruited, thus compensating for the defective transcription-associated recruitment of RAG2, and providing a mechanistic basis for RAG1/RAG2 assembly to initiate V(D)J recombination.

Developmental Switch in the Transcriptional Activity of a Long-Range Regulatory Element

Eukaryotic gene expression is often controlled by distant regulatory elements. In developing B lymphocytes, transcription is associated with V(D)J recombination at immunoglobulin loci. This process is regulated by remote cis-acting elements. At the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) locus, the 3' regulatory region (3'RR) promotes transcription in mature B cells. This led to the notion that the 3'RR orchestrates the IgH locus activity at late stages of B cell maturation only. However, long-range interactions involving the 3'RR were detected in early B cells, but the functional consequences of these interactions were unknown. Here we show that not only does the 3'RR affect transcription at distant sites within the IgH variable region but also it conveys a transcriptional silencing activity on both sense and antisense transcription. The 3'RR-mediated silencing activity is switched off upon completion of VH-DJH recombination. Our findings reveal a developmentally controlled, stage-dependent shift in the transcriptional activity of a master regulatory element.

Recombination centres and the orchestration of V(D)J recombination

The initiation of V(D)J recombination by the recombination activating gene 1 (RAG1) and RAG2 proteins is carefully orchestrated to ensure that antigen receptor gene assembly occurs in the appropriate cell lineage and in the proper developmental order. Here we review recent advances in our understanding of how DNA binding and cleavage by the RAG proteins are regulated by the chromatin structure and architecture of antigen receptor genes. These advances suggest novel mechanisms for both the targeting and the mistargeting of V(D)J recombination, and have implications for how these events contribute to genome instability and lymphoid malignancy.

Allelic exclusion of immunoglobulin genes: models and mechanisms

The allelic exclusion of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes is one of the most evolutionarily conserved features of the adaptive immune system and underlies the monospecificity of B cells. While much has been learned about how Ig allelic exclusion is established during B-cell development, the relevance of monospecificity to B-cell function remains enigmatic. Here, we review the theoretical models that have been proposed to explain the establishment of Ig allelic exclusion and focus on the molecular mechanisms utilized by developing B cells to ensure the monoallelic expression of Ig kappa and Ig lambda light chain genes. We also discuss the physiological consequences of Ig allelic exclusion and speculate on the importance of monospecificity of B cells for immune recognition.

Germline transcription: a key regulator of accessibility and recombination

The developmental control of V(D)J recombination is imposed at the level of chromatin accessibility of recombination signal sequences (RSSs) to the recombinase machinery. Cis-acting transcriptional regulatory elements such as promoters and enhancers play a central role in the control of accessibility in vivo. However, the molecular mechanisms by which these elements influence accessibility are still under investigation. Although accessibility for V(D)J recombination is usually accompanied by germline transcription at antigen receptor loci, the functional significance of this transcription in directing RSS accessibility has been elusive. In this chapter, we review past studies outlining the complex relationship between V(D)J recombination and transcription as well as our current understanding on how chromatin structure is regulated during gene expression. We then summarize recent work that directly addresses the functional role of transcription in V(D)J recombination.

Activation of 12/23-RSS-dependent RAG cleavage by hSWI/SNF complex in the absence of transcription

Maintenance of genomic integrity during antigen receptor gene rearrangements requires (1) regulated access of the V(D)J recombinase to specific loci and (2) generation of double-strand DNA breaks only after recognition of a pair of matched recombination signal sequences (RSSs). Here we recapitulate both key aspects of regulated recombinase accessibility in a cell-free system using plasmid substrates assembled into chromatin. We show that recruitment of the SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling complex to both RSSs increases coupled cleavage by RAG1 and RAG2 proteins. SWI/SNF functions by altering local chromatin structure in the absence of RNA polymerase II-dependent transcription or histone modifications. These observations demonstrate a direct role for cis-sequence-regulated local chromatin remodeling in RAG1/2-dependent initiation of V(D)J recombination.

Yin Yang 1 is a critical regulator of B-cell development

The role of the transcription factor Yin Yang 1 (YY1) in development is largely unknown. Here we show that specific ablation of YY1 in mouse B cells caused a defect in somatic rearrangement in the immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) locus and a block in the progenitor-B-to-precursor-B-cell transition, which was partially rescued by a prerearranged IgH transgene. Three-dimensional DNA fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis revealed an important function for YY1 in IgH locus contraction, a process indispensable for distal V(H) to D(H)J(H) recombination. We provide evidence that YY1 binds the intronic Ei mu enhancer within the IgH locus, consistent with a direct role for YY1 in V(H)D(H)J(H) recombination. These findings identified YY1 as a critical regulator of early B-cell development.

Bright/ARID3A contributes to chromatin accessibility of the immunoglobulin heavy chain enhancer

Bright/ARID3A is a nuclear matrix-associated transcription factor that stimulates immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) expression and Cyclin E1/E2F-dependent cell cycle progression. Bright positively activates IgH transcriptional initiation by binding to ATC-rich P sites within nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) flanking the IgH intronic enhancer (Eμ). Over-expression of Bright in cultured B cells was shown to correlate with DNase hypersensitivity of Eμ. We report here further efforts to analyze Bright-mediated Eμ enhancer activation within the physiological constraints of chromatin. A system was established in which VH promoter-driven in vitro transcription on chromatin- reconstituted templates was responsive to Eμ. Bright assisted in blocking the general repression caused by nucleosome assembly but was incapable of stimulating transcription from prebound nucleosome arrays. In vitro transcriptional derepression by Bright was enhanced on templates in which Eμ is flanked by MARs and was inhibited by competition with high affinity Bright binding (P2) sites. DNase hypersensitivity of chromatin-reconstituted Eμ was increased when prepackaged with B cell nuclear extract supplemented with Bright. These results identify Bright as a contributor to accessibility of the IgH enhancer.

