Hemispherectomy--a modification

Trends and Most-Cited Articles on Hemispheric Surgery: A Bibliometric Analysis and Historical Review

INTRODUCTION

Hemispheric surgery is a multistep, highly effective, and radical surgical procedure in the treatment of drug-resistant epilepsy due to extensive unilateral hemispheric disease. The procedure ranges from a resective procedure (hemispherectomy) to disconnection (hemispherotomy) and has developed substantially over the last century from morbid to elegant, minimally invasive, and routinely practiced procedures. Bearing in mind the numerous articles that have been published on hemispherectomy and hemispherotomy, we aimed to highlight the top 100 cited and impactful articles to create familiarity with the topic. We anticipate that this will be a helpful guide for clinicians and academics navigating the literature on this subject.

METHODS

A Scopus title-based search on the top 100 most-cited articles on "hemispherectomy" and "hemispherotomy" was performed in September 2023 with no restrictions. The top 100 most-cited articles were then retrieved. The article title, first author, first author's specialty, country of origin, first author's institution at the time of publication, journal of publication, year of publication, citation count, and citations per year were collected. The Google Scholar database citation count for each paper was added for correlation and comprehensive coverage.

RESULTS

The top 100 most-cited articles were cited 92 times per paper on average. The publication dates ranged from 1949 to 2016. The most frequently cited article "Clinical outcomes of hemispherectomy for epilepsy in childhood and adolescence" with 307 citations was published by A.M. Devlin et al. (2003) in the journal Brain. The USA was the highest publishing country (41 articles). The highest-publishing journal was Neurology. The most prolific first authors were A. Smith, J. Schramm, and J. Villemure, each with four publications. The institution with the most contributions was McGill University and its affiliated Health Centers, with nine publications in total. Neurosurgery was the most common specialty among the first authors. Most of the included studies were cohort studies or case series.

CONCLUSION

We identified the top 100 cited articles on hemispherectomy and hemispherotomy using the Scopus database and supplemented our results with Google Scholar. We highlighted the most prominent authors, institutions, countries, journals, and study designs and illuminated the historical development of hemispherectomy and hemispherotomy procedures, in addition to landmark and currently trending papers.

Hemimegalencephaly: A Systematic Comparison of Functional and Anatomic Hemispherectomy for Drug-Resistant Epilepsy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Hemimegalencephaly (HME) is a rare diffuse malformation of cortical development characterized by unihemispheric hypertrophy, drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE), hemiparesis, and developmental delay. Definitive treatment for HME-related DRE is hemispheric surgery through either anatomic (AH) or functional hemispherectomy (FH). This individual patient data meta-analysis assessed seizure outcomes of AH and FH for HME with pharmacoresistant epilepsy, predictors of Engel I, and efficacy of different FH approaches.

METHODS

PubMed, Web of Science, and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched from inception to Jan 13th, 2023, for primary literature reporting seizure outcomes in >3 patients with HME receiving AH or FH. Demographics, neurophysiology findings, and Engel outcome at the last follow-up were extracted. Postsurgical seizure outcomes were compared through 2-tailed t -test and Fisher exact test. Univariate and multivariate Cox regression analyses were performed to identify independent predictors of Engel I outcome.

RESULTS

Data from 145 patients were extracted from 26 studies, of which 89 underwent FH (22 vertical, 33 lateral), 47 underwent AH, and 9 received an unspecified hemispherectomy with a median last follow-up of 44.0 months (FH cohort) and 45.0 months (AH cohort). Cohorts were similar in preoperative characteristics and at the last follow-up; 77% (n = 66) of the FH cohort and 81% (n = 38) and of the AH cohort were Engel I. On multivariate analysis, only the presence of bilateral ictal electroencephalography abnormalities (hazard ratio = 11.5; P = .002) was significantly associated with faster time-to-seizure recurrence. A number-needed-to-treat analysis to prevent 1 additional case of posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus reveals that FH, compared with AH, was 3. There was no statistical significance for any differences in time-to-seizure recurrence between lateral and vertical FH approaches (hazard ratio = 2.59; P = .101).

CONCLUSION

We show that hemispheric surgery is a highly effective treatment for HME-related DRE. Unilateral ictal electroencephalography changes and using the FH approach as initial surgical management may result in better outcomes due to significantly lower posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus probability. However, larger HME registries are needed to further delineate the predictors of seizure outcomes.

Functional hemispheric disconnection procedures for chronic epilepsy: history, indications, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe. A consensus statement on behalf of the EANS functional neurosurgery section

Introduction

The surgical procedure for severe, drug-resistant, unilateral hemispheric epilepsy is challenging. Over the last decades the surgical landscape for hemispheric disconnection procedures changed from anatomical hemispherectomy to functional hemispherotomy with a reduction of complications and stable good seizure outcome. Here, a task force of European epilepsy surgeons prepared, on behalf of the EANS Section for Functional Neurosurgery, a consensus statement on different aspects of the hemispheric disconnection procedure.

Research question

To determine history, indication, timing, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe for hemispheric disconnection procedures in drug-resistant epilepsy.

Material and methods

Relevant literature on the topic was collected by a literature search based on the PRISMA 2020 guidelines.

Results

A comprehensive overview on the historical development of hemispheric disconnection procedures for epilepsy is presented, while discussing indications, timing, surgical techniques and complications. Current practice for this procedure in European epilepsy surgery centers is provided. At present, our knowledge of long-term seizure outcomes primarily stems from open surgical disconnection procedures. Although minimal invasive surgical techniques in epilepsy are rapidly developing and reported in case reports or small case series, long-term seizure outcome remain uncertain and needs to be reported.

Discussion and conclusion

This is the first paper presenting a European consensus statement regarding history, indications, techniques and complications of hemispheric disconnection procedures for different causes of chronic, drug-resistant epilepsy. Furthermore, it serves as the pioneering document to report a comprehensive overview of the current surgical practices regarding this type of surgery employed in renowned epilepsy surgery centers across Europe.

Midline Brain Shift After Hemispheric Surgery: Natural History, Clinical Significance, and Association With Cerebrospinal Fluid Diversion

BACKGROUND

Hemispherectomy and its modern variants are effective surgical treatments for medically intractable unihemispheric epilepsy. Although some complications such as posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus are well documented, midline brain shift (MLBS) after hemispheric surgery has only been described anecdotally and never formally studied.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the natural history and clinical relevance of MLBS and determine whether cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) shunting of the ipsilateral surgical cavity exacerbates MLBS posthemispheric surgery.

