Increased phagocytosis of Plasmodium falciparum-infected erythrocytes with haemoglobin E by peripheral blood monocytes

Hemoglobin E, malaria and natural selection

It is known that there has been positive natural selection for hemoglobin S and C in humans despite negative health effects, due to its role in malaria resistance. However, it is not well understood, if there has been natural selection for hemoglobin E (HbE), which is a common variant in Southeast Asia. Therefore, we reviewed previous studies and discussed the potential role of natural selection in the prevalence of HbE. Our review shows that in vitro studies, evolutionary genetics studies and epidemiologic studies largely support an involvement of natural selection in the evolution of HbE and a protective role of HbE against malaria infection. However, the evidence is inconsistent, provided from different regions, and insufficient to perform an aggregated analysis such as a meta-analysis. In addition, few candidate gene, genome-wide association or epistasis studies, which have been made possible with the use of big data in the post-genomic era, have investigated HbE. The biological pathways linking HbE and malaria infection have not yet been fully elucidated. Therefore, further research is necessary before it can be concluded that there was positive natural selection for HbE due to protection against malaria.

Lay summary: Our review shows that evidence largely supports an involvement of natural selection in the evolution of HbE and a protective role of HbE against malaria. However, the evidence is not consistent. Further research is necessary before it is concluded.

The influence of host genetics on erythrocytes and malaria infection: is there therapeutic potential?

As parasites, Plasmodium species depend upon their host for survival. During the blood stage of their life-cycle parasites invade and reside within erythrocytes, commandeering host proteins and resources towards their own ends, and dramatically transforming the host cell. Parasites aptly avoid immune detection by minimizing the exposure of parasite proteins and removing themselves from circulation through cytoadherence. Erythrocytic disorders brought on by host genetic mutations can interfere with one or more of these processes, thereby providing a measure of protection against malaria to the host. This review summarizes recent findings regarding the mechanistic aspects of this protection, as mediated through the parasites interaction with abnormal erythrocytes. These novel findings include the reliance of the parasite on the host enzyme ferrochelatase, and the discovery of basigin and CD55 as obligate erythrocyte receptors for parasite invasion. The elucidation of these naturally occurring malaria resistance mechanisms is increasing the understanding of the host-parasite interaction, and as discussed below, is providing new insights into the development of therapies to prevent this disease.

Complement receptor 1 and the molecular pathogenesis of malaria

Malaria is a pathogenic infection caused by protozoa of the genus plasmodium. It is mainly confined to sub-Saharan Africa, Asia and South America. This disease claims the life of over 1.5 to 2.7 million people per year. Owing to such a high incidence of malarial infections, there is an urgent need for the development of suitable vaccines. For the development of ideal vaccines, it is essential to understand the molecular mechanisms of malarial pathogenesis and the factors that lead to malaria infection. Genetic factors have been proposed to play an important role in malarial pathogenesis. Complement receptor 1 (CR1) is an important host red blood cell protein involved in interaction with malarial parasite. Various polymorphic forms of CR1 have been found to be involved in conferring protection or increasing susceptibility to malaria infections. Low-density allele (L) of CR1 gave contradictory results in different set of studies. In addition, Knops polymorphic forms Sl (a⁺) and McC (a) have been found to contribute more towards the occurrence of cerebral malaria in malaria endemic regions compared to individuals with Sl (a^-) / McC (a/b) genotype. This article reviews the research currently going on in this area and throws light on as yet unresolved mysteries of the role of CR1 in malarial pathogenesis

Beta-globin gene cluster polymorphisms are strongly associated with severity of HbE/beta(0)-thalassemia

We evaluated the contribution of 67 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) within the beta-globin gene cluster to disease severity in groups of 207 mild- and 305 severe unrelated patients from Thailand with Hemoglobin E (HbE)/beta(0)-thalassemia and normal alpha-globin genes. Our analysis showed that these SNPs comprise two distinct linkage disequilibrium blocks, one containing the beta-globin gene and the other extending from the locus control region (LCR) to the delta gene, which are separated by a recombination hotspot in the narrow region of the beta-globin gene promoter. Forty-five SNPs within the interval including the LCR region and the delta gene showed strong association with disease severity. The strongest association was observed with the XmnI polymorphism located 158-bp upstream to the G gamma gene (p = 4.6E-12). Carriers of the T allele of XmnI were more likely to have a milder disease course and higher level of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) in both the mild (p = 0.005) and severe (p = 8.7E-06) patient groups. Haplotype analysis revealed that the T allele of XmnI was nearly always in cis with the HbE allele. The high frequency of this haplotype may be favored by positive selection against malarial infection. Further studies are needed to validate this hypothesis and determine whether XmnI or another closely linked variant modulates severity and HbF levels in patients with beta(0)-thalassemia/HbE disease.