Regulation of T cell receptor-alpha gene recombination by transcription

Despite the longstanding correlation between transcription and variable-(diversity)-joining (V(D)J) recombination, it is unknown whether transcription itself can direct recombinase targeting. Here we show that blockade of transcriptional elongation through the mouse T cell receptor-alpha (Tcra) locus suppressed V(alpha)-to-J(alpha) recombination and chromatin remodeling of J(alpha) segments. Transcriptional blockade also derepressed cryptic J(alpha) promoters. Our results demonstrate two key functions for transcription in Tcra locus regulation. Transcription increases the recombination of J(alpha) segments located within several kilobases of a promoter and prevents the activation of downstream promoters through transcriptional interference. These influences promote an ordered progression of Tcra locus recombination events and selection of a robust Tcra repertoire.

Identification of a candidate regulatory element within the 5' flanking region of the mouse Igh locus defined by pro-B cell-specific hypersensitivity associated with binding of PU.1, Pax5, and E2A

The Igh locus is controlled by cis-acting elements, including Emu and the 3' IgH regulatory region which flank the C region genes within the well-studied 3' part of the locus. Although the presence of additional control elements has been postulated to regulate rearrangements of the VH gene array that extends to the 5' end of the locus, the 5' border of Igh and its flanking region have not been characterized. To facilitate the analysis of this unexplored region and to identify potential novel control elements, we physically mapped the most D-distal VH segments and scanned 46 kb of the immediate 5' flanking region for DNase I hypersensitive sites. Our studies revealed a cluster of hypersensitive sites 30 kb upstream of the most 5' VH gene. Detection of one site, HS1, is restricted to pro-B cell lines and HS1 is accessible to restriction enzyme digestion exclusively in normal pro-B cells, the stage defined by actively rearranging Igh-V loci. Sequence motifs within HS1 for PU.1, Pax5, and E2A bind these proteins in vitro and these factors are recruited to HS1 sequence only in pro-B cells. Transient transfection assays indicate that the Pax5 binding site is required for the repression of transcriptional activity of HS1-containing constructs. Thus, our characterization of the region 5' of the VH gene cluster demonstrated the presence of a single cluster of DNase I hypersensitive sites within the 5' flanking region, and identified a candidate Igh regulatory region defined by pro-B cell-specific hypersensitivity and interaction with factors implicated in regulating VDJ recombination.

Hypothesis: a biological role for germline transcription in the mechanism of V(D)J recombination--implications for initiation of allelic exclusion

The sequences that encode the antigen-binding sites of IgH and IgL chains - variable (V), diversity (D, H chain loci only) and joining (J) sequences - are configured as separate DNA segments at the germline level. Expression of an Ig molecule requires V(D)J assembly. Productive V(D)J recombination is monoallelic. How rearrangement is initiated differentially at maternal and paternal alleles is unclear. The products of recombination activating gene (RAG)1 and RAG2 mediate rearrangement by cleaving the DNA between an unrearranged gene segment and adjacent recombination signal sequences (RSS). It is proposed that supercoiling generated during germline transcription at Ig loci (which occurs concomitantly with rearrangement) is required at RSS for RAG1/2 recognition. Rearrangement might hence initiate sequentially at maternal and paternal alleles where deregulated germline transcription causes RAG1/2 recognition of RSS to become stochastic.

Accessibility control of V(D)J recombination

Mammals contend with a universe of evolving pathogens by generating an enormous diversity of antigen receptors during lymphocyte development. Precursor B and T cells assemble functional immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) genes via recombination of numerous variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) gene segments. Although this combinatorial process generates significant diversity, genetic reorganization is inherently dangerous. Thus, V(D)J recombination must be tightly regulated to ensure proper lymphocyte development and avoid chromosomal translocations that cause lymphoid tumors. Each genomic rearrangement is mediated by a common V(D)J recombinase that recognizes sequences flanking all antigen receptor gene segments. The specificity of V(D)J recombination is due, in large part, to changes in the accessibility of chromatin at target gene segments, which either permits or restricts access to recombinase. The chromatin configuration of antigen receptor loci is governed by the concerted action of enhancers and promoters, which function as accessibility control elements (ACEs). In general, ACEs act as conduits for transcription factors, which in turn recruit enzymes that covalently modify or remodel nucleosomes. These ACE-mediated alterations are critical for activation of gene segment transcription and for opening chromatin associated with recombinase target sequences. In this chapter, we describe advances in understanding the mechanisms that control V(D)J recombination at the level of chromatin accessibility. The discussion will focus on cis-acting regulation by ACEs, the nuclear factors that control ACE function, and the epigenetic modifications that establish recombinase accessibility.

Linking age-related defects in B lymphopoiesis to the aging of hematopoietic stem cells

B cell genesis declines with age, but at what stage and why remains unclear. Previous studies attribute the decline in B cell production in aged mice to both environmental and cell-intrinsic defects that impact mid-to-late stream B cell precursors. However, mounting evidence suggests that the aging process may also negatively affect the earliest phases of B cell development. We review past studies on the B cells and aging question, discuss recent data suggesting that age-associated defects in B cell development reflect deficiencies in hematopoietic stem cell-proximal progenitor pools, and provide an integrative model that will hopefully facilitate further studies into this complex problem.

Epigenetic control of B cell differentiation

Gene expression, differentiation and the specialized function of various cell types are controlled epigenetically by post-translational histone modifications. These modifications establish a "histone code" that is recognized by various regulatory proteins, thereby creating a stable pattern of gene expression. The focus of this review is to discuss how the chromatin modifications regulate immunoglobulin gene rearrangement and B cell differentiation.