METHODS

A retrospective review of consecutive pediatric patients who underwent hemispheric surgery for intractable epilepsy and at least 6 months of follow-up at UCLA between 1994 and 2018 was performed. Patients were grouped by MLBS severity, shunt placement, valve type, and valve opening pressure (VOP). MLBS was evaluated using the paired samples t-test and analysis of covariance adjusting for follow-up time and baseline postoperative MLBS.

RESULTS

Seventy patients were analyzed, of which 23 (33%) required CSF shunt placement in the ipsilateral surgical cavity for posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus. MLBS increased between first and last follow-up for nonshunted (5.3 ± 4.9-9.7 ± 6.6 mm, P < .001) and shunted (6.6 ± 3.5-16.3 ± 9.4 mm, P < .001) patients. MLBS progression was greater in shunted patients (P = .001). Shunts with higher VOPs did not increase MLBS relative to nonshunted patients (P = .834), whereas MLBS increased with lower VOPs (P = .001). Severe MLBS was associated with debilitating headaches (P = .048).

CONCLUSION

Patients undergoing hemispheric surgery often develop postoperative MLBS, ie, exacerbated by CSF shunting of the ipsilateral surgical cavity, specifically when using lower VOP settings. MLBS exacerbation may be related to overshunting. Severe MLBS is associated with debilitating headaches.

Modified hemispherectomy for infantile hemiparesis and epilepsy

Objective

To investigate the effect and medical imaging of modified hemispherectomy on patients with infantile hemiparesis and medically refractory epilepsy.

Patients and methods

Forty-three patients with infantile hemiparesis and refractory epilepsy who underwent hemispherectomy were enrolled. The treatment effect and medical imaging were analyzed.

Results

Anatomical hemispherectomy was successfully performed in all patients (100%). In all patients, the muscular tension decreased and the contracted limbs relaxed. In the pathological examination of the resected brain tissue, secondary cicatricial gyri with concomitant cortical dysplasia was present in 36 cases and polycerebellar gyrus malformation and porencephalia in the other 7 cases. Followed up for 7-15 years (mean 11.3), all patients were alive without a long-term sequela. Epilepsy was satisfactorily controlled, with complete seizure relief in 39 cases (91%) classified as Engel I and basic control in the other 4 (9%) defined as Engel II. The posthemispherectomy medical imaging demonstrated that the intracranial space on the operative side shrank, and the healthy cerebral hemisphere shifted markedly toward the hemispherectomy side, with expanded lateral ventricle on the healthy side and thickened skull and enlarged frontal sinus on the operative side. After 4-5 years, the intracranial space on the operative side disappeared in 75% of the patients, demonstrating enlarged cerebral peduncle on the healthy side.

Conclusion

Further modified hemispherectomy in patients with infantile hemiparesis and medically refractory epilepsy demonstrated markedly ameliorated effects on epilepsy control and the prevention of superficial cerebral hemosiderosis in the long-term follow-up.

Hemispherotomy for Epilepsy: The Procedure Evolution and Outcome

Hemispherectomy is a unique epilepsy surgery procedure that has undergone significant modification and evolution since Dandy's early description. This procedure is mainly indicated to treat early childhood and infancy medically intractable epilepsy. Various epileptic syndromes have been treated with this procedure, including hemimegalencephaly (HME), Rasmussen's encephalitis, Sturge-Weber syndrome (SWS), perinatal stroke, and hemispheric cortical dysplasia. In terms of seizure reduction, hemispherectomy remains one of the most successful epilepsy surgery procedures. The modification of this procedure over many years has resulted in lower mortality and morbidity rates. HME might increase morbidity and lower the success rate. Future studies should identify the predictors of outcomes based on the pathology and the type of hemispherectomy. Here, based on a literature review, we discuss the evolution of hemispherectomy techniques and their outcomes and complications.

Anatomical hemispherectomy revisited-outcome, blood loss, hydrocephalus, and absence of chronic hemosiderosis

PURPOSE

To evaluate microsurgical trans-sylvian trans-ventricular anatomical hemispherectomy with regard to seizure outcome, risk of hydrocephalus, blood loss, and risk of chronic hemosiderosis in patients with intractable seizures selected for surgery using current preoperative assessment techniques.

METHODS

Out of 86 patients who underwent hemispherectomy between February 2000 and April 2019, by a single surgeon, at a tertiary care referral center, 77 patients (ages 0.2-20 years; 40 females) who had an anatomical hemispherectomy were analyzed. Five of these were 'palliative' surgeries. One-stage anatomical hemispherectomy was performed in 55 children, two-stage anatomical hemispherectomy after extraoperative intracranial monitoring in 16, and six hemispherectomies were done following failed previous resection. Mean follow-up duration was 5.7 years (range 1-16.84 years). Forty-six patients had postoperative MRI scans.

RESULTS

Ninety percent of children with non-palliative hemispherectomy achieved ILAE Class-1 outcome. Twenty-seven patients were no longer taking anticonvulsant medications. Surgical failures (n = 4) included one patient with previous meningoencephalitis, one with anti-GAD antibody encephalitis, one with idiopathic neonatal thalamic hemorrhage, and one with extensive tuberous sclerosis. There were no failures among patients with malformations of cortical development. Estimated average blood loss during surgery was 387 ml. Ten (21%) children developed hydrocephalus and required a shunt following one-stage hemispherectomy, whereas 10 (50%) patients developed hydrocephalus among those who had extraoperative intracranial monitoring. Only 20% of the shunts malfunctioned in the first year. Early malfunctions were related to the valve and later to fracture disconnection of the shunt. One patent had a traumatic subdural hematoma. None of the patients developed clinical signs of chronic 'superficial cerebral hemosiderosis' nor was there evidence of radiologically persistent chronic hemosiderosis in patients who had postoperative MRI imaging.

CONCLUSION

Surgical results of anatomical hemispherectomy are excellent in carefully selected cases. Post-operative complications of hydrocephalus and intraoperative blood loss are comparable to those reported for hemispheric disconnective surgery (hemispherotomy). The rate of shunt malfunction was less than that reported for patients with hydrocephalus of other etiologies Absence of chronic 'superficial hemosiderosis', even on long-term follow-up, suggests that anatomical hemispherectomy should be revisited as a viable option in patients with intractable seizures and altered anatomy such as in malformations of cortical development, a group that has a reported high rate of seizure recurrence related to incomplete disconnection following hemispheric disconnective surgery.

