Inherited immunodeficiency with a defect in a major histocompatibility complex class II promoter-binding protein differs in the chromatin structure of the HLA-DRA gene

Technological advances in the study of HLA-DRA promoter regulation: extending the functions of CIITA, Oct-1, Rb, and RFX

Several advances were established in examining the interaction of transcriptional factors with the HLA-DRA promoter. First, hydrodynamic injection was used to demonstrate the activation of the promoter by class II transactivator in a live mouse. Second, the Oct-1 DNA-binding site in the HLA-DRA promoter is a negative element in many cells, but here we show that Oct-1 activates the promoter independently of the Oct-1-binding site. Third, the retinoblastoma (Rb) protein is required for the induction of the endogenous HLA-DRA gene, due to a poorly understood, pleiotropic effect on the Oct-1 and YY1 repressive functions at the HLA-DRA promoter. There has never been an indication that direct promoter activation, by Rb, is possible. Here, we report that the first HLA-DRA intron has an Rb-responsive element, as indicated by a transient transfection/promoter reporter assay. Finally, RFX activates a methylated version of an HLA-DRA promoter reporter construct, consistent with the role of RFX in rescuing the expression of the methylated, endogenous HLA-DRA gene. Here, we report that this RFX function is not limited to a specific RFX-binding sequence or to the HLA-DRA promoter. These advances provide bases for novel investigations into the function of the major histocompatibility class II promoter.

Nucleosome eviction from MHC class II promoters controls positioning of the transcription start site

Nucleosome depletion at transcription start sites (TSS) has been documented genome-wide in multiple eukaryotic organisms. However, the mechanisms that mediate this nucleosome depletion and its functional impact on transcription remain largely unknown. We have studied these issues at human MHC class II (MHCII) genes. Activation-induced nucleosome free regions (NFR) encompassing the TSS were observed at all MHCII genes. Nucleosome depletion was exceptionally strong, attaining over 250-fold, at the promoter of the prototypical HLA-DRA gene. The NFR was induced primarily by the transcription factor complex that assembles on the conserved promoter-proximal enhancer situated upstream of the TSS. Functional analyses performed in the context of native chromatin demonstrated that displacing the NFR without altering the sequence of the core promoter induced a shift in the position of the TSS. The NFR thus appears to play a critical role in transcription initiation because it directs correct TSS positioning in vivo. Our results provide support for a novel mechanism in transcription initiation whereby the position of the TSS is controlled by nucleosome eviction rather than by promoter sequence.

Activation of a methylated promoter mediated by a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein, RFX

The roles of eukaryotic DNA methylation in the repression of mRNA transcription and in the formation of heterochromatin have been extensively elucidated over the past several years. However, the role of DNA methylation in transcriptional activation remains a mystery. In particular, it is not known whether the transcriptional activation of methylated DNA is promoter-specific, depends directly on sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins, or is facilitated by the methylation. Here we report that the sequence-specific DNA-binding protein, RFX, previously shown to mediate the transition from an inactive to an active chromatin structure, activates a methylated promoter. RFX is capable of mediating enhanceosome formation on a methylated promoter, thereby mediating a transition from a methylation-dependent repression of the promoter to a methylation-dependent activation of the promoter. These results indicate novel roles for DNA methylation and sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins in transcriptional activation.

Oct-1 maintains an intermediate, stable state of HLA-DRA promoter repression in Rb-defective cells: an Oct-1-containing repressosome that prevents NF-Y binding to the HLA-DRA promoter

