Emerging Applications of Machine Learning in Food Safety

Data integrity of food and machine learning: Strategies, advances and prospective

Data integrity is an emerging concept aimed at recording real food properties in the form of data throughout the food lifecycle. However, due to the one-sided nature of current food control data, the comprehensive implementation of data integrity has not been fully achieved. Cause food data integrity realization is required to establish the connection of data-algorithm-application. Machine learning (ML) provides a possibility for the practical carrier of food data integrity. Despite ML is one of top-trend in food quality and safety, ML applications are floating on the surface. The current review does not reveal the relationships behind different algorithms and data patterns. Similarly, due to the rapid development of ML, the current advanced concepts and data explanation tools have not been systematically reviewed. This paper expounds the feasibility of machine learning to achieve data integrity and looks forward to the future vision brought about by artificial intelligence to data integrity.

Applications of Machine Learning in Food Safety and HACCP Monitoring of Animal-Source Foods

Integrating advanced computing techniques into food safety management has attracted significant attention recently. Machine learning (ML) algorithms offer innovative solutions for Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP) monitoring by providing advanced data analysis capabilities and have proven to be powerful tools for assessing the safety of Animal-Source Foods (ASFs). Studies that link ML with HACCP monitoring in ASFs are limited. The present review provides an overview of ML, feature extraction, and selection algorithms employed for food safety. Several non-destructive techniques are presented, including spectroscopic methods, smartphone-based sensors, paper chromogenic arrays, machine vision, and hyperspectral imaging combined with ML algorithms. Prospects include enhancing predictive models for food safety with the development of hybrid Artificial Intelligence (AI) models and the automation of quality control processes using AI-driven computer vision, which could revolutionize food safety inspections. However, handling conceivable inclinations in AI models is vital to guaranteeing reasonable and exact hazard assessments in an assortment of nourishment generation settings. Moreover, moving forward, the interpretability of ML models will make them more straightforward and dependable. Conclusively, applying ML algorithms allows real-time monitoring and predictive analytics and can significantly reduce the risks associated with ASF consumption.

Recent Use of Novel Data Streams During Foodborne Illness Cluster Investigations by the United States Food and Drug Administration: Qualitative Review

Unlabelled

Foodborne illness is a continuous public health risk. The recognition of signals indicating a cluster of foodborne illness is key to the detection, mitigation, and prevention of foodborne adverse event incidents and outbreaks. With increased internet availability and access, novel data streams (NDSs) for foodborne illness reports initiated by users outside of the traditional public health framework have emerged. These include, but are not limited to, social media websites, web-based product reviews posted to retailer websites, and private companies that host public-generated notices of foodborne illnesses. Information gathered by these platforms can help identify early signals of foodborne illness clusters or help inform ongoing public health investigations. Here we present an overview of NDSs and 3 investigations of foodborne illness incidents by the US Food and Drug Administration that included the use of NDSs at various stages. Each example demonstrates how these data were collected, integrated into traditional data sources, and used to inform the investigation. NDSs present a unique opportunity for public health agencies to identify clusters that may not have been identified otherwise, due to new or unique etiologies, as shown in the 3 examples. Clusters may also be identified earlier than they would have been through traditional sources. NDSs can further provide investigators supplemental information that may help confirm or rule out a source of illness. However, data collected from NDSs are often incomplete and lack critical details for investigators, such as product information (eg, lot numbers), clinical or medical details (eg, laboratory results of affected individuals), and contact information for report follow-up. In the future, public health agencies may wish to standardize an approach to maximize the potential of NDSs to catalyze and supplement adverse event investigations. Additionally, the collection of essential data elements by NDS platforms and data-sharing processes with public health agencies may aid in the investigation of foodborne illness clusters and inform subsequent public health and regulatory actions.

Research on Risk Prediction of Condiments Based on Gray Correlation Analysis - Deep Neural Networks

Food safety is directly related to the health of the public, and the safety of condiments is also of great significance. In this study, a risk assessment model for condiments based on gray correlation analysis was established by using publicly available sampling data of soy sauce and vinegar in China. Risk indicator screening and data preprocessing were performed first, and the weight of each indicator was calculated by gray correlation analysis to formulate a comprehensive risk value label. Then, three machine learning models, Deep Neural Network (DNN), Random Forest (RF), and eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost), were used to predict the comprehensive risk values. Finally, the fuzzy synthesis analysis was utilized to classify the risk level of the composite risk value. In this study, based on the analysis of 282 sets of soy sauce and 704 sets of vinegar samples, the trained DNN model has the optimal prediction performance, which can basically predict the comprehensive risk value and risk level of a sample by inputting the detection indexes of that sample. This method can provide a more reasonable basis for relevant departments to formulate risk control strategies.

Using GWAS and Machine Learning to Identify and Predict Genetic Variants Associated with Foodborne Bacteria Phenotypic Traits

One of the main challenges in food microbiology is to prevent the risk of outbreaks by avoiding the distribution of food contaminated by bacteria. This requires constant monitoring of the circulating strains throughout the food production chain. Bacterial genomes contain signatures of natural evolution and adaptive markers that can be exploited to better understand the behavior of pathogen in the food industry. The monitoring of foodborne strains can therefore be facilitated by the use of these genomic markers capable of rapidly providing essential information on isolated strains, such as the source of contamination, risk of illness, potential for biofilm formation, and tolerance or resistance to biocides. The increasing availability of large genome datasets is enhancing the understanding of the genetic basis of complex traits such as host adaptation, virulence, and persistence. Genome-wide association studies have shown very promising results in the discovery of genomic markers that can be integrated into rapid detection tools. In addition, machine learning has successfully predicted phenotypes and classified important traits. Genome-wide association and machine learning tools have therefore the potential to support decision-making circuits intending at reducing the burden of foodborne diseases. The aim of this chapter review is to provide knowledge on the use of these two methods in food microbiology and to recommend their use in the field.