Case Report: Free Latissimus Dorsi Flap in Combination With Subdural Space Reduction for the Prevention of Recurrent Hemorrhage Following Hemispherectomy

BACKGROUND AND IMPORTANCE

Extensive cerebral resections for the treatment of epilepsy may result in a large intracranial dead space that is prone to recurrent hemorrhage, either due to mechanical dislodgement or the development of extensive subdural membranes. Several techniques have been proposed to decrease the risk of hemorrhage by either reducing or filling the remaining intracranial dead space.

CLINICAL PRESENTATION

We present a case of persistent hemorrhage following functional hemispherectomy in a patient with a large porencephalic cyst. A treatment strategy involving both subdural space reduction and cranial vault filling with a vascularized free latissimus dorsi flap is discussed.

CONCLUSION

Subdural space reduction and cranial vault filling with a vascularized free latissimus dorsi flap is a viable treatment alternative in patients with large areas of intracranial dead space.

Functional hemispherectomy is safe and effective in adult patients with epilepsy

INTRODUCTION

Functional hemispherectomy (FH) is a well-established therapeutic option for children with epilepsy with parenchymal damage confined to one hemisphere, yet its application in adults remains rare. The intention of our study was to investigate postoperative clinical and epileptological outcome in adults who received FH for intractable epilepsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 12 adult patients (18-56years) with intractable epilepsy due to unihemispheric pathology. All patients underwent FH. Postoperative neurological and cognitive outcome as well as seizure status were evaluated with a mean follow-up period of 4.9years.

RESULTS

Ten patients (83%) were seizure-free (Engel I), and two (17%) had recurrent seizures at last follow-up. Apart from one patient requiring operative revision for bone flap infection, no perioperative morbidity or mortality occurred. Postoperative functional assessment revealed deterioration of motor function in 7 patients, whereas 5 remained unchanged. Language was unchanged in 8 patients. The absence of background slowing in preoperative electroencephalogram (EEG) as well as ictal and interictal EEG patterns located ipsilateral to the side of surgery was associated with favorable seizure outcome.

CONCLUSION

Favorable seizure control and acceptable functional outcome can be achieved by FH in adults with intractable epilepsy. The risk of postoperative deficits is moderate and even older patients are able to manage postoperative motor impairment. Therefore, FH should be considered in case of unihemispheric lesions also in adults.

Vertical extraventricular functional hemispherotomy: a new variant for hemispheric disconnection. Technical notes and results in three patients

PURPOSE

Hemispherectomy and disconnective hemispherotomy are the most effective epilepsy surgical procedures for the treatment of epilepsy due to hemispheric pathologies such as Sturge-Weber syndrome, diffuse hemispheric cortical dysplasia, and posttraumatic and postischemic focal lesions. Disconnective hemispherotomy is nowadays preferred to reduce surgical morbidity in term of early and late complications (i.e., cerebral superficial hemosiderosis). Despite the number of existing technical variants conceived to further reduce the amount of brain tissue to be removed, postoperative hydrocephalus still persists and may account for an average incidence of 15-41% according to different series and reviews. A new variant of disconnective vertical hemispherotomy we termed vertical extraventricular parasagittal hemispherotomy is described aiming to further reduce the amount of removed brain tissue and so the risk of postoperative hydrocephalus in favor of a pure hemispheric disconnection.

METHODS

Three patients affected by drug-resistant epilepsy due to different hemispheric pathologies (posttraumatic epilepsy, Sturge-Weber syndrome, diffuse hemispheric cortical dysplasia) were considered to be candidates for vertical extraventricular parasagittal hemispherotomy disconnective based on presurgical evaluation protocol. The oldest patient was 15 years old, the two youngest were both 2 years old.

RESULTS

None of the patients experienced early and late surgical complications. After a mean follow-up of 36 months (range 12-60 months), two patients were seizure free, one relapsed seizures 18 months later. Postoperative hydrocephalus never occurred.

CONCLUSION

Vertical extraventricular parasagittal hemispherotomy may be an efficacious and less invasive technique as it consists in a pure disconnection of the hemisphere with less amount of brain tissue removed and a theoretical reduced risk of postoperative hydrocephalus.

Endoscopy-Assisted Interhemispheric Transcallosal Hemispherotomy

BACKGROUND:

Various hemispherotomy techniques have been developed to reduce complication rates and achieve the best possible seizure control.

OBJECTIVE:

To present a novel and minimally invasive endoscopy-assisted approach to perform this procedure.

METHODS:

Endoscopy-assisted interhemispheric transcallosal hemispherotomy was performed in 5 children (April 2013-June 2014). The procedure consisted of performing a small craniotomy (4 × 3 cm) just lateral to midline using a transverse skin incision. After dural opening, the surgery was performed with the assistance of a rigid high-definition endoscope, and bayoneted self-irrigating bipolar forceps and other standard endoscopic instruments. Steps included a complete corpus callosotomy followed by the disconnection of the hemisphere at the level of the basal nuclei and thalamus. The surgeries were performed in a dedicated operating room with intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging and neuronavigation. Intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging confirmed a total disconnection.

RESULTS:

The pathologies for which surgeries were performed included sequelae of middle a cerebral artery infarct (n = 2), Rasmussen syndrome (n = 1), and hemimegalencephaly (2). Four patients had an Engel class I and 1 patient had a class II outcome at a mean follow-up of 10.2 months (range, 3-14 months). The mean blood loss was 80 mL, and mean operating time was 220 minutes. There were no complications in this study.

CONCLUSION:

This study describes a pilot novel technique and the feasibility of performing a minimally invasive, endoscopy-assisted hemispherotomy.

Intact intracranial breast prosthesis: a 28-year CT follow-up after treatment of late hemispherectomy complications

Anatomical hemispherectomy has had excellent results in treating drug-resistant seizures of infantile hemiplegia. This technique of hemispherectomy consists in the removal of a whole hemisphere, with or without the basal ganglia, the end result being a large cavity left at the end of the operation. The technique, however, is considered to be weighted by important complications, in particular intracranial hemorrhages due to vessels tearing secondary to dislodgement of the remaining hemisphere. Several techniques have been consequently proposed to reduce the volume of the residual hemicranial cavity. An alternative measure is the filling of the cavity itself. We have demonstrated that this type of procedure can be carried out using a silicone breast prosthesis. In this report, we demonstrate also that such an implant can have a surprisingly long duration in its unusual location.