The cell surface HLA-DR molecule binds foreign peptide antigen and forms an intercellular complex with the T cell receptor in the course of the development of an immune response against or immune tolerance to the antigen represented by the bound peptide. The HLA-DR molecule also functions as a receptor that mediates cell signaling pathways, including as yet poorly characterized pathway(s) leading to apoptosis. Expression of HLA-DR mRNA and protein is ordinarily inducible by interferon-gamma but is not inducible in tumor cells defective for the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein (Rb). In the case of the HLA-DRA gene, which encodes the HLA-DR heavy chain, previous work has indicated that this loss of inducibility is attributable to Oct-1 binding to the HLA-DRA promoter. In this report, we used Oct-1 antisense transformants to determine that Oct-1 represses the interferon-gamma response of the endogenous HLA-DRA gene. This determination is consistent with results from a chromatin immunoprecipitation assay, indicating that Oct-1 occupies the endogenous HLA-DRA promoter when the HLA-DRA promoter is inactive in Rb-defective cells but not when the promoter is converted to a previously defined, transcriptionally competent state, induced by treatment of the Rb-defective cells with the HDAC inhibitor, trichostatin A. In vitro DNA-protein binding analyses indicated that Oct-1 prevents HLA-DRA promoter activation by mediating the formation of a complex of proteins, termed DRAN (DRA negative), that blocks NF-Y access to the promoter.

Constitutive DNase I hypersensitivity of p53-regulated promoters

The ability of p53 to alter, at the transcriptional level, the gene expression of downstream targets is critical for its role as a tumor suppressor. Most models of p53 activation postulate the stepwise recruitment by p53 of coactivators, histone acetyltransferases, and/or chromatin remodeling factors to a promoter region to facilitate the subsequent access of the general transcriptional machinery required for transcriptional induction. We demonstrate here, however, that the promoter regions for the p53 target genes, p21, 14-3-3sigma, and KARP-1, exist in a constitutively open conformation that is readily accessible to DNase I. This conformation was not altered by DNA damage or by whether p53 was present or absent in the cell. In contrast, p53 response elements, which resided outside the immediate promoter regions, existed within DNase I-resistant chromatin domains. Thus, p53 activation of downstream target genes occurs without p53 inducing chromatin alterations detectable by DNase I accessibility at either the promoter or the response element. As such, these data support models of p53 activation that do not require extensive chromatin alterations to support cognate gene expression.

The bare lymphocyte syndrome and the regulation of MHC expression

The bare lymphocyte syndrome (BLS) is a hereditary immunodeficiency resulting from the absence of major histocompatibility complex class II (MHCII) expression. Considering the central role of MHCII molecules in the development and activation of CD4(+) T cells, it is not surprising that the immune system of the patients is severely impaired. BLS is the prototype of a "disease of gene regulation." The affected genes encode RFXANK, RFX5, RFXAP, and CIITA, four regulatory factors that are highly specific and essential for MHCII genes. The first three are subunits of RFX, a trimeric complex that binds to all MHCII promoters. CIITA is a non-DNA-binding coactivator that functions as the master control factor for MHCII expression. The study of RFX and CIITA has made major contributions to our comprehension of the molecular mechanisms controlling MHCII genes and has made this system into a textbook model for the regulation of gene expression.

MHC class II deficiency: definition of a new complementation group

MHC class II deficiency is a severe primary immunodeficiency characterized by the absence of Major Histocompatibility Complex class II gene expression. It is genetically heterogenous and can result from defects in several different transacting regulatory factors required for transcription of MHC class II genes. Cell lines from MHC class II deficiency patients have been assigned to three complementation groups (A, B, C). An in vitro generated cell line (6.1.6) was reported to be the sole representative of a fourth group (group D). The molecular defect in 6.1.6 resides in the recently cloned RFXAP gene. Direct complementation experiments and mutation analysis were performed with cell lines from several MHC class II deficiency patients in which the affected gene had not been identified. These experiments have allowed us to define a previously unrecognized MHC class II deficiency complementation group containing patients having mutations in the RFXAP gene.