Utilization of AI - reshaping the future of food safety, agriculture and food security - a critical review

Artificial intelligence is an emerging technology which harbors a suite of mechanisms that have the potential to be leveraged for reaping value across multiple domains. Lately, there is an increased interest in embracing applications associated with Artificial Intelligence to positively contribute to food safety. These applications such as machine learning, computer vision, predictive analytics algorithms, sensor networks, robotic inspection systems, and supply chain optimization tools have been established to contribute to several domains of food safety such as early warning of outbreaks, risk prediction, detection and identification of food associated pathogens. Simultaneously, the ambition toward establishing a sustainable food system has motivated the adoption of cutting-edge technologies such as Artificial Intelligence to strengthen food security. Given the myriad challenges confronting stakeholders in their endeavors to safeguard food security, Artificial Intelligence emerges as a promising tool capable of crafting holistic management strategies for food security. This entails maximizing crop yields, mitigating losses, and trimming operational expenses. AI models present notable benefits in efficiency, precision, uniformity, automation, pattern identification, accessibility, and scalability for food security endeavors. The escalation in the global trend for adopting alternative protein sources such as edible insects and microalgae as a sustainable food source reflects a growing recognition of the need for sustainable and resilient food systems to address the challenges of population growth, environmental degradation, and food insecurity. Artificial Intelligence offers a range of capabilities to enhance food safety in the production and consumption of alternative proteins like microalgae and edible insects, contributing to a sustainable and secure food system.

Optical detection and enumeration of Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica using a low-magnification light microscope

A rapid and cost-effective method for detecting bacterial cells from surfaces is critical to food safety, clinical hygiene, and pharmacy quality. Herein, we established an optical detection method based on a gold chip coating with 3-mercaptophenylboronic acid (3-MPBA) to capture bacterial cells, which allows for the detection and quantification of bacterial cells with a standard light microscope under low-magnification (10×) objective lens. Then, integrate the developed optical detection method with swab sampling to detect bacterial cells loading on stainless-steel surfaces. Using Salmonella enterica (SE1045) and Escherichia coli (E. coli OP50) as model bacterial cells, we achieved a capture efficiency of up to 76.0 ± 2.0 % for SE1045 cells and 81.1 ± 3.3 % for E. coli OP50 cells at 103 CFU/mL upon the optimized conditions, which slightly decreased with the increasing bacterial concentrations. Our assay showed good linear relationships between the concentrations of bacterial cells with the cell counting in images in the range of 103 -107 CFU/mL for SE1045, and 103 -108 CFU/mL for E. coli OP50 cells. The limit of detection (LOD) was 103 CFU/mL for both SE1045 and E. coli OP50 cells. A further increase in sensitivity in detecting E. coli OP50 cells was achieved through a heat treatment, enabling the LOD to be reduced as low as 102 CFU/mL. Furthermore, a preliminary application succeeded in assessing bacterial contamination on stainless-steel surfaces following integration with the approximately 40 % recovery rate, suggesting prospects for evaluating the bacteria from surfaces. The entire process was completed within around 2 h, costing merely a few dollars per sample. Considering the low cost of standard light microscopes, our method holds significant potential for practical industrial applications in bacterial contamination control on surfaces, especially in low-resource settings.

Advanced data analytics and "omics" techniques to control enteric foodborne pathogens

Enteric pathogens, particularly bacterial pathogens, are associated with millions of cases of foodborne illness in the U.S. and worldwide, necessitating the identification and development of methods to control and minimize their impact on public health. Predictive modeling and quantitative microbial risk assessment are two such methods that analyze data on microbial behavior, particularly as a response to changes in the food matrix, to predict and control the presence and prevalence of these pathogens in food. However, a number of these bacterial enteric pathogens, including Escherichia coli, Listeria monocytogenes, and Salmonella enterica, have inherent genetic and phenotypic differences among their subtypes and variants. This has led to an increasing reliance on "omics" technologies, including genomics, proteomics, transcriptomics, and metabolomics, to identify and characterize pathogenic microorganisms and their behavior in food systems. With this exponential increase in available data on these enteric pathogens, comes a need for the development of novel strategies to analyze this data. Advanced data analysis/analytics is a means to extract value from these large data sources, and is considered the core of data processing. In the past few years, advanced data analytics methods such as machine learning and artificial intelligence have been increasingly used to extract meaningful, actionable knowledge from these data sources to help mitigate food safety issues caused by enteric pathogens. This chapter reviews the latest in research into the use of advanced data analytics, particularly machine learning, to analyze "omics" data of enteric bacterial pathogens, and identifies potential future uses of these techniques in mitigating the risk of these pathogens on public health.

A Review of Gastrodia Elata Bl.: Extraction, Analysis and Application of Functional Food

Gastrodia elata Bl. still widely known as a medicinal plant due to its anti-inflammatory, neuroprotection, cardiovascular protection etc. Additionally, these medical applications cannot be separated from its antioxidant, anti-aging, regulating cell apoptosis ability, which make it have potential as a functional food as well as it has been eaten for more than 2,000 years in China. At present, although Gastrodia elata Bl. has appeared in a large number of studies, much of the research is based on drugs rather than foods. The review of Gastrodia elata Bl. from the perspective of food is one of the necessary steps to promote related development, by reviewing the literature on analytical methods of Gastrodia elata Bl. in recent years, critical components change in the extraction, analytical methods and improvement of food applications, all of aspects of it was summarized. Based on the report about physical and chemical changes in Gastrodia elata Bl. to discover the pathway of Gastrodia elata Bl. functional food development from current to the future.