Cytoadherence between endothelial cells and P. falciparum infected and noninfected normal and thalassemic red blood cells

BACKGROUND

Cytoadhesion of P. falciparum infected red blood cells (RBCs) to endothelial cells (ECs) is an important phenomenon that causes cerebral malaria in man. Reduced adhesion especially in thalassemia and hemoglobinopathies may be related to a protective mechanism against malaria in such people.

METHODS

The cytoadherence assay was performed using both conventional and floating conditions between ECs (ECV 304) and P. falciparum infected and noninfected RBCs from both normal and thalassemia subjects. In floating condition, RBC was fluorescently labeled with anti-glycophorin A antibody, whereas EC was identified by surface expression of PECAM-1, CD-36, ICAM-1, and E-selectin. The condition of floating EC was similar to the condition for subcultivation as they can adhere or bind to any surface. The phosphatidylserine (PS) exposure was also determined by using flow cytometer.

RESULTS

The adhesion of noninfected heterozygous thalassemic RBCs (all genotypes) to ECs was significantly increased as compared with normal RBCs (P < 0.02). Interestingly, after P. falciparum infection, the number of normal RBCs bound to ECs was significantly increased as compared with noninfected RBCs (P < 0.01), whereas heterozygous thalassemic RBCs infected by P. falciparum showed no significant difference compared with noninfected RBCs. In addition, we found a similar level of PS exposure in normal and thalassemic infected RBCs, which was related to the cytoadherence phenomenon.

CONCLUSION

The reduced adhesion between heterozygous thalassemic RBCs infected by P. falciparum to ECs provides an explanation for their protective mechanism against malaria, as increased adhesion is a high risk for cerebral malaria and nonbinding infected RBCs can be removed by the reticuloendothelial system and other mechanism(s) in vivo.

Protection against malaria by thalassaemia and haemoglobin variants

Recent epidemiological evidence has given increasing support to Haldane's 1949 hypothesis that heterozygotes for such genetic disorders as thalassaemia might be protected against malaria, hence explaining the high gene frequencies for such disorders in endemic areas. As discussed here by Yongyuth Yuthavong and Prapon Wilairat, the possible cellular mechanisms, although still unclear, are emerging from in vitro studies which increasingly point to the importance of immune clearance mechanisms in some cases (such as alpha-thalassaemia and haemoglobin E). In other situations, decreased survival of the intra-erythrocytic parasite or decreased parasite invasion of the variant red blood cells may explain the protective effect. Whatever the cellular mechanisms are, the ultimate decisive factor is the relative fitness of the infected variant host, which may not be simply extrapolated from the cellular studies.

Extended linkage disequilibrium surrounding the hemoglobin E variant due to malarial selection

The hemoglobin E variant (HbE; ( beta )26Glu-->Lys) is concentrated in parts of Southeast Asia where malaria is endemic, and HbE carrier status has been shown to confer some protection against Plasmodium falciparum malaria. To examine the effect of natural selection on the pattern of linkage disequilibrium (LD) and to infer the evolutionary history of the HbE variant, we analyzed biallelic markers surrounding the HbE variant in a Thai population. Pairwise LD analysis of HbE and 43 surrounding biallelic markers revealed LD of HbE extending beyond 100 kb, whereas no LD was observed between non-HbE variants and the same markers. The inferred haplotype network suggests a single origin of the HbE variant in the Thai population. Forward-in-time computer simulations under a variety of selection models indicate that the HbE variant arose 1,240-4,440 years ago. These results support the conjecture that the HbE mutation occurred recently, and the allele frequency has increased rapidly. Our study provides another clear demonstration that a high-resolution LD map across the human genome can detect recent variants that have been subjected to positive selection.