Monoallelic gene expression: a repertoire of recurrent themes

The development of mature B and T cells in the lymphoid system involves a series of molecular decisions that culminate in the expression of a single antigen receptor on the cell surface, a phenomenon termed allelic exclusion. While feedback inhibition of the recombinase-activation gene proteins evidently plays an important role in the maintenance of allelic exclusion, the initial restriction of rearrangement to only one allele in each cell seems to be achieved through monoallelic epigenetic changes. Epigenetic mechanisms involved in the establishment of allelic exclusion also play a central role in other types of monoallelic expression, including X-chromosome inactivation in female cells, and parental imprinting. In all three systems, the inequality of the two alleles seems to be achieved mainly by differential DNA methylation, asynchronous DNA replication, differential chromatin modifications, unequal nuclear localization, and non-coding RNA. In this review, we discuss the unifying features among these monoallelically expressed systems and the unique characteristics displayed by each of them.

How to keep V(D)J recombination under control

Breaking apart chromosomes is not a matter to be taken lightly. The possible negative outcomes are obvious: loss of information, unstable chromosomes, chromosomal translocations, tumorigenesis, or cell death. Utilizing DNA rearrangement to generate the desired diversity in the antigen receptor loci is a risky business, and it must be carefully controlled. In general, the regulation is so precise that the negative consequences are minimal or not apparent. They are visible only when the process of V(D)J recombination goes awry, as for example in some chromosomal translocations associated with lymphoid tumors. Regulation is imposed not only to prevent the generation of random breaks in the DNA, but also to direct rearrangement to the appropriate locus or subregion of a locus in the appropriate cell at the appropriate time. Antigen receptor rearrangement is regulated essentially at four different levels: expression of the RAG1/2 recombinase, intrinsic biochemical properties of the recombinase and the cleavage reaction, the post-cleavage /DNA repair stage of the process, and accessibility of the substrate to the recombinase. Within each of these broad categories, multiple mechanisms are used to achieve the desired aims. The major focus of this review is on accessibility control and the role of chromatin and nuclear architecture in achieving this regulation, although other issues are touched upon.

Differential functions for the transcription factor E2A in positive and negative gene regulation in pre-B lymphocytes

The transcription factors encoded by the E2A gene have been shown to play essential roles in the initiation and progression of lymphocyte development. However, there is still a lack of comprehensive understanding of E2A downstream genes in B-cell development. We previously developed a gene tagging-based chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) system to directly evaluate E2A target genes in B-cell development. Here, we have improved this ChIP strategy and used it in conjunction with microarray analysis on E2A-deficient pre-B-cell lines to determine E2A target genes in lymphocyte development. Both microarray data and ChIP studies confirmed that E2A directly controls IgH gene expression. The microarray assay also revealed genes that were significantly up-regulated after E2A disruption. ChIP analysis showed that E2A was most likely to be directly involved in repression of some of these target genes such as Nfil3 and FGFR2. An inducible E2A reconstitution system further demonstrated that E2A-mediated repression of Nfil3 and FGFR2 was reversible. Collectively, these findings indicate that E2A is a positive regulator for one set of genes and a negative regulator for another set of genes in developing B lymphocytes.

Pax5 activates immunoglobulin heavy chain V to DJ rearrangement in transgenic thymocytes

Mice deficient for the B cell-restricted transcription factor Pax5 show a defect in the VH to DJH rearrangement step of immunoglobulin heavy chain gene assembly even though the expression of the V(D)J recombinase is not diminished in Pax5-/- pro-B cells. To investigate whether Pax5 is limiting for VH to DJH rearrangement, we generated transgenic mice which express Pax5 in developing thymocytes. We show that enforced expression of Pax5 in thymocytes results in a partial block in T cell development due to defective pre-TCR signaling in beta-selection. Moreover, our results demonstrate that expression of Pax5 in early thymocytes is sufficient to induce VH to DJH rearrangements in CD4+CD8+ T cells and lead us to suggest that Pax5 may play a direct role in the lineage-specific regulation of immunoglobulin heavy chain gene rearrangement.

Epigenetic regulation of antigen receptor rearrangement

In the mammalian immune system, V(D)J rearrangement of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T-cell receptor (TCR) genes is regulated in a lineage- and stage-specific fashion. Because each of the seven loci capable of rearrangement utilizes the same recombination machinery, it is thought that V(D)J recombination of each antigen receptor locus is regulated through the differential accessibility of each locus to the V(D)J recombination machinery. Accumulating evidence indicates that chromatin remodeling mediated by DNA methylation and demethylation plays important roles in regulating V(D)J recombination and germline transcription through the Ig and TCR loci. DNA demethylation within the antigen receptor loci appears to be regulated by cis-elements also required for coordinated V(D)J recombination and germline transcription. In this paper, we critically examine the relationship between demethylation and V(D)J recombination as well as the mechanism to regulate DNA demethylation within the antigen receptor loci.

Combinatorial control of DNase I-hypersensitive site formation and erasure by immunoglobulin heavy chain enhancer-binding proteins

DNase I-hypersensitive sites in cellular chromatin are usually believed to be nucleosome-free regions generated by transcription factor binding. Using a cell-free system we show that hypersensitivity does not simply correlate with the number of DNA-bound proteins. Specifically, the leucine zipper containing basic helix-loop-helix protein TFE3 was sufficient to induce a DNase I-hypersensitive site at the immunoglobulin heavy chain micro enhancer in vitro. TFE3 enhanced binding of an ETS protein PU.1 to the enhancer. However, PU.1 binding erased the DNase I-hypersensitive site without abolishing TFE3 binding. Furthermore, TFE3 binding enhanced transcription in the presence and absence of a hypersensitive site, whereas endonuclease accessibility correlated strictly with DNase I hypersensitivity. We infer that chromatin constraints for transcription and nuclease sensitivity can differ.

