Replication in the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain in CHO cells may initiate at two distinct sites, one of which is a repetitive sequence element

Pre-replication complex proteins assemble at regions of low nucleosome occupancy within the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase initiation zone

Genome-scale mapping of pre-replication complex proteins has not been reported in mammalian cells. Poor enrichment of these proteins at specific sites may be due to dispersed binding, poor epitope availability or cell cycle stage-specific binding. Here, we have mapped sites of biotin-tagged ORC and MCM protein binding in G1-synchronized populations of Chinese hamster cells harboring amplified copies of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) locus, using avidin-affinity purification of biotinylated chromatin followed by high-density microarray analysis across the DHFR locus. We have identified several sites of significant enrichment for both complexes distributed throughout the previously identified initiation zone. Analysis of the frequency of initiations across stretched DNA fibers from the DHFR locus confirmed a broad zone of de-localized initiation activity surrounding the sites of ORC and MCM enrichment. Mapping positions of mononucleosomal DNA empirically and computing nucleosome-positioning information in silico revealed that ORC and MCM map to regions of low measured and predicted nucleosome occupancy. Our results demonstrate that specific sites of ORC and MCM enrichment can be detected within a mammalian intitiation zone, and suggest that initiation zones may be regions of generally low nucleosome occupancy where flexible nucleosome positioning permits flexible pre-RC assembly sites.

A winding road to origin discovery

Studies in our laboratory over the last three decades have shown that the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) origin of replication corresponds to a broad zone of inefficient initiation sites distributed throughout the spacer between the convergently transcribed DHFR and 2BE2121 genes. It is clear from mutational analysis that none of these sites is genetically required for controlling origin activity. However, the integrity of the promoter of the DHFR gene is needed to activate the downstream origin, while the 3' processing signals prevent invasion and inactivation of the downstream origin by transcription forks. Several other origins in metazoans have been shown to correspond to zones of inefficient sites, while a different subset appears to be similar to the fixed replicators that characterize origins in S. cerevisiae and lower organisms. These observations have led us to suggest a model in which the mammalian genome is dotted with a hierarchy of degenerate, redundant, and inefficient replicators at intervals of a kilobase or less, some of which may have evolved to be highly circumscribed and efficient. The activities of initiation sites are proposed to be largely regulated by local transcription and chromatin architecture. Recently, we and others have devised strategies for identifying active origins on a genome-wide scale in order to define their distributions between fixed and dispersive origin types and to detect relationships among origins, genes, and epigenetic markers. The global pictures emerging are suggestive but far from complete and appear to be plagued by some of the same uncertainties that have led to conflicting views of individual origins in the past (particularly DHFR). In this paper, we will trace the history of origin discovery in mammalian genomes, primarily using the well-studied DHFR origin as a model, because it has been analyzed by nearly every available origin mapping technique in several different laboratories, while many origins have been identified by only one. We will address the strengths and shortcomings of the various methods utilized to identify and characterize origins in complex genomes and will point out how we and others were sometimes led astray by false assumptions and biases, as well as insufficient information. The goal is to help guide future experiments that will provide a truly comprehensive and accurate portrait of origins and their regulation. After all, in the words of George Santayana, "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it."

Initiation of DNA replication at a nuclear matrix-attached chromatin fraction

It is still unclear what nuclear components support initiation of DNA replication. To address this issue, we developed a cell-free replication system in which the nuclear matrix along with the residual matrix-attached chromatin was used as a substrate for DNA replication. We found out that initiation occurred at late G1 residual chromatin but not at early G1 chromatin and depended on cytosolic and nuclear factors present in S phase cells but not in G1 cells. Initiation of DNA replication occurred at discrete replication foci in a pattern typical for early S phase. To prove that the observed initiation takes place at legitimate DNA replication origins, the in vitro synthesized nascent DNA strands were isolated and analyzed. It was shown that they were enriched in sequences from the core origin region of the early firing, dihydrofolate reductase origin of replication ori-beta and not in distal to the origin sequences. A conclusion is drawn that initiation of DNA replication occurs at discrete sub-chromosomal structures attached to the nuclear matrix.

Distribution of DNA replication origins between matrix-attached and loop DNA in mammalian cells

Using a previously developed procedure (Gencheva et al. [1996] J Biol Chem 271:2608-2614), we isolated a DNA fraction consisting of short fragments originating from the regions of initiation of DNA synthesis from exponentially growing Chinese hamster ovary cells. This fraction arbitrarily designated as "collective origin fraction" was labeled in vitro and used to probe the abundance of origin containing sequences in preparations of matrix-attached and loop DNA isolated by two different procedures from Chinese hamster ovary cells. Alternatively, an individual DNA replication origin sequence - a 478-bp long DNA fragment located at about 17-kb downstream of the dihydrofolate reductase gene - was used to probe the same matrix-attached and loop DNA fractions. The results with both the collective and individual DNA replication origins showed that there was random distribution of the origin sequences between DNA attached to the matrix and DNA from the loops.