Hemispherectomy in the treatment of seizures: a review

The term hemispherectomy refers to the complete removal or functional disconnection of a cerebral hemisphere. The technique was initially developed over 85 years ago to treat infiltrating brain tumors but is now used exclusively for medically refractory epilepsy. Hemispherectomy surgery has progressed from an extremely morbid procedure fraught with complications to a fairly routine one performed at most pediatric epilepsy centers with relatively low risk and great efficacy. The author reviews the history and evolution of hemispherectomy surgery, the relevant pathological conditions, as well as outcomes and complications.

Ipsilateral and contralateral auditory brainstem response reorganization in hemispherectomized patients

Background. Cortical hemispherectomy leads to degeneration of ipsilateral subcortical structures, which can be observed long term after the operation. Therefore, reorganization of the brainstem auditory pathway might occur. The aim of this study was to assess reorganization of brainstem auditory pathways by measuring the auditory brainstem response (ABR) in long-term hemispherectomized patients. Methods. We performed bilateral monaural stimulation and measured bilateral ABR in 8 patients ~20 years after hemispherectomy and 10 control subjects. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed in patients to assess structural degeneration. Results. All patients showed degenerated ipsilateral brainstem structures by MRI but no significant differences in bilateral recording ABR wave latencies. However, nonsurgical-side stimulation elicited significantly longer wave V latencies compared to surgical-side stimulation. Differences in bilateral ABR were observed between hemispherectomized patients and control subjects. Waves III and V latencies elicited by nonsurgical-side stimulation were significantly longer than those in control subjects; surgical-side stimulation showed no significant differences. Conclusions. (1) Differences in ABR latency elicited by unilateral stimulation are predominantly due to bilateral brainstem auditory pathway activity rather than to changes in brainstem volume; (2) ABR Waves III and V originate predominantly in the contralateral brainstem; and (3) subcortical auditory pathways appear to reorganize after long term hemispherectomy.

Hemispherotomy and other disconnective techniques

The surgical treatment of intractable epilepsy has evolved as new technical innovations have been made. Hemispherotomy techniques have been developed to replace hemispherectomy in order to reduce the complication rates while maintaining good seizure control. Disconnective procedures are based on the interruption of the epileptic network rather than the removal of the epileptogenic zone. They can be applied to hemispheric pathologies, leading to hemispherotomy, but they can also be applied to posterior quadrant epilepsies, or hypothalamic hamartomas. In this paper, the authors review the literature, present an overview of the historical background, and discuss the different techniques along with their outcomes and complications.

Vertical parasagittal hemispherotomy: surgical procedures and clinical long-term outcomes in a population of 83 children

OBJECTIVE

Hemispherotomy techniques have been developed to reduce complication rates and achieve the best possible seizure control. We present the results of our pediatric patients who underwent vertical parasagittal hemispherotomy and evaluate the safety and global long-term outcome of this technique.

METHODS

Eighty-three patients underwent vertical parasagittal hemispherotomy by the same neurosurgeon (OD) between 1990 and 2000. We reviewed all patients between 2001 and 2003 for a standard global evaluation. The general principle is to achieve, through a posterior frontal cortical window, the same line of disconnection as performed with the classic hemispherectomy, while leaving the majority of the hemisphere intact along with its afferent and efferent vascular supply.

METHODS

Seventy-four percent of the patients were seizure-free; among them, 77% were seizure-free without further drug treatment. Twelve percent rarely had seizures (Engel Class II) and 14% continued to have seizures (Engel Class III or IV). The results varied according to the etiology, but this variation was not statistically significant. The early postoperative course was uneventful for 94% of the children, and shunt placement was necessary in 15%. We found a correlation between the preoperative delay and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior score: children with a longer duration of seizures had lower performances.

CONCLUSION

Vertical parasagittal hemispherotomy is an effective surgical technique for hemispheric disconnection. It allows complete disconnection of the hemisphere through a cortical window with good results in terms of seizure outcome and a comparably low complication rate.

Hemispherectomy for intractable epilepsy in adults: The first reported series

Hemispherectomy for intractable unihemispheric epilepsy (IUE) has long been established in pediatric patients. This study reports the first series examining hemispherectomy exclusively in adult patients (>18 years old). Nine adults with IUE underwent hemispherectomy at the University of Minnesota. All patients had unilateral hemiplegia and visual field loss. Seven patients (77.8%) were Engel class I/II at last follow-up. Five (83.3%) of the six patients with >30 years of follow-up were seizure free. No surgery-related mortality, hydrocephalus, or superficial cerebral hemosiderosis occurred. Hemispherectomy is an effective procedure in appropriately selected adult patients, resulting in excellent long-term seizure control and no mortality.

Supercalifragilistic hemosiderosis: a rare and unusual complication that really sounds atrocious

Anatomical Hemispherectomy for Intractable Seizures: Excellent Seizure Control, Low Morbidity and No Superficial Cerebral Haemosiderosis

O'Brien DF, Basu S, Williams DH, May PL

Childs Nerv Syst 2006;22:489–498.

Objective

This current study was performed to evaluate whether superficial cerebral hemosiderosis (SCH) is still a complication of modern day anatomical hemispherectomy.

Methods

We report a 13-year institutional experience with anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable epilepsy. Seizure control at a mean follow-up interval of 7 years was 83%. Though one patient died post-operatively from a nonneurosurgical complication, mortality was otherwise zero and morbidity minimal. The much-described complication of SCH following anatomical hemispherectomy was nonexistent. We explain the history of SCH as a complication of anatomical hemispherectomy, and the measures that are presently taken to prevent it.

Conclusions

We suggest that the importance of SCH in modern epilepsy surgery is probably over-emphasized.