Oxidative stress in malaria parasite-infected erythrocytes: host–parasite interactions

Experimenta naturae, like the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency, indicate that malaria parasites are highly susceptible to alterations in the redox equilibrium. This offers a great potential for the development of urgently required novel chemotherapeutic strategies. However, the relationship between the redox status of malarial parasites and that of their host is complex. In this review article we summarise the presently available knowledge on sources and detoxification pathways of reactive oxygen species in malaria parasite-infected red cells, on clinical aspects of redox metabolism and redox-related mechanisms of drug action as well as future prospects for drug development. As delineated below, alterations in redox status contribute to disease manifestation including sequestration, cerebral pathology, anaemia, respiratory distress, and placental malaria. Studying haemoglobinopathies, like thalassemias and sickle cell disease, and other red cell defects that provide protection against malaria allows insights into this fine balance of redox interactions. The host immune response to malaria involves phagocytosis as well as the production of nitric oxide and oxygen radicals that form part of the host defence system and also contribute to the pathology of the disease. Haemoglobin degradation by the malarial parasite produces the redox active by-products, free haem and H(2)O(2), conferring oxidative insult on the host cell. However, the parasite also supplies antioxidant moieties to the host and possesses an efficient enzymatic antioxidant defence system including glutathione- and thioredoxin-dependent proteins. Mechanistic and structural work on these enzymes might provide a basis for targeting the parasite. Indeed, a number of currently used drugs, especially the endoperoxide antimalarials, appear to act by increasing oxidant stress, and novel drugs such as peroxidic compounds and anthroquinones are being developed.

Hemoglobin E: a balanced polymorphism protective against high parasitemias and thus severe P falciparum malaria

Hemoglobin E is very common in parts of Southeast Asia. The possible malaria protective effects of this and other inherited hemoglobin abnormalities prevalent in Thailand were assessed in a mixed erythrocyte invasion assay. In vitro, starting at 1% parasitemia,Plasmodium falciparum preferentially invaded normal (HbAA) compared to abnormal hemoglobin (HbH, AE, EE, HCS, β-thalassemia E) red cells (HRBCs). The median (range) ratio of parasitization of HRBCs (n = 109) compared to the controls of different major blood groups was 0.40 (0.08, 0.98), less than half that of the normal red cells (NRBCs) compared to their controls 0.88 (0.53, 1.4;P = .001). The median (range) parasitemia in the HRBCs was 2% (0.1%-9%) compared to 5.2% (1.2%-16.3%) in the NRBCs (P = .001). The proportion of the RBC population that is susceptible to malaria parasite invasion can be described by a selectivity index (SI; observed number of multiply invaded RBCs/number predicted). The heterozygote AE cells differed markedly from all the other cells tested with invasion restricted to approximately 25% of the RBCs; the median (range) SI was 3.8 (1-15) compared with 0.75 (0.1-0.9) for EE RBCs (P &lt; .01). Despite their microcytosis, AE cells are functionally relatively normal in contrast to the RBCs from the other hemoglobinopathies studied. These findings suggest that HbAE erythrocytes have an unidentified membrane abnormality that renders the majority of the RBC population relatively resistant to invasion by P falciparum. This would not protect from uncomplicated malaria infections but would prevent the development of heavy parasite burdens and is consistent with the “Haldane” hypothesis of heterozygote protection against severe malaria for hemoglobin E.

The membrane characteristics of Plasmodium falciparum-infected and -uninfected heterozygous alpha(0)thalassaemic erythrocytes

The alpha thalassaemias are the commonest known human genetic disorders. Although they have almost certainly risen to their current frequencies through natural selection by malaria, the precise mechanism of malaria protection remains unknown. We have investigated the characteristics of red blood cells (RBCs) from individuals heterozygous for alpha(0)thalassaemia (-/alphaalpha) from a range of perspectives. On the basis of the hypothesis that defects in membrane transport could be relevant to the mechanism of malaria protection, we investigated sodium and potassium transport and the activity of the Plamodium falciparum-induced choline channel but found no significant differences in -/alphaalpha RBCs. Using flow cytometry, we found that thalassaemic P. falciparum-infected RBCs (IRBCs) bound 44% more antibody from immune plasma than control IRBCs. This excess binding was abrogated by predigestion of IRBCs with trypsin but was not directed at the variant surface molecule PfEMP1. Furthermore, we found no evidence for altered cytoadhesion of alpha-thalassaemic IRBCs to the endothelial receptors intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), CD36 or thrombospondin. We hypothesize that altered red-cell membrane band 3 protein may be a target for enhanced antibody binding to alpha-thalassaemic IRBCs and could be involved in the mechanism of malaria protection.