Dispersive initiation of replication in the Chinese hamster rhodopsin locus

Several higher eukaryotic replication origins appear to be composed of broad zones of potential nascent strand start sites, while others are more circumscribed, resembling those of yeast, bacteria, and viruses. The most delocalized origin identified so far is approximately 55 kb in length and lies between the convergently transcribed dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) and the 2BE2121 genes on chromosome 2 in the Chinese hamster genome. In some of our studies, we have utilized the rhodopsin origin as an early replicating internal standard for assessing the effects of deleting various parts of the DHFR locus on DHFR origin activity. However, it had not been previously established that the rhodopsin locus was located at a site far enough away to be immune to such deletions, nor had the mechanism of initiation at this origin been characterized. In the present study, we have localized the rhodopsin domain to a pair of small metacentric chromosomes and have used neutral/neutral 2-D gel replicon mapping to show that initiation in this origin is also highly delocalized, encompassing a region more than 50 kb in length that includes the nontranscribed rhodopsin gene itself. The initiation zone is flanked at least on one end by an actively transcribed gene that does not support initiation. Thus, the DHFR and rhodopsin origins belong to a class of complex, polydisperse origins that appears to be unique to higher eukaryotic cells.

Physical and genetic mapping of mammalian replication origins

The neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel electrophoretic techniques are sensitive physical mapping methods that have been used successfully to identify replication initiation sites in genomes of widely varying complexity. We present detailed methodology for the preparation of replication intermediates from mammalian cells and their analysis by both neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel approaches. The methods described allow characterization of the replication pattern of single-copy loci, even in mammalian cells. When applied to metazoans, initiation is found to occur at multiple sites scattered throughout zones that can be as long as 50 kb, with some subregions being preferred. Although these observations do not rule out the possibility of genetically defined replicators, they offer the alternative or additional possibility that chromosomal context may play an important role in defining replication initiation sites in complex genomes. We discuss novel recombination strategies that can be used to test for the presence of sequence elements critical for origin function if the origin lies in the vicinity of a selectable gene. Application of this strategy to the DHFR locus shows that loss of sequences more than 25 kb from the local initiation zone can markedly affect origin activity in the zone.

Differentiation-related mechanisms which suppress DNA replication

Differentiation of mammalian cells implies cessation of DNA replication and cell proliferation; the potential controls of this coupling are examined here. It is clear that the known or proposed mechanisms of down-regulation of replicative cellular activities vary in different lineages of cell differentiation, and occur in all phases of the cell cycle. In G1 these regulators include p21/Cip1 or p27/Kip1, pRb, and p53; the novel, recently reported mechanisms of their action are summarized. In S phase the availability of nucleotide precursors, the origin recognition complex (ORC), and other replication proteins may be important in differentiation, and in G2 phase the cdc2/cyclin B complex and replication licensing factors determine normal G2 traverse versus an arrest or polyploidisation. Other replication-related mechanisms include transcription factors, e.g., Sp1, telomerase, and nuclear matrix changes. Thus, differentiation alters the activity not only of the various checkpoint proteins, but also of the components of the replicative machinery itself.

Early-replicating DNA from mosquito cells is associated with a distinct EcoRI fragment

In an effort to define an origin of bi-directional DNA replication (OBR) in mosquito genomic DNA, we applied methods that take advantage of characteristic features of single-stranded DNA to methotrexate-resistant Aedes albopictus cells. The Mtx-5011-256 cells contained approximately 1000 copies of a 200 kb amplicon containing the dihydrofolate reductase locus, which likely contained one or more replication origins. When Mtx-5011-256 cells were synchronized by treatment with hydroxyurea, released into the S phase of the cell cycle, and labeled in vivo with tritiated DNA precursors, a 1.9 kb EcoRI fragment was preferentially labeled in EcoRI-digested genomic DNA. Similarly, we detected a 1.9 kb EcoRI fragment in DNA from wild type cells after cell cycle synchronization and in vivo labeling. In a complementary method, unlabeled single-stranded DNA was isolated from Mtx-5011-256 cells, labeled in vitro, and hybridized to EcoRI-digested genomic DNA from mosquito cells. The labeled probe hybridized preferentially to a 1.9 kb fragment. Finally, a 1.9 kb EcoRI fragment was detected when nascent DNA was recovered from unsynchronized cells, made double-stranded by in vitro labeling, and digested with EcoRI. Taken together, these results suggest that in Aedes albopictus mosquito cells, many replication origins used at different times during S are flanked by EcoRI sites that define a 1.9 kb fragment, which has become more abundant in Mtx-5011-256 cells because it occurs in the dhfr amplicon. Tentative mapping of this origin to amplicon DNA remains ambiguous, further suggesting that a repeated sequence element occurs at or near the origin of replication.

Distal sequences, but not ori-beta/OBR-1, are essential for initiation of DNA replication in the Chinese hamster DHFR origin

In the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase replication initiation zone, the ori-beta locus is preferred over other start sites. To test the hypothesis that ori-beta contains a genetic replicator, we restored a deletion in the 3' end of the DHFR gene with a cosmid that provides the missing sequence and simultaneously knocks out the downstream ori-beta locus. Replication initiates normally in ori-beta knockout cell lines, and the DHFR domain is still synthesized in early S phase. However, initiation is completely suppressed in the starting deletion variant lacking the 3' end of the gene. We conclude that ori-beta does not contain an essential replicator, but that distant sequence elements have profound effects on origin activity in this locus.

oriGNAI3: a narrow zone of preferential replication initiation in mammalian cells identified by 2D gel and competitive PCR replicon mapping techniques