A comparative study on bath and horn ultrasound-assisted modification of bentonite and their effects on the bleaching efficiency of soybean and sunflower oil: Machine learning as a new approach for mathematical modeling

In this study, the effect of high-power bath and horn ultrasound at different powers on specific surface area (S BET), total pore volume (V total), and average pore volume (D ave) of bleaching clay was examined. After subjecting the bleaching clay to ultrasonication treatment, the SBET values demonstrated an escalation from 31.4 ± 2.7 m2 g-1 to 59.8 ± 3.1 m2 g-1 for HU200BC, 143.8 ± 3.9 m2 g-1 for HU400BC, 54.4 ± 3.6 m2 g-1 for BU400BC, and 137.5 ± 2.8 m2 g-1 for BU800BC. The mean pore diameter (D ave) declined from 29.7 ± 0.14 nm in bleaching clay to 11.3 ± 0.13 nm in HU200BC, 8.3 ± 0.12 nm in HU400BC, 16.7 ± 0.14 nm in BU400BC, and 9.6 ± 0.12 nm in BU800BC. Therefore, horn ultrasound-treated bleaching clay significantly increased S BET and V total, indicating improved adsorption capacity. Moreover, to establish the relationship between bleaching parameters, seven multi-output ML regression models of Feedforward Neural Network (FNN), Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Regression (SVR), Multi-Task Lasso, Ridge regression, Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost), and Gradient Boosting are used, and compared with response surface methodology (RSM). ML has revolutionized the understanding of complex relationships between ultrasonic parameters, oil color, and pigment degradation, providing insights into how various factors such as temperature, ultrasonic power, and time can influence the bleaching process, ultimately enhancing the efficiency and precision of the treatment. The XGBoost model showed outstanding performance in predicting the target variables with a high R 2-train up to 1, R 2-test up to .983, and a minimum mean absolute error (MAE) of 0.498. The lower error between the predicted and experimental values implies the superiority of the XGBoost model to predict outcomes rather than RSM. It represents the suitability of bath ultrasound as a mild condition for low-pigmented oil bleaching. Finally, the Bayesian optimization method in conjunction with XGBoost was used to optimize the amount of bleaching clay and energy consumption, and its performance was compared with RSM. It was observed that the consumption of bleaching clay was reduced by approximately 60% for sunflower oil and 30%-35% for soybean oil.

Revealing alcoholization-related volatile compounds and determining alcoholization indices in tobacco using GC-IMS coupled with chemometrics

Alcoholization is an integral part of tobacco processing and volatile compounds are key to assessing tobacco alcoholization. In this study, a total of 154 volatiles from nine categories were determined by gas chromatography-ion mobility spectrometry (GC-IMS) from four grades of tobacco, of which 114 were better identified. And then, the dynamic trends of volatile compounds with significant changes in tobacco alcoholization were analyzed. The relevant volatiles with the alcoholization indices (AIs) (R > 0.8) were screened as indicators of tobacco alcoholization. Cinnamyl isobutyrate, linolenic acid alcohol, propanoic acid-M and propanoic acid-D in all tobacco samples were highly correlated with the AIs and tended to increase during the alcoholization process. In addition, linear discriminant analysis (LDA), back-propagation neural network (BPNN) and random forest (RF) classifiers were constructed for discrimination of tobacco AIs. Three classifiers trained with a combination of 20 volatiles achieved satisfactory results with area under the curve (AUC) of 0.95 (LDA), 0.94 (BPNN) and 0.97 (RF), respectively. The RF classifier gained optimal accuracy of 100 % and 96.1 % for the training and test sets, respectively. The study confirmed that GC-IMS can be used to characterize the changes of volatile compounds in tobacco during alcoholization and combined with machine learning to achieve the determination of AIs. The results of the study may provide a new means for the tobacco industry to monitor the alcoholization process and determine the degree of alcoholization.

Elevating nanomaterial optical sensor arrays through the integration of advanced machine learning techniques for enhancing visual inspection of food quality and safety

Food quality and safety problems caused by inefficient control in the food chain have significant implications for human health, social stability, and economic progress and optical sensor arrays (OSAs) can effectively address these challenges. This review aims to summarize the recent applications of nanomaterials-based OSA for food quality and safety visual monitoring, including colourimetric sensor array (CSA) and fluorescent sensor array (FSA). First, the fundamental properties of various advanced nanomaterials, mainly including metal nanoparticles (MNPs) and nanoclusters (MNCs), quantum dots (QDs), upconversion nanoparticles (UCNPs), and others, were described. Besides, the diverse machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) methods of high-dimensional data obtained from the responses between different sensing elements and analytes were presented. Moreover, the recent and representative applications in pesticide residues, heavy metal ions, bacterial contamination, antioxidants, flavor matters, and food freshness detection were comprehensively summarized. Finally, the challenges and future perspectives for nanomaterials-based OSAs are discussed. It is believed that with the advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) techniques and integrated technology, nanomaterials-based OSAs are expected to be an intelligent, effective, and rapid tool for food quality assessment and safety control.

Hyperspectral imaging as a non-destructive technique for estimating the nutritional value of food

Knowledge of the energy and macronutrient content of complex foods is essential for the food industry and to implement population-based dietary guidelines. However, conventional methodologies are time-consuming, require the use of chemical products and the sample cannot be recovered. We hypothesize that the nutritional value of heterogeneous food products can be readily measured instead by using hyperspectral imaging systems (NIR and VIS-NIR) combined with mathematical models previously fitted with spectral profiles.118 samples from different food products were collected for building the predictive models using their hyperspectral imaging data as predictors and their nutritional values as dependent variables. Ten different models were screened (Multivariate Linear regression, Lasso regression, Rigde regression, Elastic Net regression, K-Neighbors regression, Decision trees regression, Partial Least Square, Support Vector Machines, Gradient Boosting regression and Random Forest regression). The best results were obtained with Ridge regression for all parameters. The best performance was for estimating the protein content with a RMSE of 1.02 and a R2 equal to 0.88 in a test set, following by moisture (RMSE of 2.21 and R2 equal to 0.85), energy value (RMSE of 21.84 and R2 equal to 0.76) and total fat (RMSE of 2.17 and R2 equal to 0.72). The performance with carbohydrates (RMSE of 2.12 and R2 equal to 0.61) and ashes (RMSE of 0.25 and R2 equal to 0.38) was worse. This study shows that it is possible to predict the energy and nutrient values of processed complex foods, using hyperspectral imaging systems combined with supervised machine learning methods.