Membrane heme as a host factor in reducing effectiveness of dihydroartemisinin

Plasmodium falciparum infecting alpha-thalassemic erythrocytes are resistant to artemisinin and its derivatives. Binding of the drug to hemoglobin H resulting in drug inactivation was previously demonstrated. We now show that an additional host factor, membrane heme, significantly accounted for decreased antimalarial activity of artemisinin. The antimalarial activity of dihydroartemisinin in the presence of normal and thalassemic erythrocyte membranes showed a correlation with the heme content of the membrane (r(2)=0.466, P<0.01). The correlation was more clearly seen when the drug effectiveness was correlated with the heme content of alpha-thalassemic membrane (r(2)=0.636, P<0.01). However, the drug effectiveness showed no correlation to ferrozine-reactive (free or non-heme) iron content (r(2)=0.0001, P>0.05). alpha-Thalassemic erythrocytes contained higher amounts of membrane heme (11.04+/-8.96 nmol/mg membrane protein) than those from normal and beta-thalassemia/HbE erythrocytes (2.68+/-1.28 and 3.98+/-3.98 nmol/mg membrane protein, respectively, P<0.01). Loss of drug effectiveness was also correlated with increment of heme content in membrane prepared from normal erythrocytes treated with phenylhydrazine. It is concluded that heme in both normal and thalassemic erythrocyte membranes is an important factor in drug inactivation.

Haemoglobin-E in the presence of oxidative substances from fava bean may be protective against Plasmodium falciparum malaria

A case-control study was carried out at a community hospital in eastern Thailand in order to study the association between haemoglobin E and Plasmodium falciparum malaria; 271 P. falciparum cases and 271 controls were enrolled. After adjusting for age, sex, time since last malaria attack, history of mosquito net use, and history of fava bean consumption in the previous month, neither heterozygous nor homozygous haemoglobin E provided significant protection against P. falciparum infection, with odds ratios (OR) = 0.91 (95% confidence limits = 0.61, 1.36) and 0.78 (0.34, 1.82) respectively when compared to persons with haemoglobin A who were not consumers of fava beans. However, haemoglobin E carriers who ate fava beans were significantly protected against P. falciparum malaria with OR = 0.26 (0.09, 0.76) and OR = 0.001 (0.00, 1120.59) for subjects with heterozygous and homozygous haemoglobin E, respectively. The study suggests a possible synergistic protective effect of haemoglobin E on the risk of P. falciparum malaria in subjects who have consumed fava beans.

Molecular epidemiology of the thalassaemias (including haemoglobin E)

The thalassaemias are the most common genetic disorders of man, and over the last decade the molecular epidemiology of these defects has been studied in detail. After briefly reviewing the great diversity of mutations giving rise to these conditions, four global regions are discussed in more detail. The thalassaemias, of which haemoglobin E is one, are most frequent in Asia, where recent work has defined the molecular basis of the beta thalassaemias and the frequencies of the various types of alpha + and alpha 0 thalassaemia. Oceanic populations have a range of globin gene variants remarkably different to those of south-east Asia. Most is known about the nature and frequencies of thalassaemia mutations in Mediterranean countries, where prenatal diagnosis programmes have been very successful in reducing the frequency of new cases of thalassaemia major. alpha + Thalassaemia is the most common haemoglobinopathy in sub-Saharan Africa, and molecular studies of American Blacks with beta thalassaemia have elucidated the probable molecular basis of the mild form of this disorder in Africans. Although each geographical region has its own group of common beta thalassaemia mutations, with little overlap, most of these appear to have had a single origin. The question of single or multiple origins for HbE in south-east Asia is unresolved. Recombination events producing alpha + thalassaemia deletions are frequent, whereas alpha 0 thalassaemia is produced by a variety of large deletions, each of which has had a single origin. The evidence favouring natural selection by P. falciparum malaria as the primary cause of high frequencies of the thalassaemias throughout the tropics and subtropics is reviewed. While the mechanism of protection remains unclear, epidemiological evidence supporting the hypothesis is strong, but more information is required from case-control studies on the amount of protection provided by the various thalassaemia genotypes.

Erythrophagocytosis in malaria: Host defence or menace to the macrophage?

Macrophages in the host's bloodstream and tissue serve as a first line of defence during infection with Plasmodium. While the killing effect of these cells on parasites has been investigated extensively, relatively little is known about the phagocytosis of infected red blood cells. In this article, Paolo Arese and Franca Turrini have joined Hagai Ginsburg to address the perplexing relationships between the macrophage and the malaria-infected red blood cell. They suggest that the same molecular mechanisms that normally operate to remove senescent or damaged red blood cells also operate during malaria, although the parasite may indirectly cause the destruction of macrophages.