Peri-insular hemispherotomy in paediatric epilepsy

OBJECTS

Outline the indications, investigation, surgical technique, pitfalls, complications and benefits of peri-insular hemispherotomy (PIH) in the surgical treatment of paediatric epilepsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This report is based on a consecutive series of 43 children who underwent PIH. Sixty percent were males; there were slightly more left-sided surgeries. Median interval between seizure onset and surgery was 5 years. In more than half the cases, the anatomical substrate was congenital. There were few complications: one death, one hydrocephalus and two anatomically remote haemorrhages. Ninety percent of the patients have remained in Engel's class I epilepsy outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

There are clear indications for hemispherectomy in children. In some instances of incomplete deficit, timing of surgery remains a major concern. The less invasive approach to eliminate the influence of the diseased hemisphere, in our opinion, is with disconnective techniques of hemispherectomy, and among the latter, peri-insular hemispherotomy provides, in our opinion, the best complications-benefits ratio.

Cognitive assessment in epilepsy surgery of children

INTRODUCTION

Although the neurocognitive assessment in children as in the adults is an important step before and after surgery, in the literature, the data about pre- and postoperative neurocognitive evaluations in children are very few.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this paper is to consider some peculiar aspects of the neurocognitive assessment during development, and report literature data about neuropsychological outcome of epileptic children treated with focal resection and hemispherectomy.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The second section concerns our personal experience about a cohort of 45 children with refractory epilepsy operated on before 7 years. The results suggest that early surgical treatment is generally effective for seizure control and behavior improvement in children with refractory epilepsy. Concerning cognitive outcome, we found that the neurocognitive level was unchanged in the majority of the patients.

CONCLUSION

We underline the importance of multicentric studies with standardized neuropsychological assessments in large series of young children.

Anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable seizures: excellent seizure control, low morbidity and no superficial cerebral haemosiderosis

OBJECTIVE

This current study was performed to evaluate whether superficial cerebral haemosiderosis (SCH) is still a complication of modern day anatomical hemispherectomy.

METHODS

We report a 13-year institutional experience with anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable epilepsy. Seizure control at a mean follow-up interval of 7 years was 83%. Though one patient died post-operatively from a non-neurosurgical complication, mortality was otherwise zero and morbidity minimal. The much-described complication of SCH following anatomical hemispherectomy was non-existent. We explain the history of SCH as a complication of anatomical hemispherectomy, and the measures that are presently taken to prevent it.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that the importance of SCH in modern epilepsy surgery is probably over-emphasised.

Hemispherectomy: a schematic review of the current techniques

Anatomical hemispherectomy has been used for the treatment of seizures since 1938. However, it was almost abandoned in the 1960s after reports of postoperative fatalities caused by hydrocephalus, hemosiderosis, and trivial head traumas. Despite serious complications, the remarkable improvement of patients encouraged authors to carry out modifications on anatomical hemispherectomy in order to lessen its morbidity while preserving its efficacy. The effort to improve the technique generated several original procedures. This paper reviews current techniques of hemispherectomy and proposes a classification scheme based on their surgical characteristics. Techniques of hemispherectomy were sorted into two major groups: (1) those that remove completely the cortex from the hemisphere and (2) those that associate partial cortical removal and disconnection. Group 1 was subdivided into two subgroups based on the integrity of the ventricular cavity and group 2 was subdivided into three subgroups depending on the amount and location of the corticectomy. Grouping similar techniques may allow a better understanding of the distinctive features of each one and creates the possibility of comparing data from different authors.

Presurgical evaluation and surgical treatment of medically refractory epilepsy

Thanks to today's modern imaging examination techniques and especially to the common use of intracranial electrodes for localizing seizure foci, more and more patients with partial epilepsy can be treated microsurgically. The results of such neurosurgical therapies are very good, particularly in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy. In recent years, good results (60-70% seizure freedom) have also been achieved in extratemporal epilepsy surgery, so that such procedures can now be recommended for carefully selected patients. In this review, presurgical evaluations and the different surgical approaches are presented.

Speech and non-speech processing in hemispherectomised children: an event-related potential study

Although hemispherectomy is now used as a radical treatment for intractable seizures in a number of centres, there have been limited electrophysiological studies investigating post-procedure auditory-speech processing and recovery or reorganisation. We therefore recorded auditory event-related potentials (ERPs) evoked by pure tones and syllables employing a 51-channel electrode array concentrated over the functional hemisphere in 17 patients (nine males, mean age 14.2 years) who had undergone hemispherectomy for intractable seizures; eight of the patients had congenital brain damage and nine had sustained their initial insult at an age of 1 year or older. For comparison, recordings were made from 10 controls (five males, mean age 13.5 years). Responses from patients consisted of five small amplitude components restricted to the functional hemisphere whose scalp polarity was opposite to the ERPs observed in control subjects. The topography of the auditory ERPs in the patients was localised to the centro-temporal regions of the functional hemisphere in comparison to the midline distribution observed in control subjects. As in the control subjects, the latencies of the components evoked by tones were shorter than those evoked by syllables in both left and right hemispherectomised children. In addition, further analysis of the N1 and P2 component revealed increased syllable latencies in left hemispherectomised children only. The results of this study suggest that the left hemisphere alone may be more efficient at processing both pure tones and syllables compared to the right or both together.

Surgical treatment of epilepsies

Epilepsy is characterized by recurrent epileptic seizures. Surgical interventions represent a reasonable alternative to long-term antiepileptic drug treatment in those patients destined to achieve incomplete seizure control. The presurgical work-up aims at identifying appropriate surgical candidates. Surgical options with a curative goal include temporal and extratemporal resections and hemispherectomy. With these procedures complete seizure control can be achieved in approximately 2/3 of patients. With palliative procedures such as callosotomy, multiple subpial transections, and vagal nerve stimulation, approximately half of the patients will significantly improve after surgery. In all, epilepsy surgery has proven to be a highly effective treatment option. Major problems include the definition of the epileptogenic area with respect to optimal seizure control and minimum neurological and neuropsychological impairment after surgery.

Anatomical analysis of different hemispherotomy procedures based on dissection of cadaveric brains

OBJECT

Functional hemispherectomy, itself a modification of anatomical hemispherectomy, has been further modified to a less invasive method (hemispherotomy), in which cortical resection is minimized and the rest of the affected hemisphere is functionally isolated by transecting its projection and commissural fibers. Although descriptions of three different types of hemispherotomy procedures have been published, the authors believe that it is important to develop a common and universally acceptable method based on a systematic analysis of topographic anatomy and neuronal connections. To this end, they have analyzed the three aforementioned procedures on the basis of meticulous fiber dissections in previously frozen formalin-fixed human brains.