Gene segment selection in V(D)J recombination: accessibility and beyond

V(D)J recombination assembles genes encoding antigen receptors according to defined developmental programs in immature B and T lymphocytes. The 'accessibility hypothesis' was initially invoked to explain how a single recombinase complex could control the locus and allele specificity of V(D)J recombination. It has been since shown that recombination signal sequences themselves influence recombination efficiency and specificity in ways that had not been previously appreciated. Recent developments have increased our understanding of how the chromatin barrier to V(D)J recombination is regulated, and how chromatin control and the properties of the underlying recombination signal sequences may cooperate to create diverse, lineage-restricted and allelically excluded repertoires of antigen receptors.

B cell development arrest upon insertion of a neo gene between JH and Emu: promoter competition results in transcriptional silencing of germline JH and complete VDJ rearrangements

Previous targeting experiments within the IgH locus have shown that V(D)J recombination was affected by an insertion of a neo gene within E(mu) upstream of the core enhancer, but not by insertions downstream of the enhancer. Similarly, class switch recombination to a given (C) gene was affected only by interposition of neo in between that gene and the 3' IgH enhancers. Here we show that insertion of neo upstream E(mu) only marginally impairs V(D)J recombination, but results in an altered D and J(H) gene usage and completely blocks transcription of the germline J(H) region and the rearranged VDJ segments. Although transcriptional silencing of J(H) occurs upstream of the insertion and results in the lack of mature B cells in homozygous mutant animals, IgH transcription is maintained downstream of the insertion together with neo transcription and can be up-regulated by LPS stimulation or upon fusion with plasmacytoma cells. Altogether these data argue for a polarized "neo effect" involving promoter competition and further show that V(D)J rearrangement can be uncoupled from transcription.

Regulation of early lymphocyte development by E2A family proteins

Lymphocytes develop from hematopoietic stem cells through a series of highly regulated differentiation events in the bone marrow and thymus. A number of transcription factors are known to collaborate in controlling the timing and specificity of gene expression required for these developmental processes to occur. The basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) proteins encoded by the E2A gene have been shown to play particularly important roles in the initiation and progression of lymphocyte differentiation. Gene targeting experiments in mice have demonstrated a requirement for E2A proteins at the onset of B lymphocyte development. More recent studies have broadened our view on the function of E2A proteins at multiple stages of lymphopoiesis and in the regulation of lymphoid-specific gene expression. Here we review the mammalian E2A proteins and the accumulated evidence demonstrating central roles for E2A throughout early B and T lymphocyte development. We also speculate on the direction of future research on the mechanisms underlying the lineage and stage-specific functions of E2A in lymphopoiesis.

Identification of E2A target genes in B lymphocyte development by using a gene tagging-based chromatin immunoprecipitation system

The transcription factors encoded by the E2A gene are known to be essential for B lymphocyte development, and ectopic expression or gene inactivation studies have revealed several potential lineage-specific E2A target genes. However, it remains unknown whether these target genes are directly regulated by E2A at the transcriptional level. We therefore generated mice carrying an affinity-tagged E2A knock-in allele to provide a system for the direct elucidation of E2A target genes based on E2A binding to target regulatory regions. Abelson-transformed pre-B cell lines derived from these mice were used in chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments to identify regulatory sequences bound by E2A in the context of an early B lymphocyte environment. Significant E2A binding was detected at the promoters and enhancers of several essential B-lineage genes, including the Igkappa intronic and 3' enhancers, lambda5 and VpreB surrogate light chain promoters, the EBF locus promoter region, and the mb-1 (Igalpha) promoter. Low levels of E2A binding were observed at several other lymphoid-restricted regulatory regions including the Ig heavy chain (IgH) intronic enhancer, the IgH 3' enhancers hs3b/hs4, the RAG-2 enhancer, and the 5' regions of the B29 and TdT loci. An E2A target gene, the predicted butyrophilin-like gene NG9 (BTL-II), was also identified by using a chromatin immunoprecipitation-based cloning strategy. In summary, our studies have provided evidence that E2A is directly involved in the transcriptional regulation of a number of early B-lineage genes.

Distinct control of the frequency and allelic exclusion of the V beta gene rearrangement at the TCR beta locus

Ag receptor gene loci contain many V gene segments, each of which is recombined and expressed at a different frequency and is subject to allelic exclusion. To probe the parameters that mediate the different levels of regulation of V gene rearrangement, a Vbeta gene segment together with 3.6-kb 5' and 0.7-kb 3' flanking sequences was inserted 6.8 kb upstream of the Dbeta1 gene segment in the murine TCRbeta locus. Despite its proximity to the Dbeta gene segments and the Ebeta enhancer, the inserted Vbeta segment underwent VDJ recombination at the same frequency as the natural copy located 470 kb upstream. However, the inserted Vbeta segment was no longer under allelic exclusion control as it recombined at a similar frequency in the presence of a TCRbeta transgene. These results suggest that while the inserted fragment contains the necessary cis-regulatory elements for determining the frequency of Vbeta rearrangement, additional cis-regulatory elements are required for mediating Vbeta allelic exclusion. Interestingly, most of the inserted Vbeta rearrangements were not transcribed and expressed in the presence of a TCRbeta transgene, suggesting that TCRbeta allelic exclusion can also be achieved by blocking the transcription of the rearranged gene segments. These findings provide strong evidence for distinct control of the frequency and allelic exclusion of Vbeta gene rearrangement.