Functional significance of polymorphism among MHC class II gene promoters

The functional significance of polymorphism among MHC class II promoters in man and mouse is here reviewed, mainly in terms of the hypothesis of differential expression. The hypothesis proposes that differences between antigen-presenting cells in MHC class II expression exert a co-dominant effect on the Th1-Th2 cytokine balance, such that class II molecules of one type come to control to a greater extent the production of one group of cytokines, and those of another type the production of the alternative group. The survey deals with the influence of signal strength and antigen-presenting cell type on T-cell subset differentiation; functional differences between MHC class II molecules not obviously related to determinant selection; disease protection mediated by HLA alleles; mechanisms possibly responsible for allotypic and isotypic bias; overdominance (heterozygous advantage) in selection for expression of class II alleles; MHC class II promoter structure and function; inter-locus and inter-allele variability within human MHC class II gene upstream regulatory regions; a comparison of these polymorphisms in mouse and man; read-out of class II promoter function; and a comparison with expression of MHC class I. We conclude that the evidence that this variation is functionally active (i.e. controls expression) is increasing, but is not yet compelling. The crucial test still to come, we suggest, is whether or not the biological effects attributable to this polymorphism will line up with molecular studies on expression.

Regulation of MHC class II genes: lessons from a disease

Precise regulation of major histocompatibility complex class II (MHC-II) gene expression plays a crucial role in the control of the immune response. A major breakthrough in the elucidation of the molecular mechanisms involved in MHC-II regulation has recently come from the study of patients that suffer from a primary immunodeficiency resulting from regulatory defects in MHC-II expression. A genetic complementation cloning approach has led to the isolation of CIITA and RFX5, two essential MHC-II gene transactivators. CIITA and RFX5 are mutated in these patients, and the wild-type genes are capable of correcting their defect in MHC-II expression. The identification of these regulatory factors has furthered our understanding of the molecular mechanisms that regulate MHC-II genes. CIITA was found to be a non-DNA binding transactivator that functions as a molecular switch controlling both constitutive and inducible MHC-II expression. The finding that RFX5 is a subunit of the nuclear RFX-complex has confirmed that a deficiency in the binding of this complex is indeed the molecular basis for MHC-II deficiency in the majority of patients. Furthermore, the study of RFX has demonstrated that MHC-II promoter activity is dependent on the binding of higher-order complexes that are formed by highly specific cooperative binding interactions between certain MHC-II promoter-binding proteins. Two of these proteins belong to families of which the other members, although capable of binding to the same DNA motifs, are probably not directly involved in the control of MHC-II expression. Finally, the facts that CIITA and RFX5 are both essential and highly specific for MHC-II genes make possible novel strategies designed to achieve immunomodulation via transcriptional intervention.

Molecular defects in the bare lymphocyte syndrome and regulation of MHC class II genes

The complex pattern of expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules plays an essential role in the control of the immune response. Our understanding of the molecular mechanisms controlling this expression has benefited greatly from the identification of the regulatory factors defective in two forms of a hereditary disease of MHC class II regulation: bare lymphocyte syndrome. This has also provided new tools for the experimental modulation of MHC class II expression.

Transcriptional regulation of MHC class II genes

MHC class II molecules play a fundamental role in the homeostasis of the immune response, functioning as receptors for antigenic peptides to be presented to regulatory T cells. Both quantitative and qualitative alterations in the expression of these molecules on the cell surface dramatically affect the onset of the immune response, and may be the basis of a wide variety of disease states, such as autoimmunity, immunodeficiencies, and cancer. Most regulation of MHC class II molecule expression is under the control of transcription mechanisms which are both cell type and development specific. In the last few years classical genetics together with molecular biology have greatly contributed to the widening of our knowledge on the regulatory mechanisms operating in the control of class II gene expression. This review deals with the latest developments in this fundamental area of immunology.

Definition of a novel complementation group in MHC class II deficiency

In this study we analyzed fibroblasts derived from an MHC class II deficiency patient (type III bare lymphocyte syndrome). Northern blot analysis showed that upon induction with IFN-gamma these fibroblasts did not express HLA class II genes and displayed a strongly reduced level of HLA class I gene expression when compared with fibroblasts of a healthy individual. However, when analyzed by RT-polymerase chain reaction (PCR), residual expression could be detected for HLA-DRA, DPB, and DQA, but not for HLA-DRB, DPA, and DQB. The lack of HLA-DRB transcripts in the patient fibroblasts and the high degree of sequence polymorphism of HLA-DRB were exploited in the further analysis of these fibroblasts. Thus far, at least three, and probably four, complementation groups have been defined among patient-derived and experimentally-derived MHC class II-negative cell lines. Transient heterokaryons between the patient fibroblasts and representative B-lymphoblastoid cell lines from each of the complementation groups were analyzed by RT-PCR and Southern blotting, using HLA-DRB-specific primers and biotin-labeled sequence specific oligonucleotides, respectively. These analyses showed that the fibroblasts of this particular patient belonged to a novel complementation group in MHC class II deficiency.