METHODS

The brain anatomy pertinent to surgical hemispherotomy is described in conjunction with dissection studies in 14 previously frozen, formalin-fixed human brains. The anatomical landmarks necessary for performing particular neuronal fiber resections are identified, and their relationships with operative methods are discussed, with an emphasis on commonalities among the three hemispherotomy procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

In this analysis the authors confirmed that hemispherotomy typically consists of four common procedures: 1) interruption of the internal capsule and corona radiata; 2) resection of the medial temporal structures; 3) transventricular corpus callosotomy; and 4) disruption of the frontal horizontal fibers. After meticulous dissection of cadavers, the authors have designated a reliable method for performing these four operations that may be applicable as a commonly used procedure.

Hemispherectomy techniques

Hemispherectomy techniques have undergone multiple changes. Because of these changes, several current alternatives are described. The need for an extensive procedure in young children with special pediatric requirements is the background for the development of newer and more microsurgically oriented techniques aimed at reducing the intraoperative problems and late postoperative complications. This article reviews the strengths and the disadvantages of the currently used procedures in light of special requirements for hemispheric dysplasias.

Transsylvian keyhole functional hemispherectomy

OBJECTIVE

To describe the technical steps, advantages, and limitations of a quicker, minimal-exposure, functional hemispherectomy procedure developed from a hemispherical deafferentation technique previously described.

METHODS

The surgical approach using the transsylvian/transsulcal passage to the ventricular system, with the anatomic orientation points and key features for planning of the small trepanation, is described. Through a linear incision, a craniotomy (4 x 4 to 4 x 5 cm) is placed over the sylvian fissure. Transsylvian exposure of the circular sulcus allows transcortical exposure of the entire ventricular system, from the frontal horn to the temporal horn encircling the insular cortex. The frontobasal and mesial white matter is disconnected via the intraventricular approach, with a callosotomy. An amygdalohippocampectomy completes the dissection. The experience with 20 patients who were treated using the transsylvian keyhole hemispherectomy technique is summarized.

RESULTS

The operation time was significantly shorter (mean, 3.6 h) than with the Rasmussen technique (mean, 6.3 h) and 25% shorter than with the transcortical perisylvian technique (mean, 4.9 h). The proportion of patients requiring blood replacements was lower (15 versus 58%), as was the mean amount of transfused blood. The mean follow-up period was 46 months; 88% of patients were in Engel Outcome Class I, 6% in Class III, and 6% in Class IV.

CONCLUSION

The transsylvian keyhole procedure has been demonstrated to further reduce operation time and the need for blood replacement. It is most easily performed in cases with enlarged ventricles or perinatal ischemic cysts and is not recommended for hemimegalencephaly. The immediate seizure relief was satisfying. This minimal-exposure approach seems to be a satisfying alternative among possible functional hemispherectomy procedures.

Complications of epilepsy surgery after 654 procedures in Sweden, September 1990-1995: a multicenter study based on the Swedish National Epilepsy Surgery Register

OBJECTIVE

To present the first national multicenter study on complications after epilepsy surgery procedures to include all epilepsy surgery centers in Sweden: Göteborg, Linköping, Lund, Stockholm, Umeå, and Uppsala.

METHODS

Every epilepsy surgery procedure in Sweden is reported to the Swedish National Epilepsy Surgery Register. The report includes relevant social and medical items and complications. A complication is defined as minor if it resolves within 3 months and major if it affects activities of daily living and lasts longer than 3 months. Follow-up data are recorded for 2 years after the operation. Intrinsic checkpoints and external revision validate the register data.

RESULTS

During the inclusion period (September 1990-December 1995), 654 surgical procedures were performed (age range, 6 mo-67 yr). Of these, 205 were invasive electrode procedures (182 first investigations and 23 reinvestigations), and 449 were therapeutic procedures (375 first operations and 74 reoperations). After invasive electrode procedures, only minor complications were reported (6.3%). For all 449 therapeutic procedures (including reoperations), minor complications were reported in 8.9% and major complications in 3.1 %. Only one major complication was reported in a patient under the age of 35 years.

CONCLUSION

This is the first national multicenter study on complications after epilepsy surgery. It demonstrates that these procedures as performed at six different centers in Sweden are safe, but also that risk is related to age. In patients younger than age 35 years, the risk for a major complication after invasive subdural strip electrode investigation and epilepsy surgery is low.

Rasmussen's syndrome: intractable epilepsy and progressive neurological deterioration from a unilateral central nervous system

Rasmussen's syndrome (chronic encephalitis with epilepsy) is a rare neurological disorder of unknown cause characterized by severe epilepsy, hemiplegia, dementia, and inflammation of the brain, and progressive functional and structural destruction of a single cerebral hemisphere. While one mechanism underlying the pathogenesis of Rasmussen's encephalitis has been hypothesized to be mediated by production of excitotoxic GluR3 autoantibodies to the a-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methylisoxazole-4-propionic acid (AMPA) receptor, other neuropathological etiologies have also been indicated. Proposed therapies have included antiepileptics, steroids, antiviral agents, alpha-interferon, and immunoglobulin. The mainstay of therapy is surgical hemispherectomy. To date, no medical therapies have permanently halted neurologic deterioration.

Intractable epilepsy after a functional hemispherectomy: important lessons from an unusual case. Case report

Residual seizures after functional hemispherectomy occur in approximately 20% of patients with catastrophic epilepsy. These episodes are traditionally attributed to incomplete disconnection, persistent epileptogenic activity in the ipsilateral insular cortex, or bilateral independent epileptogenic activity. The authors report on the case of an 8-year-old boy with an intractable seizure disorder who had classic frontal adversive seizures related to extensive unilateral left hemispheric cortical dysplasia. The initial intervention consisted of extensive removal of the epileptic frontal and precentral dysplastic tissue and multiple subpial transections of the dysplastic motor strip, guided by intraoperative electrocorticography, Subsequently, functional hemispherectomy including insular cortex resection was performed for persistent attacks. After a seizure-free period of 6 months, a new pattern ensued, consisting of an aura of fear, dystonic posturing of the right arm, and unusual postictal hyperphagia coupled with an interictal diencephalic-like syndrome. Electroencephalography and ictal/interictal single-photon emission computerized tomography were used to localize the residual epileptic discharges to deep ipsilateral structures. Results of magnetic resonance imaging indicated a complete disconnection except for a strip of residual frontobasal tissue. Therefore, a volumetric resection of the epileptogenic frontal basal tissue up to the anterior commissure was completed. The child has remained free of seizures during 21 months of follow-up review. Standard hemispherectomy methods provide extensive disconnection, despite the presence of residual frontal basal cortex. However, rarely, and especially if it is dysplastic, this tissue can represent a focus for refractory seizures. This is an important consideration in determining the source of ongoing seizures posthemispherectomy in patients with extensive cortical dysplasia. It remains important to assess them fully before considering their disease refractory to surgical treatment.