The nature of mammalian origins of DNA replication remains controversial and this is primarily because two-dimensional gel replicon mapping techniques have identified broad zones of replication initiation whereas several other techniques, such as quantitative PCR, have disclosed more discrete sites of initiation at the same chromosomal loci. In this report we analyze the replication of an amplified genomic region encompassing the 3'-end of the GNAI3 gene, the entire GNAT2 gene and the intergenic region between them in exponentially growing Chinese hamster fibroblasts. These cells express GNAI3 but not GNAT2 . The replication pattern was first analyzed by two-dimensional neutral-alkaline gel electrophoresis. Surprisingly, the results revealed a small preferential zone of replication initiation, of at most 1.7 kb, located in a limited part of the GNAI3 - GNAT2 intergenic region. Mapping of this initiation zone was then confirmed by quantitative PCR. The agreement between the two techniques exploited here strengthens the hypothesis that preferred sites of replication initiation do exist in mammalian genomes.

The search for origins of DNA replication

The past decade has witnessed an explosion of new information about the nature of DNA replication in eukaryotic cells. Much of this information has resulted from the advent of novel methods for identifying and characterizing origins of DNA replication in the genomes of viruses, plasmids, and cells. These methods can map with remarkable precision sites where replication begins. In addition, they provide assays for origin activity that can be used to identify the sequence of events leading to the formation and activation of prereplication complexes at specific sites in chromosomal DNA. I summarize briefly the current view of eukaryotic replication origins and the methods that have been used to identify and characterize them. Selected methods that show promise for future applications are then described in detail in subsequent articles.

Mapping replication origins by nascent DNA strand length

The mapping of replication origins by nascent DNA strand length determination is a very sensitive generally applicable method that identifies even single-copy origins in mammalian chromosomes. A major advantage of this procedure is that there is no need for synchronization of cells or treatment with metabolic agents, which allows the origin to be studied under physiological conditions. This technique is based upon the amplification of specific sequence markers on nascent DNA strands that initiated replication within the region of the putative origin. Therefore, this method requires detailed sequence information of the locus to be analyzed. As a first step, nascent DNA of proliferating cells is pulse-labeled with BrdU followed by size fractionation and purification with anti-BrdU antibodies. The position of putative origins can then be determined via identification of the shortest nascent strands that can be amplified by PCR and hybridized to probes homologous to the amplified segments. Here, we give a detailed description of the theory behind the method and a full recipe for its application. Advantages and limitations of the procedure are discussed.

Role of nuclear architecture in the initiation of eukaryotic DNA replication

The eukaryotic genome is compacted in the cell nucleus, in a way that allows its faithful and ordered replication each cell cycle. Chromatin is organized into topologically constrained loops that are anchored to the nuclear matrix by specific attachment regions (SARs). Chromatin loops were proposed to correspond to replication units. In particular, it has been suggested that replication origins coincide with SARs. Critical examination of these hypotheses has long been hampered by the elusive nature of higher eukaryotic DNA replication origins and termini. In recent years, however, a number of loci have been mapped for both SARs and replication units, and studies on the nuclear localization of replicating DNA and replication proteins have begun. We review these data and argue that they question this model. We then try to delineate other aspects of chromosome compartmentalization and cell-cycle remodeling which might be responsible for the specification and activation of metazoan DNA replication origins.

Clusters of replicons that fire simultaneously may be organized into superloops

To study the relation between replicon initiation and nuclear organization of DNA, mouse erythroleukemia F4N cells were irradiated with 60Co source and the rates of initiation of DNA synthesis were determined by a sensitive assay based on the introduction of Trioxsalen cross-links in DNA in vivo and determination of the amount of short nascent DNA fragments synthesized between the cross-links. In parallel, nuclear organization of DNA was monitored using the nucleoid sedimentation technique. The results show that DNA initiation rate and relative nucleoid sedimentation change sharply and simultaneously at doses of about 1 Gy, which suggests the existence of relationship between them. This suggestion was supported by the finding, that during the after-irradiation period, first DNA organization was restored and only after this process had been completed, the restoration of replicon initiation commenced. When cells were treated with novobiocin, an agent that is known to slow down the recovery of nucleoid sedimentation rate, initiation of DNA synthesis was also postponed. A hypothesis is put forward that replicon clusters represent groups of adjacent DNA loops organized in superloop domains and that the intact superloop domain structure is necessary for activation of the cluster.

Structural mapping of the dihydrofolate reductase amplicon in mosquito cells resistant to methotrexate

A cosmid library containing genomic DNA from mosquito cells in which the dihydrofolate reductase gene had become amplified in response to methotrexate selection was used to define the structure of the amplified DNA region (amplicon). A series of overlapping cosmids identified more than 200 kb of amplicon DNA, which was mapped relative to BssHII fragments from genomic DNA separated by transverse alternating field electrophoresis. These analyses indicated that, in Mtx-5011-256 mosquito cells, dhfr genes occur in at least two types of amplicon. The predominant Type I amplicon measures at least 215 kb and contains most of the dhfr genes. In addition, a small proportion of dhfr genes reside in a Type II amplicon, which is arranged in head-to-tail tandem repeats measuring 162 kb. Both amplicons share at least 70 kb of DNA sequence at their 5' ends. Approximately 20 fragments containing repeated sequence elements have been identified in the cloned amplicon DNA. Hybridization of amplicon DNA fragments containing repeated sequences to genomic DNA detected polymorphisms between wild type and methotrexate-resistant cells, suggesting that recombination may generate the divergence observed at the 3'-ends of Type I and Type II amplicons. This first detailed analysis of an insect dhfr amplicon provides an essential basis for ongoing investigation of repeated sequences, transcribed units and replication origins within the amplicon DNA.