Deep machine learning identified fish flesh using multispectral imaging

Food fraud is widespread in the aquatic food market, hence fast and non-destructive methods of identification of fish flesh are needed. In this study, multispectral imaging (MSI) was used to screen flesh slices from 20 edible fish species commonly found in the sea around Yantai, China, by combining identification based on the mitochondrial COI gene. We found that nCDA images transformed from MSI data showed significant differences in flesh splices of the 20 fish species. We then employed eight models to compare their prediction performances based on the hold-out method with 70% training and 30% test sets. Convolutional neural network (CNN), quadratic discriminant analysis (QDA), support vector machine (SVM), and linear discriminant analysis (LDA) models perform well on cross-validation and test data. CNN and QDA achieved more than 99% accuracy on the test set. By extracting the CNN features for optimization, a very high degree of separation was obtained for all species. Furthermore, based on the Gini index in RF, 11 bands were selected as key classification features for CNN, and an accuracy of 98% was achieved. Our study developed a successful pipeline for employing machine learning models (especially CNN) on MSI identification of fish flesh, and provided a convenient and non-destructive method to determine the marketing of fish flesh in the future.

Recent advances and challenges in the analysis of natural toxins

Natural toxins (NTs) are poisonous secondary metabolites produced by living organisms developed to ward off predators. Especially low molecular weight NTs (MW<∼1 kDa), such as mycotoxins, phycotoxins, and plant toxins, are considered an important and growing food safety concern. Therefore, accurate risk assessment of food and feed for the presence of NTs is crucial. Currently, the analysis of NTs is predominantly performed with targeted high pressure liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS/MS) methods. Although these methods are highly sensitive and accurate, they are relatively expensive and time-consuming, while unknown or unexpected NTs will be missed. To overcome this, novel on-site screening methods and non-targeted HPLC high resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) methods have been developed. On-site screening methods can give non-specialists the possibility for broad "scanning" of potential geographical regions of interest, while also providing sensitive and specific analysis at the point-of-need. Non-targeted chromatography-HRMS methods can detect unexpected as well as unknown NTs and their metabolites in a lab-based approach. The aim of this chapter is to provide an insight in the recent advances, challenges, and perspectives in the field of NTs analysis both from the on-site and the laboratory perspective.

Visible detection of chilled beef freshness using a paper-based colourimetric sensor array combining with deep learning algorithms

This study developed an innovative approach that combines a colourimetric sensor array (CSA) composed of twelve pH-response dyes with advanced algorithms, aiming to detect amine gases and assess the freshness of chilled beef. With the assistance of multivariate statistical analysis, the sensor array can effectively distinguish five amine gases and enable rapid quantification of trimethylamine vapour with a limit of detection (LOD) of 8.02 ppb and visually monitor the fresh levels of chilled beef. Moreover, the utilization of deep learning models (ResNet34, VGG16, and GoogleNet) for chilled beef freshness evaluation achieved an overall accuracy of 98.0 %. Furthermore, t-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding (t-SNE) visualized the feature extraction process and provided explanations to understand the classification process of deep learning. The results demonstrated that applying deep learning techniques in the process of pattern recognition of CSA can help in realizing the rapid, robust, and accurate assessment of chilled beef freshness.

Machine learning identification of edible vegetable oils from fatty acid compositions and hyperspectral images

Hyperspectral imaging analysis combined with machine learning was applied to identify eight edible vegetable oils, and its classification performance was compared with the chemical method based on fatty acid compositions. Furthermore, the degree of adulteration in vegetable oils was quantitatively investigated using machine learning-enabled hyperspectral approaches. The hyperspectral absorbance spectra of palm oil with a high degree of saturation were distinctly different from those of the other liquid oils. The flaxseed and olive oils exhibited the dominant hyperspectral intensities at 1170/1671 and 1212/1415 nm, respectively. Linear discriminant analysis demonstrated that two linear discriminants could explain a significant portion of the total variability, accounting for 96.0% (fatty acid compositions) and 98.9% (hyperspectral images). When the hyperspectral results were used as datasets for three machine learning models (decision tree, random forest, and k-nearest neighbor), several instances to incorrectly classify grapeseed and sunflower oils were detected, while olive, palm, and flaxseed oils were successfully identified. The machine learning models showed a great classification performance that exceeded 98.9% from the hyperspectral images of the vegetable oils, which was comparable to the fatty acid composition-based chemical method in identifying edible vegetable oils. In addition, the random forest model was the most effective in ascertaining adulteration levels in binary oil blends (R2 > 0.992 and RMSE < 2.75).

Explainable machine learning for predicting the geographical origin of Chinese Oysters via mineral elements analysis

The traceability of geographic origin is essential for guaranteeing the quality, safety, and protection of oyster brands. However, the current outcomes of traceability lack credibility as they do not adequately explain the model's predictions. Consequently, we conducted a study to evaluate the efficacy of utilizing explainable machine learning combined with mineral elements analysis. The study findings revealed that 18 elements have the ability to determine regional orientation. Simultaneously, individuals should pay closer attention to the potential risks associated with oyster consumption due to the regional differences in essential and toxic elements they contain. Light gradient boosting machine (LightGBM) model exhibited indistinguishable performance, achieving flawless accuracy, precision, recall, F1 score and AUC, with values of 96.77%, 96.43%, 98.53%, 97.32% and 0.998, respectively. The SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) method was used to evaluate the output of the LightGBM model, revealing differences in feature interactions among oysters from different provinces. Specifically, the features Na, Zn, V, Mg, and K were found to have a significant impact on the predictive process of the model. Consistent with existing research, the use of explainable machine learning techniques can provide insights into the complex connections between important product attributes and relevant geographical information.