Chromatin remodeling by the T cell receptor (TCR)-beta gene enhancer during early T cell development: Implications for the control of TCR-beta locus recombination

Gene targeting studies have shown that T cell receptor (TCR)-beta gene expression and recombination are inhibited after deletion of an enhancer (Ebeta) located at the 3' end of the approximately 500-kb TCR-beta locus. Using knockout mouse models, we have measured, at different regions throughout the TCR-beta locus, the effects of Ebeta deletion on molecular parameters believed to reflect epigenetic changes associated with the control of gene activation, including restriction endonuclease access to chromosomal DNA, germline transcription, DNA methylation, and histone H3 acetylation. Our results demonstrate that, in early developing thymocytes, Ebeta contributes to major chromatin remodeling directed to an approximately 25-kb upstream domain comprised of the Dbeta-Jbeta locus regions. Accordingly, treatment of Ebeta-deleted thymocytes with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A relieved the block in TCR-beta gene expression and promoted recombination within the Dbeta-Jbeta loci. Unexpectedly, however, epigenetic processes at distal Vbeta genes on the 5' side of the locus and at the 3' proximal Vbeta14 gene appear to be less dependent on Ebeta, suggesting that Ebeta activity is confined to a discrete region of the TCR-beta locus. These findings have implications with respect to the developmental control of TCR-beta gene recombination, and the process of allelic exclusion at this locus.

T cell development in TCR beta enhancer-deleted mice: implications for alpha beta T cell lineage commitment and differentiation

T cell differentiation in the mouse thymus is an intricate, highly coordinated process that requires the assembly of TCR complexes from individual components, including those produced by the precisely timed V(D)J recombination of TCR genes. Mice carrying a homozygous deletion of the TCR beta transcriptional enhancer (E beta) demonstrate an inhibition of V(D)J recombination at the targeted TCR beta locus and a block in alpha beta T cell differentiation. In this study, we have characterized the T cell developmental defects resulting from the E beta-/- mutation, in light of previously reported results of the analyses of TCR beta-deficient (TCR beta-/-) mice. Similar to the latter mice, production of TCR beta-chains is abolished in the E beta-/- animals, and under these conditions differentiation into cell-surface TCR-, CD4+CD8+ double positive (DP) thymocytes depends essentially on the cell-autonomous expression of TCR delta-chains and, most likely, TCR gamma-chains. However, contrary to previous reports using TCR beta-/- mice, a minor population of TCR gamma delta+ DP thymocytes was found within the E beta-/- thymi, which differ in terms of T cell-specific gene expression and V(D)J recombinase activity, from the majority of TCR-, alpha beta lineage-committed DP thymocytes. We discuss these data with respect to the functional role of E beta in driving alpha beta T cell differentiation and the mechanism of alpha beta T lineage commitment.

Definition of a T-cell receptor beta gene core enhancer of V(D)J recombination by transgenic mapping

V(D)J recombination in differentiating lymphocytes is a highly regulated process in terms of both cell lineage and the stage of cell development. Transgenic and knockout mouse studies have demonstrated that transcriptional enhancers from antigen receptor genes play an important role in this regulation by activating cis-recombination events. A striking example is the T-cell receptor beta-chain (TCRbeta) gene enhancer (Ebeta), which in the mouse consists of at least seven nuclear factor binding motifs (betaE1 to betaE7). Here, using a well-characterized transgenic recombination substrate approach, we define the sequences within Ebeta required for recombination enhancer activity. The Ebeta core is comprised of a limited set of motifs (betaE3 and betaE4) and an additional previously uncharacterized 20-bp sequence 3' of the betaE4 motif. This core element confers cell lineage- and stage-specific recombination within the transgenic substrates, although it cannot bypass the suppressive effects resulting from transgene integration in heterochromatic centromeres. Strikingly, the core enhancer is heavily occupied by nuclear factors in immature thymocytes, as shown by in vivo footprinting analyses. A larger enhancer fragment including the betaE1 through betaE4 motifs but not the 3' sequences, although active in inducing germ line transcription within the transgenic array, did not retain the Ebeta recombinational activity. Our results emphasize the multifunctionality of the TCRbeta enhancer and shed some light on the molecular mechanisms by which transcriptional enhancers and associated nuclear factors may impact on cis recombination, gene expression, and lymphoid cell differentiation.

Hypomethylation is necessary but not sufficient for V(D)J recombination within a transgenic substrate

Although an inverse correlation between CpG methylation and V(D)J recombination has been demonstrated for both artificial substrates and endogenous genes, it is not known whether all hypomethylated targets are competent to rearrange or if other factors are required. We have created several artificial V(D)J recombination substrate transgenes whose methylation can be controlled by breeding into different genetic backgrounds. A transgene which contains the immunoglobulin heavy chain intronic enhancer rearranges efficiently in B lymphocytes when the transgene loci are unmethylated. When the same loci become methylated, upon breeding into a different mouse strain, no rearrangement can be detected. A similar transgene, but lacking the enhancer, also shows no evidence of V(D)J recombination when it is methylated. Even when this enhancerless transgene is hypomethylated, however, no V(D)J recombination can be detected in B lymphocytes. Thus, hypomethylation is required to permit V(D)J recombination but not all hypomethylated targets are capable of recombination. The results may indicate that the immunoglobulin enhancer is required for the assembly of factors involved in V(D)J recombination.

Allelic exclusion in B and T lymphopoiesis

The plasticity of the immune system relies on stochastic, i.e. random, decisions as well as on controlled events. V(D)J rearrangement of antigen receptors on B and T cells are mediated through the action of compound elements containing enhancer sequences. These elements function in a developmentally stage-specific and a cell-type-specific manner to attract machineries that demethylate DNA, remodel chromatin structure, and induce V(D)J recombination on one allele preferentially.