Inverted repeats, stem-loops, and cruciforms: significance for initiation of DNA replication

Inverted repeats occur nonrandomly in the DNA of most organisms. Stem-loops and cruciforms can form from inverted repeats. Such structures have been detected in pro- and eukaryotes. They may affect the supercoiling degree of the DNA, the positioning of nucleosomes, the formation of other secondary structures of DNA, or directly interact with proteins. Inverted repeats, stem-loops, and cruciforms are present at the replication origins of phage, plasmids, mitochondria, eukaryotic viruses, and mammalian cells. Experiments with anti-cruciform antibodies suggest that formation and stabilization of cruciforms at particular mammalian origins may be associated with initiation of DNA replication. Many proteins have been shown to interact with cruciforms, recognizing features like DNA crossovers, four-way junctions, and curved/bent DNA of specific angles. A human cruciform binding protein (CBP) displays a novel type of interaction with cruciforms and may be linked to initiation of DNA replication.

Decreased rates of replicon initiation in mammalian cells

We have designed an assay to measure the rate of initiation of DNA synthesis in Friend erythroleukemia cells and have shown that this parameter is reduced by gamma-radiation and treatment with 4'-demethyl-epipodophyllotoxin-9-(4,6-O-ethylene-beta-D-glucopyranoside) (VP-16). It is concluded, that double-strand breaks in DNA are the immediate cause for this effect. The decrease in the rate of replicon initiation is affected differently by different agents such as cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II), cycloheximide, staurosporine, and 3-aminobenzamide. The analysis of these results indicates that the observed partial decrease of the rate of DNA initiation is most probably transmitted from the site of damage to the initiation site by one or more phosphorylation/dephosphorylation steps. It does not require de novo synthesis of protein factors, but is probably dependent on poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of chromatin at the site of DNA breaks.

Mapping of replication initiation sites in the mouse ribosomal gene cluster

We have used nascent strand determination analysis to map start sites of DNA replication in the mouse ribosomal gene cluster in which individual copies of the ribosomal genes are separated by intergenic spacer regions. One origin of bidirectional replication (OBR) was localized within a 3 kb region centered about 1.6 kb upstream of the rDNA transcription start site. At least one additional initiation site is situated near the 3' end of the transcription unit. Adjacent to the OBR at the transcription start site are located two amplification-promoting sequences, i.e., APS1 and APS2. Nuclease-hypersensitive sites were identified in both of the two APSs as well as in the OBR region, thus indicating that these sequences have an altered chromatin structure. In the OBR an intrinsically bent region, a purine-rich element and other prospective initiation zone components are found.

Common structural features of replication origins in all life forms

Origins of replication (ORIs) among prokaryotes, viruses, and multicellular organisms appear to possess simple tri-, tetra-, or higher dispersed repetitions of nucleotides, AT tracts, inverted repeats, one to four binding sites of an initiator protein, intrinsically curved DNA, DNase I-hypersensitive sites, a distinct pattern of DNA methylation, and binding sites for transcription factors. Eukaryotic ORIs are sequestered on the nuclear matrix; this attachment is supposed to facilitate execution of their activation/deactivation programs during development. Furthermore, ORIs fall into various classes with respect to their sequence complexity: those enriched in AT tracts, those with GA- and CT-rich tracts, a smaller class of GC-rich ORIs, and a major class composed of mixed motifs yet containing distinct AT and polypurine or GC stretches. Multimers of an initiator protein in prokaryotes and viruses that might have evolved into a multiprotein replication initiation complex in multicellular organisms bind to the core ORI, causing a structural distortion to the DNA which is transferred to the AT tract flanking the initiator protein site; single-stranded DNA-binding proteins then interact with the melted AT tract as well as with the DNA polymerase alpha-primase complex in animal viruses and mammalian cells, causing initiation in DNA replication. ORIs in mammalian cells seem to colocalize with matrix-attached regions and are proposed to become DNase I-hypersensitive during their activation.

Mapping the sites of initiation of DNA replication in rat and human rRNA genes

To study the organization of DNA replication in mammalian rRNA genes, the sites of initiation of DNA synthesis in rat and human rRNA genes were mapped by two independent techniques. In rat cells the growth of the nascent DNA chains was blocked by Trioxsalen cross-links introduced in vivo. The fraction of "restricted" nascent DNA chains labeled in vivo was isolated, and the abundance in this fraction of cloned ribosomal DNA sequences was determined by hybridization. In the experiments with human cells, the nascent DNA chains were allowed to grow unrestricted for a certain period of time and the movement of the replication forks along the rRNA genes was followed by hybridization of cloned ribosomal DNA sequences to the "unrestricted" nascent DNA fragments fractionated according to size. The results show that in both rRNA genes there are two well defined regions of initiation of DNA synthesis. The first one is located upstream of the transcription units and the second one is located at the 3'-end of the coding regions of the ribosomal DNA repeats.