Optical sensing for real-time detection of food-borne pathogens in fresh produce using machine learning

Contaminated fresh produce remains a prominent catalyst for food-borne illnesses, prompting the need for swift and precise pathogen detection to mitigate health risks. This paper introduces an innovative strategy for identifying food-borne pathogens in fresh produce samples from local markets and grocery stores, utilizing optical sensing and machine learning. The core of our approach is a photonics-based sensor system, which instantaneously generates optical signals to detect pathogen presence. Machine learning algorithms process the copious sensor data to predict contamination probabilities in real time. Our study reveals compelling results, affirming the efficacy of our method in identifying prevalent food-borne pathogens, including Escherichia coli (E. coli) and Salmonella enteric, across diverse fresh produce samples. The outcomes underline our approach's precision, achieving detection accuracies of up to 95%, surpassing traditional, time-consuming, and less accurate methods. Our method's key advantages encompass real-time capabilities, heightened accuracy, and cost-effectiveness, facilitating its adoption by both food industry stakeholders and regulatory bodies for quality assurance and safety oversight. Implementation holds the potential to elevate food safety and reduce wastage. Our research signifies a substantial stride toward the development of a dependable, real-time food safety monitoring system for fresh produce. Future research endeavors will be dedicated to optimizing system performance, crafting portable field sensors, and broadening pathogen detection capabilities. This novel approach promises substantial enhancements in food safety and public health.

Machine-learning-driven optical immunosensor based on microspheres-encoded signal transduction for the rapid and multiplexed detection of antibiotics in milk

Antibiotic residues are the most common contaminants in milk and other related dairy products. Simultaneous, convenient, and stable detection of antibiotic residues in foods is vital to secure public health. Herein, we proposed an optical immunosensor with easily-functionalized polystyrene nanoparticles differing in size and quantity, and bearing multiplex signal probes for the simultaneous detection of multiple antibiotics through a simple one-step signal conversion reaction. After the integration of the machine-learning-based transcoding analysis, this sensor is suitable for multiplexed detection of antibiotics in a broad linear range from pg/mL to ng/mL within 30 min, with an overall accuracy of >99 %. Compared to the conventional standard chemiluminescence immunoassays, this immunosensor is suitable for the accurate quantification of multiple antibiotics in milk, with improved accuracy, reduced costs, and simplified procedure. This ensures its applications in food safety monitoring when simultaneous detection of multiple hazardous substances in food matrices is needed.

Machine learning assisted biosensing technology: An emerging powerful tool for improving the intelligence of food safety detection

Recently, the application of biosensors in food safety assessment has gained considerable research attention. Nevertheless, the evaluation of biosensors' sensitivity, accuracy, and efficiency is still ongoing. The advent of machine learning has enhanced the application of biosensors in food security assessment, yielding improved results. Machine learning has been preliminarily applied in combination with different biosensors in food safety assessment, with positive results. This review offers a comprehensive summary of the diverse machine learning methods employed in biosensors for food safety. Initially, the primary machine learning methods were outlined, and the integrated application of biosensors and machine learning in food safety was thoroughly examined. Lastly, the challenges and limitations of machine learning and biosensors in the realm of food safety were underscored, and potential solutions were explored. The review's findings demonstrated that algorithms grounded in machine learning can aid in the early detection of food safety issues. Furthermore, preliminary research suggests that biosensors could be optimized through machine learning for real-time, multifaceted analyses of food safety variables and their interactions. The potential of machine learning and biosensors in real-time monitoring of food quality has been discussed.

Material Breakthroughs in Smart Food Monitoring: Intelligent Packaging and On-Site Testing Technologies for Spoilage and Contamination Detection

Despite extensive commercial and regulatory interventions, food spoilage and contamination continue to impose massive ramifications on human health and the global economy. Recognizing that such issues will be significantly eliminated by the accurate and timely monitoring of food quality markers, smart food sensors have garnered significant interest as platforms for both real-time, in-package food monitoring and on-site commercial testing. In both cases, the sensitivity, stability, and efficiency of the developed sensors are largely informed by underlying material design, driving focus toward the creation of advanced materials optimized for such applications. Herein, a comprehensive review of emerging intelligent materials and sensors developed in this space is provided, through the lens of three key food quality markers - biogenic amines, pH, and pathogenic microbes. Each sensing platform is presented with targeted consideration toward the contributions of the underlying metallic or polymeric substrate to the sensing mechanism and detection performance. Further, the real-world applicability of presented works is considered with respect to their capabilities, regulatory adherence, and commercial potential. Finally, a situational assessment of the current state of intelligent food monitoring technologies is provided, discussing material-centric strategies to address their existing limitations, regulatory concerns, and commercial considerations.

A perspective on data sharing in digital food safety systems

In this age of data, digital tools are widely promoted as having tremendous potential for enhancing food safety. However, the potential of these digital tools depends on the availability and quality of data, and a number of obstacles need to be overcome to achieve the goal of digitally enabled "smarter food safety" approaches. One key obstacle is that participants in the food system and in food safety often lack the willingness to share data, due to fears of data abuse, bad publicity, liability, and the need to keep certain data (e.g., human illness data) confidential. As these multifaceted concerns lead to tension between data utility and privacy, the solutions to these challenges need to be multifaceted. This review outlines the data needs in digital food safety systems, exemplified in different data categories and model types, and key concerns associated with sharing of food safety data, including confidentiality and privacy of shared data. To address the data privacy issue a combination of innovative strategies to protect privacy as well as legal protection against data abuse need to be pursued. Existing solutions for maximizing data utility, while not compromising data privacy, are discussed, most notably differential privacy and federated learning.

Review of visual analytics methods for food safety risks

With the availability of big data for food safety, more and more advanced data analysis methods are being applied to risk analysis and prewarning (RAPW). Visual analytics, which has emerged in recent years, integrates human and machine intelligence into the data analysis process in a visually interactive manner, helping researchers gain insights into large-scale data and providing new solutions for RAPW. This review presents the developments in visual analytics for food safety RAPW in the past decade. Firstly, the data sources, data characteristics, and analysis tasks in the food safety field are summarized. Then, data analysis methods for four types of analysis tasks: association analysis, risk assessment, risk prediction, and fraud identification, are reviewed. After that, the visualization and interaction techniques are reviewed for four types of characteristic data: multidimensional, hierarchical, associative, and spatial-temporal data. Finally, opportunities and challenges in this area are proposed, such as the visual analysis of multimodal food safety data, the application of artificial intelligence techniques in the visual analysis pipeline, etc.