A targeted deletion of a region upstream from the Jkappa cluster impairs kappa chain rearrangement in cis in mice and in the 103/bcl2 cell line

We have shown previously that a mutation of the KI-KII site immediately 5' to J(kappa)1 on the mouse immunoglobulin light chain kappa locus reduces the rearrangement level in cis, although it does not affect transcription. Here we deleted by homologous recombination in mouse embryonic stem cells a 4-kb DNA fragment, located immediately upstream of the KI-KII element, which contains the promoter of the long germline transcript. Analysis of gene-targeted heterozygous mouse splenic B cells showed a strong decrease in rearrangement for the allele bearing the deletion. When both the KI-KII mutation and the 4-kb deletion were present on the same allele, the overall reduction in rearrangement was stronger than with the 4-kb deletion alone underlying the role of these two elements in the regulation of rearrangement. The same deletion was performed by homologous recombination on one allele of the rearrangement-inducible mouse 103/bcl2-hygro(R) pre-B cell line, and resulted in a similar reduction in the induction of rearrangement of the mutated allele. This result validates this cell line as an in vitro model for studying the incidence of gene-targeted modifications of the kappa locus on the regulation of rearrangement.

Regulation of V(D)J recombination by transcriptional promoters

Enhancer elements potentiate the rearrangement of antigen receptor loci via changes in the accessibility of gene segment clusters to V(D)J recombinase. Here, we show that enhancer activity per se is insufficient to target T-cell receptor beta miniloci for DbetaJbeta recombination. Instead, a promoter situated 5' to Dbeta1 (PDbeta) was required for efficient rearrangement of chromosomal substrates. A critical function for promoters in regulating gene segment accessibility was further supported by the ability of heterologous promoters to direct rearrangement of enhancer-containing substrates. Importantly, activation of a synthetic tetracycline-inducible promoter (Ptet) positioned upstream from the Dbeta gene segment was sufficient to target recombination of miniloci lacking a distal enhancer element. The latter result suggests that DNA loops, generated by interactions between flanking promoter and enhancer elements, are not required for efficient recognition of chromosomal gene segments by V(D)J recombinase. Unexpectedly, the Ptet substrate exhibited normal levels of rearrangement despite its retention of a hypermethylated DNA status within the DbetaJbeta cluster. Together, our findings support a model in which promoter activation, rather than intrinsic properties of enhancers, is the primary determinant for regulating recombinational accessibility within antigen receptor loci.

Cux/CDP homeoprotein is a component of NF-muNR and represses the immunoglobulin heavy chain intronic enhancer by antagonizing the bright transcription activator

Nuclear matrix attachment regions (MARs) flanking the immunoglobulin heavy chain intronic enhancer (Emu) are the targets of the negative regulator, NF-muNR, found in non-B and early pre-B cells. Expression library screening with NF-muNR binding sites yielded a cDNA clone encoding an alternatively spliced form of the Cux/CDP homeodomain protein. Cux/CDP fulfills criteria required for NF-muNR identity. It is expressed in non-B and early pre-B cells but not mature B cells. It binds to NF-muNR binding sites within Emu with appropriate differential affinities. Antiserum specific for Cux/CDP recognizes a polypeptide of the predicted size in affinity-purified NF-muNR preparations and binds NF-muNR complexed with DNA. Cotransfection with Cux/CDP represses the activity of Emu via the MAR sequences in both B and non-B cells. Cux/CDP antagonizes the effects of the Bright transcription activator at both the DNA binding and functional levels. We propose that Cux/CDP regulates cell-type-restricted, differentiation stage-specific Emu enhancer activity by interfering with the function of nuclear matrix-bound transcription activators.

Developmental regulation of V(D)J recombination at the TCR alpha/delta locus

The T-cell receptor (TCR) alpha/delta locus includes a large number of V, D, J and C gene segments that are used to produce functional TCR delta and TCR alpha chains expressed by distinct subsets of T lymphocytes. V(D)J recombination events within the locus are regulated as a function of developmental stage and cell lineage during T-lymphocyte differentiation in the thymus. The process of V(D)J recombination is regulated by cis-acting elements that modulate the accessibility of chromosomal substrates to the recombinase. Here we evaluate how the assembly of transcription factor complexes onto enhancers, promoters and other regulatory elements within the TCR alpha/delta locus imparts developmental control to VDJ delta and VJ alpha rearrangement events. Furthermore, we develop the notion that within a complex locus such as the TCR alpha/delta locus, highly localized and region-specific control is likely to require an interplay between positive regulatory elements and blocking or boundary elements that restrict the influence of the positive elements to defined regions of the locus.

Regulatory Elements in the Promoter of a Murine TCRD V Gene Segment

TCRD V segments rearrange in an ordered fashion during human and murine thymic development. Recombination requires the accessibility of substrate gene segments, and transcriptional enhancers and promoters have been shown to regulate the accessible chromatin configuration. We therefore investigated the regulation of TCRD V rearrangements by characterizing the promoter of the first TCRD V segment to be rearranged, DV101S1, under the influence of its own enhancer. Sequences required for full promoter activity were identified by transient transfections of normal and mutated promoters into a human γδ lymphoma, and necessary elements fall between −86 and +66 nt, relative to the major transcription start site. They include a cAMP responsive element (CRE) at −62, an Ets site at −39, a TATA box at −26, the major transcriptional start site sequence (−8 to −5 and −2 to +11), and a downstream sequence (+12 to +33). Gel shift analyses and in vitro DNase I footprinting showed that nuclear proteins bind to the functionally relevant CRE, Ets, +1 to +10 sequence, and the +17 to +21 sequence. Nuclear proteins also bind to an E box at −52, and GATA-3 binds to a GATA motif at −5, as shown by Ab ablation-supershift experiments, but mutations that abrogated protein binding to these sites failed to affect DV101S1 promoter activity. We conclude that not all protein-binding sites within the DV101S1 minimal promoter are important for enhancer driven TCRD gene transcription. Further, the possibility remains that the GATA and E box sites function in enhancer independent DV101S1 germline transcription.