Modification of peri-insular hemispherotomy and surgical results

OBJECTIVE

We modified the peri-insular hemispherotomy technique devised by Villemure and Mascott. Our modified technique and the surgical results obtained with this method are presented.

METHODS

The frontoparietal operculum is resected, and the resection cavity is connected with the lateral ventricle. Through this cavity, a transventricular corpus callosotomy and resection of the medial temporal structures are performed.

RESULTS

This technique was used for 34 patients, with satisfactory surgical results. Cerebrospinal fluid shunt placement was necessary for five patients, and incomplete callosal sectioning was postoperatively detected in three cases.

CONCLUSION

Our modification of the peri-insular hemispherotomy can be safely and effectively used to treat epilepsy caused by hemispheric lesions, even in cases without ventricular dilation.

Cognitive functions and epileptic activity

Epilepsy, and its treatment, can affect the development and use of language in a number of different ways. The seizures may be a symptom of a lesion in areas of the brain essential for language function, and the complications of both the seizures and of the drugs can interfere with learning. However, the purpose of this review is to consider the role of epileptic activity as demonstrated by electrical discharges in the electroencephalogram (EEG), whether these are accompanied by overt seizures or not, on cerebral function especially that of language. The Landau-Kleffner, the continuous spike-waves during sleep, and the benign epilepsy of childhood with Rolandic spikes syndromes are considered; as well as the evidence of epileptic discharges affecting language development. If there are doubts that a patient is suffering from epilepsy the diagnosis may be difficult; and anyone involved in the treatment of language disorders should keep this possibility in mind. Particularly during childhood an EEG, awake and asleep, should be an important part of the assessment of both developmental and acquired dysphasia. The control of overt fits may be relatively easy, but drugs are not so effective in controlling the epileptic activity in the EEG. The treatment of such discharges used to be discouraged, but the evidence is now strongly in favour of employing both medical and surgical treatment. The results in restoring language function are sometimes dramatic.

Developmental neuroplasticity in a model of cerebral hemispherectomy and stroke

Cerebral hemispherectomy, a last resort treatment for childhood epilepsy, is a standard procedure which dramatically illustrates the resilience of the brain to extensive damage. If this operation, also mimicking long-term, extensive unilateral capsular stroke, is performed in postnatal cats of up to 60 days of age, there is a remarkable recovery/sparing of neurological functions that is not seen when the lesion occurs during late fetal life or in adulthood. A long-term effect at all ages is loss of neurons in bilateral brain areas remote from the resection site. This is pronounced in adult cats and shows intriguing, paradoxical features in fetal animals, but is substantially attenuated in neonatal cats. Similarly, large-scale reinnervation of subcortical sites (sprouting) by neurons of the remaining, intact hemisphere is prominent in young cats, but not in fetal or adult animals. These and other restorative processes (described herein) in young postnatal animals are matched by relatively higher rates of local cerebral glucose utilization, supporting the notion that they underlie the improved behavioral outcome. Thus, during a critical, defined stage of maturation, presumably common to higher mammals including humans, the brain entirely remodels itself in response to extensive but focal injury. Perhaps the molecular environment allowing for rescue of neurons and enhanced reinnervation at a specific developmental stage could be recreated in subjects with brain lesions at less favorable ages, thereby helping to restore circuitry and spare neurons. However, replacement via transplantation of neurons eliminated by the damage appears to be crucial in attempts to further preserve cells located remotely but yet destined to die or decrease in size. This article presents abundant evidence to show that there is a surprisingly comprehensive long-term morphological remodeling of the entire brain after extensive unilateral damage and that this occurs preferentially during a discrete period of early life. Additional evidence strongly suggests that the remodeling underlies the outstanding behavioral and functional recovery/sparing following early cerebral hemispherectomy. We argue that this period of reduced brain vulnerability to injury also exists in other higher mammals, including man, and suggest ways to enhance restorative processes after stroke/hemispherectomy occurring at other ages.

Why would you remove half a brain? The outcome of 58 children after hemispherectomy-the Johns Hopkins experience: 1968 to 1996

PURPOSE

To report the outcomes of the 58 hemispherectomies performed at Johns Hopkins between 1968 and January 1996.

METHODS

Charts were reviewed of the 58 hemispherectomies performed at Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions by the Pediatric Epilepsy Group during the years 1968 to 1996. Twenty-seven operations were done for Rasmussen's syndrome, 24 operations for cortical dysplasias/hemimegalencephalies, and 7 for Sturge-Weber syndrome or other congenital vascular problems. Seizure control alone did not seem to adequately describe the outcomes of the procedure. Therefore, a score was constructed that included seizure frequency, motor disability, and intellectual handicap. This burden of illness score better described the child's handicap before and after surgery.

RESULTS

Perioperative death occurred in 4 out of 58 children. Of the 54 surviving children, 54% (29/54) are seizure-free, 24% (13/54) have nonhandicapping seizures, and 23% (12/54) have residual seizures that interfere to some extent with function. Reduction in seizures was related to the etiology of the unilateral epilepsy. Eighty-nine percent of children with Rasmussen's, 67% of those with dysplasias, and 67% of the vascular group are seizure-free, or have occasional, nonhandicapping seizures. All operations were considered by the parents and the physicians to have been successful in decreasing the burden of illness. In 44 the procedure was very successful, in 7 it was moderately successful, and in 3 it was minimally successful. Success was related to the etiology, and early surgery was preferable.

CONCLUSION

Hemispherectomy can be a valuable procedure for relieving the burden of seizures, the burden of medication, and the general dysfunction in children with severe or progressive unilateral cortical disease. Early hemispherectomy, although increasing the hemiparesis in children with Rasmussen's syndrome, relieves the burden of constant seizures and allows the child to return to a more normal life. In children with dysplasias, early surgery can allow the resumption of more normal development.