Artificial Intelligence in Food Safety: A Decade Review and Bibliometric Analysis

Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies have been powerful solutions used to improve food yield, quality, and nutrition, increase safety and traceability while decreasing resource consumption, and eliminate food waste. Compared with several qualitative reviews on AI in food safety, we conducted an in-depth quantitative and systematic review based on the Core Collection database of WoS (Web of Science). To discover the historical trajectory and identify future trends, we analysed the literature concerning AI technologies in food safety from 2012 to 2022 by CiteSpace. In this review, we used bibliometric methods to describe the development of AI in food safety, including performance analysis, science mapping, and network analysis by CiteSpace. Among the 1855 selected articles, China and the United States contributed the most literature, and the Chinese Academy of Sciences released the largest number of relevant articles. Among all the journals in this field, PLoS ONE and Computers and Electronics in Agriculture ranked first and second in terms of annual publications and co-citation frequency. The present character, hot spots, and future research trends of AI technologies in food safety research were determined. Furthermore, based on our analyses, we provide researchers, practitioners, and policymakers with the big picture of research on AI in food safety across the whole process, from precision agriculture to precision nutrition, through 28 enlightening articles.

Neural network in food analytics

Neural network (i.e. deep learning, NN)-based data analysis techniques have been listed as a pivotal opportunity to protect the integrity and safety of the global food supply chain and forecast $11.2 billion in agriculture markets. As a general-purpose data analytic tool, NN has been applied in several areas of food science, such as food recognition, food supply chain security and omics analysis, and so on. Therefore, given the rapid emergence of NN applications in food safety, this review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the NN application in food analysis for the first time, focusing on domain-specific applications in food analysis by introducing fundamental methodology, reviewing recent and notable progress, and discussing challenges and potential pitfalls. NN demonstrated that it has a bright future through effective collaboration between food specialist and the broader community in the food field, for example, superiority in food recognition, sensory evaluation, pattern recognition of spectroscopy and chromatography. However, major challenges impeded NN extension including void in the food scientist-friendly interface software package, incomprehensible model behavior, multi-source heterogeneous data, and so on. The breakthrough from other fields proved NN has the potential to offer a revolution in the immediate future.

Protecting Sensitive Data in the Information Age: State of the Art and Future Prospects

The present information age is characterized by an ever-increasing digitalization. Smart devices quantify our entire lives. These collected data provide the foundation for data-driven services called smart services. They are able to adapt to a given context and thus tailor their functionalities to the user’s needs. It is therefore not surprising that their main resource, namely data, is nowadays a valuable commodity that can also be traded. However, this trend does not only have positive sides, as the gathered data reveal a lot of information about various data subjects. To prevent uncontrolled insights into private or confidential matters, data protection laws restrict the processing of sensitive data. One key factor in this regard is user-friendly privacy mechanisms. In this paper, we therefore assess current state-of-the-art privacy mechanisms. To this end, we initially identify forms of data processing applied by smart services. We then discuss privacy mechanisms suited for these use cases. Our findings reveal that current state-of-the-art privacy mechanisms provide good protection in principle, but there is no compelling one-size-fits-all privacy approach. This leads to further questions regarding the practicality of these mechanisms, which we present in the form of seven thought-provoking propositions.

Deep learning accurately predicts food categories and nutrients based on ingredient statements

Determining attributes such as classification, creating taxonomies and nutrients for foods can be a challenging and resource-intensive task, albeit important for a better understanding of foods. In this study, a novel dataset, 134 k BFPD, was collected from USDA Branded Food Products Database with modification and labeled with three food taxonomy and nutrient values and became an artificial intelligence (AI) dataset that covered the largest food types to date. Overall, the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP)-TF-SE method obtained the highest learning efficiency for food natural language processing tasks using AI, which achieved up to 99% accuracy for food classification and 0.98 R² for calcium estimation (0.93 ∼ 0.97 for calories, protein, sodium, total carbohydrate, total lipids, etc.). The deep learning approach has great potential to be embedded in other food classification and regression tasks and as an extension to other applications in the food and nutrient scope.

Applications of machine learning techniques for enhancing nondestructive food quality and safety detection

In considering the need of people all over the world for high-quality food, there has been a recent increase in interest in the role of nondestructive and rapid detection technologies in the food industry. Moreover, the analysis of data acquired by most nondestructive technologies is complex, time-consuming, and requires highly skilled operators. Meanwhile, the general applicability of various chemometric or statistical methods is affected by noise, sample, variability, and data complexity that vary under various testing conditions. Nowadays, machine learning (ML) techniques have a wide range of applications in the food industry, especially in nondestructive technology and equipment intelligence, due to their powerful ability in handling irrelevant information, extracting feature variables, and building calibration models. The review provides an introduction and comparison of machine learning techniques, and summarizes these algorithms as traditional machine learning (TML), and deep learning (DL). Moreover, several novel nondestructive technologies, namely acoustic analysis, machine vision (MV), electronic nose (E-nose), and spectral imaging, combined with different advanced ML techniques and their applications in food quality assessment such as variety identification and classification, safety inspection and processing control, are presented. In addition to this, the existing challenges and prospects are discussed. The result of this review indicates that nondestructive testing technologies combined with state-of-the-art machine learning techniques show great potential for monitoring the quality and safety of food products and different machine learning algorithms have their characteristics and applicability scenarios. Due to the nature of feature learning, DL is one of the most promising and powerful techniques for real-time applications, which needs further research for full and wide applications in the food industry.