Clusters of modular regulatory elements at DNA replication origins

To study the specificity of eukaryotic origins of replication (ori), we have isolated a fraction of mouse DNA enriched in replication initiation sequences (RIS), and cloned and characterised some of these RIS. The sequences of three RIS were analysed for the presence of sequence elements common to other known eukaryotic ori. It was found that the three RIS were A+T rich and contained a number of sequence elements that may function in the initiation of DNA replication. The data support the idea that mammalian ori are organised from modular sequence elements.

Mimosine arrests DNA synthesis at replication forks by inhibiting deoxyribonucleotide metabolism

Mimosine has been reported to specifically prevent initiation of DNA replication in the chromosomes of mammalian nuclei. To test this hypothesis, the effects of mimosine were examined in several DNA replication systems and compared with the effects of aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of replicative DNA polymerases. Our results demonstrated that mimosine inhibits DNA synthesis in mitochondrial, nuclear, and simian virus 40 (SV40) genomes to a similar extent. Furthermore, mimosine and aphidicolin were indistinguishable in their ability to arrest SV40 replication forks and mammalian nuclear chromosomal replication forks. In contrast to aphidicolin, mimosine did not inhibit DNA replication in lysates of mammalian cells supplied with exogenous deoxyribonucleotide triphosphate precursors for DNA synthesis. Mimosine also had no effect on initiation or elongation of DNA replication in Xenopus eggs or egg extracts containing high levels of deoxyribonucleotide triphosphates. In parallel with its inhibitory effect on DNA synthesis in mammalian cells, mimosine altered deoxyribonucleotide triphosphate pools in a manner similar to that reported for another DNA replication inhibitor that affects deoxyribonucleotide metabolism, hydroxyurea. Taken together, these results show that mimosine inhibits DNA synthesis at the level of elongation of nascent chains by altering deoxyribonucleotide metabolism.

Autonomous replication in vivo and in vitro of clones spanning the region of the DHFR origin of bidirectional replication (ori beta)

Plasmids containing the origin of bidirectional replication (ori beta) of the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase-encoding gene (DHFR) were tested for autonomous replication in vivo and in vitro. The results show that plasmids pX24 and pneoS13, that contain a 4.8- and a 11.5-kb fragment, respectively, spanning the ori beta region, are able to replicate autonomously in human cells and in a cell-free system that uses human cell extracts. Another plasmid, pX14, containing a 4.8-kb fragment that is immediately adjacent to the ori beta region, also replicated in these two assays.

Structural homologies and functional similarities between mammalian origins of replication and amplification promoting sequences

MuNTS2, a 423 bp sequence isolated from the non-transcribed spacer of murine rDNA stimulates the amplification of cis-linked plasmid DNA in mouse cells under selective conditions. Here we demonstrate that a 180 bp subdomain of muNTS2 is highly homologous (approximately 70%) to three domains of the first well-characterized origin of replication of mammalian chromosomes, i.e. the origin of bidirectional replication (OBR) of the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) locus in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. When subcloned, the 180 bp homology region of muNTS2 was revealed to be essential for the amplification promoting activity of muNTS2. Fragments of the initiation zone of DNA replication from the DHFR locus of hamster cells containing the domains of homology to the mouse muNTS2 element proved also to promote DNA amplification. Thus, the screening system for amplification promoting elements turned out to detect an origin of bidirectional replication.

The quest for a human ori

Attempts at identifying DNA replication origins in human cells have been performed with a variety of molecular genetic and biochemical approaches, with often controversial results. The combination of bromodeoxyuridine labelling, immunopurification of newly synthesized labelled DNA, measurement of the relative abundance of markers in this DNA by quantitative competitive PCR, has allowed the identification within 450 bp of the start-site of DNA replication located at the human lamin B2 gene. The origin is located near the non-transcribed spacer between two highly transcribed genes and shows evidence of a number of specific protein-DNA interactions, the most prominent of which disappears when the cells are differentiated into a non-proliferating state.

Searching for replication origins in mammalian DNA

The attempts at identifying precise replication origins (ori) in mammalian DNA have been pursued mainly through physico-chemical and biochemical approaches, in view of the essential failure of the search for autonomously replicating sequences in cultured cells. These approaches involve the mapping of short stretches of nascent DNA, the identification of the regions where either leading or lagging strands switch polarity, or the localization of replication intermediates by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Due to the complexity of animal cell genomes, most of these studies have been performed on amplified domains and with the use of synchronization procedures. The results obtained have been controversial. In order to avoid the use of experimental procedures potentially affecting the physiological mechanism of DNA replication, we have developed a method for the localization of ori in single-copy loci in exponentially growing cells. This method entails the absolute quantification of the abundance of selected DNA fragments along a genomic region within samples of newly synthesized DNA by competitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR); the latter is immune to all the uncontrollable variables which severely affect the reproducibility of conventional PCR. The application of this method to SV40 ori-driven plasmid replication precisely identifies the known ori localization. Using the same approach, we have mapped an ori for bi-directional DNA replication in a 13.7-kb locus of human chromosome 19 encoding lamin B2.

Replication structure of the human beta-globin gene domain

The animal cell genome is organized into a series of replicons with an average size of 50-300 kilobases; each of these units is characterized by its own origin of replication which serves as the point of initiation for DNA synthesis. In animal viruses, origin usage can be regulated by cis-acting elements, and in some cases, replication may be cell-type specific. Little is known, however, about the organization and control of endogenous tissue-specific gene replication. To understand this process, we have used a replication direction assay to examine DNA fragments covering more than 200 kilobases of the human beta-like globin domain, and have identified a single bidirectional origin located upstream of the beta-globin itself. This locus is used to initiate DNA synthesis in expressing cells, where the globin domain replicates early, and in non-expressing cells, which are characterized by late replication of the same region. Deletion of this origin sequence, as occurs in the haemoglobin Lepore syndrome, cancels bidirectional DNA synthesis at this site and leads to a striking reversal of replication direction upstream to the locus. This represents the first genetic proof of the existence of specific, discrete origins of replication in animal cells.