Kappa chain monoallelic demethylation and the establishment of allelic exclusion

Allelic exclusion in kappa light-chain synthesis is thought to result from a feedback mechanism by which the expression of a functional kappa light chain on the surface of the B cell leads to an intracellular signal that down-regulates the V(D)J recombinase, thus precluding rearrangement of the other allele. Whereas such a feedback mechanism clearly plays a role in the maintenance of allelic exclusion, here we provide evidence suggesting that the initial establishment of allelic exclusion involves differential availability of the two kappa alleles for rearrangement. Analysis of kappa+ B-cell populations and of individual kappa+ B cells that have rearranged only one allele demonstrates that in these cells, critical sites on the rearranged allele are unmethylated, whereas the nonrearranged allele remains methylated. This pattern is apparently generated by demethylation that is initiated at the small pre-B cell stage, on a single allele, in a process that occurs prior to rearrangement and requires the presence in cis of both the intronic and 3' kappa enhancers. Taken together with data demonstrating that undermethylation is required for rearrangement, these results indicate that demethylation may actually underly the process of allelic exclusion by directing the initial choice of a single kappa allele for rearrangement.

ETS-mediated cooperation between basic helix-loop-helix motifs of the immunoglobulin mu heavy-chain gene enhancer

The muE motifs of the immunoglobulin mu heavy-chain gene enhancer bind ubiquitously expressed proteins of the basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) family. These elements work together with other, more tissue-restricted elements to produce B-cell-specific enhancer activity by presently undefined combinatorial mechanisms. We found that muE2 contributed to transcription activation in B cells only when the muE3 site was intact, providing the first evidence for functional interactions between bHLH proteins. In vitro assays showed that bHLH zipper proteins binding to muE3 enhanced Ets-1 binding to muA. One of the consequences of this protein-protein interaction was to facilitate binding of a second bHLH protein, E47, to the muE2 site, thereby generating a three-protein-DNA complex. Furthermore, transcriptional synergy between bHLH and bHLH zipper factors also required an intermediate ETS protein, which may bridge the transcription activation domains of the bHLH factors. Our observations define an unusual form of cooperation between bHLH and ETS proteins and suggest mechanisms by which tissue-restricted and ubiquitous factors combine to generate tissue-specific enhancer activity.

Biochemical and Functional Analyses of Chromatin Changes at the TCR-β Gene Locus During CD4−CD8− to CD4+CD8+ Thymocyte Differentiation

Allelic exclusion is the process wherein lymphocytes express Ag receptors from only one of two possible alleles, and is effected through a feedback inhibition of further rearrangement of the second allele. The feedback signal is thought to cause chromatin changes that block accessibility of the second allele to the recombinase. To identify the putative chromatin changes associated with allelic exclusion, we assayed for DNase I hypersensitivity, DNA methylation, and transcription in 100 kb of the TCR-β locus. Contrary to current models, we identified chromatin changes indicative of an active and accessible locus associated with the occurrence of allelic exclusion. Of 11 DNase I hypersensitive sites identified, 3 were induced during CD4−CD8− to CD4+CD8+ thymocyte differentiation, and demethylation and increased germline transcription of the locus were evident. We further examined the role of the most prominently induced site near the TCR-β enhancer (Eβ) in allelic exclusion by targeted mutagenesis. Two other sites were also examined in New Zealand White (NZW) mice that have a natural deletion in the TCR-β locus. TCR-β gene recombination and allelic exclusion were normal in both mutant mice, negating dominant roles for the three hypersensitive sites in the control of allelic exclusion. The data suggest that alternative cis-regulatory elements, perhaps contained in the Eβ enhancer and/or in the upstream Vβ region, are involved in the control of TCR-β allelic exclusion.

V(D)J recombination frequency is affected by the sequence interposed between a pair of recombination signals: sequence comparison reveals a putative recombinational enhancer element

The immunoglobulin heavy chain intron enhancer (Emu) not only stimulates transcription but also V(D)J recombination of chromosomally integrated recombination substrates. We aimed at reproducing this effect in recombination competent cells by transient transfection of extrachromosomal substrates. These we prepared by interposing between the recombination signal sequences (RSS) of the plasmid pBlueRec various fragments, including Emu, possibly affecting V(D)J recombination. Our work shows that sequences inserted between RSS 23 and RSS 12, with distances from their proximal ends of 26 and 284 bp respectively, can markedly affect the frequency of V(D)J recombination. We report that the entire Emu, the Emu core as well as its flanking 5' and 3' matrix associated regions (5' and 3' MARs) upregulate V(D)J recombination while the downstream section of the 3' MAR of Emu does not. Also, prokaryotic sequences markedly suppress V(D)J recombination. This confirms previous results obtained with chromosomally integrated substrates, except for the finding that the full length 3' MAR of Emu stimulates V(D)J recombination in an episomal but not in a chromosomal context. The fact that other MARs do not share this activity suggests that the effect is no mediated through attachment of the recombination substrate to a nuclear matrix-associated recombination complex but through cis-activation. The presence of a 26 bp A-T-rich sequence motif in the 5' and 3' MARs of Emu and in all of the other upregulating fragments investigated, leads us to propose that the motif represents a novel recombinational enhancer element distinct from those constituting the Emu core.