Toward in-process technology-aided automation for enhanced microbial food safety and quality assurance in milk and beverages processing

Ensuring the safety of food products is critical to food production and processing. In food processing and production, several standard guidelines are implemented to achieve acceptable food quality and safety. This notwithstanding, due to human limitations, processed foods are often contaminated either with microorganisms, microbial byproducts, or chemical agents, resulting in the compromise of product quality with far-reaching consequences including foodborne diseases, food intoxication, and food recall. Transitioning from manual food processing to automation-aided food processing (smart food processing) which is guided by artificial intelligence will guarantee the safety and quality of food. However, this will require huge investments in terms of resources, technologies, and expertise. This study reviews the potential of artificial intelligence in food processing. In addition, it presents the technologies and methods with potential applications in implementing automated technology-aided processing. A conceptual design for an automated food processing line comprised of various operational layers and processes targeted at enhancing the microbial safety and quality assurance of liquid foods such as milk and beverages is elaborated.

Predictive and explanatory themes of NOAEL through a systematic comparison of different machine learning methods and descriptors

No observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) is an identified dose level which used as a point of departure to infer a safe exposure limit of chemicals, especially in food additives and cosmetics. Recently, in silico approaches have been employed as effective alternatives to determine the toxicity endpoints of chemicals instead of animal experiments. Several acceptable models have been reported, yet assessing the risk of repeated-dose toxicity remains inadequate. This study established robust machine learning predictive models for NOAEL at different exposure durations by constructing high-quality datasets and comparing different kinds of molecular representations and algorithms. The features of molecular structures affecting NOAEL were explored using advanced cheminformatics methods, and predictive models also communicated the NOAEL between different species and exposure durations. In addition, a NOAEL prediction tool for chemical risk assessment is provided (available at: https://github.com/ifyoungnet/NOAEL). We hope this study will help researchers easily screen and evaluate the subacute and sub-chronic toxicity of disparate compounds in the development of food additives in the future.

Truths and myths about superfoods in the era of the COVID-19 pandemic

Nowadays, during the current COVID-19 pandemic, consumers increasingly seek foods that not only fulfill the basic need (i.e., satisfying hunger) but also enhance human health and well-being. As a result, more attention has been given to some kinds of foods, termed "superfoods," making big claims about their richness in valuable nutrients and bioactive compounds as well as their capability to prevent illness, reinforcing the human immune system, and improve overall health.This review is an attempt to uncover truths and myths about superfoods by giving examples of the most popular foods (e.g., berries, pomegranates, watermelon, olive, green tea, several seeds and nuts, honey, salmon, and camel milk, among many others) that are commonly reported as having unique nutritional, nutraceutical, and functional characteristics.While superfoods have become a popular buzzword in blog articles and social media posts, scientific publications are still relatively marginal. The reviewed findings show that COVID-19 has become a significant driver for superfoods consumption. Food Industry 4.0 innovations have revolutionized many sectors of food technologies, including the manufacturing of functional foods, offering new opportunities to improve the sensory and nutritional quality of such foods. Although many food products have been considered superfoods and intensively sought by consumers, scientific evidence for their beneficial effectiveness and their "superpower" are yet to be provided. Therefore, more research and collaboration between researchers, industry, consumers, and policymakers are still needed to differentiate facts from marketing gimmicks and promote human health and nutrition.

Machine Learning Algorithms Highlight tRNA Information Content and Chargaff’s Second Parity Rule Score as Important Features in Discriminating Probiotics from Non-Probiotics

Simple Summary

Probiotics are a group of beneficial microorganisms that are symbionts of the human gut microbiome. The identification of new probiotics is therefore of paramount importance from both public health and commercial perspectives. In this study, we show for the first time that Artificial Intelligence algorithms can identify novel probiotics and also discriminate them from pathogenic organisms in the human gut. We were also able to determine the information content within tRNA sequences as the key genomic features capable of characterizing probiotics.

Abstract

Probiotic bacteria are microorganisms with beneficial effects on human health and are currently used in numerous food supplements. However, no selection process is able to effectively distinguish probiotics from non-probiotic organisms on the basis of their genomic characteristics. In the current study, four Machine Learning algorithms were employed to accurately identify probiotic bacteria based on their DNA characteristics. Although the prediction accuracies of all algorithms were excellent, the Neural Network returned the highest scores in all the evaluation metrics, managing to discriminate probiotics from non-probiotics with an accuracy greater than 90%. Interestingly, our analysis also highlighted the information content of the tRNA sequences as the most important feature in distinguishing the two groups of organisms probably because tRNAs have regulatory functions and might have allowed probiotics to evolve faster in the human gut environment. Through the methodology presented here, it was also possible to identify seven promising new probiotics that have a higher information content in their tRNA sequences compared to non-probiotics. In conclusion, we prove for the first time that Machine Learning methods can discriminate human probiotic from non-probiotic organisms underlining information within tRNA sequences as the most important genomic feature in distinguishing them.

An Investigation in Applying Internet of Things Approach in Safe Food Dietary Plan for Better Chronic Diabetes Management among Elderly Adults

Chronic diabetes among adults is a public health concern and clinicians are trying to implement new strategies to effectively manage the disease. Traditionally, healthcare professionals are used to monitor and track the lab reports of patients. After that, they used to provide respective medicines and lifestyle plans to manage the chronic disease. The lifestyle of the patients and access to safe and secure food products is also responsible for developing chronic diseases. Thus, the Internet of Things (IoT) has taken an utmost interest in managing diabetes. This research is going to analyze the accuracy of IoT in assisting chronic diabetes management and determining food safety. To accomplish the research objectives, the researchers performed a linear regression analysis to understand whether IoT devices and Artificial Intelligence (AI) assist in assessing food safety and diabetes management. The independent variables selected were lab test values, treatment records, epoch size of AI, and image resolution of the training dataset. Dependent variables were the accuracy of IoT. Here, the accuracy of IoT and AI has been determined. Moreover, the accuracy of clinicians in diabetes management has been observed. It has been found that clinicians have high variance in accuracy (max 99%) whereas machines have limited variance in accuracy (max. 98%). Secondary research identified that clinicians need to be involved along with IoT devices for better management of this chronic disease and help patients by providing the safest food options.