Analysis of soybean chloroplast DNA replication by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Chloroplast DNA replication was studied in the green, autotrophic suspension culture line SB-1 of Glycine max. Three regions (restriction fragments Sac I 14.5, Pvu II 4.1 and Pvu II 14.8) on the plastome were identified that displayed significantly higher template activity in in vitro DNA replication assays than all other cloned restriction fragments of the organelle genome, suggesting that these clones contain sequences that are able to direct initiation of DNA replication in vitro. In order to confirm that the potential in vitro origin sites are functional in vivo as well, replication intermediates were analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis using cloned restriction fragments as probes. The two Pvu II fragments that supported deoxynucleotide incorporation in vitro apparently do not contain a functional in vivo replication origin since replication intermediates from these areas of the plastome represent only fork structures. The Sac I 14.5 chloroplast DNA fragment, on the other hand, showed intermediates consistent with a replication bubble originating within its borders, which is indicative of an active in vivo origin. Closer examination of cloned Sac I 14.5 sub-fragments confirmed high template activity in vitro for two, S/B 5 and S/B 3, which also seem to contain origin sites utilized in vivo as determined by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The types of replication intermediate patterns obtained for these sub-fragments are consistent with the double D-loop model for chloroplast DNA replication with both origins being located in the large unique region of the plastome [17, 18]. This is the first report of a chloroplast DNA replication origin in higher plants that has been directly tested for in vivo function.

DNase-sensitive chromatin structure near a chromosomal origin of bidirectional replication of the avian alpha-globin locus

We used an in vitro nuclear run-off replication assay to analyze the direction of replication in a 13-kb region 5' to the avian alpha-globin genes. Previous work from this laboratory suggested that the alpha-globin genes of 5-day chick red blood cells and avian MSB cells replicate in vivo in the transcriptional direction, possibly from a chromosomal origin near the alpha pi-globin gene. Here we extend those studies by showing that replication forks move divergently from an 8-kb region of alpha-globin 5'-flanking DNA. One potential zone for the initiation of bidirectional replication was located approximately 2.5 kb 5' to the alpha pi-globin gene in both of these cell types. Additionally, a barrier to replication fork movement, which may be located in a second origin zone, was found approximately 5 kb farther upstream. Both in 5-day RBCs, where the alpha-globin genes are expressed, and in MSB cells where they are not expressed, DNase I hypersensitive structures were found approximately 5 kb 5' to the alpha pi-globin gene, in the putative replication initiation domain. Another DNase I hypersensitive site was confirmed to exist in 5-day RBC nuclei upstream of the transcribed alpha pi-globin gene. These results suggest that replication of the alpha-globin genes initiates in the nearby 5'-flanking DNA of this locus in a region marked by distinct chromatin structures.

Initiation of replication in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase domain

Two-dimensional (2-D) gel analysis of replication intermediates in the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase domain has suggested that nascent chains can initiate at any of a large number of sites scattered throughout a approximately 50 kb "initiation locus" (although the level of initiation detected at any given site within this region was relatively low). This result contrasts markedly with data from an in vitro strand switching assay suggesting that > 80% of initiations occur within a single 500 bp fragment lying within the initiation locus. In an effort to reconcile these two disparate views of the initiation reaction, we have questioned the validity of our 2-D gel data in several ways. We show here that: 1) the number of replication bubbles detected in the DHFR locus in the early S period is markedly increased when the cells are released from a synchronizing agent that inhibits initiation per se, rather than from aphidicolin, which is a chain elongation inhibitor; 2) initiation in the DHFR domain occurs only during the first 90 min of the S period, as would be expected of an early-firing origin; 3) a pulse of 3H-thymidine moves through the structures observed on 2-D gels with the kinetics expected of bonafide replication intermediates; and 4) preparations of replication intermediates that are subsequently analyzed on 2-D gels appear, by electron microscopy, to represent the typical theta structures and single-forked molecules expected of bidirectional origins of replication; no unusual structures (e.g., microbubbles) were seen.

Organization of specific DNA sequence elements in the region of the replication origin and matrix attachment site in the chicken alpha-globin gene domain

The distribution of specific DNA sequence elements in a 2.9 kb HindIII fragment of chicken DNA containing the replication origin and the upstream matrix attachment site (MAR) of the alpha-globin gene domain was investigated. The fragment was shown to contain a CR1-type repetitive element and two stably bent DNA sequences. One of them colocalizes with the previously described MAR element and with the recognition site for a proliferating-cell-specific, DNA-binding protein. The melting pattern of a set of subfragments of the region proved to be non random. No correlation between the distribution of readily melting sequences and bent DNA was found. The possible importance of curved, low-melting and repetitive DNA sequences for the organization of the upstream boundary of the alpha-globin gene domain and the function of the replication origin is discussed.