Regulation of T cell receptor delta gene rearrangement by CBF/PEBP2

We have analyzed transgenic mice carrying versions of a human T cell receptor (TCR)-delta gene minilocus to study the developmental control of VDJ (variable/diversity/joining) recombination. Previous data indicated that a 1.4-kb DNA fragment carrying the TCR-delta enhancer (E(delta)) efficiently activates minilocus VDJ recombination in vivo. We tested whether the transcription factor CBF/PEBP2 plays an important role in the ability of E(delta) to activate VDJ recombination by analyzing VDJ recombination in mice carrying a minilocus in which the deltaE3 element of E(delta) includes a mutated CBF/PEBP2 binding site. The enhancer-dependent VD to J step of minilocus rearrangement was dramatically inhibited in three of four transgenic lines, arguing that the binding of CBF/PEBP2 plays a role in modulating local accessibility to the VDJ recombinase in vivo. Because mutation of the deltaE3 binding site for the transcription factor c-Myb had previously established a similar role for c-Myb, and because a 60-bp fragment of E(delta) carrying deltaE3 and deltaE4 binding sites for CBF/PEBP2, c-Myb, and GATA-3 displays significant enhancer activity in transient transfection experiments, we tested whether this fragment of E(delta) is sufficient to activate VDJ recombination in vivo. This fragment failed to efficiently activate the enhancer-dependent VD to J step of minilocus rearrangement in all three transgenic lines examined, indicating that the binding of CBF/PEBP2 and c-Myb to their cognate sites within E(delta), although necessary, is not sufficient for the activation of VDJ recombination by E(delta). These results imply that CBF/PEBP2 and c-Myb collaborate with additional factors that bind elsewhere within E(delta) to modulate local accessibility to the VDJ recombinase in vivo.

E47 activates the Ig-heavy chain and TdT loci in non-B cells

The E2A proteins, E12 and E47, are basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) proteins essential for the B-cell lineage. Initially identified as immunoglobulin enhancer-binding proteins, they have also been shown to activate immunoglobulin enhancer-based reporters in transient transfection assays. Here, we examine the relationship between E2A DNA binding activity and activation of the endogenous, chromosomal immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) locus. Using sterile I(mu) transcription as an indicator of IgH enhancer activity, we see a direct correlation between E2A DNA binding activity and I(mu) transcription in stable BxT hybrids. We also observe a 1000-fold stimulation of endogenous I(mu) transcription in fibroblasts that express high levels of E47 and less stimulation in cells that express E12. By contrast, none of the other IgH enhancer-binding proteins tested (E2-2, Pu.1, Oct-2, OCA-B, TFE3 and USF) were able to activate I(mu) transcription. E47 overexpression also resulted in transcriptional activation of the endogenous gene encoding TdT, indicating that it, too, is a target of E2A proteins early in the B-cell lineage. Our results indicate that E2A proteins have the distinctive property of activating silent, chromatin-embedded B-cell-specific genes, underscoring their crucial role in B-cell development.

A role for nuclear NF-kappaB in B-cell-specific demethylation of the Igkappa locus

The immunoglobulin kappa gene is specifically demethylated during B-cell maturation in a process which utilizes discrete cis-acting modules such as the intronic kappa enhancer element and the matrix attachment region (MAR). While any MAR sequence is sufficient for this reaction, mutation analysis indicates that tissue specificity is mediated by kappaB binding sequences within the kappa intronic enhancer. The plasmacytoma cell line S107 lacks kappaB binding activity and fails to demethylate the kappa locus. However, B-cell specific demethylation is restored by the introduction of an active kappaB binding protein gene relB. This represents the first demonstration of a trans-acting factor involved in cell-type-specific demethylation, and suggests that the same protein-DNA recognition system used for transcription may also contribute to the earlier developmental events that bring about activation of the kappa locus.

Precise alignment of sites required for mu enhancer activation in B cells

The lymphocyte-specific immunoglobulin mu heavy-chain gene intronic enhancer is regulated by multiple nuclear factors. The previously defined minimal enhancer containing the muA, muE3, and muB sites is transactivated by a combination of the ETS-domain proteins PU.1 and Ets-1 in nonlymphoid cells. The core GGAAs of the muA and muB sites are separated by 30 nucleotides, suggesting that ETS proteins bind to these sites from these same side of the DNA helix. We tested the necessity for appropriate spatial alignment of these elements by using mutated enhancers with altered spacings. A 4- or 10-bp insertion between muE3 and muB inactivated the mu enhancer in S194 plasma cells but did not affect in vitro binding of Ets-1, PU.1, or the muE3-binding protein TFE3, alone or in pairwise combinations. Circular permutation and phasing analyses demonstrated that PU.1 binding but not TFE3 or Ets-1 bends mu enhancer DNA toward the major groove. We propose that the requirement for precise spacing of the muA and muB elements is due in part to a directed DNA bend induced by PU.1.

Cell type-specific chromatin structure determines the targeting of V(D)J recombinase activity in vitro

A common V(D)J recombinase that recognizes a conserved recombination signal sequence (RSS) mediates the assembly of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) genes in B and T cell precursors. The rearrangement of particular Ig and TCR gene segments, however, is tightly regulated with respect to cell lineage and developmental stage. Using an in vitro system, we analyzed recombinase cleavage of RSSs flanking Ig and TCR gene segments in nuclei. We found that both the lineage-specificity and temporal ordering of gene rearrangement is reflected in the accessibility of RSSs within chromatin to in vitro cleavage.

Accessibility control of antigen-receptor variable-region gene assembly: role of cis-acting elements

Antigen receptor variable region genes are assembled from germline variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) gene segments. This process requires expression of V(D)J recombinase activity, and "accessibility" of variable gene segments to this recombinase. The exact mechanism by which variable gene segments become accessible during development is not known. However, several studies have shown that cis-acting elements that regulate transcription may also function to regulate accessibility. Here we review the evidence that transcriptional promoters, enhancers, and silencers are involved in regulation of accessibility. The manner in which these elements may combine to regulate accessibility is addressed. In addition, current and potential strategies for identifying and analyzing cis-acting elements that mediate locus accessibility are discussed.