Recent Advances and Applications of Rapid Microbial Assessment from a Food Safety Perspective

Unsafe food is estimated to cause 600 million cases of foodborne disease, annually. Thus, the development of methods that could assist in the prevention of foodborne diseases is of high interest. This review summarizes the recent progress toward rapid microbial assessment through (i) spectroscopic techniques, (ii) spectral imaging techniques, (iii) biosensors and (iv) sensors designed to mimic human senses. These methods often produce complex and high-dimensional data that cannot be analyzed with conventional statistical methods. Multivariate statistics and machine learning approaches seemed to be valuable for these methods so as to "translate" measurements to microbial estimations. However, a great proportion of the models reported in the literature misuse these approaches, which may lead to models with low predictive power under generic conditions. Overall, all the methods showed great potential for rapid microbial assessment. Biosensors are closer to wide-scale implementation followed by spectroscopic techniques and then by spectral imaging techniques and sensors designed to mimic human senses.

The fourth industrial revolution in the food industry-Part I: Industry 4.0 technologies

Climate change, the growth in world population, high levels of food waste and food loss, and the risk of new disease or pandemic outbreaks are examples of the many challenges that threaten future food sustainability and the security of the planet and urgently need to be addressed. The fourth industrial revolution, or Industry 4.0, has been gaining momentum since 2015, being a significant driver for sustainable development and a successful catalyst to tackle critical global challenges. This review paper summarizes the most relevant food Industry 4.0 technologies including, among others, digital technologies (e.g., artificial intelligence, big data analytics, Internet of Things, and blockchain) and other technological advances (e.g., smart sensors, robotics, digital twins, and cyber-physical systems). Moreover, insights into the new food trends (such as 3D printed foods) that have emerged as a result of the Industry 4.0 technological revolution will also be discussed in Part II of this work. The Industry 4.0 technologies have significantly modified the food industry and led to substantial consequences for the environment, economics, and human health. Despite the importance of each of the technologies mentioned above, ground-breaking sustainable solutions could only emerge by combining many technologies simultaneously. The Food Industry 4.0 era has been characterized by new challenges, opportunities, and trends that have reshaped current strategies and prospects for food production and consumption patterns, paving the way for the move toward Industry 5.0.

Application of machine learning to the monitoring and prediction of food safety: A review

Machine learning (ML) has proven to be a useful technology for data analysis and modeling in a wide variety of domains, including food science and engineering. The use of ML models for the monitoring and prediction of food safety is growing in recent years. Currently, several studies have reviewed ML applications on foodborne disease and deep learning applications on food. This article presents a literature review on ML applications for monitoring and predicting food safety. The paper summarizes and categorizes ML applications in this domain, categorizes and discusses data types used for ML modeling, and provides suggestions for data sources and input variables for future ML applications. The review is based on three scientific literature databases: Scopus, CAB Abstracts, and IEEE. It includes studies that were published in English in the period from January 1, 2011 to April 1, 2021. Results show that most studies applied Bayesian networks, Neural networks, or Support vector machines. Of the various ML models reviewed, all relevant studies showed high prediction accuracy by the validation process. Based on the ML applications, this article identifies several avenues for future studies applying ML models for the monitoring and prediction of food safety, in addition to providing suggestions for data sources and input variables.

The Use of Different Image Recognition Techniques in Food Safety: A Study

Food safety refers to preparing, transporting, and storing food to avoid foodborne sickness and harm. From farm to factory and factory to fork, food items may meet various health dangers. Therefore, food safety is crucial both monetarily and morally. The implications of failing to comply with food safety requirements are varied. The requirement for accurate, quick, and nonpartisan quality assessments of these features in food products continues to rise with increased demands for dietary materials and high-quality requirements. Computer vision provides an automatic, nondestructive, and economic approach to achieving these aims. A substantial research has demonstrated its effectiveness for fruit and vegetable assessment and classification. It stresses the critical components of image processing technology and a survey of the most current advances across the food sector. This article outlines the essential parts of a computer vision system. In order to avoid foodborne disease and ensure food security, fast and effective detection of pathogenic microorganisms is crucial for public safety biomonitoring. Over the years, microorganism detection techniques have evolved.

Crowdsourcing and machine learning approaches for extracting entities indicating potential foodborne outbreaks from social media

Foodborne outbreaks are a serious but preventable threat to public health that often lead to illness, loss of life, significant economic loss, and the erosion of consumer confidence. Understanding how consumers respond when interacting with foods, as well as extracting information from posts on social media may provide new means of reducing the risks and curtailing the outbreaks. In recent years, Twitter has been employed as a new tool for identifying unreported foodborne illnesses. However, there is a huge gap between the identification of sporadic illnesses and the early detection of a potential outbreak. In this work, the dual-task BERTweet model was developed to identify unreported foodborne illnesses and extract foodborne-illness-related entities from Twitter. Unlike previous methods, our model leveraged the mutually beneficial relationships between the two tasks. The results showed that the F1-score of relevance prediction was 0.87, and the F1-score of entity extraction was 0.61. Key elements such as time, location, and food detected from sentences indicating foodborne illnesses were used to analyze potential foodborne outbreaks in massive historical tweets. A case study on tweets indicating foodborne illnesses showed that the discovered trend is consistent with the true outbreaks that occurred during the same period.

Present and Future Perspectives on Therapeutic Options for Carbapenemase-Producing Enterobacterales Infections

Carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales (CRE) are included in the list of the most threatening antibiotic resistance microorganisms, being responsible for often insurmountable therapeutic issues, especially in hospitalized patients and immunocompromised individuals and patients in intensive care units. The enzymatic resistance to carbapenems is encoded by different β-lactamases belonging to A, B or D Ambler class. Besides compromising the activity of last-resort antibiotics, CRE have spread from the clinical to the environmental sectors, in all geographic regions. The purpose of this review is to present present and future perspectives on CRE-associated infections treatment.