Mammalian origins of replication

It has been almost twenty-five years since Huberman and Riggs first showed that there are multiple bidirectional origins of replication scattered at approximately 100 kb intervals along mammalian chromosomal fibers. Since that time, every conceivable physical property unique to replicating DNA has been taken advantage of to determine whether origins of replication are defined sequence elements, as they are in microorganisms. The most thoroughly studied mammalian locus to date is the dihydrofolate reductase domain of Chinese hamster cells, which will be used as a model to discuss the various methods of investigation. While several laboratories agree on the rough location of the 'initiation locus' in this large chromosomal domain, different experimental approaches paint different pictures of the mechanism by which initiation occurs. However, a variety of new techniques and synchronizing agents promises to clarify the picture for this particular locus, and to provide the means for identifying and isolating other origins of replication for comparison.

Localization and DNA sequence of a replication origin in the rhodopsin gene locus of Chinese hamster cells

A chromosomal origin of DNA replication has been localized within the single-copy rhodopsin gene locus in Chinese hamster (line CHO) cells using two methods. In the first method, single-copy segments were identified at 3 to 15 kb intervals within approximately 75 kb (kb = 10(3) bases) of cloned genomic DNA containing the early-replicating rhodopsin gene near its middle. The cloned single-copy segments were then used as hybridization probes to quantify the replication of their corresponding genomic segments as synchronized cells progressed into S phase. In the second method, genomic DNA synthesized in vivo or in permeabilized early S phase cells was hybridized with slot-blots of the cloned single-copy DNA segments to identify the earliest replicating part of the 75 kb mapped region. The first method indicates that the earliest replicating DNA is located within a 10 kb region beginning 4 kb upstream from and extending 1 kb beyond the rhodopsin gene. The second method confirms the location in the vicinity of the rhodopsin gene and indicates that the earliest replicating region is located within or very near the 4.5 kb rhodopsin gene itself. An extended region of 12 kb that encompasses the entire early-replicating region has been sequenced for analysis and comparison with currently characterized origin regions associated with the CHO dihydrofolate reductase (dhfr) and human c-myc genes. There are several sequence similarities between the dhfr rhodopsin origin regions, including common transcription promoter consensus sequences, rodent Alu repeats with their 3'-A+T rich flanking sequences, A+T-rich yeast ARS and Drosophila SAR consensus sequences, and simple (GA)n repeats, but there are no extended regions of direct similarity. The rhodopsin gene locus is the second sequenced CHO origin region.

Guide to identification of origins of DNA replication in eukaryotic cell chromosomes

Several experimental approaches for identification of origins of DNA replication have been developed recently that allow, for the first time, unique initiation sites in mammalian chromosomes to be mapped at single-copy loci. A brief description of the rationale, advantages, and limitations has been provided for each approach, as well as information that can help the reader choose the method(s) most suitable for a particular system. The various methods are divided into three groups: (1) analysis of nascent DNA strands, (2) analysis of DNA structures, and (3) analysis of origin activity (i.e., ability to support autonomous replication). It is hoped that this information will serve as a practical guide for identifying new origins of replication.

DNA cruciforms and the nuclear supporting structure

Cruciforms have been suggested as potential recognition structures at or near origins of DNA replication in eukaryotic cells. Monoclonal antibodies with structural specificity for DNA cruciforms have been produced (Frappier et al. J. Mol. Biol. 193, 751, 1987). The effect of these antibodies, when introduced into permeabilized cells, was to increase overall DNA synthesis and relative copy number of genes (Zannis-Hadjopoulos et al. EMBO J. 7, 1837, 1988); this was interpreted to be a consequence of antibody stabilization of the cruciforms located at or near replication origins resulting in multiple initiations of DNA replication at a single site. Fluorescent labeling of nuclei with anti-cruciform antibodies produces a nonuniform pattern of fluorescence in cells arrested at the G1/S boundary which then changes with progression through S-phase (Ward et al. Exp. Cell Res. 188, 235, 1990). In order to determine the relationship of cruciform distribution in DNA with the nuclear matrix/chromosomal scaffold, we assessed the susceptibility of DNA containing cruciforms to digestion with DNase I. The majority of the cruciforms detectable at G1/S and throughout the nucleus are readily digested by DNase, suggesting that cruciform structures may not be intimately associated with matrix proteins. The fraction that is resistant to DNase I appears associated with nuclear membrane and the nucleolus. No cruciforms could be detected in metaphase chromosomes; cruciforms either are not present or are inaccessible--buried in the scaffold. The absence of cruciforms from metaphase chromosomes would be consistent with the viewpoint that the cruciform in vivo is a transient structure dependent upon and interacting with proteins essential for replication or transcription.

Identification of p53 as a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein

The tumor-suppressor gene p53 is altered by missense mutation in numerous human malignancies. However, the biochemical properties of p53 and the effect of mutation on these properties are unclear. A human DNA sequence was identified that binds specifically to wild-type human p53 protein in vitro. As few as 33 base pairs were sufficient to confer specific binding. Certain guanines within this 33-base pair region were critical, as methylation of these guanines or their substitution with thymine-abrogated binding. Human p53 proteins containing either of two missense mutations commonly found in human tumors were unable to bind significantly to this sequence. These data suggest that a function of p53 may be mediated by its ability to bind to specific DNA sequences in the human genome, and that this activity is altered by mutations that occur in human tumors.