Surgical treatment for epilepsy: a retrospective Swedish multicenter study

The characteristics of patients suffering from drug resistant epilepsy, including the results of the preoperative evaluation and epilepsy surgery were retrospectively analyzed in a Swedish multicenter 10-year cohort of children and adults. Altogether 152 patients (65 children and 87 adults) treated during the period 1980-1990 in three epilepsy centers were included and followed-up 2 years after surgery. Median age at onset of seizures was 4 years for the children and 12 years for the adults. A localization related epilepsy was present in 85% of the children and in 95% of the adults. The mean number of seizure types in the children was 1.7 (range 1-4) and in the adults 1.8 (range 1-4). The median monthly seizure frequency was 52 and 15 for children and adults respectively. Resective surgery was performed in 143 cases (94 temporal, 31 extratemporal, 9 multilobar and 9 major resection procedures) and palliative procedures in 16 cases (13 callosotomies and 3 stereotactic amygdalotomies). Postoperative neurological deficits were detected in 9% of the patients after temporal lobe resections and in 15% of the patients after extratemporal and multilobar resection procedures. Two years after resective surgery 53% of the children and 49% of the adults were seizure free. Another 25% of the patients had a more than 50% reduction of seizure frequency. In the postoperative non seizure free group of patients there was a negative correlation between decrease in weighted seizure severity and decrease in seizure frequency. This finding stresses the need for including other parameters than seizure frequency when evaluating the outcome of epilepsy surgery.

Computer-assisted endoscopy for neurosurgical procedures: technical note

OBJECTIVE

As neuroendoscopy technology evolves, the ventriculoscope is playing a greater role in the diagnosis and treatment of disorders affecting the ventricular system. However, even with direct visualization, correctly orienting and safely navigating an endoscope may be difficult with abnormal anatomy, in small ventricles, or when searching for small periventricular lesions identified on neuroimaging studies. The ability to define the location of the endoscope during such procedures enhances its effectiveness and safety.

INSTRUMENTATION

We report the successful adaptation of an image-guided stereotactic wand to a rigid neuroendoscope. With computer-assisted neuroendoscopy (CANE), the tip position and orientation of a rigid ventriculoscope were visualized in real-time on neuroimaging studies that were obtained before surgery. Because computer guidance may also be used with the neuroendoscope obturator during ventricular access, uncertainty in accessing small ventricles is minimized.

RESULTS

Eleven patients were operated on at The Cleveland Clinic Foundation using the CANE system. All patients except one were improved after surgery. Early experience suggests that CANE is useful for certain endoscopic procedures by aiding in trajectory planning, ventricular navigation, and localizing certain pathological conditions.

CONCLUSION

Even with direct visualization, ventriculoscopy in abnormal anatomy may be difficult. Although the CANE system may not always be necessary in neuroendoscopy, correlation of the endoscope tip location, with an intraoperative magnetic resonance image via continuous computer updates, may enhance the safety, as well as the efficiency, of neuroendoscopy in the future.

Hemispherectomy for intractable seizures in children: a report of 58 cases

Fifty-eight children who underwent anatomical, functional, or modified anatomical hemispherectomy for intractable seizures from 1986 to 1995 were evaluated for seizure control, motor function, and complications. Age at surgery ranged from 0.3 to 17.3 years (median 2.8 years). Twenty-seven anatomical, 27 functional, and 4 modified anatomical hemispherectomies were performed. Seizure control and motor function in the 50 patients with more than 1 year follow-up revealed a 90% or better reduction in seizure frequency in 44/50 (88%) overall: 19/22 (86%) anatomical, 23/26 (89%) functional, and 2/2 modified anatomical. Motor function of the preoperatively hemiparetic extremities was improved or unchanged postoperatively in 38/50 (76%) of the patients. Complications included one intraoperative death, one late death from shunt obstruction managed elsewhere, late postoperative seizure breakthrough requiring reoperation and further disconnection in 5/27 functional hemispherectomy patients, mild cerebrospinal fluid infections in 3/27 anatomical hemispherectomy patients, and hydrocephalus requiring shunting in 3/27 functional hemispherectomy patients. A review of the literature and comparison of techniques is presented.

Hemispherectomy: a hemidecortication approach and review of 52 cases

Between 1975 and 1994, 52 hemispherectomies, of which two were anatomical and 50 hemidecortications, were performed at Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions. Eighteen patients were 2 years old or less. There were three perioperative mortalities and one patient died 9 months later from causes not related to surgery. One patient developed hydrocephalus 6 years postsurgery and has been treated effectively. Seizure control and the functional status of each patient were measured as outcome variables. Forty-six (96%) of the surviving patients were seizure free or had reduced seizures as of their last follow-up examination. Twenty-one individuals (44%) were participating in age-appropriate classes or working independently, 18 were classified as semiindependent, and nine children will likely depend on a lifetime of assisted living. The relationships between the outcome variables and the patient's age at surgery, the interval to surgery, and the etiology of the disease were compared. The authors' clinical experiences strongly suggest the importance of a multidisciplinary approach to patient selection and follow-up care. Moreover, anesthetic management of infant surgery is a major component of success.

The role of light scatter in the residual visual sensitivity of patients with complete cerebral hemispherectomy

Various residual visual capacities have been reported for the phenomenally blind field of hemispherectomized patients, providing evidence for the relative roles of cortical and subcortical pathways in vision. We attempted to characterize these functions by examining the ability of five patients to detect, localize, and discriminate high-contrast flashed, flickering and moving targets. Dependent measures were verbal, manual, and oculomotor responses. As a control for light scatter, intensity thresholds for monocular detection of targets in the hemianopic field were compared with thresholds obtained when using an additional half eyepatch to occlude the blind hemiretina of the tested eye. One unilaterally destriate patient was tested on the same tasks. In photopic conditions, none of the hemispherectomized patients could respond to visual cues in their impaired fields, whereas the destriate patient could detect, discriminate, and point to targets, and appreciate the apparent motion of stimuli across his midline. Under reduced lighting, the threshold luminance required by hemispherectomized patients to detect stimuli presented monocularly was similar to that required for their detection when all visual information was occluded in the blind field, and only available to the visual system indirectly via light scatter. In contrast, the destriate patient's monocular threshold in his blind field was substantially lower than that for stimuli directly occluded in the blind field. As we found no range of stimuli which the hemispherectomized patients could detect or discriminate that was not also associated with discriminable scattered light, we conclude that the subcortical pathways which survive hemispherectomy cannot mediate voluntary behavioural responses to visual information in the hemianopic field.