In vivo modification of major histocompatibility complex class II DRA promoter occupancy mediated by the AIR-1 trans-activator

RJ 2.2.5 is a human B cell mutant derived from the Burkitt lymphoma Raji cell which is defective in the AIR-1 locus function. This locus encodes a transcriptional trans-activator required for the constitutive expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II genes. Here we show, by in vivo DNase I footprinting, that the AIR-1 locus defect correlates with changes in the DRA promoter occupancy. Interestingly, reexpression of human MHC class II genes in RJ 2.2.5 x mouse spleen cell hybrids is associated with partial reversion of DRA promoter occupancy to the Raji pattern. DRA promoter occupancy in other class II-negative B cell lines, derived from patients with bare lymphocyte syndrome, is drastically different from the one observed in RJ 2.2.5 and Raji cells. Moreover, the use of the DNase I as an in vivo footprinting agent reveals that the patients' cell lines do not display a completely "bare promoter" as previously reported using dimethyl sulfate as the footprinting agent. Thus, the use of DNase I allowed us, for the first time, to correlate the AIR-1 locus defect with class II promoter occupancy alterations and distinguish these alterations from the ones observed in phenotypically similar but genetically distinct MHC class II-negative cells.

Methylation state of the human HLA-DRA gene in T-lymphocytes and B-lymphocytes of transgenic mice. Lack of methylation at one 5'-GCGC site is not required for gene expression

A consistent lack of DNA methylation at one or both of two GCGC (Hha I) restriction sites in the 5' region of the HLA-DRA gene has been previously documented by the use of methyl-sensitive restriction enzymes in human cells and tissues, irrespectively of their expression of DR alpha products. Evidence presently available, however, does not exclude that a lack of methylation in this region, although not sufficient, might be necessary for gene expression. In this report, we show that only one of the 5'-GCGC sites is protected, although less efficiently than in man, from CG-->mCG modifications in tissues and cells of transgenic mice carrying an expressed single copy of the HLA-DRA gene/diploid genome. We demonstrate that the two 5' GCGC sites of the HLA-DRA transgene are fully methylated in DR alpha- splenocytes (more than 80% T-lymphocytes), while one of them (the most 5' site) is not methylated in a fraction of DR alpha+ splenocytes (more than 95% B-lymphocytes). These results provide evidence that absence of DNA methylation in the 5' region is not necessary for, but might be associated with and possibly secondary to the expression of the DRA gene.

Techniques for cloning cDNAs encoding interactive transcriptional regulatory proteins

Several approaches aimed at detecting and cloning interactive transcriptional regulatory proteins have been presented. All of the techniques can effectively identify specific interactions between two transcription proteins. However, interaction cloning and the two hybrid system have the added advantage of yielding a cDNA expression clone directly. The other methods, EMSA-mediated cloning, co-immunoprecipitation, oligonucleotide/PCR-facilitated cloning, Southwestern, and Farwestern, require additional manipulations to obtain a cDNA clone. Clearly, the interactive cloning system of choice will depend on the proteins under investigation.

Biological aspects of cytosine methylation in eukaryotic cells

The existence in eukaryotes of a fifth base, 5-methylcytosine, and of tissue-specific methylation patterns have been known for many years, but except for a general association with inactive genes and chromatin the exact function of this DNA modification has remained elusive. The different hypotheses regarding the role of DNA methylation in regulation of gene expression, chromatin structure, development, and diseases, including cancer are summarized, and the experimental evidence for them is discussed. Structural and functional properties of the eukaryotic DNA cytosine methyltransferase are also reviewed.