Origins of replication: timing and chromosomal position

Several new methods have been used to localize replication initiation sites in mammalian chromosomes. The results of these studies argue strongly for the presence of defined sequence elements that function much like the origins in the genomes of simple microorganisms. However, relatively disparate results from in vivo and in vitro studies suggest that initiation reactions in mammalian chromosomes may have unique features, possibly related to a more complicated chromosomal architecture.

Classes of autonomously replicating sequences are found among early-replicating monkey DNA

Thirteen new independent clones of origin-enriched sequences (ors) that are capable of autonomous replication have been identified from a library of 100 ors i clones that had been previously isolated from early replicating monkey (CV-1) DNA. Autonomous replication was assayed by transient episomal replication in transfected HeLa cells; ors-plasmid DNA was isolated at various times after transfection and screened by the DpnI resistance assay and the bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) substitution assay to differentiate between input and newly replicated DNA. Four of the autonomously replicating clones were identified by screening the ors-library with probes of ors 3, 8, 9 and 12, previously shown to be capable of autonomous replication (Frappier and Zannis-Hadjopoulos, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA (1987) 84, 6668-6672). The other nine functional ors clones were identified among 18 randomly chosen ones, which were similarly screened for autonomous replication. Nucleotide sequence analyses of 11 of the newly identified functional ors plasmids revealed, in most of them, features similar to those present in other viral or eukaryotic replication origins, notably the presence of AT-rich regions and inverted repeats. Pairwise comparisons between the newly identified ors showed no extensive sequence homologies, other than the presence of the alpha-satellite repetitive sequence family in three ors and of the repetitive Alu sequence family in one ors. The results suggest that there exist different classes of mammalian replication origin, highly or moderately repetitive and unique, and that their activation is most probably dependent on the presence of structural determinants rather than on a particular sequence.

Mimosine reversibly arrests cell cycle progression at the G1-S phase border

It has previously been demonstrated that the compound mimosine inhibits cell cycle traverse in late G1 phase prior to the onset of DNA synthesis (Hoffman BD, Hanauske-Abel HM, Flint A, Lalande M: Cytometry 12:26-32, 1991; Lalande M: Exp Cell Res 186:332-339, 1990). These results were obtained by using flow cytometric analysis of DNA content to compare the effects of mimosine on cell cycle traverse with those of aphidicolin, an inhibitor of DNA polymerase alpha activity. We have now measured the incorporation of bromodeoxyuridine into lymphoblastoid cells by flow cytometry to determine precisely where the two inhibitors act relative to the initiation of DNA synthesis. It is demonstrated here that mimosine arrests cell cycle progression at the G1-S phase border. The onset of DNA replication occurs within 15 min of releasing the cells from the mimosine block. In contrast, treatment with aphidicolin results in the accumulation of cells in early S phase. These results indicate that mimosine is a suitable compound for affecting the synchronous release of cells from G1 into S phase and for analyzing the biochemical events associated with this cell cycle phase transition.

A new class of reversible cell cycle inhibitors

The effects of three compounds on the cell cycle of HL-60 promyeloid leukemia cells has been examined. Ciclopirox olamine, an antifungal agent, and the compound Hoechst 768159 reversibly block the cell cycle at a point occurring roughly 1 h before the arrest mediated by aphidicolin, an inhibitor of DNA polymerase alpha activity, which acts in early S phase. Similar results are also obtained with the compound mimosine, a plant amino acid. Based on these data, it is concluded that all three agents inhibit cell cycle traverse at or very near the G1/S phase boundary and identify a previously undefined reversible cell cycle arrest point.

Identification of an origin of bidirectional DNA replication in mammalian chromosomes

Mechanistically, an origin of bidirectional DNA replication (OBR) can be defined by the transition from discontinuous to continuous DNA synthesis that must occur on each template strand at the site where replication forks originate. This results from synthesis of Okazaki fragments predominantly on the retrograde arms of forks. We have identified these transitions at a specific site within a 0.45 kb sequence approximately 17 kb downstream from the 3' end of the dihydrofolate reductase gene in Chinese hamster ovary chromosomes. At least 80% of the replication forks in a 27 kb region emanated from this OBR. Thus, initiation of DNA replication in mammalian chromosomes uses the same replication fork mechanism previously described in a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes, suggesting that mammalian chromosomes also utilize specific cis-acting sequences as origins of DNA replication.

Repetitive sequence elements in an initiation locus of the amplified dihydrofolate reductase domain in CHO cells

We have previously demonstrated that one of the replication initiation loci in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of Chinese hamster cells contains a repeated sequence that is enriched in the early-replicating fraction of the Chinese hamster genome. Here we present the sequence of the initiation locus, identify the relevant repeated element, and show that, while this element is enriched in early-replicating DNA, its synthesis is not confined to early S.

Replication initiates in a broad zone in the amplified CHO dihydrofolate reductase domain

We have used two complementary two-dimensional gel electrophoretic methods to localize replication inititation sites and to determine replication fork direction in the amplified 240 kb dihydrofolate reductase domain of the methotrexate-resistant CHO cell line CHOC 400. Surprisingly, our analysis indicates that replication begins at many sites in several restriction fragments distributed throughout a previously defined 28 kb initiation locus, including a fragment containing a matrix attachment region. Initiation sites were not detected in regions lying upstream or downstream of this locus. Our results suggest that initiation reactions in mammalian chromosomal origins may be more complex than in the origins of simple microorganisms.